AI Rotoscoping in Final Cut Pro with Rotomatic

[@FxFactory]

Awesome, thanks so much for spreading the word!

[@kosherdosher2839]

I would love you to give us a full tutorial with lots of details before we buy. Or have someone else do it!! Thanks

[@JosephSlinker]

You bet!

[@rayaontour6345]

Very cool and thanks for showing it. It seems, the Plugin has still a little trouble with your arm, as the mask is flickering a few times.

[@JosephSlinker]

Yeah it definitely was struggling with orange skin on red background.

[@mikkoleivonen2905]

I have downloaded and been working extensively with this. In trial mode, after 1,000 frames, it stops working despite it being advertised as fully functional in trial mode plus the addition of a small watermark overlay. Do you know if this a limitation on the trial version, or is this frame limitation also in force in the paid version?

[@JosephSlinker]

I didn’t run into that with the paid version. I’m not sure about trial limitations.

[@mikkoleivonen2905]

@@JosephSlinker I learned only after purchasing it that it will do max 2500 frames (according to FX Factory support) which is about a 3 minute clip. Great software but worthless given this limitation that other do not, such as mRotoAI, AI Background Remover and Keypr. So I contacted them, explained this, and they immediately gave me a refund back. Very good service and support, and I told them that when this limitation is removed, I will come back and buy it the same day, and I mean it.

[@FxFactory]

@@mikkoleivonen2905 Please check out RotoMatic 1.1 with updated support for longer clips alongside many other improvements.

[@deheiligebron]

This still looks in beta.. (for 149…?!)

[@IoVideoMaker]

Why shouldn’t I be using the free FCPX Scene Removal Mask? It’s free, and it gives more professional results. Am I missing something (apart the fancy name “Rotoscoping”, but I don’t think it’s worth this plugin price, per se!). Thank you, Joseph!

[@TOPSFANIS]

FCPX Scene Removal Mask?

[@JosephSlinker]

Scene removal only really only works on locked off shots. Although scene removal might have worked better for my example, it doesn’t do as well with motion.

[@patrickgoethals3235]

I wonder if this can also be used in Apple motion. (I don't use F.C.)

[@JosephSlinker]

I got confirmation from the developer that they want to make it work in Apple Motion, but the they ran into technical issues that made it not possible for launch.

[@FRANKRICECOLD209]

I Don't Know How This Compares to mRotoAI But Atleast You Can Buy It And Don't Have To Pay For a Dumb Subscription

[@JosephSlinker]

Check out Jenn Jagers video! She does a direct comparison of the two.

[@FRANKRICECOLD209]

@@JosephSlinker Just Looked Can't Fin Her Video Weird Thanks Though

[@DigiDriftZone]

The results look pretty poor though

[@SteveMcGarrigle]

It looks poor at the start when he's small in the frame. Better when larger. Not a great example to show it off imo.

[@JustAddMovement]

Is keyper better this?

[@JosephSlinker]

I think Jen Jager actually has a video directly comparing the two.

[@rgbman01]

So sad to see where we are today in FCP. Tools that just aren't ready for prime time and have no business being utilized in any professional video environment. My clients would laugh at the results of something like this. No knock on you Joseph. I would never kill the messenger.

[@JosephSlinker]

I know what you mean. For many KZbinrs this is good enough, but if you’re doing any serious VFX work this would never fly, especially considering the pipelines most shops work in.

[@TheElseCrash]

Good to see that people start to work on alternatives for mRotoAI without subscription! But RotoMatic feels more kind of a too expensive Beta Version at this point. It is a disease of our time to abuse customers for testing. Lets see what an update to version 2.0 will give us in the future or what other developers will do shortly ... I will wait for a better conclusion.

[@kosherdosher2839]

Subscriptions suck!! I prefer mRotoAI but refuse to $$$$$. Jenn Jagger did a comparison video and says VFX is a little better.

[@spearcy]

Not worth $149 just to buy a only a simple rotoscoping tool (which doesn't even work that good) when, for $295, you can buy the entire editing software package of Davinci Resolve Studio, which not only has high precision Magic Mask rotoscoping but also all kinds of cutting edge editing capabilities, tools, transitions, color grading, etc. It's interesting that Final Cut Pro is so far behind the curve when it comes having a built-in rotoscoping tool. Its competitors have had it for years.

[@JosephSlinker]

Agreed. I don’t enjoy editing in DaVinci, but it’s shocking how far FCP is behind the curve. Like if DaVinci added the full magnetic timeline I’d probably switch and never look back.

[@mediabear]

Ai < Actual Intelligence

[@thehomiebigrich]

Mine doesn’t even mask it just turns sold red, can’t see anything, and the background sold black Pointless so far hopefully Fxfactory reaches out to me for a fix or imma need that refund

[@JosephSlinker]

It sounds like you’re using the wrong masking display options. Either way you should reach out to their support team.

[@thehomiebigrich]

@@JosephSlinker I’ve tried every option and it doesn’t work smh … waitin for them to reply

[@JosephSlinker]

@thehomiebigrich good luck! Hopefully you get a speedy response from their support team.

[@christopher_nelson]

I've watched two videos now using this tool, both from people that I know are good with FCP, and they both are pretty poor results. I am not impressed with the quality of the results at all. This can't be a finished product... I expect better than this.

[@JosephSlinker]

From my experience, and it seems like others, it really can't be your one and only roto tool. If you notice in my video, sometimes it does shockingly well, and other times it does shockingly poorly. I didn't want to edit out either so that people could get an accurate portrayal of how the tool works.

[@christopher_nelson]

@@JosephSlinker I appreciate honest reviews like yours… showing good and bad is important to develop trust in viewers.

[@TohPhimmasenh]

IT DOESN'T EVEN WORK FOR ME, I WANT A REFUND SO BAD

[@JosephSlinker]

Definitely reach out to their support team if you’re having issues. I’m not affiliated with the company so I don’t have much ability to help out.

[@TohPhimmasenh]

​@@mikkoleivonen2905 it sucks, but i hope that they would update it and make it better, i really hate mrotoAI for their subscription

[@mikkoleivonen2905]

I learned only after purchasing it that it will do max 2500 frames (according to FX Factory support) which is about a 3 minute clip. Great software but worthless given this limitation that other do not, such as mRotoAI, AI Background Remover and Keypr. So I contacted them, explained this, and they immediately gave me a refund back. Very good service and support, and I told them that when this limitation is removed, I will come back and buy it the same day, and I mean it.

[@FxFactory]

​@@mikkoleivonen2905 Please check out RotoMatic 1.1 with updated support for longer clips alongside many other improvements.

[@bradstudio]

Your arms are very close to the same color as the bricks, which is why the AI is having difficulty.

[@JosephSlinker]

I imagine you're right, but it's still something people should be aware of before buying.

[@MadMixy]

man apple really screwed these guys as soon as roto became a thing boom magnetic mask