AGATHA ALL ALONG Episode 6 REACTION!! Marvel Studios | 1x06 Breakdown & Review

[@corbanwoosley6891]

I think you guys forgot Alice was an ex-cop lol Edit: Woah. Didn't mean to start arguments lol. Did I personally think this was a hard detail to remember? No haha but I'm crazy invested and they watch a lot of stuff. I wasn't calling them out, I was just making an observation 😅

[@ReelRejects]

yup

[@jamesjackson8292]

Yep episode 2

[@MarcSpctr]

this is exactly why web series need to be either RELEASE ALL AT ONCE or atleast an episode EVERY DAY. A week is way too much time and is also the reason many people kind of loose interest. Cause, You have to wait a whole week for like a 30 min. episode, which can be really be impatient. and if not and you wanna watch it all at once, then you need to wait like 2 months or more and by that time you already get all the spoilers, thus making it less fun ti watch and thus people then skip the show. Don't understand why the people at Disney, HBO, etc have not understood this yet. DARK is a very complex yet brilliant show on Netflix (100% recommend to watch), and if you have watched it, now imagine all episodes releasing over a period of 3 months with one episode per week. No one would be able to keep up with the characters, the stories, etc

[@MidoriFlygon]

@@MarcSpctr nahhhh i dont think so. weekly episodes keeps the conversation going for longer. i know some netflix series people watched and then no one mentioned it ever again after 2 months. This is literally how regular TV functioned. You would've never survived being a Steven Universe or Owl House fan. we got episodes once every 3 months

[@dafr3ak]

@@MarcSpctrnah normal tv series would air once a week. Binge watching kind of ruined the hype of shows. That why streaming went back to weekly.

[@allenpayne927]

"He's a Jewish gay witch, how cool is that" Probably the best thing Greg has ever said in these reaction videos

[@arc7375]

Jewish, gay, witch…and no-one here has made a reference to Willow Rosenberg from Buffy the Vampire Slayer!

[@lucifer2745]

haahahahahahhhahahahahahahahaha

[@maggiepb4]

@@arc7375 all hail Dark Willow

[@arc7375]

@@maggiepb4 Funnily enough, Willow was based entirely on Jean Grey, and the Dark Willow arc was taken from the Dark Phoenix saga. The writers confirmed it and the characters even reference it on the show! :)

[@allenpayne927]

@@arc7375 Damn, how could I forget about her

[@blakej1892]

Billiam is 🖤, not Rio. Lilia couldn’t write his name because of the sigil.

[@nunocargaleiro]

:O TRUE

[@azuli5520]

YOURE RIGHT

[@cuffzter]

ooh, nice catch

[@shinigamis_like_apples4797]

That's what i was thinkinggg, plus Jen also revealed how Billy was able to do this. William is an agent of Mephisto, he just doesn't know it lol he's made from a shard of his soul

[@alexp601]

So he is William, AND Billy, AND Death?

[@AnnaLeii]

I just want to give John a huge hug and talk about this show with HIM, because he is the only one who seems to be actually enjoying it AND also understanding it. Which to me, seems like what you should be highlighting instead of constantly cutting him off or interacting with each other while he’s sharing his opinion 🤷🏼‍♀️ GIVE JOHN HIS FLOWERS!!! 💐

[@Spbatt]

“I do not want to go back in the closet” had me dying

[@eugeniamarch]

one of the best jokes in recent marvel i fear😭

[@Eternalsfan]

Me too! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@Spbatt]

@@eugeniamarch saw it coming from a mile away but Joe made it work 😂

[@Michelle-DiPalo]

It was happening so fast at the time, I didn't even catch that joke. Lol.

[@KD-xp2eo]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@legitonejc]

Lilia being the one to put the sigil on him for 3 years goes to show why Wanda didn’t know that Billy was still alive. 😭 But the question is, why did she put the sigil on him?! Also, I don’t think y’all noticed as soon as she placed the sigil in the jacket pocket she instantly forgot who he was. ❗️Unanswered Questions❗️ Another thing, Billy’s soul went into Williams body after he died. You can hear William’s heart beat go away, then you hear Billy and Tommy telling eachother goodnight because in the Hex as Wanda closed it, it was night and they were going to bed. Billy THEN entered Williams Body when it closed and that’s why he didn’t remember who he was and was acting weird. Alice also said she used to be a cop when she got to the house before they went into the basement. It’s just a coincidence that he met or had a correlation to all the witches in the coven before they officially met (There’s witches in close proximity that can create a spark).

[@jamiedoe6822]

Yup .

[@austinhale5699]

Agatha stated that Billy basically broke the rules of death. I wonder if something overcame Lilia using her deviation powers to protect Billy Maximoff from Death who I think is rio is

[@jaydenmares5842]

They did say covens are brought together by fate when Billy and Agatha were in the car in episode 2

[@alftuvik3820]

@@austinhale5699 Mephisto confirmed? Except maybe it's not a joke anymore?

[@jamiedoe6822]

@@austinhale5699 I don’t know if we should believe her. The circumstances with him differs where Dr Strange possessed an actual dead body. Clearly, the body inhabited by Billy came back to life.

[@ot7biasedmashups]

Okay so you guys missed some things. First of all it's comic book accurate that Billy reincarnated. Also Alice mentioned in ep 2 that she's an Ex-Cop which idk stood out to me so I'm confused why you guys forgot about it. Also Billy's boyfriend called him his 🖤 which is also HUGE bc that means that's he's a part of the coven and not Rio. It also explains why Lilia wrote it down instead of his name bc of the sigil. Wouldn't make sense why she didn't write Rio if it was her. I also wonder why Coy keeps saying that he's not the demographic like if he's the comic guy and this is a series about comics... Then who's the demographic exactly

[@toastyjacks]

Don't think anyone's picked up on Billy's BF saying that he's his 'blackheart' which is what Lilia wrote on Agatha's Coven list. Rio was never a member of the true coven but Billy is.

[@jullin4061]

OMG you might be right!😮

[@Kuhlee84]

I caught it, for sure! Also, that brings up when "Rio" said that magic takes the path of least resistance and that she was the closest nearby... because Sharon had just died! She was collecting Sharon's soul, then crawled out of the grave.

[@randompeople465]

But if Billy one of the coven why he can passes the water trial without drinking the wine? Is not make sense. Also Agatha mention about blackheart too, for Rio.

[@toastyjacks]

@@randompeople465 They just had to drink all the wine, it didn't matter who did or didn't. Sharon drank twice as much wine as everyone else (which is why she died) and she wasn't even a real witch.

[@zoephotoart]

@@randompeople465probably because the road designed it for their coven. He was underage and then they ended up needing a person who wasn't poisoned to finish.

[@rjsmith5678]

Everyone’s entitled to their own opinions, I just think it’s interesting that instead of just sitting, watching and absorbing, what’s happening to catch the little details that could maybe be missed, It’s always being passed over by a joke or trying to harp on the show for its predictability. Again, it’s not that there’s anything completely wrong with this, I think it’s just tough as a viewer when your job is to give a reaction and your reaction doesn’t feel like you’re truly watching the show for what it is but continuously finding ways to, crack a joke in order for you to stay engaged which again, nothing wrong with that it just feels backwards and like you’re held against your will or something to watch lol. Very interesting that Coy doesn’t like the show but again totally entitled to his own opinion. It’s just interesting of the things that he does like and how this is not working for him? But I really hope that all of you are able to keep your own perspective of the show and not blend each other‘s thoughts into one. If Greg or Jon you really truly like the show for what it is then don’t be afraid to really like it wholeheartedly! Also, just a suggestion, but curious if you guys would ever consider just searching up the answer that you have questioned directly after the episode ? For example, how you guys were confused about the actress being a cop - maybe just search it when you talk about it so that way you have your answers while you’re still in your review🤷🏾‍♀️

[@OHALALNOHA]

THIS PART OMG

[@drewrayg]

Joe Locke was fantastic in this episode. I'm sick of the demographic. I'm a 40+ year-old Marvel fan and this series is one of the best Marvel shows.

[@JackFlicks]

Agreed!

[@toidaconkkk]

“My wife and her flying saucers” “My husband and his indestructible head” I’m crying on a Wednesday missing a witch and android 😭😭😭

[@herobreaker9011]

I honestly cannot believe that you guys cannot believe. Sometimes a banana is JUST a banana. Occam's Razor. William Kaplan died in the exact moment that Wanda's Hex came down -- and Billy (age 10) entered William's body (age 13). "3 Years Later" (now) Billy is PHYSICALLY age 16, as he tells Agatha in Episode 2. Alice used to be a cop -- she mentioned that in Episode 2. And the reason Lilia didn't recognize Teen is because the Sigil she cast on him works on her as well.

[@plainrosiejane]

"why is she randomly a cop?" its literally said in the first scene she appears in in episode 2 thats she's former law enforcement lol. and again later at the end of the ep when they're trying to open the road that she says "i was a cop. its gonna be the answer for a lot of things for me."

[@nugget3687]

To be fair, it's only really said in one episode, and they don't bring a lot of attention to it. I forgot too lol

[@cable7152]

They spend too much time making jokes to pay attention

[@1shaquillecox]

​@@cable7152this, then complain about something not making sense.

[@kyloren1014]

I know

[@ReelRejects]

@@cable7152 nope. we literally react and laugh at that line in episode 2 about how it'll answer things. So we PAID ATTENTION. We just forgot as im sure a lot of people did

[@anais6654]

Why does coy keep coming back for the reaction ? It’s clearly "not for him"

[@TheOneiricIXII]

Cool thing to consider is William saying he "died that night" when he was in the car with Eddie... The car crash against the tree that killed William happened in broad daylight but inside the hex it was bedtime/night. That's the "death" that Billy remembers.

[@lilbrownbear]

@@TheOneiricIXII you just lowkey blew my mind ngl i didnt connect those dots

[@FoxyGuyHere]

Cool detail, thanks!

[@rosyellis14]

omg i didn't realize that

[@finnix4428]

OOOHH that made sense, I was confused when he said “that night” lol

[@JuQui228]

They also have “Dead of Night” by Orville Peck playing in the car 😅

[@JDomino_]

Joe Locke crushed it this episode. Im loving him as Wiccan.

[@ReelRejects]

Yeah he's fantastic

[@Knightowl1980]

I was really unsure about his casting being a Heartstopper fan and that being his first acting role. But he’s doing a really great job, I don’t really see “Charlie Spring” at all

[@Phelie315]

​@@Knightowl1980same. Really becoming a fan of his - the clips I saw from Sweeney Todd also seemed like he crushed it :)

[@filmfangirls9163]

You can never go wrong with Broadway talent!

[@poe_more_please]

@@Knightowl1980 it's like Joe is an actor or something

[@bradm112]

alice said she was a cop second ep, it’s how she found agatha’s house. she’s had many different jobs and not been able to keep them (referenced in ep 4 with her curse). she isn’t a witch like the others, she stopped believing in it all (referenced when they were sat on the road talking) - hence her having a normal person job

[@scotthewitt258]

She has some pretty strong magick to not be a witch. She died casting a ghost out of Agatha.....

[@bradm112]

@@scotthewitt258 i meant like, she wasn’t like jen or lilia who had jobs with a witch-like background. i didn’t mean she was a witch, she just had normal people jobs (cop, security guard etc) & avoided the witch stuff since her mom died :)

[@Mrempoleon100]

But also remember that rule that there are witchtes around a witch within certain miles radius all the time (they dont have to be powerful witches...just "witchy" enough people)

[@filmfangirls9163]

I forgot all about that 😂

[@danslesbrasdemorphee4181]

​@@scotthewitt258 because she passed her trial...

[@d-snowden7906]

Ngl at this point its just getting ridiculous. 6 episodes in and yall still dont like it, yall arent invested, yall not connecting to the characters, seems yall dont care for the actors, yall seem to not like the show for what is is, the non stop jokes are tiring, not paying attention to diaoluge, etc, etc. Like if im not liking a tv show/film im gonna stop watching it and move on with my day, like nobodys forcing yall to watch this. If you dont like it move on, John seems to be the only one intrested and trying to understand/watch the show for the show, not because its part of the MCU. I do enjoy yall reactions and i been a fan for a while, but BBFR and be honest.

[@kac5318]

Why are you having trouble understanding this?

[@rogue8059]

Isn't Billy Kaplan/Billy Maximoff from the comics. I thought Coy would know this

[@arc7375]

For someone who is such a self-proclaimed big comic fan, he’s consistently shown to know nothing. Ever since I started their reactions from X-Men 97 onwards. He’s unenjoyable to watch.

[@ot7biasedmashups]

Yeah I'm confused why the comic book guy doesn't know such a... Non niche thing. Like even I knew that and I've never read a single comic.

[@y4uriteme]

Yeah, the twins were reborn into different families, Billy Kaplan and Tommy Shepherd. This isn't far off, really. Wiccan is indeed a Jewish gay witch. I don't think Coy is that familiar with the Young Avenvers, though. I seem to recall that coming up before, as some of the others were introduced.

[@SPACEKNOCKERZ76]

@@arc7375he’s just wasn’t feeling how the show handles it lol easier to do things in the comics

[@Laurica-lb6nv]

@@SPACEKNOCKERZ76 there was literally no other way to do it. Marvel would be in flames by Wiccan fans if they just removed Billy Kaplan. Can’t be the comic book guy and not respect comic accuracy because it’s not “your demographic”

[@MikaylaSnow]

Weird that Cory refuses to learn some character names like he calls Alice “the singer” I feel like he could never get away with that if it was a show “for his demographic “

[@OHALALNOHA]

literallllllly

[@gabegrapejuice3787]

Who's cory

[@Lillian.Gao.]

Yeah she’s clearly been presented as the surly bouncer character, if not “cop character”

[@donnymiddlebrook]

@@gabegrapejuice3787 They meant Coy

[@donnymiddlebrook]

I'm not sure why Coy would question that Joe is a charming actor.

[@OHALALNOHA]

right- why would he be cast in heartstopper if he wasnt

[@donnymiddlebrook]

@@OHALALNOHA Exactly!

[@Lillian.Gao.]

I normally love Coy on RR, but him questioning Joe Locke’s charm/onscreen presence took me out of the reaction completely for a sec. He’s got a reason for disliking this show he hasn’t voiced yet.

[@donnymiddlebrook]

@@Lillian.Gao. I think he's just becoming one of those content creators that thinks that every movie, tv show, and episode have to be 110% for him to like it. And if it doesn't meet every thing on his checklist he then rags on the show. But yeah, his reaction to the comment about Joe being charming was telling to me that he's going into a direction that makes me not want to see anymore content from him. I especially didn't like his review of last weeks episode on his own channel.

[@Lillian.Gao.]

@@donnymiddlebrookcriticizing the show is one thing, but it’s very telling when he went out of his way to go “REALLY?” to Greg’s compliment about an actor who, at the very least, is objectively “charming.” I’ve never heard of Joe Locke before this show but I picked up on his charisma immediately. Coy’s takes are coming off like those guys who said Scarlett Johansson’s looks are just “mid”

[@bigjahh1848]

thinking too hard abt everything, it literally shows that boy “William Kaplan” die at the exact time wanda’s spell gets undone and billy’s soul is transferred onto his body, how is it that hard to infer that

[@ot7biasedmashups]

That was literally SO obvious I don't even know...

[@Mads97415]

I was surprised how they simple they made it for live action because the comic explanation is WAAAAAYYY more confusing lol. I'm actually surprised they did the soul transfer ting at all lol

[@edrianbobbycalabio1]

The actor did amazing in portraying the story of original William. I was really invested.

[@gaymer07]

His name is joe Loke. Hes really good in heartstopper.

[@marshsundeen]

​@@gaymer07his last name is Locke.

[@jasonmarbach]

Not sure what show coy is watching to be honest, this was the best episode yet and every ep has been a banger

[@ot7biasedmashups]

Exactly. He's being so weird with this show...

[@arc7375]

If he said he just doesn’t like it, that’d be fine, and something easily to accept and respect. But he does this weird slimy, squirmy thing, it’s really…well, _weird_ to watch.

[@eugeniamarch]

it just gets better and better

[@alexp601]

Just because some people are loving it doesn't mean everyone needs to love it. I think it's okay, bordering on meh, but it's an enjoyable enough watch for me to keep watching every week. But I wouldn't go so far as to say I love the show. It doesn't mean I'm the weird one, it just means that everyone has different tastes and everything hits people differently.

[@takewhataway]

@@arc7375 For real. I dont know how many fanboy looking at me weird when I say I dont vibe with fantasy much so even though I can acknowledge that LOTR is one of the best franchises/stories, I just cant be a fan and they're fine. Because its not my thing. While Coy just make himself sound stupid FYI, I didnt care about Agatha much and I never like Witch stories but this show is very entertaining

[@IndieFilmmaker82]

I've never seen them more clueless, lol. And I'm surprised by Coy and coming up short on recognizing restructured comic lore 😂

[@kac5318]

Weird that Coy hates this show and is hung up on the William/Billy name being the same thing when that is comic book accurate… aren’t you the comic book guy?

[@arc7375]

Calls himself the comics guy, but knows nothing and makes tons of mistakes ever since I started watching the X-Men 97 reactions.

[@ot7biasedmashups]

Exactly. I never read the comics and even I knew that Billy was reincarnated into somebody else's body. Like damn what's your issue

[@jessicaluk74]

Honestly smh

[@Keawe]

Yall are just so rude. Cory knows a lot, but when he misses something out of a plethora of things he references, and yall are on his ass. He's human, have some grace.

[@BotchaLoa4]

Shit yo b as up 😂with your valid points

[@steelothian]

They said the dome was shrinking, on the radio. William probably died when Billy and Tommy disappeared. Since they’re kids, there was probably an amount of panic. Finding the closest vessel makes sense.

[@donnymiddlebrook]

William did die. You can hear his heartbeat stop.

[@shortstuff780]

I'm a straight Indian / American born male who is pushing 30s, i hate horror and i hate crime dramas.. This is 100% not written for me, but I'm loving this, this is what I've been missing with, with marvel. Great acting, writing and characters

[@Veggieboo]

Is this a female show of a certain age or something?

[@shortstuff780]

@@Veggieboo na, just a very Lgbtq friendly, witch/horror esq, female empowerment, comedy, sisterhood story Very well done, and a very compelling story so far!

[@FireJach]

This is neither horror or crime drama. This is a comedy for kids, my dude

[@AntiKaiMatic]

​@@FireJachThe show has moments of humor but overall it fits more with the mystery thriller genre.

[@shortstuff780]

@@FireJach it fits multiple genres. Yes it's kid friendly but it's also has a lot of adult stuff too. It's a fun cheesey cute show with a lot of heart

[@misteryman526]

"Why would she be a cop?" We already knew that Alice had been a cop. The manager of the Hot Topic where she was a security guard mentioned that he had hired her on the recommendation of her former Captain. And when she found Agatha's house even though Teen didn't give her the address she said "because I'm an ex-cop. That's going to be the answer to a lot of questions"

[@arc7375]

Alice is a protection witch. And cops are _sworn to serve and _*_protect._*

[@adriannamonet3584]

I love the channel and enjoy Coy in other things, but if he really doesn't like the show this much, I think it'd be best for the other two to continue and he bow out of watching. He doesn't have to watch it and waste his time or fans of the show's time. Making comments about not liking it nearly every episode is really bringing the experience down at this point. It's totally okay not to like it, but harping on it every video is a lot. I think a redirect on who participates in the Agatha reactions is needed. EDIT: Back after reading comments. While I don't think rude or snarky comments are helpful one bit, I wanted to try to give some context on why the dislike or "not my demographic" comments may hit nerves with people and make them comment out of emotion. This is Marvel's first ever queer focused story. It's a milestone. Queer people are used to being the reason why people 'disconnect' or don't like something simply because they exist. Saying 'not my demographic' once or twice & then moving on - whatever. Making it a common theme centering the reactions to this show while also giving the perception of making fun of it - this can feed into the narrative that only male, straight leads can have a successful show that deserves to be taken seriously. Are people allowed to not like something? Of course! It's the underlying tone and frequency that people are off put by. Honestly, at this point, it does feel a bit like unconscious bias because of the behavior shown over the course of the six episode reactions. (emphasis on feels like as I do not know Coy in any capacity and as someone who worked in the film industry for years, I understand editing can take context out) Does that make it okay to be mean and call people names? no of course not. At this point, 6 episodes in, I think it may be some's breaking point on speaking out about it. I certainly was for me. Again, love the channel. I don't usually comment on things, but wanted to share and be clear that I have good intentions of course.

[@Gkwilson1487]

@@adriannamonet3584 YES EXACTLY THIS!!! You said it way better than I could. All the borderline misogynistic and homophobic remarks are a real turn off with the “it’s not for my demographic” bullshit. If he hates it so much, I wish he’d just go do something else and leave the rest of us to have fun. We can do without the Negative Nancy - us and “our demographic” are having a ball

[@adriannamonet3584]

@@Gkwilson1487 I've really been enjoying the show. As a queer person myself the first few 'not my demographic' comments brought me mentally to some threads on X I've read where people were saying hurtful things, but I chose to ignore it the first few episodes. Unfortunately, that remark is a gateway for things like this. Now, with it being a consistent remark carrying to episode 6, it sort of feels like a twisting knife. I really hope it isn't intentional and I hope our voices are heard.

[@Christian_Ada1]

Beautifully said!!! I agree Like I hate sci-fi so you’ll never catch me watching Star Trek or Star Wars it’s not my genre

[@Christian_Ada1]

@@adriannamonet3584 Gay guy here too and I love this series as I loved Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Charmed and The X-Files I remember being a subscriber to the channel about a year and a half ago and I unsubscribed because I wasn’t really caring too much for their commentary. They come off like a bunch of highschoolers trying to be cool and they’re supposed to be adult men it doesn’t work for me .

[@Veggieboo]

Right?!? It just bums everybody else out

[@LooseAsADEUCE]

Usually I appreciate Coy's commentary but for some reason this show has him saying the most ridiculous things. Like these reactions are literally changing my opinion of him bc constantly saying "its not my demographic" is starting to feel a little dog whistle-y.

[@Lillian.Gao.]

Coy hates witches

[@FireJach]

Well, Coy is adult and the show is like a sketch from SNL. Yikes

[@Iiiigamingsins]

@@FireJach ok?

[@rockstarburne]

hahahaha coy is Dog whistling? what a joke. the show is literally advertised by the cast as the gayest marvel show ever. it was continuously marketed towards women and gay men in the media. but when a white man, probably the majority demographic of marvel content, doesn't feel the show was made for him, it must be he's secretly harbouring one of the isms. must be a secret bigot

[@zac_94]

Seeing all the convo happening around the “demographic” comments and I think this kinda gets to the heart of why it’s still difficult having queer focused stories. Like there wasn’t a moment where I felt like Coy (or anyone from this channel) was saying “queer stories just aren’t for me” but I definitely felt a chill run down my spine every time Coy mentions the “demographic” comment because it’s not too far from other things I’ve heard throughout my life. When me and my little brother watched the Legend of Korra series finale, there’s that moment that hints at a queer relationship and, I’m beaming with joy at FINALLY having some representation (we were so starved back then, still are but not as bad) but my brother is like “not for me” and even goes as far as to say it ruined his childhood. He may have been exaggerating for a bit but it still hinted at his own feelings about queerness. It completely deflated me in what was supposed to be a good moment. Not for a second do I think that’s what Coy meant but you can see where my emotional response stems from. Probably similar for a lot of queer people watching reactions to this show. There is this unfortunate issue where queer stories are not welcome among certain masculine-centric circles. I’ve seen it my entire life and have been in numerous instances where I’ve been forced to defend the validity of queer stories even existing. It gets exhausting. And I do find it interesting that talk about this show not being for certain “demographics” is a bit more heightened compared to other MCU or fan-related projects (not on this channel but just in general). I’ve seen reactors (male and presumably straight) turn the queer scenes between Hahn and Plaza into full-on fetishization by jokingly but also kinda seriously licking their lips at the screen. Meanwhile, these same people will lose their minds over two men kissing and being intimate with each other. They get tired of queer stuff pretty quickly when that happens for some reason. These are the tricky waters we all wade into when it comes to FINALLY having queer stories go mainstream in the biggest pop-culture fandom of our time. While the conversation can get difficult and messy at times, I implore Reel Rejects and anyone reading this to contemplate *who* the demographic for this show truly is. Sure, this is a story about queer people, for queer people, but it’s also for everyone! I want straight dudes who brag about their pickup trucks to watch the scene between Billy/Eddie being flirty with each other and just be happy for them! I want straight dudes to be invested in the growing tension between Hahn/Plaza to the point where they go “just kiss already!” but not whittle them down to just a steamy make-out session. All of this is to say we are in uncharted waters. Exciting waters! But still uncharted. Marvel seems to FINALLY be investing in queer characters/stories with Billy’s introduction, which means these convos are gonna have to happen. I’ve honestly waited years for these conversations to start. For fandoms that are typically male-focused to start undressing the issues around welcoming queer stories/people into the fold. We’ve spent so long trying to find representation that it can be a reminder of how we’ve been demeaned nearly our entire lives when someone mentions this show is for a different “demographic” than them. For me I relive that moment with my brother dismissing my joy at seeing a breadcrumb of representation. Imagine how much more heightened those emotions are once we have ACTUAL queer representation like here. It’s an extremely big deal that Marvel has an unapologetically-queer story here but I can already see how some groups are trying to dismiss this milestone. So please, for the Reel Rejects and people online, don’t be discouraged from engaging and I think Coy should ABSOLUTELY STAY in the reactions! These are important conversations to have and if everyone is able to approach these in good-faith then it’ll get easier to have these convos. But excluding people from them doesn’t help anyone. Queer people have been excluded from so much for so long, let’s not force out people who could be natural allies to prevent that from happening again. Also, who does the KZbin comments for Reel Rejects? Is it Greg? Is he BI?! Cause whoever does those comments mentioned that in another thread here but I do not recall this being known. Either way, bi-erasure shall not stand! We love some bi kings reacting to Jewish gay witches! That is beautifully queer! Looking forward to the next episode and whatever messy convo comes from it!

[@ReelRejects]

You are someone I would love to have a real Conversation with :)

[@zac_94]

@@ReelRejects ditto ❤️

[@torijeri]

I love this comment. I feel like you summed up what it’s like to grow up queer surrounded by people who aren’t necessarily super homophobic but have those deep rooted biases that can tarnish something so small like korrasami breadcrumbs even without knowing it. ALSO, right? i feel like if that was greg AND he likes joe locke this much as an actor he’d absolutely love heartstopper lol but i could be wrong who knows. Anyways I really appreciated this comment a lot. I haven’t tuned in to every reaction to this show, but i do think this sparked a really important conversation that I think the guys AND most fans are receptive to & are willing to have. I love when the internet can be used for good. 🤍

[@Nion8six]

Coy not liking it could just be “well I’m just not connecting with it” rather than “I’m just not in the demographic” 😂 There can be things that are not necessarily specifically made for you, whatever demographic you feel you fit in & still enjoy it. I’m not gay, a woman, a witch etc. I’m a middle aged dad of two boys 😂 and I enjoy the show.

[@arc7375]

If he just straight-up said he doesn’t like the show, that’d be totally fine. But it’s the weird way he squirms around and the slimy sort of things he keeps repeating which are just…odd.

[@lilbrownbear]

@@arc7375 yeah what's weirder is he's still sitting for the reactions like if he genuinely doesnt like it he's under no obligation to even watch it let alone react on screen. especially since he wasnt here for the first few episodes. its not even genuine criticism just dancing around the fact that he's not vibing with it which would be fine if he was just upfront about it

[@thecheckup9219]

​@@arc7375just like you left that comment. he can do as he wants .

[@arc7375]

@@thecheckup9219 Fair.

[@ccole99]

Thank you!!! I am a middle aged father of a teenage girl and I have been enjoying this show a lot as well!!!

[@zoephotoart]

Just because a show has women and gay leads does not mean that the target demographic has to also be women and gays. There are plenty of male reactors enjoying the show. It's totally fine if Coy doesn't like the show but the demographic comments come across as slightly sexist/homophobic. I appreciate the other two balancing him out though! All the other witches were literally doing the jobs they did or mentioned in episode 2. Alice used to be a cop. Also you missed the boyfriend calling Billy a 🖤 in a text.

[@stevenjump8234]

Ya I'm done with these chuckle heads!

[@ReelRejects]

I mean when there were two guys kissing and saying I love you.... I don't think Coy's response at all hints at homophobic lol

[@zoephotoart]

@@ReelRejects I'm not saying he is, I'm just pointing out that comments inferring shows that star women and gays are not for him give off that flavor, reinforced by him not being able to explain what he meant. Remember this is yet another women led show/movie that was initially review bombed by insecure men who don't like when content is too woke or "isn't for them".

[@Square-ow7oq]

​@ReelRejects do you mean the disgusted expression on his face while they kiss?😂

[@ot7biasedmashups]

​@@Square-ow7oqliterally wtf was that man...

[@regstacks]

I'm surprised at how much you guys just didn't pay attention to the smaller details from the previous episodes. Normally, you pick up on the threads but it seems like Coy has decided that his dislike of the show is more important than actually watching. For example, how did you miss that Alice was a cop? Or that ALL of the citizens of West View have popped up in some way?

[@bradm112]

the point about william kaplan - his character exists in the comic, it would’ve spoiled the billy reveal. it’s kinda like saying they should’ve called agnes agatha harkness from the beginning of wandavision instead of calling her agnes

[@Jumpoable]

Exactly.

[@blakej1892]

The fact of the matter is that real surprises in the MCU will be few and far apart to the people who read the comics, or otherwise consume “spoilers” outside of what is shown on screen. Because we all know that if the MCU started making a a lot of major changes from the comics in order surprise, there would be masses of comic fans losing their shit (in a bad way) at all the deviations. True surprises are pretty much left to those who only watch the MCU, and don’t have outside information. Agnes being the villain in WandaVision and Teen being Wanda’s son were surprises to MCU only viewers.

[@shanexavier6612]

Love you guys and this episode, but I agree that Coy's opinion here is NOT my demographic! ;)

[@TikkiEXX]

Man....that was rough. Waaaay too much clowning, too much joking, not enough actually watching the show. Started watching this channel because i appreciate you guys opinions and knowledge but this was just a bad comedy routine. And Coy is one of my favorites. You guys are better than this

[@keenthek]

Greg appreciating Joe Locke/Billy made my day.

[@Christian_Ada1]

😂

[@Lillian.Gao.]

Greg full-on crushing over here ☺️

[@esoteric_1]

It's Libra season

[@elizabethgidney3768]

@@esoteric_1This has to be the best joke I have read in a while I applaud you 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼🙌🏼

[@fuzzyotterpaws4395]

This episode was AMAZING! Something about the different tone, the story, the characters, the soundtrack and everything was surprisingly good on this one especially!❤

[@dsfddsgh]

It helps when the episode is longer then 25 minutes.

[@KipToothPicc]

She was a cop, was being the key word, in the episode she was introduced she even said "im an ex cop" thats how she tracked them down without them giving her the address. Assuming something happened in the three years where she lost her job and ended up mall security.

[@mc720]

John used to be so excited for this - I think Coy is really bringing him down.

[@TabbyQ.9563]

Uggg! They all lived in Eastville. Alice was a protection witch. In her first scene she said she has lost her job as a cop. She said it again when they first met at Agatha's house. Why are y'all struggling with this Alice/cop thing?

[@Gkwilson1487]

They don’t pay attention

[@Logan-b4f]

I’ve come to realize that Coy just plays like he knows a lot but he’s very judgemental everything and can’t learn to just have fun for once! He messes up very often, i liked him at first but honestly he’s extremely annoying!

[@OmalleyCat]

My brain cells are on thin ice here

[@brianr1371]

How did you remember Ralph Bohner was an actor but forgot Alice was a cop?

[@ReelRejects]

Cause that was a big reveal he wasn't actually Quicksilver & people kept talking about Ralph Bohner for a long while after it aired so it got engrained,

[@donnymiddlebrook]

@@ReelRejects But that was over 2.5 years ago. Alice formerly being a cop was just from a few weeks back.

[@FireJach]

Who the fuck is Alice

[@toidaconkkk]

@@donnymiddlebrook not the most memorable episodes within the show. You know the answer. You just want them to say it. Hope that helps lol

[@ReelRejects]

@@donnymiddlebrookdid you know that sometimes actors - the very actors you watch on screen - forget their lines from the scene they just rehearsed?

[@betteryourlife865]

I go to watch the video then read the comments and don’t wanna watch anymore 🤣

[@zac_94]

Greg’s joy at Billy being a “Jewish, gay, witch” earned this a like from me. As a Jewish, gay, witch myself I found this episode to be UTTERLY DELIGHTFUL!

[@jacers14]

Alice is a cop she said it in episode 2.

[@johnp2311]

Welp apparently they're not the demographic for this show so I doubt they were paying that much attention to remember that Alice was a former cop 👀

[@ReelRejects]

@@johnp2311 that one line of information from over a month ago - yup forgot

[@joeytj]

@@ReelRejectsyet, we all remembered. It’s not a big deal that she’s a cop, but it was indeed mentioned.

[@ReelRejects]

@@joeytj the "all" are the people who acknowledged it in the comments. I bet there's a whole lot of people who forgot

[@ZHOZEP]

⁠@@ReelRejectssame logic applies when you pay attention enough to remember these details instead of trying to…idk, make jokes in the middle? It’s very clear that you didn’t forget, you weren’t paying attention.

[@jeronthomas1003]

Ngl I don’t understand why Coy is here. He’s really bumping me out fr. Also you guys should react to heartstopper starring Joe Locke!!!

[@filmfangirls9163]

Then leave. You people are the worst.

[@OHALALNOHA]

@@filmfangirls9163 no you guys defending it are, i came here to enjoy the show with them not have some loser in my hearbud constantly complain or sit there acting unamused sucking the life out of the video and room.

[@jamesliggins891]

@@OHALALNOHA tbf this is their channel, not yours. i get the frustration but at any point you are free to downvote/stop watching/move on, i'm sure there are many reactors out there who will give you what you're looking for

[@OHALALNOHA]

@@jamesliggins891 they can't function without that, tell that to all the coy haters and they'll have to shut down the marvel segment due to lack of viewers. they dont do this for fun anymore it's usually always for views and a paycheck now.

[@OHALALNOHA]

@@jamesliggins891 tbh it's their channel but they aren't anything without their massive views. if they piss off a majority of their fans that are able to speak their mind in the comments, imagine the hundreds of thousands who dont who think they exact same way.

[@antonioakpati7441]

don’t worry i’m with you John! it’s a great show

[@Mads97415]

It's just hard to take y'alls opinions and reactions at least a little seriously when it feels like you don't pay attention to the show at all just to try and get a joke in every few seconds...

[@ReelRejects]

I love these types of comments because...we use maybe 1/4 of footage from the series. Footage being 5-6 second clips as well. So vast majority of the runtime, we are just...paying attention not talking. The illusion that all we do is "joke every few seconds" is not true lol

[@katkatkat321]

@@ReelRejects But your reviews miss obvious things, so it's hard to believe that

[@MattheusSantos-sf3zb]

Joe Locke is shutting up those who talk bad about his performance, the boy is improving a lot 💙

[@chiklitz]

"its not for me" dude we get it, you say this EVERY EPISODE. surely you can find something else to say about it

[@Gkwilson1487]

@@chiklitz he’s such a miserable person like why do you even do this? The other two guys are having fun and finding fun things to point out. He’s just a fucking downer

[@yayazow]

I wonder why he's here watching the show smh plus they talking way too much for nothing, one of the worst review of this show so far... was hard to watch

[@Mjsports3730]

Y’all sure love being so offended by that one little line.

[@Mjsports3730]

@@yayazow “Was hard to watch” so don’t continue watching the video and move on to something else

[@Gkwilson1487]

@@Mjsports3730 you think we didn’t ?

[@bigeent.5160]

I’m just confused on how coy liked joker 2 but this he isn’t connecting with😂.

[@Say0nn.]

Cause one’s a movie and one’s a tv show geek

[@bigeent.5160]

@@Say0nn. doesn’t matter. Both are comic forms of media. And one is absolute dogshit😂

[@arc7375]

Nothing wrong with liking one over the other, regardless which one it is.

[@kimberlyjeanne9456]

@@bigeent.5160thats your opinion, his is different. Then end.

[@filmfangirls9163]

I like plenty of comic works over another. Are you saying we have to like everything comic book related? Talk about gatekeepers.

[@johnfredericks4376]

Coy.... You are absolutely NOT the demographic for this show.

[@joshr9812]

Top example of how reactor's try to overthink every angle in a show to try and sound smart and completely fail and end up looking like they don't pay attention l

[@justme5465]

I feel like this group just simply don’t care for this show. which I think is fair. Just that I don’t like when they say “i don’t get it/how did that happen?/since when?” on details that they would understand if they actually watched the show. It’s fine to not like a show but to actively ignore it and miss all the details then question the “plotholes” without a quick google or even a twitter search is lazy.

[@pricewright8030]

I’m surprised a comic lore expert doesn’t know that William Kaplan is the character Wiccan from the comics so calling him that off rip would have been a complete spoiler, I just assumed that’s in his demographic to know. Billy Maximoff has been dead for years & was reincarnated as Billy Kaplan (which is the name he uses in the comics) the route the MCU is taking by making Billy Maximoff the primary character is far removed from comic canon.

[@annasofie9830]

I'm so surprised so many comic book people didn't seem to know this too. Them calling him Billy Maximoff is gonna take a looot of getting used to for me personally, it feels so off

[@rosyellis14]

yeah, i havent even read the comics and i still knew that

[@bookswithike3256]

@@annasofie9830 I refuse to get used to it. I need him to end the series calling himself Billy Kaplan.

[@annasofie9830]

@@bookswithike3256 Fr same, I can’t call him Billy Maximoff after calling him Billy Kaplan for so long, and I’ve already have people being like “ummm why are you saying Billy Kaplan, isn’t it Maximoff 🤨🤨”, i’m tired of it already 😭😭 I know they’re doing it to make it easier to comprehend for more casual MCU viewers but still… it feels so wrong (plus, what Rebecca and Jeff… like what are they gonna do with them…)

[@shadowx8145]

@@annasofie9830 I mean billy eventually started calling himself maximoff and his reincarnated family became irrelevant. The MCU is just fast forwarding cuz ultimately nobody give a shit about that

[@Jamiiemac]

Billy is literally a nickname of William… Billl-Billy-will-William I think it’s extremely self explanatory

[@Sebastian-wj7bc]

Lilia being responsible for Wanda going berserk in MoM😭

[@LocksAndChains]

That’s actually tragic. Even if she was looking for him in her universe, she wouldn’t have been able to find him.

[@justme5465]

Tommy doesn’t have a sigil on him but MoM still happened.

[@curtismurphy6206]

No the Darkhold caused that. Lilia just made sure Wanda didn't get to this son while she was hopped up on Dark magical power

[@steven_r33d]

Anyone else notice that the Bohner family reunion T-shirt said "pitch a tent"? 😂

[@cavon_08]

The "demographic" is people who enjoyed Wandavision

[@Lillian.Gao.]

Which is a WIDE demo lol

[@CrowTRobot]

I admit that the first few episodes aren’t going to be for everyone. It’s very camp witch adventure stuff on the level of Hocus Pocus. But this episode? This was legitimately captivating tv.

[@Lillian.Gao.]

@@CrowTRobot yeah the humor alone this episode was broad enough to qualify as a four-quadrant show

[@FireJach]

​@@CrowTRobotyou should try the penguin lol

[@godislightskin4868]

nah wandavision felt a little different from this, they don't have the exact same feel so that aint the demographic

[@spiritivy1861]

That’s official- this group usually has such good reactions, but I think for my peace and stopping myself from getting irritated every time they forget something or crack weak jokes- I’ll just stop watching their Agatha reactions 😅 I’ll tune in when it’s something they’re actually interested in

[@OHALALNOHA]

im one of their biggest fans got all of their merch and everything and im almost at this point too.. like seriously? im disappointed

[@cnote8546]

Yeah it gets really frustrating, especially when they miss things and try and blame the show, no you were not paying attention

[@crazydaave5394]

Yeah its such a shame, there reactions to other things are usually top tier, but all the agatha reactions just seem forced and they spend the whole time taking the piss.

[@jamesliggins891]

this is a good attitude to have. if you're not enjoying engaging with something, don't engage with it.

[@jomarch1085]

@@jamesliggins891fair point. Can’t the channel do the same?

[@jjh5374]

Maybe if the three of them weren’t constantly joking, they’d be able to follow that he died and Billy’s soul transferred into the body of William Kaplan at that moment. Instead they’re having a constant contest to see who can crack the best joke like it’s Mystery Science Theater 3000.

[@cmu0012]

7:03 lol i love how you guys refused to even consider it was a flashback for the whole episode and tried to convince yourselves it was a construct of his mind 🤣

[@austinhale5699]

Theory: Rio is death and lilia had a vision of billys resurrection and used the sigil to hide billy from her because as agatha said billy broke some rules to come to life. Also now it makes sense why agathas coven was chosen like that. Each witch had some connection to billy in some shape or form

[@angellilica451]

🤯

[@SandSlash242]

She is actually playing Lady Death, yes

[@TezzyDE]

I like the detail he says “i died that night” because for billy it was night time when he disappeared but for Willam it was day time

[@TezzyDE]

Also right before billy enters the body you can here him say a spell first

[@melissasardjo2069]

​@@TezzyDE Really? I did not hear that. I only heard. Goodnight Billy. Goodnight Tommy. That was a part in wandavision.

[@SouMorse]

Agatha said Billy broke the rules by possessing Billy Kaplan. In Multiverse of Madness they established the rule that possessing a dead body is forbidden and the souls of the damned kept calling Stephen a "trespasser". That means it's not just forbidden through Dreamwalking, it's forbidden in any way. You just can't possess a dead body at all. The writers of the show did their homework this time and watched the other stories to write this one.

[@faizantariqt629]

And they only forgot the small part where the souls of the damned show up immediately to f u up 😂

[@SouMorse]

@@faizantariqt629 lol yeah, I'm still curious about why they didn't come for him too

[@jaysax7381]

@@SouMorseit could be because of Rio. If she’s here then maybe the souls of the damned don’t need to be🤷🏽‍♀️

[@nilsburman3046]

@@faizantariqt629 @SouMorse @jaysax7381 because of lilias sigil.

[@Nacho2003YT]

Bro, the detail that William’s face went from pale back to more pinkish when Billy took over his body 🤯

[@lesterpapadopoulos2818]

i know the opinions of these reactors are valid. But, we as viewers, value on how you, reactors, feel too. So if the show/movie is not for your "demographic", then why not stop watching the show. We're not actually forcing you to watch a show that's not your cup of tea and maybe have a peace within youself for not watching a show you don't like.

[@FallenKnight2244]

Because it’s Marvel. It’s good to be up to date with the universe even if you don’t like the show.

[@ReelRejects]

You're Saying you want me to kick Coy out????

[@afriezalkamil2892]

​@@ReelRejectsYes, if he doesn’t like the show and doesn’t want to watch it, then just don’t watch it instead of saying something rude and disrespectful. You don’t have to like everything, that’s totally normal. But you do have control over your own opinions.

[@ReelRejects]

@@afriezalkamil2892 what happens when someone doesn't like something that you also don't like? Do you also not want them to put their opinions out there?

[@ot7biasedmashups]

​@@ReelRejectswell y'all are literally just reactors. If he doesn't like the show he can get watch it on his own or at least separate from the other two bc he's just ruining the vibe. Y'all have big enough reach for him to post a separate review. It's fine if he doesn't like the show but there's barely and constructive criticism.

[@Hellohellonada]

35:18 guys you forgot episode 2 of Alice saying “I was a cop, that will explain a lot of things.” 😂

[@DianaHerrmann]

Exactly.

[@jeremenogueras]

Alice said she was a cop at one point

[@aliengranpa]

Why did it take you guys so long to figure out what was going on?? You good, rejects?

[@midnightearth1015]

24:33 “the canceled Armor Wars” is crazy 😭😭

[@claudiaamengualmateo6989]

Okey, so I've been reading the comments and I think there's a bit of miscommunication between parties here. I think what people don't like is NOT that Coy is not liking the show, I think what most of us don't like is the feeling that we get that you are not paying attention and missing a lot of key storytelling by making cheap jokes over it and then saying the reason you don't like the show is because it doesn't make sense. When it doesn't make sense if you miss the storytelling. Like if a show sucks because it sucks, no one is gonna be mad about you not liking it, but if a show is good but you miss important parts and then blame that you don't like it on the show not being for you when it's simply the fact that you are not paying attention, then there's a difference. I feel like you came into the show wanting a Marvel show and only talking about references and cameos, instead of wanting to enjoy the show as its own thing, and that creates expectations and the disconnect that Coy was talking about. And Greg comparing it to Wandavision in the first couple of episodes, like the format pf the trial and stuff, when they are doing their own thing. Like if you're trying to connect everything to something else when its not connecting you're gonna miss what the show is actually communicating. All of that said, to the people who comment, some of you should just relax a little bit, you can give your opinion but don't forget they are people too and they deserve respect, if you start attacking people are not gonna be open to listening to you. We all just wanna watch a silly little show and enjoy it❤❤❤

[@pemberliegh]

Opened the comments to see how many people gave these rejects the business about Alice being a cop. 😂 How you dealing with those coals and the rakes? Looks hot and kinda scratchy. Coy, my dude, it's not that they forced a convenient name connection for Billy/William in the show... They just used the comics. I mean it's wayyyy weirder in the comics, but same names and roles and relationships for Billy Maximoff and William Kaplan. This was a pretty tame, easy to follow version of their story... William dies, Billys "spirit" or "soul" or whatever you wanna call it escapes and finds a newly deceased teen to take over.. Some theories that boyf Eddie will turn out to be Hulkling, aka Teddy, who is Billy/Wiccan's boyfriend in the comics. Which. I hope so.

[@arvenblack5656]

Who this show is for? For example me, 29 year old straight woman who loves witches and Marvel and Kathryn Hahn :) There are many things on the show that make people like it, it's not just for the queer community.

[@alexp601]

You're right, but at the same time, if someone doesn't like the show it doesn't mean they have a problem with women or the queer community. Many people are trying to call out those who aren't loving the show as the problem.

[@jamesliggins891]

well tbf the stereotypical answer is that this show is for the girls and gays so you would be part of the "expected" demographic

[@veenasudheer8532]

​@@alexp601 there are lot of men who is not part of the community actually enjoy this show. But people who actually diss this show mostly come across as very sexist and homophobic. This reaction especially made me uncomfortable.

[@alexp601]

@@veenasudheer8532 yeah you kinda just proved my point. If they don’t like the show they’re sexist/homophobic/whatever other name you want to call them. They can’t just genuinely not like the show, they have to be part of the problem. Personally I didn’t get any sense of homophobia or sexism from the reaction, but I understand that everyone interprets things differently (and maybe you caught things I genuinely missed or can’t notice).

[@Eazyduzit24]

Alice literally said she use to be a cop in ep 2 😅 the security even mentioned she gave her the job as a favor to her old “LIEUTENANT” 😂

[@richtang4946]

Joe Locke was amazing in this episode

[@jamesliggins891]

i thought he was alright. he can carry his scenes well enough on his own, but when he's in scenes with actors the caliber of Kathryn Hahn or Patti Lupone he doesn't quite hold up enough to me.

[@sailorboy8314]

I love how he put his hood up just like Wanda did in the finale

[@poe_more_please]

"This isn't my demographic." This will haunt Coy for a while.

[@vincentclark5853]

Yep.

[@jemmellpyron2527]

That's a fair opinion for him to have.

[@poe_more_please]

@jemmellpyron2527 and I would be okay with that if there was further explanation to this specific statement. But he hasn't explored that talking point. A lot of people have stated that Coy probably doesn't like the show. That can be true and valid. I'm not in that camp as of yet because he hasn't confirmed that. Right now, I would like for him to be more articulate in his reviews (which is ironic to say since he often dives into subtext enthusiastically).

[@jamesliggins891]

I mean I guess it IS my demographic and I still think it's just OK. Not great, not bad. I think it's fine not to like the show or like it but using demographic as an excuse is weird, I don't think that has anything to do with the quality.

[@poe_more_please]

@jamesliggins891 exactly. I guess he wasn't into Luke Cage because that's not his demographic. How does he like Wu Tang since they don't cater to his demographic? It's weird that he also likes The Penguin - Coy is neither a penguin or a mobster or a resident of Gotham.

[@talesyuki]

This episode was soooooooooooo good!! Damn, this show just keeps getting better. It's a shame it's just a limited mini series. Joe Locke was on fire, from the first scene you can immediately tell that this is not Teen. I found particularly funny that until now, Billy hasn't reminded of his other character, Charlie, at all. But as soon as I saw William(Kaplan) I thought "oh, there he is". Haha. He did a brilliant job. Can't wait for the next episode. Trailer spoilers beyond here. . . . . . . . . . Lilia and Jen will be back according to the trailer. Idk how tho.

[@jamesliggins891]

that was actually one of my criticisms of the episode, that there wasn't really a big enough difference in how joe was playing wiliam vs. how he was playing billy

[@talesyuki]

@@jamesliggins891 Oh dayum. Well, at the end it comes to taste, so we'll just have to disagree haha I hope you still managed to enjoy the episode!! It was my favorite so far.

[@fraliexb]

6:28 Alice said she was a cop prior to the security job.

[@AntiSocialExtrovert323]

The reason why he started out as William Kaplan > Billy is bc that’s the story in the comics. Also, he has a bar mitzva bc Kaplan is a Jewish name :)

[@AntiSocialExtrovert323]

Also, the true crime accent is New Jersey :)

[@wxywawjy626]

And the theme of the bar mitzvah was magic (they showed it). I didn't know this but saw it in NR recap video.

[@Itszaden_]

I was impatiently waiting for this notification. Just finished the episode like 30 minutes ago and I got here after you posted at 15 seconds ago.

[@julianasimpson3340]

how interesting coy isnt paying attention or even giving a chance to the only marvel show with a 99% female cast and gay characters...hmmm

[@carlosheredia443]

In episode 1, Agatha said "there's always witchy enough people to form a coven in a 5 mile radius"

[@user-dontdothemost]

finally someone else who likes Joe (billy) like he's just so charming in this role I don't get how more people don't like him.

[@amanda6212]

Well I guess I'm part of the demographic that enjoys this show...because this episode was pretty great. When Billy was at the hospital and then came home with the parents overwhelming him... I could see that young kid from WandaVision. Also the idea of a vessel/body for a soul to inhabit is soooo much more easy for folks to get if they aren't deep comic fans, b/c that can be crazy confusing. And Ralph Bohner! Yay, so glad Evan Peters came back for that cameo!

[@LavenderKAR]

Re (Ep. 6): Agatha’s true crime accent is an exaggerated South Philadelphia/Delaware County, PA accent. I was born and raised in Philly. You’ll hear it when you get a cheesesteak/water ice in that area, or go to the Italian Market.

[@sharbut]

Reactions have been so off. There’s more effort to make stand up comedy jokes than to actually watch and react to the important details in the show. No wonder so much has been missed. I’ve watched some of your other reactions and you guys mentioned stuff that even I haven’t remembered because of how locked in you were. Kinda disappointed. I still appreciate your reactions though!

[@starry002]

i love people having their own opinions but atp coy is just giving hater energy like if you have to try so hard to like it just stop watching. most of the things yall are saying is cause you miss details in the show lol

[@Gkwilson1487]

THISSS

[@shadmedina3033]

“ A Jewish gay witch, how f*ckin’ cool is that ?!” Very well said my dude, very well said ☮️❤️🧙‍♀️

[@jamesliggins891]

on its face, not very. but in terms of the meta, yes it's cool to even be able to say that about a disney marvel property in 2024.

[@sargentrowell81]

The post credit for the last episode needs to be someone attending the one man show!

[@burnt-croissants]

Love the Joe Locke appreciation, he really endeared me to Billy in this episode

[@Factsarebetterthan]

I turned off the channel when Coy said jokingly “not enough man stuff”. I’ve watched your reactions since Wandavision covering numerous shows. I think Coy is a good dude. He isn’t a fan. That’s cool. But watching someone neg something you love and throw out passive aggressive opinions is why I’m unsubbing from this channel and Coys. People can have their opinions. This is just why I personally am unsubbing and I want the folks at reel to just have an audience opinion.

[@Gkwilson1487]

Yeah if all feels super borderline misogynistic and homophobic. Like sorry the gay show isn’t manly enough for you 🤷‍♀️

[@arise3897]

This is what happens when you overthink everything you get more confused, just enjoy the show. ♥️

[@Say0nn.]

Just shut up

[@markknoop5468]

The demographic comments and the “Really?” after that compliment for Joe Locke’s acting ar3 quite off-putting. And this is coming from someone who usually enjoys listening to Coy.

[@OHALALNOHA]

Don't dislike the video for coy, use the like button on this comment as the dislike button for coy.

[@thedarkknight2221]

I love these guys, and I’ll always watch them, but maybe they need to take notes to refresh their memories like The Normies do sometimes. I always go to this channel because these guys usually find things I missed, now I’m the one ahead of them?!