5 Clone Troopers Who Hated The JEDI

[@Raeinok]

Imperial Officer: Trooper you killed half a dozen Jedi, order 66 must have been a crazy time for you. Trooper: Order what now?

[@echo_the-planetsmasher5608]

RIP to the Imperial officer

[@perfectectlylegitimatename631]

Dogma gets crap for being the "teacher's pet" to Krell, but Appo was the one who was always by Krell's side. Krell even called him by his name.

[@edwardcui7535]

dogma made up for it though, rex was never going to kill him

[@davidpierce7581]

@@edwardcui7535 Rex would of been arrested if he killed Krell. But appo was always at krells side

[@FootieFraternity]

I don’t remember appo in that arc was he standing with krell instead of fighting with his men?

[@perfectectlylegitimatename631]

@@FootieFraternity It was when Rex and some of the 501st were down in the gorge fighting those tanks. Appo comes up to Krell and says something along the lines of "the platoons are in the position you requested. Should we move in to support his forces?" Then Krell says "I'll give the order when I give it, Sargeant Appo". He was a Sargeant at the time and the only thing distinguishing him from a regular 501st clone is a small arrow on his helmet.

[@cpttankerjoe]

@@perfectectlylegitimatename631 the arrow on Appos helmet and his name is actually a reference to Appa from Avatar the Last air bender. Dave Filoni helped with ATLA and wanted to leave its own mark in the clone wars

[@casbot71]

What's suprising is with the Clone troopers all speaking with a *New Zealand accent,* Palpatine didn't have to issue _"Oarder Sexty Seks"._

[@DMSProduktions]

And it's actually, ' Awdah suxty sux!'

[@liammoody9516]

I'm from new Zealand we say six. Australians say sex we have a different accent.

[@Dusty_Noodles123]

@@DMSProduktions it’s New Zealand but ok not Brit at all

[@DMSProduktions]

@@liammoody9516 NO we don't! We say six (sicks) YOU say SUX! (sucks)!

[@DMSProduktions]

@@Dusty_Noodles123 HAH! The clones' accents are nowhere near 'NZ'! Trust me as some1 who has grown up with lots of Kiwis from both islands, that accent is not even close! Thank you!

[@bigafroman4277]

Ah yes, another great episode of Generation Tick

[@bradleygetchel4016]

Omg 😂

[@eddieram435]

Generation Tick?

[@wolfgang_mittermeyer987]

Tiktok

[@themarvelfan3227]

Tick Icko Recka Hunta Crooshare

[@theredhood028]

@@themarvelfan3227 Omayga

[@sougotokiwa8439]

Whoever scores the most kills in Order 66 earns a free polynesian spa day...

[@Sableguy97]

I was hoping for a pizza party but as long as I get recognition...

[@protogensvisiontimelost254]

so you're going to tell me no one pointed out the fact he put "Dogma" instead of "Darman"

[@cole1182]

Alpha-17 is one of my favorite clones. He’s 100% a badass.

[@paladyntt7232]

Legends arcs and commanders were generally awesome. Too bad nowadays most fans don't even know about them and think that Rex is the best. As if, lol.

[@russellmoffett2447]

@@paladyntt7232 for real Rex sucks especially compared to EU clones

[@paladyntt7232]

@@russellmoffett2447 I think that an avarage Galactic Marine could fold Rex without much work. Bacara would straight up massacre him. Remember that time it took both Rex and Cody to take out Slick?

[@N120Xeno]

@@russellmoffett2447 one of my friends called Rex discount Fordo and I can see it lol

[@russellmoffett2447]

@@N120Xeno I need to start using that

[@danielcollinspda9936]

Palaptine: "Execute order 66" The Jedi is an Ewok The clones: calls in Allen and Generation tech to to prepare a fresh Ewok barbecue

[@spacemarineoftheimperialfi7053]

🤣🤣🤣

[@Cipher_Nine]

This is exactly why i think the chips were unnecessary. Also even if they loved their Jedi, like Aayla in legends, they still carried out the order, but kept shooting to make sure she doesn't feel anything. Good vid man

[@robertnelson9599]

I think the chips makes sense. Helps ensure that every clone did what Palpatine wanted when the time came.

[@scapegoatcomics6168]

@@robertnelson9599 from a narrative perspective the inhibitor chips are necessary and in universe it's the final fail safe. Since Clones capacity for independent thought and their own unique personalities mean it would OOC for them to kill their jedi comrades without reservation. The inhibitor chip makes Order 66 completely infallible in it's totality. So yeah whilst some clones wouldn't put up much of a fight and follow it with enthusiam or professionalism some would resist but ultimately have to follow the order thus all doing the same thing and yet not betraying their character and can go through the aftermath true to their respective character

[@RazuX5]

I thought you were better than this, I guess I was wrong about you not being one of those chip haters that are obsessed with not letting this go.

[@dutch_asocialite]

@@robertnelson9599 They do make sense, but I feel it also makes things a bit less interesting as it renders Order 66 completely black and white because of them; instead of clones killing Jedi as a, "finally, revenge," moment, Of Mice & Men-ing it up or a minority just straight up not following through with the order, they *have* to do it with no reservations and... that's it. It's especially egregious, to me at least, because of how _individual_ each Clone is developed to be in the show so we don't get a really deep and developed, "am I a good soldier or a good friend," sort of conflict which, I believe, would've been great and tested the deliberation of clones being products or people. And that's not even getting into the potential of clone renegades who disobeyed Order 66, hunted by Imperial Commandos or something, which, argh, honestly sounds so _coool!_ And anyway, clone conditioning is, like, 99.9% effective, so even without the inhibitor chip and in spite of friendships the Jedi Question is solved.

[@Kazaam818]

Bad batch says otherwise to your entire comment lol

[@nebcyt-notenoughbraincells419]

Commando neyo,commander bacara,the commander who was under quin man vos and clone Jedi hunter keller

[@ChadHoffmanwickalan]

The commando series is an unfinished masterpiece

[@olafgurke4699]

Agreed. The moment Etain died was the first time I cried over something fictional, because I was just so attached to those characters and hoped for a happy ending.

[@The_Elite_Emerald]

@@olafgurke4699 There was no happy ending possible after she died.

[@olafgurke4699]

@@The_Elite_Emerald Yes. Which is why I cried.

[@JarenWelen]

Ion Team was a clone commando squad who disobeyed Order 66, working to disrupt the efforts of "regular" clones and even engaging Darth Vader. The clones as written by Legends authors like James Luceno and Karen Traviss had to tackle deep questions of loyalty rather than the inhibitor chip hand-waviness introduced in the Clone Wars series. Despite the resentment of the Jedi following Geonosis, there's room for clone commandos to question the reasoning of Order 66. Even Skirata's clones with their hatred of the Jedi eventually helped Arligan Zey and others to escape.

[@Gustav_Kuriga]

Hand-waviness? Why would you go through the trouble of cloning and mind-conditioning an entire army only to let them be able to betray you at a pivotal moment because of conflicting loyalties?

[@The_Elite_Emerald]

It is worth mentioning that the commandos didn't hate all Jedi there were some who they respected and even liked. (Bardan Jusik and Etain Tur-Mukan come to mind though there were probably more) The Jedi in that category are particularly Un-Jedi Jedi but they existed. The commandos liked and respected the Jedi who were competent and treated them like men and equals.

[@grandadmiralthrawn1758]

To defeat an enemy, you must know them. Not simply their battle tactics, but their history, philosophy, art.

[@Kylorenz710]

We are Generation Tech! Please cover Sebulba & the dugs!!!!

[@ObiTheHomie]

lol

[@Kylorenz710]

@@ObiTheHomie until you can confirm the kill obi wan you need to just get better Confirm The Kill is all you had to do! Vader lived because you cant confirm the kill, ya let the galaxy down Jedi lol

[@ObiTheHomie]

@@Kylorenz710 kylo couldn't confirm the kill on his mother

[@Kylorenz710]

@@ObiTheHomie Kylo didnt even try to kill his mother!!! His men he commanded to do did it! And he clapped han solo...I have the high ground.....dont try it

[@ObiTheHomie]

@@Kylorenz710 but he was hesitating and gulping when his fingers were around the trigger tho, until his squadron did it for him lol

[@rodo9566]

Alan: For some (clones) the chip wasn't even necessary, they had been thinking for this moment (order 66) for quite some time! Alan: maliciously smiles for a sec 0:17

[@jimmyhoffa2530]

I actually felt bad for Slick because he was totally right for doing what he did.

[@occam7382]

Was he right for turning his back on the Republic? Yes. Was he right for getting his brothers killed and putting many more of them at risk? Absolutely not.

[@mattd2026]

Slick was probably "reprogrammed" back on kamino. He came out a new man!

[@diddydrizzy]

What the fuck

[@Kai.Kollects]

Video ideas: 1, What would have happened if Crosshair didn't obey Order 66? 2, What if Crosshair joined the bad batch at the end of the bad batch season? 3, What happened if the bad batch obeyed Order 66?

[@Sumguyinavan_]

I definitely could have gone for more Clone Wars episodes of Jedi being inept leaders. We just get Pong Krell being a super obvious traitor, and Ahsoka being a 14 year old in charge of 9 year olds in star fighters. Let us really see some of that resentment and lack of leadership.

[@donovansweet142]

What i don't understand is why Dogma was arrested for shooting Krell when Rex was about to do the same thing?

[@harbingerd.8457]

I don't think it was for shooting Krell, but it was that he threatened to shoot Rex and the others when Krell revealed his true colors. And also, Dogma was already in custody when Krell was executed by him, as he took a weapon without authorization

[@Enigma75614]

@@harbingerd.8457 He was clearly arrested for killing Krell.

[@kingorange7739]

@@Enigma75614 um no. Krell committing treason would be more than enough provocation to kill him.

[@Enigma75614]

@@kingorange7739 He killed an unarmed prisoner. Even if the prisoner is a complete douche, you can’t kill them.

[@kingorange7739]

@@Enigma75614 actually as a matter of fact he can. Rex as the next highest rank can do an execution order within a combat situation.

[@Eric-ch6gq]

Hope y'all okay there. I know it's a more somber video, but sounds like some self-care is needed. Take vare of you Alan.

[@grantt1589]

Literally every clone that served under general Krell

[@BansheeNT-D]

Legends Bacara is not in the List? :( He had an awesome line in the books about Order 66.

[@nickvinsable3798]

🤔 . . . Just the pickier ones, those who wouldn’t kill every Jedi, just Criminal Jedi…

[@MistahFox]

All Jedi are criminals! (Technically)

[@nickvinsable3798]

Does that mean that if your parents OR your kids commits murder, you should be punished for their crimes as well, @@MistahFox? What if a fellow follower of your religion commits murder & uses religion to justify it, atheism technically included (justifying murder with atheism), should you be punished as well? Hopefully you’ll start to grasp what I’m typing here…

[@mannofdober873]

Five good soldiers, all following orders.

[@あいうえお-h9w1i]

Is it just me? Doesn’t Alan sound depressed today?

[@knightiafletcher]

Yeah he sounded a bit off, I hope he's alright.

[@johnw391]

You could tell all the shows could of used a miltary tech adviser for tactics plus telling a story in the right order timeliness was so messed up

[@olafgurke4699]

You mean like the Republic Commando game, where the devs got an ex-swat guy to give them a crash course in breach & clear tactics and squad behaviours?

[@warriorwolf77]

Honestly not enough clones did hate them, having been watching the clone wars from the start there's so many jedi that are like I care about you to the 2 remaining of an entire ship of clones and then they're saved not for the clones sake but for the jedi, and then the massive amount of really shit tactical decisions.

[@luigimrlgaming9484]

Fortunately every time a small amount of clones are sent usually one unnamed one survives

[@FirstNameLastName-tg3rc]

(7:18) It was a supply ship, not a battleship.

[@Annabelle-nq5lk]

He did typo by naming that commando Dogma when Dogma was the one with Krell on Umbara

[@breadg1818]

Can you do some of the most loved jedi by there clones

[@thedarkknight5239]

every body knows slick would be here

[@jayvhoncalma3458]

7:09 that would explain his name he's very *dogma* tic

[@gabrielivan2538]

Those 4, not including Darman, are not the only ones that Hated The Jedi, Fun Fact Anakin has always hated Commander Fox, and Commander Fox has always hated the Jedi, He doesn't care that they're Great Warriors, doesn't care about their Wise Plans, doesn't even care about any of the Jedi that die for the Clones, he enjoys Jedi getting Killed. After completing the training simulation on Kamino he signed up to be a Commander, but not to follow the Jedi Generals Orders, not even follow Jedi Grandmaster General Yoda's own Orders, he signed up as a Republic Senate Obedient Dog to obey only Politicians Orders and Regular Military soldiers like the Admiral. That's mostly why he didn't obey Anakin's order there, He's like the Terminator Model T850 in Terminator 3 that was send from 2032 to 2003, send by Katerine Connor, since John Connor Got Killed in 2032 by Terminator Model T850, then reprogrammed and send him back to the past to ensure the survival of John Connor and Kathetine Brewster, he wasn't programmed to follow 2003 John Connor Orders, he even said it himself, I am not programmed to follow your orders. Funny since Both Terminator And Star Wars are part of the Dark Horse Universe, but anyway point is that Commander Fox was like I am not signed up to follow Jedi Orders. And no doubt when Most Clones Executed Order 66 he Enjoyed Killing Jedi, not just the men, but the women, and the Children too, he's an asshole Animal so he got choked like an Asshole animal We hate Him. And even Darth VADER Still hated him, when Fox and his men shot VADER Mistakening him for a Jedi, that was the last Straw, VADER FORCED Choked him, got his neck broken and GOT Fox KILLED!

[@StevenAlexander44]

4:13 6:36 Both "DOGMA" lol instead of the first one being "Darman" or however you spell it

[@dustin7562]

Keller and Neyo should be mentioned Dogma doesn't really belong because he did that out of anger towards krell and tbh we all wanted krell executed. Faye was by far the worst tho. Doman just was trying to protect his son and Slick ig just wanted to save his brothers although he went about it wrong. The biggest lost to Jedi during order 66 was Plo koon because he would have survived if not vulnerable in starfighter. He was definitely my favorite council member with Fisto being second. Thanks for video the Faye Vos brought back memories because I have that comic book

[@paulkafant1008]

U should make a video on why there were no clone generals

[@diddydrizzy]

There actually were

[@paulkafant1008]

@@diddydrizzy there were?

[@diddydrizzy]

@@paulkafant1008 yep

[@danielgrayam6758]

Anyone else notice that darmin had dogmas name and dogma had dogmas name so dogma was on here twice

[@e4corndog]

5 Clone Troopers Who Hated The Jedi, Aahh Yes, The Battle Of Geonosis.

[@gabrielivan2538]

Darman didn't hate them, he loves Etain the Jedi, he loves their son. Most Clones Love their Jedi Generals, remaing Survivor Clones after the Clone Wars still Love Jedi, always will Love Jedi, like Rex, Gregor, Wolffe, but each ones that still had their inhibitor chips, were not in control of themselves, as soon excute order 66 came in on the Holo Comm, their inhibitor chips took control of them, they only had one choice, And No, that's not true, Clone Elite Republic Great Commandos are NOT Cannon Fodder, maybe Gregor is, most of the Regular Clones are definitely Expandable, but not the rest, there were Clone that regretted killing their Jedi Generals during Excute Order 66 like Commander Gray. As for Delta Elite squad Clone Republic Great Commandos, Not even sure Sev is Dead, SEV is one Strong guy he's just as Hard to Kill like Chewbacca. I Just Finished Star Wars Republic Commando on the Xbox 360 last year 2021 and have a theory to how he could survive, He fights on, go through some lower sewer levels, finds a computer to temporarily disable communication grid along with temporarily disabling the droids from finding him, uses the computer to help boost his signal again, and then the rest of Delta squad picks up his signal, they remove the inhibitor chips Like Commander Doom did, they disobey any and all orders including Disobey execute order 66. they rescued him, returns to their posts, and continue defending Kashyyyk, then Order 66 Comes in, thry refuse to do it, but Sev still has his Inhibitor Chip forces him to obey it, but then Scorch grabs hold of Him and Pixer uses his Wrist Blade to cut out the Chip, they continue serving the Remaining Jedi. Lie to other Clone Troopers saying Yoda is already dead, Saved Lumina and Yoda takes them to another SpaceShip, Thanks em for Disobeying Excute Order 66, puts them in Cryostasis Pods to stopping their Ageing Process, waiting for the Right time to awake them which is their sequel along with Darman even his son. Whenever They found true Fallen Rogue Evil Crazed Jedi Insane Traitors they didn't like them, they definitely hated those true Traitors like Bariss Offee. Barriss Offee is a Fool Dumb BITCH Slow Learner, she is Wrong, the Jedi have not become Villians, their actions as Warrior Combat Generals are Justified in the Desperate Republic during the Clone Wars, Desperate Time calls for Desperate Measures, the Jedi are Heroes, but Not SuperHeroes. It is not their places as Jedi Official Generals that should be in questioned, it's their ways that have been part of their Society that has happened for Generations that is in questions, most of their Decrees are OBSOLETE, have Unethical Genocidal rules that makes most of them Brainwashed, along with their Horrible Laws of having Love with anyone, laws of how they barely mourn their dead but do not miss them, even Laws of the Force. Barriss was Wrong to question their roles as Generals in the Clone Wars, to frame Ashoka for Treason, while secretly joining the Sith, but that plan failed, Anakin beaten her, brought her to trial clearing Ashoka of all Charges, arrested Barris her actions were wrong, but Ahsoka was right to leave the Regular Jedi Order, not just because to survive the Upcoming Excution of Order 66, not just to join Leaders that know the True Senate Corruption bring in the New Republic, but because she is one of the Most Urgent Jedi that start an Order that had few Memebers that have Disobeyed the rules of the Old Obsolete Regular Jedi Order that were already fighting their Decrees knowing that Blindly listening to them will only lead to their downfall which it did in Revenge of the Sith. So those Disobedient Jedi they were to permeantly change their Laws, planed to do different Recuitment, even plan to use both sides of the Force to their full potential, Qui Gon Jinn was one of those Jedi, he disobeyed even the Council themselves, was offered to be on the Council, but didn't need nor want be a Jedi Council Memeber, bend the law when recruiting Anakin at age 9 to Join the Jedi, he was pratically a Ninja Martial Artist Stratigist Warrior Planner Jedi, when it came to Ninjas, Shaolin Monks, every Martial Artists Warriors they don't just recruit at Toddler's age, they recruit anyone at any age willing to join them. A Jedi woman that fell in love with a Clone Republic Commando 1,136 Called Darman secretly got married, he got that Jedi lady pregnant, gave birth to a boy, but that poor lady died, Darman disobeyed Order 66, got the child to a Mandalorian Darman with his wife, were mostly likely willing to change the Jedi Rules for their son. Oppo Rancisis that survived Order 66 probably willing to change. Anakin was also a Jedi to disobeyed the Rules having to fall in love Padme Amidala his childhood friend, him, his kids were willing to change the rules. Cere, Cal Kestis from Jedi Fallen Order also willing to change their obsolete ways since he's in love with Nightsister Merrin. I along with a KZbinr know about an Truth about the Jedi that has made them Partially Dishonorable taint Warriors. I Sir Gabriel Collado Ivan and this KZbinr The Film Theorist both have same idea that the Regular Jedi are Evil to a lesser degree on this video Called Film Theory The Uncomfortable truth about the Jedi Order (Star Wars Jedi Evil,) On 10:34 he and I was kinda like no They are So Wrong, We are both thinking the same idea, the Jedi are Brainwashed, Dishonest, Dishonorable Warriors, but the Sith are NOT Good, the regular Jedi Order we're dishonorable, the Sith too, and I have Great Ideal Explanation for this, 1 The Jedi are Brainwashed to have no emotions except Serenity, calmness, and happiness, they think they make them strong but they're wrong, sometimes Anger is needed, it helps The HULK, it had helped Obi Wan get Maul beaten by using Anger after he stabbed his Master Qui Gon Jinn, along with help Anakin get Darth Tyranus killed. 2 Yoda in Star Wars 3 ROTS said not to care about those who have died never to mourn nor miss them but they mourned Qui Gon by giving him a funeral that's totally Terrible. 3 They take children at toddler age separate them from their parents either never let them see each other again or let them see each other again but in a long time not even to text or send a message, that's even more cold blooded than Dr Halsey taking kids at pre teen age to their facilities training them to be Spartans then give them their Serums at 14 worse of all their parents don't even know their children have been taken, they clone their child lie to the parents letting them think they got their original children but they didn't, their original children are still in thir custody. 4 Jedi don't use Mandalorian Trinkets, nor Use Sith Trinkets no matter how great knowledge they have, but they use Jedi Trinket Holocrons for info, they think that's all the knowledge they need to learn between Jedi Holocrons, Books, Computers, but they're wrong sometimes need other sources of Intel, and that's what Number 5 turns out to be truly helpfully Hopeful. Number 5 Jedi think Lightside of the Force own abilities are more powerful than the Darkside, that should never use anything related to the Darkside except Skills something Mace Windu did when fighting on Geonosis, the Clone Wars, and against Palpatine as Darth Sidious it comes with being a Purple Lightsaber wielder using both Lightside and Darkside Fighting physical Melee Lightsaber Skills, but everything else in the Darkside other than Skills are Forbidden, such as Knowledge Power Ehancement Abilities, but I say it doesn't matter what side of the Force those knowledge and Abilities are from, it only matters how the person uses them, depending on who they are, for what reason they use it for, the Regular Jedi Order didn't see like that, they believed only using happiness, calmness, Serenity, Only use Jedi Holocrons, and only use Lightsiders Force Abilities are more powerful than Darksiders Force Abilities but they're Wrong, both sides of the Force are Powerful, Repulse, Mind Trick, Lightning are needed, Plo Coon used Lightning called Electrical judgement, Luke Skywalker used Green Emerald Lightning, pyrokinesis, healing power, control of water, and Metamorphosis are needed, (Metamorphosis power to shape-shift into anyone, anyspecies, and any animals even Monstrous types.) So really both Factions of the Force are Powerful at the same level, even Sith Lord Count Dooku that became Darth Tyranus didn't fully embrace the Darkside that's why he was never deformed nor did have Sith Eyes, he still used some Abilities of the Lightside of the Force, same goes out for Kylo Ren, and the True Force Weilders Warriors that are honorably Wisely Powerful are the Grey Order Jedi, Samurais, a Martial Artists Warrior Clans Ninjas take toddlers to be trained in their Martial Arts Fightings, but they also can accept pre teens, Adults, middle age adults, and Teenagers. Grey Order Jedi are the ones that use White lightsabers starting with Ahsoka Tano, Gold Lightsabers wielders such as Rey, Green Lightsabers true Excellent Jedi Grey Consulars like Luke Skywalker, even Yoda as a Spirit used Force Weather to destroy that tree, but still used Force Lightning nonetheless along with Rey, Purple Lightsabers wielders for half Lightsiders, half Darksiders, and Darksabers (which Moff Gideon in Mandalorian don't deserve, only the Mandalorians, Nightsisters like Merrin, and Grey Excellent Jedi Deserve the Darksaber, should probably make More Black Lightsabers.) But anyway the True Non Brainwashed Great Emotional Enhanced Powerful gifted Force User SuperHeroes are the Grey Order Jedi

[@potatoheadpokemario1931]

I don't think Dogma hated the Jedi, he just hated prong krell, and who could blame him?

[@iamReddington]

The irony here is, as flawed as the Jedi were, they were loyal. The clones were monsters who never should have existed.

[@KirbyBWebb]

Good Video ! The Clones were NOT Robots .

[@KrisjanVanFokkol]

Yeeeees new gen tech vid, me very happy

[@luisemoralesfalcon4716]

Thanks for the video.

[@KathaofSants]

@GenerationTech can you make a video about the High Republic council?

[@Enigma75614]

4:14 It says Dogma, not Darman.

[@imperialguardsman4361]

You should do 5 Clones who Hated Order 66

[@shawnwing-kovarik9762]

How about that Commando team from the game Republic Commando? Delta Squad I think? Did they hate jedi so much that they wouldn't have tried to resist order 66 at all?

[@The_Elite_Emerald]

They hated most Jedi with two exceptions that I can think of those Being Etain Tur-Mukan and Bardan Jusik both of whom acted as the head of Delta's unit (05 Commando Battalion) those are the only two Delta wouldn't have shot, Jusik no longer being a Jedi also would have spared him as he left the order a year into the war on a moral objection.

[@MrRonald327]

Good for them.

[@steffent.6477]

Where is Darmans story continued after order 66? His imperial career is new to me.

[@ArielKahane]

Read imperial commando by Karen Traviss

[@armorbearer9702]

I wonder if Commander Faye would still hate Jedi if he served under Obi-Wan?

[@steffent.6477]

Darman stays as imperial commando for the rest of his life or does he escape to clan Skirata as well?

[@edwardhayes6816]

No one knows. The author never finished the story

[@olafgurke4699]

@@edwardhayes6816 She never was allowed to finish it. Which is quite sad.

[@steffent.6477]

@@olafgurke4699 Why that?

[@olafgurke4699]

@@steffent.6477 I'm not sure on the details, but there apparently were some disagreements with Lucasfilm at the time. That's why Imperial Commando was the last of the books, despite more having been planned.

[@wojtek561]

@@steffent.6477 She stop writing, because Lucas and Filoni clone wars project just appeard and retcone whole clone lore she create. I am not sure if she did not want to adapt and retcone her books to this new lore and therefore was not allowed to continue writing, or if it was she who decided, that she did not want to write if she could not as she wanted.

[@ryanjapan3113]

I think you show Dogma’s name twice (also, unrelated, but for some reason the first time I saw Dogma’s name in the video I confused him with Slick).

[@cpttankerjoe]

4:13 and 6:37 both say dogma. Also if you read this Allen, you seem a bit down today. Not sure if it was the subject or something else but take a day off or something and get some rest.

[@rangerleaf1505]

Oh no the dolphins broke his legs....

[@tristankawatsuma8962]

Okay, we all know genocide is evil and all that, but you have to think twice if the people who are being wiped out technically could be called slavers and the people who are wiping them out are their slaves. On a bit of an unrelated note, can we be honest and just say that the Force technically is starting the biggest and bloodiest wars in the galaxy? Force Wielders try to stay out of galactic politics, but they keep dragging themselves in for their own goals (Sith: Conquering the galaxy/Jedi: Stopping the Sith). The "Balance of the Force" is a major motivator to keeping Jedi and Sith on opposite ends. On that note, I'm still not sure if balance means balance between light or dark or just the plain eradication of the Sith. Either case though is impossible to achieve as the Sith and the Jedi will always return. Sure, world peace is a tough goal but at least we know we need to work together to achieve it. Jedi and Sith on the other hand will always be fighting each other as the Force wills it and they will always drag non-Force users into these wars. Honestly, a purge of both Jedi and Sith, while grim, probably would eliminate some threats to the galaxy and save lives in the long wrong. Of course then the galaxy would still have regular criminals and militants to deal with, but at least the superpowered folks are no longer dragging the rest of us into their fights.

[@lerneanlion]

Hey Alan, do you think the Kaminoans deserved what just happened to them? You know, their city being bombarded and then deported to somewhere else by the Empire?

[@rc59191]

They didn't deserve that they may of been cold but without them we wouldn't have heroes like Delta and Omega Squads, Bad Batch, Rex, Fives.

[@nobleman9393]

No.

[@regularguy2807]

@@rc59191 But they literally just bred them to be child slave soldiers for the republic. They attempted to terminate clones that were defective and only were stopped by the jedi which they would then send to work as labourers in maintenance instead. They also turned dead clones into paste which was likely fed to their living brothers as food. They only cared about the clones as being products for their buyers ( the republic ) and did not care about them as individuals.

[@rc59191]

@@regularguy2807 they had to be like that in order to survive. It's not morally right but it's easy for us to take the moral high rode when we haven't been tested by the same conditions of their world.

[@lerneanlion]

@@rc59191 No offense but I never heard anyone weep, complain or even shed a tear when the Empire dissolved the Techno Union and forced hundreds and thousands of its workers and machinesmiths to find employments elsewhere in the galaxy. Those who are not lucky may have to live on the streets or even ended up dying.

[@zephyr8072]

Jedi is an anagram of "Die, J" J for Jango. Therefor all Jedi want Jango clones dead. Hence the hatred. Logic.

[@Michaelengelmann]

Will there be a Bad Batch season 2?

[@geviesanta3631]

Yeah, it's already been confirmed that it's going to get S2. Which is scheduled to come out next summer on Disney ➕

[@mongoxray5552]

Is it just me or does Alan look high AF? 😂

[@georgeoldsterd8994]

I hated the inhibitor chip idea, it robbed the clones of what made them different from droids: choice. And don't give me the "that's what Palpatine wanted all along" because it was a cheap copout on Filloni's team to explain why likeable characters like Rex and Cody would betray the Jedi. I mean, the clones are just human beings, and we know from the old lore that the longer the war waged, the more clones grew tired of fighting and got resentful of the Jedi. In the old lore not all clones obeyed Order 66, and it made them realistic, and explained why certain Jedi actually survived into the Imperial Era, but with the chips it just didn't make sense. A handful removed their chips, because they've got plot armour, but the rest executed Order 66 and then went to serve the Empire. Yet with more and more new SW content being released, more and more Order 66 survivors turn up. How did they survive when all Jedi were out on battlefields and the rest were wiped out in the Jedi Temple raid? Obi-Wan got lucky, Cal got saved by his master, who sacrificed himself, Ahsoka left the Jedi prior to the Order, but what about the rest, you know, the fodder characters that are used to show how dangerous the Inquisitorious is?

[@Casey-jn3ib]

Who wouldn’t hate the Jedi? Bloody hypocrites.

[@regularguy2807]

Claim to be against slavery yet lead a slave army into battle.

[@luissantiago5163]

Oh cool. This'll be great

[@stevensosa5995]

What Jedi generals did clones hate the most?

[@johnnyboybearsfan9848]

What happened to Boil?

[@diddydrizzy]

1:53 sauce And no I am not 8

[@mattd2026]

I forgot about darman post 66... sad ting

[@stephengayton5246]

Is it dogma or darman?

[@ShinGoukiSan]

Time for a new hat

[@PhoenixT70]

4:21 ... hi?

[@bobafett4617]

Did Darmin/Garmin (how is he spelled??) really hate the jedi or just feared them because of his family? I mean yes, he lost brothers to jedi, but I feel like he could clearly differ between pure blood lust and fear for life, and his family made him even more sensitive to this. So is it really hate or fear? And one clone you lost would probably be Commander Bacara as well as Commander Neyo

[@peachdevils3893]

Why was dogma on there twice

[@sammywhite5127]

0:16 god the inhibitor chip really just ruins order 66 and the whole drama surrounding it

[@Mysmero425]

Boba's a clone right? And doesn't he hate the Jedi order too?

[@RedArmyShogun]

He hates them because they killed his father in the middle of an arena.

[@RazuX5]

@@RedArmyShogun he mainly hated Mace Windu.

[@jesielcardenales2108]

How jedi the Survive next

[@AQuietVoice2022]

Alan, you okay? You seem pretty down, moreso than it just being the subject matter of the video.

[@JacobGen]

What if Darth Nihilus trained Anakin?

[@Snoozy0331]

No one gonna mention it says dogma twice?

[@jacobrobinson787]

I think Allen is a bit off his game on this one.

[@Snoozy0331]

@@jacobrobinson787 maybe it’s not his day, he doesn’t sound enthusiastic either

[@lordofpain3476]

Even though the clones were superior to any alien species ( obviously ) , they were far inferior to even the lowliest human . Never forget. HUMANITY FIRST.

[@lilacocto9103]

I don't blame them really, most Jedi didn't care or didn't know how to properly manage a battalion of soldiers.

[@dustinkennedy7055]

What about dogma

[@silvercypher8435]

Why did it say dogma for darmon

[@pyeitme508]

No wonder

[@GRIGGINS1]

Looks at thumbnail. It would be so easy............. Too bang. Sneaky Smile.

[@Michaelengelmann]

Whose the chick at 1:51?

[@wilsoniothegreat6162]

What happened to his voice?

[@NoOne-et9mi]

Execute order 66

[@HolyShitNew]

no i dont think i will

[@obi-wan-kenobi2393]

@@HolyShitNew yeah can't be bothered

[@HolyShitNew]

Yes, lord sidious

[@LeoAYt]

I love commander faie

[@harveybarnes2049]

Bacara is another

[@Lom251]

U have mistake in video. There is Dogma instead Darman

[@oscarcintra-sadiki1703]

I think neyo should have been number one

[@RespecterAlexander]

👍

[@zacjose1323]

Hello

[@graynomad7735]

There

[@stevenf.gonzalez1080]

General

[@Scarface39212]

Kenobi

[@merlinmeurer5339]

Dogma twice?

[@Capitulated000]

Darman or dogma

[@dark_shadowjv1959]

You forgot commander fox lol.

[@russellmoffett2447]

He doesn’t hate Jedi

[@dark_shadowjv1959]

@@russellmoffett2447 might wanna do your research lol

[@russellmoffett2447]

@@dark_shadowjv1959 what did he do to show he doesn’t like Jedi he only tried to arrest the crappy character Asoka( in my opinion crappy) because he was following orders

[@dark_shadowjv1959]

@@russellmoffett2447 read the comics, then you’ll see how he looked at the Jedi, I wasn’t only talking about the Jedi, he didn’t like other clones either and only saw himself and his unit superior to other units.

[@RazuX5]

@@dark_shadowjv1959 why don’t you actually give us sources to prove that he actually did otherwise nobody has any reason to believe you.

[@EarhirX]

Hey where’s American Ben?

[@davidgiles4681]

Let me put this in Mil/non-Mil relationship: Jedi were non-Mil persons. They did not understand Mil Tactics, Mil movements, Mil mindset, etc... Jedi tended to put the Clones in tactically unsound situations (in which their Brothers in Arms died needlessly). Even the Admirals and Generals hated the Jedi. They saw them as "useless tactically". But, they held a greater rank over the Mil and thus "commanded" the Mil. Put yourself as a tactically trained Clone Soldier. From Birth to release, all you learned was Mil tactics and Mil protocol. Now, you have a "civilian Jedi" ordering you around and killing your Brothers in Arms needlessly. They would be alive if it were not for the Jedi. The Admirals and Generals (who went to War College [where Mil Leaders learn tactics, history, movements, command of large forces, etc...]). Now, you have a robed civilian commanding you. Anakin was different. He understood tactics. Obi-Wan understood tactics. Some Jedi did not and killed entire clone forces. One could understand how a Clone Soldier would love to have a Mil (real Mil) commander - commanding them. I had the same problem (while an e3 in the AF) with the CAP Civil Air Patrol. Some CAP Captain would want me to salute them. I refused. Some teenager (with CAP rank) I will not salute. You better get real 2lt rank and then I will salute them.

[@Fordo007]

The thing is Jedi have the Force. They have an advantage no amount of military training can match there. Despite not being trained to be tacticians or strategists... throughout galactic history the Jedi end up in command of the Republic's forces and end up achieving victory. The Force guides them and following it they win battles. Some Jedi are better leaders than others... but if the Jedi were really bad leaders, the Republic wouldn't keep giving them command. A Jedi commander 9 times out of 10 will be better than any officer from any military academy. A Jedi who isn't a good combat leader, who gets their troops killed, is rare. But a bad Jedi leader is less likely than a bad officer in general. You are way more likely to have a military officer whose awful at their job. Just look at the Empire where sooooooooooooo many of their officers were incompetent. A far higher percentage than of the Jedi. And with a Jedi the troops KNOW their general is going to be on the front lines with them. How many non-Jedi generals do that? I think people really overestimate the bad Jedi leaders and don't take into account the alternative.