aespa 에스파 ~ All Songs Line Distribution (from BLACK MAMBA to WHIPLASH)

[@sunmoon_k]

Source: kzbin.info/aero/PLNMWM8EHufDwMKniVZ7htk1iVCRVXIuEx&si=sLO0RO7xttxpKV1u Solos distributions by me. FIXED Line Distributions: - Forever - Hold On Tight - ZOOM ZOOM - Drama - Over You - Die Trying - Prologue - Whiplash

[@tzuyu1989]

why didn't you use nobody_k distribution for ill make you cry? also what did you change in drama for kariselle to be tied

[@sunmoon_k]

​@@tzuyu1989I'm pretty sure the chorus is labeled as all-line, firstly because they never sing these parts live, and secondly, I think this part is the same case as the Savage chorus, which is lead by who sings afterwards About drama, karina sings the adlib "yah yah" in giselle's verse (right before the pre-chorus), she sings it in the recording behind

[@mixa_6532]

What's the change in Whiplash?

[@perezoso29622]

I always thought that Karina was the one who sang the most in all the songs, but now watching this video I realize that Karina actually has a gift for making such a strong impression that what you remember most are her iconic moments.

[@aa1yannn]

ningning and winter fr fighting for 1st place. 😂

[@tzuyu1989]

i know they're tryna show us how they're all good vocalists and rappers but they need to start following their positions again

[@redloona1085]

wdym? 1st. NingNing(main vocalist) 2nd. Winter(main vocalist) 3rd. Karina(lead vocalist, lead rapper) 4th. Giselle(main rapper)

[@tzuyu1989]

@@redloona1085 most of the raps go to ningning nowadays while giselle gets half a rap and adlibs

[@redloona1085]

@@tzuyu1989 wrong

[@yumi54372]

​@@redloona1085That's right, you're wrong.

[@redloona1085]

@@yumi54372 how so? ningning is 100% not getting more raps than Giselle nowadays, yeah Giselle gets mostly adlibs and raps but she also now gets more vocal lines, in Whiplash almost all her lines were vocal ones.

[@bestminijeongss]

Giselle being 2nd in only 3 songs is insane sm if u wont give her first place then at least make her 2nd or 3rd more often she isnt talentless tho i will never understand why she always becomes 4th

[@Windshrine]

I mean....its not that bad as people portray their distributions. All of them are good vocalists and rappers so the distribution is quite fair. Giselle surely deserve more parts especially raps but hey....atleast she is not invisible. She has her own parts which she slays. And especially in their Whiplash album, you can see her singing and rapping a lot. She literally had a high vocal prechorus in Kill it (which she normally dont receive a lot) and also had a lot of lines and vocal adlibs in Flowers. She slayed other songs too.

[@guilhermesoares8005]

Black Mamba Forever Next Level Aenergy Savage I'll Make You Cry Yeppi Yeppi Iconic Lucid Dream Dreams Come True Illusion Life's Too Short Girls Lingo Icu Beautiful Christmas Hold On Tight Welcome To My World Spicy Salty & Sweet Thirsty I'm Unhappy Til we meet again We go Zoom Zoom Drama Trick or Trick Don't Blink Hot Air Balloon Yolo

[@CHAEJI_]

Guys, I highly doubt SM counts the seconds they sing in the studio to purposefully have Giselle last, stop being dramatic

[@sowhat1674]

I would have the same sentiment if giselle gets a full rap in a rap track or get at least more 2nd place. Sm just know that she isn't as popular as the other 3 members so they just gave her what is left. She is the main rapper after all.

[@tulio3476]

2ning trying take out Winter of the First place simce debut 😂

[@Oliver-uz1fs]

Damn I didn't know Giselle was this low

[@guilhermesoares8005]

0 seconds 1000 seconds 2000 seconds

[@БориславАмов-ю8е]

20 seconds ago ❤😊

[@lanhnguyen-sl6ke]

Giselle Chỉ đứng hạng nhấtVới bài lucil dream

[@lanhnguyen-sl6ke]

Dạo gần đây winter Hát ít quá và không nhiều như hồi xưa để Ningning Lấy luôn cái vị trí Hạng Một của winter Luôn rồi😢

[@hamstatouille]

mấy bài title 2 năm nay (từ Spicy trở đi) cx ko nhiều line nhất lần nào:((

[@YatoKpop]

I thought Giselle was getting better treatment in the recent comebacks but somehow her gap between WiNing got longer

[@2Blu2]

Well 1-2 comebacks won't do that much, she needs to have good lines in a few more

[@tzuyu1989]

@@YatoKpop unless she gets first in the next album the gap between them won't get any shorter

[@rafaelakrauss4015]

I thought Karina was top 1/2 in long chat and prologue

[@Kpoplinedistribution__]

she is she’s second in long chat they used the wrong line distribution I guess

[@user-oh3sg2ls5i]

Karina doesnt really have a good parts or parts by herself its always words like wh whiplash or armageddon manual all of the 3 have parts by themselfs even if its short. it shows them right!! Karina is one who is poor here not them

[@weejinnie22]

Giselle technically finally got another first place with dopamine

[@redenoseo6375]

Ningning - 2457.6 Winter - 2394.2 Karina - 2068.3 Giselle - 1839.3

[@Runicness]

You should use nomallen's I'll make you cry

[@sunmoon_k]

@@Runicness The chorus is probably labeled as all-line Btw I'm his friend and he has the same opinion as me at the moment

[@Runicness]

@@sunmoon_k oh okay

[@AnyGamerfofis]

I

[@lanhnguyen-sl6ke]

Giselle Chỉ đứng hạng nhấtVới bài lucil dream