AI Editing Battle - Google Photos vs Apple Photos vs Samsung Gallery

[@GunzyHD]

Sketch to image on Samsung is insane. I took a photo of my 5 month old son and I, and added christmas hats using the Sketch to image. It worked perfectly, so I could send them to my mom for a little early Christmas card.

[@wilmerfernandez1221]

I believe Google phones are getting this soon. Kinda excited about it

[@Discord_users]

Apple already have this with image playground😂😂

[@Discord_users]

It just isn’t 9n iOS 18.1, it is on iOS 18.2 but he didn’t turn on the beta update to get it.

[@TMP_XT]

Samsung uses google on his ai 😂, check on google 😂

[@tsuk1nome]

Apple themselves admitted that they are at least 2 year behind

[@MrJgdekker]

Where did they state that?

[@manolakios]

apples ai is DEVICE based. thats the most impressive thing to me out of this video

[@Shorekeeper69]

@@manolakios it was device based on pixel 6 back in 2021.

[@Marc-OliverSchmidt]

​@@manolakiosThis is certainly a great thing, but ultimately, in my opinion, it is more important that the quality of the result is right.

[@TheWanderer-mq5rx]

​​@@MrJgdekkerBy delaying all serious capabilities of Apple Intelligence to 2026 or 2027.

[@KianFloppa]

w google pixel

[@ChasingState]

Total domination.

[@Rikeur]

@@ChasingStateSamsung >

[@asheronval]

​@@Rikeur u blind???

[@Rikeur]

@@asheronval u stupid ?

[@Jeno_Sinatra]

​@@Rikeur Samsung literally uses Google's AI, just slapped their own branding on it LMAOO

[@lucthegreat989]

2:39 I have a Samsung and the ai photo editor can be dumb sometimes. If you look closely you can see you didn't select the face of the small building on the left. Therefore it tries to continue whatever it thinks is there.

[@fame2726]

I wanted to write the same thing 😅

[@Tenems1]

For Samsung, you used Galaxy AI, but you had to use the Eraser because Galaxy AI only fills the image, and the Eraser erases the image. So, for the first one, it was better suited to use the eraser feature. I did the same thing with the picture that you did it with, and it erased the building in front of it.

[@SteveNeo]

yes, you have to use the right function. samsung offers two different functions, one erasing and one generative

[@Jberv]

Valid point

[@bbsxgummy-brawlstars4297]

dawg it wouldnt change the scores much

[@Tenems1]

@@bbsxgummy-brawlstars4297 i didn't want the score to change. just pointing out something that could be useful for others. not everything is a competition.

[@wavhalmukund]

I also used to take picture of the same image and tried on my phone, with correct erase it worked perfectly.

[@YasinHasan]

apple wont even touch samsung but fanboys will say they surpassed google

[@noufiyamol7615]

no google no samsung.

[@4musiclovers1]

Fanboy found 👍

[@danispringer]

they all suck.

[@TMP_XT]

Samsung uses google on his ai 😂, check on google 😂

[@TMP_XT]

​@@4musiclovers1 another fanboy found 👍🏻

[@Mhmd_SHA]

Google photos 🤳📸🎉

[@nico._lombana]

I can't wait until apple releases in 2 years all the AI features android have and then show it as something new and innovative.

[@noufiyamol7615]

apple doing on device processing.is very fast. objects automatically detected. and apple is just begning

[@Marc-OliverSchmidt]

​@@noufiyamol7615Well, but Google doesn't stop. I've seen many examples of Apple Cleanup and it's still quite a bit behind the Magic Editor. Ultimately, The result is much more important than the 5 seconds it takes longer, especially since the Magic Editor makes 3 suggestions at the same time.

[@Marc-OliverSchmidt]

@@noufiyamol7615 At Google, development doesn't stand still either. What good is a very fast function to me if the result is initially significantly worse for larger objects? In addition, with the Magic Editor, it is actually the case that three suggestions are made at the same time and you can choose the best result. I have really seen many, many comparisons, and in 80% of the cases the Magic Editor is better. At least currently, that's the state of affairs.

[@TheWanderer-mq5rx]

​@@noufiyamol7615Fyi, Google Magic Eraser does that too. It was there way before Magic Editor was a thing, Magic Editor does not auto select because it is a multipurpose tool rather than just an eraser tool.

[@Hhhh22222-w]

in 2 yesrs youll have to pay for these features on google and samsung lol

[@kristianivanov36]

It is impressive how well the Apple clean up did, given that it runs on the Neural Engine ON THE DEVICE, not a farm of 4000000 4090 GPUs. Means you can use it offline on a plane etc, and it will only get better in the feature. Might not be the best right now, or ever, but is good enough, and the offline part is definitely a win for me.

[@nonanonymous2378]

Fr haha. The Google/Samsung AI are obviously impressive in their own right but this comparison video seems to misrepresent Apple’s on-device approach to AI. Apple is offering a very different product from the others and when compared to them in this way it just seems inferior.

[@nzuzobrian6488]

First edit pf the video for Samsung making up L shape, it because you didnt fully select the qhole building, you lest the side of it

[@taylornicty1170]

I think Samsung should give us a Erase or Replace option

[@nzuzobrian6488]

@taylornicty1170 fr 💯

[@-Zodiac13]

​@taylornicty1170 samsung has a object eraser but he use ai generation

[@YssineVivo]

What about: * picture remastering *removing shadows *removing reflections *live effect *portrait studio... Are those not AI? Try to view things with a neutral eye

[@MokePops]

An important thing to note about this is that Apple will probably never add these features because you are esentially changing history. They even debated about adding Clean Up.

[@DarZen_no]

Apple is lagging quite a bit behind Google. I reckon they’ve been a bit slow off the mark when it comes to software development

[@aluimmumitat]

Apples head of software Craig Federighi said in an interview that the possibilities to change the meaning of a photo with AI has lead to internal discussions. I think they will never go beyond the clean up feature

[@Riddlerboss]

You forgot the exclusive AI features of Samsung Gallery where you can colorize black and white photos. Plus the ability to remove shadows and glare.

[@nayyuuuuuuiu853]

there are many in pixel too he forgot

[@nayyuuuuuuiu853]

add me and others

[@HomiebeaR_]

It is interesting to note that the majority of Google AI features can be accessed on Samsung devices (and potentially other Android devices, as well as iOS devices, although I cannot confirm this with certainty) through the use of Google Photos.

[@mafiaboy4925]

Yea by paying & which is not the case with pixel

[@AravindVNair]

​@@mafiaboy4925 Not all are paid.

[@Hhhh22222-w]

well yeah, whose ai features do you think samsung is using lol

[@Hhhh22222-w]

​@@mafiaboy4925 for now, itll be subscription based later, the fact that even google photos isnt available for free to all google pixel phones already tells you

[@Dwayne3007]

I have been sent photos to edit on my Pixel 8 Pro from people that have an iphone and 24 Ultra all the time. There really is no comparison.

[@sondofragz4583]

2:01 for Photo Assist I notice your drawing for removal isn't as precise as with the other 2, the S-Pen does help in this regard

[@ciprianadrian21]

Audio magic eraser is a game changer.

[@ENGRSAGORHASAN]

2:40 your selection was wrong for Samsung

[@pranavdupati9164]

is just the same part as the others, it has skill issue

[@fernando_her85]

What a fantastic video to watch, mate! This is one of the main reasons I use the Pixel 9. Even if you aren't a professional photographer, spending just a minute tweaking your photos with the magic editor can dramatically improve your results.

[@jadenramos7039]

3:26 how is it a tie? The Samsung didn’t even remove the object at least the iPhone did.

[@Red33760]

I guess he hates apple. Calling this a tie is crazy.

[@Red33760]

An the funny thing is, on the next, wehre google and Samsung couldn’t do the task he gives Google half a point. You can’t watch this guy. Not a good tech KZbinr.

[@jacopoleone4524]

He just select the front and not the all building, and he used the wrong tool, he should use the eraser tool 😂😂

[@notyouraveragecomment1328]

You are just too good

[@demiz]

The best Smart phone brand for AI is Google Pixel

[@SRKHD]

You gave half point to google instead of 1.0 you made it 1.5

[@ashrafulishti]

The way apple does things in much faster way and without cloud processing makes us realize its potential. Their should be an option for deep edit feature that may take time but gives the best result. Bring it, Apple!

[@RikoNakamura-o4c]

Pixel's Enhance tool is absolutely mind boggling

[@evenmagical]

Samsung made the big L cuz u didn't select the building properly...

[@dirtydirtsgt4751]

Samsung has many on-device tools that show up when you swipe up a photo. The features available depend on the photo, but it works really well. Most underrated galaxy ai feature imo

[@nauvalmuhammad3619]

Well sharp comparison, meanwhile google hasnt been scored for that add me features😂

[@EricCooleric]

loving the way Aliagents is blending AI technology with real world applications

[@MarkWether]

the innovative approach Aliagents is taking with tokenized AI agents is seriously next level

[@wantikjasonchiu4711]

But remember, this is iOS 18.1, which is still much less features about Apple Intelligence then what is more available for you to use on iOS 18.2 with features like image playground, Genmoji

[@ashwinbhat95]

I mean the Pixel might be better, but they are all terrible right now. Anyone buying new phones for these AI features are just offering to be testing data at this point.

[@Johnbrownpe]

the tech behind Aliagents is super interesting, tokenized AI systems with real functionality

[@jayjayhak-o3b]

Thank you Emad...for the honest reviews

[@Absarock1]

Sometimes magic editor wont remove the selected object. Eg: overhead cables in the pictures. To fix it, instead of shading over the undesired object, i would zoom in and tap. that would autoselect the object. And then erasing works

[@johnpraise27]

Apple is 3 years behind, for those waiting for apple in 2 years time. Do you think Google will fold their hands and wait for apple?

[@thorodin8773]

Erase shadows in samsung is not compared here...that is also a very useful feature.

[@amrdoe]

Are Google Photos AI features Pixel-exclusive?

[@Lefty7788tinkatolli]

You missed several AI features in the Samsung. Also, Samsung has a separate image remover and shadow remover, which was not shown in this video.

[@Red33760]

3:26 Calling this a tie is crazy. Samsung puts a whole object there where apple at least removed it.

[@nonanonymous2378]

I thought the same thing haha

[@Jberv]

For samsung in erasing object, you have to use the right tool, Object eraser, As galaxy ai tends to fills what it is selected

[@omarmaamouri]

Please more app comparisons for these 3 flagships/companies! Please 😊

[@4musiclovers1]

What is your point method? Samsung's Object eraser isn't quite right, but how did it get .5 point? And the last thing in the selection of the pixel was not correct. The output would be different if the selection had gone up last in pixel

[@maxking8146]

2:01 you didnt draw on the side of the building to remove it

[@Spoonfed78]

Great comparison as always. What would be interesting is a comparison of the latest iPhone 16 pro whatever with Apple photos vs an older iPhone 13 or 14pro with Google photos. Apple won't like it as those phones can't do these things *cough*"lies" , could include on device only as a component too...for the comments section 😉

[@WhyAmogh]

2:00 u did not select whole building a left portion was not selected

[@alonsobrito3926]

You can tap to select (people and objects) on Samsung, there's no need to manually draw the shape of it.

[@muhammedhanun3593]

As always google is the best when it comes to AI

[@fahadrammoo1504]

Yo just wanted to mention, I think for the Samsung using the AI button to do the erasure is actually just telling it to replace image not erase it, its a bit weird, if you want just erasure then click the edit pencil, go to the 4 dots option and hit object erasure tool, this will only erase object and not replace it

[@kyuubi_0261]

Honor's Magic Ai eraser is the best Ai editing tool so far

[@mostafizurrahmanjhalak8629]

This is the only reviewer i trust.

[@MIIB7773]

hoping for apple to see this video and release major updates late this year. can apple beat these two?

[@valecasini]

For me Google atm is the best one on the AI side! Google Photo editor and Gemini too are very nice compared to the others...

[@doodlexenosinfopinion]

AI memories, Samsung gallery can auto create stories and can create stories, edit, and auto music too...can also create 24-hour time lapse photos sunset to sunrise..

[@rico4you]

All this on the Pixel 9 XL with a tensor 4! Home Run Google! Benchmark trolls keep walking...😂

[@muhammadragilsaputra3067]

For all people saying apple will catch up android AI feature in a few years, no they didn't. In fact Apple is planning not to give their user ANY Generative edits, so you will not find any of this generative edit in iPhone.

[@JoaniMariano]

Samsung phones can have both, google photos and their own gallery. So it's the best option

[@creepy_egDC]

apple fans in 2030 receiving the half features from 2024 saying that is so innovative

[@largon2008]

I had the s24 ultra great phone but right now i am using the 16 pro max and i am loving it. Always have liked their OS i never cared about the echosystem. Iphones are good phones that do the job right with fluidity.

[@pavelmares97]

Why unsable image on iPhone gets 0 points but unusable in Samsung gets 0.5?

[@davout5775]

I support Apple's approach. Local LLMs are the way to go as it doesn't rely on the Internet to do these simple tasks. For now, they are behind tho. They have an advantage in NPU performance so I'm sure they will catch up soon

[@Marc-OliverSchmidt]

I'm not sure if they really have an advantage at the MPU. At the moment, Apple's self-dictation function is slower and much more error-prone than Google's. When it comes to photo functions, it's more important to me that the quality is right, even if it's currently still in the cloud. Google's development doesn't stand still either.

[@orian-x]

On pixel phone u can still use in phone local addeting tols the it was released with the pixel 6. U got more options and even the magic eraser still work great and I use it to this day

[@Marc-OliverSchmidt]

@@orian-x The Magic Eraser actually works well for smaller objects, but for larger ones I would tend to be more towards Magic Editor.

[@orian-x]

@@Marc-OliverSchmidt true it's good to have the options to have both for better result and even I. can fix my old iPhones photos lol

[@davout5775]

@@Marc-OliverSchmidt It beats it in benchmarks. NPUs are harder to measure.

[@watchout5508]

The first image with samsung was because you used generate and not object erase! I used it from a screenshot of ur video on my s21 and it was onpar with what Iphone did.

[@tarekalrifaie]

The selecting line is not around the whole building, thats why I guess.. in photo 1

[@samadkhan85]

Where do you buy your pixel phones from

[@apostolkaftani9149]

Just tap on what you need to erase. Why you do it manually just tap

[@Azmodaeus49]

Yeah I mostly let the AI do the work, instead of doing it manually

[@joelarson6884]

Well, Apple photos sucks but I can use magic editor on google photos app.

[@Erick-uf4uq]

I’m a Samsung guy but why is always the Indian guy hating on Apple even if there are 1 or 2 things apple makes better.

[@CheckSystem69]

Great video as always, but as far as the pixel functions are concerned, you have not shown the Add Me function. 😊

[@BIGD39hki]

iPhone AI doesnt even ready cmon bro

[@petereliassen9698]

Why did google photos delete the editing video features?

[@Hamed_Behzad]

Samsung also offers increase resolution

[@MARTIANZZMUSIC]

so does google

[@Citrumoothy]

So does google?

[@hardikagarwal1383]

no one can beat samsung and google 🗿🗿

[@vMattv]

Not samsung, no one can beat google

[@Z1bi]

Apple started exaggerating in their loss of features and creativity I understand that they don't want to, but that's too much

[@sawako3142]

On device vs cloud

[@Lagoonedit]

6:00 “made me laok like a stickar”

[@SteveNeo]

you have to use the right function. samsung offers two different functions, one erasing and one generative

[@emrebey2244]

This test also has to make after one year. Apple's AI only 4 months old I think

[@Red33760]

This little guy is just a Google fanboy.

[@Zarathustra_II]

For information: Samsung is using Googles ai

[@timotei3937]

Why do I not have many of these features on my google pixel 7 pro?

[@DevinChandula]

I don't have AI on my Galaxy but the Object Remover tool which I have on my phone would do better than what AI did on that building photo

[@Citrumoothy]

You cant just say that 💀

[@janeleekeller]

Thanks once again Emad ✨ JaneLee 11/3/24

[@cheeerfulchameleon1881]

I am thankful for having 300 subscriber and am hoping to reach 400 by the end of the month

[@jimmysuplon]

I am using a google pixel and I love it but the button to open the magic editor never shows up so I can't use it fully. It only appears randomly sometimes. When I press where the button is supposed to be it vibrates just as if I clicked it but nothing happens...

[@Marc-OliverSchmidt]

@@jimmysuplon The function is only available if the image has already been loaded into the cloud. This should work without any problems via Google Photos

[@jimmysuplon]

@Marc-OliverSchmidt it is, and my whole gallery is already saved!

[@Marc-OliverSchmidt]

@@jimmysuplon That's funny. It works for me without any problems and if I want to edit a photo that is not yet in the cloud, it is automatically uploaded first. I'll keep my fingers crossed that you find the cause quickly.

[@jimmysuplon]

@@Marc-OliverSchmidt I've contacted support but they didn't understand

[@ZahidHasAnd]

My iPhone 16 pro max doesn’t have this features ?

[@dijonweb]

You just have to use Google Photos on Samsung, no need a Pixel !

[@YourvitamineD]

If only pixel use a better chipset then I will consider them

[@Infamousgamer5026]

you are doing wrong with samsung. Samsung have separate object erase option. You are using AI tool which replace original object to AI generate object.

[@linusoberwinster]

I would say every AI is very good, but Google is a bit stronger. But unfortunately, the chip in Google phones is not quite as good.

[@redamohammad1937]

Is the pictures shoot by google ? If yes than its not fair for others

[@Spoonfed78]

@@redamohammad1937 relevance? Zero

[@redamohammad1937]

@Spoonfed78 yes , try it your self and see dude.

[@Spoonfed78]

@@redamohammad1937 Google is a company though, so do you mean the company has provided him the pictures. I doubt it.

[@redamohammad1937]

@Spoonfed78 dude try than reply. If you take it by pixel than you use AI edit by other phones it will not work 100% not even 70%

[@gammon2001]

Do you have the same functions on the Samsung device if you use Google Photos on it?

[@markkendall6144]

They should just both use google photos,thats the thing isnt it samsung and apple dont share there app but google works across all of them

[@OnilMarteNavarroza]

Apple has left the chat.

[@leemo5580]

Sketch to Image is the same as Reimagine though. Its not fair to give grade for that.

[@GayashanBandara-lw5ov]

Google photos is th best, no doubt🤩🤩🤩

[@farmanullah20200]

Bro is some personal issue with samsung and got some extra money from google 😂😂

[@electric-up2tr]

Like having a pixel 9 pro xl or a 16 pro max makes any bloody difference to a 9 pro or a bloody 16 pro. Only difference in battery size. Stupid tech reviewers.

[@Green_Globe_z]

You must test Xiaomi alongside, it offers great AI features which other lacks

[@albibushi3006]

Which one allows me to change beard style based on my photo?