Dialogue with History Episode 22: What is Pakistan's Biggest Problem?: GupShup with Aftab Iqbal

What is Pakistan's Biggest Problem? This Episode is a discussion of Pakistan's Biggest Problem--Corruption. Watch the previously unaired episode from the original host of Hasb e Haal, Khabarnaak, and Khabardar.
Subscribe now: / @aftabiqbalofficial
Please like, share, comment, and subscribe!
/ gupshupwithaftabiqbal
/ gupshupwaftab
Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed is a Swedish political scientist and author of Pakistani descent. He holds a Ph.D. in Political Science from Stockholm University. He has taught at Government College University, Lahore the Lahore University of Management Sciences (LUMS), Stockholm University, and the National University of Singapore. He is a member of the editorial advisory boards of "Asian Ethnicity"; "Journal of Punjab Studies"; "IPRI Journal, Islamabad"; and "PIPS Research Journal of Conflict and Peace Studies, Islamabad". He has written numerous books on the politics of South Asia, political Islam, human rights, multiculturalism, ethnicity, identity, and nationalism.
Aftab Iqbal, best known as the original host of Hasb e Haal, Khabarnaak, and Khabardaar, is launching a brand new KZbin channel custom-tailored to the fans. We will feature new, never-before-seen content, unlike anything that has ever existed on Pakistani television. He has been on numerous channels including currently on Express News, but also Geo TV, and Dunya TV.
Watch our promo trailer here: • Gup Shup with Aftab Iq...
Watch the Pilot Episode of Dialogue with History here where Aftab Iqbal discusses Kashmir, CPEC, and the Indian Partition: • Dialogue with History ...
Watch Episode 2 of Dialogue with History where Aftab Iqbal discusses Corruption, the Panama Papers, and Muckrakers: • Dialogue with History ...
Watch Episode 3 of Dialogue with History where Aftab Iqbal discusses the Cure to Corruption in Pakistan: • Dialogue with History ...
Watch Episode 4 of Dialogue with History where Aftab Iqbal discusses whether or not Democracy is the ideal form of government for Pakistan: • Dialogue with History ...
Watch Episode 5 of Dialogue with History where Aftab Iqbal discusses the controversy around Premature Elections for Nawaz Sharif due to the Panama Papers scandal: • Dialogue with History ...
Watch Episode 6 of Dialogue with History where Aftab Iqbal discusses the Birth of the Nation of Pakistan and the Indian Partition Part 1: • Dialogue with History ...
Watch Episode 7 of Dialogue with History where Aftab Iqbal discusses the Birth of the Nation of Pakistan and the Indian Partition Part 2: • Dialogue with History ...
Watch Episode 8 of Dialogue with History where Aftab Iqbal discusses the Decline of the Establishment Part 1: • Dialogue with History ...
Watch Episode 9 of Dialogue with History where Aftab Iqbal discusses the Decline of the Establishment Part 2: • Dialogue with History ...
Watch Episode 10 of Dialogue with History where Aftab Iqbal discusses the why Alexander is Not so Great Part 1: • Dialogue with History ...
Watch Episode 11 of Dialogue with History where Aftab Iqbal discusses the why Alexander is Not so Great Part 2: • Dialogue with History ...
Watch Episode 12 of Dialogue with History where Aftab Iqbal addresses the question Should Pakistan have been formed? Part 1: • Dialogue with History ...
Watch Episode 13 of Dialogue with History where Aftab Iqbal addresses the question Should Pakistan have been formed? Part 2: • Dialogue with History ...
Watch Episode 14 of Dialogue with History where Aftab Iqbal and special guest Dr. Mubarak Ali discuss the writing of our history? • Dialogue with History ...
Watch Episode 15 of Dialogue with History where Aftab Iqbal and special guest Dr. Mubarak Ali address the critics of our history with a focus on the Mughal period: • Dialogue with History ...
Watch Episode 16 of Dialogue with History where Aftab Iqbal and special guest Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed discuss why Pakistan was created Part 1: • Dialogue with History ...
Watch Episode 17 of Dialogue with History where Aftab Iqbal and special guest Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed discuss why Pakistan was created Part 2: • Dialogue with History ...
Watch Episode 18 of Dialogue with History where Aftab Iqbal and special guest Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed discuss why Pakistan was created Part 3: • Dialogue with History ...
Watch Episode 19 of Dialogue with History where Aftab Iqbal and special guest Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed discuss if Pakistan is a Failed State: • Dialogue with History ...
Watch Episode 20 of Dialogue with History where Aftab Iqbal and special guest Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed discuss if Pakistan is an Idealogical State Part 1: • Dialogue with History ...
Watch Episode 21 of Dialogue with History where Aftab Iqbal and special guest Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed discuss if Pakistan is an Idealogical State Part 2: • Dialogue with History ...

[@daralmabnaestablishment7638]

Aftab Sab thank you very very much for having Dr. Ishtiaq on your show. Meri taraf say Dr. sab ko deero salam. Stay Blessed.

[@MUhammadRizwan-cq8ht]

Bravo Bravo Dr. Istiaq. You're the man of century. You're ideology will practice very soon in state of Pakistan

[@khalidrasheed1716]

i empresed . Aftab Iqbal SB. main ap k show ko bry ghor sy sunta hon aur agy share bi krta hon

[@turkifahadalshadukhiest7013]

BOHAT KHOOB BOHAT KUCH SIKHNE KO MILTA HAI APKE PROGRAMS SE ALLAH PAK APKO HIMAT AUR ISTEQAMAT DIE JAZAKALLAH AMEEN SUMA AMEEN

[@mohammadnaeemarain2076]

excellent work Geo my Sweet lovely big brother aftab Iqbal Bhai allah pak apko bori nazar se mehfoz rakhe aameen

[@asadify]

i agree sir...hamare course me bohat si cheezein hain jo sirf myth hain...aur bohat se students unhi cheezoun ko sach maan kar chalte hain...me khud is show se reality view kar rha hun...

[@mobyinayet5383]

Great discussion. Please keep going. We need such frank discussions rather than sweeping sensitive topics under the rug and pretend they don't exist.

[@alkubaisi9585]

brillient actually speachless

[@ghulammustafa-qc3br]

اسلام اعلیکم سر ۔ پاکستان کا سب سے بڑا مسئلہ ناانصافی ہے اسی وجہ سے باقی سب ہین

[@neshanabbas3693]

Thanx a information very nice

[@touseef_akhtar]

Best as Always !! Keep it up .

[@mansoorkhan1313]

very nice show sir you are doing a great job.I have a request plez discuss about problems related to balochistan and which policy led to baloch rebalionist stance against govt and punjab.

[@mujtabajafri4958]

India and Pakistan should have friendly relations and both should separate their economic from politics. Great job sir.! Hats off to both of you.

[@maqsoodansariniazali9641]

اگلے دن کی بجائے آپ next episode کا استعمال کیجئے پلیز

[@izharsadiq6468]

superb

[@kumarmantosh4878]

Very nice show I m big fan

[@naqashraza726]

Sir you are doing great job by discussing history to educate new generation. Its very informative channel. I like it.

[@AftabIqbalOfficial]

Thanks again Naqash! Please subscribe and continue to share with your friends!

[@naqashraza726]

I subscribed it.

[@santoshroat7955]

Great

[@jattvolume3]

and please advise dr sahib to put his literature on google books/ amazon. please its hard to find pakistan factual books online. and if its already online; i apologize

[@mlangientertainment5445]

Bravo

[@projecttitans]

Aftab Bhai I would like you to do a very detailed discussion on British occupation on India from state to the end and its causes... Thanks in Advance..

[@TheSah85]

salam, aftab sahab aapke yeh 22episodes aga koi bhi banda jisme 1% ki samaj ho, dekehga aur amal karega toh India - Pakistan ki dosti aur Pakistan ki taraqqi pakki hai... Meri dil se dua hai apke liye

[@mkhan3982]

good work aftab sahab. if you can do one program on the rule of Abdul Ghafar Khan (bacha khan) in context of India partition then it would be great for the people of Pakistan to know truth about their great hero.

[@asimshahzad2976]

nice show sir

[@pakrose]

Sir Aap Copyrights Enable karain Doosre Chanel wale bhi upload kr rhe hain,

[@MsPinkrose786]

جناب آفتاب اقبال صاحب میں آپ کا پرانا فین ہوں مگر آپ سے رابطہ آج پہلی بار کر رہا ہوں میں آپ کے پروگرام عموما یو ٹیوب پر دیکھا کرتا ہوں اور جب مجھے آپ کے ذاتی چینل کا پتہ چلا تو میں نے اس کو دیکھا اور اکثر دیکھتا ہوں مگر اس میں مجھے ایک کمہ محسوس ہوئی ہے کہ نئی اقساط نہیں ملتی وہی پرانی دیکھنے کو ملتی ہیں۔ براہ کرم نئی اقساط کو بر وقت اپ لوڈ کروایا کریں تاکہ اس چینل سے پوری طرح استفادہ حاصل کیا جا سکے شکریہ۔ عامر اعجاز حویلوی(اوکاڑوی

[@Dunyannambr]

nyc

[@solidwaters1866]

i must appreciate you always remind us APS, we cannot move on with India in friendly environment. until we avenge our innocent children blood.

[@AftabIqbalOfficial]

Thanks for the comment Azhar, just remember that an eye for eye leaves the whole world blind.

[@solidwaters1866]

GupShup With Aftab Iqbal agree, but we must not show our weakness again, as weakness invites aggression. i must qout your own words let's compete India educationally, economically, and on moral values. thank you for your contribution to our society

[@ammarahmed2810]

Pakistan is bestowed with every resource by the almighty; we only lack sincere people who can lead us from the front for the betterment of this country.

[@mbali1115]

nyc shoo

[@MuhammadUsman-nz8pv]

I wanted to talk to you regarding this concept. Thanks now i can say here my perception. I guess corruption is completly defined by means of action means its set of actions which result in malfunction in various forms of society. But we all know that before action there comes intent, intent is source and action is always result of that intent. So to understand main problem we will have to look for that source in our behaviours as a society, from where comes this intent to do corruption in all walks of life, for our society as a whole. If we study other various models where nations have changed their course completely, just like France than after losing wars from germany they also taught there society some lies but still they manage to rise, so this means even if you do something with history but if you stick to them still you can achieve something as a society. So it come down to behaviours/ non seriousness which is being injected by our education system. I guess route cause is lack of education and enlightement. I guess its such an education system which injects this virus of non seriousness in very early part of our life and thus as a result whole society take everything for granted and they think tweaking with this will nit effect and thus we get what we are, we need to change this in our next generations and onky way is education.

[@jattvolume3]

sir talk about open borders between hind pak and kashmir being a buffer state... and possible introduction of ipec , between und nd pak.. i understand why ind keeps pak occupied with kashmir issue bt i dont understand why pak doesnt utilize the indian market,the way china does...

[@zohairazzak1226]

sir thori c sport's py b bat honi chahey agr Pakistan and India aps men sports ko forog den to ham dono countrys Olympic games men boht koch kr sakty han

[@AbdulRehman-to4qr]

Sir have's and have's not ki samajh nahi ai. What is this. Please ap kuch bata dyn.

[@GOGA_DON]

have's not= jis ke pass kuch nhi ha have's = jis ke pass sab kuch ha

[@AbdulRehman-to4qr]

amir ali bhai thank you! Me samajh raha tha k shyd yeh koi political term hai. Thank you very much!😊

[@afzalshabir1173]

❤

[@iqbaluk]

دنیا کی تاریخ چاہے ماضی بعید کی ہو یا ماضی قریب کی ہمیشہ اس قوم کی کامیابی اور ناکامی کی بنیاد پر ہی پرکھی جاتی ہے. اور وقت کے مؤرخ ہر دور میں اس قوم کے موجودہ حالات کو بنیاد بنا کر اپنا بیانیہ تبدیل کرتے رہیں گے. کچھ تاریخیں تو الله کی حکمت کا پیش خیمہ ہی ہیں. انگریز کا ہندوستان میں آنا حکمت خداوندی لگتا ہے کہ جس طرح سے یہاں کی قوم مسلم بادشاہوں، نوابوں اور جاگیر داروں کے چنگل میں ١٠٠٠ سال سے پھنسی ہوئی تھی، مزید ١٠٠٠ سال بھی غلام بن کر ہی رہ رہی ہوتی. اس کی کچھ ملتی جلتی مثال دیکھنا ہو تو سندھ کے دیہات میں آج بھی دیکھی جاسکتی ہے.

[@s.k.parashar2175]

History has enough lesson which we will learn or not choice is there.But now the time has come to draw roadmap for future. There is a thousand war story of England n France in history we have read. Where are they now. How they moved on.

[@GOGA_DON]

sir Pakistan main ane wale 50 saalon main bhi population control nhi ho skti.......or aap ko uss ki waja pta hia....keun ke log population ko religion ke point of view se dekhte hain.

[@ROUMI7777]

Please invite Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy.

[@GOGA_DON]

yess.....he must be invite in this show

[@aliraza_1953]

Islam says born child as want as you want

[@iqbaluk]

Make Pakistan a successful Nation and you will see that these (Same) Historian will change their narrative that "20% was too much given to India, under Sindh Tass Treaty". History is always interpreted/judged differently in each Era based on the success and failure of the Nation.

[@skycomputers1652]

1A. good sir. history depends on success and failur

[@NaeemAkramAndroidiOSApp]

Kalabagh dam is the silver bullet?

[@NaeemAkramAndroidiOSApp]

but sir our women want to have more children . plus our society make school teacher job easy for women but they can't get into really profitable businesses.

[@asif1]

پھر دو قومی نظریہ کیا ہے

[@AftabIqbalOfficial]

Thanks for your comment.

[@asif1]

سر آپ کو فالو کرتے ہیں اس لئے اعتراض آپ سے ہی سیکھا ہے.

[@Rajakhoji]

sir my question is why Pakistan is not saving the water.why not the army take action and take decision.because its about the survival of people of our country our politicians r in deep sleep.our cost on product is so high we can't survive in international markets.............................

[@fgghjk1131]

سر شاید میرا یہ ایک گستانہ مذاق ھے یا قدرت کا حصول پانی ھم سنبھال نہی سکتے اس لیے وہ اس کو کنٹرول کرنے کا بندوبست کر رھے ھے ھمارے رہنما مستقبل کے بارے میں نہی سوچتے اور وہ آنے والے وقت کو بہتر کر سکے

[@MohammadAli-uu8pp]

Pakistan and its mammoth problems are they actually correctable .. or will it go on to live a crippled and injured life for ever ??

[@bestestforyou]

Population is also a cause as it has alot solutions to resolved.

[@malikimran547]

اسلام علیکم سر آج آپ نے 1966 والی بات کی زرا وضاحت سےاس کا ذکرفرمائیےگا دوسری بات یہ ہے کہ آپ انگلش کم اور اردو ذیاده بولیں تو خاصوں کے ساتھ عام بہی مستفید ہوں گے انشاءاللہ

[@muhammedmudassirqureshi1309]

Mujhay aik do baatoo par aitraaz hay Hum Allah KO maantay hain Laikin Allah ki nahi maantay aisa Kio. Aap spirituality ki baat kartay hay aap nay dunia ki bhoat si kitaboo k sath Quran bhi parha hay jismay waaziha likha hay about population control. quran.com/6/151 Come, I will recite what your Lord has prohibited to you. [He commands] that you not associate anything with Him, and to parents, good treatment, and do not kill your children out of poverty; We will provide for you and them. Surat Al-'Isra' [17:31] And do not kill your children for fear of poverty. We provide for them and for you. Indeed, their killing is ever a great sin. Maira dosra sawal law implementation k baray may hay Kio possible nahi hay Islamic law. Kia jo punishment Quran o Sunnah may hay kia Wo ishtiaq AHMED sahib ki nazar may non implementable hay. Yea Allah aur uskay Rasool(SA) ka hukum dunia aur apni sooch say ziada aihmiat rakhta hay. Jawab zaroor dijiay ga. Aagar ijteehad ki zarorat hay tu Wo sunnah may tu ho sakti hay Quran may likhay hukum kay baray may nahi ho Sakta jaha tak may janta ho if I am wrong please correct me. Thanks

[@abdurrehman3254]

Sir Add Hassan nisar in your discussion.

[@ROUMI7777]

And if possible have a discussion with Hassan Nissar on media role in Pakistan

[@changeyourselffirst8812]

Population kay mamlay par islam kA hawala dene walay KO ye Bawar Karana chaye k wo bachay jo us nay paida kiye Hain in kee parvirash ka sawal bhee us say hee ho ga...or pakad to us par bhee Hai...

[@muhammedmudassirqureshi1309]

Majid Ghouri sahib kia baat hay kia Koi zi rooh Allah k hukum k baghair aasakti hay? Jab Wo aajati hay tu uskay rizq ka waada tu Allah nay kia hay tu aap say sawal kaisay ho ga aur Quran may hay hidayat Allah daita hay jab Wo hidayat daita hay tu aap say sawaal kaisa?

[@jarnailchahal8891]

If you want to solve your population problem then you have to follow Indian Punjabis.

[@noorijatt393]

So the moral of the story is Vote to Imran Khan he's not corrupt and he won't make it happen.✌️

[@AftabIqbalOfficial]

Interesting thought Noori, but I am not endorsing any candidate.

[@noorijatt393]

GupShup With Aftab Iqbal Fair enough

[@sheikhejaz3174]

PARTITION. OF INDIA WAS. THE. WRONG IDEA.

[@peejaylal353]

Nasir Azeem,kyu khafa ho Rahe hon? Unki wife ka khayal bhi aisa hi Hain Aftab ke bare mein Hain. Khair Jo bhi ho ek visionary historian dr Ishtiaq Ahmed se Khul kar unko apni baate rakhne de n ki apni theories unpar thopein.

[@Rajakhoji]

Pakistan and India not gonna b frnds because they came so for forward especially Indians.now they r our soul enemy .look resent past and present what they r doing....I think pak army have to revisit there strategy.hit back to india the way they did than they came to table again I think that's the only way.... what u think sir

[@asif1]

Slow poison

[@hamzaawan2350]

One thing i will tell you we actually made all the polution i bet you have throwed rubbish outside many time of your car

[@ansh_u_r]

Pakistani ameero ka time pass.

[@rashidomar5423]

Aftab sahib, I watched all the episodes so far. Your style of discussion is very odd. You force your opinion on the other person. This is not khabardar. You both claim to be Muslims but discussing the solutions for the problems of Pakistan, you never mention what GOD says in his book. Do you feel wiser than GOD or do you think the message of GOD is not worth mentioning?