A-10 BRRRT SOUND comparison | War Thunder vs SQUAD

[@K2Krabiwe]

they changed the sound after my video kzbin.info/www/bejne/hISpaWWfZsmUgNk

[@miroo7736]

"2 min ago" lol

[@supertrinigamer]

The new one sounds worse.... what the hell

[@chesnut-3918]

the sound in squad is still way more realistic with the sound of the impact playing before the gunfire itself

[@gtaxmods]

@@chesnut-3918 You can turn on the speed of sound in war thunder's settings.

[@SatelliteYL]

Wow, I did not expect the Squad one to be THAT good, that was amazing. What also stuck out to me was how good the sound of the jet engines overhead are in Squad. Pretty damn similar to what it sounds like on the ground in real life. The flyover so much more realistic that WT

[@LooperEpic]

Imagine that but being the target, under lots of fire and with artillery going off every 2 seconds. True squad experience right there

[@karatekoala7345]

Squad is a good game, but their sound design is what makes it a truly one of a kind experience. It spoiled me to every other game on the market. I play battlefield, and the guns and explosions just don't have the same oomph behind them.

[@raidzor5452]

Squad is still unrealistic. The plane in the video was coming TOWARDS the player, which means that if it fired for 2 seconds, and started firing at 750m distance(which it looks like from the video) and ended firing at 250m, this means that the start of the “brrrt” would start with around a 2.2 second delay from the start of rounds falling, and would end just 0.8 seconds after the rounds finished falling (calculated speed of sound). This means we would hear the impact for 2 seconds, but the “brrt” for just 1.4 seconds, which would be much higher pitched than it is in the video (as if playing it at 1.5x speed). It sounds realistic, because all the “brrrts” we heard were from vides filmed far away, where plane was travelling tangent to the filming person, and not towards or away. So it would’ve been realistic if the plane was firing a couple of kilometers away, not towards or away from the player, but in this case it doesn’t account for doppler shift. So it sounds like the videos on youtube, but NOWHERE close to real life in this case particularly. It’s just copy-paste audio.

[@therapist913]

@@raidzor5452 cool

[@thehaus6998]

You know that War thunder is played essentialy fully by players,the A10 is a player,unlike squad

[@polkovnik2823]

A-10 Insurgency Sandstorm

[@oboltussgaming6720]

Мне нравится А-10 в сандшторме, звук сочный, настоящий пельмень (но не когда он во вражеской команде)

[@vodkawjuice]

@@oboltussgaming6720 вообще звуки М134 и GAU-8 у них нормально получились. Люблю блэкхоки с рпг сбивать, смешно)

[@gameplayer0534]

A10 dcs

[@vodkawjuice]

@@gameplayer0534 мб

[@Frank-mc9lb]

friendly fire fxxk I am down

[@Eye5x5]

Damn the way you hear the impacts first and then the sound of the gun.

[@Eye5x5]

@Lohaon Yeah I know, it was just so realistic.

[@Its_Mango]

@@Eye5x5 when hearing that on the battlefield in Squad, I almost always get chills. It's definitely a moral boost when you're in a tight spot too!

[@drifterjack1937]

He doesnt have the setting "speed of sound" on, it makes it so that the Brrrt happens after the boolets. but yeah it do be quiet

[@condes9188]

Like people said before, if you hear the 30mm of the A-10, so you are not his target.

[@drifterjack1937]

@@condes9188ok but how does that have anything to do with what we're talking about

[@vhydra3705]

I did not even realize when the A-10 in war thunder fired lol

[@adriane8645]

Physics-wise with the sound of war thunder, it does not make sense how the sound of the gun brrrts first before the bullets raining, this should be fixed 💀

[@GothicHellhound]

They probably dont have the speed of sound on which is why it's doing that.

[@tenhoandersson]

WT has a setting to make sound travel at the correct speed

[@m1sz3lpl24]

It's already in the game, although speed of sound is optional setting with default at disabled, because people were bitching about it. Dude just forgot to turn it on

[@_aleda_]

There is a setting for it the person who made the videos is just not very smart and didn't turn it on

[@elliotsmith102]

@@GothicHellhound speed of sound sometimes just randomly doesn’t work for aircraft guns

[@CUL8TR]

What do you expect from a game where DShK's are louder than some cannons and explosions.

[@worldoftancraft]

It's DŠK. And they are DŠKs

[@PapaThad]

And 30mm being louder than a 120mm

[@Mirage-kr8mm]

​@@worldoftancraft he wrote that correctly, russian ш in ДШК is litterally sh in English

[@worldoftancraft]

@@Mirage-kr8mm when you loan French in English, do you replace Ch with Sh since "it's literally Sh in English" Or Spanish J is literally H in English? Oh, see, I know only Mojito. And it doesn't bother you. Just as Cartridge - dg thing doesn't make any sense in English. But not Russian. For Russian you need to turn on your creative and try being a language rather than a patchwork of European languages. Greek, Latin, French, German. What a good mix, and it surely combines great. And all of them don't have different spelling principles.

[@АнтонКолесников-ъ3х]

​​​​​@@worldoftancraftOkay... Did you say that Russian language is poor? Now do the same thing in your "rich" and beautiful language. make a story out of words starting with one letter. Moreover, the same connected story, where the words are not often repeated, and the story itself has plot repetitions and a denouement with a logical conclusion. Example from my Mother tongue Russian: Пётр Петрович Петухов, поручик пятьдесят пятого Подольского пехотного полка, получил по почте письмо, полное приятных пожеланий. «Приезжайте, - писала прелестная Полина Павловна Перепёлкина, - поговорим, помечтаем, потанцуем, погуляем, посетим полузабытый, полузаросший пруд, порыбачим. Приезжайте, Пётр Петрович, поскорее погостить». Петухову предложение понравилось. Прикинул: приеду. Прихватил полуистёртый полевой плащ, подумал: пригодится. Поезд прибыл после полудня. Принял Петра Петровича почтеннейший папа Полины Павловны, Павел Пантелеймонович. «Пожалуйста, Пётр Петрович, присаживайтесь поудобнее», - проговорил папаша. Подошёл плешивенький племянник, представился: «Порфирий Платонович Поликарпов. Просим, просим». Появилась прелестная Полина. Полные плечи прикрывал прозрачный персидский платок. Поговорили, пошутили, пригласили пообедать. Подали пельмени, плов, пикули, печёнку, паштет, пирожки, пирожное, пол-литра померанцевой. Плотно пообедали. Пётр Петрович почувствовал приятное пресыщение. После приёма пищи, после плотного перекуса Полина Павловна пригласила Петра Петровича прогуляться по парку. Перед парком простирался полузабытый полузаросший пруд. Прокатились под парусами. После плавания по пруду пошли погулять по парку. «Присядем», - предложила Полина Павловна. Присели. Полина Павловна придвинулась поближе. Посидели, помолчали. Прозвучал первый поцелуй. Пётр Петрович притомился, предложил полежать, подстелил полуистёртый полевой плащ, подумал: пригодился. Полежали, повалялись, повлюблялись. «Пётр Петрович - проказник, прохвост», - привычно проговорила Полина Павловна. «Поженим, поженим!», - прошептал плешивенький племянник. «Поженим, поженим», - пробасил подошедший папаша. Пётр Петрович побледнел, пошатнулся, потом побежал прочь. Побежав, подумал: «Полина Петровна - прекрасная партия, полноте париться». Перед Петром Петровичем промелькнула перспектива получить прекрасное поместье. Поспешил послать предложение. Полина Павловна приняла предложение, позже поженились. Приятели приходили поздравлять, приносили подарки. Передавая пакет, приговаривали: «Прекрасная пара».

[@betaripoff]

I mean to be honest, if the WT sound was too loud it would be harder to hear everything else on the ground. But I do agree that they need to fix it by at least making it a tad louder.

[@LilTachanka]

and a bit more brrrrrt-ier

[@maplearrow1842]

I mean it already is. You can’t hear anything if there’s more than three prop planes flying over you

[@sgtfoley2]

War games are supposed to be loud lmao

[@maplearrow1842]

@@sgtfoley2 not loud to the point you can’t hear anything because of the bad audio quality and the terrible way sounds overlap

[@machinech183]

@@maplearrow1842 Trust me when I tell you, that close to a GAU gun run you can't hear shit over it aside from HMGs, pops from NEARBY gunfire, and shit blowing up from start to finish of the run. That said Gaijin can barely manage to pull their collective head out of their ass on a monthly basis let alone manage audio quality. Taken them years to get aircraft even kind of right, and lets not get started on how many times they've waffled back an forth on gun and engines sounds.

[@batorkelecsenyi5304]

The most nostalgic Sound for me is the a10 from the old insurgency game, and I think its Still the Best. im glad that they done a great job in sandstorm too

[@untrust2033]

Insurgency 2014 is honestly one of the best games of all time IMO, wish more people still played it

[@RicoJuan1998]

wise man

[@yesseru]

If you want it to sound better, just enable the "speed of sound" setting. The "speed of sound" setting makes the sounds of planes and shit sounds better, it's worth it even tho it kinda laggy.

[@2ARM2]

Doesn't help. The game needs a full sound rework

[@interpl6089]

@@2ARM2 It has Sound Rework Like Every 2 Months, And They Change Everything From Good to Shit, From Shit to Good and Repeat...

[@R1tsu_Tyan]

Лмао, даже модовый А-10 в Арме звучит куда лучше. Отличная работа, Гайджины

[@klinpiece5714]

Мне кажется что танк на земле не уловил звук выстрела А-10

[@oboltussgaming6720]

@@klinpiece5714 бесшумные пушки От создателей бесшумных самолётах в 100 метрах от тебя и невидимых трассирующих пуль

[@TantalOfficial]

​@@klinpiece5714 Найди видео "A 10 saves my life" и перемотай его на 4:46

[@BigPadjik14i88]

В арме в целом все неплохо звучит

[@coolpaper1140]

@@BigPadjik14i88 Нет, нихрена нормально там ничего не звучит. Только в некоторых модах(не РХС и не КАП) всё более или менее звучит. Например СПР или Unsung. А так приходится ставить звуковые моды в которых куча своих погрешностей.

[@barsdogukankarakoyun8798]

if you have never played squad you cannot understand how fucking scary it is to hear an A-10 coming, and much scarier it is when you _don't_ hear it coming in until the rounds hit.

[@Alex_You]

Хз, а на что вы рассчитывали? Может вам и патч без багов выпустить?

[@StreetPunk161]

Совсем ахуели эти игроки, может им еще пофиксить баг с застреванием в воздухе?

[@СломаннаяШея]

У-у-у суки. А может им еще и нормальные карты с оптимизацией завести? Нормальную механику пробития и урона? А может начать прислушиваться к игрокам? Наглости нет предела!

[@Stormidze]

ну ты это... не перегибай

[@MannyXVIII]

THank you for the video ... just the reason I needed to start playing squad again. Damn that's amazing

[@Acid_Burn9]

БРРРРТ сам по себе так то сделан прилично, просто дальность, с которой его слышно, неадекватно низкая. В большинстве случаев слышны только попадания, но не сама стрельба. Подкрутить дальности и будет вкусно че бухтеть то🗿🗿🗿

[@messonair3280]

Да и скорость звука в настройках отключена, хотя мб показалось

[@K2Krabiwe]

@@messonair3280 включена скорость звука.

[@glebskachko1811]

Тогда и остальные звуки придётся поднять, а тогда уже будет каша. В squad основной шумовой фон это винтовки, а в War Thunder нон-стоп звуки ракет, истребителей, гаубиц и бомб.

[@TheArklyte]

Да пофиг им, главное впарили очередной аттракцион аля Ка-50. Люди говорят, что даже больше продаж выходит. Потом когда его начнут балансить и пойдет нытье будет здец:(

[@benjaminwatson7868]

That’s how you spell “BRRRRT” in russian

[@thelemon2764]

They straight up disrespected the A-10 in war thunder. Now I want to get back into squad just hearing that sound.

[@statelyelms]

Make sure you have Speed of Sound enabled for WT, that brrt and spray sounded simultaneous

[@null_entity472]

Epic Thunder: "Hold my GAU-8" _doesn't release for another 6 years_

[@krustykrew106]

And fury thunder. I swear their needs to be a new sound mod made by other people because these two aren’t doing anything Anymore and it’s frustrating

[@asnshadow616]

In the war thunder one it sounds like someone missed the toilet and pissed everywhere

[@plutoidrepublic2765]

you gotta say tho, war thunder's jet sounds are very interesting, especially when you get ur first 6.0 br plane and start hearing jets

[@hutchthelynx]

Squad-Sounds live for their perfection. You can even see the shockwave of an explosion far away and only hear it after its gone off.

[@raidzor5452]

Squad is still unrealistic. The plane in the video was coming TOWARDS the player, which means that if it fired for 2 seconds, and started firing at 750m distance(which it looks like from the video) and ended firing at 250m, this means that the start of the “brrrt” would start with around a 2.2 second delay from the start of rounds falling, and would end just 0.8 seconds after the rounds finished falling (calculated speed of sound). This means we would hear the impact for 2 seconds, but the “brrt” for just 1.4 seconds, which would be much higher pitched than it is in the video (as if playing it at 1.5x speed). It sounds realistic, because all the “brrrts” we heard were from vides filmed far away, where plane was travelling tangent to the filming person, and not towards or away. So it would’ve been realistic if the plane was firing a couple of kilometers away, not towards or away from the player, but in this case it doesn’t account for doppler shift. So it sounds like the videos on youtube, but NOWHERE close to real life in this case particularly. It’s just copy-paste audio.

[@gemtownMANCHURIA]

@@raidzor5452 holy shit you turbo nerd why did you copy paste this to every comment

[@JustTiger-ec4fs]

​@@raidzor5452damn, nice man

[@manofcultura]

Squad is PTSD simulator with its sound design.

[@momos_SDG]

My phone vibrated from how good that PRRRRRRRRRTT was,

[@socialistpastries.stooby]

They even added the hydraulics sound in sqaud

[@clownofwar]

not gonna lie the squad one gave me goose bumps.

[@Elgallo1107]

I don’t know how you make an a-10 in a game and don’t do the iconic sound the plane is famous for

[@seanstewart2344]

squad got it down right, love the delay

[@AugmentedGravity]

Doing it wrong vs doing it right.

[@charbird20]

Nothing in multiplayer games will ever be as satisfying as the real thing. The physics required to replicate it would be too laggy currently, but one day… one day we’ll get it right…

[@arthurofalsen2110]

I can tell you that I hear planes all the time where I live and they sound almost exactly like squad.

[@YouKnowThatGuy]

Bro needs to try the RCSM War Thunder sound mod

[@Kochie11]

Insurgency has the beefiest sound I’ve heard yet. And literally sends body parts flying

[@davidnewton2518]

WT's a10 just sounds like a learjet dropping a large tub of golf balls

[@Del80VR]

Insurgency sandstorm, argument won. That shit goes *BRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRT* hard enough to give me PTSD

[@danielmarsden4573]

I love the sound of supersonic depleted Uranium bullets in the morning

[@johan1740]

I haven't played squad, but I honestly get quite spooked when I hear the air straife in warzone, my hair stands on end

[@karbster1796]

oh my gode the sounds from SQUAD are gorgeous

[@Wolvenworks]

the lack of brrrrt in WT was....disturbing...like a KV2 that doesn't go BOOM. it makes anemic gun sounds (eg: small caliber guns in WoT) sound macho.

[@Tgnfishing]

Gaijin updated warthunder brrrt now it’s cold🥶

[@jordanr0419]

To be fair, In squad, the a-10 is a static callable tool, so it has volatility considering there’s no human input besides where it goes. In war thunder it’s controlled by a human so it makes much more room for error.

[@armadillo3454]

I thought war thunders sound wasnt bad but my god squads A-10 sounds beautiful

[@THEOPDESTROYER777]

last thing a couple soldiers didnt hear before the pilot tested to see if friendly fire was on

[@potato88872]

"My fucking guns goes BRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR" Cynaide

[@terrified057t4]

Gaijin legit just took 20mm and made it _louder_

[@nadhifsaputra7310]

Project reality:"done playing with call-ins airstrikes?"

[@Jarda-di4gd]

My reaction seeing and most importantly hearing the A10 in the action in WarThunder for the first time - "DISAPPOINTEEEEEEEED!!!"

[@davidcastillo6835]

War thunder A10 engines: 🗿 War thunder A10 GAU-8: 🤡

[@sterben7656]

wt just sounds like what you hear in airsoft

[@hellothere9167]

Warthunder sounds like someone had tacobells for a week

[@H1y0haTheF1rst]

Ah, this sweet and gentle "Brrrrr"😌

[@theocelot3957]

Youve heard in squad. Now lets proceed to insurgency sandstorm please

[@patrickradcliffe3837]

I think that goes to sound sample each developer used, they are both GAU-8 sounds.

[@Beriothien007]

If you heard the BRRRRRTTT you werent the target.

[@werewolfgamer115]

Now let's hear the bo2 A-10 warthog

[@gamefunmoment4074]

the guy in the tank:"is that all?"

[@Nepomniachtchi_Austin]

The best part is the sound of the Avenger's 30mm rounds burying themselves through the target and into the dirt.

[@lucasmiller5977]

That’s almost perfect, I’m tempted to play that game now

[@k_anuargg2083]

В скваде прям классно звучит

[@Montgomer5678]

Да, особенно когда ты слышишь звук после отстрела, а не до.

[@bcmshm1659]

Impossible to hear that and not smile… unless of course it was intended for you

[@ekkovaan2261]

Man Rising Storm 2s distant A-10 fire followed by the bullets eventually begining to impact the ground feels good tho. *brrrrrrrrrr... *shishishishishishishishi...

[@Z4rius]

That sounded like my shorts tearing apart

[@crinoxum6549]

Squad is meant for an immersive and realistic milsim experience while war thunder is a free ww2 arcade game what do you expect

[@youngk4455]

By far the most terrifying thing in squad

[@verpmentv8941]

If you hear this outside your house and nothing happend to you, your the lucky person or not the target.

[@DeltaOperationOfficialYT]

truly a "BRRRRRRRR" moment

[@frightfulbuffalo7081]

DCS: Give me your ears and I will give you freedom.

[@yoesoef4902]

Have u turn on the Speed Of Sound in the sound setting?

[@K2Krabiwe]

Yes. This option is enabled.

[@yoesoef4902]

@@K2Krabiwe it might be bugged, if im turning that on, the Gun firing is gone

[@vezzzzz]

thx the first clip gave me crippling depression

[@ДанькаПупанька]

У меня после шавухи звуки как в ВТ, можёт там и записали?

[@Smoothie-Cr1minal]

Attack the D point!

[@ilhamshobri461]

game that just recicle a lot of same sound effect vs game that actually has attention of detail for sound

[@muhammad5379]

The war thunder A-10 is me after taco bell

[@TotallyNotShiny_Stone]

I didn't even hear the Brrrrrr in War Thunder...

[@skyeshepherd6341]

How does everyone forget about DCSWorld? If you want a true A-10 sim experience, that’s where you get it.

[@blinks942]

It's the gun sound, DCS World has pretty unrealistic sounds for the guns

[@potcupcake]

Squad does everything right

[@hunkre3268]

Insurgency sandstorm: Подержите моё пиво

[@crayonchomper1180]

in essence it is the comparison between Fallout's minigun and TF2's minigun

[@loganthesaint]

That second one was nasty AF.

[@rem520]

Jesus, Squad really killed it

[@davidwas77]

I was not expecting that aftershock 😩😩

[@Exotio_]

Fun fact: If you hear an A-10 shooting its gun, that means you're not the target.

[@karmatic2793]

Inaccurate, not enough friendly fire.

[@snaH20]

in war thunder it just sounds like a painful fart

[@ZenithPeak1]

*INSURGENCY SANDSTORM HAS ENTERED THE CHAT*

[@LeonTReal]

You gotta check the A-10's sound in Insurgency: Sandstorm, it's amazing

[@ddsplayzz]

Yeah, war thunder's a10 gun needs updated sounds

[@rxse8208]

A10 in warthunder sounds like a BB gun😭

[@protonicusarchon]

War Thunder violated the law when using A10 Brrt Brrt sound.

[@321GhostRider123]

And once again we see how arcade WT is

[@yonkies4543]

The A10 in Black Ops 2 sounds pretty horrifying

[@AzureKaioshin]

If I were a sound designer and didn't have the budget or access to a synthesiser. I would just take a stock clip of a fog horn from a steamboat and stutter the hell out of it.

[@mantic1008]

Ah yes the SQUAD the game that made you have PTSD after playing the game

[@draconex1]

Remember people if you hear the brrrt it means you aren't the target

[@mentalpatriot636]

In my opinion, the A-10 in Insurgency Sandstorm sounds the most accurate.

[@boogieloogie3150]

dcs world i think has a good one too

[@FarawayConjunction30]

Экипаж скорпиона: Ой а что щас было, а ла все нормально можем сидеть дальше

[@RyanTheRagster]

Squad sounds like real life

[@they_callme_goat]

The thumbnail is even better than the video

[@miakodakot7359]

Also make the comparison between SQUAD and Insurgency: Sandstorm A-10 BRRRRT

[@SlavJerry]

huge flaw in war thunder sound design is that it compresses the loudness when loud and a sound louder than current environment is played, which basically makes nothing sounds impactful