9-Year-Old Girl Killed at Wedding Venue After Mother's Bizarre Decision | Charlise Mutten Analysis

[@stephaniesinclair4175]

She left her daughter alone, overnight, with a man she met in prison who used meth and took antipsychotic meds? Shouldn’t she have been charged with something?

[@enjoystraveling]

Child neglect at the very least

[@judepower4425]

I'm Australian and wasn't aware female and male prisoners could meet in prison - how does that work? Unless he's one of those blokes "identifying' as a woman so he can do his time in a women's prison?

[@amandabeaty1492]

Him taking an antipyschotic has nothing to do with him being dangerous. People who suffer from psychosis (which means the sufferer is out of touch with reality) are, like most people that suffer from mental illness, much more likely to be the victims of crimes than being the perpetrator. He shouldn't have been left alone with a drug addicted convict.

[@EasrterRising1fan]

I am sure she had no problem loaning her daughter out for other things. What is wrong with those grandparents letting those creeps have their granddaughter.

[@lesliewoinarowicz7018]

@@stephaniesinclair4175 An accomplice to murder, sweetie.

[@make-believe]

Mother should be behind bars as well.

[@Davidpostingshid]

She’s a woman so she won’t

[@OyVeyy]

vvomen are rarely held accountable for their actions

[@BettiePagan]

@@OyVeyy can you be held accountable for that channel banner you got? Yikes on bikes man, who hurt you. At least we know you’ve got a grand idea for the ideal place this “mother” belongs tho.

[@BettiePagan]

@@OyVeyy​​⁠ can you be held accountable for that channel banner you got? Yikes on bikes man, who hvrt you. At least we know you’ve got a grand idea for the ideal place this “mother” belongs tho.

[@BettiePagan]

@ OyVeyy ​​⁠​​⁠ can you be held accountable for that channel banner you got? Yikes on bikes man, who hvrt you. At least we know you’ve got a grand idea for the ideal place this “mother” belongs tho.

[@roco5718]

She definitely set up her daughter to be abused by that man, no woman in their right might would ever allow that to happen, no real mother would allow their child stay alone with a boyfriend because she liked the dog

[@GoAskAlice23]

@@lesliewoinarowicz7018do you have an opposing argument or are you just being facetious?

[@lesliewoinarowicz7018]

@@GoAskAlice23 If you correct your grammar, I will answer you.

[@aprilallen5859]

@@lesliewoinarowicz7018 Leslie you need to calm it down lol

[@ticket2space]

​@@lesliewoinarowicz7018gah dawg Leslie you sure are a miserable beach ain't ya

[@ticket2space]

​@@lesliewoinarowicz7018I wonder if you just have terrible days so you come online and say stuff like this lol things won't change for you until you change them lady. Picking fights on KZbin over incredible silly things won't do it for you. Just makes you looks silly and miserable

[@willelliott5052]

Too bad that the mother walked free. She could not have cared less about that poor child.

[@dahliarose6986]

Don't worry, someone will be able to find her in person. It's a matter of time til someone who really hates that mother takes her out for what she's done. Australia isn't really that big.

[@Tigglytoot]

Same situation with Jen Soto.

[@annie68164]

Nothing is more dangerous for children than their own mother. Between ending them before their birth, to exposing them to their "love life" it's horrible the things happening to the innocent. Millions are ended or abused in disgusting ways because their mother refused to protect them. It's very sad.

[@willelliott5052]

@@annie68164 Yes, I don't consider them to be the fairer sex.

[@HellyeahRook]

@@willelliott5052 Oh so you hate women that's not a flex lol

[@summerdonnelly4675]

I'm sorry, baby girl. You deserved so very much better in the world.

[@heath2483]

It's pretty heart-breaking. Seemed like a nice kid and her grand-parents must have been - and still are - devastated

[@caroleckstein3541]

Poor little girl. She got a raw deal.

[@carolwilliams8281]

Enjoy living with Jesus baby girl. That's the best there is!

[@michaelbarbera1616]

Yes, she did.

[@joannharden8867]

God bless her soul ❤

[@mshockey73]

It's too bad that the mother took the little girl from what sounded like a stable home with her grandparents. There was a reason that she wasn't with her mother to begin with.

[@jackdowling5212]

I agree. I’m guessing any intervention by the family courts ceased well before this holiday. Given the serious nature of the crime her mother went to prison for, as well as her drug use, the interactions between the mother and child should have been monitored for longer as a condition to the change of legal guardianship. I know we say it with the benefit of hindsight, but it is clear that staying at her mother’s residence overnight was not in the interest of the child’s well-being. Very sad.

[@lesliewoinarowicz7018]

@@jackdowling5212 Sherlock Holmes would be proud of you, sweetie.

[@jackdowling5212]

@@lesliewoinarowicz7018 thanks Leslie, but he doesn’t exist.

[@weirdscience6820]

​@@jackdowling5212There wasn't a change in guardianship. I understand the grandparents had guardianship and allowed her to stay with them a number of days. How much monitoring would be long enough to know she won't go back to her old ways? She'd been taking drugs since her early 20s. Ice is the worst I hear. Psychotic episodes.

[@jackdowling5212]

@ I know, it’s such a hard one. The grandparents were trying to do the right thing by allowing the mother and daughter to be together. They could not have reasonably anticipated the evil that would transpire. These murder cases involving ice and subsequent senseless volatility are tragic.

[@LauraSnow-in3nx]

Why is the mother allowed to walk free? She allowed a grown man that she was dating to take her nine-year-old daughter overnight by herself. Why?? She was the one who wanted to spend time with her daughter. I think I can see what happened here and it’s disgusting. She needs to be held accountable too. She can be in jail right next to him.

[@dontbelongherefromanother]

Sad

[@chantemoody8416]

Honestly, I think the mother allowed her daughter to go with him to forbid the night with him and his family, because she was engaged to him and pregnant with his child, so she wanted him and her daughter to bond in a parent/child relationship since he was basically going to be her step-father. However, since the mother was a drug addict, she didn't use rational thinking to consider how potentially dangerous it could be to leave her small child alone with a convicted killer who supposedly takes antipsychotics while high on meth.

[@amandamorgan2802]

Could you please elaborate about what you see? Am interested to know,too. But they are low lives, yes.

[@amandamorgan2802]

​@@chantemoody8416Your comment makes no sense.She did not care,period.Buys drugs while the child is missing.

[@VantaBlackhole]

@@chantemoody8416 Nice fairytale that in no way is consistent with what really happened. You’re just Romanticizing a woman’s actions trying to justify what she did.

[@chev39rsh]

That poor little child, brought into this world to face TWO friggen monsters.

[@KimSmith-b9v]

Where were everybody else? The father, the grandparents, aunts and uncles, teachers, neighbors and so on?!

[@MaryHarper-x6r]

It happens all the time

[@Swnsasy]

If it happened here in the States, the mother would also be behind bars!

[@MaryHarper-x6r]

Child abuse is so common it would make your head spin times x20 at most x30 ... many want to avoid the subject also means [avoiding the problem] leading to a kind of slight involuntary legalization of it, it will be not talked about because its incriminating to the criminal! 2# 2020 election many voted for joe biden.. also meaning people voted on child abuse! [The nation is guilty of or an accessory to abuse with their vote] many kids are lost because of their vote...

[@lusomarga]

Those lowlifes did not deserve that beautiful little girl.

[@nyccollin]

Or the house.

[@albertafarmer8638]

So true but at least she is in heaven now.

[@AlintraxAika]

There is no such a thing as heaven, if we want the world to be fair it depends on us as a society. If god exists he permitted her to suffer immensely.

[@gkindustrialmachine1]

I cry for her. She was so sweet.

[@albertafarmer8638]

@@AlintraxAika Hi, this world is under the curse of sin. Before sin everything was perfect. You can read it for yourself in the first chapter of Genesis and if you don't believe that the Bible is the word of GOD you must study fulfilled Bible prophecy - only GOD can declare the end from the beginning! JESUS is GOD and though HIM we can go back to paradise, thank HIM for this while you can! Check out Dr. Ron Rhodes, a former Hollywood producer. He got saved after the studied fulfilled Bible prophecy.

[@jnever9768]

i bet you he tried to SA her and she resisted and ran away thats when he tracked her down and killed her. her mother should be back in prison for negligence.

[@crocadoodle7101]

A young child resisted, so he killed her?? More like, he did sexually assault her, wanted to again and killed her. And speaking of Justin being a pathological liar, same same for Scott Peterson who murdered Laci and Connor. When he speaks he lies.

[@judymurray191]

I was thinking the same thing.

[@Ashethetics]

What happened with the Seroquel in her system though? That’s very strange.

[@capricioushorse]

@@AshetheticsProbably thought he could drug her with it. But it didn’t work and when she tried to get away he shot her.

[@jnever9768]

@@Ashethetics prob gave her that to subdue her maybe? im not sure what the drug does...

[@GigiRulesTheRoost]

Being a grandparent of 3 precious children, I can't even imagine how the grandparents of this beautiful little girl coped after they let her go visit her low life mother only to be murdered by her even lower life boyfriend, never to return to their loving home and arms. Oh my. The pain, sorrow and horror.

[@blueStarKitt7924]

😔😔😔😢😢😢

[@Cochita322]

So sad 😢😢😢

[@ea8269]

What a horrific mother. She should be in jail with her bfriend.

[@DEPARTMENTOFREDUNDANCYDEPT]

This is one of the saddest cases ever, Dr. Grande. With broken, selfish adults like those two in her life, that poor child was doomed.

[@suzyq4982]

Happens all the time in this crazy mixed up sick world 😢 humans suck !!

[@supposedhumanmars]

Way off topic but your username is awesome.

[@DEPARTMENTOFREDUNDANCYDEPT]

@@supposedhumanmars Thanks! I wish I could say I invented it, but I got it from a comedy sketch by Firesign Theater decades ago.

[@amandamorgan2802]

Excactly.And some of these commenters who talk about second chances, are losers themselves.They should also not have children.Yes,that child was doomed.

[@blueStarKitt7924]

​@@suzyq4982Humans... Like that poor child ?😢

[@museumghost]

mom chooses substances and a man over her child, a tale as old as time

[@journeylvr]

Unfortunately!!

[@ohsweetmystery]

The child was wearing lipstick at the age of 9. I think that mother was complicit and grooming her.

[@ashleighsparkle8810]

@@ohsweetmysterylol o stop

[@ritahorvath8207]

Father chooses "freedom" and promiscuity over his child . A truth million more often occurs .

[@Laplata-r9n]

​@@ritahorvath8207 the father or the family court?

[@lindafarnes486]

I still don't understand how the mum got to just walk away from this.

[@lesliewoinarowicz7018]

Wokeness

[@Andersonsdanish]

@lindafarnes486, I understand what you mean. But, also, all too often, women fall for men who turn out to be nightmare material. The hope of finding love leaves us vulnerable to charm and manipulation.

[@thesaddestdude3575]

Women usually walk away.

[@johnmorris8444]

@@Andersonsdanishit’s not really an excuse though. People putting their children in dangerous situations with dangerous people is negligent and should be charged as a negligent homicide.

[@supposedhumanmars]

​@@johnmorris8444agreed

[@amandabeaty1492]

Mum waited two days to report her 9 year old missing? How do you go two days without seeing your 9 year old? When I was 9 years old, my mother knew where I was 24 hours a day.

[@aude2sapere]

Drugs, that's the only possible explanation

[@Samanta-van-laar]

Man, if my ass was not home when the street lights went on, I had a problem growing up with 2 uncles and ma grandma. I would not even be missing 1 hour 😂😂 this is just weird 2 days and she is still free how

[@Brazealen]

This is why we have Caylee’s Law in Florida (after Casey Anthony failed to report her daughter Caylee missing for over a month… bc obviously, she killed her). This law is used to prosecute parents who fail to report their children missing. They need to have it everywhere. Calista wasn’t a mother, any more than Casey Anthony. She just gave birth. She didn’t earn the title. She violated a sacrosanct position of trust. Charlize’s REAL mother is her grandmother, who only allowed her to be with her birth giver for the child’s sake and never knew what monsters were capable of doing. Her boyfriend probably asked her to request to have Charlize for the holiday. He had child porn in his possession at the time. He likely drugged her with Seroquel to incapacitate her so he could hurt her. Calista admitted she became psychotic when rejected by lovers. She wouldn’t have denied him anything to keep him, all he had to do was threaten to leave her.

[@ruuddriessen8547]

Mom knew ......she just didnt care. She is a disgusting waste of air.

[@chanelno.5560]

What a POS Mum! The police would be called if my Daughter was gone for 10mins - even more than likely immediately! Two days? For a 9 yr old? That’s got to be classed as 100% guilt?

[@budm9982]

Poor little innocent Angel. Mom should have been charged along with the sleazebag.

[@ThatCrazyDogLady74]

These stupid women letting monsters into the lives of their children.

[@lesliewoinarowicz7018]

They are naughty for sure, sweetie.

[@Hank-q8u]

they are monsters to

[@truthsocialmedia]

Women are children in many cases

[@lesliewoinarowicz7018]

@@Hank-q8u No relation to the Cookie Monster I hope. 🤞

[@JCSaves714]

💯💯💯💯💯💯

[@KathiLou1980]

She needs to be held accountable for her bad judgement in the death of her child

[@thesaddestdude3575]

Agreed

[@motorcycleguy73]

Good luck holding a woman accountable for anything. The court system won't

[@susanbennett9062]

Jennifer Soto

[@SS-iw2nq]

@@susanbennett9062Casey Anthony too.

[@TheBerkeleyBeauty]

Beautiful little girl. RIP Charlise. 😞

[@stevencuenca1980]

So sad.. she looks alot like my little girl used to...shes all grown up in her 20s now😢

[@wallhagens2001]

I'm tired of people trying to use mental health issues to avoid responsibility. I've had mental health issues all my life and I've never committed any serious crimes. (I do speed on the freeway!)

[@lesliewoinarowicz7018]

Please take your meds sweetie.

[@darbyelliott2890]

💯

[@GarthWatkins-th3jt]

​@@lesliewoinarowicz7018he does. He just told you "I DO SPEED on the freeway", probably while traveling in the fast lane with cruise control on and steering wheel held steady between his knees.

[@lesliewoinarowicz7018]

@@GarthWatkins-th3jt ….and barefoot too!

[@lesliewoinarowicz7018]

@@GarthWatkins-th3jt Barefoot too!

[@kathyegbert6532]

That poor child. 😢

[@susyq.218]

💔💔💔💔😥😥😥😥

[@virginiaconnor8350]

Charlie should've been taken into productive custody before things happened. Why didn't the grandparents do anything to help the child and where were they when this happened anyway?

[@kwas101]

Poor little mite...she never had a chance. Rest in peace beautiful little girl.

[@althunder4269]

It never ceases to amaze me how screwed up some people can be.

[@honeybunch5765]

Drugs. The world needs to wake up and stop normalising substance abuse. It will be the thing that ends civilisation.

[@nobertstanel9428]

When prisoners finds out about his paper, he's gone.

[@alsmith9853]

What's worse is he was rich, millionaire parents, private school, very privileged upbringing

[@blueStarKitt7924]

​@@alsmith9853Exactly.😡🤬

[@1300towPtyLtd]

When this story broke here in Australia people said the mother was guilty to and I have to say I totally agree with that. After seeing her interview on 60 minutes I was more convinced than ever. Her crocodile tears and lack of care for the child made me sick and how she made everything about herself. I think she should have been charged as well bcos she didn't care for the child. Drugs and the boyfriend came first. No one let's a child goes off with someone they barely know. The grandparents should never have let her have visitation without supervision especially with her history. Sadly the child paid the price of her mother's lack of care. RIP little one ❤

[@Ad-Lo]

*too

[@deborahblackvideoediting8697]

At the very least, she should have been charged with child endangerment. I'm baffled why the grandparents allowed Charlise to visit Calista. They still had legal custody, right? Did you ever see an interview with them?

[@ashleighsparkle8810]

And the man? Somehow they always are skipped over in this rhetoric. Is it just expected that they behave this way now?

[@mrsam0496]

She was enabled by her parents. The signs are all there. They even gave her the girl despite her drug problem and psycho boyfriend. I bet that huge house was theirs too. Parents think spoiling their children is love.

[@margaretr5701]

@@mrsam0496 The house belonged to his parents.

[@clutch2827]

Human garbage. Feel sorry for the kid.

[@bossyspaghetti]

I'm a mother who is luckily still with the father of my child. If for some reason I had wound up single, I would stay that way. Trusting unrelated men with children who aren't theirs is just too risky.

[@sparagmos4748]

I had 2 step fathers. One was fine in a way, the other was pretty horrible, but my dad wasn't any better. On the whole I agree, but I would have really hated to have had to have grown up with my dad🫤

[@renwar71]

This is exactly my story .. my husband left for another woman ..and I’ve stayed single to raise my son …I put him first always

[@SY-ok2dq]

Well there are plenty of cases where the biological father was the one who couldn't be trusted with the kids. And cases where the mothers knew e.g. the Menendez brothers. There was that bizarre case of the girl who was adopted out as a baby but eventually reconnected with her bio father as an 18yr old, and they wound up getting married! And having a baby! 😮 Before he killed her and himself (Steven Plaidl I think). He couldn't be trusted around his bio daughter - or his baby bio daughter/bio granddaughter! Remember the Wurtzl family case? The father had several children/grandchildren with his own bio daughter. Then there's the likes of Chris Watts. Loving dad on FB, who could clearly be trusted around his own children!

[@Plaksa2004]

Sometimes it's not safe with fathers, sometimes it's cool with step fathers. It's all about how careful u are and if u take drugs and are an idiot or not

[@tinamarisia123]

🎉That's what I did . I made it very clear to my boys and any potential boyfriend that I would not marry or live with another man until my boys were 18 years. ( My youngest was 4) When I went out they were at their dads. It was the right decision for me because I actively brought my boys into the world and I did not want them to have to deal with an antagonistic relationship in their home and I knew that you never really know someone and no one was touching,hurting or being mean. Or abusing my boys... I knew that I could not live with myself, if I let it happen..

[@steveeuphrates-river7342]

Two people get out of prison and move into a massive house. Nice.

[@We_Are_All_Vultures]

Obviously his parents spoiled him

[@chcr18]

They definitely enabled him to enamor his victims.

[@sparagmos4748]

Would you prefer it that wealthy people never got sent to prison?🙄

[@thesaddestdude3575]

@@sparagmos4748 No we are against criminals being rich

[@sparagmos4748]

@thesaddestdude3575 As the crime had nothing to do with the wealth that's irrelevant.

[@yusiyola2011]

3 yrs in prison for being responsible for killing someone

[@cookie_dough_hangover]

I blame the mom,too.

[@SwimminWitDaFishies]

Another tragic example of how NOT to be a mom. And the type of people who should have never reproduced.

[@infinitejest441]

And yet she walks away from it all.

[@Swansong321]

These men target gross women with children..

[@Gingerblaze]

True. Also Justin was enabled in his continued drug abuse by his wealthy family.

[@lesliewoinarowicz7018]

@@Swansong321They also target pretty women without children.

[@chcr18]

@@lesliewoinarowicz7018 The latter holds very little weight when compared to the former. Child vs pretty woman? The woman has a choice of who she allows in her life, the child doesn't.

[@chcr18]

The latter pails in comparison to the former. What a ridiculous point to add. Like the woman doesn't have control of who she allows to be in her life, the child sure doesn't.

[@lesliewoinarowicz7018]

@@Swansong321 They also target gross women without children sweetie.

[@Stevethebear]

One of the most prolific youtubers out there, the doc is always in!

[@AnthonyOMulligan-yv9cg]

Here In Australia, Many Of Us Are Still Confused And VERY ANGERED.

[@lindamcclenny9516]

Never never never leave your kids with strangers

[@LúciaKitten]

I've said before, cases involving children are particularly harder for me, the oldest of my grandchildren is a 9 year old incredible little girl. I can't fathom the terror that innocent child went through! Thank you so much for your analysis on this case, Dr. Grande, I hadn't heard about it.

[@lesliewoinarowicz7018]

@@LúciaKitten Why do you feel a need to share your family on this channel? Please get help and take your meds as prescribed. No thanks needed.

[@cosmicgirl1116]

What??? Two incompetent drug addicts buying drugs and having sex, while a 9 year old child gets drugged, shot to death, put in a barrel and thrown in a river embankment? HORRIBLE beyond words.

[@audreycasassa1683]

They are both guilty. If Justin and Calista's child was born I pray Calista does not have custody. I pray this child grows up loved, healthy & happy and is always out of harms way. Rest in Peace beautiful child💔💔💔

[@angelatheriault8855]

The custodial grandparents should have told their pathetic daughter that if she wanted to see the kid, she had to visit her in their home.

[@sweettea527]

Mom left her daughter with her convicted felon that she didn't know very long boyfriend?

[@LouiesLog]

😞

[@bassman8144]

“Mom” is an undeserving title for this piece of garbage.

[@nyccollin]

Happens all the time.

[@Tryp-j9d]

They LUV the Bad Boys!!!

[@Tryp-j9d]

@@bassman8144. Was she Puerto Rican??

[@MEL2theJ]

Those last two lines were incredible! "...inexcusable for an adult..." Thank you again Dr. Grande 🙏

[@tallblonde1976]

When you said “now moving to the timeline of the crime”, my stomach dropped.

[@gregscally5119]

Taking meth whilst pregnant wont do the baby any good. This woman is despicable.

[@emmagatewood3898]

Right?? Mom is on drugs, and dad is a psychopath. What a start in life for that baby. 😢

[@margaretr5701]

@@emmagatewood3898 The little girls dad wasn't mentioned.

[@emmagatewood3898]

@@margaretr5701 I was referring to the baby that she was pregnant with at the time of the crime.

[@margaretr5701]

@@emmagatewood3898 Right, I wonder what happened to that baby, surely not left in her care.

[@ginandtonic69]

How did she meet him in prison? And only 3 years for killing your passenger while stoned? WTF Australia?

[@We_Are_All_Vultures]

They talk at the fences and send snail mail

[@simonewebber-nq9ep]

Money will buy you a top lawyer in Australia, and they will make sure your judge is compromised... we have a sick crew running this country!

[@judepower4425]

passenger?

[@lesliewoinarowicz7018]

@@ginandtonic69 Woke!

[@SRWJ]

Dr Grande failed to mention this, you would have to look it up to confirm the details but I believe they say why this is in the interview she did did with A Current Affair. Something to do with covid/and or facilities being renovated caused male and female populations to be integrated for a period of time in the jail they were housed in.

[@candyjamaican]

Parents, please go home and hug your kids. Tell them you’ll love and protect them always. As a mom, I know where my kids are & what they’re doing at all times.

[@evapunk522]

It's actually really crazy how you can talk about the most messed up stuff but because your voice is so relaxing, I am somehow always calmed by your videos, well unless I think about the content too much lol..but it's still kinda funny in a way.

[@Swansong321]

Gorgeous little girl..horrid mother..so bloody depressing

[@LouiesLog]

Cat

[@deborahblackvideoediting8697]

It really is utterly depressing. And so preventable.

[@ashleighsparkle8810]

And the man? A lot of you need some serious reflection.

[@lololnope34567]

@@ashleighsparkle8810 yep, both the murderer and her useless father are also to blame

[@amandamorgan2802]

​@@ashleighsparkle8810 Both of them!

[@HarleysDucks]

*TO ALL SINGLE MOTHERS- STOP ALLOWING STRANGER MEN AROUND YOUR YOUNG CHILDREN.*

[@MrsPixie-ni4lb]

Ty for always speaking with empathy and never fluffing up /dragging on the story. Another great video! RIP Charlize💔

[@DonHendrickson-xd7jw]

Both Callista and Justin should be imprisoned for life. What a tragic story.

[@pegcity4eva]

The only people who get imprisoned in Australia are people who break covid rules.

[@method2madness762]

Both adults here are complete scumbags. The mom should have been charged too. She’ll get hers tho,.

[@TrentReeves-c2k]

A perfect marriage or relationship is an illusion; there's no universal playbook for making them work. What's effective for one couple may not apply to another. Nevertheless, I've come to understand that there's always a solution to be found. Half a decade ago, my wife and I faced such trials in our marriage that divorce seemed inevitable. Yet, through perseverance and determination, we navigated through the rough waters and emerged stronger, reunited, and more resilient.

[@GregMunro]

There is a lot of sense in what you just said and I hope mine works the same way too, we are currently separated but I cant live without her, I love her so much. wish I can get her back I can do anything to have her back, we have tried therapy amongst other things

[@TrentReeves-c2k]

Its always difficult to let someone you love go, but in my case I had the help of a spiritual adviser who saved my marriage from collapsing her name is shelly renee white..

[@GregMunro]

This is helpful, I will look her up online right now...Thanks..

[@amandamorgan2802]

And this is relevant how?

[@-._.-KRiS-._.-]

@@amandamorgan2802 Paid bot comment.

[@didamnesia3575]

The world is less dangerous if you avoid social gatherings and drug addicts

[@lesliewoinarowicz7018]

True!

[@Generalindifference]

So don't leave the house

[@didamnesia3575]

@Generalindifference buzz off belly scratcher. Don't out yourself as a drug addict

[@lesliewoinarowicz7018]

@@didamnesia3575 There is a home in Siberia that has your name on it.🖖

[@lesliewoinarowicz7018]

@ What if she is a drug addict?

[@shawnaellcey6970]

5:45 says it all. Look at his eyes, then look at hers. Poor little angel. 😢

[@gkindustrialmachine1]

Such a beautiful child. Every father hopes for at least one. Nothing in the world is more precious than a daughter ... nothing. I cry for her. She was so sweet. I don't know what more to say. I don't understand how anyone could do such a thing.

[@reneejones7807]

Imagine the heartbreak of the little girl’s grandparents.

[@marilyn6168]

I’m so sick of those irresponsible people. And they get away with their behaviour, it’s despicable.

[@tonyprice2256]

How can anyone kill such a beautiful child?

[@SteveJones379]

Makes me sick to my stomach.

[@JenniferWaite63]

Children always suffer in these types of relationships 😢

[@MrELMENDA27]

I live in NSW and at one stage not far from the said properties. I remember this case and words fail me.

[@riatsila144]

Once he said she lived with her grandparents, I was able to fill in the next part of the story pretty easily. Tale as old as time. Absolutely horrible.

[@BubbleBas]

10:25 He started taking drugs at the age of ELEVEN? He grew up well off, but with no parents who cared. Jesus Christ.

[@karenneill9109]

Heroin at 13. How does a kid even get access to heroin at that age? My kid’s allowance is $25/week, where did he get the money? If my kid was getting high at that age, I would NOTICE! yeah, the parents didn’t care.

[@renwar71]

Yeah definitely didn’t have loving parents in his life…they probably paid him to leave them alone hence the money for the drugs and feeling totally neglected himself… still doesn’t excuse what he did by any stretch

[@SY-ok2dq]

​@@karenneill9109 25bucks???? We got nothing ever, for most of our childhood, and anything we got went into a bank account in our names but which we had no access to. However I've read about the lives of the children of the wealthy and very wealthy. There's cash around, there's access to cards and whatever. Ordinary people have no idea of the lives of these kids.

[@Enigma8750]

Justin got everything he ever wanted. He even called his mother from Jail to go into the forest behind the house to get the guns that he had stashed out in the woods. I heard the call on the 60 minutes Australia story. So his mother and father were the kind that did what ever he wanted with no consequences. He gave the girl a huge dose of Quetiapine which would have tranquilized her but for some reason she didn't fall asleep or she woke up during a sexual assault and ran out the back door he went in the woods after her with both of the rifles and shot her with the .22 first in the hip which would have been extremely painful even for her drug addled body then she probably started screaming from the pain of the bullet wound in a big bone of her hip and he got up close range and fired the face shot up close and personal. Probably mad because she had foiled his plan to SA her. That is what I believed happened to her. Eternal Rest Grant Unto her oh Lord and let perpetual light shine upon her and may she rest in peace, Amen.

[@SY-ok2dq]

@@Enigma8750 Lack of boundaries and enforcement of appropriate rules, and lack of regard for the law and for consequences for others and for himself. Spoiled but it would seem he had somewhat absentee parents. And it's far easier to get away with stuff, doing drugs or whatever when your parents are away a lot (business trips, or personal vacations abroad for long periods of time, the way the wealthy do, called away on business etc. Also living in a great big mansion with a lot of rooms makes it a lot easier. If you grow up in a tiny apartment with one bathroom, with parents and a lot of siblings for example, there's hardly any privacy for anyone, kids will be sharing a small room together etc.

[@cassandraotroy6325]

Both those monsters should be put away for life. (Real life, not 'legal' life) Poor baby 😢

[@bohenriksson2330]

How sad😢, that beautiful little girl….

[@SurnaturalM]

I'm a man and a father, when we separated, the mother of my kids and I, I wanted to know what other guy was living with my daughters half the time. (I wasn't worried because I knew their mother have common sense, but we never know) and she wanted to know who was my girlfriend too. I think it's normal. Take care of kids people.

[@ditzyavocado]

The sad thing is that in that picture with the monster this little girl displayed that she really liked and felt comfortable around him. That picture speaks volumes

[@SY-ok2dq]

Well I suppose that's why the mother allowed it. Mind you she's the woman who's done time for running over a person with her car, and who makes runs into Sydney to buy meth and do drugs with her fellow drug user ex-convict bf (not that his being an ex-convict necessarily means he's a really bad person, or hasn't reformed, or that he's dangerous as plenty of people have gone to prison who are not violent). And why wouldn't the girl be comfortable with that guy? I mean she's spending time in the care of a mother who's a meth user who went to prison for killing a person with her driving. I mean that guy is just normal to the girl - feels just like home.

[@amandamorgan2802]

​@@SY-ok2dq Exuse me??? Are you sarcastic.Or just stupid?

[@susanfisher4944]

Dr. Grande, I love listening. Your voice calms me.

[@lesliewoinarowicz7018]

Take your meds sweetie.

[@mollyram2997]

@@lesliewoinarowicz7018 that not very nice to say. Dr Grande IS calming to listen to. Go gain some empathy “sweetie”

[@renwar71]

@@lesliewoinarowicz7018 get off the drugs sweetie

[@sonjagatto9981]

@@mollyram2997 I agree❣

[@yogadork_namaste]

RIP sweet baby angel. you deserved better adults in your life.

[@rbspider]

I knew I shouldn't have watched this. The grandparents should also have never allowed this beautiful little girl to visit the mother.

[@SY-ok2dq]

The grandparents named their daughter Calista - I am guessing that they chose that highly unusual name because of actress Calista Flockhart. It certainly wasn't a name anyone was giviing to their kids in Australia back then. Tje granddaughter als o has a highly unusual name. It has to be inspired by the actress Charlize Theron. I know of no other Charlize and it too was an unheard-of name in Australia and the U.S. until Theron became famous. It all seems a little bit strange.

[@rbspider]

@@SY-ok2dq I met a girl the other day that was named after the actress in Good Will Hunting . We got the idea for our daughters name from a singer who was on the TV. Names don't make people strange , going to jail and dating a released inmate make them strange. Allowing the human you are given guardianship over into the hands of drug addicts is a crime.

[@duncanmcintyre6230]

"When considering all the evidence in this case, do I think he was guilty? ... Yes." Always the most epic moment of any Dr. Grande video.

[@Bebecat477]

I can't tell you how badly I hate hearing "the timeline of the crime" and "child" in the same story. 😢

[@lesliewoinarowicz7018]

Are you trying to say you feel regretful sweetie?

[@nevergonnagiveyouupnevergo2795]

@@lesliewoinarowicz7018what are you implying?

[@fightingtosurvive6527]

Dr. Grande ! I haven't seen your channel in such a long time because KZbin buried it in the algorithm ! 💜🌷🐾🐾💜

[@majordolbyscat]

Heartbreaking to think this beautiful little girl had such ugly monsters as parents and was denied blossoming into adulthood. Sickening, truly sickening.

[@AleaIactaEst2009]

How the heck do a couple meet in jail? Men and women should be entirely segregated, it's not a dating centre. What a horrendous mother. And what a monstrous guy. Poor sweet girl.

[@blast_processing6577]

They initially met through a pen pal program, they didn't meet in person until both had been released from prison.

[@AleaIactaEst2009]

@@blast_processing6577 Thank you.

[@stevecapil6577]

@@blast_processing6577 That's not how it is portrayed in the script.... 1:10

[@blast_processing6577]

@@stevecapil6577 Check out an article titled _"Private_ _schoolboy_ _to_ _'wicked'_ _killer"_ that was in the Australian news, as it provides a lot of details that are missing from this video. There are plenty other sources that specify how (not just when) Kallista met Justin though too.

[@blast_processing6577]

@@stevecapil6577 From the news article _Private_ _schoolboy_ _to_ _'wicked'_ _killer:_ "Stein and Ms Mutten began their relationship behind bars in 2018, sending letters to each other from their respective cells."

[@NieceyWeesey]

I'm so glad that Dr Grande has started speculating again

[@SgtPepper138-n2l]

What the hell? That poor little girl. 😣

[@kuroneko7022]

I hate these kind of stories! What kind of mother leaves her little girl with a convict to spend the night? These women are so desperate to be with a man, any man, until they hand their children over willingly. If you’re a single mother your child comes before your damn sex and dating life! That so-called mother needs to be indicted, too!

[@lesliewoinarowicz7018]

Relax sweetie and take your meds as prescribed.

[@KayosHybrid]

@@lesliewoinarowicz7018 you’re a weird bot

[@lesliewoinarowicz7018]

@@KayosHybrid Take a deep breath and remember you are a ray of sunshine for a troubled world.

[@kuroneko7022]

@@lesliewoinarowicz7018 Seems like you could be one of those mamas the way you ran up on my comment instead of minding your business.😂

[@lesliewoinarowicz7018]

@ What kind of stories do you like, honey. So sorry if I hurt your little feelings. I’m sure you just made a mistake, no thanks needed.

[@alancolenso3895]

That poor, dear child. How horrible it must have been for her. Heartbreaking.

[@philipwurm5121]

Poor kid! What kind of trash can of a mother would leave their kid with garbage like .that ??? And what kind of pos can’t watch a kid for just a day or two??? What a shame!!! May she RIP 🙏🏻

[@GoddessOfLoveEnergy333]

That is heart breaking. I appreciate you discussing the issue of substance abuse and how it can harm people and their loved ones. I know so many people who slip into this and my heart breaks for them. And then they fall in love with people who have low morals and also live in that way. 😢 my heart goes out to them.

[@kerry8461]

I work in the healthcare field and the majority of time I see Seroquel prescribed to people without psychotic symptoms or history but for help with sleep.

[@MaeMae99]

I have used it for sleep 20mg

[@gemlayne1400]

I was thinking of that too when he said it. I know someone that was prescribed Seroquel for sleep

[@renwar71]

This is true… I was prescribed it for my mental health ,I’m not psychotic but it made me sleep and stop nightmares from PTSD but it made me so dopey the next day that i couldn’t function till at least midday … so went off that … but my mums prescribed a low dose for insomnia which I think is absolutely crazy ..it’s definitely overprescribed

[@astraltiddies]

i’m on 100mg for sleep

[@shirleyrobinson-taylor9652]

My daughter was on it, 90mg she lost her 2nd son crib death and as a result she had a psychotic break and was admitted to a phyc hospital. In 3 months, she went from 125lbs to 265 and it took another 2 months to ween her off of it. She is still on a lot of phyc. drugs. And that was 5 years ago.😢😢😢❤❤❤

[@azaidahsalim519]

Dr Grade thank you for bringing content with compassion. May God continue to bless you

[@tomfoolery342]

I saw where this story was going and turned off the video.........I just can't!!!🤬🤬🤬

[@kindyyo7]

O Dr Grande!!! I grieve for little Charlise 😢 That picture of her beaming with happiness holding her soft toys gets me EVERY time. Animals like him make me sad that Jesus loves them.

[@1farahnaz]

Does jesus love the devil? I think not.

[@renwar71]

I can certainly guarantee that Jesus does not love him … I doubt anyone does

[@zenawarrior7442]

Always raises my hair when I hear your list of the bad characteristics. So sad what happened to Charlise😢Excellent round up & points. Thanks Dr G😊💕💕

[@Tryp-j9d]

Bouffant?

[@zenawarrior7442]

@Tryp-j9d 😁Maybe! Meant hair on my neck...lol🤷‍♀️🧑‍🦱

[@thelocalmaladroit8873]

As soon as you said Calista left Charlise with Justin, I thought “oh no.”

[@emmagatewood3898]

I don't understand why she left them alone together. Why didn't Calista just go with them? Bizarre.

[@lornaginetteharrison7168]

I wonder what happened to the child Kalista was pregnant with at the time of the murder? I hope it was removed from her custody immediately after birth.

[@ningkucing]

HEY DR GRANDE, they weren’t living at the Mt Wilson home, they were just staying there a couple of nights. Justin lived in a really disgusting flat in Sydney. Charlies’ mum was living somewhere else. While in Mt Wilson they were actually staying at a caravan park. That’s where the mum was the night poor little Charlies was killed. LOVE your work!! ❤

[@Uglyoldhag]

This makes sense. I bet Justin used that fancy house to use mdma/coke and whatnot to abuse women/girls

[@jotruman6936]

They were also staying at the house. I live in the district and follow the case closely.

[@mariehenneken4767]

Mother should be in jail for child neglect.

[@margaretr5701]

She was pregnant too, I hope the baby wasn't left in her care.

[@mtadams2009]

They both should be in prison.

[@NealBurkard-ut1oo]

Seroquel can be prescribed for other reason outside being psychotic. I knows its commonly prescibed for sleep

[@chicanica64]

Instant release low dose, Seroquel is prescribed for sleep because of the sedating effects. Psychosis range is 400-800 MG of XR. Instant release makes people zombies. It can be a wonderful drug and life saving for some people.

[@creatureslim]

Yes, but in like 1/20 th of the dosage as for psychosis issues.

[@chicanica64]

@ for psychosis is dosed to remission of symptoms.

[@MadCatLady28]

​@@creatureslim I've seen alarmingly large quantities of it be prescribed for sleep. It's harder to get a prescription for zopiclone.

[@DatoUSA]

Seems like he was molesting the innocent little girl and she was trying to run away, maybe after being assaulted. That’s why he wanted her alone with the excuse of a dog to begin with. The mother is equally guilty for putting her in danger of sexual assault and for the murder. Sad for the child.

[@RosemaryOltarzewski]

Oh that poor little angel. RIP away from those monsters 🎉

[@NexusFantismo]

Three years for vehicular homicide speaks to the worldwide issue we have in the justics system. There's not much deterrent to murder, much less crime in general.

[@galelascala105]

Heroin at age 13? Jesus!

[@y6cd3sdzHs1g]

6:20 given Seroquel and shot by a 22??? Many governments don't even allow hunting deer with a 22 because it is inhumane. This is awful

[@terrilee68]

My heart still breaks for this sweet girl I feel he drugged her to SA her, she woke & She ran for her life from this animal. Praise our justice system got it right He will never be released to walk our streets & hurt anyone else.

[@truhunk1]

That poor little girl. WTF ?

[@lademoiselleketoret6958]

What a beautiful young girl. So sad!!! 😰😭😭😭