5 SCARIEST Creepypastas to Keep You Up At Night

[@allifitz]

OMG HES BACK

[@MatthewSantoro]

You know it fam! :D

[@uraverageskeleton6480]

You know it fam :D

[@Mathematty06]

You know it fam! :D

[@BaveRAWWR]

@@MatthewSantoro hope you got your Mojo back :)

[@ThunderingGames]

You know it fam! :D

[@needisnecessito8663]

He proteccc He attaccc But most importantly Scary Matt is bacccc

[@Unknown-fn9fc]

Shut up Come up with an original joke

[@Kre8-1duH]

@@Unknown-fn9fc like yours?

[@Unknown-fn9fc]

@@Kre8-1duH ???

[@jolinkarlsson8569]

Yay

[@MexicanMartialArts]

Matthew Santoro keeping me up for YEARS!! 💯🤣

[@smokeythereactor5929]

Me too, in both ways.

[@LillibitOfHere]

Giggity

[@jumpykilllerqx6029]

Grandmaster

[@jumpykilllerqx6029]

@Mexican Martial Arts you gonna submit a creppy pasta about the Bruce lee death touch?

[@IR088Y]

WHOA MEXICAN MARTIAL ARTS WHAT ARE YOU DOING HERE??!!

[@bees.creative.collections]

"that will keep you up at night" me: *falls asleep while listening to these*

[@aeroexcrx3056]

I thought I was the only one who did this. *Leaves the chat*

[@monstruswallaby9981]

What irony.

[@xo.psychooo8650]

right😭🤣

[@FallenRingbearer]

Heh. Lovecraft is comedy. I'd love to see you try.

[@cherryfaith4877]

Lol I know aye, I'm fighting to stay awake atm myself...

[@GottliebVideos]

That’s why they call him slim shady...he’s back, he’s back.

[@mwsn736]

guess he’s back back again guess he’s back tell a friend

[@GottliebVideos]

@@mwsn736 now this looks like a job for me, so everybody just follow me, cause we need a little controversy, cause it feels so empty without me!

[@vxfusion6975]

@@GottliebVideos Now this looks like a job for me, so everybody just follow me, cause we need a little con-tro-vers-ee, cause it feels so empty without ME!

[@myiamoore7985]

Guess who's back shady,s back tell a frien

[@austinhunt6455]

And when the world needed him most... HE CAME BACK

[@aleno525]

I haven't seen Mathew santoro in over 3 or 4 years. I forgot how good his narration is

[@blondezeke6640]

Uncle Matt's back to tell us a bed time story

[@dogsandwolves]

hi Matthew keep up the great work

[@thepretzelman4054]

FRANKIE

[@thepretzelman4054]

The legend himself

[@josemiguelgonzalezwachter2269]

Woah that last one! I love it when they reveal a grim dark reality at the end of what you thought was just another spooky ghost story! ^^

[@Chixmiss]

You're back 🥺❣

[@claysoggyfries]

I’m back too 😳

[@dreii.6749]

FELLOW Filipino who loves Matt, hey ate Chix! 😍

[@arjay3803]

Uy ate chix!

[@hosskvlt]

SCARY MAT IS BACK, MY DAY IS SAVED.

[@MatthewSantoro]

BOO! B&^ch I'm a ghost...oh sorry this isn't TikTok.

[@brandonfarley8279]

Matthew Santoro 😂😂

[@hosskvlt]

@@MatthewSantoro OH- IGIGJGGKB

[@Daddyme92]

@@MatthewSantoro ayy papi

[@Justagirl1982]

2021 has a fighting chance now

[@TheGunmanChannel]

So glad you're back Matthew. Love your vids

[@sweenytodd3145]

Matthew you have returned, it actually made me happy, and giddy when you popped up on my recommended list. Welcome back, dear friend

[@tmmini5969]

And the bedtime stories are back!!!

[@sandoraboxx1451]

Love it

[@rosalina5089]

Eh, I love it but I think his old ones are better

[@jetghoul4182]

AND WHEN THE WORLD NEEDED HIM THE MOST HE RETURNED

[@mrsshahshah4447]

XD

[@ezra-jacksimas9613]

Yassssss

[@sususnandes]

Just imagine Matthew narrating Stephen kings and R.L Stine books

[@no-cs3fx]

Is there a petition I can sign or-?

[@cherryblossoms85]

Or any Creepy Pastas!

[@Amateur.Nail.Art.1]

Yes, please!!

[@KevinTan]

or SCPs

[@MarcusTheStoryteller]

I need this. Matt to read scary stories to tell in the dark

[@KevinTan]

*Conspiracy Theory : We are in a separate timeline where Matthew is still making list videos..*

[@Sumirevins]

r/technicallythetruth

[@halejandrohd2955]

Bruhhhh

[@thesunsofliberty1789]

Oh boy

[@Chaotic_Club]

“He was fed instead of paid.” He was cleaning the building after all staff left or died. *What was the food?*

[@froggo5690]

milk and cookies

[@tsubakiofmelancholy6297]

Thank goodness I'm not the only one wanting to know what he was eating.

[@brenyatta]

It was a bunch of pickled, preserved food that was probably incredibly disgusting, most of it being moldy

[@ravenlampel2214]

Matthew Santoro I'm so proud of you you've come so far with your editing and your videos huge fan can't wait to see your projects in the future keep up the good work

[@boldandbrash259]

This is the Matthew Santoro who built my childhood

[@stevenlaird6480]

Me

[@stevenlaird6480]

Me to

[@Its_ShaniaNcl]

SAMEEEE

[@umq1]

yesss! 👍🏻

[@yapyapthedestroyer2562]

The creepypastas be back

[@enkikim5803]

the fact that uncle matt's been telling me bedtime stories for more than 7 years makes me happy

[@CorelexVoidOwl]

Unlike the Avatar, he returned when the world needed him the most.

[@RedTurtleneckYT]

🤣amen!!!

[@zerobolt9506]

You know if you think about it, the Avatar returned just when it need him the most, not to mention with a war starting then how would he even learn firebending.

[@katie7673]

Fact

[@pandamonium9322]

Who's to say he's NOT the Avatar?

[@aca0891]

@@pandamonium9322 he just paints over the arrow on his head.

[@creepy.cookie3187]

I've been subscribed for almost 5 years, it's good to see some things never change.

[@doodlebob9889]

That last story was a really good one I was never expecting that

[@ErikTheElectric]

Let's goooooo!

[@jrich5795]

Aight, If you are the real Erik the Electric. What day is Kristie's birthday on? Actually, the real Erik the Electric probably doesn't even know that. Never mind

[@johnymcmuffins7898]

@@jrich5795 u can just click on him to see his channel if its the real one

[@raisa_cherry35]

@@johnymcmuffins7898 yes it's real.

[@violenceisfun991]

RubItRubItRubIt! RubYaPeanessOnAPuppet

[@jrich5795]

@@johnymcmuffins7898 True

[@JudahProject2012]

Creepy Matt, oh how we've missed ya.

[@jamesonweimann4720]

But he owes us more videos

[@JudahProject2012]

@@jamesonweimann4720 He owes us nothing let him live bro

[@vladimirpetrusev8376]

yea he does it was boring and now hes bak and i got my coffee and now its not boring anymore

[@FluffyNebula]

The ending of Distorted Warning Signals got me. The ambiguous ending completes the story more than any “proper” ending could.

[@pundertalefan4391]

Well, if she survived whatever it was, which I doubt, I'm sure she learned to always bring her phone with her. XD

[@theatticaddict]

Tbh I kinda wanna know what happened to her

[@MiraTheWarlock]

It's the creepiest when it's read by Madame Macabre, as she adds in the sound effect of a door opening, and creeking loudly after the final message

[@watercuh2364]

Me: it’s ok that it’s nighttime because I’m in my bed and I’m safe here The water I’ve been drinking all day: *are you sure about that*

[@kchiia]

YAY MY UNCLE MATT CAME BACK TO TELL ME MORE BEDTIME STORIES!

[@j.p.wilson6921]

That free food was the most disturbing part of all this...

[@Sumirevins]

Me after Studying hard all day: let's meditate Also me: *"Watches Creepy pastas and SCP tales Under the blanket"*

[@aeroexcrx3056]

Definitely relatable

[@eitonaraoka6213]

So for the second story do I even want to know what the “food” the janitor was payed with was?

[@rishi_1003]

No you don't, cannibalism is not cool.

[@petepeterson5917]

@@rishi_1003 "Alright lads, words of wisdom coming our way"

[@ApWhatever]

Im thinking the same thing

[@mikeleonard2433]

Hey Matt Do you know why Goofy put a clock under his desk? He wanted to work overtime!!

[@peanutsans6780]

Thanks for making me smile 😊

[@p.d.l7023]

Why did Goofy throw that clock out of the window? He wanted see time fly.

[@mikeleonard2433]

@@p.d.l7023 that was good! :)

[@pundertalefan4391]

Ahyuck. XD

[@zysep7362]

Wow that joke made me laugh😯😯😯

[@kingaudio6464]

Matt, why don't you go into acting? That video called "There's something I never told you" had some pretty awesome emotion. Your great at expressing yourself, just a thought

[@zonkeos100]

Is this a alternate universe or something or a sick joke or is he actually doing list videos again

[@kaigaming5453]

I miss these vids 😌

[@dcmarvel6035]

That’s what I’m saying

[@j_mack1996]

I thought that he said that he wasn't doing list videos anymore?

[@KevinTan]

that was a different timeline, we live in a new timeline now with matthew santoro still uploading list videos

[@RGBeanie]

He'll do whatever makes the $. In this case, his popular lists.

[@theundeadqueen4173]

Wait, who was feeding the guy if everyone was dead and the school wasn't operating???

[@basketballkidforever]

I’m guessing he would eat the dead bodies

[@bilsbathbomb6414]

@@basketballkidforever EW

[@Mewse1203]

That was my first thought too!

[@sirornstein]

"From the ashes a fire shall be woken A light from the shadows shall spring Renewed shall be channel that was inactive Uploading again shall be Matt" -Riddle of Santoro, Fellowship of the Move

[@abirbasu757]

0:01 me expecting a weird funny face... Gets a really creepy face instead.. Me : Matthew your are going to wash my pants.....

[@B1luvzB2]

I’m so happy I follow you on Instagram because I didn’t get a notification about your upload even though I have it on! Time to catch up. So excited and happy you’re back!!! ❤️ you’re awesome, thank you so much!

[@justdecaffeinated]

JESUS CHRIST MATT THAT INTRO SCARED THE BEJESUS OUT OF ME

[@Darth_Vader258]

@Calico Trace That's BLASPHEMY.

[@puffspiss3104]

Mathew: “If your easily scared you should turn away now” Me home alone: “I have no fear in my body! *After the video* Me hears a noise down the hallway: *Gotta go fast*

[@no-cs3fx]

After watching this I turned off my basement light and slowly walked up the stairs to assert my dominance

[@suspect-king5267]

underrated comment

[@jesseberry2046]

Gotta go faster faster faster sonic X

[@pepesilvia429]

@@no-cs3fx that and if if I run I feel like I'm being chased and I panic

[@no-cs3fx]

@@pepesilvia429 the number of times I would slam my face into the stairs as a kid after sprinting up the stairs

[@samanthaburroughs91923]

I've been following all along the way, but I cant lie, when I saw the notification for this I was like omg is this new??? Very excited and erhmagerd that intro!!!

[@seraphbeatz2204]

Wow, I used to watch him in 2010 and his production quality has increased tremendously. Love to see him back

[@KunalSharma-xf6cc]

Bro, earlier, before sleeping every night, I would watch your videos on scary, chilling topics, especially creepypastas. Now you're finally back, so I can resume that routine of mine. Love your content man. Welcome back :)

[@TendersLOL]

I'm glad that uncle Mat is back and will tell me yet another bedtime story!

[@nickelnl7111]

"Uncle Matt is back to tell you a bedtime story..." Me: *Pops popcorn, makes a drink* "NOW it's Christmas!"

[@immrlonelyihavenobody4176]

That beginning got me

[@zoltire6478]

Same

[@Goleon]

I was like “Dude, some warning next time!”.

[@ninawilson3132]

I'm so happy you're back!!! These videos have helped me through some of the toughest times. I don't know why, but they have

[@jennzee8751]

3:12 Commercial kicked in and said "I've dated much worse guys than him!" I can't make this up! Perfect timing 😜

[@nicktucker2623]

Most anticipated sequel of all time

[@carolynt5445]

Hey, Matt! I remember watching your videos way back when you first started, but fell out of tune after a couple of years due to school and preference. But I kept telling myself to join back in, and the change is kind of astounding haha. I see you've got a new backdrop, and your ambience is different, too. It used to have more of a comedic effect, but now is more serious and creepy, which is awesome. Definitely gonna be going on a video binge! Hope you are well! :)

[@benw4409]

Matthew Santoro with a creepypasta video. Man I'm nostalgic. I've missed these.

[@ivybee347]

I love creepypastas. The only one I've actually heard as far as I remember is number 1. Maybe I just forgot that I've heard the others, but I'll go look and listen to them again. Number 1 was crazy.

[@spid3rfrommars]

It feels like ages hearing Matthew talk about creepypasta

[@aq3x.1]

and I love it

[@heroofrhyme2539]

These types of his videos makes me feel nostalgic bc I got into him when I was like 10 based around his scary videos

[@minesweeper83]

So good to see Matt back on KZbin. 2021 is looking my positive already 🙂

[@colleeniborbeeni2902]

I wasnt gonna go to sleep anyway Also, hearing that intro made me very happy

[@Its_ShaniaNcl]

My cousins and I used to watch your videos every day, I'm pretty much confident I have watched everything you posted. When you stopped uploading my older cousin re-watched his favorite videos of you. We still wait for your uploads and we watch it all together! ❤️

[@samk1651]

So happy to see you posting again Matt!!! Just hope you’re taking care of yourself. That’s our number ONE concern! Missed you

[@Yoshisboss07]

The “Distorted Warning Signals” story made me get goosebumps and all my hairs stand up! I felt my heart sink into my stomach 🥶 Also, Welcome Back Uncle Matt! Thanks for the bedtime stories 😄

[@kristinadelfierro1320]

DUDE DUDE SERIOUSLY I missed your crazy positive vibes about the most twisted stuff, with out being disrespectful... ♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️😎🐰🐰🐰🐰🐰♥️♥️ Missed you

[@rebeccamount50]

"Living History" is more a feelspasta than a creepypasta.

[@joetrump2983]

It's very depressing

[@jester1894]

The lights in the background make it so much more perfect!!! Sets the mood! Welcome back, Matt!!

[@cameronreyno7175]

The scariest stories are the ones grounded in reality. Change my mind

[@RIPMalice]

The wild baldo returns! YES! We missed you, Matt.

[@RIPMalice]

@Lady Angedevimon Thank you thank you. I'll be here all week ✋😂

[@Mr.nesser]

not gonna lie, these are really good. Goosebumps with every single one of them

[@GeminiThaKing]

Matt: "My channel is changing forever, I'm not making anymore list videos." Also Matt:

[@matthewbates9629]

He probably missed making them

[@theatticaddict]

IKR 🤣

[@almasanchez4421]

I mean they ARE pretty entertaining lol

[@delaneyreyes8995]

I love these videos!

[@whocares8567]

Are you complaining? Weirdchamp

[@nightmarefiles1]

Hmm

[@Healthywave99]

Uh... Yes?

[@Nevermore-Nevermore]

I had a great uncle Steve who was a hoarder...That sent chills down my spine when he said that

[@sonofagun743]

This brings back memories of the time he started in that apartment with a creepy basement ❤️❤️ I love this

[@sandycheeks2372]

Omg I’m literally so happy to see you back Matt! You are an amazing human being🥰 Love from Australia 🇦🇺

[@SWY1356]

Heck yeah, scary matt stories are back!

[@Devvijing]

I've never been happier seeing you in my recomendations Matt. Welcome back!

[@glennandrew6449]

MAHHHH MANNN IS BACKKK 2021 LEZZZGOOOO FEELIN LILE A GOOD YEAR

[@sky_line0616]

This makes me very happy that Matt is back

[@AliceBluegothBunny]

The wild baldo has appeared on my notifications! welcome back matt!

[@FirithPanda]

I thought you were stepping away from the countdown list type videos, but I'm still glad they might be here every once in a while. I will say, however, that I'm enjoying the other content as well.

[@xAdorNexasYT]

I've missed Matt, he's like AMSR sometimes man

[@HashtagAbdul]

Welcome back Matt. I feel like the "If you're easily scared" disclaimer came too late lol

[@tristajohnson8838]

God I love him, his videos help me get through the worst days.

[@wightspider]

His Metamorphosis is now complete. Matthew Santoro v2.0 is live.

[@SaviorUchiha]

The king is back! I'm glad to see he's doing good.

[@RoswellContinuum]

You know, it’s been years since I watched this man’s content, and he has not changed a bit. Love you Matt, you’re amazing

[@deathlymelody5932]

IVE MISSED YOUR VIDEOS!!! So glad you are alright! What you went through was terrible, and glad to see you are back, you sound and look happier!

[@daburgerbandit1598]

Lol, I was NOT ready for that intro... Heart attack intensifies.

[@000ZeroDelta]

He lives. I didn't realize how much I missed this channel.

[@4mbersmith]

I’m not easily scared. But that sort of intro UNSETTLES me to my soul 😫

[@le_emo_tac0]

I'm honestly so happy to see this type of video. This is what I would BINGE when I found you years ago amd I've been in love with your content ever since. When you said you were tired of making list content I respected it and still supported you and your content, but I'm not going to lie amd say I'm not beyond excited to watch another creepy list video of yours!! Honestly best person I've found on youtube who makes videos like this. Everyone else is monotone and boring. They're all the same. You're interesting, fun, and unique!!

[@bxnsheesh]

Hope your doing absolutely amazing. You made my childhood a whole lot easier and better, thank you so much for that Matt

[@LaviUSAGI1234]

the scariest creepypasta is Matt himself!!

[@spm_maverick1958]

The king is back!!

[@scarletassassin523]

Not king Emperor

[@pugphone2313]

Santoro: my channel is changing forever. Santoro 7 months later: *CREEPYPASTAS THAT WILL KEEP YOU AWAKE IN 2021*

[@koan__23]

Half of these were rather confusing... But that last one was thrilling wow.

[@gloriouslyaesthetic]

The first three were hot garbage of stories

[@roxieblaze73]

Matthew santoro i am so happy you're back. You have no idea how much your videos make my day i enjoy listening to them and watching them and i get a good laugh out please dont ever stop doing what you love because we missed you dearly and im so glad your doing better you're an inspiration to us all we love you.

[@peanutsans6780]

A warm welcome back from me for the smoothest egg in the carton.

[@raymondscott6269]

As a Supernatural fan, I can't get over Uncle Matt's demonic eyes! They're so well done! :0

[@nicolegetschow50]

“If you cannot do great things, do small things in a great way.”- Napoleon Hill 😗

[@austinmckenna6912]

I’m glad the list videos are back. These are what I subscribed for.

[@ckja1994]

I missed seeing new content from Matt. Glad to see he's rocking and rollin again.