Cam Newton ranks every single 2024 NFL Quarterback

[@jasonalfonso210]

Sad cause Cam literally states it's not based on skill and clearly situation. Yet ppl commenting, how is this player ranked higher than this player...smh

[@ezekwu]

smh...

[@Martial300]

can’t be cus Brock’s in probably the best situation in the league

[@jasonalfonso210]

@natea3638 smh, again, if you hear him speak, he literally put Burdy in both categories 2 and 3 because he has the best supporting cast...not sure what you're arguing

[@tinaholland6915]

In certain situations your situation will affect your skills

[@Imblxkk]

@jasonalfonso210 A lot of these people just dumb asf that’s why

[@ZacharyRB2]

This is the right way to rank QB's, you can't simply put a number on a position this complex and dependent.

[@bonym371]

Fax! Players like Purdy and hurts, teams loaded to the Hilt should be doing the Super Bowl every year.,Tua, Same thing

[@luism8130]

@@bonym371 Clearly you don't watch the dolphins... We have the worst O-line in the NFL and Tua still led the league in passing yards. All these other teams have loaded O-lines, Tua literally has less than 2 seconds to throw the ball. No other QB would survive this line.

[@Los150]

💯

[@Los150]

@@luism8130Give us Tua’s numbers before Reek got there…

[@Wheretheicecreamatinthisjoint]

@@luism8130burrow would lol. He had a dookie o line

[@Marcdadon85]

I like this break down..especially that “are you the reason” category..good sh*t

[@jeanfourcade]

Indeed, it's a brilliant classification.

[@malachiyoung4005]

Minus Jalen hurts but facts

[@maskedman5657]

It's dumb like Cam's opinions

[@elizabethgodfrey1033]

Why are u on his site if he is dumb?? Seems like u stir up s*it!

[@cgruthless49erstalk58]

Nope he disrespect Brock Purdy that's why Christian McCaffrey didn't invite him to the wedding

[@DeikerriaMoore-bi7vw]

I guess nobody can get over the dak hate to comprehend why he is in tier 1.. he always does great in the regular season but not in the post season, so there for at this point in his career nothing to else matters except doing well in the POST SEASON!

[@bobbyvance7902]

Him and tua did the same but tua had the most yards and is a better qb

[@DeikerriaMoore-bi7vw]

If you feel tua is better then that’s fine but that doesn’t change the facts of what cam said.. nothing matters but the playoffs for dak because he needs to do better. We already know he’s good in the regular season so now he has to go farther in the postseason

[@neetrab]

​@@DeikerriaMoore-bi7vw Dak is Tier 3. The team is 8-2 last 10 games he's missed dating back to 2020.

[@SilmeonMusic]

@@neetrabwhy you lying? They won 5 games without Dak in 2020 smh. Defense kept those teams in 2022 to less than 20 points the games they won without him. And we know the defense fizzles out second half of the season.. but go ahead and think the cowboys are even contenders in their division let alone their conference without Dak. It’s not just by chance Cowboys have had a top 5 offense with Dak. I mean the QB runs the offense 😂 they haven’t depended on the run game since 2019..

[@DeikerriaMoore-bi7vw]

So because the cowboys had good back ups that can hold down the fort when dak is injured that’s a bad thing 🤔.. the last time I checked a back up won y’all Super Bowl but did y’all complain no! And you clearly keep missing the point of the tiers

[@dejeonbattick1245]

haven't seen a list I agree with so much..... well done Cam

[@hockeyfan1799]

Yikes

[@sterlt.2836]

People in the comments demonstrating their lack of active listening skills. Lmfao. It’s no wonder yal having so much trouble in that dating pool

[@maskedman5657]

@sterlt.2836 I've listened long enough to know Cam is biased as hell

[@Giopowered]

@@maskedman5657ok sissy

[@maskedman5657]

@@Giopowered ok panzy

[@davidfossi5016]

You slobbin on cam so hard

[@maskedman5657]

@@hugh-jasole I know what an opinion is. It just happens that Cam's opinions is trash

[@FLipSide5254]

I liked the way Cam ranked them; this is probably the best way to rank QB.

[@Cookiesrfood]

A lot of people in these comments are completely missing the point of these tiers these tiers are not about who are the best QB's there about the type of situation each QB is in lol. For example, Dak is in tier 1 not because he's one of the best QBs but because he is currently in a situation where regular season success doesn't mean anything he could go 17-0 and no one would care he needs to win a SB. Dak has already proven he can win in the regular season with 3 straight 12-win seasons.

[@mopinggoku4708]

Then why is brock tier 3 lol

[@mopinggoku4708]

Dak should be in 3 if Jalen and brock r

[@Cookiesrfood]

@@mopinggoku4708 Reread my comment and others explaining this the answer is obvious why Brock and Hurts are in tier 3 but your still one of the people hung up on this tier being a best QB list when its not.

[@mattdrummond9087]

There is only 1 QB in teir 1.

[@Jettias_]

@@mopinggoku4708is Brock the reason why the 9er winning or is it the team built around him that wins? Really is not that hard to understand

[@fulcrumsee5968]

What if in some off universe when Andy Reid got fired in 2012, Rivera was fired as well, and Reid ended up as the Panthers head coach? I think Cam's story would be completely different.

[@JKB12344]

Oh yeah Cam winning atleast 2 super bowls

[@jump6098]

Rivera finessed the NFL into thinking he was a good coach

[@malachiyoung4005]

I don’t think that’s how it works

[@CLS_7301]

Yeah cocaine is hell of a drug

[@chilliewilliefromphilly]

That puts him in tier 3. BTW, I'm a huge Cam fan, but he sneak dissin.

[@lilmanluigiofficial2557]

Yall so slow in the comments 😂

[@real_blackmamba8665]

🐌 no child left behind

[@ejpeoples170]

Nah bruh this a terrible list dawg Watson over hurts? Joe Flacco played better than him last year 😂

[@maskedman5657]

@lilmanluigiofficial2557 The only thing that is slow is Cam's Critical Thinking Skills

[@MallyG678]

They're slow in real life, not just in the comments. There's a lot of people who don't listen well and/or comprehend well & it shows. 😅

[@maskedman5657]

@@MallyG678 I've listened to Cam's reasoning. And it still sucks. This list is garbage

[@Fytb_Austin]

“He can take all the other ones he not faster then me” 🤣🤣

[@tumelo4526]

Or stronger 💪 😂

[@MckieDs595]

Cam basically just doing what he wants more in life. I love it

[@DirtyJraco]

jalen hurts wasnt even close to the problem that horrible coaching staff who couldnt plan a decent drive was the problem

[@w0nderwallCS]

The coaches threw all the ints last year?

[@DirtyJraco]

@@w0nderwallCS naw im talking about the plays the coaching called jalen threw them picks but like i said they couldnt plan a decent drive to save their lives if you watched a game the moment when they went on that losing streak you'd see

[@michaelleslie6992]

Can should include the coaching unless it’s part of team problem. But it mostly falls on player situation.

[@DirtyJraco]

@@michaelleslie6992 most of the time no matter the time no matter the horrible coaching players will take the blame because most players only watch the game and not whats going on behide the scenes

[@Standby_JRB]

​@stxrfighter first off, 15ints is a lot, but it's not astronomical or horrendous... 2nd off, if ur unwilling to say 1 great year makes him great, then 1 poor year doesn't make him bad... he's inconsistent bc he's had 4 different OCs in 4 years in the league, he has to learn a completely new offense every year with Brian Johnson being by far the worst offensive scheme I think has ever existed in the NFL and Hurts still put up better numbers than most other QBs would have. Plus Nick Siriani is a joke, he's a yes man and hype man, he does nothing to help scheme for wins and is less mature than Hurts. Give Hurts a legit OC and HC for 2+ years and he's top 3 QB for sure

[@magshell5]

MY GUY!!!! CAM IS A GENIUS! Me and brother just had this conversation. We need another one!!!!

[@pm21-v3h]

Not so much, Herbert being in tier 3 while he’s had a bottom 5 defense and special teams his whole career is wild.. how are you still debating if Hebert is the problem when the only reason the chargers are relevant is due to his play.. Herbert has led the chargers to a top 10 offense twice… never has he been able to rely on the chargers. If Herbert has a off game there’s literally 0 chances they win..

[@MrZynmaster]

your bar for genius is is really really ridiculously low

[@dwaynekeenum1916]

He was a bust

[@CornealiusG24]

I like Cam's view on these QBs because a bunch of them definitely only thrive because of coaching and the environment around them. I also liked that he made it clear for a few QBs that yes, u did good for 1 year or your rookie year, but can u do it consistently every year. Good list by Cam.

[@Drocalypse6]

Can't you say Mahomes would be tier 3 then? Cause Alex Smith was going crazy in the Chiefs system

[@CornealiusG24]

@Drocalypse6 No u can't say that because although having Andy Reid as his head coach and having that environment/system has been very beneficial to his career no doubt about it, but with that being said Mahomes is still Mahomes. What I mean when I say that is Andy Reid didn't give him his arm/talents. Mahomes is the only quarterback in the league that has no flaws/weaknesses. He's able to make every throw, and he's always even keel. He's able to play inside the pocket and outside the pocket. He's able to throw with both hands. Mahomes is in a league of his own, and no other quarterback comes close. Mahomes would thrive with any team in any system. Having Andy Reid definitely makes him a Super Bowl contender every year, but Mahomes would be playoff bound even if he played for the bears or the Panthers that's just how great he is. I don't believe the same thing could be said for Brock Purdy, Joe Burrow, or Josh Allen. To your point yes Alex Smith did good with the Chiefs but Alex Smith never won the Super Bowl even though he had Jamal Charles at running back, Dwayne Bowe at receiver, and Travis Kelce at tight end. Andy Reid was his head coach from 2013-2017 and finally Mahomes took over in December of 2017, so Alex Smith had a plenty of chance but couldn't get over the hump and Mahomes did.

[@Drocalypse6]

@@CornealiusG24 I know he got the accolades, the talent but for in my opinion is Mahomes without weapons is a different Mahomes he's not putting up the good to crazy numbers and the Chiefs defense pretty much carried that team last year I feel and this year already. That's just me though, and the argument with him going to one of the bad teams and changing them around, I would say yeah I feel he would get a couple more wins than the qbs there now because of the coach. But we won't know that

[@CornealiusG24]

@Drocalypse6 I can respect your point of view/opinion my guy and yea it's all hypotheticals right now, so unless he changes teams, we definitely won't know the outcome for fact if he played somewhere else. As for him without weapons, in my view nothing really changed except the numbers did slightly dip a lil bit. He lost Tyreek Hill and won the Super Bowl. Also this year he loses his top receiver and running back and still managed to stay undefeated so for me personally Mahomes is just on another level but to your credit yes last year defensively the Chiefs was top tier but it was Mahomes that put of the points to secure the wins.

[@lilmanluigiofficial2557]

Y’all clearly didn’t listen 😂 this ain’t based on talent

[@dexwayne24]

They fast forwarded to the end 😂😂😂

[@kennyb1997]

People gotta listen bro was MVP in 2015 and didn't had a team like the 49ers 💯

[@davidolla9148]

So then what was the point of the list 😂and being in tiers

[@maskedman5657]

It's based in who's Cam is biased against and who he's not

[@brandonharry7565]

Then why isn't Brock #1 🙃

[@thegamingsociety7880]

His take on Herbert is ridiculous. He's been listening to Acho way too much. Herbert has single-handedly willed his team to win games while his defenses have snatched defeat from the jaws of victory. Herbert set many records in his rookie season and threw for over 5k in his second season. He's played hurt the last 2 seasons and his team lost all their games when he was out.

[@haydenwatsongk5117]

Yea Herbert should be in the second list. Only person I disagreed with

[@CKpremium1992]

Herbert is a generational talent, the ideal NFL qb and easily top 5.. Staley was honestly the worst HC in the NFL since the time he was hired and fired.. the fact Herbert was able to perform as well as he did under Staley just provides further proof of how great he is and how terrible Staley was.. but tier 3 is simply “is it you or is it the team” and that’s exactly where Herbert belongs because it’s not him it’s the team or more specifically Staley..

[@Eidenhoek]

@@CKpremium1992 Worse than Urban Meyer?

[@GuapoSantana]

Agreed he's legit

[@costfnbr]

@@haydenwatsongk5117he should be in the first list lmfao

[@robballard2197]

I’ve never seen Cam in anything off the field. This is gold. His personality is amazing! I’m a fan now.

[@JJGarrett-mv5zz]

As a Bucs fan I can appreciate Baker in tier 3 but like Cam said he can be in tier 2

[@KColonelSanders405]

I glad he said that bc I was hoping to see Bake in tier 2

[@martinsanchez1089]

@@KColonelSanders405 bro baker took us deep in the playoff wth yall mean tier 3 over dak and levis and putting jones above him is slap in the face !

[@kalebbennet8460]

Tier three was made specifically for Purdy 😂

[@chiefSuga20]

Tier 3 clearly the reason he made this whole list

[@cmartin1663]

💯

[@Jayskimz]

Nah fr I ain’t mad at it, Purdy does gotta show another year fr

[@chilliewilliefromphilly]

That's because he couldn't justify putting him, Hurts and Tua in the win consistently category. So it's either tier 3 or 1. He could've left this alone.

[@kingnaz8465]

@@Jayskimzhe went to back to back nfc championship games and a Super Bowl his first 2 years and he still has something to prove to you👀😂😂😂

[@BuffyFreak192]

Cams real and that's why I love him. His reaction to the Rodgers "is it his team? " question was what most vets say. They know what's good when it comes to that man. It's a health question with that man.

[@gabrielcesar2388]

Cam has better analysis than any national media program. Cool to listen to a former pro give this insight

[@mistahlee404]

This is the best off season football ball question(s)/list I've seen this year. Bravo 👏🏿, they finna steal yo content 😎😂

[@elizabethgodfrey1033]

They been stealing Cam’s content! Then they also criticize him, but take his brilliant ideas!

[@aaronhugz4277]

They DEFINITELY are going to steal his content and then diminish what he says or does moving forward

[@maskedman5657]

Cam's content is too dumb to steal

[@elizabethgodfrey1033]

Why are u here stealing if he is so dumb? U are a rogue! 😱

[@elizabethgodfrey1033]

Why are u on here stealing & soaking up everything so u can use it? 👁😱😞

[@brandonmyer8589]

I didn't know I needed this until I had it. Love the animation by these two!

[@JPYDKME]

8:55 why does Russell Wilson and Justin Field’s have Chicago next to their name😂😂

[@JohnnyProfit13]

THIS IS SAD! Reading hate in the comments!! My ANSWER?!? Yea, I got the real answer!! Sir Cam Newton! The NFL was around a LONG time, but somehow Cam was way ahead of the game. Drip/Swag/Attire been around a LONG time, yet Cam was and is still miles ahead! Pod casts been around a bit now too, YET SIR Cam Newton is ahead of it, so much that y'all cant keep up with him. I'm a old white dude and I hear him, because by now if you dont listen to Cam, your OLD NEWS! Cam for PRESIDENT! ❤ the show cam, keep ahead of the world brother! You are one of the few on earth that deserves more than what he has! That's my opinion Sir! GOD bless! 🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤

[@zeke9067]

Everyone of these quarterbacks are in tier 3… not ONE of the teams in the NFL are winning ONLY because of the quarterback play. I love the way Cam did this though!

[@IMaBeastDoWatDEn]

The chiefs my good sir

[@itsfedorahere9985]

mahomes is

[@bjslugzbeatz2103]

@@itsfedorahere9985 no he is not but he is a BIG reason. qb needs everything to go right or else u have rings like marino and other great hof qbs. teams, coaches, gms, and owners MATTERS A LOT!!!!!

[@zeke9067]

Are you guys slow? Or just casuals? Everyone knows that the chiefs had a lot of their success this year because of their defense. Mahomes is the best qb in the league, is a future hall of famer, and could possibly beat out Brady as the goat. BUT, he admitted himself that his defense was winning games for him this last year.

[@itsfedorahere9985]

@@zeke9067 his defense was top tier but who scored the points ? defense wins championships but it can’t carry out full on games lol, they get tired with trash offenses. mahomes is a one man army

[@davidellis6468]

Brilliant conversation and breakdown, knowing what we now know into week 3 of the season. Much fun with the Allen conversation.

[@jaykun182]

People cant grasp this isn't a ranking list 😂

[@greenmanalishi6963]

“How dare you”😂 Just earned a sub

[@geowenvaughn8429]

When tf did Andy Dalton play for the Jets?!?!?! I must’ve missed that season😂😂

[@vrose1_]

think he meant darnold lmao

[@Panthersfan_13]

@@vrose1_they are very close look alikes and def have similar names

[@KRUDDYMUSICIAN]

​@@vrose1_ he said ginger Darnold ain't a ginger😂

[@DarksouIjah]

@@KRUDDYMUSICIAN I don't think a ginger has ever started as a NYJ QB. Did he mean Boomer and mixed him up with Dalton? Since both played for Cincy? lol That is the only explanation that I could think of.

[@scrubadubdub8360]

New to the series, been on a binge. Glad I've found the channel.

[@MeloMP4]

Interesting take on Jalen. The team was 10-1 last season with a bottom ranked defense in the league???

[@Five_2Entertainment]

This was fun to watch. Good video!!

[@Arguing101]

Herbert in Bucket 3 is crazy. Nobody with a brain between their ears is questioning if Herbert is the problem 😂. Clear as a cloudless blue sky that the org/team was the problem

[@CKpremium1992]

100% fact.. and I’m a chargers fan.. Herbert is a generational talent and everything you could dream of in an NFL QB.. it’s pretty evident Staley and Telesco were the problems.. mainly Staley tho.. dude was easily the worst HC since he was hired.. ppl say Urban Meyer was the worst during that time period but I think Staley has him beat.. the fact Herbert performed as well as he did under Staley just reinforces that point too..

[@ScubaDiverPicker]

As a Rivers fan its def the organization. The organization kept Rivers from winning a SB by hiring terrible coaches.

[@CKpremium1992]

@@ScubaDiverPicker facts

[@Chrollojr66]

Listen to what he said tho, also had said ‘are you the reason we’re winning or the team?’ So it’s not negative in the sense of the conversation, plus this ‘third bucket’ has great teams/qbs on it

[@PrimeU24]

He's trash stop it, Herbert had a stack team did nothing offensive defensive no playoff wins

[@TheAxlSnaks]

I know I'm a Hawks fan, so I admit my bias upfront: I feel really good about this season for Geno. He is playing with a chip on his shoulder come off a bit of a slump compared to the season prior. We are LOADED in the receiver room, have a great RB room - so the questions, on offense, that it comes to is can our OL improve and can our playcalling improve. Five of our games last season were one-score losses, with the blowouts coming against truly great teams. So can our defense also hold up? Geno played very good in the clutch last year, and only improved as the year went on, but was stagnant outside of that do-or-die situation [especially early in the year] Geno is not the problem with our offense - but can he elevate us in that time of need? I think this season answers that question definitively.

[@fulcrumsee5968]

For Anthony Richardson it wouldn't the team being the problem based on last year's performance. He was out since week 6 and it came down to a week 18 overtime against the Texans for the division crown. All of his injuries was from him running down field and not protecting himself. I hope he listened you Cam, because you of all QBs knows the importance of protecting yourself.

[@ZayDeyknow]

He also said that it was more can he be consistent than anything

[@MazyckMitchell-n9l]

I feel like there should be a group below 3 that says “you are the reason indefinitely and we’re looking for a qb”

[@briane6554]

Brock purdy still needs to prove something after being in the Super Bowl and being down by 17 in the championship and brining them back in the game, this guy just wants to see Brock fail and be like I told you”. Brock is a tier one guy he’s the franchise qb only reason why the niners were in the Super Bowl and last year being in the championship after lance and Jimmy g went down

[@IMaBeastDoWatDEn]

How is he the only reason for there success when he’s not even close to the best player and the 49ers were good before him, Super Bowl good, literally played the chiefs to a very close game would’ve won if Jimmy G hit a routine throw, it’s obvious that Brock has a ton to prove

[@dontworryidontknowwhereyou7972]

The 49er run a more complex offense now that they have a better qb, they don’t only throw screens and check downs. They ask purdy to do difficult things, their system only would work with 8 or so guys.

[@itsjayswelly]

You guys need to listen and not get butthurt

[@thisshouldbeentertaining3386]

I get it Brock was the last pick in the draft. But Kurt Warner wasn't even drafted at all. And he had great offensive weapons. Yet he wasn't criticized and kept being told you have to keep proving yourself.

[@briane6554]

@@IMaBeastDoWatDEn literally he is despite the team look at last time jimmy g was in the championship against the rams plenty of time to go down the field and win the game but instead threw a pick to send the rams to the Super Bowl, Brock purdy against Green Bay, lions, came back twice, so I don’t what else he need to do

[@coachpopetv9256]

Cam's topics and knowledge is on-point! Love the breakdowns of why

[@guitarjack87]

does everyone remember the key and peel sketch about the steampunk friend? because this whole podcast reminded me of that skit

[@neetrab]

How is Dak not in tier 3? His team is 8-2 without him his last 10 missed games. Meanwhile, the eagles team has 0 wins without Hurts the last 2 yrs. 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔 - Andy Dalton beat Cincinnati Bengals w/ cowboys 30-7 - Andy Dalton beat 9ers w/ cowboys 41-33 - Andy Dalton beat Eagles w/cowboys 37-17 - Cooper Rush beat Minnesota w/cowboys 20-16 - Cooper Rush beat Cincinnati Bengals w/ cowboys 20-17 - Cooper Rush beat Giants w/cowboys 23-16 - Cooper Rush beat Washington w/cowboys 25-10 - Cooper Rush beat LA Rams w/cowboys 22-10 Is it Dak or the team? Lol

[@bobbym9510]

Because he can go to a different team and if he doesn't win the Superbowl he will still get most of the hate. If tua goes to a different team and doesn't win I think most would expect that

[@Marioso256]

You must be the one everyone talking bout in the comments that didn't listen.

[@neetrab]

@@Marioso256 so, what in the video did I miss?

[@neetrab]

@@bobbym9510 That is not a good answer at all. Dak would naturally get most of the hate for not winning a SB with another team because he's the quarterback and that's what naturally happens with QBs who don't win it regardless of what team they're on. Ignorant fans do it erroneously with Hurts. It's just the norm.

[@bobbym9510]

@@neetrab yeah because I remember them saying fire Nick but I don't remember a lot of get rid of Hurts. I even remember hurts having to come out and say nicks staying

[@omarortega1291]

Cam with the break down im here for it all. I couldnt agree more.

[@TheFrostFilesPodcast]

Blaming Herbert for the chargers situation is insane

[@tommyharper126]

Blowing 27-0 lead in the playoffs is def Herbert fault

[@TheFrostFilesPodcast]

@@tommyharper126 casual

[@TheFrostFilesPodcast]

@@tommyharper126 Play calling was atrocious he had zero turnovers and a decent completion percentage

[@tommyharper126]

@@TheFrostFilesPodcast play calling wasn’t the problem when he was up 27-0, only scoring 3 points all 2nd half is embarrassing. Herbert fans give him every excuse in the book

[@TheFrostFilesPodcast]

@@tommyharper126 you haven’t even watched the game your just commenting on something you haven’t seen thinking your right. It’s Brandon Staley of course play calling is the issue. If it was on Herbert his completion percentage would have been lower and he would have had turnovers.

[@PrecisionPlayConsultants]

This might be the best tier list I’ve seen….ever. Cam may be polarizing at times but he killed it in this vid.

[@DaGradyest]

This grading scale is so complicated. It's not really rating the QB. The team and "the situation" is too much of the equation.

[@MaloneHart08]

I wish I could have seen this side of Cam during his playing days. I would have been a huge fan.

[@chevyjr1862]

Well tbh if this is based off situations burrow should be in tier 3 because he has had 2 top tier #1 WRs and a top tier back he didnt do so good without jamar

[@ZayDeyknow]

He also had one of the worst o line with a shotgun offense

[@bobbym9510]

But his QB ranking makes him Superbowl or bust. He's consistently ranked in the top 3.

[@bazimyan]

@@ZayDeyknow except that same offense had Jake Browning as one of the highest rated QBs in the league as a backup, so that's not really an excuse.

[@KaneJeffries]

In 2022 without chase he played well lmao

[@davidl.williams6776]

I think this ranking is really dope. I only barely disagree with Justin Herbert - I feel like he's clearly the guy and we wanna know if he can start winning. So Tier 2 for me. However, I see the logic of him being in tier 3 because the Chargers are notorious for imploding basically every year; and now those implosions are hapening regardless of what he does, and it makes you questions if he's the "reason."

[@OneNateS]

Cam it’s your opinion you’re entitled to it. You gonna catch HELL online for this, especially saying someone like Daniel Jones being “The Guy but can you win consistently” but have guys like Herbert, Hurts, Mayfield, and even Tua in the Tier 3 “are you the reason”

[@jeanfourcade]

You don't get it. We know Daniel Jones is one of the reasons the Giants suck. The question is, can D. Jones win consistently, despite the shitty team? Just like Burrow or Mahomes are capable of doing. Fair.

[@Trickabizzatch]

@@jeanfourcade Joe Burrow is 29-22-1 in his career. What’s this win consistently shit you’re talking about?

[@leejax4467]

@@Trickabizzatch5-2 in Postseason. Plus SB appearance. He’s a winner

[@Trickabizzatch]

@@leejax4467 if he makes it to the post season.

[@SkysLimitDoesMC]

@@jeanfourcadeare you joking? how are the chiefs a shitty team?? they are one of the best all around teams in the nfl, bengals not so much, but they had mixon higgins and chase when they went to the sb. daniel jones is mediocre quarterback at best with rushing upside. his shitty o-line doesnt help, and saquon leaving dooms their run game.

[@cmartin7052]

This is actually a really smart list. And describing them as buckets is great!

[@tnbwolfie]

18:00 had me rollin😭the story hilarious.

[@humblewarrior4648]

My only issue with Tier 3 is Tua has consistently won. Not to mention when he was injured how did the offense look? Also did he remember the 28 4th quarter in Baltimore? Tua can win more then just about anyone his only obstacle was health, but he played a full season so now he should be able to put together a season that can push him into Tier 1

[@lilcyrusj]

Justin Herbert in bucket 3 is insane

[@theoperry3236]

It’s true tho

[@LaRez2]

Literally insane. Justin Herbert with Jim Harbaugh is going to tear shit up remember reading this.

[@lilcyrusj]

@@theoperry3236 You liked your own comment

[@holpcs2]

Right. He should be in bucket 4.

[@pm21-v3h]

Nah Fr isn’t tier 3 made to see who’s the problem?? Hebert has been a top 5 qb since joining the league. He’s led his offense to being top 10, he’s stayed consistent up until his injuries last season… but everyone knows the charger’s problem is defense and coaching. Since joining the league Herbert has had a bottom 5 defense and special teams.. it doesn’t take much to figure this problem out 😑😑

[@Askfornate]

Cam, I wasn't sure what to expect with your rankings, but I like the categories and I especially appreciate Group #3.

[@jonbowman]

Tua never had a losing record in a season his only question ever was staying healthy

[@REVBomB1]

Only gets better year after year! He’s making all pro this year!!

[@maskedman5657]

Don't tell Cam supporters that

[@Bigbossmula2]

Tua gotta go 🙏🏾 We need a Gunslinger 💯

[@jaywebb0113]

Hey Dak has never had a losing season as a starter either.

[@peterwilson4865]

Just a 1 read system QB man. He's a really good one, but time and time again when he's forced to look elsewhere or throw outside the numbers, he's one of the worst in the league. He's just lucky to have those WRs doing most of the work after the catch.

[@tommyrobinson-rf2je]

Just now finding out Cam had a yt and he’s freaking hilarious 😂

[@jeremiahpayne4284]

I’m convinced He made tier 3 for Purdy & Purdy only🤣🤣 everyone else was a deco lol

[@maskedman5657]

Of course it was. Cam likes to have crappy unpopular opinions and try to make sense of it even though he knows he's biased

[@michaelwynn2273]

Yeah that's kinda what I was thinking lol

[@imastered9021]

lol exactly. Purdy hit every single criteria for his Tier 1, yet he put him in 3. Spun his words around by saying “Oh they winning but is he the reason they are winning?” When CLEARLY tier 3 is supposed to be for: they are losing but is he the reason they are losing. For the clicks, and cam doesn’t want to admit he was wrong.

[@maskedman5657]

@@imastered9021 exactly he's cap

[@sanddc178]

Good idea and list! Like Cam mentioned, only changes I would make are putting Baker and Herbert in tier 2. This was a good watch.

[@harrisonbarnes1567]

No one has done less with more than Dak Prescott. No way he’s not in the last tier

[@quann06]

The last 2 years no receivers outside of Lamb, no consistent running game, suspect OL. Bad run defense. I wouldn’t mind giving another QB a chance after 8 years, but I can’t put everything on Dak in recent years.

[@ZayDeyknow]

No hes not tf are you on about also roster don't matter when yo scheme and game planning is terrible which is cause of coaching and Jerry not letting coaches coach

[@Dee-jd6ym]

Also in a cupcake division let's not forget that. At one point that division was by far the worst in the league.

[@g0r3reaper]

it’s more based off you’re a starter for the cowboys, with all the tools, it’s super bowl or bust just because your team is the cowboys

[@WontonSlim]

@@Dee-jd6ymthe year before last nfc east had 3 playoff teams and Washington finished at .500

[@Ali-wi8bx]

I think Herbert fits more in tier 2 because I think we saw exactly what we needed to see when it comes to if herbert is the reason for tthe charers lack of success. And im talkin about the raiders 63-21 win. First time herbert is out in his career and the team loses 63-21 to a below averae raiders team

[@bromododragon2252]

The Jalen Hurts hate this offseason is crazy. Can't wait for him to prove all the doubters wrong (again)

[@w0nderwallCS]

Can't wait for him to follow the eagles QB cycle, be good for one season, get huge contract, play mediocre with lots of turn over and then play awful and get traded.

[@RedZoneProd123]

Ok, he made a Super Bowl, top 3 in MvP voting, and has one of the best receivers, and Oline, and coaching staff around him

[@w0nderwallCS]

@@RedZoneProd123 hurts is bad 🤷

[@RedZoneProd123]

@@w0nderwallCS no he’s not

[@w0nderwallCS]

@@RedZoneProd123 hes the worst

[@DCuse315]

Everybody still shittin on Hurts is just feeding the fuel. The best QBs thrived based on the system and playmakers they had around them.. to have him so far down the list of best QBs right now is crazy fr

[@MJS-PS144]

Best way I've seen this done... It's about so much more than skill.

[@liltone465]

Jalen is Tier 1 no argument

[@holpcs2]

Nah

[@murph4lyfe]

Nah he similar to purdy he relies on the luxury of weapons at his disposal

[@innmyass8088]

He’s like Goff while he was on the Rams

[@julianwatts9024]

Show me a tier one that’s ever finished a season losing like 7 straight

[@bazimyan]

@@murph4lyfe "he relies on the luxury of weapons at his disposal" - weird, cause last time I checked Jake Browning had one of the highest QB ratings with the Bengals weapons on offense when Joe Burrow was injured, and Cooper Rush went 5-0 when Dak was injured with the Cowboys weapons. Interesting how you pick and choose which QBs to downplay and not others.

[@cristiansalgado9713]

Cam has a special place in my heart cause my lil nephew was a panthers fan when he was a baby he would dab and all that.

[@coopndaclutch7132]

Cam u smoking something crazy bro I’m really starting to think u got something against jalen hurts. For u to have dak and cousins in tier 1 all I needed to know about u bro

[@elizabethgodfrey1033]

Cam loves Jalen Hurts! It’s just an evaluation!

[@bobbym9510]

@@coopndaclutch7132 we saw hurts lose and we saw who got all the blame even when hurts fumbled and probably cost them the game lol. We then saw him out of the playoffs next season and we saw them calling for the coach to be fired. How is it Superbowl or bust when you aren't even getting the blame?

[@thewavyprince5691]

Jalen hurts cant throw the ball and his decision making is trash i dont know why people think hes good

[@frankquattlebaum6126]

This was an impressive breakdown. Cam showing how creative you can be when you have a great grasp of the fundamental knowledge

[@FlexFinito]

Your sick for putting Brock Purdy in group 3 😂…. JIMMY G wasn’t doing nothing Brock did

[@raymondelliott1546]

Thats what i said, he is at least tier 1

[@exciphy]

dawgy, both made the super bowl w the 49ers… they ain’t even have cmc yet, it’s the fucking system 😭😭😭

[@bazimyan]

@@exciphy except that Brock was responsible for 2 come from behind wins in the playoffs, the first against GB when trailing in the 4th Q where Kyle Shanahan has almost never won, and the second was having largest comeback in NFC title game HISTORY, tied only by the 2012 Niners against the Falcons. Also in the SB, Brock Purdy never left the field without a lead; the only reason the Niners lost was because Mahomes was the last QB to touch the football and not Purdy. Contrast that with Jimmy who only needed to throw 8 passes in a playoff game in the year that Niners team went to the SB. He was never responsible for any playoff win with the Niners, unlike Brock.

[@exciphy]

@@bazimyan you got me there, but i’m replying to the concept that jimmy g never did anything brock purdy did. when they’ve both made it to and lost in the super bowl, they’re the same for what they’ve done for the 49ers in terms of team success. now i wont say that purdy is a bad player/ worse than jimmy g, cuz i don’t think he his, dude can ball. but saying jimmy g never did anything brock has done is idiotic.

[@RomeoDaRealist]

Jimmy G did the same thing. Make it to the SB with the Avengers and Thanos at coach. 🤦🏾‍♂️🤣This is a plug and play QB system.

[@Osama_bin_Gaming]

Not mad at the list. Makes you think on all the QBs tbh. As a niner fan as great as purdy is. The tier is valid

[@lvi_.jaden521]

The Jalen disrespect is crazy 🤦🏾‍♂️

[@adonijahdelancy6722]

Not foreal. We haven’t seen him with anything but an elite supporting cast… even going back to college.

[@dwaynekeenum1916]

@@adonijahdelancy6722Oklahoma wasn’t elite you gotta be dumb he carried them

[@elchanclas6035]

My man got the Best team in the league and cant beat the buccs

[@matheusabreu2534]

Very solid list of situations and very good points of view. Good shit Cam

[@shaheemtaylor960]

Lmaoooooo dude said Purdy has to prove what he can do he was a dam MVP candidate last year. Jalen Hurts definitely proved himself. Both Purdy and Hurts are in the Teir 1 category. Tua is definitely the guy in MIAMI he needs to be in that teir 2. Herbert is determined by his playoff success at this point.

[@bobbym9510]

No Herbert is not. They will just blame it on mahomes. Tua is the man but you can't tell me if he's the reason they are winning. Put another quarterback with that offense and they arguably do just as well. Perfect place to put him

[@shaheemtaylor960]

@@bobbym9510 Herbert puts up insane regular season stats so his success is determined by the playoffs. Idk how Mahomes is an excuse for Herbert to fail in the playoffs lol. Tua is the guy in Miami . He’s a great factor to why the Dolphins are a playoff caliber team after being mediocre for the last 20 years since Marino retired. Tua does great in the regular season improved every year now it’s time to win a playoff game

[@bobbym9510]

@@shaheemtaylor960 he is a great factor nobody disagrees but everytime playoffs come around we wonder how he will do. We know he can win consistently right? So tier 2 is out We aren't going to blame him for not winning the Superbowl so tier 1 is out. Same with Herbert nobody is going to say get rid of Herbert because they didn't make the Superbowl they will say he's in the chiefs division, he's young etc. that man doesn't even get bad press for not making the playoffs.

[@qestym8777]

Purdy being in tier 1 is hilarious 😂

[@austinreed5302]

Bro all Tua does is beat up on bad teams that play zone against them as soon as they play a team with a above .500 record he does absolutely nothing. It's been that way since he's been in the league look it up he literally has like 1 win against teams that are above .500 and has never won a game below 40 degrees he's average at best

[@shawn4105]

I like this approach to a list. I’m a Dolphins fan and I think this is the perfect spot for Tua.

[@TheRealG_fr]

Bro jalen hurts is the reason for that offense what other qb running that system with the qb sneak? Hurts should not be on that list that’s crazy lol😂

[@bobbym9510]

@@TheRealG_fr they have 2 of the best receivers in the league. A great tight end and a great o line. I can name a few QBs who would do well

[@CerebralSigma]

@@bobbym9510With last season’s HC, you could put Mahomes in that situation and he would’ve looked so bad. The Eagles had no strategy. I take that back. The strategy they had wasn’t working for them anymore and Sirianni refused to make the necessary adjustments (because he was clueless). Play design and play calling are just as important as your talent/weapons. What is the point of having a stacked O line if you don’t utilize your weapons properly?

[@NG-ps9hs]

@@bobbym9510Dallas godert is not a great TE. He stay hurt. He’s average. Jalen has two great WRs and an good OL. We gonna see what he does this year tho

[@DylanBadour]

I love that Cam keeps it real when talking about Josh Allen. Cause all in all, they're very similar QBs. Tall, athletic, with cannon arms. Both studs with good but not great situations and an insane amount of natural talent. "He can have all the other ones but he ain't faster than me!" That shit is hilarious and love the honesty. Then he kepts it real with Lamar. Cam the GOAT, glad he started this commentating side. He led the way.

[@EddieMendoza-v9x]

Anyone starting to think Herbert’s underrated😭😭 how is he in the same category as Bryce young and baker mayfield 😭😭😭

[@Waiting_for_the_end]

He's completely underrated. Staley tanked the team last year and you can't expect Herbert to be Superman every game. A Harbaugh coached team and an Alt led OL will show the world how good Herbie is!

[@LaRez2]

It’s literally insane. Justin Herbert with Jim Harbaugh is going to tear through the league.

[@pm21-v3h]

Must not be paying attention to the chargers. Because I’m a fan of them and without Herbert this team would easily be 0-16. Herbert has had a bottom 5 defense and special teams his whole nfl career.. he has done more then enough to win but people forget he isn’t the only one out there on that field. Casual take from cam. Would’ve loved for him to call that out.

[@David-eh3ht]

Herbert is a top 5 Qb

[@David-eh3ht]

@@pm21-v3h well I will say our special team is really good now

[@ZachHollander117]

I was at that game! Sat behind the panthers bench. Lots of eyes on you and Josh that day including mine much love and respect

[@dg8games438]

Now make a group 4 for the qbs out of a job and put yo name on there.

[@michaelwynn2273]

LMAOOOOOOOOOOOOO fr 😂

[@troystation2526]

The only counter you have to his argument is that he no longer plays😂😂 weak

[@dg8games438]

@troystation2526 well there's a reason he no longer plays isn't there? we don't just say that for no reason.

[@michaelwynn2273]

@@troystation2526 he has no right to judge quarterbacks when he couldn't win the big game. He can't judge when he isn't in the league because nobody wants him. Cam was good for a season or two but failed after that. His word means nothing lmao.

[@troystation2526]

@@michaelwynn2273 so his words mean nothing because he was bad in the nfl but 90% of people giving their opinion were never good enough to make the nfl 😂😂😂 you see the irony

[@caesarleo3702]

Lance, Beathard, Mullins to name a few played in Kyle's system. How did that work out? Heck even Garopolo didn't move the offense like Purdy. Put some respect on that man's name.

[@765thatdude]

Damn Brock ain’t prove himself yet?

[@BlackMatrix-pl4fe]

His team is too strong so it kinda feels like not all of the success they've had is because of Brock.

[@COA5T]

People still question it because Jimmy G also took that team to the SuperBowl, but look at how he is viewed. Was Jimmy G's success in SF a product of Shanahan or was it him? This is why Brock is questioned still.

[@deangelo8498]

Nope

[@ScottWD]

To the people that matter he has. But to those with the bad takes early, they gotta keep Hating or look the fool. Here we got a fool

[@elizabethgodfrey1033]

It’s no hate! U didn’t listen to Cam’s comments. Are u the real fool?

[@Rmzrider3135]

“How dare you” had me dead 😂😂😂

[@fatmoefatmoe2645]

The Jalen Hurts and Dak Prescott meat eating is fckn crazy. Hurts out played Mahomes in the SUPER BOWL. Lamar, Allen, Kirk, etc never even been to the Super Bowl.

[@MikkiChavez]

Hurts had the best defense in NFL history & a top tier offense. Lamar doesn't. Hurts fumbled the ball for a TD but he outplayed Mahomes? The idiocy smh

[@Dub257]

Jalen hurts also lost the superbowl

[@thomasjones3063]

@@MikkiChavezsir, they weren’t the best defense in NFL history lol. They almost had the most sacks in NFL history. Two completely different things. A good defense but the middle of the field was open for everyone to come in and make a play. Just like last year.

[@MikkiChavez]

@@thomasjones3063 no, they did have the most sacks in history. Point is Jalens team is miles ahead of Ravens overall. Lamar has never had elite WRs he can just lob the ball to. EVER. But yet everyone wants him to win one when Burrow, Hurts, Allen, & everyone else has 2x the weapons & still haven't won. While Lamar keeps ripping off MVPs.

[@nickdehart7463]

It’s easy argue if Lamar or Allen was in the NFC they would been played in the Super Bowl and if hurts was in the AFC he would never made the SB so really can’t use that

[@chrisbruchak4519]

I really like the structure of this list because its not a skill eval. But truthfully I think the best way I've seen QB's ranked was a 4 tier category. 1.) You win BECAUSE of this QB. 2.) You CAN win WITH this QB. 3.) When you win, its IN SPITE of this QB. 4.) You cant win with this QB. I feel like breaking it down like that is the best way to evaluate the position as a whole and how it fits in a particular teams situation.

[@JabAdrianJab]

*waits for the debates in the comments*

[@Scottygetright]

Actually, I was getting ready to come with some skepticism on this, but Cam, you did a great job breaking this down. The people are wondering allll of these things, glad to hear an retired Pro NFL QB1 is having the same thoughts

[@jerellebey15]

Cam your opinion means nothin, tf u got Trevor over Jalen

[@arqueviousfoster91]

I was wondering that

[@maskedman5657]

He also has Purdy in Group 3

[@702couch]

I like this kind of ranking system. Like he said, its not based on skill or who he thinks is better, its based on real world factors.

[@mariocarvajal864]

Jalen had the most comeback winning games all season last year and his first year he took a bad team to the playoffs barely with aj and a rookie Devonte smith

[@LinnellBinn]

No AJ Smitty rookie year

[@tite732]

Aj wasnt even there yet

[@mariocarvajal864]

@@tite732 my bad typo lol good looking tho

[@synnceregriffin8218]

Let’s be real Jalen is not that good It shows with help 🤷🏾‍♂️

[@neetrab]

​@@mariocarvajal864 you can edit, you know. Just click the 3 buttons on the side to edit. Google it if you must.

[@shoey7100]

I actually like this ranking system from Cam for the fact that it is more nuanced and speaks to the complexity of football.

[@quijelmina]

That part...❤👏💯

[@MOJOXL24]

Cams disrespect for Purdy is real

[@oronmurphy3724]

This has some genius to it?

[@bobbym9510]

@@MOJOXL24 what disrespect? Where would you put him? Can't be tier 1 because the coaches got all the blame for the Superbowl loss. Can't be tier 2 because we saw he could win consistently. Where would you put him here?

[@maskedman5657]

​@@bobbym9510 Tier 1

[@domp9185]

@@maskedman5657it’s not based off skill 🤦‍♂️

[@maskedman5657]

@@domp9185 It's based off wins right?

[@ciresolstice]

I like how this was broken down by the situation of the team and how the QB exists in that framework, and not just individual accolades. Cam did a nice job on this Imho.

[@curtisg4817]

To have TLaw over Jalen Hurts is blasphemous

[@3rdCoastSportsTV]

He’s just putting people in tiers not an actual number where he rates them

[@jgok5580]

What u think t law does on the eagles ? 🧐

[@3rdCoastSportsTV]

Same thing he doing now

[@curtisg4817]

@@jgok5580 first round exit😂

[@bobbym9510]

@@curtisg4817 what did the hurts do with the eagles? First round exit?

[@Chiefa334]

this so dope. Something new like this could only come from guys that played!

[@mr.ks.7083]

Tua doesn't belong in Tier 3, he should be in Tier 2.

[@jeanfourcade]

No. Tua proved he could win consistently. But we don't know whether it's thanks to McDaniel designing plays for his speed offense where any decent QB would thrive, or if Tua brings something special. Cam placed him exactly where he belongs.

[@maskedman5657]

​@@jeanfourcadeDude you're baffling ignorant it's comical. So take Andy Reid away from Pat Mahomes is his still as good? What about Stafford with Sean McVay? Or Jared Goff with Ben Johnson? Most of the Top 10 QBs have the top coaches you bird brain

[@alfonzojordan8395]

Your show deserves a primetime channel

[@diamontaewilliams5286]

The gripe he has against Brock Purdy is insane man , this man was an MVP Candidate and a superbowl appearance. Cam hating is crazy gang

[@BizioRecords]

Brock Purdy did exactly what Gimmy G did.....and Brock has the better team...

[@fourliferrrr]

⁠@@BizioRecordsian finna say purdy ahh but if a couple guys who were “past there prime” had what he has they would have a so called “career comeback”

[@mario.gaines]

@@BizioRecordsexactly what i was gonna say

[@frankmathews]

Naw Cam is spot on with Purdy. We really don't know if he's that good or is it the players around him

[@jeanfourcade]

And yet, nobody can tell whether it'a all Shanahan and the team, or if it's Brock. After all, just like Jimmy G., Brock was one pass away from winning the SB, and missed. So, Cam's question is solid.

[@henryleonardo3544]

This is the best way to put a list.

[@jwilliamson-xo8nd]

It’s always is it Jalen or the team cause his GM does his job… Like Pat ,Josh, Lamar ,Dak ,and Joe only ever played with scrubs. 😂

[@daibu05]

Jalen without talent looked terrible he got that tape on film they don't. Well Lamar and Josh did they still looked great

[@jwilliamson-xo8nd]

@@daibu05Josh looked terrible without talent then he got Diggs. 😂

[@daibu05]

@jwilliamson-xo8nd correction the team looked terrible Josh looked like he could play. At no point in Josh career did you ever think Josh couldn't throw. We still question Jalen now

[@neetrab]

​@@daibu05 which is dumb, because y'all stay hating the guy and literally just judging him for where he was drafted. He was literally a rookie learning a new offense with trash receivers and Devonta wasn't even that dude yet. 🙄

[@alexwilkins5783]

Kirk absolutely belongs in bucket 1. All he’s done is show out in the regular season. Nothing matters to Atlanta but the postseason, either.