6 December 2023 | Editorial Discussion | Kissinger, Maratha navy, Social Justice, Climate change

[@OnlyIasnothingelse]

To Download Lecture Pdf Join - t.me/onlyiasnothingelse For daily Answer Writing Practice Visit - pwonlyias.com/mains-answer-writing/

[@Be_n_ak]

Ethics ki Hindi book kab Tak milegi sir

[@sammyD706]

Sir 4th dec ka editorial summary pdf only ias video ke topics se match nahi Kar raha hai drive link pe. Pls sahi editorial pdf daal deejyega.

[@abdeshsinghyadav]

Positives If govt gives subsidy to Tesla 1.Manufacturing plant in india create jobs 2. Bring cutting edge technology 3. Other Indian ev manufacturer will also get benifited as competition bring their best from them. 4. EV Ecosystem will be created 5. Employees switching from Tesla to other brands will bring technologies. Negatives 1. Extra favor to Tesla is injustice to other firms. 2. Tesla is giant...therefore chance in future that in subsume the other Indian brand 3. Indians firms face losses due to lack of innovation compare to Tesla. 4. Current growth in EV from Indian brands already growing with good pace govt should not disturb the growth Way forward Considering the fact India is a humongous market. India show stick to their Current policy for ev... eventually due to growth and increase purchasing power of Indians... Soon of later Tesla will also come to India as govt terms and conditions. Till then govt focus to boost domestic production of Evs made them that they can compete with Tesla in USA.

[@Harshita912]

Absolutely right 👍

[@SurbhiSingh761]

I like ur opinion

[@SurbhiSingh761]

Yes u r right that switching employees will bring technology but my ques is that...why do Tesla employees want to switch?

[@SagarSharma-ty4kq]

Sticking on Custom duties like 60 % or 100 % shows rigidness and solidify Protectionist image . Tesla will bring new cutting edge technology for manufacturing of EV vehicles ,Present EV vehicles are not on that competitive stage (except Tata Nexon) . But solution lies in joint venture and perfect example of this is Jaguar and Tata's joint venture, which increased sales of luxury jaguar cars and also boosted domestic manufacturing of Jaguar under the TATA, So in this direction Tesla can also collaborate with India' s automobile manufacturing companies and all this can be happened by negotiations for mutual benefits of both the companies as well as countries.

[@manik966]

Your positives are good.. But quite generic--include drastic points first, *tackle climate change *india's NDC(wrt carbon emission) @COPs *reduce subsidy burden on govt to bring this social shift from diesel vehicles to EVs (With due respect)

[@AditiSilakari]

The government should not provide any special subsidy to Tesla.... Tesla we are very sorry😅😂😂😂

[@aishapatel1877]

Subsidy ka to nhi pta but Import duty zarur lagega😂

[@kanwal989]

Yes import duty should be same for all the foreign companies and no exception should be given to Tesla as well and instead domestic automobile sector should be made more competitive by providing them more subsidies

[@kushaltiwari3423]

Moye moye

[@Clickviralshorts]

No subsidy nahi deni chahiye india ki company jyada se jyada govt k sath milke dusri countris ki tech smjh k apni cars me modify kare….##Local for vocal🇮🇳

[@RD-fw8ys]

A person who can afford buying a Tesla car can pay the import duty too. And in India majority is middle class so they go for the vehicles which are durable and at a quality price which is being ensured by the domestic manufacturers.

[@gajananjaybhaye8033]

Dear sumit sir we in Maharashtra call them 'Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj' and u r calling 'Chhatrapati Shivaji' i know u didn't know about this but i request u from next time call them 'Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj'

[@riyapathak7573]

Good morning sir 🙏 sir I request u to plz extend the validity of prahar batch 2023 till our prelims 2024 plz sir less than 5 months are left ,I beg you sir literally sir please 🙏 as upu have helped us prior plz I beg u to plz keep your hands once again on my head plz Sumit Sir

[@HARIOMSINGH-ki7sj]

Sir , aapka editorial jis din nhi aata us din bahut adhura feel hota hai….❤

[@Royal_IAS]

Day-779 Consistent efforts makes you prosperous ❤

[@abhinavanshu7298]

1. Social Justice reform: a) solution: economic development participation of aadivasi and dalits. 2. Navy Day on 4 Dec: a) Shivaji navy strong: built multiple forts, have around 400 ships. B) Criticism: brown water navy ie only capable to work around his empire. 3.Henry kissinger: a) US diplomat died.a

[@sirdanny4637]

if we restrict our economy by fear of competition fr to ham vapas 1991 wala model apna rae h... if tesla open its manufacturing in india - 1- job opportunities 2- R&D on electriccal vehicle 3- increased competition and ultimate benefits to people 4- will help to achieve 500GW renewable energy target 5- tesla may export their cars by india ... there should be some medium path and we should allow tesla in india.

[@anuradhamohan21]

No sir, no to tesla...govt have to encourage our youth to do more innovation because it's the era of innovation and globalization.......and our youth can do better..😊

[@farmer-akshaysingh595]

सरकार को subsidy देना चाहिए, लेकिन सिर्फ अपनी शर्तो पर। इससे रोजगार सृजन होगा और भारतीय कंपनियां भी प्रतिस्पर्धी बनेंगे, जिससे एक सकारात्मक लाभ होगा।

[@Mustak94940]

Fantastic News Analysis... Thank you Sirji..!!

[@iasmotivation1552]

Sir please discuss 3 to 4 mcqs daily in the end of session. 😊

[@chowhananirudhsingh1763]

Rather than providing subsidy to forgein manufacturing companies, better to encourage and provide some initiative to indian brands to design same model in india.

[@ustaad9220]

Thank you sir for consistently providing us with your valuable insights. I know these 30 minutes daily will play a vital role in my 70th BPSC results. ❤

[@vibhori]

Hare Krishna

[@anshuchaurasia5667]

Good morning sir thank you for this wonderful editorial discussion sir ❤😊😊

[@AishaSingh-ej1ew]

Thank you sir ❤❤😊😊😊😊😊

[@priyankajena2678]

Thank you Sumit sir abd only ias as team

[@shubhgangrade6405]

Thank you sir I think there is no need to give spacial incentives to tesla. If they want to do business in India 🇮🇳 they have to follow our terms.

[@dattaprasadambre4461]

Chatrapati shivaji maharaj ki jai🙏🚩🇮🇳

[@majaaaaya]

Special subsidy ki jagah chhoot de sakte hain, agar Tesla aayegi to competition badhega EV sector me

[@shivamchaurasiya4515]

Good morning sir editorial ka pdf Hindi mai provide karwa dijiye 🙏

[@RadhaPatel3]

Good morning sir 🔆 Thankyou for the discussion 🙏❤️

[@tehminaaslam7283]

Thank you for the discussion sir

[@anilsaini8860]

kafi saandar sir...

[@ankitaojha1176]

4:21 Sir muje lgta govt ko tesla ki demand pr bhaut kam charge to nhi krna chahiye lekin 1 ya 2% km kr skte hain jaise 24 h to 23 lekin isse jyada nhi taki apne desh me bi tesla jaisi companies invest kr sake jisse more jobs generate ho sake

[@hemantkumar8722]

Social and economical equality for downtrodden communities

[@vivekpandey8638]

tesla ko entry na dena wo bhi aise base pr ki is se india ki automobile sector pr bad impact hoga kya ye protectionism ka perspective show nhi krta and is se to kuch time baad globalisation pr khatra ho skta h because baki country bhi yhi start kr rhe then yahan ye sochne ki baat h kya hum us situation me hai ki sabhi sector me aatmanirbhar ho skte h

[@aditilata7033]

I think...govt should give ..yes, it can be less ... because of,...if subsidy will be not provide then ... their will be less compition in market....and .. situation can maybe like afterfreedom economic situation.. where competition was so much less....so ,...I think.. would be give.. benefits - 1) infrastructurel growth of GDP ✓ 2) competition in market .. increase.. 3) ultimately... benefits to people.. 4) quality will be increase.... 5) yes , it's not be more and more ...

[@LearnwithLegends.]

We have to accept Tesla only under our conditions.

[@aartik1253]

Thank you very much sir for this beautiful discussion... Your videos are on time now

[@SahabKumar-f7k]

Awesome Sir 🙏

[@m.mmangalvlogs]

Awesome discussion❤❤❤❤Tq so much

[@RahulYadav-iz4zr]

Thank you so much sir for giving us your afert ❤❤

[@Rohitbamniya05]

THANK YOU SIR

[@anshul2873]

Thanks sr ji🙏🙏🙏

[@ravindramandal8915]

Briefing: 2:40 import duty on tesla car . Protection policy of Indian govt. Vs introduction of new tech. Cars . My view : govt should wisely deal with tesla as the introduction of new tech. Car is need of the hour . At the same time domestic company must be incentivised to mfg. New tech cars esp. Electronic Vehicle. Domestic production must be prioritised. 2:40 social justice: is to ensure justice, fair equal rights, equal treatment, and protection to marginalised section of society such as SC ,ST and minority, women etc.. Modern democracy :- social harmony and reform B. Ambedkar: Dalits and other invites Dalits and other marginalised people to be equal shareholders in the nation's Economic and political development.. Political sphere: can be seen But Economic sphere Free Market order is not working for upliftment of SC and ST . Govt. Should intervene in the senerio .. and take steps for eco. Empowerment. Say of Dalits in decision making .. policy should be by and for the SC and ST .. 2:40 Climate change: Global Renewables and Energy efficiency pledge not signed by India and China.. Developed and developing fight over agreement. 2:40 4th of Dec Navy Day: Chhatrapati Shivaji one of pioneer of Navy in india (1661-1663) Brown water operation:- near the coast Blue water policy- on high sea 2:40 Henry kissinger Realpolitik: ✓Practicality over ideology: eg US investment in communist china ✓Ruthless national interest : no value eg: Bangladesh and USA ✓ stretegic ambiguity: eg Taiwan policy of US ✓Flexible alliance : No permanent friend no permanent enemy only national interest ✓Back channel diplomacy ✓ Global peer balance. India should learned from this policy to make balance bet Russia and Europe : middle east and Israel. Thank you sir

[@Rjrawat123]

Thanks sir❤

[@anukalpanusar4488]

Thanks ❤sir

[@gajendrayadav8209]

As always amazing discussion

[@babygamesjcb]

In my Opinion Tesla is not growing because of his features or faculties provides in it it's growing because of the name of his owner Elon Musk. And providing subsidy to a single company will be called partiality. Indian Automobile companies are doing great. They are trying to be more better. They are also manufacturing EVs that are also good and in range of middle class family. Tesla is not made for middle class on behalf of it's price range. And upper class in India is not too much that Tesla will provide a good Economy to us. Our country is doing better in Automobiles and those who are talking about Tesla is because of his owner. Please correct me if needed on my POV

[@zennatperween2668]

Sir plz pdf thodha jaldi provide kr deya kro thank you dear sir 💖✨

[@cricketkedewane8362]

4th December 1971 Indian navy destroyed many ports in karachi and captured karachi in operation TRIDENT My late GRANDFATHER was in Indian Navy and he also took part in that operation

[@ankitaojha1176]

Amazing discussion hmesha ki tarh 🙏🙏

[@ManormaUpadhyay-g9k]

bilkul nhi jb india me jyada purchase nhi hota to koyi point ofu nhi bnta 18% krne ka

[@preetkour4606]

Tysm sir

[@arunmk21]

Thank you sir

[@SaurabhKumar-ir9rh]

🙏

[@shashikarguwal3014]

Please कोई ये बता दो onlyias की site पर answer कैसे लिखे मैंने बहुत बार try किया पर उसमें केवल question ही show होता है लिखने के लिए क्या करु please कोई तो बता दो yrr😢

[@Passive612]

Question open Krke scroll down krna reply ka space show hoga

[@shashikarguwal3014]

@@Passive612 नही हो रहा Scroll down करने पर ‘ answer will publish soon ’ show हो रहा है लिखने के लिए space नही है कही भी और ना ही हिन्दी में question का answer है 😢

[@shashikarguwal3014]

@@Passive612 आप check करके बताओ please 🥺

[@shashikarguwal3014]

​@@Passive612बताओ please 🥺

[@Nk-upsc]

​​@@shashikarguwal3014 Step 1- open website in desktop site mode step 2- open question step 3- scroll down step 4- there u will see written - comment, start the conversation, sign up with Disqus step 5- u do sign-up in Disqus step 6- after sign up u can comment - to click on start the conversation select ur ans image and Comment

[@Ajay-jp9cq]

Thanks sir

[@aakashchandrakar928]

Discussion was good but I feel sorry for my self that u am not able to write mains answer, as CSAT bhi start karna Maruti hai

[@shivamdubey1581]

ACHHA LAGA DISCUSSION GURUJI

[@maneeshapatel6697]

Thkyu so much sir for discussion ❤❤🙏🏼🙏🏼

[@Iasram-o1k]

Day 1

[@munibrock9613]

Good morning sir thank you thank you for very much discussion

[@manik966]

13:15 FOOD_FOR_THOUGHT---Dr. B. R. Ambedkar--in his book("Revolution and Counter-Revolution in Ancient India") --said----------"The history of India is nothing but a history of a mortal conflict between Buddhism and Brahminism”

[@akworldcreation5300]

Not provide Tesla🚗🔌🔋 special subsidy.. Tata and mahendra is best and all vehicle are 4 to 5 star ⭐ rating, but only the problem is electric vehicles but tata have many electric vehicles so india don't need Tesla🚗🔌🔋

[@Ayesha-jh2vp]

Really nice discussion 👍

[@meenagupta7352]

Thank you sir❤❤ bahut achchha lagta h aap jaldi aa the ho ..

[@SumanMeena-p8p]

Tesla ko special subsidy nahi deni chahiye because isse hmare Automobile companies ko loss Ho sakta h jo hme kathi bardaas nhi h 🤨🤨

[@Visionary_Victory11]

Reservation is a curse to the deserving candidate.... This is actually regressing our country.

[@enjoyingwithanurag]

Wonderful and mindful discussion sir . 🎉

[@harshamishra9568]

Good afternoon sir🙏

[@vijaykumar-pu1dn]

Very nice

[@IAS1111]

Good morning sir ji❤

[@ujjwalpal3225]

No reservations should be provided into pvt jobs, the efficiency should not be compromised.

[@naveen.1435]

Govt of India every time talking about "Vocal for local" and "Aatmnirbhar Bharat" . So providing tax relaxation to Tesla and any other company is not good

[@mukeshkhichar635]

I think Tesla needs india more than... India needs Tesla

[@Rommel992]

Sir, Pvt sector main kaise reservation de sakte hai. Aur agar market itna hi kharab hai toh America kaise thrive kar raha hai, waha kaise itne Indians jaake CEOs bane hai. Kaise unke waha people with color President and Defense Secretary and Vice President bante hai. Reservation De do sab thik ho jayega ek bht galat philosophy hai, yeah Lalu aur unke beto ko political gain dilane ke liye toh thik hai, but actual jo deprived hai unke kisi kam ka nhi. Jaise aap UPSC ko dekh lo kitne garib gharke, marginalized section ke log participate and clear kar pate hai, main exceptions ki baat nhi kar raha. But as a whole actual Marginalized communities is competition main aa hi nhi pati aur pura malai ek ya do caste milke kha jaate hai.

[@anshumandash2220]

Elon Musk inspires me...but I love my country mora than anything...so according to me Govt should not give any special preference to anyone..

[@SurbhiSingh761]

U can't just say u love ur country that's why we need not to give any preferences to others...we have to consider negatives and positives😅

[@satyapalsingh6089]

Sir,please provide upsc mains-2023 model answer in hindi

[@Gautamgehlot-x4e]

Sir please explain text and context part of the Hindu when it matters pls sir

[@smartinvester1912]

Nice class❤

[@sammyD706]

Sir 4th dec ka editorial summary pdf only ias video ke topics se match nahi Kar raha hai drive link pe. Pls sahi editorial pdf daal deejyega.

[@SudhaKumari-mj5nu]

Nii ho raha hai

[@kursamshivram5160]

❤❤

[@Everything028]

Day 12

[@Vedangikavedu2004]

Good morning 🌞 sir 🙏

[@sahilsalaria909]

Good

[@sushilbijarnia9880]

🎉🎉

[@ashishchaurasia799]

Good morning

[@keshav1458]

Thank you so much sir🙏🏻.

[@sanaqureshi3369]

Hello sir aapka y chennal amount payment krke join krne se kya kya facilities milti h study m plzz reply me

[@Theananomousvj]

Sir pls kal ka aur aj ka pdf share kiyjie aur 29th ka bhi missing h❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@Theananomousvj]

Pls

[@Subhamjaisworld]

Jai hind sir

[@reetu-q13a18ilu]

Good morning sir.. Thank you so much sir 😊😊😊

[@RavindraKumar-vc4mp]

If tesla insure india to invest 2 billion, then indian government should bargain with tesla otherwise no

[@jyotimeena6736]

Good morning sir thank you ❤❤

[@anurathore6523]

Thank you sir❤❤

[@NO_SIMP_ZONE]

Only when the last tree has died and the last river been poisoned and the last fish been caught will we realize we cannot eat money.”cop 28 bickering led me to post this quote

[@Shubham-u7u2x]

Thanking you ❤

[@aspirants_ias3232]

Super discussion sir....❤

[@ABHAY_MONDAL]

THANK YOU SO MUCH SIR 😊😊

[@tannupriya9532]

I loved the discussion

[@User50080]

Thnku sir

[@empowerbharat]

Good discussion TQ

[@raghavendrachoudhary889]

Sir pdf 2 to 3 days later milta hai, Revision thik se nahi kar pata plz jaldi pdf dal de.