93. Basis of Charge Sec. 28 | Profits & Gains from Business or Profession | PGBP Lecture 1

[@StudyAtHome]

✅Join Study At Home WhatsApp Channel - whatsapp.com/channel/0029VaAOYpQ7j6g3r4W4Rr0H ✅Stay in Touch with CA Raj K Agrawal by following him on all his social media - linktr.ee/CARajKAgrawal

[@nripendraku]

आप सही कह रहे हैं सर मेरा GST complete है मैं इसे दो बार revise कर चुका हूं और तीसरी बार कर रहा हूं और इस बार भी मुझे लगता है कि कुछ नया सिख रहा हूं इनकम टैक्स का revision भी अभी स्टार्ट किया हूं ये आप बहुत important बात बता रहे हैं सर।❤❤

[@StudyAtHome]

Great! All the best!

[@keerthana5461]

Can u share gst playlist for may24

[@StudyAtHome]

GST Playlist - kzbin.info/aero/PLyY2ccCWylAozEb7wfWYjPAJjCiKoNRP4

[@theboys1210]

25:15 mind blowing sir. Whenever i think I got a little grip on taxation, you become mirror for me like one in cindrella....

[@StudyAtHome]

Thank you so much for your kind words!

[@184PurviKelkar]

Aftet a long hectic day.. at the end when I watch your videos I not at only get knowledge but I also feel relaxed!! 👏🙏🙏🙏🙏 Aap great ho sir 🙏

[@khushibansal6080]

Good morning sir. Sir ap legend ho. Humare India ki apke jaise hi teachers ki zarurat hai. Apke lectures bahut hi jyada amazing hote hai. Thank you so much sir hm itna valuable content dena ke liye🙏

[@StudyAtHome]

Good Morning! Thank you so much for your kind words and I'm delighted to know that you find my lectures valuable!

[@rashmisinha7518]

i like it,it is much beneficial and easy to understand each point in a very deep sense.May god bless you...and it is request u r very knowledgeble person.gst is scoring pliz start its fresh lectures people will like it more ...and you will be highly recommended faculty for taxation...pliz start with fresh lectures....u will save many more attempts that students r facing with failure in taxation ....start teaching gst with new perspective in the new way..may god bless you

[@dilipnorton6465]

Understood the concept just because of your efforts sir🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@StudyAtHome]

Glad to know that!

[@rutujathakur2173]

Very good teaching!

[@StudyAtHome]

Thank you so much!

[@vanshgupta6397]

Thank you sir.❤❤

[@suryabalasubramani8476]

24:12 As there is no termination and no changes in the terms of the contract, the compensation received will not be treated as a business income. (Compensation received is for delay not for termination of contract or changes in the contract)

[@suryabalasubramani8476]

Ohh my god! I'm right 🎉

[@shadow-dz4de]

sir aapka padhaya to kya mst aasaani se sab deemag me jaata h....

[@anmolbajaj1178]

Salute 🫡 man maine Pw classes li par Sir your doing great job I have a vission If i become ca i will also give free lecture for students like me that have financial problems

[@StudyAtHome]

Glad to know that! Thank you! 😊🙌

[@kriparadhekrishn]

Yeah..... Stress free

[@ankitjha2]

Thank you so much sir 🙌

[@StudyAtHome]

Most welcome! 🙌

[@SandhyaO-jm9tg]

👏👏👏👏 25:37

[@demon04x]

Thank You sir ❤😌

[@StudyAtHome]

Welcome

[@kgrvkt]

Thank you so much Sir & Team.❣❣❣❣

[@StudyAtHome]

You're most welcome! 😊

[@SrishtiGoel14]

Thank you very much sir

[@A_Small_Seedling]

Thank you for the lecture

[@StudyAtHome]

Most Welcome

[@SanjitSaw-ih9lo]

Bohot bohot sukriya sir ❤

[@StudyAtHome]

Most welcome 😇

[@demon04x]

24:21 Taxable as the contract has provision for compensation in delay

[@demon04x]

wrong😢 But Still it a amount received relating to business why won't it be taxable??

[@StudyAtHome]

@@demon04x This penalty receivable would reduce our purchase cost which would automatically increase our profit.

[@zeeshankhan90122]

thank you sir you r a great teacher sir nice explaination with DEEP KNOWLEDGE

[@StudyAtHome]

That's so nice of you!😊

[@38nehasarkar65]

24:29 yes it is taxable

[@mr.chinmayajoshi2688]

Thank you very much for such a detailed class, Sir. Thanks to you, I am conversant with PGBP now❤🙏🙏🙏. God bless you, Sir.

[@StudyAtHome]

You are most welcome!😊

[@chittireddy2949]

Thank u sir ❤

[@sanyeuhsah]

Yes it is taxable point no 3 ans

[@getit2333]

❤❤❤

[@akashhazarika1922]

24:22 Point no:3 taxable

[@akashhazarika1922]

I was wrong

[@gamingfest4411]

Thank for your support

[@StudyAtHome]

You're Welcome! 😊

[@sonyjha7081]

Thanku so much sir ❤😊

[@StudyAtHome]

You're most welcome! 😄

[@ameetopiwala7255]

Thank you so much sir for the wonderful lecture 😊

[@StudyAtHome]

You're most welcome! 😊🙌

[@TaniyaYadav-x6w]

well explained sir thanku so much

[@StudyAtHome]

Most welcome

[@rishabhmishra4855]

Thank you sir for an wonderful session and everything was amazing

[@StudyAtHome]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@MOUNITAJANA-f4h]

Really sir you are creat a very smart question ❤

[@StudyAtHome]

Thank you!

[@nripendraku]

❤ Today class is also Awesome ❤

[@StudyAtHome]

Thank you so much! 😊

[@rajanikantaghadai7822]

Thanks sir a lot of thank sir.❤❤❤

[@StudyAtHome]

Most welcome

[@ameetopiwala7255]

Point 3 : yes sir taxable under head pgbp because it is business income

[@ameetopiwala7255]

Incorrect 😅

[@solfygaming9797]

24:38 taxable😊

[@laxmikantkshirsagar7941]

Very nice teaching sir

[@StudyAtHome]

Thank you so much!

[@priyankathakur9892]

Thank you sir for this amazing session 😄😊❤

[@StudyAtHome]

You're welcome 😊

[@shree8862]

thank you sir

[@StudyAtHome]

You're welcome!

[@naina5208]

19:31 sir in icai book nothing is written about revenue or capital receipt in this topic ??

[@MaxAgarwal007]

Yes, please reply sir

[@pranavsingh5572]

JUST AMAZIGN YOU ARE

[@StudyAtHome]

Thank you!

[@anuragmodi2251]

24:11, point no. 3 yes taxable hai

[@anuragmodi2251]

My answer is wrong, very smart question

[@Raadhe_shyam_7]

point 3 answer: AS ALL THE CONDITIONS written in the contract is being followed by the supplier , means there shall be no termination in the said contract . so on the conclusion note , not taxable under the income head PGBP.

[@priyanshuguptakartavyabatc2334]

Sir ji 3 rd point mai jo example hai n usami taxability nil hogi kyunki yaha pe contact terminate nhi hua hai n isliye aur usmai likha tha compensation received on termination and modification of T&C IN RELATION TO BUSINESS THEN TAXABLE AS A PGBP INCOME ❤ 24:27

[@priyanshuguptakartavyabatc2334]

I am right sir 😁😊 because aapne samjhaya ache se ❤😊

[@ayogesh789]

25:25 will the compensation taxable under IFOS then ? plz reply

[@StudyAtHome]

This penalty receivable would reduce our purchase cost which would automatically increase our profit.

[@ayogesh789]

Isn't it the treatment is same ?? Both are taxable in pgbp only .🤔

[@Travelwithsamar18]

new chapter start with ❤❤

[@StudyAtHome]

😊🙌

[@INDALCHOUDHURY-r1v]

Sir I am repeating the PGBP class

[@Aditi_noir]

24:13 taxable pt. 3

[@Aditi_noir]

I was wrong 😅

[@nripendraku]

❤ Good morning sir ❤

[@StudyAtHome]

Good morning! 🙌

[@rdxbihari1779]

Sir in point 3 's example that you ask,its answer is yes it is taxable under the head pgbp of rupees 100000(0.5% delay of each month of 10000000 for 2 months)

[@rdxbihari1779]

I GIVE WRONG ANSWER😟

[@Student_._.]

24:10 yes sir taxable hoga

[@Student_._.]

I'm wrong 😅

[@71shubhamtiwari49]

24:07 taxable nahi hoga as there is not any termination or modification

[@dibyajyotibose2370]

3.taxable

[@ankitjha2]

24:39 Points 3, Answer: Yes, It will be taxable

[@ankitjha2]

It's incorrect sir

[@LICBABA-k8y]

🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤❤super

[@StudyAtHome]

😄

[@monikadwivedi4939]

Sir wo compensation in business contract ke example me kya kisi bhi head me taxable ni hogi

[@plzunbox7763]

sir toh kya point 3 ka example kahi bhi taxable nahi hoga ki, IOS mea taxable hoga>> please clear

[@amberchhimwal9924]

24:24 point no. 3 it'll be taxable

[@amberchhimwal9924]

My answer is incorrect😅 It'll be non taxable

[@StudyAtHome]

It's okay!😊

[@plzunbox7763]

27:30 sir mera 3rd time hai>> first classes, 1 brief revision ,,, agian detail class from you

[@StudyAtHome]

Good!

[@urvisinghai4676]

sir if i get stock in trade free of cost then is it benifit /perquisite if yes then will it not be taxable twice once as Sale without booking puchase grossly taxable + as perquisite

[@ritikakumari3566]

Taxable

[@Vishwatanvi]

Example 3 ans is taxable under PGBP

[@Amitkumar-vl3dn]

point number 3 - taxable

[@Amitkumar-vl3dn]

i got wrong

[@urvisinghai4676]

sir in this qn u asked it is a case of RM so it is a revenue receipt so taxable even it is a breach of contract yes if it was a Capital receipt then breach would not have been taxable i think,so answer is it is taxable

[@rakhikumari9150]

Is this playlist applicable for cs executive dec 2025?

[@StudyAtHome]

Yes applicable, will add amendment lectures also to the playlist

[@rakhikumari9150]

@StudyAtHome so just by doing amendment lectures after completion of this playlist, we are all good for the exam?

[@Ashishkr2100]

24:12 will be taxable

[@Ashishkr2100]

i am wrong

[@nripendraku]

Point no 3 Ans. Taxable

[@nripendraku]

My answer is wrong

[@naina5208]

24:19 yes its taxable point 3 Wrong 😢

[@pavank5497]

Point no 3 : Not Taxable bcz not in nature of termination or modification of Contract..

[@pavank5497]

I am right 👍👍👍

[@StudyAtHome]

Good

[@INDALCHOUDHURY-r1v]

Sir delay in delivery is also modification of contract hona chahiye to. because time extension is required for live of the contract and liquidated damage is imposed. Sir e mera explanation hey, please galat hey to maf kijiyega.

[@sakshi3275]

Sir, is gst playlist fully updated?

[@StudyAtHome]

Yes!

[@khr295cshr]

Maine glt ans Kiya aapke question ka sir maine dekha hi ki contract modify or terminate bhi ho rha h ya nhi

[@priyankathakur9892]

3rd point- Taxable

[@priyankathakur9892]

Wrong ans 😅

[@sahilthakur447]

Point 3 Taxable in pgbp

[@sahilthakur447]

Wrong answer

[@JholaRam101]

Sir agar raw material ko ek month me deliver karna hai but delay ho gaya 5 din baad delivere hua aur is 5 din ka compensation supplier ne pay kiya to ye taxable hoga?

[@StudyAtHome]

Taxable hoga

[@deepakvishwakarma3730]

Point no. 3 this is taxable income under the head of pgbp

[@deepakvishwakarma3730]

I am wrong 😔

[@deepakvishwakarma3730]

I am trying my best

[@CallMeRandomGuy]

1st like ❤️

[@AfreenBano-cy9cw]

24:35 taxable Wrong answer

[@sachinbaghel1015]

example 3= taxable

[@sachinbaghel1015]

wrong answer

[@rawol9647]

Sir, ICAI collects registration fee from students is it also pgbp income? (Since we are not members of ICAI)

[@StudyAtHome]

Yes

[@souravmittu3333]

Compensation taxable

[@souravmittu3333]

My answer is wrong

[@anchalpandey7251]

Points 3 taxable

[@mdjahangiralam1009]

Sir taxable hoga

[@mdjahangiralam1009]

Wrong

[@abhibarthwal1529]

Sir apki video starting se dekh rha hu toh yha CMA students ke liya bhi applicable hai sara jo apne pdaya videos me ki CA ke study material ke according hai sare video plz reply

[@StudyAtHome]

These videos are applicable for CA/CS/CMA. So, you can watch this!

[@akularaviteja7825]

Sir I think that such compensation shall be taxable U/H PGBP

[@akularaviteja7825]

It's wrong😅

[@monikadwivedi4939]

Sir sec 28 (ii) (a) (b) (d) ke bare me explain kijiyena

[@sirishasiri4680]

Ans 3, its taxable

[@sudiptabera4387]

Ay classes CMA FINAL ka relevant hoga ?

[@StudyAtHome]

These are for Inter level but you can cover common topics from here.

[@basavarajpatil6240]

Chargeability : 1 to 5 Points

[@tanyasingh2955]

Hoga taxable 24:12

[@tanyasingh2955]

Wrong

[@tanyasingh2955]

Sir mera and galat hai but as such revenue of business to treat hoke taxable hoga hi na?

[@StudyAtHome]

Still, it will not be taxable.

[@HrishantShetty]

Point 3 it will be taxable under head pgbp

[@StudyAtHome]

👍

[@Lax_p14]

Is this vdo is applicable for Sep 24 attempt Plz reply sir

[@StudyAtHome]

Yes! The complete playlist is applicable for Sep. 2024 attempt. Check out the playlist: kzbin.info/aero/PLyY2ccCWylAq5C89aTwKEoMtNMwDqK93s

[@hamidraza7531]

point no.3 is taxable under PGBP. answer is incorrect but I am glad because i know my mistake ☺️.

[@CMAGUIDE9090]

3- NON TAXABLE

[@jaiganesh123456]

Isliye government should help tata to grow instead of ambani and adani

[@plzunbox7763]

sir ye toh point 3 karke jatka lag gya

[@nripendraku]

My answer was incorrect in respect of point number 3 sorry sir ये मेरे लिए बिल्कुल नया था

[@sonaliraninayak6615]

Point 3 :- this is taxable under the head PGBP.

[@sonaliraninayak6615]

I am wrong😢