GIRL QUESTIONS AISHA MARRIAGE TO PROPHET PBUH - SPEAKERS CORNER

#ISLAM #MUSLIM #QURAN
Download Quranly on Android & IOS & build a habit reading the Quran: linktr.ee/Quranly

[@AliDawah]

Download Quranly on Android & IOS & build a habit reading the Quran: linktr.ee/Quranly

[@thebesttruth4659]

Pray for🇵🇰🇵🇰Ex pm imran khan in Jail May Allah protect innocent family😔 in PakistaaN...

[@hanimazen5717]

Brother Ali, I am not sure if this is a valid point and also excuse my English. Wasn't maturity back then easily achievable since there is no school or the need to write or read? What did Aisha(ra) need to wait for her accounting degree? Same goes for the house responsibilities there are no chemicals to clean or big kitchens to deal with. It was like pick up the dates milk that sheep and here is your dinner. If she waited until she is 16 like this girl perhaps asking for then what is the change other than wasting 7 extra years ?

[@taasmr4203]

*Ali Dawah, please have Mohammad Hijab to watch this video as well. An Egyptian guy moves to America on Student Visa and gets married to a 15 year old White girl when he was 30 years old. After getting married, they gave birth to two daughters and one son. One of the daughters who physically looked more beautiful, European, and hot became a sexual object of a Hispanic America guy's materialist affection. Her Egyptian father was not okay with her daughter's affair with that materialist Hispanic guy, so he tried to stop her and moved to another city in order to keep her away from the Hispanic guy, but the Hispanic guy kept calling her and kept applying his pick up lines and pick up lies. The Egyptian father then shot his both daughters to death and fled to some unknown place. He was captured by authorities after several years. In this video the admin of the channel is referring the daughters as "American born Egyptian girl" while he is referring the Hispanic guy as a "American guy" while no one is real American in America except of "Native Indians/Red Indians." After both daughters were killed the brother of those two murdered girls told the Hispanic guy that he is the one who got his sister killed because he was kept calling her knowingly that their Egyptian father wasn't happy about it, so instead of saying sorry, the Hispanic guy hit of may be tried to hit the brother of those girls. And way, please watch this video now.* kzbin.info/www/bejne/rWjHioN6ZpiLoJYsi=d1-_EOV9dtkEg-Gk

[@taasmr4203]

Ali Dawah, please have Mohammad Hijab to watch this video as well. An Egyptian guy moves to America on Student Visa and gets married to a 15 year old White girl when he was 30 years old. After getting married, they gave birth to two daughters and one son. One of the daughters who physically looked more beautiful, European, and hot became a sexual object of a Hispanic America guy's materialist affection. Her Egyptian father was not okay with her daughter's affair with that materialist Hispanic guy, so he tried to stop her and moved to another city in order to keep her away from the Hispanic guy, but the Hispanic guy kept calling her and kept applying his pick up lines and pick up lies. The Egyptian father then shot his both daughters to death and fled to some unknown place. He was captured by authorities after several years. In this video the admin of the channel is referring the daughters as "American born Egyptian girl" while he is referring the Hispanic guy as a "American guy" while no one is real American in America except of "Native Indians/Red Indians." After both daughters were killed the brother of those two murdered girls told the Hispanic guy that he is the one who got his sister killed because he was kept calling her knowingly that their Egyptian father wasn't happy about it, so instead of saying sorry, the Hispanic guy hit of may be tried to hit the brother of those girls. And way, please watch this video now. kzbin.info/www/bejne/rWjHioN6ZpiLoJYsi=d1-_EOV9dtkEg-Gk

[@rakiri209]

@@hanimazen5717 its not as simple as picking food up, most the time crops had to be harvested, grains would have to be grinded by hand or stone, then cooked and thats only for the process of making bread. You still find similar difficulties in poorer countries

[@Skryzeeful]

the age of consent in US was 10 just 200 years ago for 37 states. age of consent for various countries currently are 12,14,16,18 and so forth. Islam doesnt fit one shoe on everything, it doesnt put a number, rather it puts conditions and rules in place that must be met which can then be applied anywhere at anytime. such rules are the woman cannot be harmed, it must be consensual, then you ofc u got Wali present, life span back then was literally 30-35 years, and the best argument ive come across is the fact that despite the prophet saws having many enemies . enemies who hated him, would torture and massacre his companions and spend decades persecuting and trying to assassinate the prophet saws, they would ridicule even his name every chance they get, these enemies who hated him this much but have never questioned or attacked his marraige with Aisha R.A, goes to show that people apply something called presentism , applying todays views and morals onto the past when society, practises, culture, everything was literallyn different, you cant equate two dynamics that are different

[@HamidAbu7]

That is a logical answer and an amazing comment

[@jingtroc23]

Laws are put there because a lot of men have no morals or standards. A child is a child, and if you need a law to tell you that, there's something dark and disturbing about you, your parents failed you. God says he loves children and they're to be protected, not made into sexual love objects. Even 1000 years ago, it wasn't okay to have sexual relations with a child but those who did had no soul, so would destroy a child's soul by making them lustful through grooming. If the age of consent in the UK was dropped to 10 years old, you'd see a lot of mans true colours. Failed humanity, and God will prove it and destroy those for it.

[@officialfrass]

This is a nonsense response comparing the kafirs law with the law of Allah 😂😂😂 Allah should have known that a 53 year old sleeping with a 9 year old would scientifically proven to be dangerous

[@m3ga975]

@@officialfrass Bruh you are literally engaging the fallacy he just mentioned do you not read before you reply??

[@Nikuzo]

that guy is just being stupid for the sake of it, ignore these kinds of people​@@m3ga975

[@asdfevsa]

I think the sister was genuine and open minded with her questioning. Also it should be said that victims of child abuse and pedophilia are almost always broken people that have undergone trauma. Aisha (ra) was the complete opposite, she was a very illustrious figure in Islam and probably the most knowledgeable scholar of her time.

[@NationalistIndian89]

So you do accept she was a recipient of pedophilia 😂

[@pedrofernandes2466]

So she was a victim of pedophilia who wasn't defined by her trauma, but still a victim?

[@MoeCamera]

Man, these people are obsessed with Aisha but never question Rebecca or Joseph who was 90 that married a 12 year old

[@HamzaTheLion16]

Exactly

[@VanillaSky666]

Dont cover both sides.

[@ZKTHE1STT]

​@TrueIslamVsDirtyMufti-xc8nb the parent can consent on behalf of the child but it can only be consummated after puberty

[@user-yd3uh4pz5e]

Show me the verse. Prove it.

[@user-yd3uh4pz5e]

@@ZKTHE1STT Would you be willing to ask a father to Mary his 6 year old if you were actively looking for marriage?

[@belalmiah980]

If they believe the Hadith of Aisha r.a age, why don't they believe in the Hadith affirming the Prophethood of The Prophet pbuh

[@hutao646]

Becausw they don't seek truth. They hate Islam.

[@tamanwar203]

It's not that we believe in this hadith more than in any other one, it's just that we live in the same world than people who believe this hadith is true and according to which you have to adapt our legal system.

[@belalmiah980]

@@tamanwar203 according to Islamic law, you abide by the rules of the country that you live in.

[@Naimedclaiming]

@@tamanwar203but you believe in a Hadith when Aisha RA was 9 but not when the moon was split

[@tamanwar203]

@@belalmiah980 When you live in a non Muslim country.

[@SogMasterz0]

No one had a problem with the prophet's marriage until 1948

[@drmoayad]

@@TrueIslamVsDirtyMufti-xc8nb You clearly did not watch the video. A 6 year old today is nothing like a 6 year old back then.

[@user-yd3uh4pz5e]

@@drmoayad Would you be willing to ask a father to Mary his 6 year old if you were actively looking for marriage?

[@ashj5952]

@@TrueIslamVsDirtyMufti-xc8nb 1400 years ago at the time of the Prophet pbuh people were of sound judgement at the age of puberty. In the case of Ayesha, it was 9 allegedly

[@Chiraqfan.]

@@ashj5952I have a question sincerely if he wasn’t your prophet would you defend him like this or are you biased and you are blindly defending him ?

[@ashj5952]

@@Chiraqfan. If he wasn't my prophet of course I wouldn't be talkingabout him so much but even as a normal person from that time, the stuff I have read about him I would definitely say that he was a truly inspirational personality and a very good sensible person that changed the course of a whole society indulged in all sorts of oppressive practices like burying baby girls as soon as they are born, etc. The marriage of Ayesha, even if I didn't believe him to be a prophet, is simply not wrong. She was the mentally and physically mature for marriage at that age because at that time people matured earlier. So yes, I wouldn't be defending him like this because I woldn't even be talking about him. But if you believe him to just be a normal person then he's a saint for a normal person. The man singlehandedly defeated oppression and laid down foundations for empires to come. He was raised in that very same society where people were sex addicts, alcoholics and murderers. If he wanted to do something malicious he'd have no problem doing that without Islam. He was from a very well-respected tribe and they offered him wealth, leadership of Mecca, and any women that he'd ask for to simply abandon Islam (because it was hurting them economically). And he rejected that.

[@tornimate]

Westerners be really talking about the age of marriage of Aisha at 9 when they had their legal age of marriage at 7 not very long time ago. 🤦‍♂

[@Abdur-Rahman862]

They don't have an objective source of morality. Just 20 years ago it was shameful for a man to penetrate another man. Today its celebrated and you can lose your job if you oppose it. Kuffar have no foundation.

[@youtubeaccountt1]

muslims really act like mohamd is so chosen yet they compare the so called prophets actions to non prophets. so i guess with ur logic the prohet was wrong or right?

[@Abdur-Rahman862]

@@youtubeaccountt1 the prophet ﷺ was completely justified in his marriage to Aisha. What now?

[@youtubeaccountt1]

@@Abdur-Rahman862 Nothing now i dont understand how u can defend it

[@youtubeaccountt1]

@@Abdur-Rahman862 I have question for you? If jeasus is the greatest prophet why do you muslims never say peace be upon him when you mention his name? And also why is muhamd mentioned always as "Your prophet" becouse jeasus is also suppoed to be yours?

[@Faruk1189]

My grandma got married when she was 12, and that’s less then 100 years ago

[@CheekyTop]

🤢

[@doomdesire3460]

​@@CheekyTop My grandma was also 12 Cope

[@haifaabdullah5062]

my grandma was 9

[@tamanwar203]

Welp, that's not good.

[@pessimistkai5569]

I am sure a lot of grandmas and great grandmas for married at 12. People are ignorant.

[@naehalmulazim]

Killing a six year old in a car (Hind Rajab) should have outraged far more people if they care this much about six year old girls and their marriage.

[@tamannatasnim9672]

exactly.. the hypocrisy is shameless

[@cobraxp6290]

True brother, they just are trying their best to make a bad image about our prophet, but they always fail, because they dont listen to the entire story of his marriage of Aisha, they just found out that he married aisha at age of 9years and started to spread this uncomplete story for evil purposes

[@Radec913]

U know, it is getting real tiring as a muslim to keep hearing about Aisha's (ra) age at marriage..... when her age at marriage has no consequence on the beliefs in islam. Such as tawhid, piety, living a dignified life, hellfire, heaven, day of judgement, consciousness of Allah.......... It amazes me that the above topics are less interesing for the disbelievers than the age of marriage.

[@hakaishinvegeta5114]

Its always about prophet Muhammed S.A.W. but no one mentioned the amount of wifes prophet Süleyman A.S. had or even Ishac A.S. at the age of 40 and married a 3 year old. Or even the fact that in 1885 the legal age of marriage in in the US was 7 years old. But noooo because Islam and muslims they have to make up things to attack us but they dont look at these facts. Becouse they are the biggest hypocrites.

[@FFTuk]

@Radec913 I think the point is that you can’t trust the message if you can’t trust the messenger. Jesus never had any stigma surrounding him, even his enemies couldn’t really pin much on him other than not accepting the Roman leader as his King. All the other issues that you mentioned are secondary to the one who is teaching it, unless you follow the message on those topics from one of the older monotheistic religions (unless we go down the route of calling Islam the timeless message etc). Peace

[@hakaishinvegeta5114]

@@FFTuk You say that but why is than no one talking about the fact that the prophet Solomon had about 700 wives and 300 minaretes. And the youngest was 14 year old. Or the fact that prophet Isaac was 40 when he married a 3 year old Rebecca. Or 90 year old prophet Joseph with married a 12 year old ACCORDING to the BIBLE. I tell you why that is. Its because you guys are hypocrites and only look at excuses to attack Islam.

[@tamanwar203]

As a disbeliever, I'm interested in these topics too. It's just that if you consider it legal to have an intercourse with a girl just because she seems to agree, because her parents agree and because she has her periods, then you can technically marry a 6 years old.

[@mdaaiyan1636]

She has to be developed both physically and mentally which is impossible in case of 6 yr. Also their marraige had a purpose. It's not today's purpose type. To have children, raise families. It was to upgrade religious teachings. Currently there's no religious purpose for any adult man to marry a young girl. So there's no need to agree on that type of marriage, not to mention it is illegal by law.​@@tamanwar203

[@olaiwonbolanle6762]

May Allah S.W.T strengthen us as Muslims and Make the unbelievers believers.

[@user-xf3cu4le5z]

Not going to do it by supporting jihad and Sharia law

[@HamzaTheLion16]

Ameen

[@user-xf3cu4le5z]

Quit trying to force Islam on everyone.

[@Sarah_9801]

Ameen

[@user-yz3kb1cx2q]

​@@user-xf3cu4le5zuse your mind.

[@SogMasterz0]

Rebecca was 3 years old when she was married to Isaac Mary mother of Jesus was 12 years old when she married Joseph

[@user-yd3uh4pz5e]

Prove it by sharing the verses.

[@JamesJohnson-pz8pu]

Typical pathetic stupid argument you won’t find any reference to anywhere! Without lies Islam dies

[@JamesJohnson-pz8pu]

They can’t

[@highclass7393]

@@JamesJohnson-pz8pu Genesis 24:15-20

[@highclass7393]

simple math:Sarah was 90 when Abraham was 100 (Genesis 17:17).Abraham was 100 when Isaac was born (Genesis 21:5).Sarah died at aged 127 (Genesis 23:1-2) [Thus, Isaac would be 37 as 127-90=37]Isaac was 40 when he married Rebekah (Genesis 25:20)Abraham told others about Rebekah’s birth when Sarah was 127 (So, Rebekah was born the same year that Sarah died, and therefore Isaac would have been 37).

[@esahg5421]

messtern culture says marriage is consent for intercourse. in islam marriage is a care contract. the s*x part is always the womans concern never the man for she alone knows when the best time for such things are. why do they never read the haadiths of Ayesha (r.a)?

[@Chinx231]

Why do you make such a long thing out of it when you can just say “if marrying at 9 was so bad why did your ancestors carry this on for 900 years after Islam” The prophet ﷺ could LEGALLY marry Aisha r.a at 9 in Europe all they way till 19th century This argument from white Europeans is honestly hilarious

[@irfanhakimi7172]

I don't understand why non Muslim think marriage= sex and nothing else. Marriage is a relationship with love and responsibility not just intercourse. And even if it is why would they have a problem with it when they are completely okay with fornication? So you're telling me having a relationship is too much of a responsibility for a mature 17 year old but the action of making babies isn't? The double standards are ridiculous.

[@pessimistkai5569]

Because insecurity.

[@truthboom]

gr00med love 😂😂😂 🤮🤮🤮

[@pedrofernandes2466]

Nine years old, dude.

[@doomdesire3460]

@@pedrofernandes2466 she was baligh doesn't matter what u say She wasn't told by the west "when Ur 18 u can make decisions" She started her role as a woman like many women at the time did.

[@pedrofernandes2466]

​@@doomdesire3460Nine years old.

[@Wayne_jetski]

Blurring out a woman’s arm in the UK is hella weird let’s be honest 😂

[@soldierof-allah11]

we are muslims. We dont show immodesty

[@api645]

@@soldierof-allah11😂😂😂 ok weirdo

[@TruseQ]

@@api645 its weird to cover up a woman’s body? But it isn’t weird to wear crop tops and short shorts.😂

[@soldierof-allah11]

@@api645 nakedness is okay but hijab is oppressive? You westerners need serious help

[@HeIsAllahTheOneAndOnly]

I love the way Uncle carrying the Flag of Palestine 🇵🇸 in lots of videos 😊

[@Pintexx]

I’m American and the age of consent here is 18. Subjective morality is complete nonsense! It should be the same age everywhere in the west if it was based on science or whatever they try to base it on but it’s not.

[@HassanAli-cc5vr]

To end this once and for all. In the name of God, the most merciful the especially merciful. Any truth I say now is from God, and anything I say which is falsehood, is from me, without the intention of misleading. Asma was born in 595 AD, she said she is 10 years older than her half sister Aisha, meaning Aisha would've been born around in 605 AD. Aisha and Muhammad (PBUH) were married at around 622-624. She was around 17-19. In a book about the biography of muhammed by Ibn Ishaq, he said: in the first year of the declaration of Islam (610 AD) he listed all names who accepted islam during that year, if we were to conclude Aisha married Muhammed at 6 years old in 622-624 AD then "little Aisha" wouldn't have been able to accept Islam in 610 AD (she wouldn't even exist) these are all from muslim sources. Further, ALL sahih hadiths that say she was 9 are all narrated by Hisham ibn Urwah in the chain of narration. Hisham bin Urwah is the common narrator in the chain of the hadith which says Hazrat Aisha was 6 when her Nikah was performed. Hisham's life is divided into two periods: in 131 A.H. the Madani period ended, and the Iraqi period started, when Hisham was 71 years old. Hafiz Zehbi has spoken about Hisham’s loss of memory in his later period. His students in Madina, Imam Malik and Imam Abu Hanifah, do not mention this hadith. Why? Imam Malik and the people of Madina criticised him for his Iraqi hadiths. All the narrators of this hadith are Iraqis who had heard it from Hisham. Allama Kandhulvi says that the words spoken in connection with Hazrat Aisha’s age were tissa ashara meaning 19, when Hisham only heard (or remembered), tissa, meaning nine. Maulana Usmani thinks this change was purposely and maliciously made later. "Maalik was not pleased with him. However, Hisham is honest and his narrations are considered to be amongst the authentic hadeeths. I was advised that Maalik did not like him because of his hadeeths to the people of Iraq. He went to Kufa three times. Once he said “My father told me that he heard Aishah…,” the next time he narrated the same hadeeth saying, “My father told me that Aishah…” and the third time he said, “My father narrated that Aishah…” " There are other hadith in Bukhari where Bukhari specifically noted that Hisham forgot such and such or was unsure of whether something was this or that. This is proof that while he may not have known of Hisham's memory loss itself (which would disqualify his Hisham ibn Urwah as a reliable source as it would violate Bukhari's standards for hadith that he outlined) he however did find and know that Hisham had forgotten something, which only goes to show that Hisham did in fact have memory loss. Ibn Ishaq in his Sirat Rasul Allah has given a list of people who accepted Islam in first year of the proclamation of Islam (610), in which Hazrat Aisha’s name is mentioned as Abu Bakr’s “little daughter Aisha”. If we accept Hisham’s calculations, she was not even born at that time. Some time after the death of the Prophet’s first wife, Hazrat Khadija, Khawla suggested to the Prophet that he get married again, to a bikrun, referring to Hazrat Aisha (Musnad Ahmed). In Arabic bikrun is used for an unmarried girl who has crossed the age of puberty and is of marriageable age. The word cannot be used for a six-year-old girl. Some scholars think that Hazrat Aisha was married off so early because in Arabia girls mature at an early age. But this was not a common custom of the Arabs at that time. According to Allama Kandhulvi there is no such case on record either before or after Islam. Neither has this ever been promoted as a Sunnah of Prophet. The Prophet married off his daughters Fatima at 21 and Ruquiyya at 23. Besides, Hazrat Abu Bakr, Aisha’s father, married off his eldest daughter Asma at 26. Hazrat Aisha narrates that she was present on the battlefield at the Battle of Badar (Muslim). This leads one to conclude that Hazrat Aisha moved into the Prophet’s house in 1 A.H. But a nine-year-old could not have been taken on a rough and risky military mission. In 2 A.H, the Prophet refused to take boys of less than 15 years of age to the battle of Uhud. Would he have allowed a 10-year-old girl to accompany him? But Anas reported that he saw Aisha and Umme Sulaim carrying goatskins full of water and serving it to the soldiers (Bukhari). Umme Sulaim and Umme Ammara, the other women present at Uhud, were both strong, mature women whose duties were the lifting of the dead and injured, treating their wounds, carrying water in heavy goatskins, supplying ammunition and even taking up the sword. Hazrat Aisha’s nephew Urwah once remarked that he was not surprised about her amazing knowledge of Islamic law, poetry and history because she was wife of the Prophet and daughter of Abu Bakr. If she was 8 when her father migrated, when did she learn poetry and history from him? Thus Hisham is the common man in all the lines of chain of narration of the hadith which mentions her age as six. Hisham's authenticity is challenged, for it does not correlate with the many historical facts of the time. www.dawn.com/news/696084/ofaishas-age-at-marriage safiyyahsabreen.medium.com/aisha-ra-was-19-when-the-prophet-%EF%B7%BA-married-her-4afc660865f8 Graph of dates: www.newageislam.com/picture_library/Aisha_RA_Age_NewAgeIslam.jpg

[@4d774]

so, americans back 200years ago ware all child lovers right? George Washington, to who ever........ don't run away from or own history . you cannot fake it .

[@cyberyousef7519]

Ok lets clear some stuff First, the marriage wasn’t consummated when Aisha was 6, and the hadith about playing with dolls was when she was 6 before puberty, she even said it herself Second stop comparing the kids raised on iPads/phones/cartoons and junk food to people raised in the desert, with actual life experiences and skills, and raised to be responsible with healthy food and real raw milk Third, according to biology and science, after the age of puberty and during menstruation, the body of a woman produces eggs, estrogen and pregnancy hormones?! And the body starts forming something called the corpus luteum which will contain the egg cell after it get fertilized, ofc it degenerate if the egg wasn’t fertilized, and that is the blood that comes monthly btw, but the question is, if they were actually a minor why would the body do that?? Forth, in every religion, in every country and nation in the world before the British Empire, and even to today’s primal humans, the age of consent is puberty, its only no longer the case in the last century after the west forced its values on all the world 5th, from the feats and the stuff aisha have done, we can know that she definitely was mature and knew what was happening, also if prophet muhammad was a pdf file according to them, why didn’t he do it at 6? Since a pdf file would do it at 6? 6th according to the google definition of pdf file, its the attraction towards prepubescent individuals, so the person who invented the word pdf file wouldn’t call the prophet a pdf file 7th, in Christianity Rebecca was 3-8 and marry was 11, and even non religious people can’t escape from this, because they believe in evolution, and it looks like their evolution didn’t mind it since i explained it biologically above Extra: the reason they are considered children now days is because of the way of raising, unhealthy food, ipad, cartoons, zero life experiences and skills, barely any sun exposure, also no responsibility, ofc you won’t be an adult when you hit puberty when your mom still makes your bed, also the 18 law has its influence, Parents themselves started believing that you are a child until 18, so they started treating you accordingly, therefore that became reality, sadly

[@cyberyousef7519]

True, its not based on science In my opinion the age of consent should be 15+ even in todays world Because there is a hadith of the prophet saying even if they didn’t hit puberty, they are complete adults after 15 Second stop comparing the kids raised on iPads/phones/cartoons and junk food to people raised in the desert, with actual life experiences and skills, and raised to be responsible with healthy food and real raw milk Third, according to biology and science, after the age of puberty and during menstruation, the body of a woman produces eggs, estrogen and pregnancy hormones?! And the body starts forming something called the corpus luteum which will contain the egg cell after it get fertilized, ofc it degenerate if the egg wasn’t fertilized, and that is the blood that comes monthly btw, but the question is, if they were actually a minor why would the body do that?? 5th, from the feats and the stuff aisha have done, we can know that she definitely was mature and knew what was happening, also if prophet muhammad was a pdf file according to them, why didn’t he do it at 6? Since a pdf file would do it at 6? 6th according to the google definition of pdf file, its the attraction towards prepubescent individuals, so the person who invented the word pdf file wouldn’t call the prophet a pdf file 7th, in Christianity Rebecca was 3-8 and marry was 11, and even non religious people can’t escape from this, because they believe in evolution, and it like their evolution didn’t mind it since i explained it biologically above

[@Pintexx]

@@cyberyousef7519 brother, why would you copy paste this under my comment? Not relevant to my comment.

[@h..1234]

Isabella of Valois (aged 6) was married to Richard II of England (aged 29) in October 1396. Why is it always the Muslims? Look up history books and then I’ll see that it’s not only prophet Muhammad pbuh

[@maxr247]

It's still wrong bro. What you just mentioned & Aisha & Mohammad's case are completely disgusting. Don't wish this upon anyone. On what grounds are you counting maturity because he's like she's physically & emotionally mature. When is a 9 yr old or a 6 yr old girl physically mature? She's only starting to mature & that means her periods aren't regular, she's only starting to grow her breasts & she's not fully developed to take a adult guys thing in there. Do you not see how disgusting this is? We learn biology in high school, so how come ppl like him don't know? Just goes to show that ppl will support pedophilia no matter what.

[@ranaselim1805]

Because they are always trying so hard to make our religion looks abusing to women. They ignore everything that happens on the world today that is horrific and how islam defend it and just stick to the minors and make it a big deal. Islam never supported killing of children or women even if their men are fighting the muslims in their land. Their "Fitra" is totally erased in a way that they can't see the reasoning behind it. Indeed, it is not the eyes that are blind, but it is the hearts in the chests that grow blind. I feel pity for them all that people who do dawah and all that warnings and still not listening. It's all written in their books and Allah will ask them all about not listening. May Allah guide us all. Ameen.

[@anastasia-fr1gn]

Richard II was wrong to marry a child and so was Mohammed. The fact you have to justify your “perfect” prophet by using a kufr as an example is hilarious and scary. You truly will defend any moral relativism as long as Mohammed did it. Jesus is the true perfection. He never married a child, never killed and offered kindness and compassion. 🕊️

[@gladiatorjam3594]

She is clearly doesn’t know what it’s to be an adult. Should explain that to her brother

[@finklechomsky2992]

Very good argument with valid points 👏 👏 👏

[@sharief87]

Firstly, the age of Aisha is not known, it could be between 9 to 18, but this girl just doing the same this like Pierce Morgan, do you condem Hummus

[@muslimninja9017]

May Allah SWT guide that sister to Islam Aameen ❤

[@rosyclozyfan]

ew

[@muslimninja9017]

@@rosyclozyfan worshipping the one true God is far better than worshipping a man who got killed by Romans.

[@tiaras553]

This man had to shield her arm from the eyes of his fellow pdf file islamic brothers😆.

[@Alnasir777]

It's important to understand that the Prophet Muhammad's marriage to Aisha was not questioned until much later in history. Aisha had even been engaged to Jubayr ibn Mut'im before their parents mutually decided to cancel it. Marriages at a young age were typical in that era. To put it into perspective, many notable historical figures also married very young: King Richard II married Isabella of Valois when she was 6, Emperor Akbar married Ruqaiya Sultan Begum at 9, and King John of England married Isabella of Angoulême when she was about 12. Such practices were commonplace across different cultures and times.

[@deustchedeustche2378]

وفقكم الله

[@aiyubpatel9165]

King Richard II of England married Isabelle of Valois when she was 6 in 1392. Nearly 700 years after the Prophet(PBUH). Richard II only loved until he was 33. Isabelle lived only until she was 19. This supposed issue is a complete distraction and the intention is to bring into question the morality, integrity and reality of whether our Beloved Prophet(PBUH) was really a man of G-d due to his marriage to Hadhrat Aisha(R.A). When you have a culture where marriage is seen as a piece of paper. I really do not understand from which Glass House these people are coming and throwing stones

[@Mason-626]

That's a terrible comparison because king richard was not seen as the perfect man whose moral example is applicable throughout time like muslims believe muhammed is

[@aysmch622]

​​@@Mason-626so you mean as long it was the prophet you can blame it But if it king of some country you cannot blame it??? Hmmm what double standart

[@yasararif8292]

She was engaged by her parents to someone else before the prophet married her. Thant engagement was broken and her father and mother decided for her to be the mother of the nation by marrying the prophet. She lived 40 years after the prophet as a widow teaching intricate matters about the religion and his beautiful character.

[@Mohanad_YT]

The woman has to be ready physically and mentally for her to be able to get married. Back then people were physically and mentally ready way before, you had men at 16 leading armies (meaning the argument would fall under the fallacy of presentism)

[@stageiiwappie950]

This was normal worldwide in medieval times

[@WeatherxCalipha]

And we've since evolved beyond those primitive ideologies; there's no need to defend them today.

[@stageiiwappie950]

@@WeatherxCalipha there both no need to defend or defame it since it was normal back then but we dont do it today

[@pedrofernandes2466]

So your religion does not have an objective set of laws that protect children from marrying 50 y.o. men? Eww

[@mytube1298]

​@@WeatherxCalipha today's age of consent of 18 is actually an outcome of British child prostitution which plagued British society. So they came up with rising the age of consent to protect the children

[@cyberyousef7519]

Ok lets clear some stuff First, the marriage wasn’t consummated when Aisha was 6, and the hadith about playing with dolls was when she was 6 before puberty, she even said it herself Second stop comparing the kids raised on iPads/phones/cartoons and junk food to people raised in the desert, with actual life experiences and skills, and raised to be responsible with healthy food and real raw milk Third, according to biology and science, after the age of puberty and during menstruation, the body of a woman produces eggs, estrogen and pregnancy hormones?! And the body starts forming something called the corpus luteum which will contain the egg cell after it get fertilized, ofc it degenerate if the egg wasn’t fertilized, and that is the blood that comes monthly btw, but the question is, if they were actually a minor why would the body do that?? Forth, in every religion, in every country and nation in the world before the British Empire, and even to today’s primal humans, the age of consent is puberty, its only no longer the case in the last century after the west forced its values on all the world 5th, from the feats and the stuff aisha have done, we can know that she definitely was mature and knew what was happening, also if prophet muhammad was a pdf file according to them, why didn’t he do it at 6? Since a pdf file would do it at 6? 6th according to the google definition of pdf file, its the attraction towards prepubescent individuals, so the person who invented the word pdf file wouldn’t call the prophet a pdf file 7th, in Christianity Rebecca was 3-8 and marry was 11, and even non religious people can’t escape from this, because they believe in evolution, and it looks like their evolution didn’t mind it since i explained it biologically above Extra: the reason they are considered children now days is because of the way of raising, unhealthy food, ipad, cartoons, zero life experiences and skills, barely any sun exposure, also no responsibility, ofc you won’t be an adult when you hit puberty when your mom still makes your bed, also the 18 law has its influence, Parents themselves started believing that you are a child until 18, so they started treating you accordingly, therefore that became reality, sadly

[@AbjectTestament.]

Muhammad (pbuh) didn't married Aisha A.S. at 6 but he was engaged to her at 6 but he married her when she was physically mature, when she was 9. But you may think that still wrong but the thing is that was 1400 years ago. A KZbinr named vsauce also talked about how the people started growing younger n stuff (this also May be a bit unrelated) Also I think I should add this an you can look it up too In 1885 in the US the legal Age of consent was 10 to 12 with the exception of state of Delaware which was 7 years old I should also add that the age of mary according to the earliest Christian manuscript was 12 years old whereas Joseph was 90 Isaac as married a 3 year old Rebecca when he was 40 source:rashi commentary genesis 25:20 So back than it was considered normal but ofc today is different

[@documentthedrama8279]

2 things 1. she was playing with dolls when they consumed the marriage- so was she physically mature and commiting shirk, or was she a child 2, he is supposed to be an example for all time. he obviously isnt

[@baccadaa]

Joseph was not 90 when he married Mary he was in his late 20-30’s and Mary was between 13-16. For being a messenger of god you guys compare mortal sinful beings a lot to make up for his righteousness

[@AbjectTestament.]

@@baccadaa rashi's commentary a rabbi himself stated that look it up "rashi commentary gen 25 20"

[@AbjectTestament.]

​@@documentthedrama8279​so was rebbeca

[@olasam94]

​@@documentthedrama8279don't forget how he prevented Ali from marrying fatima saying that she was too young

[@jigsaw666puppet]

This question has become legitimately exhausting. Thank you @AliDawah for educating the islamophobes n such. God Bless

[@mytube1298]

The people who ask these ridiculous questions are actually ignorant and lack basic historical knowledge about the age of consent.

[@Abdur-Rahman862]

Unfortunately, a lot of us crumble and become apologetic about it. If we learned our Deen and defended it no matter what, these questions would stop.

[@database_man1062]

This really just shows that Muhammad was just another man of his time, nothing special and certainly not a messanger of god

[@soldierof-allah11]

Of course not you are extremely confused. Then what should have he done? Should he have done something unique like marrying a statue? Far greater is he than that!

[@DEVRAJSINGHFX]

Bro saying islam is goood 😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@enamulhaquejoy6962]

It is. It teaches a good lifestyle & not following your desires unlike hinduism.

[@api645]

@@enamulhaquejoy6962sex with kids ain’t a good lifestyle lil bro

[@AmicableAgnostic]

​@@enamulhaquejoy6962 yeh. It teaches pdf'olia is fine. What a noble teaching.

[@enamulhaquejoy6962]

@@AmicableAgnostic Can you show me where it teaches pdf? I can show you in the bible where it teach pdf is good.

[@AmicableAgnostic]

@@enamulhaquejoy6962 didn't your Quran tell u to follow your prophet? Didn't he sleep with a 9 yr old?

[@cagithedude]

She thinks that adult means 18. She can‘t understand how someone is 9 years old and an adult.

[@Abdur-Rahman862]

She lives in a society where "what is a woman?" is considered a legitimate question. Can't blame her.

[@sloopjb5359]

In Islam you are born as a baby, and as soon as your vagina can be entered you are an adult. No children, not prebubescents, no teenagers. Just newborn, and adult. Very good

[@animecomsparkle3919]

1. Sarah gave birth to Isaac at the age of ninety (Genesis 17).
2. Isaac was in his thirties when the incident of Mount Moriah occurred with his father, Abraham (Genesis 22).
3. Immediately after Isaac and Abraham’s incident on Mount Moriah, Rebecca is born (Genesis 22).
4. As soon as Rebecca’s birth is mentioned in Genesis 22, few verses down (next chapter), we read that Sarah died at the age of 127 years old (Genesis 23:1-3).
5. At the time of Sarah’s death, Isaac would be have been 37-years-old.
6. Isaac married Rebecca at the age of 40 (Genesis 25:20), this would show from the Bible that Rebecca was only three years old, given that she was only born three years prior, just after the Mount Moriah incident and the death of Sarah.

[@agnieszkagauthier8997]

His explanations are pathetic. Also, it was said that Allah forbade anyone marrying the wives of prophets.

[@lurdkatmin3298]

Explain how they are pathetic. Also, are you aware of the fact that his wives were given the opportunity for divorce, but that they remained with him? Probably not because you're an idiot who hasn't done his research

[@Freedomforeverall]

That you dont know who Akon is HIT DIFFERENT!!! We're getting old guys hahaha

[@Freedomforeverall]

first and second comment. May Allah bless you Ali!!

[@Kolaalok]

​@@Freedomforeverall who didnt know who Akon was?

[@ivanos_95]

You can't be serious about love in case of a 6yo girl, because children are very ease to imanipulate, especially when manipulation comes from wealthy men in power, and when their parents are supporting the abusers for economic or political reasons, please stop using those terrible excuses for child-abuse.

[@lurdkatmin3298]

You're essentially just arguing in bad faith. You have no evidence that abuse, manipulation, or pursuit of "economic or political reasons" were involved, you're just speculating for the sake of speculation. Do you think the virgins in Numbers 31 were manipulated when the Israelites took them "for themselves"?

[@ivanos_95]

@@lurdkatmin3298 We know that Aisha was too young for marriage, so she was manipulated, and we know that her parents supported the marriage, either for economic or political reasons. No, there was no need for any manipulation, because the virgins were taken by force into slavery.

[@lurdkatmin3298]

@@ivanos_95 You've just reasserted what you originally said lmao, you haven't presented anything other than assertions. "So she was manipulated." Again, you can say that about anything you don't like, without proof this is just an argument in bad faith. I could even make the argument that Mary (who was 12) was "manipulated" into wanting to have Jesus after she became pregnant with him, but that's just retarded. "Her parents supported the marriage, either for economic or political reasons." No proof, PROVE IT, if you don't provide me with evidence I'm done talking to you. And I meant when the young midianite girls were taken as wives and concubines after that, do you think their new Israelite husbands manipulated them at all? What do you think happened there lol?

[@cyberyousef7519]

Ok lets clear some stuff First, the marriage wasn’t consummated when Aisha was 6, and the hadith about playing with dolls was when she was 6 before puberty, she even said it herself Second stop comparing the kids raised on iPads/phones/cartoons and junk food to people raised in the desert, with actual life experiences and skills, and raised to be responsible with healthy food and real raw milk Third, according to biology and science, after the age of puberty and during menstruation, the body of a woman produces eggs, estrogen and pregnancy hormones?! And the body starts forming something called the corpus luteum which will contain the egg cell after it get fertilized, ofc it degenerate if the egg wasn’t fertilized, and that is the blood that comes monthly btw, but the question is, if they were actually a minor why would the body do that?? Forth, in every religion, in every country and nation in the world before the British Empire, and even to today’s primal humans, the age of consent is puberty, its only no longer the case in the last century after the west forced its values on all the world 5th, from the feats and the stuff aisha have done, we can know that she definitely was mature and knew what was happening, also if prophet muhammad was a pdf file according to them, why didn’t he do it at 6? Since a pdf file would do it at 6? 6th according to the google definition of pdf file, its the attraction towards prepubescent individuals, so the person who invented the word pdf file wouldn’t call the prophet a pdf file 7th, in Christianity Rebecca was 3-8 and marry was 11, and even non religious people can’t escape from this, because they believe in evolution, and it looks like their evolution didn’t mind it since i explained it biologically above Extra: the reason they are considered children now days is because of the way of raising, unhealthy food, ipad, cartoons, zero life experiences and skills, barely any sun exposure, also no responsibility, ofc you won’t be an adult when you hit puberty when your mom still makes your bed, also the 18 law has its influence, Parents themselves started believing that you are a child until 18, so they started treating you accordingly, therefore that became reality, sadly

[@cyberyousef7519]

Also one thing to add When aisha was 13 she was accused of doing zina with another man If she was a child they wouldn’t think that

[@poenix_url3618]

The prophet’sﷺ marriage to Aisha(RA) explained Around 1,400 years ago in Arabia, documentation of exact ages wasn't as common or standardized as it is today. However, people might have had rough estimates of their ages based on significant life events or lunar calendars. But when it comes to marriage in Islam, age is almost completely irrelevant because there is no “one age fits all.” that’s why our criteria for marriage is mental and physical maturity. Aisha(RA) was most certainly both and if she wasn’t then her father, mother, herself, and the prophetﷺ all wouldn’t have come together and unanimously agreed to the marriage. If you still doubt this and possibly believe she was coerced into the marriage by a shared plot from her parents and the prophetﷺ then she could have easily spoke out about it after the prophet’sﷺ passing, however no such thing ever occurred but rather the polar opposite. Aisha(RA) narrated over 2,000+ Hadiths some of which containing confessions about her romantic love, affection, and jealousy towards the prophetﷺ… Islamophobes will always try to twist the story in a way that befits their own personal beliefs, propaganda, & delusions by hindering the full story, contexts, & reasonings.

[@Orgilemeplan472]

My grandmother also married when she was 9 years old and my grandfather was 35 years old at that time but we never questioned them cause they r common man right??

[@darkbyte6131]

Age of marriage in 1885 in the state of Delaware, the legal age was 7 years old.

[@bosnian_girlll]

Who cares - whoever made that law is not Gods law. Aisha was 6 and this is apparently Gods way - Gods rule and order. Don't compare Gods rules with some hippy in Delaware.

[@Christian225lbMax]

@@bosnian_girlll 9 not 6

[@bosnian_girlll]

@@Christian225lbMax She was 6 when she got married.

[@bosnian_girlll]

@@Christian225lbMax 6

[@Christian225lbMax]

@@bosnian_girlll she was 9 when she got married, the contract got signed at 6, what you an undercover serb or something lol

[@fatinwaseem8731]

Brother Ali could have elaborated more points to her. The fact that before marrying our prophet saw, Syeda Aisha RA was already engaged with Jubyr ibn Mut’im which was called off. This shows, it was a norm back then. Moreover, she was the most confident, outspoken and knowledgeable woman of her time, why? Because she stayed in the company of our prophet saw. Our prophet saw wasn’t also like a 50 year old of today, most athletic, attractive and handsome man anyone could imagine. Seeing the history from today’s lens is fallacy. This fallacy of presentism. And also don’t reduce Aisha RA to just a number. She was way above that. JazakAllah

[@FREEPALESTINEFTRTTS]

Marriage is a personal choice a person can accept and reject the marriage if they want to.. nobody is forced to marry anyone in Islam thats what people dont know or forget..

[@fedor6595]

Sure they’re not 😂 clown

[@Abdur-Rahman862]

They don't care. They're allies of shaytan.

[@gameoverfr1]

Assalamu alaykum brother! We need your help to raise awareness about the hijab ban in Tajikistan 🇹🇯. The government has banned wearing the hijab, and they are fining and arresting women who wear it on the streets. They have been trying for a long time to secularize the public and make them less religious. Men under 18 are not allowed to go to the mosque, teaching Tajweed is illegal, and men are not allowed to have beards. They imprison anyone who speaks out, and we don’t know what to do. Please pray for us and help spread the word!

[@FREEPALESTINEFTRTTS]

Your politicians are moronic hypocrites

[@aysmch622]

May ALLAH help Muslim and muslimah in Tajikistan,it is remind me of uiyghur Muslim people of china... 🤲🥺

[@gameoverfr1]

@@aysmch622 may Allah help the Muslims all around the world!

[@MaxStArlyn]

6:04 …9 yrs old, is not an adult, back then…or today.

[@AmicableAgnostic]

Never. These guys justifying it bcoz they can't even imagine that their prophet can do any wrong.

[@muhammadmads6006]

Read more buddy. Read Quran, Bible as well. You will find the answer. Just read 😊

[@AmicableAgnostic]

@@muhammadmads6006 Read something buddy. Read basic biology, psychology as well. You will understand why it's wrong. Just do basic research.

[@lurdkatmin3298]

@@AmicableAgnostic I said I was done talking with you because you ran from our conversation, failed to understand qiyas, and started yapping about taqiyya. But I have to respond to this lmao. If you had read up on basic biology and psychology you would know that people become sexually mature prior to set schooling ages in western societies. A good majority of people have actually lost their virginity prior to the age of consent, and if they're not dating they're watching pornography, statistically the average age kids start watching hardcore porn is around 10 years old. This is what a society breeds when you abolish the universal institution that has been in all traditional cultures, "child marriage".

[@AmicableAgnostic]

@@lurdkatmin3298 what a dumb argument. Kids start watching corm so start marrying them young? Dude, marrying them young is verse than watching corn. Just search in Google or chatgpt about why child marriage is wrong and u will get long list of issues. I'm sure u have never read it. Otherwise a sane person cannot say that child marriage is the solution to stop kids from watching corn.

[@sloopjb5359]

I think the sister left in shock

[@alberxenos]

السَّلاَمُ عَلَيْكُمْ وَرَحْمَةُ اللهِ وَبَرَكَاتُهُ Assalamu’alaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh

[@cccumberr572]

Justifying child abuse

[@doomdesire3460]

Abuse to a 17yrs old and 364 days is also child abuse But centuries ago 14yr old men were military leaders ...

[@Abdur-Rahman862]

You can't objectively define what a child is.

[@AmicableAgnostic]

​@@Abdur-Rahman862 science has already defined it. Atleast read basic biology and psychology before making such ignorant comments.

[@Abdur-Rahman862]

@@AmicableAgnostic you're lying to yourself. Science is the study of the observable.

[@AmicableAgnostic]

@@Abdur-Rahman862 child is not observable? 🤣🤣 Dude, science literally checks each organ to decides whether it's grown or not. That's how scientists know when a person is child or a matured. U don't even know basics bro.

[@WillScarlet1991]

The Islamophobes can't attack Islamic scripture so they go after the Messenger ﷺ - They really are so easy to argue against 😊

[@tamanwar203]

Depends how you define islamophobia.

[@truthboom]

pdfile law in islamic countries:

[@pedrofernandes2466]

Not really. You can't argue with people who are against pedophili@ and Win.

[@WillScarlet1991]

@@tamanwar203 Prejudice and bigotry against Muslims.

[@WillScarlet1991]

@@pedrofernandes2466 Any reason why you're applying the social and cultural norms of the 7th century to today? 🙄

[@Chris-sx4qw]

Where’s the full video.??

[@sloopjb5359]

He was raping her Hamas-style at the end of the video so we cant see it

[@lurdkatmin3298]

@@sloopjb5359 Hmmm... Was he raping her with his eyes like that duck-lipped woman in the "testimony" video said? Or was he raping her by not raping her? Or was he raping her by not offering her sweets...

[@scooupa]

Everyone make Dua for her so see can see the truth ameen 🤲🤲

[@MaxStArlyn]

2:35 Does this mean the Muslim prophet was the best example of some things, NOT all things, …for ALL time?

[@AmicableAgnostic]

Shh....don't ask such logical questions. It forces them to go in circles. 😂

[@olasam94]

But why are you using your everyday brain for reasoning on this channel 😂 Pull out the post dental work brain

[@aiyubpatel9165]

No, it means if you are sincere and really want to know the truth. You will see it was a consensual, normal and perfectly legitimate marriage. People in the west are obsessed with it because it makes them think they are more moral and pure. If you really believe in Jesus and his example then you should ALL be celibate. Jesus did not get married. So try and explain that

[@HassanAli-cc5vr]

To end this once and for all. In the name of God, the most merciful the especially merciful. Any truth I say now is from God, and anything I say which is falsehood, is from me, without the intention of misleading. Asma was born in 595 AD, she said she is 10 years older than her half sister Aisha, meaning Aisha would've been born around in 605 AD. Aisha and Muhammad (PBUH) were married at around 622-624. She was around 17-19. In a book about the biography of muhammed by Ibn Ishaq, he said: in the first year of the declaration of Islam (610 AD) he listed all names who accepted islam during that year, if we were to conclude Aisha married Muhammed at 6 years old in 622-624 AD then "little Aisha" wouldn't have been able to accept Islam in 610 AD (she wouldn't even exist) these are all from muslim sources. Further, ALL sahih hadiths that say she was 9 are all narrated by Hisham ibn Urwah in the chain of narration. Hisham bin Urwah is the common narrator in the chain of the hadith which says Hazrat Aisha was 6 when her Nikah was performed. Hisham's life is divided into two periods: in 131 A.H. the Madani period ended, and the Iraqi period started, when Hisham was 71 years old. Hafiz Zehbi has spoken about Hisham’s loss of memory in his later period. His students in Madina, Imam Malik and Imam Abu Hanifah, do not mention this hadith. Why? Imam Malik and the people of Madina criticised him for his Iraqi hadiths. All the narrators of this hadith are Iraqis who had heard it from Hisham. Allama Kandhulvi says that the words spoken in connection with Hazrat Aisha’s age were tissa ashara meaning 19, when Hisham only heard (or remembered), tissa, meaning nine. Maulana Usmani thinks this change was purposely and maliciously made later. "Maalik was not pleased with him. However, Hisham is honest and his narrations are considered to be amongst the authentic hadeeths. I was advised that Maalik did not like him because of his hadeeths to the people of Iraq. He went to Kufa three times. Once he said “My father told me that he heard Aishah…,” the next time he narrated the same hadeeth saying, “My father told me that Aishah…” and the third time he said, “My father narrated that Aishah…” " There are other hadith in Bukhari where Bukhari specifically noted that Hisham forgot such and such or was unsure of whether something was this or that. This is proof that while he may not have known of Hisham's memory loss itself (which would disqualify his Hisham ibn Urwah as a reliable source as it would violate Bukhari's standards for hadith that he outlined) he however did find and know that Hisham had forgotten something, which only goes to show that Hisham did in fact have memory loss. Ibn Ishaq in his Sirat Rasul Allah has given a list of people who accepted Islam in first year of the proclamation of Islam (610), in which Hazrat Aisha’s name is mentioned as Abu Bakr’s “little daughter Aisha”. If we accept Hisham’s calculations, she was not even born at that time. Some time after the death of the Prophet’s first wife, Hazrat Khadija, Khawla suggested to the Prophet that he get married again, to a bikrun, referring to Hazrat Aisha (Musnad Ahmed). In Arabic bikrun is used for an unmarried girl who has crossed the age of puberty and is of marriageable age. The word cannot be used for a six-year-old girl. Some scholars think that Hazrat Aisha was married off so early because in Arabia girls mature at an early age. But this was not a common custom of the Arabs at that time. According to Allama Kandhulvi there is no such case on record either before or after Islam. Neither has this ever been promoted as a Sunnah of Prophet. The Prophet married off his daughters Fatima at 21 and Ruquiyya at 23. Besides, Hazrat Abu Bakr, Aisha’s father, married off his eldest daughter Asma at 26. Hazrat Aisha narrates that she was present on the battlefield at the Battle of Badar (Muslim). This leads one to conclude that Hazrat Aisha moved into the Prophet’s house in 1 A.H. But a nine-year-old could not have been taken on a rough and risky military mission. In 2 A.H, the Prophet refused to take boys of less than 15 years of age to the battle of Uhud. Would he have allowed a 10-year-old girl to accompany him? But Anas reported that he saw Aisha and Umme Sulaim carrying goatskins full of water and serving it to the soldiers (Bukhari). Umme Sulaim and Umme Ammara, the other women present at Uhud, were both strong, mature women whose duties were the lifting of the dead and injured, treating their wounds, carrying water in heavy goatskins, supplying ammunition and even taking up the sword. Hazrat Aisha’s nephew Urwah once remarked that he was not surprised about her amazing knowledge of Islamic law, poetry and history because she was wife of the Prophet and daughter of Abu Bakr. If she was 8 when her father migrated, when did she learn poetry and history from him? Thus Hisham is the common man in all the lines of chain of narration of the hadith which mentions her age as six. Hisham's authenticity is challenged, for it does not correlate with the many historical facts of the time. www.dawn.com/news/696084/ofaishas-age-at-marriage safiyyahsabreen.medium.com/aisha-ra-was-19-when-the-prophet-%EF%B7%BA-married-her-4afc660865f8 Graph of dates: www.newageislam.com/picture_library/Aisha_RA_Age_NewAgeIslam.jpg

[@Abcdefg47363]

Thank you for this dude

[@HassanAli-cc5vr]

@@Abcdefg47363 Ur welcome. Denying a hadith is not against Islam. If you deny all hadith, that is as that includes the words of the Prophet (PBUH). But when you have a hadith or a person in the chain who is found to be unreliable for any reason, or that the hadith is found to be illogical, it can be refuted and rejected completely with no issues.

[@doomdesire3460]

@@HassanAli-cc5vr that's 1 view Weaker narrations say she was 17 Stronger narrations say 9 at consummation There is no issue here since she was BALIGH BOTH AGES AT TIME OF CONSUMMATION

[@HassanAli-cc5vr]

@@doomdesire3460 there is no issue. However, this isnt a weak view. This is supported by all kinds of sources including strong sahih hadiths. The weak view is that she was 9, as the only common man in the chain of narration of ALL sahih hadiths that mention her age to be 9 at marriage 6 at consummation are from Hisham ibn Urwah. He had memory loss when he narrated the hadith. This makes the hadith invalid, and no longer sahih. Further? There are no “weak” narrations that say she was 17. There are no ages mentioned except Hisham’s 6 and 9. These ages are extracted from islamic biographies, books from scholars, and historical dates that all agree

[@doomdesire3460]

@@HassanAli-cc5vr majority of the scholars agree with the hadith in bukhari regarding her age You can be whoever you want. Whether she was 9 or 17 She was baligh at both ages so this doesnt pose any issue

[@animecomsparkle3919]

Isaac was in his thirties at the time of his sacrifice. Their conclusions in all, most cases, refer to Sarah’s death at 127 (in Genesis 23:1-2), as evidence of Isaac being 37 at the time of his sacrifice. So what is the significance of Isaac’s age at the time of his sacrifice? Well, according to the Bible, Isaac was 37-years-old when he went up on Mount Moriah with his father. Rebecca was born straight after Isaac and Abraham, came down from the Mount Moriah and they went to Beersheba. Isaac was married to Rebecca when he was 40-years-old (Genesis 25:20). Since that is the case, this would mean Rebecca, was married off when she was 3 (or 4) years old.

[@abduleve8688]

His second wife was not Aisha R.A. all his wives were widows except Aisha. Also apart from Aisha all his other wives were adults and some older than him

[@javahub3269]

She wants 9 akhi you are lying on the prophet. She was atleast 17.

[@Alhamdulila786]

You more knowledgeable than bukhari yh

[@javahub3269]

@@Alhamdulila786 akhi we don't blind follow scholars. Ur probably madkhali. Read the report in musanaf ibn abi shaybah. It was known to the early salaf that she was atleast 17. The chain on narrators in bukhari are dhaeef

[@Alhamdulila786]

@@javahub3269lmaooo I am free from them bootlickers by Allah and neither do I blind follow scholars and if your saying that bukhari hadith is weak witch I learned it’s not what about the other hadith that are solid with different narrators in the chain that arnt accused of memory loss due to old age ???

[@JamesJohnson-pz8pu]

Aishah said: 'The Messenger of Allah married me when I was nine and I lived with him for nine years.'" Grade: Sahih (Darussalam) Reference In-book reference English translation Report Error | Share | Copy : Sunan an- Nasa'i 3257 : Book 26, Hadith 62 : Vol. 4, Book 26, Hadith 3259

[@cyberyousef7519]

Even if she was 9 In islam it isn’t condemned Because after puberty you are an adult

[@Plan2Persuade]

So it seems that you are saying. What was relevant 1400 years ago is not relevant today. Mmmm! This raises many questions about consistency in your arguments defending your ideology

[@Abdur-Rahman862]

Nonsense. It was never about the age. You liberals made it an issue of age. A 9 year old girl in upstate New York and a 9 year old girl in Gaza. Are they the same in terms of maturity? Of course not. The girl in Gaza will grow up much quicker than the one in a mansion in Upstate NY. We never made it about age. There are many 20+ year-olds in the west that don't provide any value to their societies while there are 14 year-olds elsewhere working to provide for their relatives. You guys made it a matter of age. We didn't.

[@Plan2Persuade]

@@Abdur-Rahman862 okay it seems you are saying it is okay for a 40 year old man to marry a 9 year old even today, not just 1400 years ago. Because it sounded like Ali Dawah was saying that to justify his explanation

[@Abdur-Rahman862]

@@Plan2Persuade you skipped the part of my comment where it isn't about age? You're being disingenuous and it's painfully obvious.

[@Plan2Persuade]

@@Abdur-Rahman862 forgive me. It seems that you are saying it is okay to marry a 9 year old if they are more physically and mentally mature than your average 9 year old western/liberal, or have life experiences gained from living in less technically developed countries or who have lived harder lives. Even in 2024 in Gaza is it okay for a 40 year old man to marry a 9 year old girl. This is a straight forward genuine question

[@Abdur-Rahman862]

@@Plan2Persuade Can a 40 year old man marry a mature 9 year-old woman in Gaza? Absolutely.

[@jimmydaniyaal]

Age 16 is from a long time ago that had the issues then,that has never changed which we as people need to make it change

[@ajiekowski]

05:09 brother I think that part is because of (Al Ahzab 33 : 53) that forbids anyone to marry the prophet's wives but other than that it's a solid argument

[@HQR_1]

A 9 year old in Gaza is more mature than a 30 year old in the west

[@FREEPALESTINEFTRTTS]

Can't just make assumptions

[@cyberyousef7519]

@@FREEPALESTINEFTRTTSok maybe he was going too far But tbh a 9 years old woman in gaza is more mature than a 16 years old in the west

[@sloopjb5359]

Exactly. IQ statistics will prove that

[@tiaras553]

@@cyberyousef7519 A 9 year old child is not a woman😆.

[@AmicableAgnostic]

​@@tiaras553 according to Islam, she is a women. 😂 53 old senior citizen is a man.

[@r_yt-ii9sn]

Anyone who asks about the prophet marriage is not sincere

[@user-yd3uh4pz5e]

Would you be willing to ask a father to Mary his 6 year old if you were actively looking for marriage, knowing around 9 she would do “wifely duties” with you?

[@stageiiwappie950]

​@@user-yd3uh4pz5e normal in medieval times worldwide not just islamic, in europe too

[@CheekyTop]

We are sincere more than Muslims that why we ask questions ... He is the perfect man for all mankind to Muslims of course we going to ask and check his credentials

[@biggestboss7911]

​@@CheekyTopsincere? Ignoring all the blatant evidence that quran is the word of god like the preservation and lack of contradiction and the scientific and historical accuracy, ignoring all the 100% accuracy of all prophecies of the prophet, and then focusing on one hadith about a marriage 1400 years ago when that was common practice at the time is the opposite of sincere. It's people trying to find fault in Islam and the prophet because the insincere have exhausted every other argument.

[@biggestboss7911]

@@Enduser323 none of its been debunked. That's why you spend all your time on islam videos. I never mentioned the word miracle in my post and by definition a miracle is something science cannot explain. So I have no idea what you're talking about.

[@user-tc7zl8et2o]

In romance "Tristan and Isolde" Tristan was fighting giant and having intimacy with woman at the age of 12. And he is called adult

[@sky.blossom2173]

Christian or non muslim who always saying prophet Muhammad saw married a 9 yo should watch this video 💁 May Allah protect us all

[@muirislandjim453]

9 years old though 😮🤮💀

[@AmicableAgnostic]

Keep your brain aside and convert to Islam. After that it won't bother u. 😂

[@aysmch622]

Just see anime apothecary diary,it was about how china kingdom was back then There is 2 girl married when he still child 1.the king concubine Li shu was 14 years old 2.the king before (li shu husband) was married 10 years old (chapter 58 apothecary diary) The china kingdom in this anime/manga maybe was fiction but there is proof that something like that (marriage child) was okay back then I think the story of this china kingdom was hundred to one thousand years after prophet Muhammad was death So I will say even after the prophet Muhammad death, married child still okay back then .......... ..................

[@muirislandjim453]

@aysmch622 I understand that some people slept with Children back in the middle ages, However, Islam & Muslims claim Mohammed was the perfect man - the most perfect man to ever live - it is clear that Mohammed was far from perfect. The fact that Mohammed married a 9 year old child & slept with her is insane, I could never worship a man who married a 9 year old child. It shows how easily people are brainwashed. Mohammed married a 9 year old girl 🤢

[@muirislandjim453]

@@aysmch622 They claim Mohammed was the most perfect man to ever live. It is obvious he wasn't. People are so easily brainwashed. He married a 9 year old child 🤢

[@dzulkafleysamad3825]

My mother was 16 when she married my father who was 34. He married late as he has to take care of about 10 siblings to finish school.

[@AbuFarouq]

What doesn’t often get brought up is the opinion that she was older in other reports

[@Abdur-Rahman862]

The fabrications that claim that she was coincidentally 18 years old when she got married? Somehow perfectly aligning with western standards? You're embarrassing.

[@alllaw3ao7]

Blah Blah Blah

[@generalali7609]

Please stop arguing the point of a 9 year old getting married. There were many things the prophet was allowed to do that the rest of us were not. As simple as that. We don’t have to bring up morality to justify a marriage ( that there is still a real dispute about her age) that happened 1400 years ago. We have absolutely no idea the ins and outs of the core details of the marriage. All we have is maybe 2 Hadiths that say her age. But what we have learned is that marriage children shouldn’t be allowed because of the possibility of harm. Hazrat Aisha wasn’t harmed however many many children have been since then. So it is absolutely ok for us to realize that and stop it.

[@messiah4951]

I have never heard that child marriage is legitimately no longer allowed or that we had any other realization as laymen than the one forced upon us by our enemies. Don't let an inferiority complex get to your head. Albeit, I do agree that if we personally know that it is going to cause harm, then we must not inflict it by consuming a marriage whether the female is too old or too young.

[@generalali7609]

@@messiah4951There is no way for anyone one of us to know if a 9 year old would be harmed but what we do know that a 9 year old has a much more likelihood of being harmed. And the older a they are the less likely they will be harmed. And a person gets fully developed around the age of 16 /17. So we can say that is an age for marriage. This would be a protection for you girls because we have seen a lot of men have taken advantage of young girls and they use that 1 Hadith to justify it. This must be used as a protection for young girls. That won’t take anything away what may have happened long ago.

[@muneerthepioneer6306]

@@messiah4951 Assalmualaykum brother, just wanted to add to this thread of comments. We have to realize that there are many factors before a women in Islam is ready for marriage, but just because you are physically ready for marriage doesn't mean you are *fit* to marry, either mentally or maturity. For example a 15 year old can be physically ready in Islam but not be mentally mature or might have mental baggage like trauma or depression, does that mean she should marry just because Islamically she is physically ready? No, she needs to figure out her issues or become more mature, understand what a marriage is really all about. But nowadays I doubt most women as young as Aisha can be married without harm as Aisha was one of a kind, a very mature women which most women aren't even close to that level of maturity, *especially* women her age, which is why I think Muslims shouldn't marry women her age because it will most likely cause harm.

[@TheProphetofLogic]

Yes this is why little girls are protected in Muslim countries and why they don't have concubines and child marriage and Muslim countries hahaha 🤣🤣😂 I'm wondering if you actually read the Quran... If you read chapter 33 verse 53 you will know that Mr Ali here is saying a bold-faced lie.... Why is Ali though a lying about the fact that Aisha had no possibility of remarriage??? And if he's not telling the truth about this, why are you trusting anyone in islam ... They lie until they get caught and then they still lie more.

[@TheProphetofLogic]

We know a woman is ready for marriage when she's playing on swings with other little girls and playing with dolls and has a wooden horse with wings attached. And Aisha's little friends would hide in the closet while Muhammad was being intimate with her. It's time to be truthful with everybody ...we all beginning to know the truth.... the spread of Islam is spreading EVERYTHING about Islam so even the deepest and darkest secrets within Islam are becoming public knowledge ...to be associated with this religion is to be associated with something that you really don't want to be associated with ....so the best thing to do is just *come out.* *You live in a secular country for a reason don't forget that.*

[@LoveNature-my8fz]

This is the verse from king James version translation before 1952: 1 Corinthian 7:36 But if any man think he behaveth himself uncomely towards his virgin , if she pass the flower of her age , and need so require , let him do what he will , his sinneth not : let them marry.

[@pandamanou]

14:45 here is the point !!! "adult" she is not aware about the term even about herself... i feel like even 16 for her is a child... and here we ask what's an adult ?

[@NorthKoreanLover89484]

and we're proud of that

[@AudioBibleInjeel-xg5md]

The Injeel narrations channel is better than Quranly ❤❤

[@zakirahmed469]

lady capulet julias mother at " Romio and Juliet " was 26 when Juliet was 14, that was the re-election of the time. Delaware state in America the age of concent was 7 as late as 1960s. According to the mainstream Judaism Rebecca was 3 when she was married to Isaac pbuh.

[@DEVRAJSINGHFX]

( PBUH) POLICE BE UPON HIM 🐷

[@aysmch622]

Just see anime apothecary diary,it was about how china kingdom was back then There is 2 girl married when he still child 1.the king concubine Li shu was 14 years old 2.the king before (li shu husband) was married 10 years old (chapter 58 apothecary diary) The china kingdom in this anime/manga maybe was fiction but there is proof that something like that (marriage child) was okay back then I think the story of this china kingdom was hundred to one thousand years after prophet Muhammad was death So I will say even after the prophet Muhammad death, married child still okay back then ..... ......... ....... ... ...

[@DEVRAJSINGHFX]

@@aysmch622 It doesn’t make Muhammad innocent he is still pdfile

[@omarbouyafar]

Ma chae Allah

[@phoebeoapollonio9569]

These people are like the flat-earthers. You'll only tire yourself from trying to debate them as they're so engulfed in their own fixed, deeply ingrained belief. They'll put out passion, loud voice, they'd cut you off during arguments, and go round and round with the seemingly "sensible" logic that appeal to less critical thinking people.

[@JstShay]

i cant see this an adut marrying a 9 ur old astugfirullah may allah help them and guied them on the right path!

[@xkayaaa]

Do you think you are superior to our prophet(saw) and have a higher moral ground than Him (saw)?

[@kashkash9244]

Rebecca was only 3 year old but I bet you are clueless there.

[@uthman2281]

ignorant one

[@thebesttruth4659]

Pray for🇵🇰🇵🇰Ex pm imran khan in Jail May Allah protect innocent family😔 in PakistaaN...

[@CheekyTop]

Yes we are superior to him.. he raped a child we do not

[@blackraid1]

did she just say thighing then proceeded to explain it ? hahahaha

[@CrescentCrusader99]

Prophet Muhammad PBUH was a GigaChad and the literal messenger of the creator of the universe. He was described as being more beautiful than the moon and even men wanted to touch and kiss him. He wasn’t some fat, ugly and old creep like what Westerners think. All the prophets were Angelical even Prophet Yusuf had half of humanity’s beauty and made the wife and handmaidens of the king of Egypt fall in love with him.

[@MASRUR11]

My Grandfather join Army in age 13. My Dad told me.( In 1954)

[@hassan2hilarious]

Who lied to her about the 'thigh-ing' stuff?? Astaghfur'Allah. These lies on the Prophet PBUH are getting ridiculous SMH! Please don't believe anything you hear people!

[@xplain8624]

Basic math and fact from Sahih Bukhari (like age of Asma, her sister and comparison to age of Hijrat) shows that the 9 yearold marriage was a lie. But why do you refuse to mention this and ignore this? Because then Sahih bukhari is not Sahih (correct) anymore, then whole Sunni sect will collapse.

[@Abdur-Rahman862]

May Allah curse those who curse the companions of the Prophet (SAW)

[@Khaledbenwalidd]

This thumbnail😂😂 I thought AliDawas speechbubble is referring to this girl and not to Aisha

[@TheRoundtable_RTG]

Dang she sprinted out of the SMH it’ll take time and reflection for her

[@meema9077]

Whose the guy with the flag in the background? Keeps popping up in loads of videos..

[@Gandumuhammad]

Ayesha was like dani daniels

[@soldierof-allah11]

how dare you insult the mother of believers?

[@sloopjb5359]

I bet Aisha must have been beautiful when Mohammed met her at 6. And very interesting to talk to.

[@doomdesire3460]

She narrated 2200 hadiths You can bet she was

[@aysmch622]

Just see anime apothecary diary,it was about how china kingdom was back then There is 2 girl married when he still child 1.the king concubine Li shu was 14 years old 2.the king before (li shu husband) was married 10 years old (chapter 58 apothecary diary) The china kingdom in this anime/manga maybe was fiction but there is proof that something like that (marriage child) was okay back then I think the story of this china kingdom was hundred to one thousand years after prophet Muhammad was death So I will say even after the prophet Muhammad death, married child still okay back then ...... .... .... ... ... ..

[@sloopjb5359]

@@doomdesire3460 subhanallah

[@sloopjb5359]

@@aysmch622 In Papua Guinea tribal people also marry children, for them it is also normal

[@alkuyuudi6975]

Which country is this?

[@maxr247]

Speakers Corner in England.

[@msanane5438]

You have one thing incorrect… nobody was allowed to marry prophets wives…for what i learned…correct me if i’m wrong…it’s in an ayat but don’t know which one

[@Abdur-Rahman862]

Correct. Surah ahzab verse 53.

[@ROSM209]

Do not post pictures or videos of women without hijab

[@sloopjb5359]

You find it hard to sleep afterwards? Wank two three times and you ll be ok. Just don´t hurt any girl

[@aysmch622]

I think if he sensored the face of the women,there will commentary from non Muslim "Why the face is censored??" Like it doesn't make any sense, actually if you see comment in this video there was someone commented About "people censored the women arm is weird" So yeah,i think it was good to censored but I know many of non Muslim people will triggered by that censored At least he censored when women dress openly (like her chest/breast is open and something like that

[@ROSM209]

@@aysmch622 so what if non muslims did not like it? God's commands are more important than whatever they think.

[@AdnanDanipagieh-gl8hh]

Aisha was 17-19 years, like her sister explained as i ever read. Then an absent minder grandpa who told that Aisha that she married 9 year. May be he mis spelled or mis saying words, mis remembered somethings: so, make peoples mis understand

[@MBeats27]

The wife's of the prophet peace be upon him are the mothers of the believers, they can't remarry after the prophet

[@naheemakhtar7842]

sometimes thess people hav a agenda and wont listen to the answer

[@FlakoBarrios]

What is your evidence that a 9 year old girl back then was an adult

[@asarmaniac]

Assalamu alaikum here in our part of the world, older people marries young womens and is celebrated very well and it is made of love

[@dorj46]

Sir if you think Islam is the truth please respectfully debate Sam Shamoun, if you successfully do that Islam will spread more.

[@shiajinn2509]

If what the prophet did 1400 years ago is not right today, i guess that explains why his teachings are not universal and infallible. He was a man of his time who did things on par with his time.

[@lurdkatmin3298]

Why would it not be moral today?

[@shiajinn2509]

@@lurdkatmin3298 so then are you okay if your sister or daughter marry a 53 year old man ?

[@lurdkatmin3298]

@@shiajinn2509 Depends on many things. I think you misunderstand the example of the prophet peace and blessings be upon him as well. The example isn't that we marry at some specific age, the example is that we marry by compatibility and at individual maturity, and there is no problem with the fact that this changes. And that if a marriage is arranged at an age of immaturity, then we wait until maturity has been reached before cohabitation in marriage. This is the example that applies for all times. What I can also give you a definitive answer for is that I would totally be for any woman or man marrying if she or he is ready and if she or he wants to, regardless. Abolishing this example has only been disastrous for society. For the youth of today, pornography and fornication has filled the space that "child marriage" once sat in pretty much every traditional culture. Is that better?

[@shiajinn2509]

@@lurdkatmin3298what a gr8 bullshit reply. The leagl age for marriage, voting and driving license etc is 16, 18 depending on what country you're in; that is as per of the developmental milestone of normal human body (go study neurology)and social norms. Everybody should have the right to make their own choice and live their life on their own terms (or how else can a person be judged in the afterlife if all his life decisions were taken by somebody else, all his deeds on on somebody else's commands, will there really be any meaning to life itself then?)

[@lurdkatmin3298]

@@shiajinn2509 The only bullshit reply is your own. Firstly, your reply just demonstrates how brainwashed and unquestioning you are of your own values and beliefs, everything you think and believe matches up to what your government teaches you. Those ages, 16, and 18, are merely based off of set schooling ages. Ages of consent and ages of marriage almost always match up to the set schooling ages in whatever country or state they are assigned in. There are no special universal milestones in the human body that match to the ages of 16 and 18, people usually reach sexual maturity before said ages. So whether or not we have marriage people under these ages will be active sexually because that is only natural, it's only an issue for you when we mention marriage (the safe, secure, and healthy option). Women often finish growing in their early teens, and have reached menarche by the age of 12 on average (according to the tanner stages menarche generally happens around stage 4 out of 5, so mid to late puberty.) You could say males often finish their growth spurt in their late teens, that's about it really. People develop neurologically and psychologically majorly into the 20s, but I don't see any logical reason as to why the age of marriage should be fixed legally to any of those developmental milestones. Everyone has the right to make his own choices and decisions, that doesn't mean consequences don't exist for those decisions. By your logic we would let people murder, steal, and maybe even dig up corpses and... uh idk if I even want to go there. Having rules and structure in place is necessary so I'm not sure what you're trying to say?