Afghanistan, Pakistan and India: A Deadly Triangle

Brookings President Strobe Talbott interviews noted historian and author William Dalrymple about his new report on a contest for power and influence in one of the world's most dangerous regions.
In "A Deadly Triangle: Afghanistan, India, and Pakistan," Dalrymple says that we look at the conflict in Afghanistan "through the wrong pair of glasses." Instead of being the Taliban against America, he says, the reality is that Pakistan supports the Afghan Taliban to avoid being surrounded by India. Dalrymple also explores the post-2014 landscape as the U.S. and allies withdraw from Afghanistan, when an already-dangerous neighborhood has the potential to become more deadly.
In this video, Talbott and Dalrymple also discuss the role of religion in the ongoing India-Pakistan rivalry; Pakistan's self-created internal security threat from the "Talibanization of Pakistan"; and whether or not the Pakistani military and intelligence communities could have known that Osama bin Laden was living in Abbottabad.
With publication of "A Deadly Triangle," Brookings inaugurates The Brookings Essay, which will feature commissioned works on major topics of public policy by distinguished authors, including Brookings scholars.
Read the entire essay at www.brookings.edu/DeadlyTriangle

[@MaakiRashoee]

Ask any Hindu student about Kalam , rest you will get the idea of respecte.

[@sachinkesarkar788]

@desiman1 tu sikh ke naam pe ek bhoot bada dhabba hai.

[@TheLieDestroyer140]

Abdul kalam only legend of modern india and happens to be a Muslim .

[@struggler6410]

@desiman1sun jahilo !!!!! Pahle Indians k label k... to ho jao .... Fir yudhh Karna....aur tujhe itni hi khujli h .....to bol de beti chod Imran ko Kar Le yudhh

[@ayyagarisubrahmanyam3041]

@Gooogle shut up.... Give respect to the dead!!

[@Sandyzzz]

@Sandoz Sandoz chutiya when u don't know any fucking info about the incident dnt puke here for the sane....

[@anuragtiwari3561]

One of the most loved Person in India *APJ ABDUL KALAM* , People here see work and heart not your religion or nationality ... Even Atif Aslam /rahatFateh / Nusrat fateh, fawad from Pakistan get pretty good love from Indian side . Don't let start telling names of Muslim who are most famous in India , from Mohd. Rafi to Javed Akhtar , Cricketers to Engineers , cooks to Politicians .. I can count 100+ names now only 😒

[@sidd1298]

@@YS-tn9ur javed akhtar isn't a terrorist bhai atleast listen to what he says, he's an atheist my friend and is hated by crazies from all sides

[@YS-tn9ur]

@@sidd1298 he is atheist that why support terrorist yeah idiot trump is christain support isis and terrorist

[@YS-tn9ur]

@@sidd1298 watch this video see how much atheist javed is

[@waqasahmed655]

Lol they can't even speak their heart out.

[@transcendent14]

Indian media has totally brainwashed most of the people in India. I'm amazed. They can't see the lynch mobs and forget the Gujrat massacres and things going around all over India. Wake up Indians before it's too late...

[@suswsh07]

How many hindu minority represents in Pakistan parliament ?

[@sanilpp3844]

@Waqar Hussain Really bruh

[@oasissanjay]

@Waqar Hussain can u name atleast two of them???

[@atifali-hm7je]

Plz check link. I've shared

[@terrawulf]

@@atifali-hm7je what's the population of Hindus now?

[@Arunxolo]

In 1947 Hindu is in Pakistan is 15% but now 1.2%

[@mohitbidhu3553]

india had muslim president. enough said.

[@SQUINX]

We even had a Muslim prime minister

[@krnduo7051]

@TheIronMan987 free POK

[@gaurav32257]

@TheIronMan987 you are free to go to Pakistan

[@duryodhannayak8762]

@TheIronMan987 Free Baloocistan, PoK, GilgitBalistan

[@sounakroy9616]

@Janardhan Parweshwar Technically Indira Gandhi was Muslim.

[@untouchboy]

We afghans 🇦🇫 always stand with india 🇮🇳

[@akbrali3214]

ur females are standing in pakistan since last 40 years.

[@untouchboy]

@@akbrali3214 and your females standing in heera mandi since 200 years

[@akbrali3214]

m not just talking dear. this is a fact. i think u have no idea about aghanes. thy are living in pak last many decade and u r supporting india. we have no issue on ur mutual relation but u need to show some sense before giving statment. Pak has enough powerful army to defend my country. think about ursefl, wht,s kind of situation are facing since last 1980 by afghanes. (we are dealing here as a Gust brother, ur response is diff.) we have no issue u r going with india or US, try to understand u need to work to develop to ur country. plz ready about ur history okay before giving comments.

[@untouchboy]

@@akbrali3214 you give very good speech only convincing yourself now let me tell you facts about Pakistan. Pakistan is the country claim to be created with the name of Islam at the same time having prostitution like heera mandi and alcohol factories like MURRY BREWERY. pakistan claim against terrorism at the same time hosting Osama bin laden, lashkar e taiba, lashkar e jangvi, haqaani network, jaish e Muhammad, Sapa e sahaba, Taliban, etc. Pakistan claim to be hosting millions of Afghan refugees and claiming 100 $ per person from United nations at the same time pakistan the is only reason destroying afghanistan by supporting terrorists groups like talibaan, mujahideen etc. Brother there is no offence about Pakistani people but your so called army and ISI is nothing but double faced terrorists

[@harshpasi2957]

@@untouchboy nailed it 😂

[@IndiaMarchingAhead]

Dr. Zakir Hussain, Mohammad Hidayatullah , Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed, too have been muslim Presidents of India besides Abdul Kalam

[@taajdaarhashmi4593]

@Mooda malyaar Pakistan also

[@taajdaarhashmi4593]

@Mooda malyaar Pakistani president and PM should be muslim

[@taajdaarhashmi4593]

@Mooda malyaar thank you

[@oppaianime4594]

Zakir hussian

[@Troublemaker4]

Dr Zakir Naik ran away from India and took asylum in Malaysia because Indian Hindu gov was about to kill him.

[@subscriberswithoutanyvid-nv4fn]

Indeed we Afghans and Indians got close to each other 😊

[@arslanaziz7249]

Gen Hammed Gul said in 2010 India always choose wrong side of history. Now America going to leave Afghanistan

[@shanejohn2452]

Pakistan Zindabad 🇵🇰 Afghanistan Zindabad 🇦🇫 Ahmed Shah Abdali (Baba-e-Qaum Afghanistan) Zindabad 💪 Islam Zindabad 🇵🇰❤️🇦🇫

[@nilanjangupta763]

@@shanejohn2452 Genghis Khan Zindabad.

[@darwinianchimp2630]

@@arslanaziz7249 Still of the same view?

[@gshrdy5415]

@@shanejohn2452 , Atleast you didn't say your original dads (Arabs) zindabad.

[@clanclashercoc1703]

India, Pakistan and Afghanistan are in line not in triangle

[@aaditsingh3632]

I love this comment XD

[@devilhex2802]

clanclasher@coc haha, yeah

[@RajKumar-ep8pr]

*facepalm*

[@---ct2hj]

😂

[@gshrdy5415]

learn more, you don't know much.

[@licagentbangaloreindia]

India has 22 official languages. According to Census of India, the total number of mother tongues spoken in India is 1652. However, only around 150 languages have a sizable speaking population. The Indian census of 1961 recognised 1,652 different languages in India (including languages not native to the subcontinent). source: Quora. India is a country for all those who think they are Indians.

[@ThePunee13]

muslims in india are not alieanated they are very succesful as any other secular people

[@ada9471]

Slaughter a cow and you find secularism

[@azrasaeed8926]

Very successful in securing low level jobs, like cleaning, car puncture shop, carpenter, etc......sorry for them, once they rule the subcontinents for centuries and look at them now, become lower than low

[@TheLieDestroyer140]

That’s why the Muslims actors are being abused. Even though we don’t class them as Muslim

[@username-nh5fv]

Soren Utpal it is home to many innocent people.

[@isrargulzar5069]

Modi RSS are in charge of India now same people who killed gandhi. Indian Muslims are seen as low by the extremists of Indian RSS. Modi is trying to get into Afghanistan and to circle Pakistan. Also you have close relationships with Iran and causing a stir by stoking relgious divide by Shia and sunni. Pakistan will defend it self and its interest. Taliban will be in power Afghanistan again when America leaves. Iran will go line also too and Pakistan know very well how to do it. Kashmir issue will be out in the mainstream.

[@sagarkale8070]

As Indian at may follow any religion but when u take a p j abdul kalam every without any doubt get goosebumps and pride in them .... we r lucky to have him ...

[@ozarintractive2534]

The major achievement of Dr. Apj Abdul kalam is not becoming the president and first citizen of India, but becoming the idol of 100% of the Indian youth. The author doesn't know a thing about Indian secularity.

[@mrht6094]

@Janardhan Parweshwar Majority of BJP spokespersons are Muslim.

[@babyjeevitha]

Don't give one example man. Look at the whole picture. They know what they're talking about

[@championman7992]

I was an youth when Azad was president and he was not my idol. So you are wrong.

[@hsn129]

Those Muslims who are coward and who are living under Hindu extremists are... Not muslims

[@mohammedmir777]

@@mrht6094 Pure fear 😨

[@Nvidia_Mesh]

Moral Is Pakistan is the core producer of Terrorists. Thanks Allah we separate in 1971. Pakistan is always a core terrorist producer.

[@soham4741]

Lupin Islam nice one Bangladesh

[@pilotcyborg.gaming]

@TheIronMan987 closet jihadi spotted

[@harsh.mishra28]

@@statusking16880 hahaha. Now say that without crying!!

[@rajadawoodyousuf9675]

same result as Jan 27 2019? their hero abhi doneDone who got caught and got kicked on the butt didn't speak nonsense

[@hassanareeinhassanaraeein2358]

Just wait for gazwa e hind

[@vishnuacharya6352]

As a UAE maulvi put it “Nations have military, In PAK the military has a nation”.

[@hireaper]

The uae is a corrupt society influenced by the wealth of the few. No surprise there with their similarities to the Indian elites.

[@Ravi_kkk]

And it is a terrorist country.. Osama is their father and hafeej is their mother

[@mrt8744]

And it burns your old ass. LMAO

[@winstonbachan9229]

@@congojander9743 AND KASHMIR IS TO INDIA WHAT LONDON IS TO GREAT BRITAIN OR BEJIN IS TO CHINA 🚩

[@tommathew7684]

Vishnu Acharya In Arabic, that must sound so scary!

[@cardcode8345]

SRK and Kalam, rest is enough. I 100% agree that most Muslims don’t get as many opportunities as Hindu’s do or get to enjoy the similar assimilated environment as Hindu’s do but, the situation is still not as bad or worst like Hindu’s in Pakistan. Muslims in India are like Muslims in USA, they have opportunities but most aren’t accepted beyond the cities and there communities.

[@weirdothings8672]

Don't put sir kalam and piece of sh¡t srk in same sentence 🙏

[@funtimewithriya2736]

Indian, afganistan are nw among pretty good frd allies

[@putintin]

always were.

[@mohammedfahad3564]

China and Pakistan too

[@kollamkaranforlife8798]

Naem Khan India and russia too.

[@hrishiupadhyay4267]

Yep think so

[@chitralvideos770]

Just Waite and see when US wil go bck . Afghanistan will be endian graveyard....

[@siddave100]

Dalrmple got most of it right, except for the fact that the most loved, respected and honored President of India was, in fact, a Muslim!

[@sanketsamant1050]

Cherry picking

[@abhisekdas435]

I think it's Dr Radhakrishnan not Dr Kalam

[@Edward4Plantagenet]

Presidents of India - Justice Mohammad Hidayatullah, Jakir Hussain, Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed, Abdul PJ Kalam.

[@sumanpalisetty6096]

The author doesn't know Dr. Kalam was president of India

[@kenningosh1447]

That is why he said “generally”

[@UseQPixinDune]

@@kenningosh1447 Finally, someone who makes sense

[@abdullahpurewalgmail]

Puppet authorities from Muslim minority

[@entertainment1443]

To All our Indian brothers and sisters!!! We Afghans will never forget your true friendship and help. From a religious perspective India has more Muslims than Pakistan, Indian Muslims are the most righteous and cultured people in South Asia.. In times of need we Afghans are ready to support you in all ways possible... Pakistan will never be Afghanistan friend till I am a live..

[@AliKhan-zq4px]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 you are an indian hindu

[@bhavyabhavsar53]

❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@lifePaultheball]

Long Live Afganistan. ❤

[@lovenature2794]

😊

[@govindr3140]

India is a secular country Ask anyone in India how they view former India's Muslimm President Abdul Kalam There is only respect No one even in the Hindu community hate kalam

[@drbharatj]

Who gave the visa to OSAMA ? How did he enter in to the Pakistan ? Cant be without documents . Who issued these documents ? Yes , the Ans.. is Pakistan .

[@epoche10]

Visa??? Are you serious??? HAHAHAHAHA you think he had a visa. You need to do some research on how Afghan people enter Pakistan.

[@epoche10]

+Masoody Khan Ok just see how anyone from Afghanistan enters Pakistan. Why do you think afghans get so pissed off if Pakistan wants to regulate border movement. You are all a bunch of internet scholars knowing nothing about reality.

[@bhootpurvmanusya]

afganistan pakkistan border is like nepal india u dont need document to enter

[@rohitjha8978]

bhootpurv manusya Afghanistan Pakistan border is an ungovernable area according to some people.

[@muhammadtasawar1556]

😆😆😆😆😆😆😆

[@dr.sakshinbelgavi]

"Not generally is positions of power "? we have had many Muslim President , PM , Supreme Justices etc ... ! and who can forget our beloved APJ Abdul Kalam ! But not as many maybe because of a simple fact ... there are more Hindus than Muslims in India !

[@abdullahpurewalgmail]

Puppet authorities from Muslim minority

[@shivamrai2809]

I think there are problems in Indian Society communalism, castesism, regionalism, sexism etc. We are not perfect but I think we are moving in the right direction. These division lines are fading with every passing year and in some areas and regions they are virtually non existent. Whatever it is atleast we are not being Pakistan trying to use every ounce of our budget in destabilizing neighboring countries .

[@RandomPerson-yz8jl]

@Soren Utpal Good luck with that ^^

[@pilotcyborg.gaming]

@Soren Utpal it will implode 😂😂 don't worry

[@videosfromchandoo]

I don't know author's history. I can just say he is not a real historian.

[@G.M.Cheema]

he is not historian but he cought the pulse of the conflict in afghanistan.that pulse is kashmir

[@geemoodhavahanan]

Where is Muslims neglected in india.? WTF

[@johnsmith8858]

hmm.. WATCH THE NEWS! and the you'll see the lynchings, murders, burnings, rape, etc... clueless much?

[@geemoodhavahanan]

@@johnsmith8858 none of those excites me. If it is your thing you stick to it. I'll keep on watching cute animal videos.

[@syedshafiq3249]

You guys! How do u c things now in 2020?

[@iamnot696]

that's exactly what happens when u create a monster one day it gets unleashed and turns back on u.

[@makg3679]

@Soren Utpal You Moron look at present BJP Govt set-up aik bhi muslim nahi, more than 300 cabinet memeber not a single muslim ..This man is absolutely correct, BJP is anti Muslim anti secularism, anti democracy and anti minority party...BJP is terrorist party with extremist support of RSS and VHP

[@tusharjain1801]

@@makg3679 chup Chutiye

[@tusharjain1801]

@@makg3679 300 cabinet minister tere baap ne banaya hai

[@clanclashercoc1703]

do not include India in it...open history of India , we never Attack first on any one. We have 60 years independence and see what we have achieved. You will get u r answer.

[@magicalgold010]

You bastards attacked In 1971 and still attacking in Kashmir

[@hsn129]

And open history of Pakistan we didn't attack first as well which one should we belive in Indian history or Pakistan history

[@nagadineshdusanapudi3376]

@@magicalgold010 Kashmir is our internal issue, we had never started a war but we will in further if we are pushed to our limits. Pakistan will never gets peace as long it hates India . Change atleast now.

[@mudassarghaffarmudassargha5122]

Hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh you know obut abinandan ☕

[@subrotonag214]

Exactly. 99.9% true. World should see this. Pakistans Paranoi about India.

[@TheLieDestroyer140]

Yeah paksitan is paranoid. They have only shot down indian jets after they illegally entered paksitan air space. Yeah paksitan is paranoid only because they have to Indian spies in custody admitting to committing terrorist attacks in paksitan. Wouldn't you be paranoid? And there are all undeniable facts. Where are the indian facts to prove there claims or is that really Indian paranoia.

[@mushwani85]

William you have the perfect knowledge of the crisces.

[@rocky-wp5ki]

Great video sir 👍 very knowledgeable

[@djoys7738]

India has huge number of doctors,engineers,lawers,scientists,politicians. Some of them presidents,VP, Judges. This guy has very poor ground level knowledge. Stright from holliwood type.

[@tomatoisasquishyfruit]

wrong! in india not all the major positions are hindus .the author should do some research. indian PM is a SIKH, the most powerful in India yhat is president of congress party Mrs Sonia gandhi is a roman catholic christian, our president Pranab mukherjee is a Hindu, in 21 century india nobody asks what religion u belong to, they just ask what can u do, what is ur ability, what can u contribute. no one gives a fuc***g sh*it about what religion u belong to. yes there are some guys who incite violence based on religion. but wait some more years. its not gonna happen then. I am an indian christian. 21 years old. till today, no one asked me which religion i belong to. because no body cares up here.

[@nileshp1347]

nobody cares coz you are in Hindu majority hindu land. U wont have such freedom in christain and muslim nations. One more thing you are not even christain. You are converted and your ancestors were hindus in fact you are Hindu only. Get ur facts correct.

[@nileshp1347]

Arjun Kini Mr I live in UK and for gods sake you dont tell me about europe. I know better than you. All countries you have mentioned above has only and only major problem i.e Islam.

[@nileshp1347]

Arjun Kini Dont start with u hv muslim friends n all. Every muslim will ask you to convert to islam at some point. so islam is a problem. Hv you ever read koran? I did. it sucks and full of hate. Koran should be banned.

[@tomatoisasquishyfruit]

+Odoyo Emperor of Hindu africans yes, I am a malabar Christian, converted to Christianity, by St Thomas, apostle of Christ 2000 years back... So yes, I am converted. I just have to ask,isn't every religion made, and people converted at some point of time, I mean no one drops off the sky as a Christian or a Muslim or a Hindu...so please keep ur "converted" theory with yourself... I live in India, have many Muslim friends and Hindu friends, we are tight mates..We work together.. Help each other.. Fully recognizing the fact that we belong to different religions. All this because we are educated...

[@nileshp1347]

Robin Thomas Mr I have no problem with any religion in the world except islam. Read koran u will understand the difference. So without knowing anything stop commenting.

[@JIBZANify]

He said it was highly suspicious for OBL to be in abotabad

[@riffraff8020]

author William Dalrymple is an ignorant man w/bias, it;snatural as he is British.

[@kapilgogia4861]

riff raff you should read his other books before coming to that opinion

[@AV-kl3dx]

@@kapilgogia4861 Why read his shitty books and waste time? There's a lot to read other than works of these garbage historians. This video is enough.

[@sumitk6800]

@@AV-kl3dx judgemental... Retarded brains are always judgemental.. Hahaha...

[@Xpakipiglover]

terror as policy ? osama bin laden living in abbotabad ?

[@KISHANSINGH-hb7ng]

Seems like this man has only superficial view of indo-pak-afghan relations. India has historical links with Afghanistan (In Mahabharata, Hastinapur queen Gandhari was from Afghanistan). He completely ignored the Pakistani army's fault in the spread of radicalism. A fool.

[@comicrewind2389]

KISHAN SINGH Its Your Media Lol Your Lol Media

[@hemantgokhale7923]

Kishan Singh wahabism was funded by Clinton's as per media reports and generally the Democrats with their leftist pro Ismic radicals policy.Who created Osama ? USA So Americans should start looking beyond their myopic history .

[@charsikhan2790]

Just another geek wow, indoctrination at its best. First off 600 AD? So Muslims went back in time since they weren’t around in 600 AD to invade Afghanistan. Secondly when the Muslims did take over Afghanistan that part of the world belonged to the Persian Sassanid/Safavid empire and did not have a Hindu king. How about you morons, on both sides actually pick up a book and read something apart from what is drilled into you through your respective medias

[@8tjboy]

@@charsikhan2790 It's so Idiotic of you that you disregard the history of Afghanistan. There was Kabul Shahi Dynasty which was there till 11th century. Moreover most of the Hazaras were Buddhist before they were forcefully converted.

[@charsikhan2790]

@@8tjboy Your inability to read shows just how incompetent you are. The comment made described there being a “Hindu” king in Afghanistan which was toppled by the Muslims. The idiotic comment (now deleted) even claimed that this happened pre 600D, 32 years BEFORE Islam was introduced to what is now Saudi Arabia. As for your comment on a majority hazara and Buddhist population living in Afghanistan being “forcefully” converted. Do you have any sources to back your claim? And by sources I mean Independent sources. Not some RSS hate speech you heard at some rally. As for your Kabul shahi reference, you may want to read into that a little more than just Wikipedia, it’s true that they faced the abbasids from the west, but what brought their kingdom down was INTERNAL squabbling, which is pretty much the story of the rulers in the sub continent. If you’re a weak pathetic little kingdom, you’re going 5o get swallowed up.

[@Grizzlybear1502]

I read the comments and a lot has changed since then

[@JustAStoner]

The piece has been kind on Pakistan for not highlighting the fact the refugees were used to curb balochi separation and fuel kashmiri insurgeance.

[@josephsm4661]

Pakistan people are good, some are bad, so do other countiries. The problem is there is not enough good leadership to guide those people to goodness.

[@flaminmongrel6955]

Leadership does what people like in order to gain the votes the politics has always been about economy in India whilst in Pakistan it was always about the islamic superiority".

[@TheLieDestroyer140]

Same as india

[@TheLieDestroyer140]

@@flaminmongrel6955 and your point is?

[@josephsm4661]

@@TheLieDestroyer140 are you sure? All Pakistan people know is to argue and fight. We are planning to send man to moon shortly!

[@josephsm4661]

@@TheLieDestroyer140 We don't have history of keeping Bin laden in our country! So our leadership is very different and not same as your country!

[@vishnurayden4256]

Lol the country who's main business is waging war against others in the name of Peace and stability but actually wants only the oil reserves, the country which killed millions of people in Japan and all over in Middle East, that country is labelling Asia as deadly triangle. World of visible Hypocrisy. 😂😂

[@virendraSingh-je3sx]

India has a contructive role building roads power stations hospitals schools destroyed by Taliban by support of Pakistan. UK plays a devisive roles. We support and respect all religions. No of Muslim's is increasing in India and of Hindus decreasing in Pakistan. Above two have poor knowledge of history in Indian subcontinent.

[@dawitshiferaw5710]

True indeed a very dangerous triangle. Very difficult people.

[@somnathchanda1250]

2014 Peshawar school massacre is what "willie" predicted in 2013 in this video @3:50.........

[@anilb1227]

There are these writers who never know whats happening. India changes every year. what happens in 2 years in India has happenend in 5 years in the west. Dont worry guys - we will catch up n 20 years.

[@blackman7186]

Pakistan's issue with india is totally psychological. They think india hate muslims but in fact india has amazimg ties with all neighboring muslim nations apart from Pakistan. Meanwhile pakistan itself does not have good relationship with its fellow muslim nation, Afghanistan. India is never the problem in this issue, it has always been and is pakistan whether you accept it or not.

[@oneallah5281]

Whats your views now in December 2020

[@Email-mu1mv]

Dust-Bin Laden was in Abottabad to search for a child-bride.

[@Email-mu1mv]

@@oldvibes7864 My mother''s name is Jemima Goldsmith.

[@oldvibes7864]

@@Email-mu1mv Good for u

[@xdadev]

*Most western experts and anchors like these are an absolute joke.* Firstly, India has more Muslim population than Pakistan and more mosques than entire islamic world. Secondly, Indian Muslims have held Positions of President, Military Chiefs, Intelligence Chiefs etc..cuz India is the largest secular Democracy. Saying India is a Hindu country is like saying USA and UK are Christian or the Middle east as Islamic...sounds communal, lol. Lastly, the west preferred and armed an Islamic dictatorial nation Pakistan instead of a Democratic India for furthering their interests in Afghanistan against USSR. And they think no one noticed this hypocrisy. Hindus, Christians, Sikhs, Parsis, Muslims, Jains, Buddhists, Jews etc all leave peacefully in India. Cheers 🥂

[@joshiumeshv]

Under British Raj, the two religions were pitted against each other successfully by the rulers. There was no country named Pakistan before 1947. But India was conglomerate of different states unified by composite culture. This composite culture has been teared off by partition made by British. Now the same partition is being exploited by big powers for the best of their interests.

[@sunnygupta4721]

I CAN NOT BELIEVE IT WAS SHOT 9 YEARS AGO ... AT THIS TIME 2023 ITS 100 % SHOWING THE SAME TRUTH AND RESULTS

[@shashirana9601]

A historian could be an Author but with limited knowledge of geopolitical situation this side an Author could not be a historian. RIP to your book👎

[@robinsen8858]

Strobe Talbott asks intelligent questions and tries to guide Dalrymple to give intelligent answers, unfortunately he gives convoluted and inaccurate replies. I was thinking of reading one of Dalrymple's books but I've changed my mind.

[@johnsmith8858]

LOLOLLL that is one of the most accurate western thinkers/consultants about that region... these fools citing Abdul Kalam is just silly... .

[@videoapp000]

listening this in 2022 makes this even scarier

[@fearecho7736]

Out of the whole population of Afghans there are more afghan pathan in Pakistan than Afghanistan

[@mujahid-9630]

FearEcho Pathan and Afghan means the same thing. Also numbers don’t matter. It was the pathans of Afghanistan that ruled over India and Pakistan since last 1000 years. The ones from Peshawar had no political power. Now, it’s still similar. All the power is with the Afghan Pashtuns wether it’s the taliban or even the Afghan government. The day they unite, they will be too strong and will fund the Pakistani Pashtuns and cause chaos in Pakistan. Afghanistan has a lot of rich minerals oil and gas. They will very quickly get rich if peace comes. And when they get rich they will cause a big concern for Pakistan and other neighbours

[@bahramghouri4035]

We've live in this region for thousands of years and Pakistan is created to create problem in this region so afghans are suffering in isi proxy war we've stand long before Americans and NATO involvement in Afghanistan and we well we want our historic land back from dose dalll khors

[@habibrr8583]

insha ALLAH very soon.

[@fatimaalnaz6115]

If you have power plzzz come on with your fathers randians

[@priyanshupandey2670]

@@fatimaalnaz6115 see if indians will come to fight then u have to surrender

[@usmanranjha9406]

Get him off whatever he's been smoking before you interview him next time. He's slurring his words

[@EragonShadowSlasher]

Totla hai saala

[@anirudh425]

All the three countries are in a line , what's the triangle here ??

[@ravindertalwar553]

India is a strong democracy capable and efficient to make the Global World--A BLESSED BEAUTIFUL AND BETTER PLACE TO LIVE IN.

[@yasinsamad7763]

We muslims are happy in india we hindu, muslim, christian live as brothers

[@sajjaddanyal3243]

Thats why modi government killed thousands of minority and you call this living in harmony.

[@yasinsamad7763]

@@sajjaddanyal3243 every nations including muslim countries kill so many peoples compare to them india is heaven i am not a supporter of modi i hate him but iam an indian & i love my country.i am from kerala &we live in perfect harmony

[@AbhishekPandey-qj7nk]

U can google it that who is the most loveable president of india in its entire history

[@sarabjitsingh5480]

sir yes there are some problem in india but we r in right direction to sove them we never suppor terrorisim or any extremist

[@harisht45]

India chose to become secular country. Muslims were in power in India and no Hindu can become president in Pakistan . Get your facts correct man.

[@aliakbarsafdari4084]

I am an Indian muslim and I'm so glad my grandfather did not emigrate to that hellhole, unlike the rest of his brothers..

[@mindoxygen7695]

Muslims are "alienated" in India? What a joker this guy is! Typical British mindset!

[@gee2190]

oh... man... William knows what is behind the curtain.

[@nc-pf3qm]

this guy is very ill informed

[@TheLieDestroyer140]

This guy needs to take some male enhancing products.

[@aadenreddy5536]

Doesn't matter brains are better than brawn

[@TheLieDestroyer140]

Sounds like your in bed with them.

[@masoodahmed3513]

great sir, you elaborate the facts in few minuts that are quite remarkable reflecting realities

[@mg9854]

Lol...well actually both of u guys are blind in that sense!

[@zuhss]

Nations have military, In PAK the military has a nation

[@jsingh265]

Jai afghan 🇦🇫 Jai India 🇮🇳

[@neripinto29]

Modiji will always prevail

[@HariSingh-uf9rw]

dear,aap iess triangle mein phas mat jana,kindly dont tangle in this triangle,it is very deadly,dear

[@mrinalkantidas9316]

Wrong statement on India, its a democratic state where on President post was given to a Muslim

[@shivamchhetri9893]

first of all Pak doesn't created taliban alone,it was created by U.S. for their benifit and once the pupose fulfilled they left Pakistan all alone.And secondly India is 2nd most populous muslim country in the world. So 1st u have proper knowledge about the south asian region,then only speak

[@ongoinger_108]

We had a muslim president and Hamid Ansari was vice president for more than 15 years, I don't understand when you says muslims are alienated in India?

[@ryzryz2402]

They break India into Afghanistan, Pakistan, India, Sri Lanka and now having conversations over these pieces, come on people be united again together you are a huge power.

[@Agnidev12]

Well said that West's arming of Jihadi extremist to counter USSR in Pakistan + Afghanistan backfired on USA

[@TheLieDestroyer140]

Why do you have to call them extremists or jihadi lol anybody there soldiers or an army lol you guys love pretending you no what's going on...

[@prabhakariyer7319]

You created it, the king's, churches, and the crusaders. You yet live the dream, if not on the same page, but yet using some pages. God bless.

[@ganesansastri8200]

Indian muslims are shining in every fields such as sports, Bollywood cinema, politics, music, Diplomatic, science and technology, ambassadors etc.etc. So nobody can need to worry about Indian muslims. In India every single citizen is protected by constitutional laws. And in India every religion & beliefs are personal in nature. But every citizen is respecting the "LAW OF LAND" which is first home to all.

[@fireking565]

100% correct

[@rohittantia4020]

10 years old video, Pakistan again supported Taliban and repeated it's mistakes, same situation again today!!

[@deathskunk3]

Really like this guy

[@Drsashisekhardubey]

They did predict the 2014 peshawar school attack brilliant analysis

[@nupurghatge684]

Indian muslims are much more educated and well known muslims around the world while pakistani muslims are not as educated as indians.. Look at examples of apj abdul kalaam zakir hussain and many more love india.. Jay hind🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳❤❤❤🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@annyoung7853]

Nupur Ghatge the average IQ of Indians is 82. The average IQ of Pakistan is 83

[@soham4741]

Ann Young and they use their iq in making bombs and guns . There you go .

[@MuhammadAliFaraz]

Look, what India did in Kashmir I do not think that Pakistan was paranoid. This was what Pakistan has feared all this time.

[@suraj-op2bx]

U must be glad among these three India is still HINDU, BUDDH, JAIN, SIKH, PARSI, CHRISTIAN But not islamic majority Pray to ur Jesus India remain non islamic Coz SELUCUS NIKATOR suffered very well Or should I remind them history of their most powerful ruler of West

[@KowsarAhmadi]

This is the beginning of WW3 people hate each other.

[@mini3460]

He had s just blabbering away. Like he knows.

[@karlmuud]

Hit piece.

[@Astrashastra]

India doesn't play double game with Afghanistan and usa, pakistan does. When afghans face crisis india will be the first to help, but if you want aghan people to suffer, you can trust pakistan on that.

[@GaneshKumar-bi1zl]

We Indian never Thinks of Muslims. Christians. Ect ect. We feel all our brothers and sisters. We Hindus respects every religion And values. We celebrate Christmas. Ramzan etc no mater who ever god is. We all live and stand as Indian That’s why India. Living in peaceful way

[@Ytube928]

I inly heard about the love triangle untill this video showed up lol a deadly triangle. .lol cool

[@varunmishra3447]

Western media is not only biased but they even do the proper homework or research on the topics which they discuss..

[@abdurrasheed1652]

*Outcome of British empire,s colonial policy of "DIVIDE AND RULE"......*

[@Alvinrasher]

Well it is now

And we Indians are the champions or boss of the triangle

[@amarjeetsehmi8995]

Jinnah created and demanded separate Pakistan for Islamic country while most Muslims remained and refused to move to Pakistan. Pakistan has Sunni, Ahmedya, Shia and Balochi, Sindhi and many others.Punjabi continued to dominate and keep its forces istly from Punjab. Other minorities like Sikhs, Hindus, Christians others continue to be persecuted and treated as slave to pressurize is migration to India or other countries.

[@sylvester63]

The ghost of Osama bin Laden continues to haunt Pakistan!

[@qadwani4327]

sylvestre US created Osama not Pakistan

[@tauhidershadKUFNAFLORAN]

@@qadwani4327 Yeah, pakistan only safeguarded him, but that's not a biggie.