CENTRE PUNCH MAKING COMPETITION!!! Steele Vs. Stelter: 2

[@CloudHater]

Sleek and modern hole punch v.s Dwarven crossbow bolt for killing minor dragons

[@Broadpaw_Fox]

Gonna have to give it to the crossbow bolt. :) Also, thanks for making me laugh/snort.

[@grotwurksmekshop6607]

Crossbow Bolt has my vote. Thank you for the laugh

[@trevorjaster4072]

Lol so true

[@Volyzer]

I would take the modern one, looked clean

[@gemagpaoa9437]

Seems about right

[@bagochips834]

Will is really good at time management and pretending he isn't worried

[@mokow3732]

I honestly think he wasn't worried at all.

[@lunchboxhedz292]

Alec is the opposite

[@jmwintermute1]

Alec, you mean you love your morning routine of: Waking up, banging your shin on your bed, and then making coffee.

[@AlecSteele]

😂😂😂😂

[@evolutionglitch4739]

LoL, by now he probably sleeps in shin guards... Problem solved 😂

[@mrbourdet]

Hey that is a great idea for a project. Forged shin guards.

[@markturcotte663]

Would really love an update now that it's been a few months on how his shins are feeling at this point.

[@zoebaz6969]

Guys, he does have shins of Steele though...

[@Joe___R]

I am surprised Will doesn't have his own touch mark. That is something you should remade on the next episode.

[@1014p]

Joe R especially if they do colon work. A touch mark on each side.

[@snteevveetns]

Pniko they can leave my colon alone...

[@zithrax101]

I think the winner here is Alec. Well done gentlemen. Both look great.

[@koloth5139]

Depends on how you prefer your aesthetics. One thing that Alec seems to prefer that I have never cared for is the forge scale that leaves that clear hand made look. I like that Will actually cleaned his up. That being said Alec's is actually really nice I think this one will be a lot closer than the bangle.

[@c-0055]

Go check out the poll on Instagram.... Spoilers! Alec definitely won, it’s like 80% to 20%

[@tezcharold]

@@c-0055 Too be honest, when they said the last poll wasn't close i imagined it to be a lot further off, in my opinion Will also won this one, but in the end Alec is going to have way more fans so this will never be a fair competition.

[@zithrax101]

@koloth I wouldn't say that. I thought Will did a better job last time and apparently so did many other viewers.

[@MathiasonProject]

My suggestion for a future challenge: After having watched "Can I Make A Sword In A Day?" I'd love to see both you and Will given 24 hours to make a sword and see who can make the cooler one.

[@hoistline]

See now, i like these challenges...and it looks like there is no real pressure, almost like a couple of average joe's having a fun day in the shop.

[@clownshoesmma6249]

Rob Bob That’s a pretty sweet looking burger in your picture. It’s 6am here and I’m now thinking about a hamburger for breakfast

[@jameshill1358]

It seems to me like they might be practicing for forged in fire maybe maybe not either way love the content

[@Ibrahim-ut6pn]

why have hamburgers when you can have hamberders

[@robertpaxton1679]

I enjoy these challenges as well. But I wish i was an average Joe with all the tools they have! They have some amazing stuff in their shop. I'm very jealous.

[@chickenmonger123]

Clown Shoes MMA Burgers for breakfast are great. When I was working 3rd it was my favorite thing.

[@ulrichkalber9039]

Alec has created a work of art. Will has created an elegant tool. why do we need a winner???

[@KrolPower]

Because that's the point of a competition.....

[@IzzyIkigai]

@@KrolPower Not necessarily. A competition might also be brought on to bring the best of the participant's skill to light. Being a winner is often just the byproduct of years of skill development.

[@WomanRespectorMD]

Will's looks like a punch you'd buy at a store but Alec' s looks more personalised

[@williamjeffersonclinton69]

Agreed. But, Alec's punch would be one I'd hang in my shop and Will's I would use.

[@Helveteshit]

@@williamjeffersonclinton69 Personally, I would probably use Alec's punch. Because it is larger and presents a better grasp and potential lack of hitting your hand when trying to strike the end with a hammer. Should your aim be off.

[@andyiliff7793]

Will's punch is refined and polished, very modern, while Alec's is very rugged and yet has a very artistic flair to it! These competition videos are good fun content!

[@TheProrage509]

I’m gonna say Alec won this one on design

[@brandonb9452]

Jorden Walter *Alec

[@goodness6664]

*won

[@Mallrat79]

Mosdef.

[@AdriWL]

Agree

[@KingHalbatorix]

Jorden Walter will's looks like a nice center punch, but it looks like a nice center punch that I would buy from a store. I wouldn't really know it was hand forged. Alec's is obviously a hand made tool and I feel like that increases the value.

[@Christoph1990]

Alec's looks like it was made 200 years ago, Will's like you can buy it at ACE

[@onetrucksizedsalmon2962]

Well it is the place

[@ethansomething9428]

Onetrucksizedsalmon I think it’s very helpful as well

[@pjmeis5226]

Well, I would actually give this to Alec, but it’s so great to see both of you work! I love how you each are pushing each other to improve and learning from each other, and thank you because it’s been such a pleasure to follow you guys on this journey!

[@munk6257]

Missed opportunity: quenched in coffee

[@CBrownAgain]

Bit of a waste of such a great cup of coffe tho :)

[@davidwellman7080]

Alec it's beautiful! And as always a gentleman . wonderful watching your channel. And Wills punch looks amazing as well. But Alecs looks like old world craftsmanship.

[@lordofnothing.]

probably, wills ist a lot stronger through the future, but Alecs just looks sooooo many levels cooler! so Alec wins!

[@onesaltyboi6575]

There both unique in there own ways so and the only way of comparing is center punching so I say it’s a tie

[@chadsephton6846]

I agreee

[@elijahgrimm8052]

Who else thought he was gonna quench in the coffee?

[@bradleykiff5193]

He already quenched the war hammer in tea when he was across the pond. Might as well go true ‘Merica with the coffee.

[@wanderinwolf3804]

@@bradleykiff5193 I thought the true American way would be to quench it in the harbor?

[@rudimentaryganglia]

@@bradleykiff5193 surely the most 'Merica thing to quench in would be kool aid

[@andrewdavies4604]

Yup, looked just like it was going to happen.

[@thejfresh09]

@@rudimentaryganglia I think you misspelled Coca-Cola

[@WelkerFarms]

You guys are awesome, love the channel, keep up the excellent content!

[@MrMrRubic]

"how's it going will?" "Good, gettin' pointy!"

[@KAYMOTOGAMING]

Lmao he said it as i saw this comment

[@MrT3a]

Love Will's analogy, I do the same kind of analogy all the time, conveys the idea pretty clearly without having to go into details.

[@charliexoxox]

ALEC: DESIGN AND EXECUTION WILL: DISCIPLINE AND LEVEL HEADEDNESS Together, they make a perfect punch.

[@AndrewBuchen]

You guys are amazing. I'm 60 years old and just getting into blacksmithing. Hope I'm half as good as you two before I'm 70. Keep on smithing.

[@AndrewBuchen]

Alex I gotta say that punch looked narly you got my vote. Sorry Will.

[@Stefone795]

They appear to be effectually the same, but they're so aesthetically different. Will's looks sleek and precise while Alec's looks gritty and hardened. Incredible jobs both of you!

[@gizmogoose.2486]

Alec's piece is magnificent! It exudes *tradition* and *character.* ...really, it does. ...That's not hyperbole! btw - The Queen called and wants you back. I flatly told her 'no'. When she hung up she was screaming something about seeing me at some 'waterloo' thing. Whatever that is.

[@thomashoffman2456]

Thank You! For showing that blacksmiths forge more than blades. I get tired of folks asking me about bladesmithing after I explain I'm an amateur blacksmith. I love making tools. Rock on young gents.

[@NicholasSmith87]

Your description still says "Alec Steele Blacksmith 2018". Just thought you'd like to know. 😁

[@Hourani95]

thats his copyright signature. and date established.

[@xIronPigx]

Last one was a land slide for the right side of the pond...this one the land slide reversed. Beautiful punch Alec. I’m liking these gentlemen competitions... keep em coming!

[@appalachianforge7537]

I'm gonna have to go with Alec's. Both preformed well but that twist you gave it was pretty awesome

[@MrUltralove]

You both have very different design approaches like material choice, lines, design languages, you two are just completely different people and enjoying it! Keep up the good work boys!

[@saggyjello5340]

Well I guess I'm going to bed 15 minutes later than usual

[@silverbullet__]

Same lol

[@TexasViking_INFP-t_5w4]

Riiight

[@silverbullet__]

Lmao

[@myparentskid]

16

[@harpernordin3981]

Lol same

[@d.mat.zero6525]

I really like these challenge videos! They are freaking awesome. It’s got the suspense, the drama, a lil bit of trash talking!

[@SReihs]

Why don't just do a pole on youtube here so everyone can directly vote right after the video?

[@Wwoodsy]

yes true

[@Turin-Fett]

To get traffic to their Instagram pages.

[@S0ULSTICE777]

Pepr fax and I’m not even mad about it

[@Martin-tb4oo]

I dont have insta..... not fare

[@onesaltyboi6575]

Martin Olson Instagram is one of the biggest social media’s so your just an exception they don’t account for

[@Ron3343]

I do love these challenges between you and Will. They are FANTASTIC!! Alec I do need one of your square circle rounding hammer in my life!! Keep up the FANTASTIC work you two!!!

[@celestigon-8901]

You should try to make a spear

[@mp_za]

Yes! A native American spear would be awesome!

[@donnaspear8494]

I would love to help them make a spear. lol

[@TheViking1]

A boar spear would be cool. And after he is done go on a boar hunt with it.

[@kauekairony990]

Or a stylised spear

[@Sakuxxx1x]

yeah he should make a "Saufeder". hrhr greetings from germany.

[@Macca2188]

Have to say Alec I'm really enjoying seeing you just make things again, the big projects are awesome but the little details that go into these bits are really cool.

[@mjf69]

I understand you guys both want to plug your social media. But I really wish you would offer an accessible poll. I would like to weigh in, but don't use social media.

[@benjaminolsson2162]

Yes he should make a poll on KZbin. I don't have Instagram and won't get it simply to vote for this.

[@TheClearwall]

Same here.

[@j-me5820]

Agreed!

[@Millcreekcoffee]

+1

[@heroftoday]

“I don’t use social media” He said, on a social media website.

[@daved1697]

Alec! I'm pretty excited to see what kind of Smith you become in your 30s and 40s. You do some awesome work and I love watching you work with your employees. You are an awesome leader. That's a skill that is lost on our generation.

[@stockcaptain1]

The downside of notification squad...no HD yet! EDIT: I refreshed its all good!

[@Nightman2152]

You guys are very entertaining to watch. I watch a lot of old timers blacksmith channels and they are excellent for learning. You guys are fun to watch. Good editing! Keep up the good work!

[@AndrewMartin600]

I'd love to see you guys forge out something like a wrench. I'm interested if a hand forged tool would be better than say, a snap-on wrench

[@jasonsummit1885]

It would be really interesting if they could make a spanner wrench😁

[@BigWillSD]

Jason, is there going that far let's see you make a Pulaski

[@BigWillSD]

*them* not u, sorry

[@jnsdroid]

Typing this out during the sponsor bit .... I love this new segment/aspect/whatever ya call it of the channel -- somehow makes things feel more light-headed and wholesome

[@FeuerToifel]

hard decision. the clean design from will looks more professional. but the design from alec is more ornate/extravagant. this time, alec won.

[@dennispratt7055]

I just found you on KZbin and have really enjoyed watching. I started my first knife today and from what I have learned from your videos, I got this. Thanks.

[@teddybutter1764]

Alec’s looks cooler, but I’d rather own and use Will’s.

[@JonathanAdshead]

Definitely agree with you :)

[@Millcreekcoffee]

I Agree

[@qtube1208]

You know I just want to say I've watched all these KZbinrs try and grow their channels while being faced with adversity, hardships, conflict with molding a crew/team, avoid becoming stagnant, creation of new interesting content, financial budgeting and literally everything that comes with not only building a business and brand but also staying true to yourself whilst sharing every step of the way on KZbin. And I just want to say Alec I'm truly impressed and proud of you. You as well Will! Cause honestly Will without you the culture shock of coming to America and completely starting over when Alec you already had something good going across the pond would not have been an easy thing to do. However you're doing it to the best of your ability taking it one step at a time working together solving any problem that has come thus far balancing off each other's strengths literally starting with an empty canvas and creating this amazing shop/channel. Sorry if this makes no sense I'm trying to put into words how amazing you two are at 4:29am in the morning. I've just been meaning to say something and whether or not you see this just know that I'm a true fan of this genuine content and this is the stuff KZbin is really defined as. Keep it up! Also Alec you won this round;)

[@jenksify]

We seem to have gone from feast to famine with the coming of videos.

[@wakefieldtacticalfurniture5155]

Alec, your curiosity has inspired me to embrace my own. Back in January I started school for applied science in mechanical engineering. Just finished my first project. Using the mill and lathe, I made a C-Clamp 💯%! Thanks for the inspiration.😉

[@eianhalsted6089]

I definitely think you took this round Alec!

[@nicholas8476]

Love the handle twist. I’ve seen someone do really aggressive triangular cuts in a similar fashion before twisting to make like a dragon tail design with scales that pop out. Very cool.

[@calebthompson1657]

As usual, great episode! Also I've used trade coffee ever since they started sponsoring you, try the El Diablo dark roast, it's the best coffee I've ever had, that's what Trade suggested to me. P.S. Alec won this one!

[@dkosmari]

Isn't it worrying though, to be sponsored by a company that bent over to a defamation campaign by The Escapist against Jeremy Hambly? They could pull out of Alec without notice. Definitely the most coward coffee sellers I've seen.

[@aceonfire12]

I love these competitions! Will and Alec have such great chemistry!!

[@jonboyd9186]

Alec wins this round of Steele vs. Will.

[@whengrapespop5728]

Jon Boyd Will’s looks more comfortable to grip because of the tapering, but Steele’s is visually interesting to look at.

[@jonboyd9186]

When Grapes Pop you’re not wrong. Maybe Alec’s texture would help with grip though...

[@jadonwilliams9194]

Those are both equally beautiful pieces in their own way. Alec's is a grittier homemade look, while Will's is more industrial looking and far sleeker. Love them, these challenges are awesome.

[@johnyoung2544]

I would use Alex punch around the forge and Will punch on the layout table

[@jross5995]

Back to tool making, love it. It's what got me watching alec's videos in the first place

[@Godzra321]

id like to see an hour as a constant time limit

[@SennaF1GP]

It takes a lot of video editing just to get 20 minutes. Plus an hour of video takes a lot more than an hour of shooting.

[@Stealthy_Phenotype]

I don't like that the previous challenge Alec time got reduces because Will did not make full use of his time. So i would like to see either set time limits or a constant of no time but the person that goes first time will be taken for the previous winner to beat.

[@danzman954]

I love the difference in personality between you two. Allec energetically running around and Will strolling with his coffee.

[@glennreggie3036]

Will for the substance over style win. 👍🏽

[@DuncanAitken]

These are great fun! I love the banter - and the end results! Thank you, Will and Alec!

[@Xempt_One]

Honestly, alecs looks absolutely stunning but practically, wills is a better size and more useable without getting blisters or calluouses on you fingers. Id have voted for will. Love a good rubiks twist though

[@quarlow1215]

I don't Instagram but I am calling Alec's the winner on this one. It's a nice classic forged look and isn't that what this channel is about. Having said that I give no slight to Wills. It is a great punch also and I would be happy to have one in my shop. Great work fella's.

[@Mjones8383]

Make some fishing hooks or arrow heads since your in such an outdoors state

[@bob3274]

I’m not on twitter. I’m going with Alec’s chisel on this one design. I have to give Will props though for taking the time to give his center punch a swedish massage LOL! I love the friendly competition. Great job you two.

[@mattleach5294]

“I can start grinding while it’s hot” (One frame later) *PEW*

[@CalebMcFadden]

Hello fellow coworker

[@taunokekkonen5733]

I quite can't put my finger on it, but Alec's sponsorships/ads are very good. You know he is making a commercial for money, but it's made so well, that you don't even mind.

[@krustysurfer]

WHAT! NO VOTING FROM YT! IMHO that comp is a Tie! fun video thanks gentleman!

[@donm6578]

Very cool punch Alec! Definitely redeemed yourself with this challenge. The twisted segments almost look like scales or stone. Love it.

[@ohmahgawdfilms]

I have the same mask as you! :D Y'all are my inspiration to forge.

[@fastamx069box8]

Alec's is a cool punch. However, I like Will's better because it reminds me of what I made in the 70's my first year in Metal Shop. I don't know if they still have Trades taught in High School or not. It is great to see Alec working with all of the tools of the trades including Foundry. Great job Gents👍👍👍✝️

[@krombopulosrick7920]

they do.

[@randall8768]

If I could name one person who seems like they drink coffee it would be alec lol

[@TomTheEnglishPicker]

Alec is the clear winner for its ancient Artefact look. Also I think as an Englishman Alec, a tea sponsor would be good .

[@ghostfather1390]

hey Alec, having worked with coffee for most of my life , I would like to explain how you are not drinking the best coffee that you could. I know this because I could see that you are using pre-ground coffee, which, by definition, means that it is more stale than it should be. (the fact that it is packaged and shipped to you means it is already pretty stale, but ground coffee is worse.) much of the flavor from coffee comes from the volatile gases encapsulated by the coffee bean, not just the oils. when you see the nice creamy, foamy "crema" (the technical term for..), the foam on top of a demitasse of fresh espresso, then you know that coffee is pretty fresh, and freshly ground. This is the reason most good cafe's, like Starbucks, will have a grinder directly attached to the dispenser for the espresso, so that it can be ground fresh, as it is needed. do not get me started on the necessity to fully de-gassify coffee, bean or ground, and so make it Stale, before vacuum packaging. get yourself an adjustable grinder, use the proper grind for the method used (turkish coffee/ibrik should be baby powder fine, finer than espresso, which should be a fine sand texture that does clump, but still has a gritty feel, turkish should feel smooth, ; drip coffee should be about beach sand texture, with pieces each about a millimeter, more or less; french press should be an even coarser grind, about 2mm pieces; on a 1 to 10 scale, with 1 being the finest possible, and 10 just barely breaking up the beans, Turkish coffee would be 1, espresso ~3, paper/mesh cone drip 5, flat bottom paper/mesh drip ("Mr Coffee") 6, French press 8, and percolator/boiled cowboy coffee 10 (do not use this method unless you grew up in the depression or actually are a cowboy out on the range with no other options, it WILL put hair on your chest and take chrome off of a bumper) finally, I would like to make a suggestion or 3 about different methods of using your press to prepare your morning brew. A; save your egg shells, clean them off well, let them dry, and then crush them into a powder that you keep in a closed container next to your coffee storage. put a nice healthy pinch, or more if you want, on top of your grounds when you brew, and you will find the shells have absorbed a great deal of the bitterness of the coffee. some folks may claim Chicory has the same effect, but that is not true in my experience. chicory was used in the depression as a coffee substitute/extender, and has become misunderstood, it is actually More bitter than coffee. 2; rather than getting flavored coffee, like hazelnut or vanilla, why not add actual fresh spices to your brew (yes, spices benefit from being freshly ground as much, or more, than coffee does), get yourself a nutmeg grater, like a small rasp-thingy, and grind some nutmeg and/or cinnamon, or what ever strikes your fancy, into the pot before your add the ground coffee, to taste (start SPARINGLY). also; if you use sugar, Stop. get some honey, hopefully unprocessed, from a local apiary (beekeeper), and try different varieties, you may notice that honey can taste surprisingly different when made from different types of flower pollen. sugar is bad for you, while raw honey has health benefits, and this comment is already FAR too long to go into those here. while you are at it, try infusing some honey, not only for coffee, but for cooking too. try drizzling garlic infused honey onto your pizza delivery and voila! gourmet pizza. heck, I bet you start putting garlic honey on Everything! but I digress. I could go on for quite a bit more regarding coffee, but I think I will wait for replies to see if there is interest. take as much care in perfecting the craft of feeding yourself as you do with your crafting career, no matter what the career, you have to eat if you read this far, thank you, I hope it helps keep making the good episodes, I will keep watching, be well

[@gerardvila4685]

Thanks for the tips. I'll be looking out for a variable coffee grinder.

[@Zak-ob5ze]

Cba reading

[@timrobinson9978]

Alec is back! Yes!!! Definitely the winner of this one. Love that design. Almost looks like some sort of alien weapon.

[@Iwhoiam999]

It's like comparing apples and oranges. Completely different by design but both are awesome. That's a tough one

[@denisconnelly390]

I didn't see the poll on Instagram last time. Won't miss this next one. Killing it guys.

[@greasypancakes9815]

I dont understand whats happening but uh its looks awesome ima sub

[@benjaminolsson2162]

Check out the viking sword he made. If you time traveled, it would probably let you rule a country or something.

[@nathanielecheverria8458]

Let's all vote for alec #2 no matter what in the upcoming episodes

[@guybramwells]

I like Alec's this time as it can double as a medievil club for midgets. I give it extra points for its versatility. Sorry Will.

[@MrPapiray23]

Both looks great, but Alec design look beautiful. The most important thing is both of you guys are having fun with this.

[@markoconnell804]

No update on the sword? I am sure you all will finish it.........

[@Sam_but_not_really]

Thanks for less jump cuts. Shortening videos lately really impacted their quality and this time it was done better.

[@vincentcombs2642]

Alec is more decorative, Will is more functional..overall....Tie.......Both are Great !!!!!!

[@godlovesmysnakesandtattoos5084]

He beat you last time but you center punched him in the face this time 😂🤣😂🤣👍🏻 you guys keep it up , would love to see more vids more often 👍🏻

[@jasongreenlaw8633]

No Instagram but round 2 goes to Alec! I like how you stepped up your game this time. 👍🥇⚒

[@spookerredmenace3950]

i;'m here because Neebs gaming talked about your channel.. i like it so far! awesome work!

[@C134B]

Subscribed because i like craftsmanship, ringed the bell because of the awesome quality.

[@DimitrijJedich]

Alec clearly won that competition, but Will definetly had the better performance in the video xD

[@Taunus-Tim]

nah, Alec's methods are morr advanced. even in the last challenge. alec is way ahead of will in his profession.

[@thebassrogue]

Alec is the true winner of this one!

[@BungAngus14]

Support the troops, Alec. Reach out to Black Rifle Coffee!

[@cthulhu9136]

Alec gets bonus points for the twist, will gets bonus points for the practicality

[@tylerhunting3928]

These competitions are better than the actual videos

[@Ronnybanan]

Enjoying the soc dynamic between Alec and Will.

[@WhiteDesignsUSA]

Why does Alec ALWAYS overcomplicate the simplest things

[@robertoswalt319]

R.W. Knife and Tool because he can?

[@benjaminolsson2162]

I think that is what lost him the bracelet challenge but also why he is going to win this one. It's what Alec does and it's one of the reasons I subscribed.

[@WhiteDesignsUSA]

@@benjaminolsson2162 yeah. It's more that he just has to learn what his perfect ratio of form and function is for certain things especially when he's being timed. Like for a timed event you emphasis function but if you want to make an art peice you focus on form.

[@benjaminolsson2162]

@@WhiteDesignsUSA That's a fair point actually.

[@justwinks1553]

I never fastforward through your sponsor info. You know how to do it right!

[@jumbojf]

Inglorious bastards Bowie next!

Great idea!

[@thomascatil4999]

Judging only the looks, I gotta give my vote to Alec. Great job guys, I really like those casual competitions.

[@fearlessferrousfire]

Alec Steele is best, but still have to give will credit for hand forging it by hand.

[@elijahnapp]

demolitia 22 Will did a better job, his end result was👌👌

[@fearlessferrousfire]

Eli N not disagreeing.

[@kieferbradley2860]

Only Alec Steele could make a cool montage of himself making and enjoying coffee.

[@Drew_lininger]

Weeeellllll it was hard buuutt I'm going to say Alec won this one.😂

[@TheIdeasGuy]

I love the fact that you both had issues but managed to solve them and finish right on time. Alec’s punch looks awesome but I kind of feel like Will’s would be nicer to use. Simple, clean and easy to hold to whack whack on. I’d be hard pressed to decide who I feel won this challenge. Also, I had to laugh at how relaxed Will was with his coffees and then how rushed he was at the end. Not only does he have my sense of humour, he also approaches deadlines like I do haha