Dialogue with History Episode 19: Is Pakistan a Failed State?: GupShup with Aftab Iqbal

[@vinayverma520]

This gentle man have great patience through deep knowledge. I am listening first time in your programme never except from you.

[@newcoc4105]

He is a moron

[@fiazbhatti7080]

doctor ishatyq saab and aftab iqbal saab you are both intellectual person ap bhot zyda izaat ky keble ha

[@shamsghafoor2974]

We are very lucky. Prof Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed give us his precious time to us. Thanks to honourable Sir Aftab Iqbal to conduct such an excellent show.

[@asadify]

i must say bohat si cheezein jo hamari course books me hain wo sirf ek side dikhati hain...dosri side mujhe is show se pata lag rahi hai...best show ever...best segment hai ye

[@mobyinayet5383]

There is never any harm in having frank discussions. We need to acknowledge our strengths and weaknesses. Living nations do so every day. Those of us who have been fed only selected versions of history must wake up and smell the coffee :-)

[@AftabIqbalOfficial]

Well said Moby! Great comments as always.

[@noacademmynews]

Mashallah buhut acha program hi sir. You should put English subtitles as well

[@Shahidiqbalrehan]

Aftab iqbal Sab app nay youtube pay yeh channel bna kr bhot acha kiya keon k bhot sari batin jo krni chye wo t.v astation par nhi ki ja sktii our agr app kay pass knowdge hay to app ko zroor shre krna chyeee . to fainly main app ko Congratulate and thanks khna chta hun is kam k lyee

[@goharkietian]

Amazing work done Sir Aftab....... I just watched last 3 episodes and it is continously increasing my historical knowledge. I have 2 questions: 1. How much the history of Pakistan being twisted... was the 1965 war started by Indians or Pakistani govt.? 2. Please also do Mehkma e Makholiat episodes too.. a bit of comedy is also necessary...

[@tabbasumhussain7045]

ماشااللہ ۔سر آفتاب اللہ پاک آپ کو لمبھی عمر اتا کرے تاکہ آپ ہم پاکستان کے لوگوں کو اسے ہی علم کی روشنی دیتے رہیں۔پرگرام کی ٹائیمنگ زیادہ ہونی چائیے ۔

[@apricity50]

What a beautiful forum you have established for youth, perfect source of information. Thak you ! stay blessed !!!

[@toqe3rahmad]

We need programs like this to educate our society. Unfortunately media is totally indulged into useless political shows which bear no fruit, and mostly biased towards one particular party.

[@MUhammadRizwan-cq8ht]

Sir Pakistan should provoke an enlighten mindset to eradicate all social and economic evils. Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed is a pragmatic man. Lots of love for you

[@shirazkhan4484]

shukria aftab saheb shiraz khan uae

[@ParhoLikhoAgayBhado]

superb sir... hmara dhyaan is taraf murtkiz krny ka shukrya!!!

[@bestestforyou]

Too much interesting information. The basic problem of Pakistan along with corruption is a lack of good leadership. Im totally agree.

[@msaleem2373]

Very good - balanced approach, touched with reason, braced by knowledge and inspired by virtue

[@masoodurrehman7015]

zabardst sir. ......Good information

[@ibrahimkhalil855]

Very very much nice,we agree with all the statements made in this conversation.

[@jaraal110]

Sir such informative programmes are better than writing books. And as these programmes will always be available on KZbin , they are sadqa e Jariya. God bless you.

[@omprakashsharma3972]

Love you sir from india

[@abdulsaboorbscs-074]

Love you so much sir, you are great just keep showering us with your knowledge and wisdom

[@aftabbahenasiihtsabsanenai5365]

vary nice janab

[@muksk7474]

I can not believe that we are having such brilliantly informative programs. Its a great initiative which should be discussed on mainstream media. Great work sir!

[@AftabIqbalOfficial]

Thanks for the kind words Muksk! We hope you will continue to participate by subscribing to the channel and sharing the videos you like with your friends!

[@farrukhraza6157]

Very Informative

[@sjsajju8852]

Salute of respect janaab best minutes of knowledge

[@shoaibghayal5886]

very informative sir very nice

[@afzalshabir1173]

Keep it up❤😍

[@qasimlora9297]

v nice sir

[@umerbhuttah1367]

kisi ik corrupt politics ko hang kr k nishane ibrat bnani chahye

[@mohammadnaeemarain2076]

Geo my Sweet brother Very Nice Allah pak apko or izzat o taraqi ata frmye aameen

[@asadarshad6700]

sir aftab iqbal u are a great pak man in tha world i love u sir aftab iqbal keep up it sir poriiii koumm ap kyyy sathhh hyy EN SHA ALLAH

[@AftabIqbalOfficial]

+Asad Arshad thanks for the support! We hope you subscribe and share the videos you are enjoying!

[@asadarshad6700]

GupShup With Aftab Iqbal my pleasure sir

[@rajsood6343]

Beautiful efforts , keep it up , Sir, my thanks for your kind information...

[@akib2542]

kindly do a series on the environmental challenges facing Pakistan both through our internal policies and external threats.. we are safe atm but only a few years ago so were Yemen, Sudan and Syria.. and one of the root causes for their current situation are environmental factors causing drought and famine

[@asimshahzad2976]

Good information sir

[@wonderfulldivyanshi]

I m big fan of AFtab iqwal and this intectual

[@mbali1115]

Aftab Sar U R Great

[@niazhussain2993]

peoples like aftab iqbal are needed to use media in right direction..

[@getakif]

Sir, Excellent discussion. I have two questions 1. First is regarding conquering other countries. All that has happened or happening in syria iraq and libya is very much in 21st century. 2. Question is about Bangladesh as if Pakistan claims to be islamic state, india is secular what should Bangladesh be., Complicated. As they got divided based on ethnicity but there is huge part of bengal still with india with same ethnicity

[@AlviSultan]

Another Good Program, with entertaining exchange between Aftab Iqbal and loomarrh, Honey Albela. Like Panama Leaks, CPEC is another God-given opportunity for us to move the whole nation forward. Get rid of the current corrupt Mafia and put a solid effort into CPEC. Success with CPEC will automatically resolve the long-lingering problem of Kashmir with India as well.

[@AftabIqbalOfficial]

Thanks for the kind words Sultan! We hope you will continue to participate by subscribing to the channel and sharing the videos you like with your friends!

[@mehmoodmughal9511]

good

[@hadi6376]

good show

[@tarygee]

So nice it's very important information for youth thx

[@AftabIqbalOfficial]

Thanks for the kind words Tary! We hope you will continue to participate by subscribing to the channel and sharing the videos you like with your friends!

[@faisalmehboob3137]

Great yaar good job well don histery told us

[@ImranKhan-sr2te]

Aftab sir love to listen u.and host is simple and kind she is a real picture of Asian cultural women even she studied in England still I think she is a proud of Pakistan 🇵🇰

[@izharsadiq6468]

nice show

[@wasimkhan-oc7hz]

Exactly, aftab sahab members of Kashmir committee are not able to be clerk. I heard interview of nawab wasan from previous government, he even don't know who is mehbooba mufti Shame on our politicians

[@shahzadwarraich5356]

V..... Good..... Sir

[@naseerahmad4349]

Good g

[@AlviSultan]

My expectation and prediction is that Aftab Iqbal will soon prove to be another Imran Khan for Pakistan. MashaAllah, all my love, respect and prayers are for his success and his family.

[@skycomputers1652]

sir Aftab great work what u are doing.

[@ameerjunaid8889]

❤

[@Lawwithhassanjamal]

Beautifull

[@khalidmemon7843]

sir v good effort. sir g mera ap se shikwa he ap ne kabi sindh ki history ko discuss nhi kia. plzzz sir g ek nishist is pr b taken. thanks

[@ZaheerAhmed-xs1sf]

very informative thora agre Year by year aap discussion karo to mazeed information mily aur jo roshni k minar kharry hain in ka b asal pata chal jaye baki books k naam zaror btaty rahne

[@mirzabaig9411]

Thanks for the great knowledge I would never able to find these fact By the way I am your big follower Thanks again God bless you

[@BubblesPothowari]

Dear Aftab, pl let the guest speak, who has been invited..... regards from Mumbai

[@shaamshanyshany3167]

BubblesPothowari.. Aftab Iqbal is annidiot Anchor. HE NEVER RESPECT HIS GUESTS AND NEVER PAY ATTENTION TO HIS VIEWS. YOU CANT TRANSLATE THE MEANING OF THIS SENTENCE IN ENGLISH . ~~~ WOH HER WAQT LUCH TALTA REHTA HEI..

[@ranaumairajmalkhan6047]

shany apka comment apki soch ki akaasi ker raha hai. do me a favour, ap aisa karo kay apki comment ko kisi aur ka comment samajh kay parho. i am sure kay ap bhi yeah comment likhney waley ko galian do gay. best wishes.

[@shaamshanyshany3167]

Umair Ajmal. Mein Bala ki tarah luch taluun ga to galian to khauun ga hi. Ye banda bohot bad tameez hei. Auron ko tameez sikhata hei leikin khud tameez ke nazdeek bhi nahi gaya. Andhon mein kaana Raja wala hisab hei is Jaahil ka.

[@ussmankhhan9888]

good sir g

[@farrukhraza6157]

Somehow,we were worried that,one day KWAI will end up.. But this initiative shows that,u'll continue...

[@AftabIqbalOfficial]

+Raza Jaffery thanks we will continue with your support!

[@majidibrahim4561]

Hamary mulk ma bhi corruption ki saza sazae mot honi chahiye

[@muhammadsaeed2346]

sir I like it your talking

[@MrHajuu]

جنوبی کوریا کی ترقی میں سب سے بڑا کردار ذریعہء تعلیم کا کوریائی میں ہونا ہے۔

[@teabreakbrewdevilskettle2820]

Pakistan same tjing doing in balochistan what they did in with bangladesi

[@mr.stubborn8025]

sir you should also talk about Illuminati and free meson. i studied a lot about this but want more by you

[@alisufyan461]

Bahi I live Canada Calgary Alberta ap ka Canada ka program Nice plz invite Imran Khan Sab ko

[@ulfatmir6900]

Good going my question is ,Why we accepted Pakistan in two parts?

[@Enslaved_96]

Sir Ap qadm bhrhayn hum apky sath hn gy hr qadm please ap ayn sisat me

[@bittugym8282]

election. hain kolkota main

[@mohammadnaeemarain2076]

Geo my Sweet brother

[@skycomputers1652]

problm of pak= 1. corruption on every leval .2. incompetancy .3. lack of educstion both technical nd moral. 4.over population. 5.policy making people not knowing well people of diffrent regions nd geography of pakistan.

[@AmitPatel-nb6us]

Sky Computers Same prblm india ka v hai.

[@trshuk]

if militry intervened,why they did not solve any problem?Problem is still there.I guess problem in social thinking.We should have open mind i.e other side can also think better and give the other side genuine RIGHT and respect and have patience.Let the social convulsions (democracy) take its root. RB Rakha!

[@AftabIqbalOfficial]

Interesting point. Thanks for sharing!

[@toseef28]

Bangladesh is now emerging state, we have ready made garments from Bangladesh in UAE, feel sad to buy made in India and made in Bangladesh products, we have only a rice in market which is from Pakistan.

[@skycomputers1652]

tmam friendz se guzarish k coments kr te wakat jo logic h ya ray wo pash krn . kindly harsh word ek dosrey k barey use na krain. if posible.thanks

[@projecttitans]

Yeh sehle rawan hamara ..thumta na tha kissi sey... comes to mind the story of corrupt Pak elite (jahils)

[@wonderfulldivyanshi]

would that they two intectuals born in india

[@Makz2000]

To sum it all, Pakistan is a failed state. Even Bangladesh has moved pas Pakistan despite the late start.

[@skycomputers1652]

PAK not failed .having great potentional. PAK needs only sincere nd visionry leadership.coperative tax paying public.

[@ranaumairajmalkhan6047]

yeah sincere leadership aasmaan say nahi uterey gi bhai. vote kisi shareef insan ko do gay then hi kuch theek ho sakta. vote to ap kuttey billey khotey ya shair ko detey ho . bhai janwar ko vote do gay to wo janwar wala salook hi karey ga na. insan ko vote dey kay dekho, i am sure kafi afaaqa hoga :p

[@shahzadwarraich5356]

Sir Islam ki history... Pae b kbi bat kraeeee

[@shahjahan8403]

sir im sorry.. kasoor war ap log bi han.. agr ap election me participate kro or dr. ishtique sahib sahib out of contry ja k na bethen or mulk k lye koi kaam kren to yeh mulk abi bi boht agy ja sakta ha..

[@skycomputers1652]

I agreed with u sir

[@AlviSultan]

Zahid Naveed: I believe the real solutions to Pakistani problems is in the hands of talented Pakistanis who are currently working abroad. They are ready and willing to come back to help the motherland but only after the current Nawaz-Zardari Mafia is removed and given the appropriate punishment. Love from Toronto, Canada.

[@skycomputers1652]

sultan mehmood alvi ...... thanks for good feelings for motherland ....from canada

[@shahjahan8403]

sir i respect ur views.. but ab log boht samjhdar ho ry han..media boht fast ho gya ha..me sirf ek bat kehta hn.. k overseas pakistani sirf pakistani govt py sirf ek pressure cooker ka kaam kren..imran khan ny dhrana syst kr k time waist kia..sirf election reforms krwa laity k je matric fail citizen vote ni daal sakta yaken kren yeh nawaz zardari or altaf ko ek bi vote na mily..

[@AlviSultan]

Zahid Naveed Sahib: Mein aap se agree nahin kerta ke Imran ne dharna de ker waqt zaaya kia hai. Dharna did a tremendous job of waking up our ignorant and stupid people. The whole set up of Pakistan has to be replaced. Every facet of our society has been ruined by Nawaz Brothers and Zardari & Company. We need more and more people like Imran Khan, Sheikh Rasheed, Dr. Tahirul Qadri, Asad Umer, Dr. Shahid Masood, Mr. Aftab Iqbal, etc. Once the current mafia is removed by Panama Case decision, you will see the country moving forward at a rapid pace. However, all good Pakistani must pitch in and do their bit to move this country forward. Overseas Pakistani are doing their best to help the mother land, and will do more in the near future, InshaAllah! Keep up the good work, and I wish you well!

[@ammiebro786]

[@TheMUBASHER138]

nice show

[@tareqjafeed6612]

good

[@toseef28]

Bangladesh is now emerging state, we have ready made garments from Bangladesh in UAE, feel sad to buy made in India and made in Bangladesh products, we have only a rice in market which is from Pakistan.

[@tareqjafeed6612]

good

[@toseef28]

Bangladesh is now emerging state, we have ready made garments from Bangladesh in UAE, feel sad to buy made in India and made in Bangladesh products, we have only a rice in market which is from Pakistan.