Afghan cities resist the Taliban with cries of Allah o Akbar & warlords rise

Join our channel to get access to perks. Click 'JOIN' or follow the link below:
/ @theprintindia
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
#CutTheClutter #Afghanistan #Taliban attacke
In the light of the Afghanistan's acting defence minister's close call with a suicide bomber, Shekhar Gupta tracks the war in Afghanistan, noting that a new and growing movement of resistance is pushing the Taliban back with the help of warlords and the local people. Episode 804, CutTheClutter.
Additional Research by Tara Rao, Amogh Rohmetra and Vidhi Gupta.
Brought in by ‪@KiaInd‬
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Video of people chanting Allah HU Akhbar in Kabul: • Chants of 'Allahu Akba...
Ch...
BB...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/su...
» Subscribe to our KZbin Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8

[@ThePrintIndia]

The future of journalism is digital. It can be bright only if you pay for its present.Take a paid subscription.Nurture the future of digital journalism. theprint.in/subscribe/

[@MohammadAliAhasan]

Their Fake Allah ho Akbar to established a rule which Promote Law against Allah. Allah is watching, Hypocrite will get their well deserve fate

[@angshumandey4061]

Ola hu Fkbar

[@pmam4241]

Ahasan..tui akta jongi

[@ajay-naz6996]

@@MohammadAliAhasan be care Allah swt is watching, who are you to judge? Only Allah swt can judge. Would you accept the rule of Bloddy Taliban in Pakistan? 💯 your answer is no.

[@ajay-naz6996]

@@MohammadAliAhasan While people of Afghanistan were chanting Allahu Akbar at the same time Taliban killed 8 innocent civilians by a suicide bomber Also probably said Allahu Akbar, if you want to judge then judge properly but keeping in mind Allah swt said if you kill one innocent person is like killing the whole human kind. You should say Taliban’s Allahu Akbar is fake. Btw the mobile phone you are using to comment here, the Taliban will give you 100 lashes as punishment for it, they showed it in 1996 for people who were having televisions in their homes, wish for others only what you wish for yourself first.

[@lovehumankind8087]

Its good to see Afghan people are standing for themselves . STAY STRONG AFGHANISTAN !!!!!!

[@wingsoffreedom4292]

@@durranishaheer1538 Tu phir aa gaya

[@AzamatBagatov413]

Afghanisstan govt is puppet of nato and usa 😂😂😂

[@jangsinghbrar156]

@@AzamatBagatov413 and talibs are puppet of bakistan

[@paytmguru5662]

Even Talibans are also afghan if u dont know 😡

[@jangsinghbrar156]

@Rohingya Taliban lauda ki sarkar hai

[@tdnuklin9878]

The history of Afghanistan and Afghans since the end of Kushan Empire has been that of internal feuds and inter tribe violence. But they are a very proud and independence loving people who never give up. That nature can never be changed. They should be left alone.

[@himmsingz]

@India🐮superpooper🚩2020 Kushan empire in its heydays (Kanishka) ran all the way to Mathura.

[@qh5716]

@India🐮superpooper🚩2020 Kushana was till Central Asia, covered entire Afganistan.

[@yashvardhanojha6796]

@India🐮superpooper🚩2020 another idi** 🤡 look at the map fool !

[@rasiksharma3453]

@India🐮superpooper🚩2020 Kushan empire even covered some parts of north west china

[@vellapb1812]

Present day Afghanistani are the descendants of Kushan.

[@aarohi.5272]

"Peace in Afghanistan is Not possible untill heavy sanctions And blacklisting of pakistan" --Chris Alexander

[@tomriddle4110]

Exactly

[@lovehumankind8087]

Absolutely right

[@amoghavarsha5715]

if USA blacklist Pakistan. Who will buy USA Arms. greed and crimes USA and Europe is the real problem in this

[@Valkyri3Z]

If it was that easy US would have done it long back. Pakistan alone can not make Taliban win. Its total nonsense. I am sure there are elements in Iran and other 'stan' countries who help them. Its not that easy conflict.

[@jeffinjoy17]

@@amoghavarsha5715 they could have said no to arms and ammunition😂 but they didnot , why? Caz the ideology teaches violence

[@subhabratamazumder3411]

The way Afghan Defense Minister said “Everything is fine” after a massive attack on him is really amazing. Last week also we have seen that President Ghani peacefully completed his prayer when rockets were banging his presidential palace. Afghan people are really brave. It’s true that luck favors only those who are brave.

[@user-qi6tp1te1y]

The sad thing is the people are getting used to it

[@akshaydhadwal3163]

@@durranishaheer1538 same goes go imran khan also..he to should surrender to pakistani taliban..

[@akshaydhadwal3163]

@@durranishaheer1538 yes

[@ajay-naz6996]

@@durranishaheer1538 stfu 🤮🤮🤮

[@rizwanshahzad2462]

فراڈ.ڈرامہ

[@mailtorajrao]

The visuals of the ordinary Afghan citizens rising up through the streets is amazing and very heartening to see.

[@sk-kr1uy]

Allahuakbar 💚

[@rehan-ic9ji]

Naare Takbeer......Allahu Akbar

[@mailtorajrao]

@@G.M.Cheema Did your Pakistani PM get the 1st phone call from Biden yet? It's been more than 6 months since Biden's' inauguration in Jan, no?

[@mailtorajrao]

@@G.M.Cheema Ask Najam Sethi and Fawad Choudhary.

[@mailtorajrao]

@@G.M.Cheema Hum Srinagar aur Kabul main investments dekh lete hain, aap CPEC restart kar lo. Ab Bajwa saheb ko remove kiya hai so maybe you can restart but then IMF and FATF ka aap kya karenge? 😊

[@prabhjitgill1987]

Come on my Afghan brothers. You've got this. Wonderful to see the local Afghan population rise up against the taliban. Our thoughts & prayers are with you. Love & respect from India.. May Allah be with you..

[@Nawazshtif]

@Tejpal singh bali Tere sikh Hindu bagwan kan vich lun pava

[@muhammadriaz2443]

Dear Cut The Clutter, Kandhar and Herat fall like nine pins.....ample proof bookish journalism from the armchairs of one's comfy offices has its limitation. Better you restrict yourself to your home ground, you're best where you belong. Respect!

[@frazahmedable]

It was SG wishful thinking rather objective journalism

[@frazahmedable]

The lion of herat is now with Tailban :)

[@anmolpatelfifa]

I'll sum it up all, in a poetic way.... Borrowing words of Winston Churchill on Afghanistan - "The Pathan tribe are always engaged in private or public war. Every man is a warrior, a politician and a theologian. Every large house is a real feudal fortress.... Every family cultivates its vendetta... Every clan its fued... Nothing is ever forgotten and very few debts are left unpaid " - (My early life, chapter 11,The Mahmund Valley)

[@IndianArma]

'Tsubodai', or 'subutai' is one of my favourite characters from history, perhaps the greatest expeditionary general ever. Kudos for being a man of culture 🙂

[@orunabho]

And the violent ideology of the Arabs just added the right fuel to this people to make it permanent

[@qh5716]

Prior to Islam, Afghanistan was a thriving Buddhist civilization. Visit the magnificent Buddhist stupas, temples, murals of Gods and Goddesses, caves cities built by them throughout Afg. All these violence came after conversion to Islam.

[@Everythinz]

i think the only country that can understand afghans and lead them towards proper statehood is India.India albeit its own problems still have thousands of different people united together. Hopefully, India can be a cultural and social backbone of the future afg

[@kunti_putra]

Wasseypur mein aapka swagat hai. 🙂

[@GyaaniBa]

All the drama by Talbn that they have changed, they want peace and they want to work with governments, all of that falls so flat and they show their true color. No terrorist govt should be allowed to be formed. May god give strength to the true afghans who want democracy so that they show these people their true place.

[@grimgoreironhide9985]

They showed their true colours when they agreed to help the Chinese Communists abuse their fellow Uighur Muslims. True Muslims don't suck the cock of the Chinese Communists. Even Erdogan who speaks of a Pan Islamic unity is really a traitor since he is very friendly with the CCP and is helping to deport Uighurs back to China.

[@cm-to6oi]

I live and work with Afgani ppl. Most hard working, helpful, honourable people I have ever met. And fearless I have to say.. And they hate Punjabi Pakistani ppl..

[@sameednakai8766]

Humm what word best fits your comment? Namak haram? Also let's thank Pakistan for being a buffer zone, would India have handed over Afghan lands east of the Durand line if Pakistan did not become a country? Perhaps India would have continued to see the rape looting and pillaging that Afghan marauding tribes did for 1000s of years

[@squad6576]

@@sameednakai8766 If India possessed such mentality, she can easily annexed Bangladesh in 1971

[@sameednakai8766]

@@squad6576 @S Quad well too bad India didn't? Or perhaps training and arming Mukti bahini And then taking over a country they got freedom for would have had been a blunder. Because India surely didn't have any issues annexing territories that were not as well armed. You fellas blame the Pakistanis for not knowing history perhaps you should give a check on areas annexed by military or political force by India, operation polo annexation of goa and annexation of Sikkim would be good places to start

[@squad6576]

@@sameednakai8766 Those wee already parts of India , captured by different imperialistic powers......We gave Independence to Bhutan also, China annexed Tibet but India never did that with Nepal...... India will be stick with her democratic ideology always......

[@sameednakai8766]

@@squad6576 who said they were already parts of India? They were princely states and goa was a portugese colony, do goans speak or consider their mother tongue as Hindi? India took over by military force, and if you're not willing to believe that then fine Balochistan was also part of Pakistan. Also ever heard of the word protectorate? Bhutan in other words is just another Indian colony, its just that the indians find it much less of a headache to make it officially part of India especially this day in age, as for Nepal they were free during British rule too, and India didn't take over with military force for the same reason the British didn't and the Chinese didn't, also wasn't there a lot of crying and whining going on recently with Nepal warming up relations with China recently. Once again would urge you to learn some true indian history not the filtered version where India is some sinless being. Also democracy isn't suited for every country glad it suits india but if you try to shove it down other people throats there isn't much difference to it from facism, which seems to be the current Democratic setup in India

[@shyamalisarkar3750]

Afghanistan is going on the very right way. No govt. forces or international aid can help Afghanistan resist Taliban but it is only the common Afghan people!! The common Afghan masses have to unite against Taliban to show what the common Afghan wants.

[@omegasensei382]

@Rohingya Taliban why like Taliban?

[@amalpradeep8003]

@Rohingya Taliban atleast not according to Cut the Clutter... not the people living in the cities...

[@amalpradeep8003]

But Taliban won't mind killing thousands of people protesting against them. Taliban is not a dignified body which respect human rights or international war laws or liberal politics. I dont think common afghan have any role to play against Taliban.

[@amalpradeep8003]

@Rohingya Taliban why? so that their basic human rights can be surrendered? Do afghan people hate watching movies and listening to songs? Do they not like internet? Do men hate shaving their beard and women hate going to school??

[@PDpakoraykidukanRskpakoray]

In few days it will be not be same. People like you will be mourning

[@hassobhatiastudent716]

Ishmael khan was minister of water and power in 2004 when I worked with him to rehabilitate power systems in Afghanistan.He was very simple small man like a Sufi derwesh..exciting to see him re-emerge as leader resisting Taliban..

[@priyanshsaxena5147]

He had joined taliban now

[@hamidhamidi3134]

And Hazarajat in Central Afghanistan is completely free of Taliban presence. The powerful Hazara militias together with Afghanistan security forces are keeping tha Taliban at bay successfully.

[@fueledbymsk6334]

Thanks Allah. May Allah bless them .

[@Happy-rm8li]

You will win ,afghans will win,women will win,humanity will win.

[@mukundbhardwaj5095]

Hope and wish u people get rid of this unfortunate violence.

[@PDpakoraykidukanRskpakoray]

Don't worry. It won't be for long.

[@muhammadasim8865]

They are willingly not attacking and pressing hazaras too much. Because they know that hazaras have been prosecuted throughout history in Afghanistan. So if they try to capture the hazara area. Then all over the world there will be a massive propaganda against them. That they are killing innocent hazaras. Man even the areas of brave pushtun are being captured by taliban. Then who the hell are hazaras??? You are trusting too much hazaras.

[@BabakrkhailKhan]

Afghans are Brave. 5k years of history nothing can beat them

[@akshatpathak25]

Idiots in Pakistan don't know anything about cultural legacy.. They got independence in 1947 and majority of them considers themselves as arabs or turks which they are not.. In mahabharata war, kurawa's mother gandhari was queen of gandhar.. And his brother shakuni was the main conspirator of the war.. Shakuni is a famous character of that war..

[@Noone-gz8li]

@@akshatpathak25 they are not Arabs or turks All of then are native converted Muslims Because of Delhi sultanat and mughals as well

[@abhishekraval7209]

As Nadia Murad wrote a last line in her biography "The last girl" that : " I want to be the last girl in the world with a story like mine". But it seems , the condition of Afghanistan will create more unfortunate stories like hers. While reading a book I really cried. What she has survived might killed me. I wish what Syria and Iraq is going through would not get repeated in Afghanistan.

[@vedsaipandla3259]

A video never aged so badly in just a week lol

[@satiresarthi1858]

Narendra Modi-If you love someone, let them go. With petrol Rs110 ,how far will they go

[@arjunshukla1160]

😂😂😂😂

[@viratkohli6572]

You make nice video 📸 Satire Sarthi.aab comments me bhi roast karoge

[@trinity4248]

just enough to the voting centre to vote bjp back in 24' 😉

[@aarohi.5272]

Lol 🤣

[@tomriddle4110]

😂

[@anuragpoddar8631]

if only Ahmed shah massoud was helped from the united states to took out the taliban completely.

[@SandeepRTyagi]

Did not understand the reason of laugh while talking about of Ahmed Shah Massou, India’s close friend.

[@SandeepRTyagi]

@Rohingya Taliban not worth responding

[@dollartreeshark6786]

@Rohingya Taliban Rohingya bhai are you back in Burma or just a ghusbhait in another country?

[@kingafghan1655]

We want peace in our country Afghanistan 😔

[@vineet3269]

We wish you same.

[@zainabk9165]

The only solution of peace in Afghanistan and India is to devide pig Pakistan

[@Pavankumar-bd5rn]

Feel very sorry for you man, you guys are strong.

[@amalpradeep8003]

Afghanistan has too many guns and too many arrogant people... Peace looks like a distant dream...

[@kaustav197]

I am sure only Afghans can defeat Taliban cause No one knows to Kill Pests in Your Home than The Home Owner themselves

[@hkumar7340]

The resistance of ordinary Afghans to the obscurantists is the one really good news this whole year! May God protect the people of Afghanistan from the evil Taliban!!

[@ajay-naz6996]

Thank you brother

[@Tryingtobringchange]

May the righteous be victorious in Afghanistan. The Talibaan has shown itself to be untrustworthy- it has reneged so many of its promises. God willing the brave Afghanis will be victorious.

[@g1y3]

There are no righteous in war these Warlords are well known for human rights abuses, kidnapping, tortures child slaves.

[@pardeeptandon]

The only promise it keeps is to God unlike many other religions

[@syedtalhasxr]

Praying for the safety of all civilians in Afghanistan. May true democracy thrive in Afg, and may all the warlords, puppets, corrupt politicians and terrorists perish.

[@lovehumankind8087]

Wondering from where Taliban getting its arms, ammunition's and logistics ? Pak media is showing its politicians, peoples and army are supporting and sympathizing with Taliban. UN and other countries should come together to pressure Pakistan for helping Afghan government instead of Taliban as Taliban is given birth by Pakistan.

[@momi3652]

Pak media is supporting talibs? Biggest joke ever...

[@dampmaky]

Yeah no, Pakistan simply doesn’t want to endanger its own people by provoking/angering them. Supporting them? In the long ago past of the 1980s yes they did alongside america. Now? Nope

[@nihalpathak3407]

'Normal life of an Afghan Warlord' what an interesting topic for a book. Chhotu warlord can be the main protagonist. Wish Shekhar Sir with his vast experience, knowledge and wit could write on this, giving us more details about these characters. These kind of details are useful as they are like antithesis of everything which these warlords claim to represent on the name of religion and ethnic values.

[@vinodiyer-wd4mm]

2 trillion dollars and 2 decades spent to replace taliban with taliban.

[@M2gmkt]

Everyone in the world deserve peace! May the people's will prevail !

[@MinhajAhmedAnsari]

I am watching this CTC just after India's victory over Germany to secure 🥉. It's good to know that the underdogs are giving fight in Afghanistan also against all odds.

[@priyanshupandey2670]

I always like to read your comments

[@Xoro-rbk]

More power to the Afghans. They will fight the evil Taliban and make way for peace and prosperity.

[@Airman..]

Talibs are Afghans too 🤣

[@Xoro-rbk]

@@Airman.. they may be afghans by birth but not by their mentality. One wants to establish an islamic emirate other wants to restore peace and prosperity.

[@TheBakor]

@@Xoro-rbk LoL 🤣

[@badkarma1425]

@@Airman.. Talibans are Pakistani puppet.

[@VijayKumar-dn4pz]

@Abdul Ghafoor Because India sends a lot of aid to Afghanistan and not to UAE. You need people to manage that aid and increase trade with Afghanistan. And what is Napakistan doing in Afghanistan? Even afghanis hate Pakistan.

[@santoshballu]

Finally finally, this gives me some hope for Afghan people. May be this is the only way Taliban can be stopped. It should be a revolt starting at the grass root level. It has to become a people's war (non-violent).

[@hamidhamidi3134]

I can assure you that Taliban will not win this war against us Afghans. We will fight them for another 50 years but they will not rule us.

[@moonbright]

@@hamidhamidi3134 STAY STRONG AFGANISTAN❤️❤️❤️

[@himanshu54365]

@@hamidhamidi3134 Stay strong brother. Afghanistan is for Afghans. Love from Kashmir

[@amalpradeep8003]

But taliban are the kind of demons that don't mind terminating a section of population if they resort to any form of non-violent protest. I don't know if it is correct to wish for a grass root revolt (non-violent)

[@sarthakkanwar]

I think gandhian style satyagrah is needed.

[@ontisalaga1789]

A wonderful episode Sir. Much appreciated. They Sound similar to our regional parties/ satraps. The actual satraps did in fact rule Afghanistan. A CTC on Afghanistan through the ages some day?

[@pardeeptandon]

That is Democracy for You.

[@amalpradeep8003]

Only our regional parties/satraps do not have so many guns. Most of the conflict is resolved amicably here. Rule of Law (atleast to some extent). Let us not draw comparisons yet.

[@Happy-rm8li]

@MD AL AMIN what a joke😂😂😂

[@ontisalaga1789]

@@amalpradeep8003 as a student of sociology power structures intrest me very much.

[@badrulalam6881]

Afgan government soldiers are well trained. In some places, they retreated but shortly they will start pushing back Notorious Talibans. Afgan National Army and Police forces are young generations and these forces will fight Talibans with their full strength.We hope Afgan people will resist notorious Talibans unitedly.

[@fazalanwer5236]

America europe and india could not defeat taliban then how can their puppet do so. Taliban zindabad

[@hirashiyokogawa4042]

they are all followers of the book of peace.

[@Kalyani561]

@@fazalanwer5236 human bombing and fighting I'm hide is not a greatness. Ask ur taliban to bring it all army and start war. Them we can see who win or not. Hiding and fighting is wring

[@subratabhattacharya7983]

@@fazalanwer5236 when did India fight Taliban?

[@GamerBoiyo]

who is watching this video after Aug 15th? Can we believe anything we hear about Afghanistan in the media? None of these defense experts and media analysts were even close to the ground reality.

[@NivedNavaneed]

Stay strict...Stay strong...Afghans

[@kuku6789]

Thanks for covering this SG sir. I saw Amarullah Saleh the vice president walking in one of those videos. He is some kind of a real life James Bond. While he is around the massive afghan army will not give up so easily. The fact is that Afghan civilians have seen a sliver of what peace can look like while US and NATO forces were present and they do not want to go back to the medieval times under the Taliban. People and fighters of Afghanistan have a reputation, if they want to defend something no power in the world will be able to take it from them. Best wishes to the Afghan National Defense Forces !!!

[@iArpanMishra]

This is man is an encyclopedia! Love you SG!

[@duvasrealm]

Bringing the Afghan under the same flag is the biggest problem they have to face. It might be the reason why neither anyone was able to conquer it or able to rule it centrally for years. Currently its more like Pashtun, Tajik, Hazara, Uzbek, Aimaq, Turkmen, Baloch, Pashai, Nuristani, Gujjar, Arab, Brahui, Qizilbash, Pamiri, Kyrgyz, Sadat and not as an Afghani as such. The Westerners are to blame for most of the country border disputes within and outside. Taliban is trying to take control of this chaos by bringing religion disguised in their ideology to unify. We can see a semblance of the same in our country too in a way.

[@r4rehan]

Which cites were resisting? 🤭🤭 Taliban took over most of the cities without a single bullet fired and today Kabul fall as well!!!

[@umarslatif]

Resist Taliban 😂😂....wonder how you feel now... probably crying late into the night 😂

[@asifghori2677]

It is not Stalingrad or Leningrad, these are the cities occupied and controlled by warlord's.

[@kanthavelkv]

India should support any democratically elected government in Afghanistan. The Taliban is coming to power just through violence & war. If elections are conducted in a fair manner, Taliban will never come to power. Come what may...India should rather take a principled stand in support of the majority opinion in Afghanistan. Only principled stand & patience will obtain respect in world politics in the long run. In any case, even if we make an enemy out of Taliban, they could never fight India directly at the border. For the short term, India should be prepared to lose the political gains, goodwill got through decades of welfare work in Afghanistan. Even if Taliban comes to power, it will not last long, the world powers will never allow that.

[@yashvardhanojha6796]

My friend told me : At the end of the Soviet war , there were more commanders than the troops .

[@habibmajeed]

I am from Pakistan, i am fan of your journalism style and in depth knowledge analysis, keep up sir

[@harshithgowda4785]

Peace is not possible in afghanistan as long as state of pakistan exist

[@sameednakai8766]

Was it possible when Pakistan did not exist? Was it possible when the Afghan marauders raped, pillaged and looted what was then Hindustan? Was it possible before the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan? If you get your head out of your rear end and stop playing a part in creating trouble on Pakistan's western border all can be solved.

[@fardinhakimi]

agreed. Pakistan needs to be nuked so the whole region can prosper.

[@sameednakai8766]

@@fardinhakimi Typical mentality of resorting to violence to resort an issue, guess its working out well in Afghanistan then.

[@lokichakra]

God bless the people of Afghanistan! May they free themselves from the shackles of the oppressive Taliban.

[@zeek9029]

Talibans themselves are afghans lol. It's a civil war. It's Afghans vs Afghans.

[@P.B...]

Afghanistan, sadly, thou art the definition of clutter! A real life deadly game of thrones. The clutter there is so great that the Chinese feel compelled to dine with the Taliban in Tianjin, while tossing down prison rations to Uighurs in Xinjiang!

[@mikespear5459]

How can anyone say that by chanting Allah ho akbar, they are encouraging govt or Taliban.? Taliban is advancing so fast that even US Nato and Britishers are surprised. It seems afghan govt has no ground support or from public.

[@864rashid]

Crying is definitely Ashraf Ghani's voice, but the tears are from India.

[@arunjetli3770]

What are you doing with a Sikh name change it or else jihadis might not like it

[@bprmel]

Sekhar great efforts... your knowledge, skills and giving a perspective is brilliant 👌🙂

[@mahatmagaand]

"IF" there is a chance for the ANA to take back control from the Taliban and "IF" our intervention can be projected to make the civil war less bloody then it is my conviction that GOI ought to covertly facilitate ANA with Material support without having Indian boots on the ground.

[@subhabratamazumder3411]

I believe staying away from direct intervention in Afghanistan by GOI is a clever move. No propaganda should float as ‘India as a foreign power interfering in Afghanistan’. End of the day Afghan people should make their move to defeat Taliban’. How long foreign power will be there to decide Afghan’s destiny? It’s their country, they have to do it by themselves. Although I believe GOI must be supporting with intelligence and logistic support.

[@mrgyani]

That would be dumb. I don't think our power projection is a priority in the afghan crisis. In fact our goal should be the opposite (do it covertly if we do). In fact we are already doing it..

[@ajay-naz6996]

@@subhabratamazumder3411 but the problem is Afghan army is fighting with Taliban who got support from 14 countries including China, Iran, double face Pakistan, Qatar, Saudi, Russia. Therefore Afghanistan need to have the support of its friends, the same way Assad had support from Iran, Russia and China.

[@subhabratamazumder3411]

@@ajay-naz6996 it’s true. I believe holding the UNGS presidency, India will surely help them. Waiting for peace keeping force in Afghanistan soil.

[@burhanali0011]

You Said Allah Akbar Many Times. You are Muslim Now! Congratulations!

[@thestrongguy1]

It is not Taliban. There is a bigger hand behind them. You are right ! PAKISTAN. winning this war for Afghan means defeating Pakistanis !

[@ShantanuVerma1]

For the first time ever I’ve become even more cluttered in my head when it comes to Afghanistan after watching this really informative CTC 😅

[@geraldpechenuk6723]

India failed to show up at climate talks in London last week, the meeting’s British hosts took it as a snub. What is goin on there. Shekhar, can you comment, please ? Thanks, An American listener

[@amalpradeep8003]

@@satyavvduddu7105 at least Biden has joined back in Paris Agreement. They are trying their bit.

[@govindpratapsingh]

Shekhar sir should have explained in the beginning; who is warlord. Do they have legal recognition

[@Manojyadav-qy6vi]

Afghans have warlords like Tajik, Uzbeki and Turkmen and Hazara Shia....

[@Manojyadav-qy6vi]

And they don't need recognition to protect their country...

[@hemmed1330]

God Bless Afghanistan and the Afghan people!

[@coolnimo]

Brilliantly done Shekhar sir. Request to have more episodes of Cut the Clutter on Afghanistan.

[@lokeshjani]

कुछ पत्रकारों को अफगानिस्तान जाके तालिबान से बात करके सरकार से समझौता करवाना चाइये क्योंकि हज़ारो लानतें वहाँ से भी कोई देगा.....

[@raghavmittal2861]

Afghanistan people had 20 years to help In war against Taliban, if there had been even slight intention of removing Taliban that would have been achieved by now. It is ironic as well that they are fighting Taliban by using 'Alah hu Akbar' slogan, in Gurella war like these if any party attain people trust it is very difficult to make them lose the war, same thing happened here, people should have supported Afghanistan government initiatives instead of Taliban.

[@saswatswain3231]

More power to Afghanistan army & Afghan people 🇮🇳 ❤️🇦🇫

[@michaelvandyne6480]

You guys are inspiring the world. Keep up the good fight for freedom. We believe in Afghanistan and it's people.

[@EnuCan]

I'll have to re-watch this in the morning, what an absolute marvel of episode this was. Thanks sg ❤️

[@ajay-naz6996]

Same here

[@Forgotten_One96]

Afghanistan will win because there's lots of lions and they are Afghans the nightmare for Pakistanis.

[@SandeepRTyagi]

SK’s passion and knowledge reflects when he talks about Pak/Af region.

[@tuxnoel]

Ismail Khan of Herat has come back like Gandalf 👍

[@framerz]

You shall not pass.

[@jeet3797]

Kabul had done this long time ago during the Soviet Occupation. Sounds came from all the rooftops. Beauty of it being, you can't stop it and it annoys the hell out of the opposition.

[@Sk-never]

Very good to hear this

[@naturelover8121]

Wow when people raise for freedom the view becomes more beautiful than valley of flowers ....... ultimately we all love freedom ..and peace ...even war Lord's are fighting for peace ...

[@poras1513]

No one can explain Afghan issue better than you Sir... 😎👍🏻

[@rehmanbilal1]

You can't take control of 3 cities in 5 days unless local people support you.

[@Shahbazthakurshow17]

As there is a saying in punjabi tht ' Barat jine v vdi kyu na hoe pind nalo vdi nai hundi similarly any terrorist group attacking any country can't be bigger than its citizens force #peace

[@humanentity2214]

India sends best wishes for the future of Afghanistan, may God have mercy on the great people of Afghanistan.

[@shekhardhamnaskar2571]

Afghanistan has become a testing ground for world powers to test their newly developed destructive weapons under guise of maintaining peace in the region, this obviously at the cost of Afghani lives.

[@Sunil5291]

In every war that is waged by imperialist & nationalist forces there will be a ready playground to test and reaffirm various deadly weapons & strategies.....

[@Forgotten_One96]

Wrong, Afghanistan is Graveyard of world powers not testing ground. Your just Pakistani

[@Forgotten_One96]

Listen Indian, don't underestimate Afghanistan you don't know anything about Afghanistan so shut your mouth.

[@sachinsrivastava2170]

This is the REAL GAME OF THRONES. Hope Netflix makes a series on this after 5-10 years.

[@arrie6054]

Sir, you should read the book IN A LAND FAR FROM HOME by Sayed Mujtaba Ali. Its translated from Bengali. The similarities between the then Afghanistan and present Afghanistan is uncanny. During his stay the city of Kabul was captured and raided by a decoy named Baccha Sakao who also wanted to establish an Islamist government in Kabul in reaction to various reforms the then king Aman Ulla had introduced in Afghanistan. The writer narrates his travel and stay in Afghanistan around 1927 during which time the great game for Afghanistan was very much on between Russia and Britain.

[@TheBakor]

May Allah give strength to all Muslims to quit Islam

[@TheBakor]

@Sultan Islam has hijacked great Allah and his wonders. May Allah forgive all Muslims for misrepresenting the mighty

[@TheBakor]

@Sultan you are confused my friend.

[@dr.poojanpatel7625]

5:45 is what a true hero looks like.

[@dr.poojanpatel7625]

@India🐮superpooper🚩2020 imagine being so pathetic that your username is dedicated towards defaming a country.

[@mik29k]

After hundreds of years of violence who knows satyagraha might be the solution.

[@amalpradeep8003]

Satyagraha would work against an organisation with some diginity. Taliban has no regard for human life/rights of khafirs, international war laws or liberal ideologies. I dont think peaceful protest can acieve anything against the brutal Taliban.

[@aayotime341]

A noble effort by you sir. Hope it counts.

[@rajbodepudi]

Excellent Commentary. Thanks

[@EarthSciEd]

Lashkergah is completely looking like Srinagar now..

[@awaisb7750]

Sir U never disappoint us.. Another brilliant overview of the current situation of Afghanistan

[@Endless_Nightmare1]

With my work experience in Afghanistan for both with NATO forces and with Ministry of Mines Afghanistan on Oil exploration,I have traveled throughout the country.The truth is beyond the imagination and I see serious threat to India if Taliban comes into power as they are total back up from Pakistan ISI,Chinese agents and few from Iran too.So,the media reports are just 20% of the truth on the ground.

[@abhisharma8734]

72 hoore milegi kise ? Afghan civilians ya shantidoot

[@tarunsurana4464]

Hats off to you & your research team!!

[@ananjain]

And as I watch this episode Abdul Rashid Dostum is back in Kabul. Afghanistan is a great game bith for insiders and outsiders.

[@864rashid]

If Army and ISI run Pakistan, why was Pegasus used for snooping Imran Khan but not Pakistan's Army Chief & ISI Chief?

[@864rashid]

The Taliban also seized the Nimroz customs headquarters on the Afghanistan-Iran border. The provincial capital of Zaranj has also reportedly fallen to the Taliban .

[@obaida7]

1 week everything changed? what the hell are you covering? give us news dont give us news as per indian foreign policy!

[@864rashid]

The Taliban also seized the Nimroz customs headquarters on the Afghanistan-Iran border. The provincial capital of Zaranj has also reportedly fallen to the Taliban .

[@bhaveshkumarbarot454]

Well studied and informative comments on latest prevailing situation in war torn Afghanistan by learned columnist Shekhar sir..

[@jolivera8451]

I always enjoy your videos, thank you so very much for all the detailed information you provide. Also how well you explain everything where we your viewers can understand everything. Thank you!

[@Irfan-xm6qo]

great news and analysis

[@yashvardhanojha6796]

Ata Noor is a coward. He went to a place ( for starting clearing ops) , did a photoshoot with his son and ran away . You can check out the photos on Twitter Btw, Dostum is back. He calls himself Marshal. His son is the police cheif of a provincial capital in North and is currently on frontline.

[@864rashid]

The Taliban also seized the Nimroz customs headquarters on the Afghanistan-Iran border. The provincial capital of Zaranj has also reportedly fallen to the Taliban

[@prashamgoel7895]

The resistance didn't last long sir, not at all.!

[@mehmoodali7197]

Indian journalist supporting ismail khan, ye indian Hippocratic behavior hai

[@firstknight193]

Let the Afghan people decide what type of government they wanted to. NOT the minority Taliban impose their will to the people! Remember Afghan population is greater than the Taliban!... SO I'M URGING THE AFGHAN PEOPLE TO DEFEND AND FIGHT YOUR RIGHTS TO EXIST!

[@tapemaj]

Turbulent nation and Afghanistan are synonymous and with a resurgent Taliban once more Afghanistan will head back to the Stone Age ? All Indian investment down the Amu darya .