A Blistering Response To My Detractors

[@FaridOmarzadeh-om]

I keep saying, and let me say it one more time, And I advice myself first brothers and sisters - Whatever Salah is, if you do not know it - please do not discuss it... Please do not let personal conflicts to get into the matter, There are so many things I do not know - and when I do not know I just simply do not discuss them

[@MahirAliAhmed]

Great video, took me 6 days to finish, Now I will watch again to make notes. Thank you so much

[@Unbelievable-yf6en]

But you can tell baba Shuab doesn’t want to admit to the truth because he already collected money for the Quran he created

[@ninimusta336]

Thank you brother...Im learning slowly but I am learning 😊

[@SomeofThisSomeofThat]

45:42 “When you recite the Quran, seek refuge with Allah from Satan, the accursed” Surah 16:98. Now does this mean to actually SAY that out loud…its not clear from here but it is an intention from the heart. There are several verses on recitation including the time of day when to recite. You are falsely assuming that we are supposed to recite for somebody else or for Allah - which is why you said “recite for who.” You recite for yourself for remembrance.

[@TheQuranExplainsItself]

None of the verses you’re referring to is addressing anyone but the messenger. He’s specifically referring to the verses that speak of reciting the Quran and establishing salat. Who’s that recited to? At least be half as educated as hamza in this topic before attempting to “correct” him.

[@A_Learner123]

Salam , do y’all still have in person meetups?

[@surul-aynawali641]

Salam Brother Hamza if you don't believe in the ritual Salat then what do you do in the times of Salat mention in 11:114 and 17:78 please kindly respond thank you

[@Unbelievable-yf6en]

Brother please read the context of that verse and see what what commandments (salat) Allah is asking you to uphold or establish?

[@surul-aynawali641]

I see so you don't have an answer thank u

[@surul-aynawali641]

Expected

[@Unbelievable-yf6en]

@@surul-aynawali641of course expected because you have your mind made up that salah is ritual if that the case your in wrong channel I suggest you go watch baba Shuab, his the hybrid between Sunna and Quran alone

[@TheQuranExplainsItself]

It’s only addressing the messenger and the only thing it’s ever associated to is reciting the Quran TO THE PUBLIC. Still think you have an argument?

[@Haneefan-Musliman]

Salaam brother Hamza, I pray that Allah blesses you, and keeps you good health. I wanted to first of all say that my latest video on 'Al-Huda' was NOT a personal attack on you my brother! Yes, I did mention your views / opinions regarding the subject, but I did not want to mention you by name because of the love and respect that I have for you. I was simply trying to point out that I repectfully disagreed with your stance on guidance (hudan). I made the video in response to a personal struggle I'm currently going through (going through a painful divorce). And this put me into a dark place, and I've been thinking about Allah's guidance alot lately. When I said: "we should put aside our pride and arrogance", I meant this in a 'general' sense. Notice that I said 'WE' & 'OUR' - and did NOT say YOU! As in, YOU need to put away your pride and arrogance. I said 'WE' need to put away our pride, so I'm including MYSELF into the statement! I did NOT make this statement directly at you my brother. Just like with brother Baba Shuaib's statement: "Lets expose the hypocrites among us concerning Salat" I'm pretty certain that brother Shuaib did NOT make that statement as a personal attack on you brother Hamza. Either way, if I have offended you in anyway (which was certainly NOT my intention), I sincerely apologize. I've watched so many of your videos and learned alot from you. And I will certainly continue watching your amazing videos. Just because I disagree on your view on 'guidance', doesn't mean we should be enemies. I mean, look at what happened to Jake Brancatella! Is he currently on guidance since becoming a Mushrik (Ahlus Sunnah)? And what about brother Joseph from the Quran-Centric channel?? They obviously slipped back into darkness, and they're in soo much need of guidance! Take care my brother. Nej

[@anamulran7970]

Is Joseph a Ahlus Sunnah too? For guidance or hudan.......... the first condition is not reciting Fathia, but to clear your mind of any partners beside Allah. Then you can recite Fatiha one time. You may not need to recite it every day. If Brancatella and Joseph didn't put "Allah Alone" in their hearts, then their slipping back into darkness was bound to happen sooner or later. For instance, taking modern so-called science as God.....i. e "scientism,"...like evolution "theory"....etc. There are so many traps laid out by the devil that if you admit any authority other than Allah, you will be in trouble and misguided.

[@Haneefan-Musliman]

​@@anamulran7970no, Joseph has become Christian! But, i hear what you're saying and may Allah bless you.

[@FaridOmarzadeh-om]

I 100% Agree with you brother, If we really wanna grow - we should keep an open mind regarding some matters, I myself have seen many wrong things from our brothers in different channels- But I usually keep quite so that perhaps with passing of time they would realize it themselves - No one is infallable - but we strive for minimum error

[@FaridOmarzadeh-om]

Brother Hamza, The Jews do not have Azra - in 9:30 the word that Allah uses is "Ibn" ابن and not Walad ولد - this word can have a different meaning than word "Walad" which Only Christians use for prophet Jesus son of Mary ... for example Jews and Christians also claim to be Allah's "Ibn" in 5:18

[@turningtide15]

Is Uzeir actually Osiris, rather than Ezra?

[@FaridOmarzadeh-om]

َAllah uses word "Ibn" and not "Walad" for Azra in 9:30 - Allah uses same word "Ibn" for Christains and Jews in 5:18, it can have a different meaning here - Only Christians use word "Walad" for prophet Jesus son of Mary

[@salihthemonotheist6700]

He never responded to my videos on the commitment or answer to the pig ?

[@TheoWrigt]

Refutation of the spiritual sujood… What did the “hudhud” see when he reported back to Solomon about the Queen and her people doing sujood to the sun? Did he see a physical activity? And if yes, then what kind of physical activity? Is it a ritual, Or what? If you say it wasn’t a physical activity, then I will need to know how did the “hudhud” intuit a spiritual activity? Because we know that only God know the intents and the innermost thoughts, so does the “hudud” have a share with the characteristics of God? And if you admit that it is a ritual you have to admit that sujood is also a ritual because when the “hudhud” reported back he identified the deed as sujood so it’s the common sujood well-known by the believers, only this one was done for the sun wrongfully. P.S: IF you ignore the argument and instead of tackling it head on you divert to some other issue, your maneuver will be futile, because we can’t both be right at the same time, so either you refute my argument or concede. I don’t see that you have any other choice because if you offhand dismiss it then you are just cherry picking the Quran.

[@383564]

why do you copy and paste this bs everywhere you go...i answered you in the comments on another video and you ran away

[@nourish5585]

You're comparing your ritual to a mushrick's prayer. Give your head a shake.

[@TheoWrigt]

@ Is solomon a mushrik? Because HE identified it AS sujood

[@FaridOmarzadeh-om]

@@nourish5585 No one is called mushrik for performin a ritual - Brothers please do not throw labels at each other out of emnosity of without knowledge - If you do not know something perhaps just leave it for the time until its knowledge comes to you , and do not let amnosity block you from the Truth "Surely those who believe, and those who are Jews, and the Christians, and the Sabians, whoever believes in Allah and the Last day and does good, they shall have their reward from their Lord, and there is no fear for them, nor shall they grieve" 2:62 "The Jews say, ‘The Christians stand on nothing,’ and the Christians say, ‘The Jews stand on nothing,’ and they are readers of the Book. Those who had no knowledge, said similar to what they say. Allah will judge between them on the Day of Resurrection concerning which they used to differ on" 2:113

[@FaridOmarzadeh-om]

brothers, I advice you and myself , If we do not know something - perhaps we should just keep studying the Quran until it becomes clear to us

[@bala147]

Abdulah is the worshipper of Allah.

[@Scumophobe]

Wrong, abdullah is Servant of God

[@EyePonder]

Surah Al Nahl, Ayah 98 is about seeking Allah's refuge when recite Quran. Respected Sir, you might have to make correction or your friends will respond soon & Jam up! Lol!. Rest is amazing, thanks

[@FaridOmarzadeh-om]

Brother Abd does not mean Slave, Abd is someone who has a lord (Rabb) take a look at 10:90, even *the attempt by pharoah to make Children of Israel as his slaves* is defined as BAXI بغی and we know BAZI بغی is forbidden in Islam - The word Raqabaten from root Ra Qa Ba is also not a slave, Raqabaten رقبه literaly means "an observant" ... for example Allah is AL-Raqeeb over us

[@FaridOmarzadeh-om]

That's why Slavery is Forbidden in Islam, for example Humans can choose to do IBadah to Allah or Satan, so it can not be Slavery, because there is no Choice in Slavery -- the only exception is 26:22 where Moses adresses Pharoah that you have عبدت (Forced IBadah) on Children of Israel and that is exactly Slavery

[@FaridOmarzadeh-om]

"And those who, when they are reminded of the Ayat of their Lord, fall not deaf and blind thereat" 25:73

[@FaridOmarzadeh-om]

There are so many reasons someone would like to be submissive to another human being, one common reason could be wealth and money - but if someone forces that IBadah on them like what Pharoah did in 26:22 well that is forbidden - in fact even the *attempt to do such thing* as defined in 10:90 by Pharoah would be a form of BAXI بغی and we know BAXI بغی is forbidden That form of submission should also have limits, there should not include any types of *FAWAHESH* or what is against *MARUF* and other parameters defined in the Qur'an in various verses .

[@FaridOmarzadeh-om]

someone might point out to 2:178 for the matter of Qisas - it that verse Allah says if "Free committed the crime, the Free should be taken into Qisas" or if "Abd committed the crime, the Abd should be taken into Qisas" , etc -- Take a look at 17:33

[@FaridOmarzadeh-om]

"It is not for a human [prophet] that Allah should give him the Scripture and authority and prophethood and then he would say to the people, *Be IBads to me rather than Allah* but [instead, he would say], “Be pious scholars of the Lord because of what you have taught of the Scripture and because of what you have studied.” 3:79 in the verse above people have *the choice and free will* to be someone’s IBAD, so it can not possibly mean being a slave

[@salliejackson5216]

Salaam Alaikum Hamza Abdul Malik! Please include me on the next Zoom Invite. Thank you

[@Unbelievable-yf6en]

Baba shuab is deluded

[@lillianbeverly-rosario1753]

Stop brother you not as smart as you think and you don’t know Arabic stop please