[아형✪하이라이트] 에스파=짱스파 퍼포먼스는 레전드라는 걸 내 마음에 Savage 〈아는 형님(Knowing bros)〉 | JTBC 211023 방송

[아형✪하이라이트] 에스파=짱스파 퍼포먼스는 레전드라는 걸 내 마음에 Savage
#아는형님 #퍼포먼스하이라이트 #에스파
〈아는 형님〉은 매주 토요일 저녁 7시 40분 본.방.사.수!

[@fuyu_winter96]

Winter and ningning vocal is a another level, vocal queen 👑

[@JeanPierreYin]

teaeyon daughter voice

[@amiraaasalwaaa620]

@@JeanPierreYin whats the tittle of song?

[@fullsun_hchan]

@@amiraaasalwaaa620 Winter - All about you (Taeyeon)

[@shzuackrmn]

@@JeanPierreYin yeah taeyeon daughter

[@shzuackrmn]

It's true

[@ZeeTaylor25]

Winter's voice is like crystal--it's cool, clear, and crisp. Ningning's voice is like a flame--warm, soft, and round. Both really good and perfect for the Fall/Winter season.

[@akuhappy3246]

true

[@jem3706]

good analysis 👌👌

[@lia701]

They're like fire and water, perfect analysis 💕

[@ZeeTaylor25]

@@lia701 They complement each other. One's subtle, one's apparent, both beautiful.

[@MrRdlv]

They also never sing on stage.

[@lillybet1]

Ningning is definitely SM's new female power vocalist. What a beautiful tone her voice has.

[@aviyolanda1026]

Ningning's singing technique is amazing. She is really that good. She sounds like singer who had released tons of albums. Imagine in few more years,she will be even better than this. SM better treats her right.

[@jennychung29]

I guess Ning will leave SM when contract expires. Chinese usually back to their country.

[@Saphaemg]

NINGNING and WINTER proving tht they are queens if vocals in 4th gen.

[@crystaltan6471]

NingNing is a rookie but her voice already the best of 4th gen GG.

[@valstarxiii]

Literally the power vocal of the gen 4

[@ricostefanus]

true

[@minmin-qg3zh]

True

[@AznIntegra521]

U can see y SM recruited Ningning at such a young age. Her vocals are next level.

[@vx184]

Yeah omg you true

[@gali8087]

Ningning is like Tiffany and Bada's voice combination. Round, husky, playful, have soft pitch, vocal range is absolutely incredible.

[@jennychung29]

I have the same feeling. NingNing likes Bada when she sings high notes, likes Tiffany with low sounds.

[@fatimahaz-zahra5187]

WINTER VOICE IS MAGICAL, SHE’S TRULY AN ACE!

[@user-vb1zf2vn7o]

I'm agree

[@happygokathy2958]

When you can sing a Taeyeon song and actually achieve the same softness, then you are great!

[@ac9901]

Title of song?

[@rivertothemoon]

@@ac9901 all about you (hotel del luna ost)

[@LILI-wv5qh]

I'm in love with winter. I'm getting more caught up every time. Her unique voice...

[@lalisaoffical421]

Yeh

[@Kez_Sam]

Me too ❤️❤️❤️

[@matiqyvs8696]

X2 😍

[@JeanPierreYin]

mother teaeyon voice

[@ainerdqtrianz768]

Where the heck is Giselle's performance?

[@moonlightsunshine6]

Winter is going to be a legend, her voice and beauty are on point. For me her voice the best in Aespa

[@misanatzudachaemojeongjitw3758]

I feel that Winter has received a lot of love from everyone in this comeback of Aespa, it's amazing. Winter fighting!!!

[@Lyf4rMusic]

Well, u just seem to have noticed this comeback maybe, but she's been loved literally right from the debut ! Especially being titled as being born with YYJ's vocal chords and her iconic parts in the song always go viral in SK :)

[@misanatzudachaemojeongjitw3758]

@@Lyf4rMusic I know that. I've liked her ever since her teaser was posted. What I want to say is that in this comeback, people's interest in her has increased a lot compared to before.

[@Lyf4rMusic]

@@misanatzudachaemojeongjitw3758 yeah, that's for sure ! Her popularity only seems to increase each CB :)

[@krissyyyyyyy2709]

Truly SM vocals are no joke

[@chanisave720]

ㅇㅈ

[@melondrip7382]

Y'all mark my words. Winter is going to be a legend because of her voice

[@g0ldenicecream]

Yes like taeyeon ❤️❤️

[@darkbladesman7353]

I totally agree

[@JeanPierreYin]

teaeyon daughter voice

[@sovarani5929]

Totally

[@cus.theos.vocals.dont.diss7443]

What's the song she sang..?

[@cutestwinry]

Winter voice is both sweet and powerful, she'll be the next OST big name

[@jenniequeendomedits5795]

If winter doesn’t sing an OST for a kdrama I will cry

[@vicvergelmarquez4608]

Aespa completely slayed in this one, they showcase their all around talents like a professional

[@angelelin4231]

Except for Giselle...No performance from Giselle and it sucks

[@user-kd7bf6ms8v]

@@angelelin4231 no....

[@fel9ne]

giselle racist??

[@angelelin4231]

@@fel9ne why're you talking about it?

[@chelondono7215]

@@angelelin4231 When you watch the full episode you will understand why Giselle didn't rap .. She showed her talent by drawing an eyebrows .. 😁 I think it's up to them what they're gonna do .. It's hard to explain cause I'm not good in English . 😅 Watch the full episode it's out now in VIU with engsub .. For me there's no mistreatment happen on Giselle .. 😌 (4ME) 😁

[@itsme-sq3cq]

WINTER SHES SINGING MY FAVORITE HOTEL DEL LUNA OST OMG HER VOICE IS SO CLEAR AND CRISP

[@celine4894]

SONG NAME?

[@TheHarbat]

@@celine4894 ALL ABOUT YOU by Kim Taeyeon

[@Dungnguyen-ib9ez]

I think this is “All with you” it's the soundtrack that she sings

[@kelviniskelvin3207]

@@Dungnguyen-ib9ez Nope, that's Moon Lovers Ost

[@gabrielleplacio7295]

@@kelviniskelvin3207 that’s actually Hotel Del Luna ost “All About You”

[@bp_revolution1]

Winter and Ningning's voice is so beautiful. They have different colours of their own voice and I love it so much.

[@chords123]

Winter is making everyone fall for her even more especially when she sings. My heart cannot bear her beautiful singing. 😍😉

[@user-yq5pe2oy5i]

닝닝 저음 뭐야 ...레전드야 아니 카리나 춤선은 또 무슨 일이야 뒤에 희님 귀여워 윈터는 음색이 기가 막히네..?지젤은 또 갈수록 예뻐지는거 보소..하 이 언니들 최고야

[@baekhyunbyun2859]

Winter... I was really dumbfounded by winter's voice.. she definitely sound (almost) the same as the song singer waaaahhh... i love aespa

[@Ann-lz3ln]

Sorry but she really doesn’t sound same with taeyeon here. I mean she has her own color. Because taeyeon is way too powerful while winter is really going smooth

[@baekhyunbyun2859]

@@Ann-lz3ln well yeah haha.. let me edit my first comment.. she sound a little same with taeyeon... haha.. anyway, she did great right but the original will always be better

[@andinadhirahharis3099]

Anyone know what song winter had sing? Bcs I can't read hangul

[@im_ur_eudora9938]

@@andinadhirahharis3099 all about you by taeyeon ost of Hotel Del luna

[@taengoonim]

Taeyeon and IU's love child is Winter 💖

[@moraeine]

Ningning fully proved why she is the main vocalist of aespa. Talent + Techniques. 👍🏻 Her voice is not just about high notes. Her low notes are also so powerful. Her voice always give me goosebumps!!! ❤️ And Winter! She must be the next OST queen! 👸 Her unique tone touch my heart!❤️ SM did a really good job!!! Aespa has such a strong vocal line!!! WinNing are real treasure!!!💎

[@moraeine]

@love again and again. U. Annoying. 👋🏻👋🏻👋🏻

[@Ss-pb7bc]

@love don't be jealous

[@user-zu5bw7qx6b]

@love i smell jealousy

[@user-jm5po9sl7q]

윈터 음색 진짜 너무 청아하고 청량함,,,, 진짜 이슬만 먹고 자란 것 같은 목소리,,,

[@songveneulyrics]

Woahhh winter's voice is everything. I will look forward for her to sing a kdrama OST because that suits her so much

[@parkbacon6857]

Yes, i hope it

[@dianasarinikomang8164]

Winter voice makes me wanna cry.. it touches my heart really.. winter ,, you are like a sunshine 🌞

[@arydaaafp5555]

winter’s voice really really good‼️💛

[@lili_5036]

Ningning's voice is so damn perfect and I loved the way she sings english songs ❤️❤️❤️

[@user-dx4ok6nn5u]

윈터 음색 보물.. 비밀의화원에 이어서 레전드 찍었다ㅠ

[@hwyh5392]

ته

[@siwoopark4011]

진짜 윈터가 만약에 좀 제대로 풀로 불러줬으면 좋겠다....

[@user-li3fz2cf2h]

와 한국인을 찾았다!! 그리고 닝닝,윈터 고음 잘 올라가고 솔로하면 잘 될듯합니다 그리고 카리나는 춤 지젤은 렙을잘하니간 다 대박이에요

[@asdfghjkl-he8ws]

그대라는 시도 좋긴한데 갠적으로 비밀의 화원은 넘사였음

[@user-id5pe6re9t]

약간 긴장해서 떨리지만 않았어도 훨씬 잘불렀을 텐데 ㅠㅠ 개인적으로 지젤의 파워래핑이 안나와서 아쉽네요..

[@lalisa7865]

Ningning’s voice is truly amazing. Her low notes are immaculate 😫 its safe to say that she is indeed the 4th gen main vocalist.

[@rawseyyy]

Ikr

[@user-gh9xb3tq3h]

윈터 제발 연차 쌓이면 드라마 ost 꼭 혼자 불러줬음 좋겠다... 진짜 최고다 보컬

[@user-zl4rf7vy8r]

지금 윈터 연차에 태연이 만약에가 나온거라 당장도 가능은 할듯요!

[@skaielvs_]

Winter's dance is sooo sharp and clean love ittttt❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️💗

[@BossBabies3]

No one can ever come for SM’s vocal in any SM group even their lead vocalist can pass as MAIN VOCAL in other kpop group~

[@Haynoor22]

Mamamoo can

[@exoplanet5482]

@@Haynoor22 that depends on the listener. While you think Mamamoo vocals are better, many others think that Taeyeon, Wendy, Luna, Bada are better. I don't think i have to mention The Grace as they have the most powerful vocal in Kpop.

[@BossBabies3]

@@Haynoor22 ‘no one’ in this context is referring to the fans(public) not idols 🥴

[@diamondshines420]

@@Haynoor22 not really looking back at the times when Mamamoo join queendomn n when they have a mission to cover Aoa’s song Solar have difficulties to even reach every high notes in the songs as she said Aoa songs r full of vocal that proves Choa n Yuna from Aoa is a stronger vocalist

[@AznIntegra521]

@@Haynoor22 granted Mamamoo are good vocalist but SM vocalist are far superior. Sm really knows how to spot great vocalist and train the hell out of them. Bada, Luna, Tae Yeon, Ningning, and wendy are just monster vocalist.

[@leaderstxt]

Winter's singing and dancing like a real pro, ace indeed! her visual is like a real doll, so beautiful and cute, even her rap verses are iconic and special, no wonder she is really popular, everyone loves Winter

[@Eeeelllleee]

Her name is Winter but her voice is so heart warming. ⭐️⭐️⭐️

[@user-co5tq1dv3o]

닝닝 대박... 음색은 말할것도 없고... 보컬이 진짜 안정적이고 탄탄하다... 너무 잘함

[@user-ur8xr8pt7j]

다리 부러트리러 갑니다~

[@user-mg7ji6lx7u]

@@user-ur8xr8pt7j ?

[@i_ll_ill]

@@user-mg7ji6lx7u 댓 쓰신분 닉보면 이해되실거임

[@jaannya]

윈터는 목소리가 진짜 보물인 듯 단순히 예쁘기만 한게 아니라 듣기 편해서 계속 듣고싶음 아직 신인이라 한참 멀었을 거 같긴 한데 솔로 빨리 나왔으면 좋겠다ㅠㅠ

[@gundalsae]

팀으로도 좋지만 솔로가 너무 기대됨ㅠㅠ 애들 다 음색 하나하나가 넘 이쁨

[@JAY_1_29]

다들 실력이 너무 좋아서 다 솔로로 나왔으면 좋겠음 ㅎㅎ

[@user-cc5dc4xh6l]

솔로나옴 개망할듯 ㅡㅡ

[@user-cc5dc4xh6l]

@ㅇㅇ ?쏠로나올 클라쓰는 아직아니지? 니 부모는 너이러는거아냐?

[@gundalsae]

@@user-cc5dc4xh6l 왜 망할것같으신건지...?

[@ameliamilylove8285]

I'm not even a fan of aespa but Winter voice really had me think of it ...that voice really melted in my heart💓

[@rlani2290]

Winter voice is so clear!

[@syazanansh4346]

Ahhh Winter's voice so soothing! I love her voice tone! I need full cover

[@user-bb8id2hd1v]

닝닝이도 보컬 너무 매력있어 진짜

[@ohsehun2813]

Winter’s voice omg 😭

[@user-sb4bl8yx1h]

winter really suits her name because her voice is really cold and calming like winter

[@user-sb4bl8yx1h]

this was so corny anyways winter best girl

[@asoimchen4440]

Winter's voice is magical but ningning is the main vocalist for a reason... Just so proud of this girls...

[@kartunanimasi7440]

@ㅇㅇ keep Ningning the main thing

[@jamineb183]

@ㅇㅇ well they sort of have official positions since in their synk videos (the one where they were first introduced) karina danced, ningning sang and giselle rapped.

[@lorenzo3284]

@ㅇㅇ They have official position updated on their official twitter account. You

[@pineapple6638]

@ㅇㅇ they have their official position and Ningning is the main while winter is the lead vocalist, lead dancer and visual

[@tabithadejong6365]

I think they're allrounders!!👍👍😄

[@Ann-lz3ln]

Ningning is the NEXT DIVA in SM. If only she gets a fair treatment like letting her doing a cover for some divas song she likes like those mariah carey, rihanna, beyonce, ariana grande.. she really will kill it. Her riff and runs is not joke also she sounds fluent in english she is good

[@jewljuju]

Winter loves Taeyeon so much!

[@snow1783]

SM artists never fails when it comes to vocal. I personally love Winter! ♥️♥️♥️

[@user-cz1yv2gb3d]

닝닝 목소리는 진한 와인같아서 팝송에 어울리는거 같고 윈터 목소리는 첫눈 같고 우리나라 노래에 어울린다.

[@just7089]

그럼 에스파는 캐롤을 내야겠네요

[@kimjiw236]

@@just7089 그것도 좋다

[@dimastikapurihitahayuningt4204]

Uuuu7uu7uuuuu7uuu77uuuuuu7uu🐈🐈🐈🐈🐈🐈🐈🐈🐈

[@white_yellow1031]

비유 너무 잘하세요 ㅠㅠ 와인이랑 첫눈 같다니..

[@Yoon_Seul_lovely_13]

@@just7089 인정이요

[@summera7144]

Winter sang Taeyeon’s song!!! Beautiful vocals n rendition

[@prutha7086]

Song name ?

[@summera7144]

@@prutha7086 Taeyeon - All About You

[@marilyndip]

Taeyeon must be so proud of Winter 🤧

[@cherrylad74]

the fact that winter look like taeyeon at first time I saw her and she sang this ost that I love omg!!!

[@yaya332]

Winter voice sounds like a melody queen.Her voice will be perfect for ost .I had been crazy with her voice since her last cover of IU secret garden.

[@wynethannerodriguez9155]

Sameee!!! Thats the best cover of secret garden ever! Winterrr the best huhu

[@forlucky8115]

True

[@lalisa7865]

Ningning’s voice is powerful ❤️her low notes are incredible! In any way , she is the main vocalist

[@honeybubblegum7746]

Winter you make me melt with your soft voice😵

[@MsDemiRocks]

Holy fuck is Winter’s voice even real? HOW do you sound like that??? Unbelievable shes truly one of a kind.

[@zara-cf5wn]

Winters voice sounds so glittery and sparkly omg

[@user-xs1bo9zi9m]

와 비밀의 화원도 미쳤었는데 이런 발라드 ost도 자기 목소리 입혀서 진짜 잘부르네

[@aesu3548]

Ningning, winter- best 4th gen vocal Winter, karina- best 4th gen visual Giselle- best 4th gen rapper (girl can rap in 3 different languages y'all)

[@blackpinkbestgroup8060]

i disagree with Giselle being the best rapper of 4th gen as we have soyeon.....

[@Tenzin_cchoenyi]

@Shen Shouting Xiaoting soyeon is 4th gen so it's disrespectful to call Giselle best rapper when soyeon is there

[@miel6131]

Winter's vocal 😍🥺🥺 so heartwarming

[@user-ku2mc2ot7u]

닝닝이 목소리 옥구슬 굴러가는 소리 사랑행

[@user-ke5oh8iz8h]

막닝이 노래도 야무지게 너무 잘함 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ

[@ddeonukim9404]

im inlove with winter's voice its so calming

[@H00TGRLZ]

When winter sings, the world feels at peace

[@hoatrinh7881]

❤️❤️

[@meme-ye2ki]

Winter is a treasure for aespa and SM.😍⭐

[@kartunanimasi7440]

👍

[@vsesvittsvite2153]

All members is a treasure for aespa and SM.

[@queensnow4359]

@@vsesvittsvite2153 yes, winter just stand out, she's most outstanding member

[@meme-ye2ki]

@@vsesvittsvite2153 all members are legit jewels, but acc to me, Winter is a whole treasure box😍⭐

[@vsesvittsvite2153]

@@queensnow4359 for you

[@user-ce2pq8gx2b]

확실히 sm 붙을 애들은 붙는다니까.. 외모로 들어와도 실력으로 인증 해버린.. 에스파 매력의 내가 어느새 에스파 덕질 중..

[@msczxx]

im inlove with winters voice

[@huybel]

As soon I hear Winter's voice I got goosebumps, indeed a vocalist

[@HaBui-ud2fs]

Ningning’s voice gets me goosebumps omg

[@user-qg2xq9hk6q]

닝닝 목소리 너무 좋다;;;

[@dindaoctavia1743]

Winter 😘😘😘

[@hanniequoka]

I love winter 😭😭😭 her voice is so angelic like her 🥰

[@afobangfo6059]

What's the tittle of the song that Winter sang?

[@anonymous-sq9vu]

@@afobangfo6059 all about you-taeyeon ost hotel del luna

[@user-uy6xg1oz6t]

@@afobangfo6059 그대라는 시

[@linaajeng2608]

@@anonymous-sq9vu thank youu💘💘

[@afobangfo6059]

@@anonymous-sq9vu Thanks

[@limizaachumi6040]

Ning ning vocal is no joke. I'm getting goosebumps... She really deserves to be the main vocal. And yes she is wearing the crown of the main vocalist of aespa.

[@royaniabdilah2127]

@J K Ningning are the main vocalis

[@raihanahfarihan1176]

@you sadly, she is!!!

[@evanloo]

@you ningning is apparently the best main vocal

[@Ri57490]

@lola dacutest I don't know if this is official but I think Giselle is main rapper and Karina is lead rapper. Giselle's flow seems better

[@dreamer4475]

All Aespa members are my biases but it just doesn't sit right with me that when Karina & Ningning are being praised for being the main vocal & dancer, Winter stans (mostly akgae's) will appear in the replies and degrade/try to make it seem that Winter is the best at everything (saying she should be the main vocal or main dancer). Like, can't we just all appreciate them, and not try to degrade their co-members? Why y'all trying to make a war in the fandom when we should be supporting each other? I don't get it. It's sad to think that they already have 'this' kind of fans when they're still rookies.

[@redvelvet103]

no but winter singing a poem titled you is a world reset for mw

[@jjhonn_bond91]

i just realized Winter face is like manequin she's pretty omg🥺

[@risa.k]

Winters vocal is no joke

[@riceball564]

윈터의 목소리가 진짜 특별하다🥺❤️ 자랑스러워 우리 윈터 와 닝닝이❤️❤️❤️

[@haha2879]

윈터가 춤으로 들어왔다는 거 듣고 진짜 놀랐다..어쩐지 춤선 예쁘다

[@hwyh5392]

ىب

[@jenniequeendomedits5795]

WINTERRRRR WHY IS HER VOICEEE SOOOOO SOOTHINGGGGG

[@xYD8o1x]

WINTER'S voice hits different.. 😍

[@bloom6291]

Winter ace keeps proving herself.

[@yevss5691]

Ning Ning's voice is very powerful, she is very talented 💗

[@lj4722]

Winter's gonna be an OST queen, too. She's just so amazing.

[@user-wi7eo2sy4q]

winter expresses so much emotion when she sings

[@bangtansonyeondanbts8681]

Winter the angel..her voice omg how can i even describe it......she deserves more love

[@jaychristiangarcia1662]

Ningning's powerful vocal 🥺❤

[@mustikatieka2162]

Winter must be a next queen of soundtrack drakor 😊😊😊😊

[@namelessfan8795]

I could listen to winter sing all day

[@cosmiclatte6604]

I keep replaying winter's song. The vocals and feelings

[@Behappyforwhatyouhave]

What's the song BTW??

[@pearlaquawol5938]

@@Behappyforwhatyouhave All About You by Taeyeon ^^

[@kade731]

I can imagine her singing an OST for an epic kdrama 😍

[@manitacharanya.a5025]

AESPA POWER IS NOT A JOKEE!! They deserve everything!

[@manitacharanya.a5025]

Woahhh I don’t think I get that much likes, Thanks GUYS!!

[@koala2155]

Ahh winters voice 😍

[@chantalvargas2251]

Winter's voice is so amazing and Ningning's is the same

[@koizumichiaki]

omg..i just hope winter will have duet with taeyeon sunbaenim in ost one day or any stage 😍

[@kaioshinn_]

Better yet a feature on her next full album!

[@user-of8dw2tj3n]

우리 막내라인 닝이 민정이 보컬 진짜 보물들이야~~ 둘다 스타일이 달라서 더 좋아

[@ahgaseven6949]

Winter's voice is healing my soul 3>

[@mindeongi8380]

winter's vocals i--

[@user-hx3dy5tv2c]

닝닝이도 잘하는데 칭찬 좀 해줘요 닝닝이도 체고 ❤️❤️🥺

[@chansoonim7919]

Yes, she deserves all love in this world

[@theifh2916]

OUR MAIN VOCAL NING NING SO BEAUTIFUL ❤️‍🔥

[@alwaysygfam-liljyp-afewsm-1456]

@love hahaha keep cryin

[@XiMe36]

@love Ning is main vocal's aespa. She is the best vocal, only accept.

[@moraeine]

@love See. You again! And again! You despised ningning under every comments that appreciates Ningning’s vocal. 😞 “NINGNING is the Main Vocalist and Maknae (youngest) of the group. She was born on October 23, 2002 in China and can speak both Chinese and Korean. Her favorite subject is art, and she can also play the piano. Her symbol is Butterfly.” This posted on their SM Global Shop Website. If you disagree, please talk with SM. Don’t blame Ningning and Ningning fans. Thanks! 🙏🏻

[@Ss-pb7bc]

@love you Jealous on Ningning. I see you everywhere when Ningning mentioned as main vocal. I can't help you cause Ningning is official main vocal.

[@didemmd]

Ningning's voice is a gift from heaven, whenever i see her i feel peaceful

[@minkookofficial2970]

Winter Vocal number one

[@DNArr562]

I'm in love with winter her voice is very soothing