6 Choices We Regretted Immediately

[@outsidextra]

Here are the choices, decisions or key moments in games that the Outside Xbox and Outside Xtra team TOTALLY fluffed, and will regret forever. What do you think you got wrong? Let us know in the comments and enjoy!

[@BanishedFox]

My regret was in Witcher 3 with Keria Metz... decided to let her take that virus research off to the king - 40 hours playtime later find her being burnt on the stake in middle of Novigrad because of it! Was so tempted to try to go back to an old save xD

[@matthewhardwick8208]

What is this Fallout 5 Andy speaks of?

[@donovanwilson840]

Assassins creed origins fighting the phylakes with only melee weapons it took me forever to learn that wasn’t the best idea

[@anarchyantz1564]

Andy, Vault 34 was the original vault that the Boomers came from, the ones at Nellis Airforce base who REALLY love blowing things up. According to various sources inside the vault, the vault became far too crowded due to overpopulation. Foreseeing problems, the overseer had a remote link to the armory lock installed on his terminal, denying access. A group of residents demanded access to the armory, stating the right to defend themselves, which the overseer denied. Rioting broke out soon after, and the group who had demanded access to the armory stormed the exit and left the vault which were the Boomers which is backed up by the fact that Pearl possesses the key to a gun case located deep in Vault 34. this story. The main exit was then sealed and guards posted to prevent anyone else from leaving. Years later, the vault started to experience problems with the overpopulation (unsurprising), and the overseer proposed population control measures, which was another thing that irritated the residence (doing well so far isn't he?). This resulted in a portion attempting to overthrow the overseer which ended up badly when they unsuccessfully tried to storm the armory, damaging areas of the vault in the process. Unfortunately the most serious damage was to the reactor cooling vents as well as to the main computer systems and other infrastructure. The damaged reactor started leaking radioactive gases throughout the vault and attempts to repair the reactor failed trapping inside to either turn to Ghouls or die from the radiation. Be it from the attacks or by the Overseer deliberately the main exit could not be opened again, trapping the residents inside, their only hope being an automated unsealing of the vault in the near future or external intervention before they died from radiation poisoning. Which is the choice you make in the game. One of the very few quests with no karma good or bad. Given that the share croppers would simply go back to NCR territory (they weren't starving in the least thanks to NCR supplies) helping the vault residents would see to be the lesser of two evils as letting more radiation into the vault would lead to certain death for the remaining group trapped. Wish there were more you could get from this quest personally.

[@Crime_city.600]

Greet video lad keep up the good work.

[@Dans_TableTennis]

When i played a night in the woods and had that argument with the mum in game i genuinely called my mum after this happened in tears being like "mum i love you and i know i don't speak to you as much as i want to but im just so busy with work right now" and she just listened to this phone call surely thinking "is he on drugs?"

[@WingedEternitys]

Daniel Webster-hall I hope not. Because at some point you can’t do that anymore. “You will never love someone as much as you’ll miss them.”

[@speakertomeat]

NiTW is a game that moves a lot of stuff in some people (like me)

[@charadreemurr344]

@@WingedEternitys that is so true my grandfather died about 2 years ago,his second year dead is in 2 games

[@simple-commentator-not-rea7345]

Nothing like a well-written drama involving the character's relationship with his/her Mother to remind us how much we care about our parents

[@LadyBern]

This made me tear up. I'm always in contact (not contrast shirt for that typo) with my mom. Not so much lately because others have been running her ragged but we check in weekly at least. But when it came to my dad... we're both socially awkward and bad at talking so we talked very little. One day I decided to stop waiting for him to call me and began calling him every weekend instead. Our talks were short but they happened, this went on for 3 years. Then the cancer came. The last time I called him we didn't talk long, he sounded so weak and tired. I got to tell him I loved him. The next week he passed away 2 hours before my usual phone call time.

[@fora1924]

*Talks to a NPC and picks the rude dialogue* Me : Shouldn't have not said that I Should NOT have said that

[@TheVoidedRealm]

Me trying to flirt with Triss marigold *Ends up pissing her off* *Garalt confused mad look at the screen* me: DONT YOU DARE LOOK AT ME LIKE THAT YOUNG MAN, YOU SAID IT NOT ME !

[@MKUltaOfficial]

Unless you're playing a rude character

[@NO-fn6wy]

I LOADED A SAVE WHERE I HAD TO FAST TRAVEL AGAIN AND WALK TO MY DESTINATION CAUSE I CHOSE THE WRONG DIALOGUE OPTION WITH YENNEFER AND MESSED EVERYTHING UP

[@aviatorcap]

Playing any DA and you make a decision that loses you points with your LI

[@Alovatololo]

Is "shouldn't have not" some sort of regional saying?

[@trumpeterjen]

Sort of minor, but there's Team Flare grunt in Pokemon X&Y who says to you, "Oh, did you make it this far all on your own?" And if you say yes, she says, "So your Pokemon don't count for anything, huh?" Ouch.

[@crystalgemgirl731]

I'm never alone.

[@michealforguson5317]

The purple-haired scientist says that when you're storming their laboratory. I fell for that trap, too.

[@phantomnite]

Shes not a grunt, but yeah, lots of people fell for it. I did too

[@Twitchy_McExorcism]

Remember: Priscilla's soul can be used to make two unique weapons, and there's an achievement for getting every unique weapon in the game. This means that when someone says they've gotten all the achievements, they're saying "I killed Priscilla at least twice!"

[@themightymcb7310]

Priscilla is used to get two boss weapons, but only one comes from her boss soul, the scythe. Her dagger comes from chopping off her tail. Both are necessary for the Knight's Honor achievement. Sif, on the other hand, has THREE boss weapons that can be made from their soul: the cursed Greatsword of Artorias, the not cursed Greatsword of Artorias, and the Greatshield of Artorias. Sif is the only reason you need to go to ng++ to get the ds1 platinum.

[@ramrodbldm9876]

Learn what you're talking about before talking bozo. You don't need to kill her twice. You clearly never played or you would know that

[@RijaMo]

I reallly REALLY REALLY REALLY LOVE this format. Watching you guys talk without script is really fun to watch

[@liamc4514]

Completely agree

[@diredinosaus]

fully completely

[@takemetoyonk]

That's what I came to see! ♡ that's why I like show of the weekend and stuff

[@isabelkelly683]

Yeah definitely agreed!

[@randomusernameforchris3392]

Agreed

[@TvTrollByIvy]

"The Witcher 3": you think you're helping a innocent spirit to rest. But you actually just unleashed a plague wraith that spreads disease and death eveywhere she goes. That felt super nice.

[@waterbrash1]

Ivy is Dead thank god somebody mentioned this quest. The second I saw the title I thought about this. There’s a couple hints that the tree spirit is deceiving you and that it’s actually the evil spirit that was the Crones’ mother. But at the same time you know the Crones are evil and you have the option to save a spirit which saves the kids from the crookback bog from being eaten AND defy the Crones’ wishes. But then it turns out that the spirit went on to slaughter the entire village nearby which also had children and adults. Witcher 3 is crazy involved with all those morals and consequences. Such a damn good game..

[@StudlyFudd13]

That one almost tripped me up, but I felt so wrong about it that I just ended up killing the tree spirit just in case. Thank god I felt like it was right?

[@Kay-fu5fk]

Honestly I didn’t feel bad at all, they were all assholes, readily leaving their kids because they didn’t want to deal with them, knowing they would likely have a miserable end. The people are outright hostile to you, etc.

[@paranagram]

I think they're talking about the Tower full of rats quest you do for Keira, but I agree with you all about the whispering tree quest too... hardest decision for me in a game

[@StudlyFudd13]

@@paranagram Oh yeah the tower one was balls too :( God damn I got tricked so hard b y that ''innocent' spirit....

[@martinwettig]

I like how the whole team suddenly goes all personal and insecure when discussing difficult decision. A big compliment for the quest designers.

[@charonib]

I killed Toriel in my first play through of Undertale. I couldn’t figure out how to get her to be spared, and I remembered one of those frogs saying that you can get a monster spareable if you hurt them enough, so I gave her a couple whacks...then watched as I insta killed her after her health dropped to half. Then of course the double slap to the face by Flowey insulting her after it, then telling me my reset didn’t change the fact I’d done it.

[@XpLiZiTcOnTeNt7]

THANK YOU. Finally someone else killed her. I thought she was kidnapping me lol

[@greatwavefan397]

I'm so sorry for your loss.

[@charonib]

@@XpLiZiTcOnTeNt7 ...yeah, umm, my killing her was a mistake because I figured out fairly quickly that the point was to avoid killing, and I didn't want to hurt her.

[@KenjuKizawa]

@@XpLiZiTcOnTeNt7 In my defense I marathon played a few RPG maker horror games, one of them being Mogeko's Castle. I just assumed Undertale was a slow burner and would get some scary stuff soon. I get to Toriel knowing she was hiding some dark secret and...oops

[@taski1]

i did this too, but I blame pokemon logic

[@ThrottleKitty]

> Become Raider in Fallout 4 Nuka World > Preston Garvey stops talking to me > Immediately regret not becoming a raider sooner

[@ryanjoyce5171]

BUT THE SETTLEMENTS!!!

[@ThrottleKitty]

Have all been raided and/or turned into forced labor camps.

[@Gilhelmi]

Top easiest choices in games.

[@HandmadeGoose97]

Preston Garvey must have remembered that

[@swaggytoast2747]

at least it's not raining

[@zacharywestbrook6773]

Worst video game decision I ever made was in 'Superman 64'. I chose "New Game" instead of turning off the console.

[@TitoMcFadden]

The true worst decision in gaming

[@kallasantysanty6092]

No finishing it would be the worst ever :)

[@Colonel_Overkill]

@@kallasantysanty6092 that's actually not physically possible. Best I recall the tutorial was bugged and you couldn't even play the game proper. Lo and behold, the game bug that saved the human race by saving us from the horror of this hellspawn abomination of a game!!!

[@kallasantysanty6092]

So why do i see, every time this game is in some sort of a list, all the videos of later mission and glitches in them?? Someone did finish it or at least get to the later parts and that someone is a martyr and a saint and should get some sort of a memorial statue in the city (virtual one would be fine :)).

[@Colonel_Overkill]

@@kallasantysanty6092 to my knowledge the tutorial was broken and you couldn't get past it. If that isnt the case then whoever played through it is a pure masochist... I played (attempted) it and couldn't get through the tutorial personally when it came out. I may be scarred for life even so ...

[@crazigirl1011]

I wanted to get the bad ending in Bioshock 2, but I regretted having to harvest the little sisters because even if you only harvest the first one, the next two little sisters are super scared of you and my heart broke the entire time because they kept talking about how they wouldn't make me angry and I'm like "I'm not angry, I'm just a completionist and I am so sorry."

[@safilmullick7884]

I tried doing that on my second playthrough, harvested the first sister, insta-regretted that, reloaded my last save and got the good ending again. Saw the bad ending on KZbin later and god! That was bleak.

[@Zoe.m.]

@@safilmullick7884 i actually found through my no death run playthrough to have the best ending because I fully harvested a few little sisters at the beginning to help me through but felt so bad that I stopped and I ended up nvh with a mixed ending where she didn't kill her mother but there was also the choice to not become part of her so she'd be her own person. I always felt in the "good" ending that being harvested by her and becoming part of her felt wrong.

[@bradypermenter8761]

princessofthedeadsheep I’m not angry, I’m just an complitionnist

[@crazigirl1011]

@Safil Mullick They definitely go out of their way to make sure you feel like a terrible person for daring to kill these little girls who call you daddy.

[@kallasantysanty6092]

Yea her "dad" was watching the world tru her eyes and was always in her mind ... just imagine if she would ever want to go on a date or ... start a family. Creepy and disturbing.

[@nonchip]

what i never got about the reactor situation: why cant we just get the people out there and THEN shut it down. then they could just be living on the farms and everyone's happy.

[@yoahnoah9780]

Same ( I mean I agree I thought that too)

[@NotHarpoGroucho]

Yeah Fallout NV is great but in a few points just didn’t make sense. Like why would the Boomers just immediately let you into their base immediately and barely even question you?! Wtf?! After almost a century of being afraid of the outside world they just decide to let you in after literally outrunning artillery instead of shooting you on site with every gun they have, which was a lot. Kinda funny that the Boomers are from vault 34 so this point was kinda related.

[@bluebip9080]

Maybe you could only pick one choice on the computer?

[@nonchip]

@@bluebip9080 yeah that's exactly what it was, but that doesn't make sense ingame. why would someone make a button that says "shut down reactor or open door". that's like having a light switch to select between your lights in the bathroom or the sprinkler on your lawn.

[@bluebip9080]

@@nonchip True, true

[@noodlepudding3464]

A night in the woods is so relatable on many different levels, even down to the guilt. I, personally, felt guilty about becoming the third wheel on Gregg and Angus’s date night.

[@nickspencerfishingrodd2383]

that game drowned me in emotions. mostly disturbed for....you know.....the "hole" in the mine.....

[@MoonlitRose101]

Gregg rules ok Seriously though, that game was a fucking rollercoaster of emotion. I loved every minute of it.

[@Clem_momo]

@@MoonlitRose101 Gregg is a good boy

[@Sam-rx7cb]

The real social experiment of vault 34 was on the gamers that had to choose without knowing if it was the correct decision

[@ogdeily]

@Rus Lemus its vault tec, i'm guessing they wouldn't have cared if they killed some people for nothing, that's all they do

[@justanamezain3602]

@Rus Lemus You're assuming that the writer is serious. r/woooosh

[@christoforospaphitis4090]

On vault 34 i chose to save the dwellers, the farmers can relocate and shouldn't have set up camp in such a hostile environment in the first place

[@anthonycaruso1781]

@@christoforospaphitis4090 my thoughts exactly. I honestly can't see how not freeing them is anything short of murder. If they go out into the wasteland they at least have an equal chance at surviving as the farmers. Less, actually, as they have no top world experience; but everyone on both sides gets the opportunity to live on. If you leave them down there they die... A slow, awful death. All so some people up top don't have to go through the trouble of finding a new place to plant their mutfruit.

[@NotHarpoGroucho]

Wasn’t Vault 34 where the boomers came from? or whatever the guys at the air force base were named?

[@jonathansmith3098]

Not hugging Leonardo Da Vinci in Assassin's Creed 2

[@blastkila6780]

OH. YES. You my friend are welcome to my place anytime. I'm glad that somebody else has played that fucking game

[@hughwatkin2667]

Oi missed that on my first playthrough and I restarted the mission just for that

[@averyd1328]

Not doing any of the “push button during cutscene moments in Assassins creed 2” in general, but that one hurt the most

[@MumuInc]

@@hughwatkin2667 but you cant restart missions?

[@hughwatkin2667]

@@MumuInc I quit the mission before it ended then repayed

[@flibbernodgets7018]

7:26 When I played Prey, I saved every human I could. Even if they actively tried to kill me. I figured enough of their fates have been decided for them already, the least I could do was give them an opportunity to decide for themselves. The mimics certainly weren't interested in second chances. And then that ending. Hooo boy. Talk about casting new light on my previous choices. I know some people criticized it but it remains my second favorite video game ending, after Bastion, and for surprisingly similar reasons.

[@NathanWeeks]

Wait, there were people trapped in Vault 34? I just turned off the reactor ... I didn't ... I need to go, um, check on something.

[@Hungabrigoo]

Did you know that if you turn the reactor off, killing the dwellers then go back to the farm they will tell you that they are shutting the farm down because as it turns out it's not really important to the NCR anyway? Surprised so many people actually missed this little punch of extra regret.

[@knotgradaunknown7414]

The first time through vault 34 I shut down the reactor thinking that message was left years ago. It wasn't until second play through I realized how resent it had been active.

[@QwertyCaesar]

I figured that the entire situation was a gamble on whether or not those folks were even alive. After all, they could've been trapped in there decades ago. You're weighing saving people who might already be dead versus trying to preserve soil for growing crops that may have already been irreversibly ruined.

[@aWalkThroughLife]

I don't understand why you can't do both, save the people in the vault and shutdown the reactor. Switch the control over to the vault people, but tell them to switch it back over to you after they are out (or just go to the area where they are at and switch it back yourself. If you can't reach the area, then how would the vault people get out in the first place?) It seems like the equivalent of choosing whether or not to let the dog out of the house before you blow it up.

[@zackjohnson4957]

you're profile pic goes perfect with the comment XD

[@mitchtherevolution]

Anyone who let Wrex die in the first game should go back and start the whole Trilogy over.

[@JoeBuk724]

Yeah, how do you not reload? He missed out on so much during ME 3's Citadel dlc.

[@SpydersByte]

@mitchtherevolution right? I just made a comment blasting Mike for getting Wrex killed and then not reverting to a previous save. The fact that he just continued on with the entire series just blows my mind, especially because Wrex is an amazing character. The only way it could be any worse would be if it was Garrus taking that bullet to the dome.

[@mitchtherevolution]

@@SpydersByte Wrex, Garrus Liara n Tali all the way. The sequel crew just never lives up to the originals.

[@MikaruXDenka]

Yo, for real. I replayed half of ME2, because I made some super heavy mistakes and reloaded the entire last chapter of ME2, because I lost three of my crew. Like, loosing Wrex would be a no no for me. How can one do that...

[@MortSalazar]

That's exactly what i did, Wreav is a terrible leader xD

[@Mavericktravo]

Fable II In the end, you make a choice between "The Needs of the Many" which resurrects all of the townspeople and they build you a statue, "The Needs of the Few" which resurrects your family and your dog, and "The Needs of the One" which nets you a lot of gold. In my first play through, I selected the Needs of the Many. It was not an immediate regret, but when I found the grave of the dog at the top of that hill where he died? i lost it. Ugly cried myself to sleep that night. I miss you, Shoehorn.

[@TheRealStoneyGames]

The correct answer is obviously needs of the few, all those dead workers will understand bc ur dog is too precious to die

[@msflibble09]

Same. I let the dude monologue for so long that Stephen Fry killed him, and then I chose the needs of the many. I saw my dog's location marker on the map afterward and ran toward it and...yeah. 0/10 would not chose again.

[@despacitochips2619]

I chose that too

[@imperiallarch7610]

Needs of the Many is a crazy nightmare scenario. Imagine your spouse died ten years ago during the rise of the evil overlord. Times were hard. But in the years since you've rebuilt your life, met someone new, started a new family. And then one day, unannounced, some asshole wishes everyone who has died in the last ten years back to life. (Except for their own family, for... reasons I can't remember that probably never made any sense.) Your recently-resurrected ex is confused and distraught to find that you've moved on when for them no time has passed. It's damaging your relationship with your current family. But you can't turn them away, can you? You inherited all their stuff, they've lost everything, they have nowhere else to go. And it's not just you, this is happening to everyone, all over the country. It likely leads to widespread civil unrest as the dispossessed recently dead organize to fight for their rights to property and titles that they lost when they died. And it's all because some jackass wanted to make a "helpful" wish but couldn't take thirty seconds to think it through.

[@MatrixMiles17]

Always your family. Needs of the few, remember that.

[@mvs109]

The thing I regret most doing in a game: I was playing AC Black Flag and had collected a bunch of materials. So I started crafting a few outfits I didn't have yet, one of them being the leopard cat outfit I absolutely didn't like, but I wanted the bunch to be complete. However I somehow got caught in a cutscene followed by a mission where it was not possible to change clothing so I was stuck with Edward in that stupid Leopard constume for the whole duration of the game. I absolutely regretted crafting that.

[@merceralex1935]

Stoopid

[@maestrofeli4259]

you coul've just crafted it and equip something else lol

[@nashvontookus7451]

Hey, I liked that outfit

[@kieranhair37]

@@maestrofeli4259 Yeah, this either didn't happen or they just forgot how the game mechanics worked. I cannot remember for the life of me a part where you'd equip this costume and irreparably be stuck with it for the rest of the game. There are definitely a few back to back missions at the end. But, as with literally every game in this franchise, it's pretty obvious when they're coming up.

[@maestrofeli4259]

@@kieranhair37 so weird how some people just make up stories for no reason, specially in the internet💀 (not saying the story is false, just talking abt it)

[@ChaunceyS]

This might sounds crazy, but: Animal Crossing. Whenever I build up a friendship with one of my villagers and then I get busy with real world stuff, and I come back and they’re either super upset that I’ve been gone for so long or they’ve moved away and I never got the chance to say goodbye T.T

[@OpaqueDreamer]

Yes! Animal Crossing punishes you pretty harshly for not playing. It sucks when a sweet neighbor moves away.

[@ChaunceyS]

Oh, it’s the worst! I always feel so bad and I want to reset the clock to when they were back in the town, but it doesn’t work that way :/

[@SoulKrosis]

I'm still upset about Apollo and Ozzie moving out of my town... and that was almost 3 years ago!

[@lux0rd01]

Dear god yes. I'm afraid to open my new leaf game for that exact reason! I can't lose Lilly!

[@r.j.penfold]

Now I'm never playing Animal Crossing. My mentally unstable mind couldn't handle digital people mad at me, nvm real world people!

[@Mocityspirit]

A Night in the Woods came out on my birthday in 2017. It also happened to be nearly the first anniversary of losing my own mother. So, as you can guess, this game is incredibly special to me. I did everything my virtual cat mom asked me to do and spent AS MUCH of the game having those conversations as possible. A Night in the Woods is an incredible game.

[@scarecrowlego884]

Damn bruh sorry to hear

[@KusagariBlues]

Mocityspirit Thanks for spoiling the game. Dick.

[@someabominationfromanother3190]

@@KusagariBlues what? What did he spoiled? Having a virtual mother?

[@brnk2]

@@KusagariBlues the mom doesn't die in the game. He just means he wants to spend time with his "mother".

[@YoruuXD]

Kusagari Blues They were saying their mum died. What’s your issue, dude?

[@maxlittlewood]

I remember playing mass effect and loving Wrex so much and then I got all the dialogue options wrong and Ashley shot him...insta reloaded a save, even though it was an hour before

[@ZackTheThunderking]

Screw Ashley

[@therealsulaco]

Good call. Even though I renegade sometimes I play a real "No one left behind!" kind of Shep.

[@cphtfluke7565]

I just went straight paragon conversation options and talked Wrex down on the first try. This is the first I'm hearing of Wrex dying ever.

[@viprthered]

I had to do two hours

[@BlazeSLK]

ZackTheThunderking exactly 😉

[@freddierhodes8201]

My biggest regret is from Become Human: Detroit. Not going to save those guys in Jericho, and then realising that they were my friends, not just random people. And then going on a violent rampage...

[@BabyKrogan]

Those vault 34 people bullied Chris Haversam so much that he thought he was a ghoul and ran away. He was the only one keeping that reactor stable so they got what was coming to them.

[@the_grim_gamer3039]

Yeah true but it might have only been some of them not everyone in a group is bad

[@the_grim_gamer3039]

Wrong crowd maybe but not necessarily bad

[@shannonrose4842]

thay all deserve to die a slow death ahahahah when I play fallout new vegas im very evil! >:D

[@asdertgasdfg5257]

Vault 34 housed Cris haversam, the boomers and the small group of survivers and gouls. I believe the lore says the gouls were the ones who bullied haversam after the boomers left, causing haversam to leave and then the reactor having a melt down

[@RubberyCat]

I think that reactor thing is damned bloody nonsense! I mean, first let them out ... and _THEN_ *SHUT THE DAMNED THING OFF ONCE THEY'RE FREE* !!!! Howcome the shit is either/or? It makes no damned sense !

[@nauscakes1868]

I recently discovered Prey, and beat it twice. Something I noticed was that the Criminal Profile in front of Aaron Ingram is NOT for him. It's actually the profile of the 'chef.' But most people don't actually read all the numbers and match them correctly.

[@b1battledroid179]

Then why did he admit to taking the kids to a "better" place.

[@roykong7024]

@@b1battledroid179 He probably broke the law saving children, and they set it up so that it would tell you that he's child trafficker, and he would think that you were reading about some other thing he did, that was not related to child-trafficking. If you choose to kill him, you essentially git played and tricked into killing a most likely innocent hero that saved kids.

[@roykong7024]

Me personally, I felt that the decision I had was fucked to begin with. Such an unethical organization, giving someone as unqualified as me to judge a person to death? When I have never even met him? Yeah no, that's not my place to be so self-righteous.

[@vladdracul5072]

@@roykong7024 As you will find out you, as one of the CEOs of that organization, have been responsible for many of those "unethical" decisions. So why change now? Just continue the experiment with the test subject as planned.

[@roykong7024]

@@vladdracul5072 Because your character obviously cares to some degree about ethics and morality. I agree with you on how it's kinda dumb for her to only consider the repercussions only this late, when she was supporting them for so long already. She is either willfully ignorant, or genuinely developing a conscience, just because it's her getting put in harm's way. Both situations are really fucked, so essentially you can either choose to continue to be a corporate slave and continue to experiments. Or you can follow through with your re-awakened sense of virtue.

[@Starcrash6984]

Papers, Please leaves you with all kinds of choices that you'll immediately regret, no matter what you choose. For example, there's a spy who wants to get someone through your post and leaves you cryptic messages so you can figure out who the person is that you're meant to let through illegally. If you choose to help the spy, you'll get rewarded for betraying your country by being corrupt at your job. If you don't help, the spy keeps harassing you over and over again with new targets, expressing disappointment in you every time and never rewarding you though you're on the edge of homelessness and starvation.

[@ped3752]

To be honest the country of Papers, Please is a pretty fucked one, betraying your country is the best option

[@ArtyoumPlays]

@@ped3752 Only cuz its written that way. Most people in real life would have absolutely no way out

[@JohnSmith-ox3gy]

Arty the Great Yeah, escaping definately not East-Berling wasn't the easiest feat. Desperate people died trying and those who managed to escape lost their family and friends untill the wall was collapsed.

[@freindmaker4473]

HELP THE SPY BOIIII

[@bluechord2928]

the worst choices are the various women in need. There is one who is trying to escape sex trafficking but her papers are wrong, I sat there for a good five minutes and wore down the clock trying to work out what to do. Another time a man crosses through with no trouble and mentions that his wife is after him but her papers are wrong. Same issue

[@Jackaxed]

lol the argument with mae's mom is an unavoidable story point that happens no matter what choice you make. the entire point of it is that the tensions that have been building up between mae and her mom finally boil over and the mom tells you what she REALLY thinks of mae dropping out of college. then later on she and mae apologize to each other and the mom says "i don't want us to stop talking to each other."

[@Redmanticore]

though i have a feeling, that if mae would stay hanging out at the house for too long, like for years, the mom would get bitter and angry again.

[@naomigreen9749]

I think she acknowledged that but it was about living every moment in the present, and making the most of it with the people you love while you can. The argument I have with dad tomorrow doesn't invalidate the time we spent together yesterday. I will never be able to speak to my grandparents again and that wouldn't be different even if I spent more time with them, but how valuable would it be just to have more good memories of them anyway?

[@mynamesjeffe782]

Fallout 3 when you convince Moira Brown to give up on her dreams with the wasteland survival guide, you get a good bonus but shes super depressed the rest of the game. Immediately went back to my last save.

[@ElMarcoHoJ]

Oasis. Set Harold on fire immediately to get the quest's achievement instantly. Felt horrible and did it the right way soon after.

[@adamgronvold8608]

I don't regret that at all. She was annoying and needed her dreams destroyed.

[@aguycalledjamal]

Adam Gronvold if that doesn’t make you feel bad for Moira then watch manyatruenerds fallout 3 kill everything series that will surely make you laugh and cry for moira

[@Oddballkane]

Some people destroyed megaton to kill her. Only she survives as a goul.

[@Alsebra]

​@@adamgronvold8608, let me guess...as soon as you and Sticky got outside Little Lamplight, you domed him.

[@boxtupos7718]

Canonically Selina wouldn't hesitate on saving Bruce. They even kind of got married recently, but Bane orchestrated some convoluted plan to not let than happen. She was willing to fight Thalia to the death for Bruce.

[@chriswilder9719]

I'm so glad someone pointed this out. She would have left the money and saved Bruce in an instant

[@chriswilder9719]

@Miss Misery Never in an obvious situation where if she doesn't do something he dies. Leaving him to fight goons or a villain is different than looking at a live video of him being trapped/crushed under concrete

[@Veladus]

This. I hate Batman, and I'd leave his whiny emo furry ass there to die every time and laugh while I do it. But if you think it's in character for Selina to do that, you don't know shit about Flying Rodent Man. Even the few times I've seen her betray him, like in Injustice, she thinks she's doing it for his own good rather than her own gain.

[@annana6098]

@@chriswilder9719 I think it's definitely in-character for her to try to talk herself out of it, but she'd always make up her mind to save him. She knows she couldn't live with herself if she let him die when she could have helped.

[@sapphiresupernova]

Exactly! I was even saying, "In the comics she would have saved him." Poison Ivy and Penguin, maybe. But not Catwoman, Riddler, or even the Joker.

[@darqjade]

Playing Heavy Rain: When I shot the religious guy to save that asshat of a partner I had. He was only reaching for his crucifix. I literally froze afterwards and felt so bad about what I had done, but I honestly thought he was reaching for a weapon. It's still one of the 'realest' moments I've ever had playing a video game.

[@skimaskedabi]

Did you get the "aquitted" trophy? (Never played the game myself)

[@darqjade]

@@skimaskedabi I just checked and I don't see Acquitted as a trophy. What do you get that one for?

[@skimaskedabi]

@@darqjade it was a dark joke about American police violence

[@corywertz9268]

I killed him too, but he was already holding the gun and pointing it at the cop. Though I didn't regret it, I did want to see what happened if that prick got killed.

[@Heavysweating]

Oh, so you Woolie'd

[@matthewsnow6004]

I remember when i played Portal 2 for the first time I got to where you are trying to escape Glados's death machines and she opens a optional path to the "final stage" with the "exit". I wasn't really paying attention, i saw a path, ignored Weatley's "HA, we won't fall for that" and "wait! what are you doing?!", and deliberately went into the trap where i was gassed with a deadly nuerotoxin....i felt so stupid from there on

[@Starfloofle]

Don't you get an achievement for that too? LOL

[@viridianfox6172]

Thanks for the feels Jane. Not going to lie, I teared up with the fight in A Night in the Woods. My mom is pretty much all I have right now, and I just really empathized with the emotions there. And it hurt

[@willhuey4891]

my mom is also all i have as well but my dad didnt die he walked out on me and my brother years ago.

[@fab.912]

Actually, in Night in the Woods that specific conversation happens regardless of you visiting your mother or not at the church. That specific dialogue has repercussions later in the game that build upon Mae and her mother's relationship. So yes, it's meant to happen. And yes, regardless of you not talking to her or talking to her it makes you feel bad. I just can't go through this game without talking to her, i feel bad if i don't...even if she is mad at me

[@2013Fangirl]

I really want to buy this game but can't find a physical copy. If I buy it from the PlayStation Store, does that mean I'll have the Weird Autumn edition? I just want the full game

[@Cool_Calm_Cam]

The Weird Autumn Edition is the full game plus some extras! So yeah, that's the full version.

[@2013Fangirl]

@@Cool_Calm_Cam Thank you. That's what I was hoping for

[@th3mdt]

I was just about to say that.

[@yellowfruit2397]

I fucking love nitw. I NEED MORE. im pretty sure yall agree with me if i say we need a sequel, or at least a sister game that is in the same universe / art style

[@VesperLilly]

"They're fools, you should eat them." Thanks for the great advice.

[@crazylasagna3576]

Whenever I get a moral choice I usually pick the trusting option since I can usually kick their ass if they betray me.

[@MidwestArtMan]

Not killing Lady Boyle in Dishonored. The creepy dude says, “She’ll learn to love me. After all, she’ll have her whole life.” Then he slowly sails away, staring straight into your soul and I ask myself, “Am I a bad person?”

[@austinshoupe1506]

The writers have sense expressed remorse at writing it that way.

[@jesseclark7105]

I remember that. Not like the fate of the guys at the Golden Cat was any better if you spare them. They get their tongues cut out and have to work as slaves for the rest of their lives, I believe.

[@GrassPokeKing]

The Pendleton brothers deserve what they got, if you spare them, whereas Lady Boyle... not so much? If I'm remembering it right. All she really does is give her boyfriend money so he can help overthrow the Regent, I think.

[@respectableaf9061]

I've played that game 4 times... I always spare her. I find it funny. Yes I am a bad person.

[@EGRJ]

All the "Low Chaos" choices are like that.

[@NapalmX717]

Killing Myla in 'Hollow Knight'. Biggest regret I've made.

[@Hermitstatus]

I had a similar heart break at that moment. I lingered over her body for a solid 10 seconds, and then I took a break from the game.

[@IronianKnight]

Yeah that's a tough one because you don't even know if the infection will be cured in overrun individuals after the end of the game. Maybe the ones that weren't already dead wake up and are okay. But maybe they're already too far gone, and leaving them there is just prolonging their suffering. Infection goo is known to be very hot, so imagine the few tatters of your awareness experiencing the agony of boiling slime in your veins while your body moves around on nothing but feral instincts and hostility for life. It's Myla still fresh enough to live after the fact? You don't know. There's no clear correct course here. Hollow Knight does this kind of thing a lot, and I think that makes it a superior moral game, since you don't really get rewarded for choosing one path over the other in most cases.

[@NapalmX717]

@@IronianKnight That's what I love about the game. Whether you feel like you made the right choice or not won't affect the game at all. You just move on with the main goal. I like to think that I eased Myla of her suffering instead of having her continuously dig that tunnel in agony under that infection to the point that she works herself to death. She was too precious to be remain in a world like Hollownest.

[@birchboom1888]

Oh gosh, Myla. She is too good for that world. I found out that she would attack you if you went her near her, so I just never went to the Crystal Mines again.

[@arthyem21320]

Stop it, I can still hear her distress scream T-T

[@south9713]

I had lost my mother a few years ago and now whenever there is a motherly figure in a piece of media I always become extremely attached to her and in games I always make sure that she is always happy and stuff because I didn't do that all that well to my mom and I feel like anything even a character feeling well makes me a bit happier I'm seventeen now and I wouldn't even be ashamed to have my mother sing me to sleep or to be tucked in or anything like that idk. Just make sure to tell your mom you lover her every chance you get even when you are mad at her cause you never know when you are gonna lose her

[@ellbent]

South Downie I’m sorry about your mother.

[@stevenbrace8579]

My mother just passed away on Oct 4th. She made a lot of mistakes, but I always made sure she knew that I knew how much she cared about us (her children) I’m sure you do every day. But pray to her. Tell her you always loved her. She’s listening.

[@emmafrey2626]

I'm sorry. So ur attached to Toriel?

[@lunarmist8330]

**NEVER** do genocide run in Undertale. Just, don't.

[@emmafrey2626]

@@lunarmist8330 I actually made a new account for my geno runs on Nintendo Switch 🤣🤣🤣

[@charlescannon2469]

Friend watching me play soulsborne: Why do you wait so long to attack enemies. Few minutes later: Whoa she gives you stuff? That's not an enemy?

[@michealforguson5317]

The first NPC I killed on accident in Dark Souls 2 was Lonesome Gavlan. First found in No Man's Wharf, I was a bit surprised to see him as he was near two other enemies that were keen on murderizing me. So like an idiot, I attacked him. He didn't start fighting back until after a few hits. Confusion soon turned into fear. After that, I had this bad taste in my mouth, like I did something horribly wrong but couldn't put my finger on it. I eventually learned that he was an NPC and therefore non-hostile. And also I locked myself out of being able to sell anything I didn't want. Moral of the story? When you play Dark Souls, it's easy to perceive anything as a threat to your life.

[@TheVergile]

"yeah, she knows that - she is up on the lingo" ...meanwhile said character: "what seekest thou?"

[@lionelrowe617]

Actually I think that example's grammatical enough, just a word-order variation on "What dost thou seek". But "If thou seekest I, thine desires shall be requited not" is complete grammatical garbage... It's like saying "If you're looking for I". Also "thine" is only used as a possessive pronoun or before a vowel, so "thine desires" should be "thy desires".

[@cediviannareeda4305]

"one of us thou art not" 'nah, soz'

[@TheGauges420]

@@lionelrowe617 what the fuck do you mean? You do realize not all things said in the past make sense in the present right? I mean to be fair we have a completely different way of speaking today. 'If thou seekest I' would be correct, because they didn't use the word me in those times, so I don't get how *you* could possibly make it any more correct. And furthermore, the original comment had NOTHING to do with the grammar, just poking fun at Luke because he says 'she's up in the lingo' when she's clearly not by the way she speaks. Don't be such a fucking twit.

[@jessicalee333]

@@TheGauges420 "Me" comes from Middle English, which is the language they're attempting (badly), and before that Old English, they did use it in "those times". It's from a Japanese developer, and it's a fictional world, but it's still incorrect in real-world Middle English. Her dialogue is nonsense, grammatically. You're probably right that he was missing the joke. But you're wrong about the rest.

[@GBfanatic15]

that one about a night in the woods actually made me cry so thanks for that

[@AnonymousFrogNG]

Made you cry 7 months ahead of time?

[@juliawasthere]

the one thing i regret the most that i will never forget is probably killing toriel in undertale bECAUSE I’M AN IDIOT AND I HAD NO IDEA YOU COULD SPARE HER so i got to live with that guilt for the rest of my life lol

[@GonmasVT]

I killed her first time around and then remembered what the frogs say so I reloaded and spared her. Flowey just came to taunt me afterwards for that..

[@lunarmist8330]

@@GonmasVT Flowey is kinda a jerk tho

[@spoon093]

I never got past the point when flowey called me out

[@grezledragon]

My friend and I made that exact same mistake on our first playthrough; we even tried sparing her a few times but it didnt seem to do anything so we committed. still feel bad remembering sans mention it vaguely in the neutral ending; hurts a lot more than being called out directly lmao

[@sapphiresupernova]

ME TOO I KILLED HER IN THE FIRST PLAYTHROUGH BECAUSE I DIDN'T KNOW

[@katfromthekong414]

Just to solve the mystery for Andy: The correct choice would have been to safe the people in the vault. If you save the vault 34 dwellers, the sharecroppers will just move back to California and no one dies (or has to live out their lives in a vault). The vault dwellers also give you items from time to time if you let them out, sooo........

[@Darthtanos]

it actually dooms a number of the NCR camps if you do that. there are no other farms in the area, and no where else has the necessary water to replace them... so in essence you doom the entire area long term with that decision. >_>

[@quinnbell2388]

I can't quite say that is was regretted, but it was certainly the most poignant. KOTOR II, a random homeless guy walks up to me and asks for some money. I'm playing a good guy Jedi, so of course I give him a hefty sum. My mentor, Kreia, asks why I did that, to which I explained that generosity is a "good" thing, and that I was helping him. As she starts explaining that blindly following this concept of "good" is hazardous, it cuts away to a scene where the guy I'd just given money is mugged and killed for it. Completely turned my 12 year old brain's conception of good and evil.

[@RuefulCenturion]

Kreia will criticize you, no matter your choice. No way to get ahead in life trying to please an evil, old lady.

[@Heartshapedbox81]

Darth "Treya" is cynical, hateful and full of s*** never listen to her. She literally lives in the gray area lol

[@chao807]

Well, she isn't wrong. Doing something good can lead to more bad than good and vice versa. The lesson that Kreia tries to teach is that there is NO good or bad, whether you are trying to help or not, your actions will have other effects. If you give the man some money, it seems like a good thing. But in actuality, it leads to the mans death. Kreia isn't about blindly following her, that wasn't her goal. The reason she was so "cynical" is to show you that nothing is as simple as good and bad. The Jedi vs the Sith, whichever side you are on, neither are completely good. The Sith aren't good for obvious reasons, The Jedi; however, would take children that show talent in the force to be trained as a Jedi without choice from either parent or child to be, depending on the era, training children to become soldiers. Other times in history, such as the Mandalorian Wars, the Jedi would refuse to help those suffering and forbade any to intervene. Those that ignored these orders were labelled as traitors. People ignoring an order so that they can help people, a good act, was met as if they were monsters by the Jedi. Another time, such as the Great Hyperspace War, after the Sith surrendered in defeat, the Jedi proceeded to murder every last one of them. I am ranting now, but my point is that Kreia's ultimate lesson to the Exile is that one good act does not lead to good things. Good does not equal good every time and labelling such things is futile. In the end, when you have power over another (like with the homeless man in question) whether you help or refuse, Power begets violence and misery. This is why Kreia sought to destroy the force. Would her actions lead to the deaths of many? Of course, but it would also save people just the same, her actions were not evil, but nor were they good. That is what she wanted to show. Don't ignore Kreia's teachings just for the sake of it, listen to them and act on your own will without thinking of "good" or "evil", weigh the results of the actions taken and live your life as you wish to. Do not just do something as it is a good thing, as it could just lead to much more suffering than what was previously at stake, no power over others is good, whatever the intentions. ~~Rant over :3 ~~

[@Heartshapedbox81]

@@chao807 that was a long rant lol, I'm aware of the Sith Jedi debate from a long amount of years of being a fan and obviously the Jedi are far from perfect which is depicted in said game so I don't disagree with it but I do disagree with her ideology nonetheless. And I was applying it to the real world not in regards to Star Wars, the people who try and paint everything as gray are usually the ones who are up to Shady things, power over others is weakness disguised as strength. So no I'm not saying blindly dictate people for the "greater good" I am however saying that there is good and there is evil and a lot of it is plain to see in those who are not lying to themselves but those who say gray area this gray area that are usually the ones who are just trying to get away with evil, if you have half a brain it shouldn't be a difficult task to figure out, not directing this at yourself but towards those who try to make excuses and call those of us who wish to do good weak or naive, my eyes have been open to a lot of the uglinest inside of this world, I don't see Gray but I do see lots of hideous secrets and lies in order to protect those who shouldn't be protected and keep people in power who also shouldn't be while stepping on the helpless so... maybe it's not different from the Star wars universe after all, but much like I hate when people act like there's no hope for Humanity and that all human beings are inherently evil I also hate when people purposefully make themselves ignorant just so they don't have to "see" between right and wrong.

[@Heartshapedbox81]

Side note: helping people doesn't make you weak, depending on the person / people it can make both of you stronger.

[@bg3929Z]

This episode had more of a 'documentary' feel, and it was very fresh and interesting. It really felt like I was getting a real glimpse behind the curtain, and it was more genuine than 90% of the youtube videos I've ever seen. Great job, guys. After this video and listening to your feelings behind the choices as well as what you learned, I really feel like I know you all just a little bit better. Thanks for this, and I wish you all success as the channel goes forward into the future -hopefully creating more videos like this as it does.

[@lifeincolour09]

+bg3929z They did another one like this some time ago but I don't remember what it was about.

[@myrojyn]

Show of the week/weekend are in this same vein

[@jojo_is_a_go5893]

I was thinking the same thing.

[@ironicdutchmoonshade]

In Dishonored, there is a mission where I had to kill lady Boyle, but there was an option to let her escape with a guy who claims to know her. Eventually, I led her into the basement and the game told me to knock her out, which I found really weird. Turned out that the guy I gave her to was her stalker. The problem is that I have no idea if she'd be better of dead or not. That one really made me think.

[@piotresoule6931]

She was better alive because she kills him and takes over his fortune

[@ML-dt2xe]

honestly i always thought that low chaos Corvo was motivated more by cruelty than mercy

[@734RECON]

All of the non-lethal approaches are designed to be fates worse than death. Take High Overseer Campbell, after he gets excommunicated and shunned from the order, you can find him later in the game as a Weeper. It’s a really interesting game when it comes to morality, as the arbitrarily ‘good’, ‘merciful’ decisions are often more cruel than the high-chaos alternatives.

[@GrimFaceHunter]

I think non-lethal approaches are there for "clean hands" challenge. And that is the point, those are "low chaos" - in Dishonored, that means suffer now or have live with you self for a greater reward later. I think game designers could have made so that some "good" actions lead to high chaos. And vice-versa.

[@Sylvirayne]

Iirc, you could kill all of your targets and still get the good ending. It was the number of people you killed that effected chaos, and you weren't punished for taking out a few as long as it wasn't a bloodbath.

[@themightymcb7310]

I think you still have that fight in Night In The Woods with your mom even if you go visit her at the church, but doing the church quest with her kind of repairs your relationship with her and brings you both closer together.

[@coltenhunter2000]

The last one brought back some memories. Always call your mom. My mom passed away and I wish I had called her more.

[@zencomeseasy602]

Same

[@rasseboi6611]

Haha lol

[@sleepergt2570]

@@rasseboi6611 your an asshole

[@sanji5262]

Sleeper GT no i

[@sanji5262]

oh no this is funny af

[@recklessrex]

Chooses a dialogue option "Nick Valentine disliked that" Oh god no I'm sorry oh my god I'm a terrible person please forgive me Nicky I'm sorry!

[@ceceliaacaba2739]

RecklessRex yep that’s me with Nick and Piper luckily I got their max affinity long ago

[@ItsMaffi]

"Nick Valentine hated that" - Alright, I am not worthy to live in this world anymore.

[@kallasantysanty6092]

Just take the dog, he likes everything you do :P

[@ethanhess8230]

But what if it’s “nick valentine disliked that” right above “Cait loved that” I would say Curie but she and nick don’t ever have conflicting opinions or ideals.

[@kallasantysanty6092]

Bots will be bots.

[@davidjames4890]

Night In The Woods needed some more appreciation, thanks!

[@prog7141]

David James Ye man but I hope it doesn’t get too popular because I really don’t want it to become like the Undertale, rick and morty and Steven universes fanbase.

[@hakasek4052]

I just hope people either stop making these ridiculous fanbase stereotypes or people stop actually believing them. Either would be fine by me but my god this is getting ridiculous. You're actually here hoping something you like doesn't become successful for fear of it having a fanbase.

[@prog7141]

Milo Keech I see you’ve not seen the fanbases. I think its the more popular something gets the worse the fandom becomes here’s why. For the most part the Undertale, rick and morty and Steven universe fan bases consist of normal reasonable people. But the parts of the fandom everyone talks about are of course the really reched, cruel and down right insane people. These people in the fandom overshadow the rest of the fandom which is why people consider them cancer. The reason you may get people like this in the fandom is because of how big it gets, that’s what all the cancerous fandoms have in common they are all really popular. Because of this the source material can reach these awful people there by overshadowing the others in the fandom there by making it cancer. I love night in the woods and really don’t want these types of people getting there hands on it.

[@vennril]

+Sans the Skeleton That's still childish, and I'll just repeat what Milo said: "You're actually here hoping something you like doesn't become successful for fear of it having a fanbase.".

[@pink1200]

+Sans the Skeleton I hope it becomes popular I just don't want it to become cancerous

[@ElSalsaRey]

Final Fantasy: Mystic Quest. Playing the game. Fire Emblem: Awakening. In the end you choose between killing the final boss and dying yourself, or letting your best friend/potential husband put the villain to sleep for 1000 years, but you live. Fire Emblem: Fates. Choosing any path but Birthright, because Birthright is the only path in which Corrin has a spine. Fire Emblem: Three Houses: Black Eagles route. Two key moments here: traveling with Edelgard to meet with her dad near the end of part one...and the end of the next battle, in which you have to choose between either your boss or your student. A decision made slightly more bitter if you listen to Edge of Dawn just before it, and realize just how conflicted Edelgard is as well. And it continues to get worse when you realize the connection between her and Lysithea and realize the Edelgard is not only conflicted, but has been completely and totally screwed over by life.

[@sugar-high_kitsune]

Oh! Fellow FE fan! I personally felt like shit when I told Chrom that we couldn't save Emmeryn and then I later found out that my choice there DIDN'T EVEN MATTER??? So, I was utterly heartless to my future husband, father of my children, for NO REASON. And I felt like garbage for it. xD

[@emmetr9405]

Great I came here to laugh internally, maybe awkwardly chuckle at the screen. I didn't realize I would end up in a great philosophical debate with my internal mind and thoughts, know I feel bad. Thanks Jane!

[@squeemlives]

I've never seen these guys before - they were all super sweet and I enjoyed this video a lot more than I expected. Subscriiibed.

[@WildfireMagni]

Yup, she'll do that. Also, welcome to the madness, Matt! Tinfoil hats are over there and do watch out for the space lasers. They're nasty this time of year.

[@jheckie14]

Just ignore the voices, that's what I do

[@immortalsun]

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

[@immortalsun]

This channel is really underrated.

[@Cunnysmythe]

The unscripted videos are the best ones Hearing everyone react to each other is even better

[@Tahsaray]

They sound like actual people with personalities like this.

[@brentage5000]

The first time I played Life is Strange (and Luke is already tearing up), I remember going into Kate's room to comfort her after seeing her get picked on in the bathroom (and I guess return her book, too). At the time, I hadn't realized how much stuff there was to view in the world, and I knew even less about the Bible, so I just looked at her family photos and the Bible verses and went on to play with Chloe (yay!). Once I was back at school, turns out someone's getting ready to jump off the dorm, and wouldn't you know -- it's sweet innocent Kate Marsh. Of course, my powers stop working, and since I don't know what the right bible verse is here and didn't answer her call earlier......she jumped. On subsequent playthroughs I was able to figure it out and save her, but that first time....I'm so sorry, Kate. Really.

[@GhostsGraveYT]

just a bad character in a bad game

[@dewoiski]

Me and my friend weren't able to save her! It's was so depressing!

[@Bookworm51485]

I don't think Catwoman canonically would have abandoned Batman. They have a relationship that's complicated, but I think both of them would save the other in that situation

[@adamweber1164]

Regarding the prisoner... *ahem* "volunteer" in Prey, if you pay close attention and remember the ID number from the file, you'll find out that that rap sheet doesn't belong to the man you can feed to mimics, but is actually a list of crimes commited by "the chef," the creepy dude who stalks you and sets recycler traps all over the station.

[@NisansaDdS]

Say whaaaat? :-O

[@Avigorus]

Okay, I have yet to play this game, but the wikia at least doesn't support this, it gives different numbers for the two characters... meh, I dunno, I need to get a copy of Prey already lol

[@imp360]

checked a video of the moment to double check and no it does not. the id in the report is v-090655-13 which you can confirm in this video is Aarons. Aaron even tries to justify the accounts of child trafficking clearly proving he knows exactly what it say's even though he can't actually see the rap sheet from his cell.

[@adamweber1164]

Huh, well, egg on my face. I could swear I remember that being a twist, but then again I haven't played Prey in a long time.

[@RuefulCenturion]

Am I the only one who released him, got the code, then shot him?

[@Null_And_Void]

My reasoning behind letting the mimics kill him was simple *I needed a large amount of exotic material for my neuromods*

[@RoastedLocust]

That's what I did. You can justify your actions by pretending you can save even more people with those neuromods.

[@TheFirstAifos]

In Bloodborne, there’s a woman named Arianna. Later in the game, the moon turns red, and Arianna becomes pregnant with Oedon’s (an invisible eldritch god-like creature) child. Eventually, the child is born as a hideous eldritch monster, and Arianna can be found crying in the sewers, as the child cries for her attention. Here you have a choice, kill the child, or let it live. This might not seem like much, the “let it live” must be the good choice, but killing it gets you one of the four Third Umbilical Cords, which you need to see the true ending. Plus, Oedon probably didn’t birth this thing with the best intentions in mind-could be a Dunwich Horror situation. I killed it, and Arianna let out a cry of pain, dying along with her child. I felt like a monster..

[@insaincaldo]

Well you are a hunter, but you are also confronted with the feeling more then once, maybe all this hunting isn't totally for the greater good. On top of that there are actually 4 cords around.

[@shizotypical]

Gascoigne's daughter situation is not much better. Never should've come back to her..

[@TheFirstAifos]

Ксения Старцева The only reason I’d say the choice with Arianna is better, at least in terms of “choices I regret” is because it was a conscious choice to do something I knew I’d regret (kil a newborn monster) rather than a bad ending with good intentions.

[@TheFirstAifos]

Chris East The “they used to be people” morality question never hit me that hard. We’re always fighting monsters who used to be people in games. I know there are 4 cords (I believe I even said there were) but getting Iosefka’s means missing out on a rune, while there’s no downside to killing Arianna’s child.

[@sophielarsen8146]

I remember my (adult) Older sister introduced me to Night in the Woods, Ever since I've always loved that game

[@rodrigocenteno9055]

Come on Luke we all know that your biggest regret is smack talking about Sniper Luigi in the early days before seeing what he can do. Sniper Luigi doesn't forget Sniper Luigi is always watching, waiting

[@lawrenceshammas3389]

I really like these confession-style videos (not that I don’t like the standard scripted videos I love them more than certain family members) but I think doing more of these would be great! But what does the opinion of an immortal time lord mean...?

[@vbgvbg1133]

Lawrence Shammas immortal time lord?

[@lawrenceshammas3389]

VbgVbg 113 ummmm... What?! Who said that?! You are?! I should be going now. Does anyone know what was in this exact spot in 1933?

[@mysteryman1036]

Last I checked, two wood boxes and an acre of grain. I mean... HOW WOULD I KNOW?!?!

[@r.j.penfold]

@@mysteryman1036 Really? I could have sworn it was a guy listening to Glenn Miller on the radio. Huh... I need to check something...

[@painkiller4240]

@@r.j.penfold Turns out ...that's where they buried my pet...

[@CheapGodiva]

"Are we still talking about a night in the woods?"

[@thenerdiestbear5403]

"Are we still talking about "A Night in the Woods"?" 🤣🤣

[@reduxThe1]

21:30 that appears to be real emotion. I think I subbed because of what seems to be an authentic emotion. Very hard to find on YT tbh. Call your mom, Jane.

[@aaroncid3643]

So here's an odd one, one time I was really immersed in to Saints Row 2 the last game of the saga when they try to actually take it seriously, so I was rolling around shooting people and running over them so I get to visit the college where I do the same things enjoying scaring of the crowds of people, until... a girl I was chasing actually surrender sits down on the floor hold her legs and start to cry, forgetting her survival and everything else because of the impotence... There I look the monster I was becoming and stop playing that way since then

[@loganrilling1448]

I wish you could tag ppl on youtube

[@PolarDove]

I have always killed Ashley, every single freaking time. I can't stand her and the choice to leave her there to go boom was an easy one, oh so very easy.

[@Veladus]

When ME1 was out, I wanted to save them both. After ME2 and ME3, I wanted an option to leave both of them holding the nuke. They're both just awful. But yeah, Ashhole is the worse of the two.

[@lucasaugsten]

I played once, didn't kill her because I didn't know it was a "choose who dies" scenario, and regreted it the whole rest of the trilogy. She is insufferable.

[@mckayleepugmire9947]

Yeah, I've never played Mass Effect, but dealing with the Space Racist sounds way worse than ignoring a boring character.

[@vladdracul5072]

@@mckayleepugmire9947 She's religious to boot, so the decision to leave her was indeed an easy one.

[@vladdracul5072]

And having her, the least likeable character, kill Wrex, the most likeable one, would have made it even easier. Fortunately that didn't happen because as usual I did the sidequests before the main quest.

[@feliciaeris7721]

"Luke the Heartless...Heartless man" after his sin confession made me thought "well i guess you kinda deserve to be called that" i mean...how could you kill her?! she already sounded so freaking sad

[@everettbyers9378]

Why couldn't you realistically release the vault people then shut down the reactor

[@simplysmiley4670]

Bethesda logic in a shell nut.

[@misablesk]

If I remember correctly, releasing them actually causes all the radiation to flood the fields.

[@ssgoko88]

I think it's cause you're giving control of the vault to a computer that nobody can access once they're out. The computer is not accessable when they escape

[@sirrealgaming6913]

Shut down the Reactor Blast a Hole in the Vault by shooting your way in

[@DiggyDougSauce94]

That thing that was built to withstand nuclear holocaust, just blast a hole into the side of?

[@sirrichiofawesome9617]

After first five reasons. “As expected, everyone had tough moral choices that were unclear at the time they made them, then instant and lifelong regret. Except Jane, who claims she made the right choice and only regret was the game over screen” after sixth reason. “Jane has a soul and I need to call my mum”

[@mp5wes]

From California and thank you for teaching me the word "row" (thought it was spelled "Rao"), didn't know what that meant (or existed) until Jane said it and looked it up. I like learning words and lingo from different parts of the world, cheers! 😀

[@jetpackcthulhu]

Leaving the barn in Red dead redemption is one for sure.

[@Poppi_QT]

Playing Jack is something I regret. Hopefully we won't have Morgan Jr. in RDR2.

[@jetpackcthulhu]

Be cool if Morgan died and then you are John again for endgame content.

[@Poppi_QT]

@@jetpackcthulhu Or you can just switch between both.

[@MrRafalel]

there's nothing after the barn. the game ends when you come back and live happily ever after with your family. I don't know what you're talking about

[@jetpackcthulhu]

Raffaele Macrì there is a secret ending where John is killed and you play as Jack for the rest.

[@jenxox5003]

If y’all want some regrettable choices play Detroit become human

[@Kk91st1]

Preeeeeeach

[@waterbrash1]

Witcher 3 as well. Game’s chock-full of tough moral decisions and Extremely Regrettable decisions/unintended consequences

[@nibwhipdragon]

Bro I unintentionally killed Kara and Alice at the end, and I haven't played it since

[@freddierhodes8201]

The worst part about that was the way there were no saves. So in Jericho during the ending, I didn't save people casue it looked dangeours and Conner wouldn't have respawend etc.... Only to find out that they were my friends all along. Needless to say, I burned that fucking city TO THE GROUND after that

[@NotHarpoGroucho]

person merc Can’t have shit in Detroit, you know that man

[@zoutig.4725]

>play skyrim for the first time >Do some random sidequests >sleep in game like a week later >Wake up in abandoned cottage not knowing its the start of the dark brotherhood questline >Kill the woman thus canceling the dark brotherhood questline >Rewrite old save

[@georgebush5588]

zoutig. You made the right choice the first time

[@simpleman4251]

I did the same!! Didnt know what was going on, thought it through and decided the person who was about to make me murder somebody was also probably the one most deserving of death. Killed Astrid and then realized my mistake, reloaded immediately lol

[@zoutig.4725]

@@simpleman4251 i couldnt reload anymore😥

[@simpleman4251]

@@zoutig.4725 D: oh no, what a cruel fate!

[@hieronymusnervig8712]

Just killed all 3 guys, seriously, if some crazy women tells me to kill some people in an RPG I just do it. No questions asked, no regrets just MORE BLOOD on my sword.

[@keithroderick5105]

A heartbreaking fight I’ve experienced is in Fire Emblem Warriors, there’s this friendly NPC character named Darios who’s prince of the enemy kingdom who chose to help your protagonists, who later gets captured and brainwashed, but you weaken him enough and he starts to break free, and asks you to kill him so the dragon who’s possessed him can’t get free, but your protagonists can’t bring themselves to kill him and dragon materializes and Darios sacrifices himself for you

[@RedHoodFH]

Surprised paying full price for battlefront 2 isnt on this list

[@oof9619]

Nice one xd

[@Jaeger_Bishop]

Nuclear burn!

[@donovanwilson840]

Title: 6 choices we regretted immediately Me: in live or in gaming. Either way that number should be A LOT higher

[@edmg7]

But this isn't a total, it's just a list of six

[@TheTopazChannel]

Skyrim: Killing Paarthurnax. The Wolf Among Us: Checking on Toad before checking on the prince.

[@ngastakvakis4425]

paarthurnax*

[@thaynede-barr6458]

i was waiting for someone to mention this

[@TheTopazChannel]

@@thaynede-barr6458 It didn't feel right and they don't exactly throw you a party afterwards.

[@proinsiascassidy2888]

But also: _> Glass him_

[@Animezingly]

At some point I was curious as to what happens after you kill him, but I never found out. I didn't like the blades just deciding to tell me what to do. To a dragon that had been nothing but nice as well. The only thing that makes me want to kill him is my anger at not being able to get that quest completed or failed or whatever. It's just sitting there. Ugh.

[@ella-strator2107]

“Princess Maker 2” is really easy to mess up.

[@CCSFM0110]

Literally. Every. Choice. In Detroit Become Human. Because I swear they designed it to where EVERYTHING has a consequence! Think you did good by saving Hank instead of shooting the Deviant? Well guess what, Connor's relationship with hank STILL goes down and they argue in the next chapter.

[@MuhammadRaiyan135]

HANKKKKKKKKKKKKK

[@fartmerchant762]

It's too bad the game was a PS4 exclusive, I was engrossed in the story even by just watching people play. I hated it when they were mean to Hank and the broship never evolved

[@Biodeamon]

hey guess what dumbass? EVERY choice in life comes at a cost. you can't have your cake and eat it too

[@AlexRango]

you mean the only choice you make in detroit become human witch is playing a david cage game *spoiler* it's a bad one

[@Joker-il8xr]

Caitlyn Coble SFM Lol True

[@sars910]

What about in Skyrim when you get a Dark Brotherhood contract to kill Alain Dufont, who robbed the Shatter-Shields and betrayed Muiri. You have to kill Alain but optionally can also kill the remaining Shatter-Shield sister for extra gold. Since I was hell-bent on completing all optional DB missions, I killed her. Then I found out that the matriarch of the Shatter-Shields commits suicide after losing her remaining daughter and I regretted my actions. I ruined a family already coping with the loss of one daughter just for some extra gold.

[@RuefulCenturion]

I would have expected better from Ser Davos Seaworth! 😋

[@sars910]

@@SuperLumianaire when Astrid first kidnapped me, my first instinct was to kill her instead of the hostages (minus the Khajeet because let's be honest, everyone killed the Khajeet). But when I got the "mission failed" prompt, I panicked and reloaded a save, then went along as Astrid told me to. Only later did I find out you can eliminate the DB. Shadowmere is cool though.

[@cassie6645]

I think the Dark Brotherhood quest of killing Narfi made me feel the worst. I believe it was right after I had helped him come to terms with his brother's death or something that I killed him too, made me feel awful.

[@insaincaldo]

Yah, I did it with my last assassin build, had deleted the character and didn't know. Then watching Gopher's current let's play I found out.. I have no illusions about what it means to be part of the brotherhood, but that mother took her own life because we wanted a gold star for effort.

[@sars910]

I think the Dark Brotherhood questline should have had some quests where you kill a serial killer or a child molester so the questline could stay in a gray area. Excluding Alain Dufont, every other target seems to be quite innocent. Commander Maro seems like an honourable man. The nobility with which the Emperor accepted his death was shocking. Narfi is a homeless man coping with the loss of his sister. Anoleius is a simple hunter who was killed for no discernable reason. The only kill I felt good about was Amaund Motierre. If you were told that your target did *this* despicable thing, then their death would be understandable but you get no such thing.

[@Furiousa96]

That last part made me want to buy night in the woods. I definitely am going to be playing a lot of games over this summer.

[@wonkybomb1865]

One of my favorite games of all time. The soundtrack is sooo good and I even bought stickers on Etsy of all the characters. Plus the guitar heroish sections so fun.

[@MoonlitRose101]

@@wonkybomb1865 Gregg rules ok

[@MoonlitRose101]

@Elalae La eeeeeeeeels

[@NoName-id6zf]

Yep i was playing it the last vacations, i couldn't complete it, i did not have the emotional stability to do it. I have to retake it.

[@metalbamboo2238]

Dude its such a good game

[@thomascruise4966]

1:50 - IIRC Vault 34 was an experiment to see what would happen if the Vault dwellers had a surplus of weaponry. Basically some folks left (they became the Boomers), and when others wanted to follow them but the overseer said no and posted guests at the entrance to the vault and the armories. Civil war happened, and while trying to blast their way into one of the armories through a side wall, the rebels damaged the reactor containment which... basically led to everyone who survived the civil war being killed or turned into feral ghouls by these radiation leaking out. Good times.

[@BloodStormOKN]

I wrote an ethics paper on vault 34. It’s a great example on morality.

[@thekrautist]

It's really just a variation on the trolley problem.

[@Sirkillmenot82]

PixelJanosz Not really. The trolley problem is about the choice between "changing an outcome to a lesser evil but murdering people" or "don't intervene, no blame on you, for a worse result." Vault 34 is more of a "doom one or the other" scenario. Big difference.

[@kallasantysanty6092]

There's always a third option, you just have to look for it (in real live, sadly not in most games)

[@takemetoyonk]

Mae is a great mascot for this regret video

[@geoffreyprecht2410]

Mae is a great mascot for regret in general.

[@slavinib6857]

Night In The Woods is my #1 regret, so it's very fitting for me, that game was fucking terrible.

[@plantspores3357]

Wait is this disrespecting *GREG* ? Oh naw, just Mae oof.

[@oivatank]

Something I did in Mass Effect 2 kinda breaks my heart every time I think about it. So during my playthrough I was romancing Tali (aka best girl) while also being the nicest guy in the universe. One time when it was time for me and Jack to have a heart-to-heart about her feelings and past etc, I thought I was just being a really good friend. Turns out the game considered it as more. I went upstairs to chat with Tali when I was met with some sad lines, one of them along the lines of “it’s a small ship, word gets around.” My heart snapped, crumbled, and got ejected into space, so I save scummed for the first and last time in my entire playthrough and picked some neutral options during Jacks heart-to-heart. To this day I feel like shit.

[@malindemunich2883]

Yeah, I had a similar thing happen. They really did make romancing Jack way too close to simply being polite and nice... which may be the point? For a person like Jack and all they've been through. Still, Tali being sad was just the worst, and I had no option to have a good heart-to-heart for the next hour with her to explain that Jack needed to unload some stuff, and I was there for her *as* *a* *friend* .

[@oivatank]

MalinDeMunich yeah, oh well. It’s a good game but it’s not perfect.

[@MsOdd86]

In my first playthrough I wanted to romance liara but I talked to kaiden about my past a little bit? And he suddenly got really sexual with me, and I didn't want to be an asshole to him so I "let him down slowly" by kinda of just joking it off but I guess the game took my neutral options as still accepting his advances and they had a big fight over me in the com room it was so awkward I hated it.

[@Frogmaiden27]

i think i did something similar in one of the dragon age games :)

[@oivatank]

EngleMun I only had a romance opportunity with Kaiden once at it was in Mass Effect 3 when we were chillin’ on the Citadel. Instead we became good bros.

[@AkiraDFun]

The one with Night in the woods is a normal event. It occurs even when you talk to your Mom every day (like I did in my Playthrough). It is story relevant but makes much more sense, when you talked to her every day before that. So yeah, it was just bad luck that you talked to her in time for the fight scene!

[@meh5145]

I've had to redo Detroit become human several times just so I had the right ending

[@ellbent]

Speaking of Detroit Become Human, remember Todd?

[@nickspencerfishingrodd2383]

ikr

[@dr.chaimsaw7841]

Still super proud of myself that i got the best ending my first playthrough.

[@shydreameress264]

I wanted to try revolution path, I felt awfully bad when I killed Chris and the police officer, I didn't recognized him, and Hank saying he just became a father made me feel even more horrible

[@waltm.3842]

My first playthrough I didn't make Kara become deviant. Since that was the end of the chapter, I went back to the main menu (had to go to work), and the blonde android was like "You let Kara and Alice die. How could you?" That bothered me while I was at work. But I finished that playthrough and made Kara deviant for the next one.

[@MrRhoobarb1]

But.... You can destroy Virmire AND talk down Wrex so he doesn't die. You talk him around and get him to see that it's wrong and not true Krogan.

[@henryshepard3688]

If you get him his family armor before Virmire it doesn't even give you the option of mucking that up. He backs down because you've "done more for me than my family ever has"

[@ElMarcoHoJ]

@@henryshepard3688 My first ever playthrough I hadn't got his armour, and I was forced to kill Wrex. I was shocked and heartbroken and vowed to save him from then on lol

[@crisvazquez433]

Thank you, I was wondering if I was the only one who was able to make the relationship work and keep wrex alive lol.

[@daanthedoctor]

I was stupid and told Loader Bot to self-destruct in Tales from the Borderlands I regretted it the entire game

[@magicmanscott40k]

Damn. He's really cool later on. How could u man? He becomes close with the robot vault thing

[@pakoussa00]

I did this too and my cousin (who had already played the game) completely lost his shit

[@TheTopazChannel]

I did it by accident and had to play that section over. Couldn't let him go like that.

[@lsmithrulez]

@@TheTopazChannel I did it because he's just a robot. How I regretted that later, never again!😂

[@IronianKnight]

I was in character as a smarmy Hyperion office worker and wondered what could have been

[@demonprincess9680]

I have a few examples of decisions in video games that could go horribly bad: Resident Evil 7: Biohazard: Who would you save? Mia or Zoe? Save Mia, your wife who worked for the secret organization that created the main villain of the game. Or Zoe, the daughter of the Bakers who tried to kill you, but was the only one who didn't go insane and tried to help you escape in exchange for saving her life. Apparently choosing poor Zoe gets both her and Mia killed. Simulacra: If you don't accept Ashley's feeling on Anna's behalf and still manage to befriend Taylor, you have to choose to either save Taylor's life of save Anna. Saving Anna means giving Taylor to a - let's face it - cyber demon and letting it inhabit his body and continue a mass killing spree. Saving Taylor means making an innocent man who was just trying to find an honest relationship kill Anna and get sent to jail on murder charges to stop a threat he didn't even know about. Simulacra 2 is essentially the same, but you have to find a way to make friends with three horrible people who are barely bothered by their dead friend. And if you fail to befriend even one, you have to choose one of them to kill. Undertale: Pretty much the whole game in a nutshell is the typical decisions of gamers n all games in general. You can choose to live like a pacifist and make friends with every single monster you meet which gets you the true and best ending. But, for every monster, you have the option of killing them. Killing even on monster, no matter how weak or insignificant, will take away that ending and get you either one of like a dozen neutral endings. Or you could go all the way and go full on genocide. But, if you make the decision to actually do full genocide, your game will remember it forever. There's no getting rid of Chara after that, even if you do pacifist again. She's always there. Completing the mission: I know, the Henry Stickmin series is just a bunch of stick figures in a some funny games filled with TV show and video game references. The games all have multiple endings you could go through. But, how many of you felt guilty getting the Valian Hero ending in Completing the Mission

[@blab5541]

One of my biggest regrets was in knights of the old republic when Bastia tries to turn you to the dark side. I went along with it and had to kill Jolee and Juhani straight way that was fine but afterwards to find the rest of your party on the beach and Zalbaar the Wookiee reluctantly sides with you because of his life debt, then when mission attacks you he has some absolutely heart breaking dialogue, and I actually really upset me that my character was making this big kindhearted teddy bear kill his best friend..... I ended up reloading and playing light side because I couldn’t deal.

[@DaBlindmann]

But you made the right choice because the dark side is canon

[@NunayahBuisness]

That moment was one of the most impactful for me. I sat back and let zall go to town. Let the hatred flow through him if you will.

[@NunayahBuisness]

Jason R. Peters what I loved about her was it taught you that by being kind today you could be far crueler in the future

[@fordid42]

@@DaBlindmann dark side Revan is just as canon as Galen Marek (Starkiller) killing Darth Vader and taking his place by Palpatine's side in The Force Unleashed. It's merely an optional choice to see what would happen. Not canon, according to "Word of God".

[@Taracinablue]

These "interview" or "confession" style videos are some of my favorites!

[@MikefromTexas1]

So many in the Fallout series. Witcher series. Mass Effect series. Dragon Age series. So many. Also, both of Janes involve cats.

[@WintersMinion]

Yeah during the Witcher 3 was doing the quest Tower of Mice and choose to do what the spirit asks by bringing her bones to her lover only to find out she's a Pesta and not only kills her lover but is now free to go where ever she wants and is a big part of what destroyed the country of Kerack.

[@kallasantysanty6092]

Hmmm there was one interesting option in Fallout 2 that i never realy regretted taking but may be that to some people ... New Reno, Wrights family, kids play outside, they see your guns and they want to play with them, you give one of them a pistol (with or with out ammo does not matter, kids know were to get some anyway) and you can tell them to go play with their father. You come back later and the head of the Wrights family is shot to death by his own kid ... sad but efficient.

[@eglacernaable]

well im speaking for a lot of people so its a game called OneShot when you quit or exit in the rpg maker version it will say "You killed Niko" (Niko is the main protagonist) showing Niko's remains while a very creepy soundtrack plays in the background

[@jaxonhuntsinger6894]

Jane doesn't know Alfred's name... that bothers me more than it should, I think.

[@GrassPokeKing]

The man headbutt Superman in the face, and she doesn't know his name.

[@wereflipper]

Notice how she also clearly doesn't care that she left Batman to die but instead is mad that she was tricked into a certain ending.

[@CrowTR0bot]

Am I the only one who thought Jane not knowing Alfred's name was just a joke? :P

[@michaelberresford4291]

She doesn't even know that catwoman likes batman and had helped him on multiple occasions.

[@jheckie14]

Naah man, he's the FATHER FIGURE of BATMAN THE COMICS CHARACTER. That's really important so you have all the reasons to be bothered.

[@therealsulaco]

The decision I regret most was in Fable 1, having to choose whether to kill Whisper or not. I normally play maximum-good but after much debate I finally decided to throw caution to the wind and off her. I then spent the rest of the game having people ask me why I did it. A little stab of guilt every time.

[@Pickoffarwim]

Jesus Christ! I played as an anti hero and I only killed her brother

[@PrettyBoiShin]

@@chaotik7853 You can kill Thunder during the "Lost Chapters" DLC I think.

[@arachnesakura9375]

My husband found either a glitch or something where you can just knock her out and still get the reward. But he always kills thunder just because hes a show offy asshole and thats how he raised his sister.

[@therealsulaco]

When I decide to go bad I go really, really bad. ;)

[@zeroattentiongaming820]

Notice how nobody questions you killing the Guildmaster? Guess everybody was sick of his intrusive hand holding.

[@hello_robot]

Not gonna lie. Jane’s Night in the Woods entry made me tear up. I’m gonna go give my mum a call.

[@GenLiu]

Quiet an old video but I wanted to say that the bonus round with Jane was adorable. When video games make you think about real life. Also, about Dark souls and Priscilla, I straight up forgot you had the choice not to fight her. I finished this game about a million times and killed her every single one like a true monster. On the other hand, I felt bad for killing Sif, even though I didn't have the choice...I mean, that animation they added at the end of the fight, when the poor beast is limping is just heartbreaking, I really felt like I was an horrible human being.