You know… once a year we have a hot summer with green parks in Russia. Why winter again?
@brainflash19 ай бұрын
You do know this story takes place over decades, right?
@Maria_Bar9 ай бұрын
@@brainflash1 and you do know that in 30 years there must be 30 Summers, Springs and Autumns?
@brainflash19 ай бұрын
@@Maria_Bar And I'm sure they could fit all of those into seven episodes. And NOTHING significant could possibly happen in Winter time.
@brainflash19 ай бұрын
@@Maria_Bar And please tell me about all the major plot points that you know happened in the summer? Because you obviously read the book.
@igorroshkovsky89489 ай бұрын
@@brainflash1 What about Battle for Moscow when germans and French Legion Charlamaine was beaten ?
@astroantares9 ай бұрын
The film is from people who have seen Moscow only in pictures and do not know what a "gentleman" is
@apocalypticdaze21399 ай бұрын
Nor do they know of a Russian dialect by choosing an actor who only knows 2
@praguhbis9 ай бұрын
Gentleman smacks is classist and inhumane. Basically you approve of slave owners.
@Renwoxing138 ай бұрын
● Your using the wrong definition of gentleman, in your assessment. - [ I thought the trailer made that clear, but apparently not ! ] - ■ "GENTLEMEN" Rather than an attitude or personality type in this movie, and context historically is rather : ★ A Class In our Caste System. Rich, doesn't need to work, etcetera. = GENTLEMEN!¡!
@apocalypticdaze21398 ай бұрын
@@Renwoxing13 the root word of gentle-man is from gentile.. A term, somewhat like that of goy, is a descriptor for any man not of Jewish origin or caste. So, the term gentleman was infact a marker for those entities or manipulators within this construct who determined themselves separate to the other men of the world, those gentile-men.
@t3hpenguinofd00m7 ай бұрын
What are you talking about? The main character is literally an aristocrat. That's the exact definition of a "gentleman".
@alesdraco91969 ай бұрын
The Americans decided to send a spy to the Soviet Union. So they chose one person. His legend was developed brilliantly. He thoroughly learned the Russian language up to correct accent. And here he is, dressed in a hat with earflaps and a padded jacket, thrown into the forest, not far from the village. He comes out of the forest comes up to the hut and says: - Grandma, give me some water to drink. Grandma answers him: - And you, my dear, wouldn’t happen to be a spy? - Where did you get the idea? - There have never been any blacks in our area.
@squamish42449 ай бұрын
Yeah yeah yeah. Tokenism. And obligatory comment about how horrifying it is and ruins everything. Work on your material.
@JewlenskyBot-d6c9 ай бұрын
@@squamish4244Russia never bought and sold Africans, only Americans did. 😂
@squamish42449 ай бұрын
@@JewlenskyBot-d6cRussia bought some black Africans from the Ottoman Empire. The aristocracy used them as servants, as they were curiosities.
@JewlenskyBot-d6c9 ай бұрын
@@squamish4244 some? 😂 That's why Russia is full of diversity like slave-Americans? 😂
@anastasiasheremetieva9 ай бұрын
@@squamish4244данные люди были свободны в России. И стали очень богатыми
@dandreer31509 ай бұрын
The trailer could've been wonderful if it weren't for one "little" distortion of history: Africans in Russia! Except for famous individuals like Abram Petrovich Gannibal (great-grandfather of Alexander Pushkin), there have never been large communities of Africans in Russia/Soviet Union as there are in the US and other Western countries. How do I know this? Well, my mother is from the former Soviet Union and one of the stories she told me of her life there was when she was a child, a football (soccer) team from some African country came to participate in a match in the USSR and passed through her town. Their arrival became an instant spectacle because neither my mother nor anyone in her town had ever seen a black person! I even showed her this trailer and the first question she immediately asked was "Why are there blacks?". If this historical distortion keeps up in American cinema, Russian films and TV series taking place in the US will be much more accurate
@Svezhaja_struja9 ай бұрын
Only one little distortion of history???? 😂😂😂😂 This piece of crap... hm, creativity is inaccurate to the core!
@astroantares9 ай бұрын
The entire trailer consists of historical mistakes. Russians who watch it see Lincoln on a dinosaur with a bazooka and the white house in which Ronald Reagan is fighting for power with Capone
@dandreer31509 ай бұрын
@@astroantares Yes, I also noticed other mistakes besides the presence of black people, but this one was the most striking.
@retro21039 ай бұрын
This is because most British movie productions have decided to follow the rules of stage acting where skin tone is just glossed over. If they were to follow historical accuracy to the letter than the only roles for black people in typical historical dramas would be as servants and slaves, so in order for them to have a shot at a variety of roles, casting has become 'colorblind'. Whether it will always be like this or if it's an overcorrection that will eventually settle down as perhaps more stories that are centred around black characters become more common place, remains to be seen.
@MichaelBeeny9 ай бұрын
To be politically correct these day, blacks have to be represented in every movie and TV program. Does not matter if their inclusion is relevant or not.
@ЕленаВ-д8ю9 ай бұрын
Клюква)) ну у иностранцев всегда своя вымышленная Россия. Поэтому они нас никогда не раскусят)
@arseniinickulin78099 ай бұрын
Будто отечественном творчестве не свой манямир с тоннами исторических ошибок и пропагандистским уклоном. Но да произведение само по себе странное и даже для альтхистори как-то не очень убедительное.
@tonysoprano78979 ай бұрын
кому ты нужен, тебя кусать
@31pas09 ай бұрын
Скрепные гомоэротические фантазии глубинного народа как всегда на месте. Укусят тебя иностранцы, укусят, не переживай
@krab28639 ай бұрын
@@tonysoprano7897 Да вроде как весь мир успокоится не может
@criolla109 ай бұрын
Not all foreigners, in South America we study World history,Geography. We have had many studying in Russia. Many we visited Russia, we took the train to travel inside Russia. Clean, no crime. The book is good, the series are Hollyweird version.
@Rus_Di9 ай бұрын
Нас ждёт отборная клюква господа.
@aleksivanova12879 ай бұрын
... и все равно до Великой не дотянет)
@sailorv80679 ай бұрын
@@aleksivanova1287 Великая хоть официально клюква, всё же не Красный воробей)
@IronRabbit67119 ай бұрын
Ну да, они(англосаксы) как джокер, а мы(русские) как бэтмен, зачем они пытаются нас уничтожить? Что они будут без нас делать? Снова станут прикалываться над неграми, скучно же. Могут же про нас кучу всего отснять, как хорошего, так и плохого.
@dmitryti97019 ай бұрын
Минусы будут?))
@Svezhaja_struja9 ай бұрын
Это даже не клюква, а какая-то перебродившая смородина.
@chubbymcphattz9 ай бұрын
Silly me, I thought Black Russians were cocktails.
@Mr.Sandevistan9 ай бұрын
And I thought Russians spoke Russian with a Russian accent instead of English with a British accent. Silly me
@tron20078 ай бұрын
It turns out that all the blacks from all over Russia were brought to work in this one hotel.
@comraderoyalguard46998 ай бұрын
@@tron2007 pretty silly.
@Trissana2818 ай бұрын
actually, Russians had the first black general, died in 1781, his name was Adam Petrovich Gannibal/Haniball, he was brought to Russia as a slave, previously owned by Turks/Ottomans, for tzar Peter the Great who gave him freedom and made him his godson. He was later on not only general, but also engineer and ancestor to russian great author Pushkin
@HomeschoolPromQueen8 ай бұрын
Russia is pretty awesome
@jrm23838 ай бұрын
The historical accuracy is amazing! The black man with dreads is spot on!
@MrAnton0137 ай бұрын
Many black people left USA and went to Russia (USSR). Paul Robeson, a black singer said when was in Russia "Here I am not a Negro but a human being for the first time in my life ... I walk in full human dignity." USSR was maybe the least racist country in the world at the time.
@ChuckHolland-i4b7 ай бұрын
And the Indian barber. Talk about cultural appropriation. Look, make a movie about a period and put the wrong caste of characters, the spell is broken. None of the actors even look Slavic.
@elenasmart17347 ай бұрын
And once again the Americans proved that they cannot make a film about Russia and the Soviet Union. , as always, their Soviet Union is terrible and America is so wonderful, where everyone just dreams of going, in their opinion. Everything in this film is not believable, everything is American style. Only Ewan McGregor tried to convey the Russian nobleman well
@jrm23837 ай бұрын
@@elenasmart1734 Russia was a horrible place during this period, and if you don’t know that, you need to read up on it a little bit
@rectotexto45866 ай бұрын
@@MrAnton013 en 1915 ?!
@WhiteDragon_889 ай бұрын
У нас не было ревущих 20-ых годов, как на западе. В России надо было поднимать страну. Люди читали, работали. Если это 1920 год, то это еще Ленин. Сталин пришёл позже. Так что это обычная фантастика с Оби-Ван Кеноби. А не исторический роман.
@дмитрийчеканов-б1х9 ай бұрын
Сталин конечно был соратником Ленина и важной фигурой, уже на тот момент его можно было считать отцом-основателем РСФСР и следовательно Российской Федерации, именно Сталин был против существования отдельных республик, он был за их включение в состав РСФСР. Но какой там у них Сталин, я даже не хочу смотреть..... Если и у нас показать реального Сталина просто неспособны.
@vadikgg45379 ай бұрын
Как сказать...20е -угар НЭПа. Как писал современник: А когда ночью светит месяц, Когда светит... черт знает как! Я иду, головою свесясь, Переулком в знакомый кабак. Шум и гам в этом логове жутком, Но всю ночь напролет, до зари, Я читаю стихи проституткам И с бандюгами жарю спирт.
@passerbyworld9 ай бұрын
Это даже не фантастика. А просто бред малообразованных людей
@passerbyworld9 ай бұрын
Это не фантастика. Это просто чушь
@toddr.doherty13349 ай бұрын
@@дмитрийчеканов-б1хI might be misunderstanding you, but, this doesn't seem to jive with Stalin's "National Question".
@innapaint29229 ай бұрын
God, what cranberries, eternal winter, foam snow, black woman hotel administrator.
@holm9119 ай бұрын
... so what ... people loves vodka __________________
@sarahtobore28329 ай бұрын
And somehow the English accent goes unnoticed? Nice
@endless_art9 ай бұрын
То есть переход от октябрьской революции в 1917 до Сталина в 1930 за три(!) года, да еще и без главенства пролетариата, вопросов не вызывает?
@Sherlok099 ай бұрын
@@endless_artя прям засмеялся, когда плакат со Сталиным увидел
@criolla109 ай бұрын
A farce from a good book.
@felegyhazifilmklub9 ай бұрын
This is purely fiction. This kind of styling is SO different from the 20's in Soviet-Union.
@patryot56688 ай бұрын
for sure explains the ridiculous DEI casting..but we must qualify for awards mustnt we? ..They should be ashamed they keep doing this idiocy just to appeal to blue haired weirdos
@comraderoyalguard46998 ай бұрын
A horrific famine is going on and : "Oooh, banana sundae for everyone!"
@Obsidian-Nebula8 ай бұрын
It's not a historical film, nor was it meant to be
@AndRei-yc3ti8 ай бұрын
@@Obsidian-Nebula yes but even then you don't put blacks in 1920's russia lmao
@Pleasant_exe4 ай бұрын
@@comraderoyalguard4699If you watched the show the hotel is more of a fake example of Russia, where foreign or rich people go, they were always stocked and they don't have any idea of the famine because the hotel always has food etc Literally later on in the show you see how it really is outside the hotel.
@CevernuiPushnoiZvereK9 ай бұрын
Да....Судя по данному трейлеру фильма, это просто "шедевр" американского "киноискусства". Ребята прекращайте курить и употреблять тяжёлые наркотики. А хотя, продолжайте...После выхода фильма King’s man: начало - про танцующего Распутина и всего остального, что вы могли себе вообразить про Россию, я ничему не удивлён. Как же всё таки, низко пало образование в США.
@SHKIESAMA9 ай бұрын
Why western people keep making shit about Russia? During the Cold War USSR made a lot of movies about US, but all of them were respectful and focused on best in the people. Do you remember any western movie that is respectful to Russians?
@ALALSK199 ай бұрын
👏👏👏
@31pas09 ай бұрын
Uhh.. where was the shit exactly?
@saintheather31659 ай бұрын
До окончания Великой Отечественной в САСШ такие фильмы снимали, потом повестка резко поменялась.
@@ilyaandreevichg Uuuuh, endless winter and darkness are kinda a thing, considering, for example, how many sun hours Moscow gets in December - a couple years back, it was 0.5. Like 30 minutes of sun in a month. So yeah, nailed that. And commies... Can't comment on that nowadays, because you know. But anyway, it's just a setting; don't get so defensive.
@misterspray73239 ай бұрын
I had no idea that they'd brought this to the screen. It's a great book. I had brunch in the main dining room with a very good friend of mine 20 years ago with my newly adopted, 7-month-old son in a basket on the floor next to our table.
@Jack-db6se9 ай бұрын
Мало клюквы в трейлере. Где пьяные медведи в ушанках? Почему красноармейцы в буденовках не черные?? Надеюсь, в самом фильме все это будет...
@БК48359 ай бұрын
Где Мишка с балалайкой я вас спрашиваю?
@bobo-cc1xw9 ай бұрын
True Russian comment.
@alexxx44349 ай бұрын
Действительно, не хватает как-то этнического разнообразия и голубых.
@JohnAmend-All9 ай бұрын
Квота на голубых выбрана сценаристами.
@marinebymistake9 ай бұрын
What really is missing from this movie is a depiction of russians invading other countries and occupating them. Cry more, ivan, clearly you don't have much more important problems
@unik4289 ай бұрын
Black person in Civil War time Russia...right.. And the main character surname was Rostov? FFS! Leave Leo Tolstoy alone! You wouldn't believe it, but there are more surnames in Russia than mentioned in War and Peace, and Anna Karenina.
@russkiishpion88928 ай бұрын
I mean with his name, this is from the book. The rest, not so much.
@ABCDEF-br6it8 ай бұрын
It’s based on the novel
@caitlintiulenev91568 ай бұрын
Google “Pushkin.” Their famous poet is half black. Your American ignorance is showing.
@StanT-y8g7 ай бұрын
@C.ODoherty entitled? Who decided that? Get lost...
@karugs90327 ай бұрын
@C.ODoherty 🤡
@MrNotipus9 ай бұрын
Has the Assange story been moved to an alternate universe?
@starofdabloc9 ай бұрын
No i think Alexei Navalny in Russia fits just fine 😏
@Vlad-sv8tz9 ай бұрын
@@starofdabloc Assange was the first case, so why do you blame Russians that they just copy the American practice?
@ampm58999 ай бұрын
@@starofdabloc Navalnyi was not a gentleman. Although, there are no gentlemen in the UK either nowadays. Brits dont behave… they are not gentle, you know. Never been, actually. 😂
@starofdabloc9 ай бұрын
@@ampm5899 and Putin is? Lmao ok bot 😂 everything you said about the British is correct, and?
@starofdabloc9 ай бұрын
@@Vlad-sv8tz Assange is still alive lol
@modesteux9 ай бұрын
The American vision of Russia has never ceased to amaze for centuries! It's clear why people don't understand why Russians do certain things, because you have your own kind of Russia! LOL
@andpinto15 ай бұрын
Doesn't that happen with all countries? What about the Russian vision of America, isn't it just as ridiculous?
@tp64392 күн бұрын
Every person who’s never visited a country or lived through its past has a distorted version of how it is/was. History is written by the victors. Cinema is made for entertainment.
@ablorenz9 ай бұрын
What's a black man with dreads doing in Moscow during the 1920s? You could've went on and put a few Bangladeshis there as well.
@kityacat54198 ай бұрын
There were SOME black people in Russian Empire. We never were involved in slave trade, so we had pretty descent relationships with African countries. Don't know about dreads tho
@tamzy48258 ай бұрын
When seen the black guy, was hopeing my dentist popped up sadly not guess no Asians was allowed there only the main man
@sidharthcs21108 ай бұрын
Alexander Pushkins had black ancestry. There was a black man in Peter the Great's staff. Not sure about the dreadlocks though..
@ablorenz8 ай бұрын
@@sidharthcs2110 That's an exceptional case. Not sure if there was more than a 1,000 combined blacks in Moscow back then.
@sweetbabyjesus65168 ай бұрын
You'd find that the Bangladeshis would have to be played by blacks, too.
@elnomio9 ай бұрын
At least now I understand the source westerners knowledge of Russia and USSR specifically.
@astroantares9 ай бұрын
The entire trailer consists of historical mistakes. Russians who watch it see Lincoln on a dinosaur with a bazooka and the white house in which Ronald Reagan fights with Capone with lightsabers.
@rosetiler9 ай бұрын
as a native russian I totally agree, but it might actually be entertaining if the show doesn't take itself too seriously :)
@КириллИгоревич-щ8ь9 ай бұрын
Весьма неплохое сравнение😂
@chigeryelam40619 ай бұрын
Welcome to Wokeland 2024.
@roman-kopylov9 ай бұрын
Nice line )
@saranlove66629 ай бұрын
@@rosetiler😂😂😂 помилуй боже. Это ж русские ...они всегда ко всему относятся серьёзно... Серьёзно, настолько, что все чаще тошнит😂 .
@brainflash19 ай бұрын
A black beekeeper in 1920s Moscow.
@abrakadabqa9 ай бұрын
His name is Pushkin
@brainflash19 ай бұрын
I know damn well who he is.
@Kliw-9 ай бұрын
You watch vtubers. Your comment holds no weight virgin
@Kliw-9 ай бұрын
You watch vtubers.
@NedBaker-v2e9 ай бұрын
Look it up. There were many black people living in Moscow at that time
@Andrexrus9 ай бұрын
Not enough cranberries and inclusivity. Stalin must be black, everyone must constantly drink vodka with bears on unicycles. With the main character, as in the series The Witcher, there should be a man with a balalaika and a hat with earflaps.
@sweet_lip9 ай бұрын
klukva
@herbal_herbs9 ай бұрын
Stalin must be not only black, but also gay. All American values must be presented carefully
@Svezhaja_struja9 ай бұрын
But Stalin can't be black and gay cos he is a cannibal monster for the West!
@jasonhaven71708 ай бұрын
@@herbal_herbs wah wah
@jasonhaven71708 ай бұрын
Wah wah cry harder
@ttp40599 ай бұрын
Wow a fantasy scifi film.. I wonder why they have bothered making historically accurate costumes hence the film is clearly placed in some weird parallel universe.
@daeryram9 ай бұрын
There is zero SciFi, just doped fantasy.
@stormhawk33199 ай бұрын
Diversity in 1920’s Russia 😂 So historically accurate
@Kuticul8 ай бұрын
this is a tv show not a documentary, seems like stupid russians in the comments don't understand that, also pretty weird how defensive they get as if it's a tv show about their grandfather, what is wrong with them
@melo47809 ай бұрын
Клюква в шоколаде...😉 😂
@СергейЛебедев-с9щ3э9 ай бұрын
как раз шоколада как в "Великая" не наблюдается
@КсенияАбакумова-с6э9 ай бұрын
а шоколад выглядит так - 💩💩💩
@ira_Li7 ай бұрын
Точно, откуда в России столько шоколада))
@nohoneynofunny9 ай бұрын
Невероятная правда в каждом кадре, никакой антикоммунистической пропаганды и, что очень порадовало, это наличие черных актеров в кадре. Для меня, как постоянного слушателя Варламова, Каца и Шульман, был снят этот фильм. Спасибо. Надеюсь вы снимите еще что-то о кровавом сталинском режиме, и поддержите либеральную оппозицию в России!
@igorroshkovsky89489 ай бұрын
Вы забыли Шендеровича и Гозмана.
@nohoneynofunny9 ай бұрын
А разве они не снимаются в фильме? @@igorroshkovsky8948
@herbal_herbs9 ай бұрын
Поддерживаю! Дорогу свободе в этом чудовищном диктаторском режиме, в котором мы мучаемся и страдаем каждый день. Голливуд, Америка, Навальная и Нулланд осветят нам путь к настоящей свободе!
@@herbal_herbs После ваших слов я заплакал, как научить наш народ жить!! Голливудский Мир - Мир Правды Истины и Демократии!!
@konsti_bel9 ай бұрын
Клюкву заказывали?
@elenastopstalking7 ай бұрын
Yeah! BoRAT forever! 😄
@Zhaba_Zhaba9 ай бұрын
Yeah... of course, it always snows in Russia and there is nothing but the Kremlin in Moscow. Мда... конечно же в России всегда идет снег и в Москве нет ничего кроме Кремля.
@brainflash19 ай бұрын
Yeah, its totally not like the entire premise of the movie is a man stuck in a specific location for the rest of his life.
@McSymm_Mcsymm9 ай бұрын
@@brainflash1, is that about Equador embassy and Assange?
@throwfascistsintopits30629 ай бұрын
@@brainflash1 He kinda deserves it lol
@jasonfargo3245 ай бұрын
Great show! A rare gem. Thank you for this show....whoever wrote and filmed it. 🙂
@grahamknox-p5g9 ай бұрын
Just finished the wonderful book..so beautifully crafted on so many levels...
@astroantares9 ай бұрын
Unfortunately, they can't help but turn every book into shit.
@teffety54669 ай бұрын
@@astroantaresа эту смогли
@michaelconnor53788 ай бұрын
@@astroantaresit’s like Dr. Chicago where his world is turned upside down by the Revolution and he is dealing with it as best he can
@shelbyscot8 ай бұрын
I had no idea half of Russia's population is of African descent. I am grateful for this educational factual show.
@StanT-y8g7 ай бұрын
In later episodes he will hold his gun sideways and walk around in BLM tshirt
@mrastickman5 ай бұрын
Literally a single black actor, obviously this is white genocide.
@suereed34749 ай бұрын
This was my favorite book of all time. Every page was an absolute pleasure. What a herculean task to try to make a movie based on it. Good luck!
@UmerNalla9 ай бұрын
Have to agree - just did not want it to end...Have read everything else written by Amor Towles - sadly does not come close...
@johnconway98829 ай бұрын
Is the character at 1:40 added or altered in order to meet certain checklist requirements for films of the 21ist century?
@suereed34749 ай бұрын
@@johnconway9882 I didn't see the film. I can't imagine it being as good as the book, as each paragraph is filled with such description and subtleties it is hard to catch on film, especially since theater goers want action, action and they have shorter attention spans than readers.
@jaideepsingh24059 ай бұрын
Made it to my top three of all time as well. Really hoping the series does justice to the literary masterpiece
@UmerNalla9 ай бұрын
@@jaideepsingh2405 have you found any other books remotely similar in tone and style to read?
@circagenx9 ай бұрын
I absolutely enjoyed working on this production in special effects department SFX. Surreal pleasure meeting Ewan and the rest of the guys.
@janemcarthur53809 ай бұрын
I have been waiting for this!
@beastybacon1999 ай бұрын
Hello it’s me Ewan mcgregory
@Dar-El_Akai9 ай бұрын
Mmmm, cultural appropriation and rewriting historical background, and you enjoyed. Why i'm not surprised.
@Dar-El_Akai9 ай бұрын
Mmmm, cultural appropriation and rewriting historical background, and you enjoyed. Why i'm not surprised.
@beckiehancock40609 ай бұрын
I worked on this too ! 😆
@Facstel9 ай бұрын
-Зей кэн тэйк эвэй ё хаус. -сэй май нэйм -иноагент
@MrCaisek9 ай бұрын
-Ю гад дэм райт - сказал признанный иногентом в СССР, РСФСР и Российской Федерации человек :-)
@planetearth94729 ай бұрын
Красная площадь вообще не та. 1:36 что они смотрели?))
@Bluey3069 ай бұрын
i love the book. what seemed like just a slice-of-life story of a quirky ex-aristocrat navigating indefinite house (or hotel) arrest that you don’t realize a chekhov’s gun is there until it’s shot its bullet. and boy does it hit its mark each time. (the book utilizes witty footnotes to break the fourth wall and so the author does technically tell you when he’s setting something up, but so much happens before the pay off that when it does happen you’re either extremely pleasantly surprised by it if you’ve forgotten it or extremely triumphant that you remembered it.)
@alexandrrogers89579 ай бұрын
Is this story about Assange?
@wolw119 ай бұрын
of course not, how can democratic countries keep a fighter for truth locked up????this is possible only in totalitarian Moscow)))))
@francevi42349 ай бұрын
Of course about Assange, but Assange in cancel culture
@nyetliuАй бұрын
No, it's based on a book having literally nothing to do with Assange.
@alexandrrogers8957Ай бұрын
@@nyetliu lol, u stpd one)
@francevi42349 ай бұрын
Это история про Ассанжа, перенесенная в Москву, чтобы тем кто не понял, было страшно.
@innapaint29229 ай бұрын
Перенесенная в альтернативную реальность бреда сценаристов скорее
@dumperttt9 ай бұрын
да нет, все проще, сюжет сперли из классического фильма - "касабланка". (я испытываю легкое чувство испанского стыда, признаваясь, что этот прости господи бестселлер я все же читал)
@ymmv999 ай бұрын
The color blind casting is ridiculous for a movie set in Soviet Russia between the 1920-195ies. "A Gentleman in Moscow" is historical fiction, not a fantasy novel set in a radically different alternate historical timeline where black men with dredlocks are common. These anachronisms completely kill the sense of verisimilitude.
@NedBaker-v2e9 ай бұрын
Look it up. There were many black people living in Moscow at that time
@ymmv999 ай бұрын
@@NedBaker-v2eYou mean at most a few dozen black people in a city with a population of millions. Even in modern Moscow you hardly find any black people, you're far, far more likely to see Asian looking people from the former Soviet republics. The black people in the former USSR would almost always be students. BTW The character the black guy is playing is an ethnic Russian in the book.
@rogovnin9 ай бұрын
I'd say ANTI-HISTSORICAL fiction
@rogovnin9 ай бұрын
@@NedBaker-v2elook it up. What was the actual percentage? 0,00000000001%?
@lexisimonsen39649 ай бұрын
This is a boring take. I’ve read the book over 10 times (it’s my favorite) and from the trailer I’d say the cast holds the integrity of the book.
@Gamer4Ever7279 ай бұрын
I remember this getting filmed near my workplace last year all the fake snow in spring was trippy 😂
@atreus29759 ай бұрын
Шедеврально! Главное не останавливайтесь 🤣🤣🤣
@cineguz9 ай бұрын
I believe the decision to cast a black actor in a movie set early 20th-century Russia era raises questions about representation and historical accuracy. Casting a black actor in a role within that specific historical context could potentially distort the reality of the period and undermine the experiences of those who lived through it. Any casting decision should prioritize authenticity. From Portugal with love.
@mistresslara72859 ай бұрын
It's just Woke nonsense. You were more likely to find a pot of gold than encounter a black person in Moscow during this time.
@Channelbermeja0109 ай бұрын
If you’re not from the U.S., you have to understand that the psyche of many of the people living in major cities has deteriorated to the point of insanity, legitimate destruction of the functioning of society itself.
@TracyInsomiac9 ай бұрын
I'm into it! We've whitewashed everything so much that we've forgotten that darker skinned people were actually in Europe. The slaves in the Northern African country of Egypt were more likely to look Ethiopian than like Charlton Heston. Trade routes and ships and wars were all conducive of great amounts of travel. Black people were in the Netherlands in the 17th century... Rembrandt painted at least 4 portraits that I have seen. The presence of a Black man in early 20th century Russia was very very possible.
@johnconway98829 ай бұрын
@@TracyInsomiac Rationalizing.
@Stella-cf4cl9 ай бұрын
I was born in Moscow. Black people have existed in Russia, Portugal, and other places all throughout history. Both because of slavery and also because like any other race, they can travel. There wasn't like a fence around Africa prior to the 21st century or something. Anyway, I really doubt you sincerely care this much about representation or else you would have done research on Afro-Russians yourself. Regardless one of the most famous figures in Russian history, Alexander Pushkin, is the descendant of a black man who himself was a famous figure and part of Russian nobility. Also, you really watched this trailer and thought they were going for authenticity? This is clearly meant to be a comedy. Again, really doubt people like you care about representation at all.
@fedoriletcki45239 ай бұрын
То есть в 1922 году, когда Ленин все еще живой, а Сталин пока даже не претендует на власть, в отеле массового вешают его портреты? Просто прекрасно.
@ТаняЧижова-я3д9 ай бұрын
Кого это там волнует? 🤣🤣🤣
@fedoriletcki45238 ай бұрын
@Manan-gq3fp тогда почему солдаты ходят в форме ркка образца двадцатых годов? Да и при Сталине его бы просто расстреляли, а не стали бы запариваться с домашним арестом в дорогом отеле
@Svezhaja_struja9 ай бұрын
Что за глюки соевого накокаиненного писаки?
@anakinskywalker88599 ай бұрын
WE'RE HAVING THE HIGH GROUND WITH THIS ONE 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
@elenastopstalking9 ай бұрын
Wow, this is a movie about Julian Assange!
@willshogren19877 ай бұрын
In what sense?
@lizng55097 ай бұрын
@@willshogren1987 They both get house arrest.
@yurypalkin58489 ай бұрын
Позову свой медведь, мы будем пить водка и смотреть Джентльмен в Москве. А потом я сыграю на балалайка, да, я такой
@tron20078 ай бұрын
Oh, those Russians!
@ivan50839 ай бұрын
Ah yes, English speaking black Russians... how can one forget about those? Thanks for reminding us California.
@Moodboard398 ай бұрын
Not speaking Russian kind kills the movie
@jasonhaven71708 ай бұрын
Cry harder, yt boy.
@DanielMcVicarOfficial9 ай бұрын
The book is one of my favorite reads of all time. It was a joy to live in the author's prose, and it should be a joy to see the series!
@АнтонАлександрович-п1с9 ай бұрын
Ребята, что вы курили, когда это снимали?😂
@Sherlok099 ай бұрын
Кокаинум 😂
@АнтонАлександрович-п1с9 ай бұрын
@@Sherlok09 Вот хулигани! 🤣
@black-armylacamora29637 ай бұрын
Химия + СОЛЬ
@artemz50169 ай бұрын
Вы что там курите?
@Andra11509 ай бұрын
Да ладно, не всё так плохо :D Ну да, есть чёрный чувак, но в целом выглядит интересно. Может, выйдет фигатория, но я посмотрю - книга, по крайней мере, хорошая
@freezasama74309 ай бұрын
Кроме черного чувака мне даже понравилось. Если они догадались придумать ему какую-нибудь предысторию из которой будет понятно, что он там забыл, то может выйти даже крутое кино
@mariaru9 ай бұрын
Пусть про Ассанжа кино снимают. Это им ближе. Хотя они и это переврут.
@JohnAmend-All9 ай бұрын
Я понял. Это сука продолжение фильма где Распутин танцует с ножами, только еще правдоподобнее.
@СергейЛебедев-с9щ3э9 ай бұрын
клюквенные листья
@AmandaC0077 ай бұрын
Excellent series. Acting was sublime. Story heart wrenching. I’m 53 and I cried at the End. I repeat casting was fantastic. ❤
@sudstahgaming7 ай бұрын
Ewan Mcgregor is such an underrated actor because he simply keeps acting well simple, hes such a naturally talented guy he doesn't need to change his persona or personality he just naturally fits into every role being himself more or less which is extraordinary.
@WSGoals9 ай бұрын
0:29 is the Bolton Town Hall (UK)
@james406589 ай бұрын
Love seeing my workplace on camera
@PlaystationProduction4 ай бұрын
Everything shot in north west, hotel is shot in space studios in Manchester
@МихаилБелик-ъ1т9 ай бұрын
Like Julian Assange at the Ecuadorian embassy?
@starofdabloc9 ай бұрын
You must have him confused for Alexei Navalny only except Assange is still alive though 🧐
@starofdabloc9 ай бұрын
No like Alexei Navalny in Russian prison 😂
@spongeaang989 ай бұрын
Assange CHOSE to live where he was, this gentleman was forced to do it. Not the same thing.
@lizng55097 ай бұрын
@@starofdabloc you should check what Navalny did before he became famous.
@nyetliuАй бұрын
No.
@spongeaang989 ай бұрын
I absolutely LOVED this book! I had no clue it was going to be a series, so I'll definitely be tuned in for this.
@vadimm43089 ай бұрын
Сплошные штампы. Это как снять фильм про США , и показать что там живут одни ковбои , которые скачут на лошадях, пьют с утра виски и чуть что сразу стреляют . А ещё в каждом городе плохой шериф 😂
@wizarywizary97138 ай бұрын
То есть любой вестерн? )
@yellowflash5877 ай бұрын
I am just waiting to see a black eskimo in a historical film, since there were everywhere.
@mariaru9 ай бұрын
Oh so this is about Assange, but in Soviet Russia. You just changed a country and a time period. Free Assange!
@starofdabloc9 ай бұрын
No more like Alexei Navalny before they offed him 😅
@squamish42449 ай бұрын
This guy is way more likeable and less rapey than Assange. He doesn't smear his shit on the walls either.
@Vlad-sv8tz9 ай бұрын
@@starofdablocAssange was the first case, so why do you blame Russians that they just copy the American practice?
@starofdabloc9 ай бұрын
@@Vlad-sv8tz because one is dead and one is not LMAO one gave away secrets and one just wanted to run for presidency
Omg I loved the book, had no idea they were making a series!! And with Ewan McGregor!
@saloneeverma99208 ай бұрын
This is an amazing book and seeing it being turned into a movie is delightful indeed. I would insist people to take it as a historical fictional representation rather than correcting the plot. Congrats to Amor Towles.
@BasharBashar9 ай бұрын
This doesn’t look like the Rostov I imagined when I read the book
@christieknapp54539 ай бұрын
I pictured Sasha Baron Cohen
@Nitzerr9 ай бұрын
I pictured Gustave from Grand Budapest Hotel haha
@KUNI-MANOVICH9 ай бұрын
Никогда такого не было и вот опять
@jerrykroth5 ай бұрын
This is a DEI production. There are more black people in this production than in the whole of Russia in 1917
@ktwei9 ай бұрын
Everyone gangster until Obi-Wan pulls out his lightsaber.
@Alex-cw3rz9 ай бұрын
Funny that the exterior ground level shots were filmed in Bolton
@WestCoastGeoLover8 ай бұрын
Loving this! Ewan is perfectly cast as Rostov. I have watched episodes 1&2 twice and looking forward to April 14, Eposode 3😊
@MegaJasjit9 ай бұрын
Disappointed. Where's bears? And why not everyone with big muscular? And why not drunk and not drinking vodka? And what happened with hedgehog in fog?
@babilabub8 ай бұрын
I can hear Emmy knocking for Ewan. He deserves it !
@ljuboizsiska54487 ай бұрын
I don't understand how black actors are not uncomfortable knowing that they got a job only thanks to the quota imposed by wokism and Hollywood and not by their own work and the quality of their performance. I'm not saying that the blacks played their roles badly, but damn, this exceeded every measure. It's time...I don't know what the hell it's time for, but it's time for reasonable decisions, decency, and truth. It's time for the gentlemen to rule the world again... When all this woke madness passes and when reason reigns again in this world, how will we laugh at such films and series, how will we laugh at enrollment quotas, employment quotas, and all other pathologies that put ideology before personal merit and truth.
@ЕкатеринаСуркова-к2ь9 ай бұрын
под тенью развесистой клюквы
@LaLa-ht3rp9 ай бұрын
Что ЭТО за дичь и как в ЭТОМ согласился сниматься Макгрегор😂 ? Напоминает сцену из Ход королевы, где у них 13 летний официант всем водку разливал в Москве
@CaptainActually19 ай бұрын
Finally! Something worth watching on Paramount+ that isn't Star Trek! And just in time for me to resume my subscription!
@johndeere34869 ай бұрын
Billionaire class anxiety at its finest “The poors are coming for our lifestyles!!!” Cried the multi national corporate “citizens”
@femalebusinessacademy9 ай бұрын
Was there a black lady with blonde hair at the hotel? I mean, seriously?… I’m sorry to disappoint some fans, but the film would be laughed at. I myself am a rather tolerant person, but this is over the top. There are some people in the comments section claiming Russia was one of the most tolerance-promoting countries and stuff - officially yes, but the reality was quite not the same. On top, all these friendships and collaborations with African & Asian countries began much later (50s and so on).
@дмитрийчеканов-б1х9 ай бұрын
Толерантность это не про Советский Союз, в СССР была дружба народов, это разные вещи, одно дело терпеть человека, а другое дружить с ним. Но важно отметить, расовой дискриминации не было и в Российской империи, там было сословное неравенство, феодал-инородец был выше по статусу чем русский крестьянин.
@dumperttt9 ай бұрын
i read the book. it is just monumental bs as it is. even netflix can't make it worse :)
@rocknrollmilitant9 ай бұрын
Why is it that every movie and TV series set during the Russian Revolution is centered on the monarchy or the aristocracy?
@Timbhu9 ай бұрын
Congratulations, you've defined what a revolution is
@rocknrollmilitant9 ай бұрын
@@Timbhu I'm just saying that I'd like at least one movie or series centered on the peasants since they were the real victims.
@Edelgeist9 ай бұрын
The rich pity their own and don't care about workers/peasants, class consciousness in action.
@Moodboard398 ай бұрын
@@rocknrollmilitantcuz they don’t give a shit about poor people.
@Rockstar-bq5fm9 ай бұрын
If I was the creators of this show. I would get out ahead by describing the show as incredibly “anachronistic” lol
@danielwilliams88103 ай бұрын
Dan Williams.Absolutely brilliant,book and series
@briankennedynjoroge31249 ай бұрын
Hope the film is half as good as the book
@carolbatistamed9 ай бұрын
I absolutely loved this book!! Great know there is a movie now! Can’t wait!
@Anton_Kalgin9 ай бұрын
Wow. What an acid trip. Seems like a steaming pile of bullshit in the making.
@allwrighty1008 ай бұрын
I read the book when it was first published some years ago and found it extremely enjoyable. I spent the entire 1990s living in Moscow and have been to the Metropol many times as we had business there as well as to socialise and dine so I felt some sort of connection. Much as I enjoyed the novel I don't think I'll be in a hurry to watch this dramatisation for the reasons listed in this comment section.
@PieceMeals9 ай бұрын
The writer isn't a Russian either so not sure why people are expecting something historically accurate or full of actual Russians.
@CommanderVimes-l5x9 ай бұрын
Well... banal respect is inherent not only in Russians
@dumperttt9 ай бұрын
something accurate you say? anything less bizzare would be appreciated. anything. 🤣
@amk51479 ай бұрын
It looks like the refinement and romance from this incredible book has been diminished to Hollywood standards. A Gentleman in Moscow is one of my all-time favorite books and it pains me to see this trailer.
@PardonJulianAssangeNow9 ай бұрын
Obi Wan joined the soviet side of the force!? - Oh wait, in Soviet Russia, the force joins you!
@annerne22999 ай бұрын
I have been looking forward to this , thank God someone had the courage to make a movie
@andrei86838 ай бұрын
oh black soviets, so real.
@theanimaltalent9 ай бұрын
We adored working on this production with the animals. What a privilege!
@ElizabethDawson-h2e9 ай бұрын
Very proud of our two Borzois, Stubbylee Mood Indigo and sister Stubbylee Chiara Mia, on their professional debut. Fabulous cast and crew and special thanks to Paula Stewart of The Animal Talent Agency for her support.
@thedabara24779 ай бұрын
That is an accomplishment to be proud of. I love Borzoi. The young ones are like gangly teenagers.
@nurlindafsihotang499 ай бұрын
And as if, being USA's borned and bred, take away their tsaritsa attitude😂. Still larger their life and prone to complain, those russian hounds.
@sayamsingh54968 ай бұрын
I wish it were releasing in India!!! My favourite literary character…can’t wait to see the Count on screen🎉🎉
@erickminor8 ай бұрын
As a Black American, the first thing that caught my attention in the trailer was the Black characters. Why does Hollywood do that?
@unknow30008 ай бұрын
Apparently DEI will get triggered if there's no black pretty colors except ⬜ men, shogun series was also complained about not Including black samurai which in book it doesn't have any, they looking to complain anything that's affected them because other shows are perfect & theirs isnt.
@KSbl288 ай бұрын
The show is incredible! Although there are a few instances that may seem unrealistic, such as bees gathering honey in winter, an over-representation of African-descendants, or Stalin's appearance in 1922. However, the actors' performances are simply astounding, and we can overlook these minor details due to their exceptional acting skills.
@phildavies76667 ай бұрын
Stalin came to power in 1922 so that fits. Also love the show and the characters quiet development. I can't say I'm a fan of the African representation either as its an unnecessary distraction that adds no meaning or value to the series.
@nocturnaavis92289 ай бұрын
Как всегда, красиво извратить историю. Впрочем, для большинства аудитории на кого рассчитан фильм плевать, информация изложенная в исторических книгах слишком сложно усваивается в маленьком мозге
@LM-hk5iq9 ай бұрын
I’m sorry, but as a Russian, both the book and the trailer to the movie are on another level of cringe 😂
@Svezhaja_struja9 ай бұрын
Don't be sorry. It's cringy as hell.
@andgo14008 ай бұрын
Surely not as cringey as russian war in Ukraine.
@LM-hk5iq8 ай бұрын
@@andgo1400 and here goes another mighty political warrior in the comments. My my, you surely made a great difference 👌🏻
@biancatellington858 ай бұрын
I’m not Russian, but I loved the book. The trailer is cringy.
@gdullage5 ай бұрын
To be honest online want my country to protect me if Russia wanted to put military bases on by countries border. Oh wait that happened it’s called the Cuban middle crises. So clearly not as cringe as your knowledge of history or current affairs.
@sweetbabyjesus65168 ай бұрын
This trailer looked fabulous, Ewan has a handlebar moustache for the ages, I was transported, I was enraptured, until... the diversity factor killed the atmosphere stone dead. Racial consciousness is rising. I wonder which tribe produced this?
@greekfreak14369 ай бұрын
“A quiet time” would be much more fitting music for this trailer
@JewlenskyBot-d6c9 ай бұрын
What's that black doing in Moscow 1920s? 😂 Remember, Russia never bought and sold Africans. Only Americans did