5 SCARIEST Creepypastas That Will Keep You Up At Night #2

[@MatthewSantoro]

*My longest video ever. Turn out the lights, sit back, and enjoy* 😉

[@jeembajoe]

Thx mate 🙂

[@fakeyoutube3187]

Glad you’re back Matt

[@Paul20661]

Yes haha it's 4AM for me :D 🇷🇴 Was about to go to sleep buuuuut okay gotta finish watching this before that :) Thanks Matt 🙃

[@dixiecobb9189]

Do you know what the next video will be about? Love your videos no matter if they are vids of facts or creepy stuff and everything in between. Just remember to take care of yourself and your mental health. You're an important person. So be stay safe and take care we your loyal fan base love you.

[@kerryann2041]

@@Paul20661 almost 2:30am for me.......enjoy! Sweet dreams for after 🤣

[@peterer567]

"Sometimes the monsters are the ones that raise you or love you the most, but it's up to you to let them in" Well said..

[@aaronatkinson177]

Deep

[@NinaRenateBertelsen-rv2zy]

Way Do Demons Need Permission To Enter You'r Home?

[@ogblackmomba]

That last one was emotional as heck, not even scary just, heartwarming

[@xG30xpwnz]

For real that was a feelpasta

[@MrProbeNWatch]

Honestly that line where she said, "you're made of stars kid" 🥺🥺🥺🥺

[@Masterr59]

Some better writing than 99% of movies made the last 5 years

[@Gerf.c5]

And dark

[@tonyping2262]

Yeah, that last one was really heart-warming

[@TenshoWasHere]

The last story wasn't scary, it was a mix of wholesome and sheer utter combination of the viewers crying

[@thatcoolguy6773]

It actually made me think about my life

[@PinkPanthress]

It was kind of overly melodramatic at certain points...

[@cherryfaith4877]

kak_has_eyes I agree it definitely wasn't scary, though it didn't make me cry either. I just thought it was a brilliant story... 🙂💖☮️

[@TwinShadow_Fox]

I won't lie, I shed a few tears on that last story. Even if it was over-embellished or something, I still felt it tugging a bit.

[@MataNui.]

There's a subcategory of creepypasta called feelspasta, this is probably one of them.

[@vidooksHD7]

As a professional creepypasta reader i can tell that the first one "The Seer Of Possibilities" is terrifying.

[@this_is_diamond_rot]

I've been on the Internet since i was 4 (2003) but somehow never caught onto creepypasta. I'm hearing a lot of this stuff for the first time.. and that's the first one that's actually SCARED me

[@gigagrave]

"You're made of stars, kid. Now go light up the world."

[@skelijohn11037]

Haha,no

[@2Ashawn]

That dope asf.

[@gabrieljohnson3885]

Dude if or whenever I make my dream of being a director true I'm buying the rights and making that movie.

[@cookiebot.]

Im going to remember those words forever

[@PixelsPolygonsNPetrichor]

Haha god joke

[@angrybirdsandwich2334]

The only thing creepy is how his teeth always look perfect.

[@RedTurtleneckYT]

Amen!

[@jckidd9269]

Yeah too perfect fr

[@rossmonwithaneaux8085]

Lolhaha....

[@woodafy]

I'm so jealous🙄

[@serenas8144]

Nice eyebrows, too. Lol

[@kamchaotic6225]

The last one made me cry more than scared. That was a beautiful story.

[@pvegabe1820]

Yea these stories made me feel something other then scared 🤧

[@bektasbirben6077]

Same

[@jeffzinn9933]

The No Sleep podcast did a amazing version of it for their Valentine’s Day episode a couple years back

[@isaaclee3271]

The last one was more of a feelspasta than a creepypasta

[@rayttt1889]

The last one is beautiful and sad but where does he get these stories from

[@nikkolewidrick4434]

That last one was kinda sweet. Makes you think about how your actions affect others. Sometimes when you’re in that state of depression, you feel alone but in reality you’re not. Your family and your future is always right there. I liked that one a lot.

[@panick_9550]

The one with the parasite making that guy living his life in fragments needs to be a movie or tv show that sounds awesome

[@trence5]

Only thing more terrifying - is how that sounds similar to frightening reality of alzheimers...

[@zerobolt9506]

Something like it happened on Dr Who

[@jennyb9065]

The Butterfly Effect, it's an older movie with a sort of similar premise. Closest thing I can think of. Edit: The writing of memories is what reminded me of it except in the movie it was old photos or home movies. Can't remember exactly, haven't watched that movie in a long time.

[@Subaru474]

Yep

[@CrownOfButch]

Sounds like The Click starring Adam Sandler.

[@braidygal]

The first one was creepy, the last one was a tearjerker!

[@kylecocciante4362]

Definitely, on both counts. For me, i was quite intrigued at that first story. I really liked how all these events both started and ended with Jack. Had he not done even one task, the whole chain would fall apart. It makes you wonder what would have happened if he lived those boing 85 years.

[@pvegabe1820]

@@kylecocciante4362 exactly 1st and last story were the best imo

[@BionikleFG]

@@pvegabe1820 my favorite was the shattered soul, it’s maybe the most unique story I’ve heard

[@tonyping2262]

The first one actually was kinda scary tbh

[@kylecocciante4362]

@@tonyping2262 To each their own.

[@Psych2go]

Keep up the good work!

[@Kuya_Yan_1234]

Wow psych2go! Uh... This is not a psike joke right?

[@________8553]

I did not expect you to be here

[@itz_mqcha_bear2167]

Psych2go watches Matthew Santoro? Best. Crossover. Ever.

[@thisisntmedicine4004]

OK you being here is unexpected

[@________8553]

@@thisisntmedicine4004 lol I was kinda happy to see them here

[@ellemarie9048]

I cannot be the only one who would be thrilled to sit down and have a conversation with him. That would be fun as heck

[@raisa_cherry35]

Yeah 😍

[@lilypolak]

I’d pay any amount for that

[@theuglybeing4673]

The nightmare bedtime stories

[@RookieCommentor]

Alright, I was expecting to be too scared to sleep. I just want a hug now.

[@ブラクマト]

“ hugs “🥰

[@vendettaknight104]

That last one wasn't scary; it was beautiful.

[@REALSTEELE5]

It’s scary because my father has actually gone through something like this (minus the suicidal tendencies) … it’s strange how something’s can seem coincidental but in reality it’s something more

[@BlankDragyn]

These stories are why my mom doesn't invite you over anymore, Uncle Matt.

[@asha_vere]

Lol

[@pundertalefan4391]

XD I think my mom would like him for it.

[@kaz3842]

Matt: "If you're watching alone at night and with the lights off, good" Me: *Immediately closed the windows and turned the lights on*

[@pengwing638]

🤣🤣🤣

[@maggiem6209]

I actually did the opposite. XDD

[@jakolisfinard6988]

I don’t know such weakness

[@pengwing638]

@@jakolisfinard6988 f off

[@maggiem6209]

@@pengwing638 I can't know the intended context of the statement, but I think it was meant to be funny or a friendly rib. I don't think it was meant to be derogatory.

[@operationagartha3097]

The last one seems like a feelspasta.

[@ericaevoy1]

RIGHT

[@katiewyvern7088]

Defo is a feelspasta 😭😭😭😭😭

[@joancastillon8261]

Yes...

[@rongabrielperalta5902]

That last one made me cry yo 😫 i could picture it being a great movie

[@PRDreams]

The last two for me. That grandson loved his grandpa so much he spent decades trying to help him.

[@KevinTan]

*Conspiracy Theory : We are in a separate timeline where Matthew is still making list videos..*

[@williamheinzman7910]

The last one wasn't creepy it was actually really sad

[@knightmarewarrior6669]

That last story was just insightful, and truly inspiring.

[@cactusman8980]

I'm a Cactus with no emotion other than hatred. Not anymore after that one.

[@Kuya_Yan_1234]

Agree i thought it was scary and beautiful tho but it's just simply beautiful!!!

[@miledhayek7005]

I listened to this story in detail a year ago on The Dark Somnium Channel. I highly recommend it to you. Very touching!!

[@LavenderRare]

I didnt think it was scary, it was beautiful

[@erinthedemonhog2090]

That story had such a happy ending

[@Boybones]

UNCLE MAT IS BACK WITH SOME MORE BED TIME STORRY

[@Boybones]

THANK YOU SO MUCH for harting this this means a lot 😀

[@Boybones]

🙄🙄🙄😲😲😲, thank you guys SO MUCH FOR 100 likes

[@theunforgiven5260]

Uncle Mat you’re scaring me

[@Boybones]

@@theunforgiven5260 Ikr there spoopy 😂

[@Boybones]

Could this comment reach 400 likes?

[@WSV125]

The last one wasn't creepy man, it was sad, you gonna make me cry

[@ninarenate5185]

GONNA MAKE ME CRY NOT GONNA GET ME CRY, LEARN HOW TO SPELL,

[@nataliagalindo4931]

@@ninarenate5185 dude chill

[@bobmunk8714]

@@ninarenate5185 what’s up with the agro

[@TheArchetype91]

The 2nd to last one was pretty sad too he thought the ambien he took would help him out but it just made everything way worse.

[@pathamilton1961]

@@ninarenate5185 calm down Jamal dont pull out the 9

[@xandosworld]

“Allie would have cheated on him and spent all of his money for 4 long years” ....oooohhh spooky !👻 Sounds like every girlfriend I ever had 😂 didn’t know my life was creepy pasta status.

[@deedecorte9448]

That last story made me cry. It was very heartwarming. Thanks Matt.

[@RyujinRoninReach]

I kinda feel bad that we inadvertently made Matthews channel into a horror channel Even though he pulls off the horror so well especially with these new edits

[@somerandomperson5473]

I don't think its completely horror but yeah he hasn't done a say happy video in a while

[@justaneditygangstar]

The vaccine one was like a week ago and that one was more hope inducing

[@BJJ5770]

What if...just hear me out...he likes it?

[@comradeabi8314]

Why would you feel bad it's great as it is

[@5192aaron]

"The mind of a Creepypasta writer can be demented and disturbing..." Hey! I resemble that remark!

[@jeffersondavis3217]

Lol

[@brian.phillips1985]

@@jeffersondavis3217 Funny that you laugh at that Jefferson.

[@5192aaron]

@@silviavallejo6873 I know what I said 😉

[@squeegiebeckenheim8476]

I swear I know what that quote is from, but it reminds me of Barry on American Dad- “Don’t lob factual statements about me as if they’re insults!”

[@alysiareid6659]

Can be a positive thing. I've been told I'm scary teddy bear. I think that's cool

[@hollerinannes7780]

That one story about being fragmented sounds more like a horror story based on Alzheimer’s or dementia.

[@jasmineedwards4328]

I felt sorry for him

[@Sumirevins]

True some ppl even faze out in 10 hours or so Imagine you can't even remember what u did 10 hours ago that's horrific than any story ever

[@cubonefan3]

It’s the Butterfly effect

[@angel6017]

Honestly I like the ending cause now he won't miss anything even tho he's seen it. But he doesn't care cause he actually gets to live his life now. 😁

[@suzukitaiga1140]

I could see it being a short film

[@gerardway302]

me who wakes up at 1AM and watches this with the lights off: Hhmm i shuld be good havent had a dream or nightmare in years anyways

[@jasonblade6157]

The first one is basically: Side Quests the Creepypasta

[@brandonchambers963]

“That soap you shower with? It’s sh*t. “ If I had a dollar for every time I’ve seen that ad....

[@thekommunistkrusader3921]

Still better than most ads

[@ericatheempress6698]

I read that in his voice, I know I wat h way too many youtube videos

[@brandonchambers963]

@@ericatheempress6698 same here lol. Starting to feel like I can say his lines with him

[@rastarappa2269]

@@thekommunistkrusader3921 yea

[@Tiger89Lilly]

Lucky you I've had 2 candy crush ads so far

[@Bigbilly-ms9bn]

Not gonna lie, that last one made me tear up a little bit.

[@NinaRenateBertelsen-rv2zy]

Agreed..😢😢

[@pinktokyo4104]

When we needed him the most He RETURNED

[@jamesthomson7551]

Matthew, this was a great compilation of creepypastas. You're reading some of the best creepypastas I've ever heard.

[@elissaenglish3604]

That last story really touched me. You never know what you have.

[@Sadistic_Bread]

Matthew Santoro: "Oh if you're watching this at night, you may want to rethink your choice" Also Matthew Santoro: "If you're watching this at night with lights off, gOoD"

[@-m7k0z7-9]

The old Mathew is back, KZbin's sole is back...

[@saeyoungchoi5986]

OMG I DODNT REALISE THIS WAS A RECENT VIDEO

[@teamkovi4144]

Soul* I’m sorry I know grammar police are terrible jus I don’t wanna think of yt having shoes..

[@xerkif889]

this man's beard is always on point

[@trudiesavage9511]

So are his teeth

[@blaizegottman4139]

I always have a thick beard myself

[@xerkif889]

@SparkSparkle ty

[@xconankunx4530]

Stubble on point.

[@ReBecca-rl4bi]

I’ve lost too many friends to suicide and have almost lost myself. The last one made me cry...made me think of my friend, made me think of my kids...

[@JAB_the_Tab]

My sincerest condolences.

[@ReBecca-rl4bi]

@@JAB_the_Tab thank you. It warms my heart to receive this even after I posted this months ago. Thank you very much ❤️

[@deckardkaine5368]

deep condolences, death is the worst.

[@juppiitterr]

so your telling me theres 30 year old people who had babies on youtube? kinda creepy man

[@shadoweyegamer2075]

@@juppiitterr So it's creepy to have children?

[@JustinPNG]

“Just go home the effects will go away within a few hours” Famous Last Words

[@randomvideosstudios4004]

Looks like Uncle Matt is back with the stories!

[@deshaunblackett4745]

Bedtime stories specifically

[@The.Tamayo]

Bingo!

[@alyceareese6941]

I don't mind I love story time with uncle Matt

[@DevilRayRex666]

OH YEAH!

[@syedshafiulhuda4951]

Yeahhhh baby!!!!!!!!!

[@kerryann2041]

Oooo I'm in bed all snug......rain pouring outside, perfect timing for some Creepypasta! Bring it on! Always a treat from Mr Santoro!

[@lilfetus5181]

Why did that last one make me tear up? It’s sounds like a movie.

[@katiewyvern7088]

So I'm not the only one?! 😭😭

[@darkrh5404]

Same I thought it was only me. Last one wasn’t scary I feel like the ending was kinda wholesome

[@rayttt1889]

Same it gave me the feels

[@RandomPerson-vq9kw]

YESSS bedtime stories! *looks at length* Almost thirty minutes of bed stories? Uncle Matt, truly I have been spoiled! XD

[@TheMrZensorin]

Let me get this right: Jack unplugged The laptop and was surprised IT diddn't GO off? IT is called a battery, Jack, and you just have been hacked.

[@Heartrose7]

Yes but smashing the LT like he does later and still getting msgs as if wasn't smashed proves there is something beyond hacking going on.

[@formless.chicken]

maybe matt meant to say computer

[@thetheatrekid7504]

“Brian felt the heat like never before...” *reeces ad*

[@odii_00]

I got the same ad lol

[@dyllanweed7366]

"If you're watching this with the light off, good" _Turns lights on IMMEADIATELY_

[@johnmivule-novabow8143]

_NAH I'm watching this with all the lights on and the sun is up_ jk nah, that's just my phone screen * turns down screen brightness *

[@entername6601]

I suggest u turn it back up mate.

[@jaclynnschaefer]

That last story made me tear up. That was a beautiful one.

[@hermabad5001]

The creepy pastas are backkk. Remember used to watch the old ones at night as a kid. Helped me fall asleep

[@amnplays3211]

Came back to this channel after a few years, nothing has changed. Thanks Matt.

[@AllisonWonderland626]

In a sense, I can almost relate to the Don't Let Them In story. My mom was and still is an avid alcoholic and for years she'd become belligerent psycho whenever she drank. There wasn't a dull moment when she didn't scream at my dad, my big sister, and me whenever she was intoxicated. But ever since she and my dad got divorced, things have somewhat gotten better. However, neither my dad nor my nor I have any idea where she is other than that she's possibly staying with a friend. I can only hope and pray that she's okay and that she gets the proper help that she needs

[@jimmyjeff1777]

I'm sorry you had do go through that I just hope she never hurt you physically

[@cainstone4039]

Man that first story was actually super good

[@kentucky_ken]

The second one was scary reality yet a sad one.

[@alexmarshall5672]

i haven't cried in close to 3 years, but that last one got me to choke up a bit.

[@Bixen_Bings]

YAY UNCLE MATT IS BACK this will surely be quite entertaining

[@FluffyDergGaming]

Honestly mate, your content was always getting better, slowly, but better, and this video is proof of that. Amazing editing, great quality, the stories were told in a way that makes them legitimately spooky. If you see this Matthew, keep it up, and don't be afraid to do longer videos, there's a lot of people, myself included, that like the lengthy videos. ❤️💚

[@Mysterious_Cat_Dragon]

The last one almost made me cry as it was the most beautiful I've ever heard

[@southerncharm8211]

That last one was a tearjerker. Beautiful, and wonderfully narrated. Thanks. (BTW: Glad to have you back!)

[@randomsurfer8865]

The first one a masterpiece, last one inspiring.

[@Waauugh]

Joke's on you, nerd, I watch this in the MORNING!

[@honeymokie]

SAMEEE

[@ethanfuggin]

Fun fact: everyone’s first til they refesh

[@Kat19760]

😆

[@Strugglebaddy616]

That intro scared the frickin bejeezus out of me

[@kerryann2041]

Haha me too! Wasnt expecting that! 🤣

[@pengwing638]

me too

[@MrPringlesish]

First time?

[@Strugglebaddy616]

@@MrPringlesish no, just a long time. :(

[@MrPringlesish]

@@Strugglebaddy616 Welcome back? If I can say that xd

[@itsarnoldbruh]

“Watching this late at night or with the lights off” The only time I ever watch your videos

[@flipkiller8521]

2nd story is scary AF. Even scarier than most stories.

[@ricojones856]

No mystic creature ever contacted me?...I guess I’m just built different.

[@jakiulalamkhan727]

Just use an antenna. Maybe you're having bad signal

[@RealCryptoTest]

Go to a Reddit video, find the Bigfoot in the comments, ask and he will contact.

[@PencilDrawing-enthusiast]

So about the distorted warning signals in the last video. I have theory, what if the caller is the father of the lady who died when the lady was very young, say the father was protective while alive. And since he died he lives on as warning calls to protect his daughter. Just a theory.

[@A_Frog]

Don’t worry frog will protect you from the scary Have a cookie 🍪

[@gracestaw9030]

is there a warm class of milk with the cookie with a sprinkle of poison

[@lunahetfield]

Thank u froggo

[@pundertalefan4391]

Thank you Mr. Frog. :03

[@A_Frog]

You’re welcome humans

[@thickthighlife]

Guess I can chill here for a bit

[@thesauce1537]

you haven’t popped out on my feed for like 8 years and THIS is what you pop out with?? not even mad

[@theonlynuk3912]

The last story is one a lot of people need to hear

[@ederpardo4694]

I remember when this guy wasn’t that dark

[@ahtngm8265]

Yeah, the reason I started watching him was that even his horror videos were funny. But I still love his videos anyway.

[@DeadInside-ew8qb]

KZbin does things to people

[@ThisWeirdWorldVids]

The Seer of Possibilities is my all time favorite pasta. i personally feel it gets way less attention than it gets, thank you for including it here.

[@kai-isnt-cool]

i forgot what the name of it was but i remember reading it years ago. it’s very well written.

[@dragonlord3537]

Now that intro was actually terrifying

[@Paul20661]

yup it sure was and it's 4am for me,was about to go to sleep now...

[@bigboyexpress6668]

Imagine living where it’s 4am and not 9pm. Bruh

[@jesslabrunette]

It’s 8 where im at. And yeah I’m gonna be scared cause it’s almost bed time for me....I’ll just hold on to my son or cat lol

[@AnnieBoBannie421]

Nah.....cringey and trying way too hard these days.....

[@putisiernie]

😱😱😱😱😱😱😱

[@the_blind_chick]

So happy to see Matt back & (hopefully) doing well that I am willingly watching ads all the way through so he gets whatever revenue that comes with that. It’s not much, but... it’s the thought that counts? Glad to see you again!

[@autumnrogers3817]

So glad your back online Matthew we all missed you! Can’t explain how happy I am to be watching your videos again!

[@L1GHTYTHING]

THE SERIES IS BACK BABY!

[@callerway7520]

If I Have A Nightmare Tonight. Matthew Has Clearly Done A Great Job

[@kalmahnalyd4615]

Man, the seer of possibilities is one of my all time favorite creepypasta!

[@uwuguy2673]

It feels like 2017 again and everything as okay in the world again. Thanks for everything, Matt! Keep it up and up!!

[@DoomSlayersPrincess]

That first one has me in goosebumps the ENTIRE TIME

[@IncriminatedAntelope]

*I literally can't look at the screen when you do your creepy pasta intro*

[@Kiterpuss]

Because creepy or epilepsy? Bc that flashing transition caught me off guard lol

[@IncriminatedAntelope]

@@Kiterpuss it disturbs me internally

[@mykaelnyx8821]

The number one story was the scary at all. Just listening to him talking about it made me cry a little, just like when I listened to it of the first time originally...

[@constell6214]

Honestly, the thing that stopped me from ending my life was the thought of how it would affect the people who rely on me. I'm glad to see that portrayed in a story. There are people who love you, no matter how few it feels, there's always someone.

[@rottinstien7629]

There are always wonderful people who will stick with you till the end. Be that type of person who will do the same.

[@snowdrop6046]

I found the last one heartwarming in a way like don't waist your life when there's others waiting just for you

[@badrudolph9447]

The story about the man with the high-speed mind, is exactly what Mayuri, does to Szayelaporro Granz, in bleach to defeat him.

[@radinkalappen551]

Audible. Hire this man, IMMEDIATELY!!!

[@Alchimexx]

As somebody with severe depression...that last story really got to me

[@nolancarlton683]

Man its been years now and you still got it

[@Dane_Luvs_You]

I've been missing these from you PLEASE KEEP THEM COMING!!!! PLEASE!!!!!

[@Dillpickle1997]

#1 honestly made me cry like a baby when I heard it. It's so amazing.

[@mccammster]

Me who can fall asleep easily and have no nightmares: *h a h*

[@livm8385]

Perfect timing. Its 9pm for me rn. Enjoy!

[@kerryann2041]

2:20 am for me ......I cant sleep! But definitely enjoying this distraction from Matthew! One of them nights....🙄

[@wtfaturkey6475]

I’m currently on a 24h shift I’m already up all night lol this is perfect! 👌

[@deppheadsunited2924]

Mat, I've been watching your channel for YEARS now and I've got to say that you are my absolute favorite youtuber ever! I am so glad your doing top 5 lists again keep up the great work!

[@nuggs5509]

This last one was so tragic but hopeful... I love it 😭❤️

[@chenlee9835]

The Shattered Life story - I thought it was a story of Alzheimer’s.

[@rimurutempest4945]

Same, that was what I was expecting too

[@chobitssofar]

same

[@vedanttaneja4428]

You dont live in the future in alzheimers

[@potatopotpie6108]

This is a new form of horror, more realistic so to speak. It’s nice, but terrifying

[@laurindascorgie716]

My newborn already keeps me up at night. Now this, double the fun! :D. But I love scary stuff. Thanks for this vid Matt!

[@kerryann2041]

Aww congratulations! 👶🍼. I love scary stuff too. Wild wind howling outside is the cherry on the cake whilst watching!😬🤣

[@pramusetyakanca1552]

The Seer story was the most sad. What had me in tears was Jack’s final reply to the Seer. “Thank you.”

[@RoslynnMckoy]

Great Video Matt haven't seen notifications for in a while and seen this on my suggestions click so quick. Last one was a tear jerker. Others gave chills