Is Physical Media Worth It Anymore?!

In this video, I discuss both the pros and cons of collecting physical media. I have collected physical media ever since I was a kid picking up VHS tapes at garage sales, but even I have noticed some of the downsides of this hobby!
//SUPPORT ME ON PATREON:
Patreon - / brandocritic
//DONATE TO THE CHANNEL:
paypal.me/Bran...
//PO BOX:
PO Box 38134 SURREY MORGAN HEIGHTS, BC, V3Z 6R3
//FOLLOW HERE:
Instagram - / brandocritic
Twitter - / brandocritic
TikTok - / brandocritic
LetterBoxd - letterboxd.com...
//INTO THE AM
into-the-am.my...
//INTO THE AM - DISCOUNT CODE
WHYISTHERUMALWAYSGONE
//MERCHANDISE:
brandocritic-m...
//MOVIE SCENE CANADA:
www.moviescene...
Instagram - / moviescenecanada
Facebook - / moviescenecanada
Twitter - / moviescenecan

[@JedEckert]

When Disney removed some dialogue from The French Connection I knew that owing physical media was paramount to preserving the films I love.

[@BrandoCritic]

Yep. You own it in its original state

[@SomeHarbourBastard]

@@BrandoCritic “How did you know to buy the disc?” “Never trust a Mouse.” “But he could have been a Rat.” “Never trust anybody.”

[@BrandoCritic]

What’s that from?

[@JedEckert]

@@BrandoCritic I'm sorry I don't understand.

[@BrandoCritic]

Yeah neither do I

[@damianvhs4127]

I prefer physical media over streaming anyday, especially since you own a movie and not have to deal with it being removed off any service. I rather watch what I own instead of pirating

[@BrandoCritic]

Yep! Totally understandable!

[@michaelhawkins7389]

@@BrandoCritic Problem with steaming... Ok so what a lot of people seems to forget when streaming is that: 1: You do NOT own the film, so take Amazon prime for example , a tv show/ film can be removed from their platform due to licence rights running out, (aka them losing the rights to have that film/tv on their platform) even if you buy a film from Amazon prime to watch later, like I did. So there is 2 options with Amazon , buy or rent a film (these are for the ones you have to pay for) I paid for a film , to keep , so I could stream this film when I wanted , after 5-6 weeks the film was removed from my Amazon Library because Amazon lost the rights , despite me paying for the film. Same with all streaming platforms. Like HBO (now HBO max?) hulu and Disney and Netflix, it's annoying having to pay for multiple streaming servers, because the films/tv shows have been removed , this is the down side to streaming. Pros of Physical media , DVD , Blu ray and Blu ray 4k: - It is yours to keep. - The Quality is better and higher ( as you don't have to worry about internet, cut out , unlike streaming!) - Special features and more of!! - Steelbooks can look amazing with the artwork

[@BrandoCritic]

Thanks Michael! You know, I made a video on this very topic 😂

[@isaiahadams1996]

I couldn’t agree more

[@BrandoCritic]

Having a hard copy of a movie I love is amazing

[@MattVs_Movies]

Always collect for yourself, not others. I see that a lot in the community people picking up films they don't even watch!

[@BrandoCritic]

Interesting... you think people are just buying movies to "fit in"?

[@MattVs_Movies]

@@BrandoCritic I think that does go on yes. I think some get caught up with the buying of titles to show as currently popular then months later think why did I pick this up 🤷 still sat on the shelf unwatched. I can't see why someone would collect that way but it happens . Also see because it's cheap and something to show on the channel but I think we have all done that blind brought and then regretted buying .I think it's best to stay true to your own tastes and reflect who you are as a collector. I have a channel myself based in UK, my preferred genres are Action, Sci fi with a little Martial arts and a sprinkling of horror.

[@BrandoCritic]

That's kind of what I allude to in my segment about balance between buying the movie and actually watching it

[@MattVs_Movies]

@@BrandoCritic yep. I do have a watch pile of films I have purchased but not got round to yet but in time I will. But to buy films that you aren't really interested in because they are trending at the present time just seems odd to me . At least rent it digitally or go to the cinema and watch it rather than just watching a trailer and blind buying off others reviews to me just seems a waste especially when it's gathering dust on the shelf months later unwatched and then got rid of.

[@BrandoCritic]

Totally! All the films that I have that I haven’t seen are either super famous or have been recommended COUNTLESS times. Movies like Schindler’s List and The Green Mile… I know… it’s embarrassing I haven’t seen those yet haha

[@NiceGuyAidey]

There's a lot worse things to spend your money on, Alcohol , cigarettes , drugs etc etc

[@BrandoCritic]

Of course

[@adammorgan4379]

@@BrandoCritic I think it's more retail therapy for me.

[@BrandoCritic]

Yes… but don’t be a drunk with your retail therapy haha

[@shadowaccount]

Horrible logic

[@Adamlopezjr_13]

I started buying physical media. Last year after a thunder storm. Knocked out wifi for a week. My family made fun of me for buying blu-rays but I got the last laugh . While they were bored I was watching movies😅

[@BrandoCritic]

Maybe you should make fun of them for choosing to live in an area where thunder storms knock out wifi for a week 😂

[@SmallSpoonBrigade]

If you want to up your game, install Jellyfin and rip that media to disc. It's a much better streaming existence and you can always put the physical disc in if you want to, but I don't bother as the experience is pretty much the same. It's the connection over the net that strips most of the picture and sound quality that gets stripped.

[@BrandoCritic]

Are power outages really that big of a thing out there? I guess I'm lucky haha

[@JD.12]

I like physical, but on my iPad i download like 20 movies that i love watching, so even if no internet or power goes, i can watch

[@MarkFoster321789]

Physical media is beautiful and still king ❤

[@BrandoCritic]

I agree!

[@HunterO-rl8ku]

2001 space Odysse

[@BrandoCritic]

That's a good one for sure!

[@SmallSpoonBrigade]

Yes, although a ripped copy that you convert and stream over your own network is hard to distinguish.

[@BrandoCritic]

Yep! That's right

[@MattSmith-ks2lc]

For me, avoiding the completionist mindset is most important. It really add more shelf space and funds for film I like.

[@BrandoCritic]

Totally!

[@ChipTuneOtakuYT]

Reasons why physical media is important. 1: buying it helps Film Preservation 2: You ALWAYS have it and can’t be taken from you, in comparison to streaming where they remove stuff constantly. 3: Bonus Features that add more content like interviews, behind the scenes content, deleted scenes, etc. 4: Doesn’t require the internet to use since not everyone have an immediate internet access. 5: you don’t have to pay a monthly subscription 6: to get the content you want on streaming you will likely need multiple services, meaning multiple subscriptions making it way more expensive than cable: aka what streaming was trying to replace. If you go the one service route, you are missing out on plenty of movies from companies that have their own services. Where physical media is as simple as buying what movies (or other forms of media) you want to buy with no catches.

[@BrandoCritic]

Yep! All good points!

[@njmfff]

Also lot of special editions and releases came in unique presentation. I have Phantasm movies that came in "Silver Sphere" package. Hellraiser trilogy that came in shape of Configuration. Blind Dead collection which came in shape of little coffin (super funny), and Evil Dead that came in shape of Necronomicon. You quite literally can't get that in digital. Also lot of physical releases just look good on your shelf, some have terrific covers, Arrow releases for example, all feature unique, hand drawn covers. Yeah, they are usually lot more expensive, but I've never had Arrow DVD\BLR that I wasn't absolutely satisfied with. Those guys are movie buffs and they always do great justice to mostly cult classic movies. Lastly, for lot of us, collective movies on DVD\BLR is actually hobby unto itself. It gives you the reason to go and seek out some of those movies and you are looking for very specific releases in some cases. For example, I know lot of people who were looking for some Elm Street remake release in my country, they all agreed movie was crap, but the edition released was in some package that had fake blood on it, so when you touch DVD fake blood will spill all over cover. It was more or less collector's item, rather then someone actually wanting to watch that crap.

[@isaiahadams1996]

As much as I like streaming, I say physical media is still better cause when it comes to streaming, that movie or tv show could disappear from your list at any time. Not to mention, your WiFi could go out at any time as well, which prevents you from streaming. But you don’t have to worry about that kind of problem with physical media. PS, some people on social media are thinking about ditching streaming and going back to physical media.

[@BrandoCritic]

Yep! Totally! All valid points I brought up in the video which you touched upon too

[@TheToaprimezilla]

I think the same way too. What’s the point in having a streaming service when the movies and shows you want to watch keep disappearing. And Wi-Fi is still a problem when there is very bad weather.

[@BrandoCritic]

Totally true!

[@SmallSpoonBrigade]

Why not both? I rip my physical media to disc and stream it over my network. It makes it easy to keep tabs on the integrity of my collection and it allows me to stream what I like over my local network with minimal loss in quality over the disc.

[@BrandoCritic]

And that way you can watch it on the go

[@brandonflorida1092]

Although I probably have over 1,000 movies in my collection, every single one of them is a movie that I love a lot. That limits the expense to the point that it's not much of a drain on my budget.

[@BrandoCritic]

Totally!

[@philipdr88]

Count me in, Brandon. I love physical media. When I was younger, I used to have a huge Blu-ray collection. Until I had to sell half of it due to dire times. I still keep most of the movies I love. Nowadays, I've transitioned more to music. I have over 500 cds in my collection. And I've started getting into vinyl, and I plan to only getting albums that I think are even better on vinyl. Until the day I die, I'll never stop buying physical media.

[@BrandoCritic]

That’s awesome! As long as there is balance right?! Still have money to pay off the mortgage haha

[@philipdr88]

@@BrandoCritic Trust me, I'm being very careful with my spendings.

[@BrandoCritic]

That’s good

[@midlevelmedia]

Great video man! Everyone collects for a variety of reasons and as long as there not hurting themselves or their families financially, I think it can all be valid. Thanks for the shout man!

[@BrandoCritic]

Absolutely! Thanks man! Appreciate it!

[@GrayWolf5000]

Not when it's affecting what these studios put out. They know collectors eat up and repackaged movie and waste time on re releases instead of new stuff

[@BrandoCritic]

I don’t quite understand my guy

[@elishawilson5342]

​@@GrayWolf5000bro what are you talking about

[@BrandoCritic]

Seems like he commented on the wrong thread lol

[@devonbrooks246]

I was almost caught in the FOMO mentality and spent lots of money and decided to rethink this. 1) No more blind buys. This is the biggest waste of money. Watch it free first then decide. 2) Do I really need to watch it in 4K? Majority of the movies I watch is a flash decision. I can watch the DVD and not care about the quality of the movie. 3) Buy used DVDs for $1. This goes back to Number 2. If I watch this movie more than once, then I can decide if it's worth an upgrade. 4) Life is short. How many movies do I really need to own to make me completely happy? I found out that the more I own, the more I get suffocated. I keep my collection under a limit.

[@BrandoCritic]

Happiness isn't acquiring more stuff... it's living more life!

[@cubsfan-l9x]

These are all great points and I've found this based on my experience. I don't do DVDs really though, I will just torrent stuff and watch it and if I like it a lot, will look for a used BD, otherwise I will just delete it.

[@JohnDoe-bz4yl]

I have torrented movies and still do and if i enjoyed the movie and can see myself watching it again I'll buy a physical copy

[@BrandoCritic]

Yeah that’s fair

[@ronthorn3]

I do the same, I’ll torrent them but, if it’s good, it’s getting bought. I also have a regal unlimited subscription so I go to the theaters every week.

[@danny9405]

You brought up a great point about buying and not watching. I feel guilty paying $30+ for something that at best may be viewed/played once. What started as a just getting physical media to support an artist for a movie or record that I enjoy turned into “hey the package design on that limited edition set would be really cool to have”. Fortunately or unfortunately I go through periods where I do not care at all about my collection and adding to it and then I get random urges to see what’s out there at the moment.

[@BrandoCritic]

I get those urges too… but I always wait a day to see if I REALLY want it, or if it’s just an urge

[@rickshaw5459]

First time coming across your channel and must say you are a very very good presenter, clear consise intelligent points of view and make yourself very relatable to the movie collector out there.

[@BrandoCritic]

Welcome aboard!

[@jasoncarter455]

At least with physical media, you don't have to worry about someone hacking into your streaming service to delete your digital media library

[@BrandoCritic]

Interesting… how often does that happen

[@alienanxiety]

@@BrandoCriticprobably less often than people’s houses being broken into and having their physical media stolen.

[@BrandoCritic]

If I were to break into a house, I’d go for the immediate valuables as opposed to bringing boxes to haul the dudes physical media lol

[@alienanxiety]

@@BrandoCritic depends, are they Criterion and Arrow collections?? lol

[@BrandoCritic]

Even still… gold necklace > Boutique labels

[@Rextum]

I never had enough money to buy films I don’t care about. Also, I never get a special version, just the regular dvd (maybe a bonus disc also if the price is about the same). So, I have about 100 films plus 20 or so series. Most of those I saw on tv back in the day. Hitchcock, Kubrick, Gilliam is quality that works for me year after year. Monty Python, The Prisoner, Golden Girls, Connery and Moore Bond films, Indiana Jones, Naked Gun Trilogy with Leslie Nielsen, Peter Jackson’s Braindead, The Ring, The Thing, Bladerunner, The Dark Knight with Heath Ledger as Joker… You just know when a film is THAT good. When you don’t need a cool package, when you don’t need extras. When the film just speaks to you as it is. That is when it deserves a place in my dvd shelf.

[@BrandoCritic]

Thanks for sharing and watching ☺️👍🏻

[@scottcochrane]

What factors into my decision when purchasing a movie is 1) rewatch ability and 2) if the movie is rare to find available on Netflix or other streaming services I’m subscribed to.

[@BrandoCritic]

Totally! It’s a very practical approach

[@roxics]

I've heard people say the same thing about books and building PCs. Although they both came to peace with the idea in different ways. The book collector recognized that collecting books was a hobby unto itself. That she also enjoyed along with the hobby of reading books. That it was ok to own books you'll never read. The PC builder just admitted that his main hobby was building gaming PCs more than actually using them to play games. That's what he enjoyed doing. I've discovered this about myself as well when it comes to movies and also cameras and other tech to some degree. I think it's just a matter of self realization and honesty. What is the thing that I really enjoy? You don't have to watch the movies you collect if that's not the thing you most love about collecting them. Sometimes the idea of the thing is stronger than the thing itself. Or the artwork, packaging, soundtrack, whatever. Or sometimes the way we view or use something is better than the way it's intended. Like when you mishear a lyric in a song and then discover the real lyric isn't as good. Or when the idea you have in your head of what a movie is, is better than the movie itself. Or when the story about the movie is better than the movie. I feel that way about El Mariachi. But I think sometimes we get caught up in the idea that because we own a movie we have to watch it and enjoy it. When really we are enjoying it just by owning it. Or because we own a camera we have to shoot with it. Or a car, PC, book, you name it. So it really depends on what you actually value. I own a laserdisc I'll never watch. Because I don't own a player. I knew that when I bought the disc. I just wanted the disc for the big artwork and to have a laserdisc since I wanted them as a kid but couldn't afford them back then, and because I own the movie on VHS and the soundtrack on cassette for some reason. It's an ok movie, but I don't love it and have only seen it once. But that's ok.

[@BrandoCritic]

Thanks for the insight

[@blueshattrick]

Physical media = the ONLY way

[@BrandoCritic]

But don’t you think there are ANY advantages to streaming?

[@Rob-z7k]

I love streaming a series...but they always take off movies​@@BrandoCritic

[@BrandoCritic]

Yep. There are advantages and disadvantages to both

[@blueshattrick]

@@BrandoCritic For me personally? No.. I don't even bother with streaming services. Just use an antenna, and supplement OTA broadcasts w/ my own library

[@BrandoCritic]

Got it

[@Zodarus]

Man, great discussion. Like you said I like having the video store in my home since they are all gone now.

[@BrandoCritic]

Exactly!

[@FredJensen4745]

It’s worth it imo. I don’t have too much disposable income so I don’t really care about upgrading formats and I can’t afford to anyway. Hell my family capped off at DVD so I wouldn’t know what the quality of blu ray and 4K discs are like. Also I’m a big fan of thrift stores. They let me pick out what I really want for cheaper instead of just what Walmart is putting on the shelf. They’re my first resort. If they don’t have it AND I can’t find one on eBay for a good price, then i go to Walmart. I love my dvd and vhs collections! Also if someone doesn’t like physical media that’s fine! My parents just like having it all built into the TV. Heck my dad called having a shelf of DVDs when prime is already built into the tv retarded. I don’t give a rat’s ass what he thinks about MY stuff that I bought with MY money!

[@BrandoCritic]

Haha looks like your dad is old school in some other ways though 😂

[@cubsfan-l9x]

you are at an advantage because dvds are cheap and they are still making them for quite a bit of stuff. i'm not sure but i thought boutique labels have mostly gone to blu-ray now.

[@FredJensen4745]

@@cubsfan-l9x well I’ve caved and I’m getting into Blu ray now since Warner Archive is putting out Wait Till Your Father Gets Home on Blu ray! That being said I’m sticking with DVD for the most part still!

[@davidhoefelman4879]

Exactly! Only get what you really want. You'll appreciate it more. It will be a collection that represents what YOU really love.

[@BrandoCritic]

Totally!

[@Dizzy1980]

I have a CD player at home, and in my car. I would not own a car that did not have a CD player. I have nearly 300 CDs that I play all the time. I own around 200 Blu-Rays and DVDs and have a few VHS tapes of rare stuff. I'm not ever going to cease preferring physical media. There you have it.

[@BrandoCritic]

I get the movie stuff, but I cannot justify CD’s over Spotify. As you’re on the go with your music, I’d rather have 3000+ songs on my phone then bring 300 CDs in my car

[@Dizzy1980]

@@BrandoCritic Obviously, I don't haul all 300 CDs into the car at once. I came from a generation where we didn't have phones with songs, so I get by just fine. Hell, my first car only had a cassette deck!

[@BrandoCritic]

So did mine!

[@walterwright8454]

Old school is still the best school!

[@BrandoCritic]

Haha put that on a tshirt

[@marla4ful]

Many of the tv shows aren’t on streaming, so I started looking for those shows. Found almost all of them.

[@BrandoCritic]

Which shows?

[@marla4ful]

Beauty and the Beast (with Ron Perlman in it), Dr. Kildare and Above and Beyond. Just to name a few.

[@BrandoCritic]

Interesting!

[@daikatana65]

most of those so called collectors like midlevel don't buy their movies anymore. They get them sent to them for reviews for free. That is why most of those ratings for subpar movies are overrated so they can still collect free movies.

[@BrandoCritic]

I used to get free physical media from studios too, and let me tell you, I would say some pretty bad things about certain movies… and they still sent movies

[@michaelhawkins7389]

@@BrandoCritic amazing vidoe just to point out also that there are 26 films lol , including No Time To die. but the 2015 James Bond boxset is 25 films (Dr No 1962- Spectre 2015) So you would have to buy No Time To Die on its own.

[@BrandoCritic]

There are 25 official films and two other unofficial films. That making the complete total number 27

[@jpenir]

Not entirely true. When Ken at Mid-level media was doing his audits he would say which ones he purchased and which were sent to him for free. He had a lot of freebies but the vast majority he still paid for. And he paid a LOT some months.

[@BrandoCritic]

Totally… even when people get stuff for free… they don’t get EVERYTHING for free. Plus, that just means they have more money to spend on movies anyway 😂😂

[@Maratletoso]

Very nice video!, and you are totally right with getting rid of a movie you dont like and never watch… that’s how you will eliminate part of the money issue of the hobby and the completionist mindset…. We all collectors have being there

[@BrandoCritic]

Totally my dude!

[@m.dorado6966]

The biggest concern for any hardcore collector is the fear of a limited edition selling out and then forced to buy in the after market from eBay or Amazon sellers. My biggest weakness in any steelbook or boxset is the artwork. It's eye candy to me. You bring out many valid points in your video.

[@BrandoCritic]

Thank you very much!

[@MAFion]

Collect what you love and hold on to it. Nothing beats the quality of physical media. Nothing.

[@BrandoCritic]

It’s very good indeed

[@SHEENAS_LAUGHS]

Pawnshop,thrifty stores that’s where I get most of my movies..1-2$ for dvd(BD-4k)..It’s not gonna be the latest movies but I’m totally fine with that..

[@BrandoCritic]

Me too!

[@MediaFeverPitch]

Yeah dude when I start my collection most of my movies were a dollar or two. And then a few I spent $5. And then generally when I upgrade to Blu-ray it was 5-8 dollar movies. Usually buy two get one free. The place where I've really spent the money is upgrading movies to 4K but that's just for my all-time favorites. And I've spent some money on boutique labels. At least most of those titles retain their value if I don't love the movie.

[@BrandoCritic]

That’s how I built my collection too!

[@camdencoblentz3245]

Some time ago, I was looking over my dvds and blu-rays and realized that I had acquired over 30 from my local thrift store, which seemed like a real money saver for me, and I'm very particular about condition, as I've passed up a lot of stuff over there. I'm not necessarily obsessed with owning a huge amount of physical media for space reasons, but I definitely enjoy claiming ownership of copies of entertainment I enjoy.

[@BrandoCritic]

For sure! I had HUNDREDS of DVDs from our local flea market

[@jordanpresley5336]

The thrill of the hunt is definitely a major aspect of collecting for me. Nothing quite like stumbling upon a rare Blu-ray copy

[@BrandoCritic]

It’s not owning it that’s fun, it’s buying it

[@BroadwayGuy]

As a person with a physical disability, it is very difficult for me to stream, use an APP, or whatever everybody is doing today. I need physical media. Apart from the fact that sometimes I have to put physical media in cases or collection boxes that are more accessible for me (easier for me to use), physical media works for.

[@BrandoCritic]

Physical Media is EASIER for someone with a disability?

[@RPKGameVids]

I would've assumed that streaming or using an app would be easier than PM for a disabled person. What makes PM easier for you if you don't mind me asking?

[@BrandoCritic]

I would assume that too, but that’s why I’m curious! No judgement I promise!

[@FORBIDCharlie1986]

As a person with a physical disability, I can switch from season 1 episode 3 of The Office to season 9 episode 1 in less than a minute using Peacock. I can also watch it at a cafe on my iPad while on vacation in Europe.

[@BrandoCritic]

Yes. Streaming is very convenient

[@ALCAN52]

Several reasons I collect physical media. 1. I want to be able to watch movies/series if internet is down. This is common in Alaska where I live. 2. We are limited in internet data per month. 3. Streaming in general sucks. 4. My mother recorded a lot of classic movies (pre-1980) and Ive been acquiring them and watching. Its my way of honoring her. I only do dvds. Dont have Blue ray player.

[@BrandoCritic]

3. Streaming in general sucks - Explain good sir

[@TheAleosha]

I remember a time when we were told that high game prices are just because printing discs is expensive, and once we go digital, prices will drop. That never happened, though, the publishers just pocketed the money.

[@BrandoCritic]

That’s capitalism. They charge you… because they can

[@TheAleosha]

@@BrandoCritic Socialists hardly managed to produce magnet tapes 😆

[@BrandoCritic]

Okay

[@cubsfan-l9x]

Yeah at least Apple movies often go on sale between $5-10. I can't believe some companies like Criterion Collection are charging $40 for a 4K Blu-ray, especially for obscure things people have never seen. I'd never pay that much on a blind buy. Maybe for a movie that I really like that I want a collector's edition of.

[@BryanRiel]

Raiders of the Lost Ark is my most double-dipped. Unpopular opinion: I don’t mind double-dipping. Most new releases omit special features from older versions, despite the awesome visual/audio upgrades. It’s cool to have everything you need to know about your favorite films on those discs.

[@BrandoCritic]

Yeah I can understand that

[@DavidMander-rs4uk]

Physical media is always worth it because streaming subscriptions suck and need to go away already!!

[@BrandoCritic]

Why do they suck and need to go away already?

[@thiscorrosion3843]

​@@BrandoCriticseriously?

[@BrandoCritic]

This guy made a statement and I am simply asking why he thinks so

[@scottaudetat3090]

On the BOB & TOM show today they were talking that since Teri Garr passed away, one of them wanted to rewatch YOUNG FRANKENSTEIN. Currently, it isn't streaming anywhere and you can't rent it anywhere either. That's why Physical Media is forever.

[@BrandoCritic]

Got it

[@southendonseaarts]

I can’t look at my whole collection. Because it crosses three rooms.😅

[@BrandoCritic]

Haha that’s a collection I tell ya

[@mikecrawford1247]

A great aunt I had as a kid and ‘inspired’ my collecting had a vhs collection so big they were in drawers all over her house

[@BrandoCritic]

Haha that's awesome!

[@robertt9342]

The time part of hunting ignores the part that some (not me for discs) enjoy the search to find these items. It’s not a waste to them, it’s the activity they really enjoy.

[@BrandoCritic]

I enjoy it too

[@sicpuppy9435]

All mine are on 2TB - 6TB hard drives, I have a massive collection of Movies, Anime, TV Shows, Cartoons from the 60's to today all in alphabetical order, I am more than happy with my set up.

[@BrandoCritic]

Perfect! See, whatever works for you! Glad you have a system you love!

[@griffin2674]

How do you get to save them on hard drives?

[@BrandoCritic]

Probably by ripping them from disc or torrenting I’m assuming

[@MediaFeverPitch]

That sounds great. But for me personally I want to have the special features and the packaging. Even if I went that route I still own at least a hundred or two movies of physically.. There's certain movies like Conan or road warrior that I have to have a physical copy of. As long as it exists.

[@BrandoCritic]

Road Warrior! Good movie!

[@Sanderus]

Physical media - books, movies, music - whatever will remain unaltered. All things digital is being altered, or deleted for one reason or another, it is happening left, right and center. With modern technology possibilities are endless.

[@BrandoCritic]

That's a good point

[@flibber123]

I gave up physical media for two main reasons. One, space. If you build up even a half way decent collection then it's going to require space. I'd rather use that space for something else. Secondly, convenience. When I want to watch something, I want to start watching it immediately. I don't want to have to go through a menu, FBI warnings, or any of that kind of stuff.

[@BrandoCritic]

All valid points!

[@nicholasthill7151]

It's also a fairly expensive hobby. Streaming is significantly cheaper. And if you don't have a player, you have a coaster collection.

[@BrandoCritic]

Totally! The exact first point I mention in the video

[@mediaintegrationservices419]

Laserdisc is the perfect format for you, no unskippable warning screens, no previews, no before movie features. You hit play and the movie begins.

[@BrandoCritic]

And the packaging can’t be beat! I have a few and I LOVE them

[@jnaught1358]

It took me until time mark 6:54 to realize that this was not aimed at my generation. I found the perspective, and the comment section quite fun, and interesting. What’s now called “physical media” (6 syllables) is what was throwing me off.. It’s a lot of vocalization to describe something that was pretty basic, and for granted for us.. Examples: Record, (two syllables) tape (one) DVD (three) CD (two) We grew up with touching, owning and experiencing those things just as our parents’ parents and their parents in the mid to late 1800’s.. I was amazed when I realized that it’s now a collector thing vs. having a film in the house because we had a home theater. Movie hits theaters, a couple months later you can own it. Wait a year or so for our fav artist to release an album, tape and cd, and simply go buy it. Clearly I must be sitting on a small fortune since I inherited my dad’s vinyl collection, which includes my grandfather’s, which are 100yrs old and change.. I thank you for the insight

[@BrandoCritic]

I grew up in this time too, but I am aware of the culture shift

[@kylesmyle4233]

I only double dipped once, First, I got the Back to the Future trilogy on DVD. Then, when I started collecting Blu-rays, i got the 30th anniversary collection on the Blu-ray. When the ultimate trilogy came out I got the Target version of it. So now, I have 3 editions of the Back to the Future trilogy. But I don't regret it.

[@BrandoCritic]

Right on! That’s awesome!

[@arokh72]

I've only accidentally double dipped, buying a movie I forgot I already owned. These days I'll only buy an upgrade, and thus double dip, if the disc no longer works, such as the dreaded DVD "rot" from movies I bought 20 years ago. I watched Pirates of the Caribbean on my original purchase DVD the other night, and was happy with the quality etc, so no need to upgrade. The only special editions I ever purchased were the original expanded release LoTR DVDs, that came with figurines. Those figurines are still proudly on display in my lounge room, over 20 years later :)

[@BrandoCritic]

I’m glad you still have your original DVD!

[@MovieGuy365]

Great video Brandon, it’s a cool topic and many of your points I share as well! 👍

[@BrandoCritic]

Awesome, thank you! Glad you enjoyed it

[@stephenperri2861]

Well said-Great video!

[@BrandoCritic]

I'm glad you liked it!

[@Vranksy]

I love the tip of getting rid of the bad ones out of a franchise... I also used to collect every movie from a franchise. Hence I own The Predator, a movie I absolutely loathe... I need to get rid of it asap.

[@BrandoCritic]

Yeah, it’s a good way to look at it

[@milescoburn1845]

Absolutely. When I purchase physical media it's mine. I have it in my possession. To watch or play it whenever I want to. I'm not reliant on whatever streaming service is providing it to maintain its license to distribute it. How often do movies / TV shows leave Amazon, Netflix, etc.? Additionally, the physical copy doesn't change with the vagaries of society that will necessitate changing dialogue, cutting scenes from movies provided by a streaming service. I've got the movie I want. No one can change it.

[@BrandoCritic]

Yep! That’s right

[@madbug1965]

This is why most of my DVD collection is standard DVD with some Blu-ray. I can pick up used DVDs for $1-$3. It allows me to have a larger collection at a cheaper price. Sure the picture quality isn't as good but the standard definition is good enough for me. I just like having the movie. So keep upgrading your movies and I will keep buying them up on the cheap. And yes I used to be a laser disc collector so I know how obsessing over your collection can be. I'm passed that now. 😊

[@BrandoCritic]

Yeah that’s awesome!

[@Choom89]

Depends what it is, do your research and get what you actually want. It may take time but that's a hobby, just make sure it's fun!

[@BrandoCritic]

Totally agree!

[@JohnDoe-bz4yl]

I am now getting through my backlog of unwatched movies by the 3:1 ratio method Watch 3 movies before buying 1 new one

[@BrandoCritic]

That’s a good method!

[@NocturnalToothbrush]

Oh course it is.

[@BrandoCritic]

Are you responding to the title? Or the thumbnail? And how come?

[@NocturnalToothbrush]

@@BrandoCritic All digital items, video games, movies, music are all rented. You don't own those. They can be removed at any time, and they WILL be removed at some point. Having a physical copy in your collection is also a physical representation of your love for that movie. People who need to collect every version of a title have a mental issue. That's ridiculous.

[@BrandoCritic]

Gotcha… so there’s a scale haha

[@jamied1579]

It's been said by some sources that most people who torrent movies usually end up buying them. Given the expense involved it's obvious it becomes a way of 'trying before buying', and also, therefore, that it doesn't cost the industry as much money as they claim it does - I don't actually know if that's the case or not but there are definitely people who subsequently buy a large percentage of what they torrent

[@BrandoCritic]

I’ve heard of that before. I also saw a study that people who have an expensive theatre system in their house are MORE likely to go to the theatre. I guess because those people REALLY love cinema, and they’re trying as hard as they can to replicate the theatre experience

[@MediaFeverPitch]

That's how I was back in the days of CDs. I still bought a lot of CDs. Probably more than the average person.

[@BrandoCritic]

So glad Spotify exists though!

[@IN5T1NCT66]

the best way I've hear it all explained!!!

[@BrandoCritic]

Thank you!!

[@ElMago-iu6ox]

I do own Pet Sematary (1989) on vhs, dvd and blu ray! Its one of my favorites

[@BrandoCritic]

That’s cool!!

[@BrandoCritic]

Never seen it actually!

[@Canbutcant]

The reason I started collecting honestly: there was an anime I couldn't watch on any streaming platforms. I got to watch it but I had to paid $100. It was out of print, it's still out of print now. I have the insurance that I'll always have access to it.

[@BrandoCritic]

Absolutely!

[@stimpy2695]

It's always worth it having a movie collection, just only buy what you absolutely want to own. Don't blind buy, and stay away from the majority of 4K releases, most are not true 4K (which involves going back to the original camera negative for movies shot on film). Don't get me wrong though, there are some very good 4KUHD releases.

[@BrandoCritic]

Totally. I always do my research before upgrading to a 4K release!

[@stimpy2695]

@@BrandoCritic 👍👍

[@BrandoCritic]

Two thumbs up indeed

[@jpenir]

I went on a physical media spending binge last year. Gobbled up like 200 horror movies. While I'm happy to have them, the reality of cost and space became apparent. I could have gotten the majority of these movies on digital either for free or very low cost. And I quickly ran out of space for the discs. While I know that physical media has superior PQ and sound, the trade off was the things I mentioned above. I ended up selling about 50 of the 200 discs. I wish I had done more research into the quality of some of those old horror movies!

[@BrandoCritic]

Totally valid points!

[@bobsmith9271]

I've considered stopping collecting physical media, too. I already don't purchase CDs or physical video games, anymore. The only physical media that I still buy is movies, and that's DVD only. I never got into 4K or Blu-ray. Even now, I always second guess myself when buying a movie. I'm always thinking to myself, "Do I really need this? Am I even going to watch it? I could just stream it.". The only thing that keeps me collecting is the fear that certain movies may eventually be removed from streaming, so basically I'm only collecting to have a backup copy. Thank goodness I never became a completionist collector. I own one DVD of every movie that I like, and that's it. I don't even display my movies. I keep them all in boxes, in my closet, until I need them.

[@BrandoCritic]

That’s a good mindset

[@MonkeBlak]

Physical copy will always be the choice. Only one reason for me. “Has better QUALITY AUDIO.” I watch movies on my home theater and there is a difference in AUDIO from Digital to Physical.

[@BrandoCritic]

Very nice!

[@kathk94]

Used to have a 4k movie collection but now I've transitioned back to cds. Like the films I had, I have a small cd collection of only albums I can repeatedly listen to that I'm passionate about. Love physical media.

[@BrandoCritic]

That’s awesome!

[@masonteague4039]

I prefer physical media I own DVD's

[@BrandoCritic]

Awesome! How many do you own?

[@masonteague4039]

@@BrandoCritic not sure but a lot

[@BrandoCritic]

Ball park… Over 500?

[@masonteague4039]

@@BrandoCritic I haven't counted

[@BrandoCritic]

Just an estimate. For example, I have about 800 blurays

[@ARMediaOfficial]

100% it is, nothing will top having something tangible in your hand especially if it's something you love. Streaming is just becoming more frustrating and expensive by the day

[@BrandoCritic]

Thanks

[@mediamaniac898]

Much like George Costanza, I double-dipped on the Dark Knight trilogy (well, actually, I have the DVD/Blu-rays/4K). Same with others, and when James Cameron released Aliens on 4K, I already had it on Blu-ray. Some streaming services don’t even let you watch a movie unless you subscribe to an additional one.

[@BrandoCritic]

Just curious how you had the abyss on BluRay? Thought that movie never got a BluRay release… like, those are the famous ones for never getting a BluRay

[@mediamaniac898]

@@BrandoCritic I saw it for the FIRST TIME with my dad when Cameron released it one night remastered for 4K, and it’s one of his highly underrated movies. A bit too long, but we agreed that the love story worked. I bought the 4K ASAP, cause it was in such short supply esp at first!

[@BrandoCritic]

Oh sorry, I was thinking of the Abyss! My bad!

[@mistersurrealist]

I love physical media, but I have no time or space for clutter at this point in my life anymore. I still have a huge collection of DVDs, Blu-rays and games and I barely touch them. They're all basically "rotting away" in a closet. These days I will support any store that sells DRM-free digital content. It's digital, but it's actually mine and no one will take it away.

[@BrandoCritic]

Space is always an issue

[@TheJuzi]

i work in a charity shop in the uk, we sell DVD's at £1 for 20. Not a typo, 20 dvds for £1!!

[@BrandoCritic]

Haha can’t get rid of them hey?!

[@TheJuzi]

@@BrandoCriticThe shelves are full and We have them stacked up in a container. Good source for 90's films though. I regularly take some home, watch them then take them back. We sell Blu ray 4 for £1. Yes FOUR for £1.

[@BrandoCritic]

Haha send me a message on IG! Maybe I can buy some and pay shipping! @BrandoCritic

[@erinrising2799]

I just bought some used movies from the library, so while money from the purchase might not have gone to the creators, it went to the library so I think that's still a benefit

[@BrandoCritic]

Of course

[@Skullcandy5282]

As a decently enthusiastic physical collector my biggest recommendation is to do research before upgrading to a better format, 4k for example lots of releases aren't really worth upgrading and have pretty bad transfers, planes, trains and automobiles for example. I use to be a huge steelbook collector and bought all the newest movies that I heard good things about but was often left disappointed if I hadn't seen the film before, I still pick up stuff but I'm a lot more conservative about what I actual want and try not to get caught up in the "limited edition" craze unless I really love the set and generally stick to something I already love unless I get a good deal.

[@BrandoCritic]

That's a good approach

[@MuhamadNazrin-y6b]

nice video brother..i was hearing this while brisk walking without seeing ur face, i was shocked at the line "'My girlfriend bring her girlfriend over" 😂 U know in this modern world, easily missunderstood haha

[@BrandoCritic]

I think we all know what kind of movies you’re watching ;)

[@MuhamadNazrin-y6b]

@@BrandoCritic haha noo

[@CRITTERBUSTERS]

I love physical media simply because when you buy it you own it. You don’t have to worry about a streaming service losing the licence to the movie when you have it on disc. Also Collectors editions with extra features are very nice. For me I went from VHS to DVD around 2003 then in 2014 I started with Blu-Ray but I never double dipped on every movie. The only time I double dipped was if the DVD version was a bare bones warts and all release. So to buy a Special edition Blu-Ray of Ridley Scott’s Black Rain (1989) for instance, was a huge upgrade. But I wouldn’t buy it again, as I just don’t see the point. The remaster on the BR looks amazing.

[@BrandoCritic]

That’s awesome!

[@justanativeman8608]

Internet wasn't working for over a week, still needs work

[@BrandoCritic]

Haha worked enough to send this comment? Kidding of course

[@alienanxiety]

I have a substantial collection, but as I get older, I realize there is less and less time to ever revisit all these films. If I could snap my fingers and trade my entire collection for what I originally paid for it, I’d do it in a heartbeat. I’m scared to even think how much money that would be.

[@BrandoCritic]

Haha oh yes, that dreaded question

[@LordDementus1987]

I believe it is still worth it. You just have to be more strategic about purchases so you aren't overpaying for things.

[@BrandoCritic]

Yep!

[@jcarr2000anz]

The most physical media copies I have of one movie is, Titanic. Last time I counted I had 16. From the VHS tape, Laser Disc, Blu-Ray, and 4K. Some of them are European copies, and one from Australia. The next movie is The Batman, and I think I have 7-8 copies, including the Steelbook from Australia to which the US received later on. Long story.

[@BrandoCritic]

Oh wow! That’s a ton of them! I’d love to see a collection photo!

[@Benieg83]

Not sure that's healthy man...

[@BrandoCritic]

He’s not hurting anyone…

[@jimwoodswrites]

I just wish physical media was easier to find at affordable prices. The prices continue to go through the roof and Walmart is doing such a lousy job at picking up the slack from Best Buy, Target and others.

[@BrandoCritic]

Yep that’s true

[@ThorTwinkle]

Right now I'm buying only movies that I now I'm going to rewatch. I realized it was the right thing to do when I kept renting the 007 movies over and over again from Prime 😅

[@BrandoCritic]

Haha there you go!

[@RyanBromhead503]

I've always been a physical media collector (DVDs and Video Games.) I've only bought a few films, that are brand new (Helldriver is 14 years old, and Grave Encounters is 13 years old, when I bought them from HMV brand new). Only pre-ordered 1 film (The FNAF movie on DVD (1 for me, and one for my mum) from HMV) Majority of the DVDs I have (and all my PS3 games), I bought from charity shops and CEX

[@BrandoCritic]

Very cool!

[@walterwright8454]

I hear you about being a completist. I recently purchased the blu-ray of Star Trek TNG. I have all 7 seasons and I didn't think the first two seasons were that great, some episodes were horrible, but since I wanted all the seasons, I bought them and I watched all of them.

[@BrandoCritic]

Gotcha!

[@Hammster69official]

I've only really upgraded the player, since the new players play the old stuff - 4K also plays BluRay and DVD, and BluRay also plays DVD. Any changes in discs have more often been when they put out an entire series that takes up the space of only a single case, for space saving/room for new titles.

[@BrandoCritic]

Sure, but have you seen some of the new 4K Transfers of your favourite movies?

[@AkagiRedSun]

I learned the hard way that PS4 or Xbox will not play Blu-ray if the console is not connected to the internet which means if the server goes down in the future you won’t be able to play Blu-ray videos. I still use PS3 to play any Blu-ray Disc even to this day

[@BrandoCritic]

Oh interesting

[@TheDreamtimezzz]

The negatives are just staying focused. Stick to your budget. Like other “collecting” hobbies, not everyone is a completionist, the hunt and social connections are part of the fun. The positives WAY out way the negatives.

[@BrandoCritic]

Of course. I love having my collection

[@djkb2239]

Great video man

[@BrandoCritic]

Appreciate it! Thank you!

[@thrashpuppy2010]

Stopped repurchasing movies I already own. There always seems to be another re-release of movies with different packaging etc coming out. Like your idea of having a collection where every movie means something too.

[@BrandoCritic]

Totally!

[@marksmovieroom]

There's no doubt-I will always want to own physical copies of my favorite films and albums. I only collect what I genuinely enjoy. When the internet goes down or streaming services remove certain titles, I'll still have my personal collection to turn to. I’ve kept my DVDs because I’ve always loved watching special features and listening to audio commentaries, which are becoming harder to find on modern releases.

[@BrandoCritic]

That's a very good point! I loved all the Lord of the Rings and Star Wars special features

[@StanleyRunk]

The one I’ve probably spent the most on over the course of my life is Night of the Living Dead. I had numerous VHS tapes with various covers in multiple editions. Same case with the dvd, including the infamous “special edition “. Then of course the Blu Ray and 4K UHD. And also consider the various multi packs that include the movie. The kicker is that the movie is in public domain!

[@BrandoCritic]

Gotcha! Good movie though 👍🏻

[@dereckabackus5411]

I double dip on vhs to dvd for my favorite movies. But I rewatch my dvd collection every weekend.

[@BrandoCritic]

How many movies do you have?

[@Kid_Ego]

Well said sir... well said! 🌟🤟

[@BrandoCritic]

Thank you!!!

[@stephenjacewicz4594]

Absolutely. I do it all though, physical, stream, and movie theaters and buy digital.

[@BrandoCritic]

A real movie fan here!

[@ronthorn3]

The downside is watching those people go overkill and buy TONS of, especially boutique films,a month. Buying 10 boutique films could run you anywhere from $500-$1000 depending on the film edition. That’s fucking insane.

[@BrandoCritic]

That’s it yep

[@njmfff]

But lot of people consider collecting physical media their hobby. It's no different then collecting memorabilia, toys, comics, etc. It's hobby for lot of people.

[@BrandoCritic]

For sure. I heard a great phrase… have your hobby, just don’t be an alcoholic with your hobby. Just don’t let it get out of hand

[@Rob-z7k]

I still collect dvds! I now want to upload my dvd series into a USB! Ive been collecting lots of Western and Mobster shows of the late 50s! Cant stream them classics! I LOVE my Clint Eastwood movie collection!

[@BrandoCritic]

That's cool!

[@patrickwilliams1801]

Target and BestBuy no longer carries physical media. Walmart carries mostly DVDS.

[@BrandoCritic]

In the USA perhaps

[@walterwright8454]

It most certainly is. I am not paying for multiple streaming services, which too many come with commercials, in hopes that what I want to watch is on one of them. I get better sound and picture with blu-ray than any streaming service out there. The internet is down, I can't use Prime, Hulu, Netflix, etc. My blu-ray player is working fine, I can watch any of my movies at any time I want to. Old school is the best school.

[@BrandoCritic]

Haha old school is the best school. Then is VHS the way to go??

[@walterwright8454]

@@BrandoCritic For some it is. Not for me, so in that case Not too old school is the best school.

[@BrandoCritic]

Haha within limits

[@adammorgan4379]

I'm suffering from spending more time collecting than actually watching my movies. This year 2024 has been the most I've ever spent on 4k and 1080 blurays. HELP !!!!

[@BrandoCritic]

Hahaha do what I did! Pledge not to buy for a year and focus on watching and thinning your collection

[@shanenice5380]

i liked physical media.u helped bring j.o.b.s.i went to best buy.i asked the guy u have.blu rays.he say no i don't wanna shipping them?i say to myself,atleast u have something to do to keep hes job.

[@BrandoCritic]

Thanks!

[@BroadwayGuy]

I have more than triple-dipped on various editions of "The Wizard Of Oz" (1939), "West Side Story" (1961) and "The Sound Of Music" (1965).

[@BrandoCritic]

Some good ones!!

[@mrjamesmay3548]

I’m a 90’s kid so grew up with VHS DVD but stopped at blu ray and went to digital purchase via iTunes as I got fed up with new formats. Luckily iTunes does the free upgrades to 4K so I think it’s better value for money. Having said that I’m half tempted to start buying 4K or maybe at least for my top 25 favourite films. Its an odd thing to be torn about

[@BrandoCritic]

What’s an odd thing? Buying Physical Media? It’s not THAT important in the grand scheme of things

[@mrjamesmay3548]

@@BrandoCritic ha no I’m saying I’m odd for being so in decisive about it.

[@BrandoCritic]

Oh, OK. Gotcha!

[@jasonleetaiwan]

Physical media plus streaming is the way. Ultimately, we want as much access as we can get in our region. I like to buy HBO titles in physical format because there is no Max in Taiwan. Hopefully 4K is the last format. I also recently decided not to upgrade a lot of my blu ray titles to 4K. I just don’t care about those films enough to repurchase them again. DVD, Blu Ray….let’s stop there.

[@BrandoCritic]

Thus the “double dipping” phenomenon

[@Scifi4life]

Digital films are the future.

[@BrandoCritic]

I think so...