An Iranian Muslim woman talks about Israel and the Jews

An Iranian Muslim woman talks about Israel and the Jews
/ elicalebon

[@renycyril6029]

I am from Bharath (India). we welcomed and accepted our Jew friends when they were exiled from their land. The only place on earth Jews were never persecuted for being Jew. Bharath is still with you Israel, we who know, Know the truth.

[@helenakolar]

Yes, so were Bosnians, the majority Muslim country, when Ottomans allowed them to come in. During the Second World War, Jewish people were protected by Muslims. So, not all Muslims are bad, Right !!! " I understand the reason behind your statement."

[@EpicLemonMusic]

thats because among the worlds people Indians are among the most peaceful, as an atheist I thank goodness everyday we have countries like India and Israel on the Arabian sea, Islamic Jihad and Christian theocracy are rampart in the world these two countries are bastions of secularism.

[@davidroscoe3815]

Indeed, India has been very supportive of the Jewish people, thank you.

[@sr16gotheextramile51]

The Philippines accepted many Jews during WW2 lots of videos here in youtube. kzbin.info/www/bejne/l2KYaH2djpirjZYsi=r61ZYd3T8gBPrR0C

[@speaksense4605]

True that Bro, the most tolerant country in the world. You are forgetting Parsis otherwise called Persians, Zoroastrians from long ago, then came Iranians after the Shah was over throwed, the invaders, colonizers etc. Still there are communities in the south who's DNA is matched to the Jews. Jai Hind!

[@GershonWolf]

I am Jewish and lived in Israel a while back. I had plenty of Arab buddies. We made music together and hung out. Some of them were Israeli Arab citizens. All of us had free health care. None of us wanted to be terrorist targets. One day Rehov Ben Yehuda, the main drag in New Jerusalem blew up. Suicide bombers. I was there. It was bad. These kind of attacks were happening there a lot at the time. Most people in Israel want to live together in peace. Its the troublemakers, like Hamas, who want to gut the place and turn it into a caliphate. iIs got nothing to do with race. It's about democracy vs. theocracy. Sure, the hardline jews want to stop the busses running on Shabbat in Jewish neighborhoods and such. But they don't kill your grandmother over it. The argue for it in the Knesset and in court. It's safer that way, don't you think? If the Caliphate (Hamas, etc.) took over they would steal my guitar, forbid women to go to school or work, or go out unaccompanied by a man, and then kill me. Not in that order. Hey, it's not what Abraham had in mind, folks, and I'm afraid he was there long before islam. In fact, he IS thier ancestor.

[@templekanu6740]

Muslim means one who submits to Allah. Only Muslims know who their Allah is.

[@darshuetube]

the problems everywhere is not about race/dna/gene. It is about cultures, your upbringing, (that ties to religions to since religion is part of your upbringing)....This includes racial division in the US.

[@ByHisGrace-]

Agreed

[@ByHisGrace-]

​​@@hajirachandlayno he was not.

[@simonsmith1974]

​@@hajirachandlayummmmmm you are clearly misinformed my friend.

[@gnosis7662]

Around 900,000 Jews were expelled from Arab countries between 1948 and 1970 with most of them losing their property and their wealth in the process. My father was one of them. He had to flee Tunisia and move to France when the Arabs revolted and attacked the Jewish and French living there. They left behind a very prosperous Jewelry business as well as their home which the Arabs took over illegally. They never got a cent back from Tunisia since that time. So as you can see, there were far more Jewish refugees than Palestinian ones since 1948 but with one big difference: Jews worked hard and prospered wherever they went while Palestinians still claim their refugee status and ask for hand outs from world governments.

[@Liv21484]

Sorry ,even the student in Yale can't use logical thinking in this way .To define what is wrong or right .

[@Josh-iz5kb]

@user-lu1ur9tk7r ???😂😂😂

[@mel3004]

So sorry to hear of your family's past troubles. God bless and protect Israel and the Jewish people everywhere.

[@imisstoronto3121]

@gnosis I am Ashkenazi but I have been posting this all over YT because it so enrages me. The injustice and the lack of memory of the world. I was under the mpression that this began in 1941, and nearly all Jews from North Africa were expelled. Stripped of everything and forced to leave pretty much at gunpoint. Its also enraging that the UN through UNWRA hands out charity, provides and supports DP camps they squat in and the Arabs can hand down their refugee status to their children and grandchildren. No assistance was provided to these Jews, and they had to get on with life. You only have one. Personally I think that's why we survive those that try to destroy us.

[@tali605]

And they are crying for nacba Ever since exploiting and manipulating the world for money and mercy instead of doing something. They are just uncapble. All of a sudden they became poor palestinian. Before they were arabs.

[@sophroniel]

I'm Jewish and I'm grateful you aren't fooled by all those lies. I have so much empathy for the innocent women and children who are being killed and live within gaza, at the same time as I condemn hamas and stand up for israel as my homeland and the homeland of all jews. It's complicated, and she is so right that people are just using this whole turmoil as an excuse to show their antisemitism

[@garyvanvreden2229]

We are praying for all Jews, they will be victorious

[@khashayar8989]

If you people Didn't invade there be no Hamas Doesn't matter how far Hamas goes simply because its in defence You still and always be invaders Since you all converts You all from Europe Nothing to do with Jews from 3000 yrs back

[@dragonflycrashed5511]

it is *not* complicated at all. the quran says that jews are to be killed or subjugated. muhammad killed and subjugated jews. so, for muhammadans, the problem is not solved until the state of israel is destroyed and the jewish population is either murdered, or forced into dhimmitude by muhammadan rule. in the core, the problem is that the cult of muhammad knows perfectly well how superior jewish theology is over the teachings of the quran, which are self defeating and simply make no sense. judaims best exposes the lie that the cult of muhammad is.

[@elisheva7772]

Mark Twain a well-known historical writer and philosopher visited Palestine in 1869. He described the land as a desolate land not occupied by millions of Arabs who are calling themselves Palestinsinas. He saw a synagogue there and wrote his statements marveling at the Jews and how they survived every civilisation and never changed. Why doesn’t anyone quote his comments? Did he also not exit in the new version of history you have been sold?

[@daniel.d2150]

Hear Hear!

[@amoyjoyce1117]

@elisheva7772 the Iranian lady has some info correct but she is wrong , then she calls God a liar , because he wrote Israel’s history , she does not believe in the book of Genesis which is the first book in the Bible. it all began in Genesis 16 that is causing this war today it Not about land , it’s which Son .God promised Abraham a son, after 25 years of waiting, Sarah told abraham to go sleep with a Egyptian maid , and a child was born , named Ishmael , God returned, and said to Abraham next year this time, Sarah will have a child and Sarah laughed , saying at this age, am I to have this pleasure. God waited till Sarah was unable to have a child naturally, God wanted a holy nation. Isaac was born a miracle child, God wanted a holy nation to bring in the Messiah. Ishmel was now 13 years old when Issac was born . Then Hagar and Ishmael was sent away from Abraham and Sarah and Isaac because the jealously was beginning to take root with Ishmael teasing the little boy Issac. And Sarah told Abraham to send them away , God told Abraham to do as Sarah says. One day God call abraham to take his son on his only son whom he loved to Mount Moriah and sacrifice Isaac to him, on the way, Isaac ask his father where is the sacrifice, and Abraham said the Lord will provide . As Abraham was about to sacrifice his son. The angel of the Lord stopped him and said Abraham ! Abraham ! don’t harm The child ! Abraham looked around and saw a ram caught in the thicket .. on that very spot, the son of God was sacrifice. Isaac had two sons. Jacob and Esau. God chose Jacob, Long story short, God change Jacob‘s name to Israel Jacob had 12 sons, 12 sons became the tribes of Israel, from the tribe of Judah came the Messiah Jesus. It’s all in the Bible. There are some Jews who don’t support Israel well, God separate the tribes of Israel . Today they are still not United but he says he will bring them back again open their eyes and see Jesus was hidden. In all of Gods feast days they celebrated for thousands of years. And still celebrate today, It was all about Jesus, death, resurrection, and the new covenant , he will open their eyes to see him write his law of love on their heart, put a new spirit in them to know him he will be there, God and they will be his people and so all Israel will be saved . It written some won’t ever return because of their idolatry against him When God first call Abraham his father was making idols. He took him to the land of Canaan. He said to abraham go walk the land I am giving to you and to your descendants, forever ! get a vision of the land . He made a covenant with Abraham and told him your descendants will be in a foreign land for 400 years I will come and take them out. It was 430 years when the children of Israel finally made it into the land of Canaan modern day, Israel today. And they had to fight your way from the Red Sea to the land of Canaan, then they had to fight to keep the land It unconditional theirs but condition that they obey him. They broke they covenant but God kept his because it swore by himself . Today they are still fighting. But The battle is for which son ? still exists because the Muslims are blinded and see the true son who died on the cross for all our sins including theirs. As you see, it’s not about land because the more land they gave to the Palestinians , it the more they use the land to launch rockets against Israel. Go read the Bible to get the true story not written by man, but God. Reason why there is a displacement of Palestinians. The Palestinians and Jews were living side-by-side when the Arabs decided to war against Israel, they infiltrated the airways and told the Palestinians who were living side by side with the Israelites as neighbours to come out and join the Arabs to fight with them, and they will win the war and give their homes and lands belonging to the Israelites to the Palestinians. Jews dropped leaflets asking them not to go and fight in the war, against them reminding them , “we are neighbours “, to remain at home and israel will go to War , the very next day, the Palestinians walked out to join the Arabs to fight against Israel. Israel won the war, and Israel refused to have them back as neighbours, and that’s why they are displacement, but a fake news will not tell you the truth. Oh by the way this is a spiritual battle it will all end when Jesus goes to war against the nations read EZE 37:24-38 Eze 38, Eze 39, . Many Iranians are becoming Christians and following Jesus and falling in love with Israel, I pray God open the eyes to the truth. She will read the Bible and see how sincerely wrong she was, and she will repent, her Eyes will be open. She denies Jesus , yet she believes in a prophet who has never prophesied anything who is a self-proclaimed prophet.he said , he flew a donkey to Jerusalem, and no one saw him. The Bible says , there has to be two witnesses and he had None. Jesus had prophecies from from Genesis 1 ! And through out the Bible , Jesus has witnesses at his birth. Three kings came all the way from the east and saw him Herod will try to kill him. He had 12 disciples. He had witnesses when he died and witnesses when he rose from the dead, 500 witnesses saw him , his 12 disciples were with him, he spend 40 days with him, and he taught them what the old Testament said about him,. Jesus including two angels, when he ascended into heaven. It’s the bible . Mohammed had no witness, and yet she believe someone who had no witness. Hate against the Jews began with the Catholic Church, the wrote books against them calling then Christ killers , then Luther came across a scripture, and he read for the first time Romans 1:15 Salvation, belongs to the Jew first then to the gentiles and Salvation is by faith, not becoming , catholic nor religion for it is by grace, through faith, we are saved, it is a gift from God not of works so no one can boast. Eph 2:8-9. The rest is history. The Bible become available to everyone for the first time, and people read how much God love his people.. today there are people who are still saying that the Jews kill Christ. Jesus died for our salvation. We broke Gods law , the wages of sin is death But the gift of God is eternal life , Jesus pay the full debt for our sins. And all we have to do is to believe and obey his Word, the Word that became flesh . And he lived and walked this earth and died on the cross . That ball is in our court .That’s the criteria for Salvation. If Christ was murdered, then we have is no salvation ! because Jesus said , no one take my life I lay it down and I take it up again.John 10:18 No one can take my life from me. I sacrifice it voluntarily. For I have the authority to lay it down when I want to and also to take it up again. For this is what my Father has commanded.”

[@M.Đ-z4u]

BS

[@Yahya8.19]

Another traveler by the name of Felix Bovet reported the same desolation of the land of Israel. This is his report as written in an article from the Jerusalem Post: “Felix Bovet, a Christian theologian and professor of French Literature and Hebrew, visited the Holy Land in 1858 and wrote a book describing it (Egypt, Palestine and Phoenicia: A Visit to Sacred Lands, translated into English in 1882). Bovet’s descriptions mirror those of Clemens - a dreary desolate landscape that is sparsely inhabited. He notes that close to half of the population of Jerusalem is Jews, and that a majority of the Jews in Jerusalem are indigenous, that is, Turkish subjects. He concludes the Palestine section of the book stating that the Turks “have made a desert of it where it is scarcely possible to walk without fear. Even the Arabs who dwell there do so as temporary sojourners.”

[@AgentSmith353]

​@@amoyjoyce1117sorry but that's your version of events not muslims

[@therealfahadameen]

You didn’t mention that: - The 750000 displaced were because they were told by their Arab neighbors to get out till the Jews are eliminated. Unfortunately, they themselves were. - “Palestine” was a desolate wasteland. It is the Jews that reinvigorated it. The Arabs came to settle here both under British and Israeli rule. Even people from Gaza work in the millions in Israel … which was a terrible idea because now we know what happens when you try to pacify terrorists. Most of the land they talk about were actually SOLD. Arabs/Muslims are some pieces of work. Anyway, kudos 🇮🇱

[@DeniseOliveiraPorto]

👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

[@lorenzo6mm]

Exactly. Sell your land is what they did. Because they were told they would all be Killed in the war of MURDER ANY JEW ALL THE TIME ANYWHERE ORDERS FROM THE KORAN AND THE PROPHET. THE KORAN " Mein Kampf" But worse infact psychopathic. For any Jew anywhere.

[@andreandree4384]

Pretty true. Palestinians are troublemakers, wherever they go, chaos follows; Jordan, Lebanon as an example.

[@Shimamon27]

Arabs : "What a worthless piece of land, here buy it for a discount you filthy jew!" Jews: "Oh great! I see so much potential here, let's see what we can do with the swamps and deserts!" Arabs : "The hell??? The land is livable now? Get out filthy jew! it's mine!". Jews: Win against hordes of arabs. Arabs: Still covet the land and fabricate about the nation of "Palestine", forgetting the word is based on the Hebrew word meaning "Invaders".

[@greenleaf8226]

Wow! your so So brainwashed with Lies...ranting and raving the zionist agenda, good for them your a success story believing their Lies and promoting them... whatbarren waste land...O! you mean the built up Palestinian villages and farms, and the built up Palestinian cities and towns, all the schools, businesses ,airport, theatres, houses, apartment blocks etc...etc.. that are photographed and filmed for public viewing from pre before1948 Israel...the same Palestinian infastructure that was Stolen by Israelis... O yes! now i know what you speak of.

[@motigal7211]

The Palestinians have been educating their children in a systematic and institutionalized way for terrorism instead of peace, and this is the root of all the problems!

[@AvesPasseri-Jinysvet]

Yes, I noticed. I saw some youtube videos where both Palestinians and Israelis were asked questions (sent by viewers). These videos are even a few years old. Palestinians, young or older, made clear that THIS IS OUR LAND AND THEY STOLE IT FROM US, ISRAEL NEEDS TO GO. What would happen to the Israelis? Well, the answers were different here - some would send them back to the USA and Europe, because they believe they are from there. Some would be willing to live with them, but in a country called Palestine ruled by Palestinians according to their rules. One can imagine. They say, they used to live in peace during the Ottoman empire like this but they forget to mention what was the position of the Jewish communities there. To be fair, Israeli settlers in the West Bank do not see themselves leaving if it is the Palestinian state in the future and some were ready to fight. Well, that is the result of all those wars and pain.

[@markknowsbest7499]

​@AvesPasseri-Jinysvet yep... I saw those too.

[@dmf30]

Educate the youth ( incorrectly in this case you point out) and you control the future. Well said.

[@markknowsbest7499]

@@dmf30 so true

[@zk116]

It's almost as if when you blow up, bulldoze and invade people's land and homes generation after generation, it causes them to hate you even more. Can you really blame then at all? You have to be braindead to say that it's impossible you wouldn't be pushed to such a point after decades of oppression.

[@TruthSeekerAll]

It takes great courage to be this truthful and this honest in her views. Take my hat off to this young lady with this level of integrity. ❣

[@dianecourtney2724]

Why do you say she’s courageous ?

[@karjalasta]

It's a well structured propaganda, but still fails on the very basic things, anyone able to critically think will notice. Shame on the u""" bi"""

[@MusicismoreImportant]

​@@karjalasta cheese blintzes, dried fruit compote, knishes, pickled herring, pastrami and corned beef, sable, romanian tenderloin,silan, tzimmes, sufganiyot, passover sponge cake , kasha , Berengena frita 🇮🇱🇮🇱

[@karjalasta]

@@MusicismoreImportant ??

[@phoenixrising7623]

​@@dianecourtney2724 Because she's educating so call Geniuses like you

[@Celestian329]

I am a Filipino and I love Israel! ❤❤❤

[@P31B]

I appreciate that. Saw a video of violent pro Palestinian protests of the US embassy in Manila, I believe. Hope everybody stays safe. Love the Filipino people.

[@גלצופר]

we love you more from israel.

[@MMZS528]

What do you mean? Are you taking sides?

[@Anknow188]

@@MMZS528 yes

[@abbiena450]

In Israel, we love the Filipino people. They are so good and kind! We stand with you and thank you for your support!

[@matannagar]

I am Jewish. This video had me tearing. Finally someone who doesn't use every possible lie to counter attack us. Wishing peace for Palestinians. I hope they one day get to live a good life. If their lives are good, so will the lives of the Israelis.

[@azcalon4897]

Noble desires, but you must wake up, real world is wild, we are not in the positoon to try to be good and fair, europeans and arabs, arabs, not "palestinians" european and arabs want to anihi....lt us✡ once for all this is K or D We must become Zaelots

[@lopez-v3k]

they want you dead....wake up.....2 year old palis want all jews dead... it is propaganda for the qouran. Best part of the video, nobody under 40 in the world knows this basic fatcs...propaganda in schools and media for 50 years

[@kwhp1507]

I can never take anyone serious if they advocate for violence because some antique book that nobody knows the origins of tells them to.

[@josej-f2j]

@@azcalon4897 arabs nations just wants israel gone to the sea

[@azcalon4897]

@@kwhp1507 whit religion or not, we ✡ the hebreans, israelites, the sons of Zion are the owners of Eretz Zion Israel ✡ and a fatzlob boobed anglosaxon will and CANT deny this

[@ولیدماگومدوف]

I am Iranian national and proud of this girl. And the points she made🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷

[@shinwaramin8582]

then fight your fu*king government

[@KygoCalvinHarris-xu4kv]

She's British Iranian Kim Kardashian 😊

[@ولیدماگومدوف]

@@KygoCalvinHarris-xu4kv okay mate😁 whatever you say😁🍺😁

[@donhue4546]

@@KygoCalvinHarris-xu4kv shes like a skelenton,she needs to eat a few more dpoublr triple burgers

[@donhue4546]

@@ولیدماگومدوف ive seen hotter looking cam,els....sorry just quoting muhammad,oh wait he liked 6yr old kids,not camels

[@negativeionz]

This beautiful, intelligent woman is spitting pure facts. I wish more people were this well-informed.

[@satenu78]

@negativeionz Beautiful? Have you ever heard of live face filters?

[@JewlenskyBot-d6c]

And race traitor 😂

[@se2473]

Sad deluded reader. You need to consult proper academic reliable books rather than listen to this attractive ‘influencer’ parroting gibberish gobbledygook without basis and evidence

[@se2473]

@@satenu78 absolutely 👍 thank you 🙏

[@satenu78]

@@se2473 You're welcome. :)

[@MikeHunt-s9m]

Bless this Muslim woman, she has a heart. I feel for the Palestinian children just as much, and it’s a shame many children are taught the Jews are their enemy from young

[@homlesy1172]

the whole problem here is the Kiran and Muslim believers

[@eddiemonesti5671]

She is not Muslim, She is Persian.

[@manuelaffonso2191]

@@eddiemonesti5671 = No muslims in Persia ?? 🤔

[@eddiemonesti5671]

@@manuelaffonso2191 No. Original is Original.

[@UshaPatel-d9x]

She is a liar

[@kein2567]

As some who's Jewish ,it so great to finally see someone with logic on this platform

[@iloveamerica4891]

The issue is #Israel zionism nationalism and not the Jews. #Politics and #Religions create problems. What is Zionism ? a #political organization in 1897 under Theodor Herzl, and was later led by Chaim Weizmann for establishment of a Jewish #nation in what is now Israel. What is Naziism ? the common name in English for #National Socialist German Workers' party government of Germanic people.

[@alukuhito]

"it so great to finally someone"?

[@City1Tiger]

I don't see any logic

[@City1Tiger]

Israel is a apartheid state.

[@thirtythreeeyes8624]

@@City1Tiger You must be blind than because it was literally only logic and facts from her. Unlike so many people who have zero logic or facts but, for some reason also have the strongest opinions.

[@LoneWolf-tk9em]

The only country where Jews were never persecuted is INDIA 🇮🇳 because of Hindus, who are the majority in India, We gave them shelter & now there are some Jewish billionaires in India. Peaceful people never caused any riots or disturbances in our country. We Hindus stand with Israel 🇮🇱

[@salemmahdi7619]

I only like Indian food

[@amaranusa]

I think Philippines too

[@libagon2234]

🇵🇭 is waving😁

[@gedlauitstar2182]

and Albania!

[@jammin1881]

@@salemmahdi7619 You don't like Indian pop music videos? Shame on yooooou. 🤣

[@josem5681]

I am Jew who’s parents were Lebanese and where kicked out from Lebanon and confiscated all their belongings, my parents and family escape to Latin America with only what they were wearing. I currently have in my possession the titles of some properties in Beirut and damasco of my family real-estate back in time and they are worth nothing a not recognize. The government just took them (stolen).

[@MsBhappy]

My great grandparents land and business were seized by the Nazis in a forced sale far below market rate. Their possessions were also stolen. The land was in Germany and now it's Poland. We'll never get it back or get compensation but we look to the future more than the past. My great grandfather fought for Germany in WWI and yet they still persecuted and tried to kill him. He was made stateless. Another family member was the only Jew in their class in Germany and the teacher of phrenology (scientific racism) classes used them as an example (thankfully this teacher didn't actually believe in what he was teaching but he was forced to teach it). Other family members were amongst the first 5 train deportations of German Jews out of Germany that became the first massacres of German Jews by the Nazis in 1941. I am absolutely disgusted and terrified by the antisemitism, Holocaust denial/minimization and comparing Israelis to Nazis. These people have no idea even though millions of documents and photos exist. :(!

[@PhoenixL0vee]

I have similar story with my grandmother. Born and raised in Lebanon to a jewish family. Though they escaped to Israel.

[@agostocobain2729]

Don''t you guys hate Iranians? but then when one speaks like this oh she is "intelligent, aware, bright, beautiful" you guys are a joke!

[@MusicismoreImportant]

what else to add to this?? cheese blintzes, dried fruit compote, knishes, pickled herring, pastrami and corned beef, sable, romanian tenderloin,silan, tzimmes, sufganiyot, passover sponge cake , kasha , Berengena frita 🇮🇱🇮🇱

[@daniladanila3230]

No we don't. Persians are our friends, for the past 2500 years. We hate their regime, and even persians (iranians) suffer in that regime. ​@@agostocobain2729

[@GEOFERET]

I am neither Jewish, nor Muslim, but I believe that this lady has it just right. A very clear view for someone so young. Well done.

[@GaryAa56]

I totally agree. She states here case with logic not hatred.

[@Anglo_Saxon1]

And she's tidy which helps ❤

[@sneakyskillz2482]

1 million in Palestine before the migration not 500 thousand

[@fredfontane4191]

@@sneakyskillz24821 million what? Before which migration?

[@tuxuhds6955]

You believe so because you lack actual historical knowledge. The Arabs in Israel and what you call Palestine do not want a country, they want to immortalize their victimhood. They were offered a state time and again but somehow they couldn't accept it because us Jewish people were not dead enough for their palates: 1. Peel Commission of 1937 - Rejected. 2. White Paper of 1939 - Rejected. During WW2 - Hajj Amin al-Husseini which was the leader of the Muslims in Palestine was considered a criminal by GB and had evaded his arrest warrant just to help the German dictator to form a Waffen-SS unit of Muslims, so they can continue their genocide against Jewish people. By the way, I call them Arabs and not Palestinians because the funny fact is that the term Palestinians was reserved to the Jewish people whom, by Lord Balfour's Declaration(1917), were to be the designated population of the country. Also - It's a bit problematic to give a sovereign responsibility to a Sunni Salafi Muslims who'd play the hadith of trees and rocks out of their mosques(actively calling to our extermination). When the Arabs decide that life is a holy thing, when they respect the moral behind "The Binding of Isaac" and accept that children are not tools to be sacrificed - Then we might be able to talk like adults. Until then, they will have to learn the hard way how is it that the Jewish people have survived for so long. The choice is theirs alone.

[@unhappydutch]

Why did Egypt and Jordan, when both countries occupied Gaza and the West Bank between 1948 and 1967, not create a Palestinian state?

[@forouzanrahimi8987]

I think to create a state you must be recognised internationally not by 2 nations!

[@kfamily770]

Trans Jordan

[@anyazubova1518]

Because there was no such desire from the start. Arab leaders wanted to divide the land between 4 countries. Lebanon and Syria get the North, Jordan gets the center, Egypt gets the south. When they lost the war, Lebanon and Syria left with nothing basically, Jordan had West Bank, Egypt took Gaza. They were so humiliated by the defeat that the only thing they wanted was a revenge, so they just started to use those territories as bases for pressure on Israel. Jordan also expelled all the Jews living in West Bank, more than 100,000 if I'm not mistaken. They held Palestinians in deliberately bad conditions to influence the West, and boy, they succeeded in this. In 1964 in the first version of PLO charter it said that Palestine should be completely free and then united with Jordan. They changed it after 1967, probably because Jordan lost West Bank in the war and the agenda had to be changed.

[@Sneakyboson]

Because neither Jordan nor Egypt give a flying fuck about Palestine. Look up Black Saturday in Jordan - disgraceful.

[@ElaineGoldhammer-r5p]

The whole purpose of the Palestinians was on this hope by the surrounding Arab nations to one day eliminate Israel as a Jewish state. It says this in their charter.

[@nojiedirkksatrucker4259]

I am Filipino. My family and I stands for Israel. We love Israelis♥️♥️🇮🇱🇵🇭. Sending love from Kingdom Saudi Arabia.♥️♥️

[@mamudsoraju8930]

I wann to have philippinischen woman

[@nojiedirkksatrucker4259]

@@mamudsoraju8930 you can

[@turikazurikaz6730]

Are you Filipino living in Saudi Arabia? As far as Im aware, Saudi Arabia is quite mad at Israel atm.

[@Josh-iz5kb]

@@turikazurikaz6730 Riiiight....Or maybe Saudi Arabia is mad at palestinians, lets be honest, pretty much all of the arab nations dont like them, and for good reason, despite having common interests at a certain point. Do you people not realise that Israel and Saudi arabia were about to make a historic moment? Saudi arabia were about to be the first arab nation to officially recognise the jewish state. And wow what a surprise, Iran didnt like that idea, so told its Hamas dogs to start the attack

[@nojiedirkksatrucker4259]

@@turikazurikaz6730 you said that not Saudi, that's your story and carry on

[@AmethystEyes]

I took a Middle East history class years ago and was horrified to see that none of these points were brought up. The teacher had an agenda. I wish I could go back in time and show her and the class this video.

[@sunnymitra6372]

Your Teacher was a Marxist hater

[@asrafamani5028]

Everyone has agenda begins with yourself

[@Universe3-e7r]

@@asrafamani5028 your agenda is based on lies

[@sarausage]

@@asrafamani5028 if the agenda is a fact then its not a agenda the way tot find out is to look at history books the ones that arent woke like this woman sorry but what is palestine it never existed Arabs never existed at the time

[@Immi3009]

I had Dutch history class, even here they said that those Zionists are just few in number among the Arabs. The Iraqi Zionist in the video has forgotten that the Jews had to fight in the British army just like the Muslims. I’m a Moroccan and did you know Morocco had a lot of Jews and still has? Did you know that the Jews that were in Morocco fled from the Iberian peninsula to not be persecuted by Castille for example?

[@steelcrown7130]

She is absolutely correct, but left out a - well, not amusing, but heavily ironic fact: at 1:26 she mentions that the Israelites had lived on the land for millennia, until the Muslim Conquest in the 7th Century, when the land was Arabised and Islamised. The fact she left out was that EXACTLY THE SAME TIME, her own people, the Iranian peoples, principally the Persians, were "colonised" in exactly the same way. The Buddhists in what is now Afghanistan also had a particularly rough time of it. The late 7th C was a pretty awful time for anybody who got in the way of the conquering Muslims.

[@DeniseOliveiraPorto]

👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

[@burden_of_knowing]

she is not accurate historically.

[@ali-rikabrands8637]

This is about Israel and why they remigrated to Israel. It was indeed an awful time. And if the west continue like this, history will repeat itself.

[@pietergangel]

​@@burden_of_knowing For a 6 minute KZbin clip it is a very good attempt imho. But please, explain.

[@osmanghazibaburhan8880]

Nonsense claim.

[@DrStrangeLemon]

You're a shining example of what critical thinking in a free society looks like. If you dared to express these thoughts in some countries you'd be stoned to death or worse. And in other countries, you'd be crushed by political correctness and media bias. We all need level-headed, informed people like you instead of the violent mobs to take control of this hate-inspired madness.

[@AKu-xs5vg]

Not really. If she were actually a critical thinker, she would question why it is that anyone in Palestine is expected to give up land when Europeans own more than 50% of the planet's green land despite making up only 13% of the population. Carving out a new state for Jews: should it be done in the European world, (a massive multicontinental planetary empire which encompasses North America, South America, Europe, Siberia, Australia, New Zealand) Or should it be done in the blazing white desert of the Middle East, whose total fertile land area is smaller than the state of Maine? Also: Why weren't Jews expelled from India and China? They had Jews just like in Europe, so what happened? Is it possible that certain races are just less selfish, and more capable of getting along? Why are there so few race riots in Singapore, despite it being one of the MOST RACIALLY DIVERSE cities on the planet (a mix of Malays, Tamils, and Cantonese)? Also by her logic, the conquistadors were not colonists, because 90% of their crew was North African people from the Canary Islands, exiled from it by Spain. Ashkenazi and Russian Jews are also "white" by the way, both looks-wise and genetically, and make up 45% of Israel's population. To rebut the guy at 1:00 They also sterilize Ethiopian Jewish women, so yeah they're pretty racist

[@AKu-xs5vg]

BTW I'm not even anti-Israel I'm just pro-reality, and the girl (and people supporting her) are anti-reality--either lying or too ignorant to grasp the whole truth, it doesn't matter There is only one moral position, and that is the position of global human equality, which is so radical that it would eliminate things like money and ownership, and necessitate a birth limit system, and require a complicated system of checks and balances to ensure that leaders do not abuse their power, among other things. The only other position is the default immoral selfishness of human history, and Israel has committed no crime here that non-Jewish Europeans have not also committed 100,000,000-fold.

[@Jake60k]

You must not have listed to anything she said in the video.@@AKu-xs5vg

[@zeroscorpion9543]

​@@AKu-xs5vgalso to add to ur point she said according to muslim account the land it was either for the Jews or used to live in it which in islam and JUDAISM agree the land was for Canaanite and they expel them out of their land by her logic if the descendents of Canaanites go and start killing jews in israel that would be ok

[@VinnieG-]

I think you mean the "shining" literal don't you 🤣

[@ThreeAngels825]

This girl has spoken rightly ,well done 👍👍

[@darrenwilliams2921]

My girlfriend is from Iran and she has the same views as this young lady , she is very intelligent and there are many more like her which is so nice to see and hear .

[@GalathNox]

Not surprising. Virtually every time I've heard someone discuss an Iranian woman they've always mentioned their intelligence, insightfulness, and hearts. It's a shame that country (and most Arab nations) don't allow their women to hold offices/positions of power. Many, if not all, of their internal and global issues could be fixed.

[@TPOL123ISBACKAGAIN]

No surprise a Majus doing Haram thing.

[@phoenixrising7623]

​​@@TPOL123ISBACKAGAIN You know I hate those words Haram and halal

[@TPOL123ISBACKAGAIN]

@@phoenixrising7623 Okay and? No one asked for your opinion.

[@phoenixrising7623]

@@TPOL123ISBACKAGAIN And no one ask for yours either

[@aashusingh6950]

Love and support for Israel from India.

[@GutoSantana]

Stop, zionist supremacist supporter. The facade is over.

[@ddg0907]

Praying for all Muslims in India🤲

[@osh2023]

Some people think that smashing a baby's head with a shovel and strutting around town with a broken half naked body of a young women you just raped is a sign of heroism. A disease called "pro-Palestinian" and it is only relevant when talking about Jews (nobody cares about the rapes in Syria/Jordan/Lebanon) -- they've had their chances to make a viable peace and reach independence, but they much rather chant about wiping the only Jewish state off the map and playing the victim card when it doesn't work according to plan.

[@Titas20059]

Muslims should go to Islamic country. If we are so bad then don't live in our country. There are 50+ Islamic country, they divided India in the base of religion and made Pakistan, Bangladesh. They should leave our country and live in the country which was made for them. Take your Muslims our of your country and give shelter to them. Only Muslims can tolerate another Muslim.

[@ashwinvk4124]

​@@ddg0907most muslims in India are safe and sound

[@whiskeytango9769]

The Palestinian Arabs have acted like pirates for the past 75 years. The only solution is for them to leave for another Arab country, or live peacefully within Israel. That Israel should also include Gaza and the West Bank. One state, Israel.

[@ramsongewargis8736]

Same too you, gotta move far away

[@byip2415]

You are soooo correct! Thank you, thank you, thank you!

[@Rabbithole8]

Gaza should become part of Egypt and the West Bank should become part of Jordan.

[@vidutepi2843]

Nor Egypt nor Jordan accepted Palestinians refugees 😂

[@Rabbithole8]

@@vidutepi2843 Yes, however, Jordan would like the land and Egypt might be cajoled into taking Gaza. The issue for them would be having to deal with the Palestinian population that would still insist that Israel should be theirs.

[@deborahherman9511]

Thank you souch for your guts, and fact based evidence and for supporting Israel and the Jews. So deeply grateful 🙏❣️

[@palepride7530]

Are we sure she is female… 🤡

[@laurakushner5383]

​@@palepride7530She is very educated and smart and knows history. Imasing

[@tuxuhds6955]

It's a funny world we live in that when someone mention half truths they deserve praises. It's a bit problematic to give a sovereign responsibility to a Sunni Salafi Muslims who'd play the hadith of trees and rocks out of their mosques(actively calling to our extermination). When the Arabs decide that life is a holy thing, when they respect the moral behind "The Binding of Isaac" and accept that children are not tools to be sacrificed - Then we might be able to talk like adults. Until then, they will have to learn the hard way how is it that the Jewish people have survived for so long. The choice is theirs alone.

[@frohnatur9806]

Very gutsy, spreading pro-Israel messages in the language of the west, which is dominated by that same rethoric

[@zdigk8]

THEY WERENG ETHNICALLY CLEANSED OUT OF THOSE COUNTRIES LOOOL THEY ALL LEFT TO GO AND SETTLE IN ISRAEL because the government were selling them dreams there what were too good to decline! thats why they all left those countries! because they wanted to go and settle in Palestine "israel" and have free homes etc!!!!

[@josephbouganmim4108]

I’m from Morocco and you absolutely right I left in 1975. We were second class citizens. They didn’t have to kill you. That’s enough that they scared you to leave.

[@AhavaMath]

There were mob attacks in the 50s, though, right?

[@stanjames9920]

I'm South African and stand solidly with Israel 🇮🇱🇿🇦🇮🇱✝️

[@mediaisthevirus]

Nice star of remphan

[@feidhlimidhmacanaltha3644]

Of course you do.

[@Grace-jf3rs]

Please show this video to Julius Malema because he has total control of the mind of most South Africans. If he hates Israel then they all do.

[@MAH-id3sx]

Obviously. You smaak apartheid

[@Atl0siy]

MANDELA AND YOUR GRANDPARENTS MUST BE PROUD OF YOU FOR STANDING WITH OCCUPATION AND APARTHEID🩸

[@Gideon01]

As an Israeli, I have to say that it's not all entirely accurate, but it is, nevertheless, one of the most fair-minded and informative summaries of the conflict that I have come across on the web in a very long time, by far. This young woman has done her research. I also appreciate the fact that she has kept "God" out of it.

[@alex324ization]

Yes few small inacuracies but agree with the main them.

[@per_se_phone]

I just wish this channel would stop assuming she's muslim just because she's Iranian. Many of us are not muslim

[@jasperchance3382]

​@@per_se_phoneit's in the title of the video.

[@jonathanbuzzard1376]

I suspect being 100% accurate in all respects on this subject is next to impossible. Is it largely correct and neutral I would say so. All Israel has ever asked for is to share the land and live in peace. The Arabs seem to be hell-bent on wiping the Israelis off the face of the earth but are doing a piss poor job of it and suffering as a result.

[@sogracie3420]

Actually many Iranians were Jews, the survivors are now Israeli citizens @@per_se_phone

[@basicstype994]

This is what intelligence looks like, advocating for human beings, not ideologies. This young lady is very educated and intelligent, she does not omit historical facts to spread such dangerous thoughts and ideas. The both sides deserve to live in peace!

[@zdigk8]

THEY WERENG ETHNICALLY CLEANSED OUT OF THOSE COUNTRIES LOOOL THEY ALL LEFT TO GO AND SETTLE IN ISRAEL because the government were selling them dreams there what were too good to decline! thats why they all left those countries! because they wanted to go and settle in Palestine "israel" and have free homes etc!!!!

[@iamLODD]

Not really a critical thinker nor is she "right". If she were actually a critical thinker, she would question why it is that anyone in Palestine is expected to give up land when Europeans own more than 50% of the planet's green land despite making up only 13% of the population. Carving out a new state for Jews: should it be done in the European world, (a massive multicontinental planetary empire which encompasses North America, South America, Europe, Siberia, Australia, New Zealand) Or should it be done in the blazing white desert of the Middle East, whose total fertile land area is smaller than the state of Maine? Also: Why weren't Jews expelled from India and China? They had Jews just like in Europe, so what happened? Is it possible that certain races are just less selfish, and more capable of getting along? Why are there so few race riots in Singapore, despite it being one of the MOST RACIALLY DIVERSE cities on the planet (a mix of Malays, Tamils, and Cantonese)? Also by her logic, the conquistadors were not colonists, because 90% of their crew was North African people from the Canary Islands, exiled from it by Spain. Ashkenazi and Russian Jews are also "white" by the way, both looks-wise and genetically, and make up 45% of Israel's population. They also sterilize Ethiopian Jewish women, so yeah they're pretty racist

[@LizRealGirlBeauty]

​@@iamLODDyour comment is massively misleading, as what we call "the middle east," including Israel, is part of the continet of Asia, meaning that counts toward Asian population. Second, ARE YOU ACTUALLY SAYING THAT CHINA IS *KIND* TO ETHNIC MINORITIES?! That is 100% the most ridiculous thing I've read in the intent all month! The country that enslaves and STERLIZES ethnic minorities is KIND in your mind?! Who's your dealer because that's some good stuff you're smoking! And for the record, 3000 Jews live in China and 4500 live in India. They are not flourishing populations in those countries, considering the total population of China and India is 1.4 BILLION each. So, where are you getting your information?

[@AE-alaa]

@@iamLODD What the actual fuck are you talking about apparently you didn't get anything from this video. you are not taking into account that the land of palestine was were jews had a place they called home why would you bring up india.. and secondly you are talking as if literally you didn't just watched a video that said the jews were driven out of euorpe lmao.

[@gudetamaminiso513]

@@iamLODD I agree with you about the impossbility to carve a new jewish state in the middle east. But there's no question of less selfish culture. Chinese has fought all the monotheism on its territory through a strict control of their spread and forced mix-weddings at some point. The same for Singapore which is in pratice governed by chinese people and I remember hearing Lee Kuan Yew sharing his concerns about religious values being made law at the expense of other communities. Those countries are doing well witb monotheism ... because... they fight them.

[@joelthorstensson2772]

Keep in absolute mind that when she mentions 1917 being the year of the first Palestinian passport (05:37), what she means (but perhaps forgot to mention) is that it was the first _British_ Palestinian passport. Palestine at that time was just the name for the area, and so when the Brits got mandate for the area as part of the League of Nations, they named it.... British Mandate for Palestine. The official languages were English (new kid on the block thinking he's hot stuff), Hebrew (the.. frozen sperm-bank baby-son of Biblical Hebrew?), and Arabic (specifically Levantine Arabic).

[@AhavaMath]

The British also had currency while they were in control, which had the letters for Eretz Yisrael (land of Israel) on them, and the West Bank under the British Mandate was called by it's Jewish historical name: Judea and Samaria.

[@karami8844]

Imagine how much better off Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank would be today if they just made peace with Israel without making anymore threats of bombing them or having terrorist groups attacking them?

[@Jestersson]

Blame religion it prevents peace.

[@PAUL25926]

Imagine if they would have spent the money improving the place instead of spending it on 300 miles of underground tunnels 🤔

[@sherryjohnson3804]

I know! That's what it's so sad about it

[@Fuzzywuzzywasawoman]

@@PAUL25926yeah it’s a complete dump and no one seems to care sitting around in the mess all day.

[@puraLusa]

Imagine if the arabized states had some self-criticism and aknowlege their nazi problem (who was spread disguized as religion) like peeps do in europe.

[@halimah.s6012]

I wish more people were as informed and intelligent as this brilliant woman. She said it better than anyone. As a Muslim woman, I'm absolutely disgusted and ashamed by the Muslim's community's reaction. They will never admit facts, they can't stand anything that goes against their close-minded ideologies. It's honestly so embarrasing and shameful. I hope that one day there will be peace in this region. #peace

[@C.I366]

I hope one day will be peace too. Do you live in Israel? Can you justify the genoside, is this peace dealings for you?

[@razalihusain]

Do you support genicide?

[@halimah.s6012]

​@razalihusain Of course not but there is more to it than just "genocide". It isn't as simple as that.

[@halimah.s6012]

​@@C.I366No, I don't live in Israel. And no, I don't support genocide. It isn't one way or the other. It isn't black and white. It's more complicated than most people will ever admit.

[@Akli12]

​​​@@razalihusain500,000 peoples are killed by islamists like you in Nigeria.

[@Seevawonderloaf]

As a Hindu I’m proud to say india is the only place Jews were not persecuted. Thank you for your video - the left wing erasure is disturbing AF

[@elizabethelias1005]

China as well.

[@mpg19844u]

What about Christians?

[@VSM101]

@@mpg19844u What about them they came the clonised they converted some of us and left when they took everthing we had.

[@naughtyfred1639]

I can see this lady and myself disagreeing on a lot of major issues and NOT getting angry about it.🙏❤

[@blackenedblue5401]

Albania as well; many hid there and the Muslims protected them and changed their names so that the Nazis wouldn't find them when they occupied Albania in 1943-44

[@sydney_theNox]

Thank you. I’m a Jew. I am also an Anthropologist and Historian. You got everything spot on. Our history goes even further. In 79 A.D., the Jewish people living in the area were kicked out again by either fear of persecution or they were forced into the Christian faith to survive. We were scattered throughout the world, and dispersed even more because of the events of WWII. Long before the nation of Israel existed, the people had a longing to return to our ancestral homeland. This is what’s known as “The Jewish Diaspora.” So, once we had a place to call our own, one where we are safe to exist and govern, the people rejoiced. That day in 1948, there were celebrations, dancing in the streets. As it was, we were essentially finally free from thousands of years. Going to the name of Palestine, the land was originally called Canaan by the people, or Judea by the Romans and Greeks. When Emperor Hadrian came to power, he renamed the land to “Philistia.” The Phillistine people were an ancient peoples that were known to be the enemies to the Indigenous people of Canaan, (Israelites). Naturally, the Israelites feared the Phillistines. And Hadrian knew this. So when he named the land “Philistia” it was a sign of power to rule over the Israelites. It was a fear tactic, and a big middle finger to the people. As language goes, the name was evolved to the name of “Palestine.” Sorry this is a lot. I believe the state of Israel has the inherent right to exist. And I also believe the innocent people of Gaza need to be freed from their government. Realistically, I don’t believe there can be a two state solution. It has been attempted for decades after “the war of independence.” But the surrounding countries of the region cannot stand the idea of a “Jewish State.” So, at the end of the day, it boils down to people still having a problem for the Jewish people. That being said: thank you for your video. It really makes me happy that someone can see both sides, and also not want us to be wiped out.

[@hanslaurentius4618]

WOOOOOOOOW, lady that was a speech of Fire and Ice ! Since I have grown up in Iran and my Brother was born in Tehran I appreciate your speech even more ! It's a good sign to see in our time poisoned by narcotics and not only people speak out and defend the truth and not belonging to a bunch of NUTCRACKERS around the world protesting without even knowing what's the truth . You really made my day , beautiful, love you, ❤️ good luck..

[@SammyRo-bm4bw]

Fr.

[@SammyRo-bm4bw]

Man speaks truth

[@ebadurrahman7848]

what truth that is Israel is innocent little baby victim? Lol!

[@tsubadaikhan6332]

The young lady is mostly correct. A couple of things though. In 1947 The United Nations partitioned Palestine into 55% a State called Israel for the Jewish Peoples, and 45% of the land for the indigenous Palestinians, when the population split was actually about 80% Indigenous Palestinian, and 20% Jewish. Hardline Jewish Militias then said that was fantastic, and started forcing up to 750,000 Palestinians off land they’d occupied for generations. This is what they call the Nakba. If they forced 750,000 to move the population must have been over a million at that point. It started as, and was briefly, a Civil War, then all the surrounding Arab Nations sent their Armies to take control, and it became the First Arab-Israeli War, which - while Israel is regarded as winning, - it is notable that Jordan ignored the UN borders afterwards, and retained occupation of the area known now as the West Bank. So Israeli occupation is not the only occupation those in the West Bank have known. Then in 1967 another War broke out between Israel and its neighbours, the Six Day War. At the end of that War, Israel had pushed Syria from the Golon Heights, Egypt from the Sinai, and Jordan out of the West Bank, increasing its size by a factor of 4. Israel then occupied these lands until the 1993 Oslo Accords. 12 years after Oslo, in 2005, Israel withdrew its Settlers from Gaza. In 2006, Hamas was voted in to power in Gaza. Hamas’ major opposition was Fatah, (the Palestinian Authority), who were widely seen as corrupt and West Bank focussed, by the Gazan population. There were other Parties, so Hamas won power with 46% of the Vote giving them 65% of the Seats in Parliament. Both Parties in this conflict have been poorly treated, and both sides have extremists. This young lady is very correct, and I don’t know the solution either. But, somehow, 9 million Israelis have to learn to share the land with 6 million Palestinians. The hatred for one another has got to go. And, after Ukraine, and learning what a HIMARS can do, it makes the area too small for two separate Countries. Maybe multiple, viable, ethnic States within one Country?

[@gothicyid]

​@@tsubadaikhan6332you forgot the part where 1 the Arab states did not intend to give Palestinians their own state but to grab land from Israel and 2 they convinced many arabs to leave their land to go fight, many more than Israel told to leave". That's why many arabs are israeli today while the rest are refugees. And while Jordan held the west Bank and egypt held Gaza there was no talk of Palestinian states there. Likewise, Jordan threw all the jews out of the west Bank when they owned it and destroyed the synagogues. But you're still wrong about one more thing. Because it wasn't about the proportion of land they got in 1948 but the Palestinian part was much more fertile while Israel got mostly desert.

[@jamesgriffith4]

Thank you for a fair and even handed advocacy for both Palestinians and Israelis.

[@DerekEno-e1k]

I know the Kurdish situation may be different from most, but I yet wonder why they, too, have no homeland.

[@actionc8453]

"Borh Palestinians and Israelis"?? Palestinians are Israelis, the romans renamed Israel as that.

[@actionc8453]

@@PAPSN Right, thanks.

[@ebadurrahman7848]

​@@actionc8453 not true at all philistin existed alongside the kingdom of judia.

[@ebadurrahman7848]

​@@PAPSN how come philistin existed alongside the kingdom of Judia?

[@jonrend]

Well said, intelligent young lady. Unfortunately, education (the good type) and history are going to the wall in the West. Thanks for a factual history and human lesson.

[@daniel.d2150]

AMEN!

[@AC-mp7cx]

a liar

[@screwsloose8631]

Whose version of history?

[@canmandan6]

What she said were half truths bs

[@khankrumV]

​@@canmandan6Only if count the palestinian lies as the other half...

[@iditbarmats]

אני מישראל, הקשבתי להסברים שלך ואת מדהימה !!! תודה רבה לך יקרה , על היושר שלך, על אומץ ליבך, על האמת שבך !!! שולחת לך אהבה מישראל ❤❤❤❤

[@mizobvious3753]

Why were they kicked out of everywhere, there has to be a reason.

[@PhoenixL0vee]

@@mizobvious3753 The reason is simple - good old antisemitism. Antisemitism is of the oldest form of racism that exists today. There are so many blood libels, so much hate and yes also envy and jealousy. The jews always stood right back up after being knocked down and we did it graciously. We contributed to the world many folds compared to our relativity in the world's population. We are considered both sub-human and the rulers of the world by our haters. We are the scapegoat of the world as we were for about 2000 years, being homeless and minority in every country we lived in until Israel. Think about being part of a minority group for 2000 years. You accumulate so many way people can be racist toward you.

[@carstenf279]

I am impressed. Not because she is muslim or Iranian. But because she got so many things right at such a young age. I am 58 living in Western Europe - and people here who are at her age following the conflict have NO idea what the facts are, and they are way too lazy to find out. Her info is very precise and whether you like her message or not you cannot argue against it - she did her due diligence and actually stuided the facts. Her father can be proud!

[@Mokh7777]

This page shouldn't have put that she's muslim. Most of us Iranians aren't muslim and she never said she was either. In fact she's been a great voice for us against the Islamic regime

[@ghosthunter0950]

@@Mokh7777 Thank you for the clarification. Love to our Iranian brothers. as an Israeli secular Arab from a Christian family , I support both Israel and Iranians.

[@Mokh7777]

@@ghosthunter0950 thank you! This means a lot to us. Yes Arab Christians have been great support for us! We wish you the best as well! And hopefully Iran will be a secular democracy soon too! 🙏

[@ElizaDolittle]

@@Mokh7777 I heard that the Christian population has grown considerably in Iran in the last decade or so. I hear that there are close to 1 million Christians. Is this true?

[@jazminb1000]

Trust me, more than 80% of us Iranians don’t identify ourselves with Islam. Not only that we we don’t believe it, but hate it too for being barbaric

[@Negs42]

I'm a Jewish boy, still a minor and voices such as yours give me hope that there are still people who care about us and those who are sensible Toda Rav! For everything you're doing and Bz'H we'll overcome this✊🏻

[@MH-tn3pp]

There are people all around the world that care about Israeli. The only concern is the settlements in Cisjordan, as Palestinians need a place to live too. In Europe, and in the West in general, we consider that Israel should be given back to Jews, and the Arabs that colonized Israel should return to Arabic countries, like Jews returned to Israel. Africa and Asia are so huge, that they don’t need to sit on the head of small Israel. Gaza should be given to Israel because they can’t be condemned to endure the presence of ultra violent enclava inside of their country. It’s inhumane, insane… Azeris expelled poor Armenians from their ancestral land and no one protests. Population of Gaza should leave Israel now, so the peace can be finally achieved. Amen 🙏

[@smsquared73]

Your comment broke my heart!! There are millions that care about you I promise!! Unfortunately, in the US anyway, our media is painfully skewed and basically full of crap. They only tell one side of a story and that is even manipulated and fun of lies! You should not have to feel like this and those that have caused it should be ashamed of themselves. Hold your head high kid and be proud of who you are. Be a good person and don't listen to these people ok. I will keep you in my prayers! 🥰

[@sharongreenberg459]

The voice you present is the voice of a poor little Jewish exile from the middle of World War II. We don't need this whining, the Jews today have a strong state and we don't need a spokeswoman to remind us that it is forbidden to call the murder of Jews but yes to call Free Palestine which is actually pretty much the same thing. Raise your head and be a proud and strong Jew just like the partisans 80 years ago or the Israeli soldiers fighting on the borders of the Land of Israel today!

[@akashchandrabehera7667]

We Indians are with you brother. 🇮🇳❤️🇮🇱

[@THE.NEW.AMERICA]

Oh NO, they are Semet1c, dont call them white,, it is against your religion ,& it calls "all Gentiles animals in human form created to serve the Jew day & night." Here is your Talmud/Jewish encyclopedia-- "The goy1m is essentially an animal in human form, & condemned to serve the J'w day & night.(Midrasch Talpiothp-225-L)

[@benjaminjoel5108]

Wow..what a presenter. This young woman is well-educated and well-spoken

[@gmw3083]

A Muslim Iranian, speaking perfect British English. Straight out of Babylondons propwash academy

[@CalculusBridge]

​@@gmw3083No hijab too.

[@vron928]

@@gmw3083 a part from accent was she untruthful?

[@gmw3083]

@@vron928 This is a propwash outlet. Everything is untruthful....

[@iamLODD]

Not really a critical thinker nor is she "right". If she were actually a critical thinker, she would question why it is that anyone in Palestine is expected to give up land when Europeans own more than 50% of the planet's green land despite making up only 13% of the population. Carving out a new state for Jews: should it be done in the European world, (a massive multicontinental planetary empire which encompasses North America, South America, Europe, Siberia, Australia, New Zealand) Or should it be done in the blazing white desert of the Middle East, whose total fertile land area is smaller than the state of Maine? Also: Why weren't Jews expelled from India and China? They had Jews just like in Europe, so what happened? Is it possible that certain races are just less selfish, and more capable of getting along? Why are there so few race riots in Singapore, despite it being one of the MOST RACIALLY DIVERSE cities on the planet (a mix of Malays, Tamils, and Cantonese)? Also by her logic, the conquistadors were not colonists, because 90% of their crew was North African people from the Canary Islands, exiled from it by Spain. Ashkenazi and Russian Jews are also "white" by the way, both looks-wise and genetically, and make up 45% of Israel's population. They also sterilize Ethiopian Jewish women, so yeah they're pretty racist

[@mikedavidson9852]

An Iranian Muslim makes me happy, she gives me hope for future generations, lets make our differences something to enjoy.

[@BamaSquirrel]

Everyone in Iran were forced to say they are Muslims when Islamic republic invaded Iran in 1979 🤷🏼‍♀️ lovely Islamic crap thinking that whole world is suppose to be conquered and submit to only Islam and be Muslim 🙄

[@mahaalabduljalil6596]

Are you sure you are a Muslim? Watching the ethnic cleansing and brutal killing of Muslim children in Palestine and stand with Isreal.. I doubt it.

[@Pink-Floyd2000]

She’s not Muslim

[@anabellarivas822]

Yes she is! Do you feel burning.....

[@Pink-Floyd2000]

@@anabellarivas822 No she is not, no burning, just laughing at the con artists

[@robertpearce4316]

Great post. People need to ask why arab country will not take in Palestinians any more. This is a major reason they are not putting pressure on Israel these days. They dnt want Palestinians refugees

[@andreandree4384]

Very true. Wherever Palestinians go, chaos follows. 😂

[@markknowsbest7499]

Exactly

[@kevincourtney7312]

They want to spread Islam and hold onto all conquered lands. They will never give up lands once they control them but they will be happy to relocate some of their hoard to western countries. They have 10 children and more while the infidel has 1 or 2.

[@PortugalZeroworldcup]

Will Arab countries take in anyone other than arabs??

[@TheMRkhalid123]

Are you that brainless not to understand why the arab countries will not take Palestinians in.

[@Magani79]

She knows the history better than the average Israeli, great video

[@briarpatchson3039]

PROBLEM is that THERE was never a time when JEWS wasn't in ISRAEL.

[@a.m204]

Not really

[@cookieMonsterSincho]

Yes there is. There always have been a jewish commuinities maybe not lage, but there were, read about "Mark Twain in Palestine" he visited the holy land in the 19 century, there are evedance even from there. @@a.m204

[@thetruegame2383]

לגמרי

[@peace-now]

She knows a lot more than me, for sure.

[@alexandrepereira3902]

May I respectfully admire this young lady… God bless her…

[@Justaguy11199]

Right on👊 Finally another person on the short list of people who actually come with facts instead of shouting for genocide or denying everything overwhelmed by emotions. Hats off to this woman.

[@happydays4302]

She didn't say it wasn't genocide, she was making a case for Israel to exsit. It absolutely is grnocide... just listen to what the leaders of Israel are saying. They literally telling us starting back in oct when the defence minster said they were stopping food and water. If stop food and water there is only one result... death. It was a method the nazis used on Jews, you might have seen the horrific pictures of Jews starving in WW2. We need food and water to survive. If you take that away you are trying to kill the person, of in Israel's case you are trying to starve 2 million Palestinians including 1 MILLION CHILDREN TO DEATH.

[@lechiarsanukaev1459]

AM ISRAEL 🇮🇱 CHAI 💙🇮🇱💙LONG LIVE OUR PEOPLE 💙

[@olena8398]

‏אמן

[@lechiarsanukaev1459]

Appreciate you 🌹

[@elspethg7497]

Unfortunately it won’t be that long

[@mondobondo49]

This woman is very intelligent. Breath of fresh air.

[@alichehabi7751]

The so called ethnic cleaning in the Middle East happened as a reaction to Zionism and the nakba. With the exception of Almohad caliphate, Jews had their golden age under Muslims. I swear the Iranian diaspora is exhausting! I get that the revolution really left a bad taste in your mouth, but good god, don’t forsake EVERYTHING because of it.

[@milli690]

Thank you dear! I’m half jewish, half uzbekian, living in Israel for 10 years. I’m a doctor in big medical center in central Israel. I have a lot of friends arabs and some of them are from Palestine, I’m treating children from Palestine. And this situation is horrible. Horrible that after our people were tortured on 7th of October, the world is blaming us… it’s horrific situation!! Thank you for your support! Thank you for sharing the truth!! I hope one day a world will be a better place, and then you’re more than welcome to visit us in Israel! Take care of yourself and be healthy!

[@MindelM]

Doctor thank you for the work you do in Isreal. Please also thank all of the people who in your hospital from me. I hope that one day Israelis and the people from Gaza and the west bank can live together

[@faithkerubo8357]

The world is blaming Israel because Israel is being seen as giving Palestinians a motive to join hamas because of the conditions in gaza and all the raids and illegal settlement in the west bank.

[@faithkerubo8357]

My country and many others have been fighting a terrorist group called Al-shabaab for 12 years.At first,I simply thought of them as the bad guys.Then,I found out my country had a war called shifta war with Somalia and because kenyan somalis were supporting Somalia in the war(they wanted to be part of Somalia along with other Somalis),our governments decided to discriminate against them in terms of infrastructure,aid and the army was always sent there to keep a watch on them so they were always seen as less than the rest of us.I then understood why some were easily indoctrinated into Al-shabaab...mind you,the media had never talked about this.

[@faithkerubo8357]

Plus some still see bantus as intruders.Bantus immigrated into east and south africa about 3000-6000 years ago,absorbing natives and displacing many.Cushites and nilotes are native however to east africa.Cushites have recessive genes.Many kenyan bantus also have recessive genes despite west and Central Africans not having Them,implying we actually settled on cushitic territory,absorbed others,displaced others.Technically,it's historically their land but in the modern world,it's ours.Also,today,it's illegal to displace us or kill us though our ancestors did that to theirs

[@faithkerubo8357]

Apply that to the conflict,no other large group would be allowed to go back to their ancestral land.That would require too many groups to move so it's seen as a double standard that Israel was allowed.Second,today if Jewish people are challenged,the words:antisemitism and holocaust denier are brought out of nowhere.That is wrong because semite is more about belonging to a linguistic group that includes Arabic so Arabs are also semites plus Belgians brought more deaths than Germans.Hitler was responsible for the death of 4-6M Jews while King leopold II of Belgium was responsible for the deaths of 10-15M Congolese people but is relatively unknown and the Congolese never bring it up.Also,the last problem is most people in Israel are there because of religion and not ancestry.African,East Asian,South East Asian and European Jews are not native to the middle east but there's too many European looking Jews claiming they are native,which adaption to your environment would deny.Finally,attitudes by some people who identify as Jewish go like...Palestinians are responsible for the actions of hamas coz it's their government...all while ignoring that the Israeli government has also been bombing gaza over the years and many Palestinians find themselves in Israeli prisons without a proper hearing.Plus hospitals and refugee camps were bombed,Palestinian journalists covering the war have also been repeatedly targeted.Civilians were told to move to certain areas and after moving to the areas,still got bombed.If we said Israeli citizens are responsible for their government's actions,that would justly be a tit for tat requiring more attacks from hamas.

[@danielbuxton4493]

What a brave soul - I have nothing but admiration for this young lady, speaking the truth. God bless her x

[@argol21]

You are a voice of light and reason in a very dark environment. Very well presented. Thank you.

[@jedlogin3982]

I love your comments and I love this video and the way it was presented!

[@therichieboy]

As one of those moderate Israelis you never hear about, I'd say this wonderful woman speaks for so many of us. Thank you and peace!

[@johnpolitis7929]

@therichieboy Zionism is morally bankrupt. From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free.

[@tigress1girl]

She still claim to support Palestinians and also not explaining how to do so or what is Israel responsibility in this which is exactly how all the misinformation propaganda starts to begin with, so most of us Israelis would have to disagree with her views, even if most of the facts she says are shared in agreement. Here are some important inaccuracies in the video: 1. Indigenous: Just because Jewish and Arab people were intermixing doesn't grant Arabs indigenous title as a fact, especially since the vast majority of Jews were forced to convert to christianity and islam under threat of death or exile. To re-inforce what I mean here, if all Jewish people would've been ethnically cleansed or converted, you wouldn't say that the Arabs in the area have a right to the land because 'the jewish people' but because of 'the Arab' who where in the land and state a (much-much later) date. 2. Willingness vs Hate: The Jewish people leaders set through many two-state-solution plans and accepted them, not only before being a state but also after. Gaza could've been a state as well with 80% of the land - yet still chose NOT to be one, why? because "from the river to the sea" - ethnic cleansing. Hamas is a terror organization that was elected democratically, by who? the people in Gaza. Important information that should be noted is: 1. Apartheid: Israel is the only democratic state in the entire Middle East - where all of us, jews muslims christians druze can live as equals (yoseph haddad

[@שניטוהרעטיה]

As an Israeli citizen you give me hope and you drop crown 👑 I do believe in a one contrary solution because i believe we can co-exist thank you so much

[@tuxuhds6955]

It's a bit problematic to give a sovereign responsibility to a Sunni Salafi Muslims who'd play the hadith of trees and rocks out of their mosques(actively calling to our extermination). When the Arabs decide that life is a holy thing, when they respect the moral behind "The Binding of Isaac" and accept that children are not tools to be sacrificed - Then we might be able to talk like adults. Until then, they will have to learn the hard way how is it that the Jewish people have survived for so long. The choice is theirs alone.

[@Human-rights4all]

​@@tuxuhds6955 survived for so long thanks to the protection of sunni Muslims remember who invited you back to Jerusalem like brothers after the byzantine Roman Christians massacred you. You attack Muslims expel them from their lands but you know you are fulfilling and upholding hadith and verses about Jews and their supporters.

[@tuxuhds6955]

@@Human-rights4all Over half of my family were butchered by Sunni Yemanite Muslims. We survived because of my great grandfather shibria was kept sharp. Kul kalb biji yumo... It's still sharp.

[@CheesyCore]

The iranians always been our brothers. Its not their fault they have been imposed with radicalized violent overthrow of their governmen into shariah extremity. They fight for justice and for freedom of expression just like us and will forever be our allies 🇮🇱♥️🇮🇷

[@karjalasta]

​@@CheesyCoreIf you don't know that you're putting yourself into shame, you know now. Next time do a minimal 5min research regarding the topic, at least... Love.

[@AFRICAISONE-g2t]

History of imaginary islamic country of 'PALESTINE' 1. Before Israel, there was a British mandate, not a Palestinian state. 2. Before the British Mandate, there was the Ottoman Empire, not a Palestinian state.3. Before the OttomanEmpire, there was the Islamic state of the Mamluks of Egypt, not a Palestinian state.4. Before the Islamic state of the Mamluks of Egypt, there was the Ayubid Arab-Kurdish Empire, not a Palestinian state.5. Before the Ayubid Empire, there was the Frankish and Christian Kingdom of Jerusalem, not a Palestinian state.6. Before the Kingdom of Jerusalem, there was the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, not a Palestinian state.7. Before the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, there was the Byzantine Christian empire, not a Palestinian state.8. Before the Byzantine Empire, there were the Sassanids, not a Palestinian state.9. Before the Sassanid Empire, there was the Byzantine Empire, not a Palestinian state.10. Before the Byzantine Empire, there was the Roman Empire, not a Palestinian state.11. Before the Roman Empire, there was the Hasmonean State, not a Palestinian state.12. Before the Hasmonean state, there was the Seleucid, not a Palestinian state.13. Before the Seleucid empire, there was the Greek empire of Alexander the Great, not a Palestinian state.14. Before the empire of Alexander the Great, there was the Persian empire, not a Palestinian state.15. Before the Persian Empire, there was the Babylonian Empire, not a Palestinian state.16. Before the Babylonian Empire, there were the Kingdoms of Israel and Judah, not a Palestinian state.17. Before the Kingdoms of Israel and Judah, there was the Kingdom of Israel, not a Palestinian state.18. Before the kingdom of Israel, there was the twelve tribes of Israel, not a Palestinian state.19. Before the twelve tribes of Israel, there was an agglomeration of many independent Canaanite city-kingdoms, not a Palestinian state.There has NEVER been a Palestinian state in this Holy Biblical land. Only the Jews have maintained a continuous presence in the Holy Biblical Land and have a strong religious connection to it. Jesus Christ, the famous Jew, was born and preached the Gospel from this land of the Jews many centuries before the Islamic arab invasions of the Holy Bible Land. Don't forget, British territory of 'palestine' includes present day Jordan which no one wants to even mention! Check History for these historical facts instead of being misled by Jihadists. Incidentally, 'palestine' is a Roman name not arabic!

[@russelldavis8415]

Someone who knows their history.

[@ceaserborn1739]

Wow thank you.

[@naturesound8660]

This is misleading information because the fact is that Israel is the one who has forced Palestinians out of their land and, since 1947, has committed more than 50 massacres to do so. Just look at the map of Israel since they were given a country in 1948 and now, how much Palestinian land they occupied since then and still going and dreaming of having a country from the river Nile in Egypt to the Alfurat river in Iraq. So please stop manipulating. You can’t make peace with oppression.

[@leahfrishling7088]

Great knowledge 👏 👌 👍

[@amoyjoyce1117]

“But you, Israel, my servant, Jacob, whom I have chosen, you descendants of Abraham my friend, 9 I took you from the ends of the earth, from its farthest corners I called you. I said, ‘You are my servant’; I have chosen you and have not rejected you. 10 So do not fear, for I am with you; do not be dismayed, for I am your God. I will strengthen you and help you; I will uphold you with my righteous right hand. 11 “All who rage against you will surely be ashamed and disgraced; those who oppose you will be as nothing and perish. 12 Though you search for your enemies, you will not find them. Those who wage war against you will be as nothing at all. 13 For I am the Lord your God who takes hold of your right hand and says to you, Do not fear; I will help you. 14 Do not be afraid, you worm Jacob, little Israel, do not fear, for I myself will help you,” declares the Lord, your Redeemer, the Holy One of Israel. 15 “See, I will make you into a threshing sledge, new and sharp, with many teeth. You will thresh the mountains and crush them, and reduce the hills to chaff. 16 You will winnow them, the wind will pick them up, and a gale will blow them away. But you will rejoice in the Lord and glory in the Holy One of Israel.

[@HenPapirman]

Good video- Yes and :) you've forgotten to mention that the word Palestine was first formally used by the roman emperor Hadrian who massacred the rebellious Jewish population in the kingdom of Judea and sent most of the remaining Jewish population into exile. He then was determined to obliterate thousands of years of Jewish presence in the land that is documented with extensive archaeological findings and place names we still use today. So he decided to rename the province of Judea - Syria Palestine after vanished nemesis of the ancient Jews The Philistines. Judea was the last independent state that existed in the land. During the time of the Ottoman Empire, the word Palestine was used a geographical term describing the land south of Syria so when that area fell into the hands of the British at the end of world war 1, it was only natural that they named it Palestine. The League of Nations, a predecessor to the UN granted the victorious world war 1 powers mandates to control the Middle East and prepare the local people for independence. This area came under the British mandate of Palestine, Two populations lived under the mandate of Palestine. Jews and Arabs. Both of them considered Palestinians. It was in 1948 that Israel was born. Jews decided not to take the name Palestinians, and Arabs, took that name only in 1964(ish). Last but not least - Zuheir Mohsen was a Palestinian leader, he was quoted once, in a dutch newspaper, saying this next thing: "Wij zijn alleen Palestijn om politieke reden". "Trouw", March 31, 1977. "The Palestinian people does not exist. The creation of a Palestinian state is only a means for continuing our struggle against the state of Israel for our Arab unity. In reality today there is no difference between Jordanians, Palestinians, Syrians and Lebanese. Only for political and tactical reasons do we speak today about the existence of a Palestinian people, since Arab national interests demand that we posit the existence of a distinct 'Palestinian people' to oppose Zionism."

[@miag.l1087]

Palestine is an English term. In Latin, it is Palaestina and in Greek it is Palaistine. The land was originally called Canaan but separated into different kingdoms: Israel, Judah, Ammon, Moab, Aram Damascus, Edom; and states: Phoenician and Philistine. That Roman emperor created the name Syria Palaestina (later shortened to Palaestina) in the 2nd century C.E. Modern day Palestinians have Canaanite and Arab ancestry. So they are descendants of Islamic Arab colonizers but are also native to the land.

[@netaji-thebritishslayer]

​@@miag.l1087only a few percentage are!!

[@gtr5860]

​@@miag.l1087what is the arabic for Palestine?

[@michalfishman5513]

​@@miag.l1087 They actually have zero connection to Canaan. They only saying that because its written in the bible that the people of Isral concerned the land from them. Just one more palestinian lie.

[@miag.l1087]

@@gtr5860 Today, Palestinians call Palestine "Falasteen". In classical Arabic, it is "Filastin". It was originally called "Jund Filastin" (Military District of Palestine), and it was one of the military districts in the province Bilad al-Sham during the Umayyad "Caliphate" and the Abbasid "Caliphate". The Muslims took the country, then called Syria-Palaestina, from the Byzantine Empire in 634 C.E. This sounds good at first, but Muslims at the time had a plan to create their own empire and get rid of Jews and Christians. A caliphate is supposed to be different from an empire, as an empire treats the natives as inferior and a caliphate treats the natives as equal. However, it is suspicious that in the Middle East and northern Africa, Arabs are the majority and the indigenous people are the minority.

[@scanDuuck]

I love these “iranians” with perfect english and zero accent and also calling palestinians “arabs”. Really makes you think huh

[@DixieFaukner]

i'm iranian and these these iranians are raging zionists because they took the phrase "enemy of my enemy is my freind" too seriosuly. they also hate anything Arab so that's why they're vile and hateful towards palestinains. oh and also most of what she said is false and ignores what israelis did to palestinains and how they stole their land

[@noelrodrigues8179]

​@@DixieFauknerhow did jews steal that land when it was always theirs, if indians conquer your land do u become an invader of your own land. Omar did ethnic cleansing of the jews and christians of madina, my evidence for this is the quran itself where omar himself says I will ethnically wipe out the jews and christians from Arabia. The Muslims used the jews only to kick them out after becoming a majority, zoorashtrians or parsis also faced the same persecution. The arabs weren't happy after stealing madina, they wanted to colonize more non-Arab land. So who is the real invader and who is indigenous

[@alwaysright3943]

@@DixieFauknerگریه کن بسیجی حاصل ازدواج فامیلی. هر چی ایرانی آدم حسابی و فرهیخته هست طرفدار پر و پا قرص اسراییله، فلسطینم‌ میمونه برا شما دهاتیای پشت کوهی براش هشتگ بزنید 😂

[@flowapowa4307]

Sending love from Israel to the people of Iran ❤🇮🇱

[@SammyRo-bm4bw]

wtf bro

[@flowapowa4307]

@@SammyRo-bm4bw why are you so surprised?

[@arI-Yabs]

Sending love back at u from my Iranian heart 🤍✌🏻

[@arI-Yabs]

@@SammyRo-bm4bwY'all Israelis and millions of us Iranians share one main enemy, the ISLAMIC REGIME in Iran. So yeah loads of support. I hope y'all save Gaza from Hamas.

[@flowapowa4307]

@@arI-Yabs my mother (Iraqian origin) always told me that the iranian people are kind and very intelligent. The accursed regime hijacked your land and abuses the people. i pray one day you will succeed in taking back your country 💕🙏🏽

[@magicLA1980]

I could watch her speak facts all day! Thank you for this

[@garyanthony5292]

Thank you, for restoring confidence that there are still young learned people who seek truth and who are a light in the world.

[@arielgn]

As an Israeli and a Jew who is proud of his long history and the eternal nation that survived so many religions that envied him and tried to destroy him, truly thank you from the bottom of my heart. Just to clarify something, when you encourage the phrase "free Palestine" you are actually encouraging terrorism and murder because the meaning of free Palestine is to destroy Jewish existence.

[@lamb_of_God422]

This woman's words need to be spread though.. she's brilliant

[@bucktaylor4960]

She’s fantastic and knows history well,well done lady!

[@gianthills]

She is wrong. European jews are not indigenous

[@cyberspek8996]

@@gianthills tf you talking about?

[@amitvil1]

Ashkenazi jews (which you call european), have atleast 50-60% of their dna traced back to the middle east. They are part of the jews that were expelled from judea. Some moved to other countries in the middle east, others to africa and europe. They are just as indigenous to the land as all the other ethnic jews. Educate yourself before talking shit. You are embarrassing@@gianthills

[@bm_wuratli6883]

@@gianthills LUL this woman is a joke they speaking about ashkenazi and im turk i know alot ashkenazi did u know u can go !srael even tho u ancestor never touched that lands? in condition u never reveal ur adn in public that why its forbidden im pretty sure they are all from outside* LUL as a turk im laughting hard the real story of sionist and ottoman empire u need to go back to theodore herzl & abdulhamid 2... not the mention before theodore herzl in palestine was in peace 500years!!! even the so called strongest US army in the world is bullshet couldnt make 1years in peace* and im also doubt this woman is a muslim* his face botox and hair open its a proof enought for me* also alot ppl forgot iran can be jews christyian and -muslim- may be jews or christian who know ALLAHU AHLEM

[@diannaanderson]

Thank you for your good sense, education, and exceptional ability to express yourself concisely.

[@hectorgarcia3675]

She repeated only the propaganda of israel. Why palestinian will leave their land where they have been for more thousand years ?? they are not only muslim, there are also christian palestinian, they are the realest christian in the world because they decent directly from the people of Jesus era. Moreover, a part of iranian are pro israel because they are children of people who left iranian after the revolution and today, they want just the vengeance by destroy all arab country and iran. They are just stupid. And finally, i watch who published this stupid video : The Australia/Israel & Jewish Affairs Council . So please, open a book and stop swallowing israeli propaganda.

[@templebase]

Really great video. Learned some and enjoyed the way you presented. We need more voices like yours 🤍💙🤍💙🤍💙🤍

[@toriesepahmd6468]

As an Iranian Jew, I’m grateful for the support from my non-Jewish countrymen.

[@thetruegame2383]

לא חשבתי שיש כאלה אנשים שלא רק מקשיבים לחדשות אלא לומדים ואז מדברים. אלוואי ויכולתנו לחיות פשוט בשלום עם כולם. ❤

[@refoelitskovich8912]

נגמרה הנאיביות די

[@azzamziply3039]

Us too, but as long as Zionists still roam the psyche... it's gonna be a bad day for everyone

[@11antun]

There are peopel that know and understand! Love and prayers

[@nemojzezat]

There seems to be a pattern: Palestinians cause a war (or massacre) then Israelis retaliate, and then the Palestinians forget their first move and see Israelis actions as the start of their struggles and are victims.

[@malinericson4065]

Exactly! Palestinians never take responsible for their own actions! They always blame others when the going gets tough! They need to stop play victims and take responible! They can’t continue to live in the old age and hate other people…. they need to evolve as human beings!!!🙏🏼❤️🇸🇪

[@mrs.rubytang9183]

This is the FAIREST cumulative history on both sides I've heard. And a call for living together amicably. God bless her, i hope she continues to see both sides, and call out when either side is wrong, along with a dose of compassion 🙏🏻

[@cathiemarvellous]

She's making some good points but luxurious multiple cities within one country in her "list of countries jews were ethnically cleansed from" is either super ignorant or disingenuous.

[@OCDadal]

This is the perspective shift that's exactly needed on both sides! As a psychologist, I applaud this woman.

[@freyja802]

Yeah, just cut that baseless crap about supporting palestine and it's a decent take. Like this, it's still playing into the hands of the terrorists. #nomercyforhamas

[@mirzamirzali5257]

you can go to iran

[@xuprehkr]

As an Israeli woman I can say this is one of the most important videos that existed, as people are just unaware of this topic's complexity. And you explained it very well, with clarity. As an Israeli and Jewish I support the Palestinian state and wish it well and for its people. The fact that some of them want me dead, in my opinion, is a result of poor life and propaganda, so I feel sorry for them but also understand my country's right to defend itself. Thanks again for understanding and explaining the Israeli state.

[@bilalbhutta6881]

Thank you showing compassion towards Palestinians. I as Muslim wish we'll for both Israeli and Palestinian people. I wish you well in all ways and may you be protected always.

[@xuprehkr]

@@bilalbhutta6881 amen my friend, thank you! I wish the same for you.

[@Hussein.Lb33123]

As a Lebanese, Lebanon was greatly damaged by the war with Israel, I see our hostility with you as temporary and absurd Long live peace 🇱🇧❤️🇮🇱❤️🇵🇸

[@Desfleeding]

​@@xuprehkr i find it funny how you seem fine with her blatantly selling false narratives. No jew was ethnically cleansed, there are jews who even emigrated from South Africa. Be transparent and stop misinforming people, just admit this entire state was just about creating a jewish colony to be among their own. Last time i checked no jew in South Africa or even Morocco was oppressed yet you keep repeating these absurd ststements trying to justify your presence in somebody elses land that you conquered. You cant say you wish for Palestine to have peace whilst actively voting in a right wing fascist maniacal government who act with impunity. You dont actually want peace or justice for any Palestinian, you just want to be able to live in peace without the worry of being attacked. You are perfectly fine leaving them in a concentration camp so long as it doesn't affect your yoga lessons and morning jogs

[@deficrypto1234]

She is incorrect. First of all its Settler Colonialism. Secondly, if all Jews are indigenous to Palestine, they werent ethnically cleansed. U can only be ethnically cleansed by 1. A drive for a homogenous group 2 . An area you are indigenous to.

[@daphnetly]

So young and vocal. I like her speech. Very clear and precise. If only there are more people like her with such clear mind to stand up and speak out to let the whole world hear the truth. Well done, Girl !!! Press on !!

[@mattharcla]

Really? Which ''points'' stand? She's a vacuous fake-faced fool.

[@altGoolam]

She's also completely wrong 😂

[@Jason_Mason]

@@altGoolam Very wrong

[@mistertwister2179]

@@altGoolam How so? Please explain, with facts, so we can all learn from your wisdom.

[@mistertwister2179]

@@Jason_Mason How so? Please explain with facts.

[@KiWi_BoO]

That ancient jews were native to the land, not the jews today with white skin with blond hair. Most of the modern jews are not the jews who they used to be (since the ethnicity goes from maternal side in jewish culture). So if you want land which belonged to jews, then bring the real jews, not some europeans who don't even believe in religion but believe that God promised this land to them

[@fredatandoh3125]

Very well said. Thank you. We the people in East and West Africa know the history so we are not worried about what is going on. We love Isreal. They are always welcome.

[@maureendequesada-yx1ul]

🙏❤‍🩹🥲

[@gunston999]

I’m Italian 🇮🇹 and I love Iranian 🇮🇷 and Israeli 🇮🇱 girls..everyone make more love and forget wars..we are here for such a short time.

[@btbb3726]

It’s perhaps interesting that Cyrus king of Persia sent the exiles from Jerusalem back home to rebuild their city and temple.

[@PortugalZeroworldcup]

First colonial empire ever

[@agostocobain2729]

@@PortugalZeroworldcup Cyrus the great is the first Messiah the torah speaks of, for freeing the Hebrews from Babylonian captivity, and allowing them to return home, and he said "the God of Israel told me to build him a house in Jerusalem", he rebuilt the temple in Jerusalem, and he put up his own money for this, and got all the royal valuables back from the Babylonians. It was the royal accountant of Judea that accounted all of it, ALL of it was returned. The Hebrews that returned back home were protected by the Persian army on their way back to Judea. Cyrus is spoken of by name 200 years before he was even born, in the Torah. Cyrus the great is one of the Messiahs in the Torah alongside King David, and Moses. Persia was the first empire to abolish slavery. Today the Persian Jews lineage goes back to this time, because even though they were free to return home, a lot of them stayed there. Today the tomb Cyrus the great, the Prophet Daniel, Queen Esther, and Mordecai still stand in Iran, and they are people the Torah speaks of. You need to learn more, you don't seem too bright!

[@PortugalZeroworldcup]

@@agostocobain2729 ok great but Iran is a joke today Slavery started in Mesopotamia, and Saudi Arabia ended in 1962 So as always Without lies Islam dies

[@agostocobain2729]

@@PortugalZeroworldcup How is it a joke? Where are you from?

[@agostocobain2729]

@@PortugalZeroworldcup So you’re anti Islamic? That doesn’t take away Iranian heritage and history scholars poets kings. Like for instance you think Italian is the most poetic language in the world? Nope it’s Persian, just google it and see. UNESCO world heritage top ten countries are Italy, Spain, China, Egypt, Mexico, and Iran is on the list. That’s top ten in the world bro.

[@simonrose313]

A nuanced, balanced understanding of the situation. So refreshing to hear this, such a change from the ill-informed, half-baked garbage that is spouted on demonstrations and social media nowadays.

[@tuxuhds6955]

"such a change from the ill-informed, half-baked garbage"? Really? She advocates an Arab fascist state... The Arabs in Israel and what you call Palestine do not want a country, they want to immortalize their victimhood. They were offered a state time and again but somehow they couldn't accept it because us Jewish people were not dead enough for their palates: 1. Peel Commission of 1937 - Rejected. 2. White Paper of 1939 - Rejected. During WW2 - Hajj Amin al-Husseini which was the leader of the Muslims in Palestine was considered a criminal by GB and had evaded his arrest warrant just to help the German dictator to form a Waffen-SS unit of Muslims, so they can continue their genocide against Jewish people. By the way, I call them Arabs and not Palestinians because the funny fact is that the term Palestinians was reserved to the Jewish people whom, by Lord Balfour's Declaration(1917), were to be the designated population of the country. Also - It's a bit problematic to give a sovereign responsibility to a Sunni Salafi Muslims who'd play the hadith of trees and rocks out of their mosques(actively calling to our extermination). When the Arabs decide that life is a holy thing, when they respect the moral behind "The Binding of Isaac" and accept that children are not tools to be sacrificed - Then we might be able to talk like adults. Until then, they will have to learn the hard way how is it that the Jewish people have survived for so long. The choice is theirs alone.

[@queenanneslace3659]

Agree! And also from most so called "journalists" sadly. 😢

[@iamLODD]

Not really a critical thinker nor is she "right". If she were actually a critical thinker, she would question why it is that anyone in Palestine is expected to give up land when Europeans own more than 50% of the planet's green land despite making up only 13% of the population. Carving out a new state for Jews: should it be done in the European world, (a massive multicontinental planetary empire which encompasses North America, South America, Europe, Siberia, Australia, New Zealand) Or should it be done in the blazing white desert of the Middle East, whose total fertile land area is smaller than the state of Maine? Also: Why weren't Jews expelled from India and China? They had Jews just like in Europe, so what happened? Is it possible that certain races are just less selfish, and more capable of getting along? Why are there so few race riots in Singapore, despite it being one of the MOST RACIALLY DIVERSE cities on the planet (a mix of Malays, Tamils, and Cantonese)? Also by her logic, the conquistadors were not colonists, because 90% of their crew was North African people from the Canary Islands, exiled from it by Spain. Ashkenazi and Russian Jews are also "white" by the way, both looks-wise and genetically, and make up 45% of Israel's population. They also sterilize Ethiopian Jewish women, so yeah they're pretty racist

[@tuxuhds6955]

@@iamLODD Islam does not run democracies. Islam dictates, from its birth, to its faithful to actively huחt Jewish people and kוll them. What If I'd start a church decreeing that all my faithful should hunt a certain nation just for being that nation or race? What kind of treatment would I get by sovereign democratic countries? Cut the bs mate...

[@TheBlackDork]

Dude stop copypasting your own comment and do some real research.

[@alonirev]

Very good video! One correction though - saying that the first time someone held a palestinian passport was in 1917 is completely missleading, because that refers to the passport issueed by the british mandate, not a passport indicating a Palestinian state. Even the Palestinians themselves didn't began referring to themselves as "Palestinians" until the 1960s. Up until the 60s they referred to themselves as trans-egyptians, trans jordanians, etc. (the countries they immigrated from.)

[@Proud_Troll]

Ya, because Palestine has always just been the name of that piece of land, not the name of a government or a culture, or a society.

[@namermeoffef]

Another way to put it is that between 1917 and 1948 both Jews and Arabs had a Palestinian passport. The conflict is originally Jewish Arab (mostly Muslim arabs) conflict, but in 1964 the Arabs starting calling themselves Palestinians (which never existing before as a country).

[@alonirev]

yes, exactly.@@Proud_Troll

[@valeriemartinez3505]

Hitler called it Palestine, I heard it in one of his speeches

[@markknowsbest7499]

​@@namermeoffefcorrect

[@gail2698]

Always remember this pattern, 1) Conflict is always between islam vs other religions 2) Other islamic countries will not accept those affected muslims as their refugees, but they somehow sneak into non-islamic countries. (Russia, whole EU problem with refugees: France, Germany, Spain etc., India divided into 3+ countries, Iran was not an islamic state initially) 3) once they are into non-islamic countries, they create separate laws and try to break that country too. Stay strong Israel 🇮🇱

[@rationalphobia5533]

100% spot on. Islam is the cause of all this atrocities. Don't open your border for this evil and filth ideology/religion.

[@bethgriesauer3825]

Conflicts are certainly not "always between Islam and other religions". Are Hitler and Putin closet Muslims?

[@boundariessetinstone5893]

That’s what I’ve read and I’m curious why they are like this and this seems to be an Arab thing not Muslim thing.

[@oldlaw67]

She is about 90% smarter than all but about six people who have addressed the same topic.

[@camarasaurus1]

Excellent , precise , clear headed historic summary

[@CissyEpifany]

And Wrong! No Jews ethnically cleansed out of Morocco! 250.000 Jews SAVED by Morocco during WW2, that fact she chose to leave out DID happen.

[@ejseabury]

Thank you for telling the truth about the history of Israel and Palestine.

[@deficrypto1234]

She lied. there was an ottoman census in 1881 and there more than 400k Jews.

[@invader7191]

@@deficrypto1234liar 🤥

[@joeracerable]

Not the whole truth she got the thing about Abraham wrong. No abraham then there is no Jewish people.

[@Ffiffijs]

And she never mention that they are fake Jews

[@ejseabury]

@@Ffiffijs: What is a fake Jew?

[@aribosch9064]

As Jewish only can say thanks to be honest view of the Palestine land

[@meia5990]

What an amazing intelligent woman, i am happy to see people like her speaking up and that there is still hope. The world hasent turned into a giant raging dumpster fire just yet.

[@meia5990]

@@mikupab33 she is a lot smarter than the pro hamas protestor i have seen so far .

[@cathyfourie3323]

A great video thank you. So well researched and packaged. Learnt so much and better understand the people advocating for Palestine. There was zero hate or violence. ❤ everyone needs to agree that the Jews have a right to exist as do the Palestinian people.

[@alimcbally2339]

Cathy, if you read your Bible, you will see Abraham did exist. Look it up in the book of Genesis. It's there, I promise you... Abraham was the father of the Jews... and the land was given to Abraham for the Jews by God Himself... So I do NOT agree with everything...

[@bethgriesauer3825]

​@@alimcbally2339 The bible isn't a historical document, though. It's religious and can't be used as a testament of fact. This young woman is talking about actual history.

[@KygoCalvinHarris-xu4kv]

3:04 Middle eastern killing

[@teresalehmitz368]

Excellent video. Informative without calling for violence

[@DianeMonahan]

@@bethgriesauer3825The Torah, Tanakh, Hebrew Bible contain loads of historical information such as the Phillistines, Indo-European seafaring invaders from Agean Islands who occupied a small area near the sea (Phillisia, now Gaza) and were the worst enemies of Israelites. Reason Roman invaders renamed Judea and Samaria by the greco-roman name of ‘Palestina’ to insult Jews and try to take away their identity by naming it by the name of their worst enemies, the Phillistines. In Hebrew, ‘Plishtim’ ‘Peleshet’ means ‘invaders. Indigenous Hebrews called the land ‘Eretz Yisrael’.

[@trojanhorse1247]

I thank this lady for being so educated in such a young age. This video needs to be showed to all 🇮🇱❤️

[@nadiashireensiddiqi]

But with her real name and not by the Australian Israeli Jewish Australian collective which automatically puts off people who need to watch this the most.

[@bensanderson7144]

Correction: an Iranian Muslim woman with an impeccable London accent

[@kwolf2145]

We support Iranian women's fight against being force to wear hijab and other things they are forced to follow.

[@freda3995]

Great that a Muslim woman is telling this. Luck that she proofs that not all Muslims are bad.

[@philstaples8122]

Well done to the woman talking, I'm not Jewish or Muslim but I like to hear someone talking common sense.

[@peace-now]

What a fascinating lecture. I only found out recently about the fact that over 100,000 Jews used to live in Baghdad, and they were all expelled. She has documented so much information in a short video.

[@meryamlightbodyradiance519]

She hasn’t documented anything - I see no supporting or factual evidence. She hasn’t quoted any reliable source such as historical books and historians

[@peace-now]

@@meryamlightbodyradiance519She has highlighted the way Jewish people were treated in the past by various governments.This is highly educational. People commenting are sometimes nitpicking to my mind.

[@DianeMonahan]

@@meryamlightbodyradiance519 Almost one million Jews were savagely thrown out of the Middle East where Jews lived even before Christianity and Islam (also North Africa), dispossessed of all they owned (robbed) and never compensated. They haven’t been whining as eternal intergenerational refugee$$$$ for 70+ years and have rebuilt their lives and sovereign nation (Israel) despite 5+ @rob states (notice not an inexistant greco-roman ‘Palestina’) waging wars of annihilation on the sovereign Jewish nation….and failing

[@DianeMonahan]

@@meryamlightbodyradiance519there is so much documentation on the exodus (almost one million Jews savagely thrown out and dispossessed of all they owned and never compensated) of Jews from the Middle East, North Africa that it would blow your mind!! Not to mention thousands of real life testimonies.

[@milad8255]

they were not expelled. They just migrated to Israel because there is more money in Israel. You know who runs after money

[@frenchfatfather]

my son has been expelled 109 times but it's never his fault it's always the schools persecuting him for no reason

[@poguelet]

This young woman has more balls than any Hamas "liberator"! She will face retribution from the Islamists and the left. But she is doing the right thing by speaking the truth!! Very courgious!!

[@moshegabay6226]

Thank you for explain the truth in fact. This is the best and most concise account of history of the Jewish and Arab peoples in this land. Better explained than any other gov official or media official. Smart girl , well versed with a clear talent on explaining issues.

[@trexusification]

I have been awed and comforted by the many Iranian individuals who have showed up and spoken up since Oct 7. Thank you.

[@derrickcox7761]

70 percent of Palestinians support Hamas. That's all I need to know.

[@meredithmartinez8024]

A relief to hear a young person versed in facts. All people should be free.

[@pluto9000]

How old is she?

[@TrevorSachko]

Her facts....

[@persvendsen2359]

The Left cant handle this much facts, they just go with emotions 😂 this woman should be in politics she´s a gem

[@jillk368]

To be fair, as a moderate moderate (yes, some of us still exist, and we have essentially no representation), when it comes to hot-button issues, extremes on both sides are less fact-based and more passion-based. Passion in front of principle, one might say. And unfortunately, this tends to discredit both extreme ends of the political spectrum.