NEW Physicians Formula Butter Bronzer?!

[@LuteofWinter]

I really like these single product reviews. This way the products don't get muddled with so many other products.

[@nicholes5942]

Definitely. Sing product reviews are very helpful. I also like the comparison type like this!

[@denial_4521]

I think she should do more of these! I think the length of these vids should be less, maybe like 5-8min vids?

[@LuteofWinter]

@@denial_4521 It would depend on the product. For brows, it can be 5-8 minutes long for sure. But for primers, foundations, etc., I can see those needing to be longer, especially if you're doing a wear test. :)

[@emagnusson6479]

@@denial_4521 she needs them to be at least 10 minutes to get paid/ads.

[@therandapoto6758]

I agree.

[@terrigaines1812]

The flowers on the new packaging are Tahitian gardenias. Monoi is a perfume oil that is produced by soaking the petals of Tahitian gardenias in coconut oil. Doesn't that sound just heavenly? Murumuru butter is made from fruit fat found in murumuru nuts that come from palm trees in the Amazon basin so that is why the original butter bronzer smells more nutty while the new has a more floral scent.

[@nikkia326]

That's really interesting! Thanks for sharing that info :) Have a Happy New Year!!!

[@terrigaines1812]

@@nikkia326 Awww you're welcome 😁 you have a happy new year too🎉🍾🥂

[@johannak1983]

Exactly. It's tiaré flower (Tahitian gardenia) dipped in coconut oil. Love that scent!

[@ninimimi2906]

What an interesting comment! Thank you for sharing 😘

[@terrigaines1812]

@@ninimimi2906 You're so welcome and thank you.

[@Wallflower-ei8es]

I do like single product reviews, especially when it’s being compared to an old product. I found this review very helpful, especially the hand swatches to see the differences in color and tone.

[@willsn1]

I would LOVE the new fenty powder vs Mac studio fix powder

[@swood2603]

I love their bronzer and blushes, but I would love it if the packaging were less bulky. Who uses the little brush? Yes, in depth product reviews are helpful, especially when comparing to similar products. The comparison swatches are very helpful. Thank you.

[@annikatribby5717]

Sw here, also I don't use the mirror.. very awkward turning the product upside down to apply it in the mirror

[@MelsLife570]

Less bulky & no scent.

[@mariadayala89]

If u love their bronzer n blush you will love their highlighters I love them I reach for them more than any other ones that I have. I highly recommend them I’m shocked not alot of people talk about them

[@IAmNotNicolex]

I love their travel butter bronzer because it’s small and compact, not taking up too much space in my makeup bag. I’m not sure what the shade range for that is, though. But you should check it out! No mirror, no brush, just a small compact for much cheaper.

[@4booky831]

I feel like they keep it so bulky so they can keep the price kind of high for drugstore 😬

[@marialedesma2777]

I can tell the difference between both bronzers, the new one looks softer and lighter in color but both look gorgeous!

[@tarajones5087]

My New Year’s resolution is not to buy any make up in 2021! I have a huge collection, thanks to all of the influencers that I watch religiously, and I’m going to spend the year going through my current collection. I love these types of videos where you focus on one specific product and I also love shot my stash videos.

[@KourttneyL]

Same lol I decluttered so many of my blushes

[@annlatham]

That’s definitely something we all need to consider!

[@selena8743]

Oh jeezz ill be praying for you girl!🙏💕

[@mariadayala89]

Same I have spent so much in makeup it’s crazy

[@melissakessler77]

That's actually a great idea! I'll start after my birthday which is January 10th 😉

[@hs223justin]

Why did the first thing that popped in my head was “mihoy minoi” from doodlebob 😭😭😭

[@TheUchihaRin]

SAME

[@nizshmc]

LMFAOOOO

[@amberisrad]

HAHAHA

[@lizziebarrie]

ME TOO LMAOOOO

[@Iamyl4]

Doodle bob

[@Fortheloveofbon]

Can you do a wear test? The matte one is supposedly long lasting, and as someone that puts my bronzer and blush on my bare skin (with no foundation) having something long lasting is really important

[@amandaadams5483]

I think they both look nice but the side with the original looks darker to me. I like the matte version, it looks softer and more natural

[@AngelaMarie236]

That’s what I thought too. It also seemed a bit cooler which was a bit shocking when she did the swatches on the back of her hand.

[@jocelynsloan7801]

Which is weird, because the swatches seemed to be the opposite! The matte was wayyyy warmer and darker looking. 🧐 I thought that the matte shade might have worked for me but after those swatches...def not.

[@jennybrandt5188]

Are you sure they're both shade "bronzer?" The matte shade looks like "light bronzer."

[@genietillery878]

Cosmetics that are heavily scented can be a problem for people, they are for me. I think a matte finish looks more natural on the skin.

[@lisak.126]

Totally agree! Fragrance is so unnecessary and excludes those of us who are sensitive to it.

[@KourttneyL]

My skins can’t handle fragrance in products but this bronzer works fine on my skin! It’s crazy

[@genietillery878]

@@lisak.126 I can't even go into Bath & Body Lisa because of the scent. I start sneezing, then my eyes start watering. I'm a mess.

[@KourttneyL]

@@genietillery878 I can’t use their hand creams at all because my hands break out :( I completely understand the pain and annoyance!!

[@genietillery878]

@@KourttneyL It's good to know I'm not alone!

[@lisah1095]

I appreciate when you tell us there's a fragrance. It saves me time and money. Thank you.

[@ruthgrier5247]

Your lashes... I can't even. GORGEOUS. I love your content! keep up the amazing work :)

[@purplekimby]

I love this kind of video because it's just a quick view of a single product. I think the full faces of products are sometimes difficult to keep up with.

[@shannonbuttimer96]

they really couldn't expand the shade range of the original, but could formulate a whole new bronzer?! People with deeper skin tones deserve better :(

[@jory6795]

They did expand the original line in 2019 - several dark shades

[@Nausithoe88]

Shannon Buttimer sorry there isn't anything for you- maybe you should try Fenty or other black owned brands.

[@84176104]

They should have added additional shades with new matte bronzer as well. They could have done better but they made a choice not to. I personally have written and called corporate in the past for this issue since 2007. I am able to use the product without issues but I give gifts that include my favorite things. I like think I am performing a cheaper form of Oprah action. I can never include this in the basket. Each year the company misses 30 individual sales of this item.

[@jasminethornburg2101]

And people with really fair tones! It is still way to warm toned and dark for the lightest shade

[@shannonbuttimer96]

@@jory6795 yeah but those were medium at best. People with deep skin tones need to be considered as well.

[@Underhollyoath2]

I haven’t smelled the new bronzer, but I’m assuming the scent is Monoi. It’s a light tropical floral scent. One of my faves 🥰

[@yvonnemarie6117]

I work at a target and we just received it and yess it does, it’s quite strong as she said

[@makayla8693]

Hi Hollyoath

[@kaburzynski]

I love this concept! Honestly it gets overwhelming when videos review a ton of products and I totally prefer you talking about one product in depth!

[@hiitehinen]

For everyone who can't use their bronzers because of the smell, try leaving the compact open for an extended period. I depotted mine and the smell has almost completely disappeared! I will catch a tiny whiff randomly when applying, but it's otherwise gone. I imagine leaving the compact open might have the same effect.

[@MrMikk532]

Omg you may have saved me. I bought the original butter bronzer a while ago but couldn't use it because it smells like buttered popcorn to me and i can smell it on my face even an hour after application. I'll have to try this.

[@pappyone6062]

Oh I’m going to have to repurchase it and try that. I live the formula and color so much but it gives me an instant migraine!

[@pappyone6062]

By the way did you use any tricks to depotting it? I break half the stuff

[@Kree.B.]

I was so freakin excited when I saw this, but when I I got it home & opened it I couldn't stand the smell. I tried it on half my forehead to patch test it & the smell never went away, so I don't even know if I like it or not because of that. I'm not even sensitive to scents. I love the idea, the water resistance & the matte feel packaging though!

[@sooph1e]

Quick question, how did you fare with the original smell? I remember buying from their Argan collection, the packaging was gorgeous but the pressed powder's fragrance were absolutely unbearable to me.

[@Kree.B.]

@@sooph1e the original smell isn't my favorite, but it didn't bother me enough to not use it and it seemed to dissipate after it was on my face. This new scent just seems way stronger & lingers the entire time you're wearing it!

[@TrulyBeauty]

love this look . ✨✨✨

[@danica7560]

Ooh I’m so excited about this video!!! Could you maybe do a video on how you touch-up your makeup throughout the day or even a full face of the best long wearing makeup? Just an idea 😊 Love you and your videos!! ❤️

[@CowGirlKat8691]

Not many remember to show us how they keep their look going! Good idea

[@leahchristman3506]

Yes PLEASE! Oily sensitive skin me needs help haha!

[@annlatham]

In 2021 all gurus should consider this lol

[@melissakessler77]

Monoi comes from the tiare flower, which is a Tahitian gardenia. It has a distinctive scent that is used in many products. Delicious!

[@tiffanykilby7560]

They use to have this certain bb compact foundation and I can never find it anymore. It was so pretty!

[@Patti-1962]

Years ago, I remember when I bought my first bronzer, it had more red in it. To look like I had "sun-kissed" skin. Then came the cool toned bronzer that now served as a contour for the face. Now bronzers have sheen in them and I find I am missing my old style bronzer. The new PF bronzer looks so much like my old product!

[@PersianPowergirl]

So they had a chance to completely change the packaging on the new bronzer and YET they stuck to the same design. Slow. Clap. 👏

[@adriannehiltz3120]

I love this format! Side by side comparisons are always helpful, especially with a new product vs old classic. Thanks!

[@Trishtrash952]

I've been wanting them to come out with a matte version of this for ages! I'm almost done with my current one and didn't want to repurchase because I have oily skin and I really don't like the sheen on the original even though I love the formula and shade. I can't wait to try out the new one though! I think it'll end up being a HG for me.

[@mildred1890]

Thank you for making such amazing videos they rly made me grow in makeup

[@melanied1681]

I do enjoy when you compare a new item to an oldie but goodie. They are changing formula, packages and in this case scent and glow.

[@cherylhall8975]

I think people might like a video on best most comfortable& natural tinted moisturizers, and best tinted lip products or a video about what products from your makeup collection that will NEVER be decluttered

[@LifeofJess13]

You look so genuinely happy when your doing your makeup!

[@ihateylanyi1167]

Omgggg that yellow eyeshadow look is so bomb! It suits you so well!!!

[@amberedmisson5395]

Navy is such a flattering color on you! That combined with the light yellow eye look made your eyes even more stunning than usual🥰

[@taramatilton706]

The All Star physicians formula palette has them both in it plus other bomb powders. Omg I love that palette.

[@MiaPageMua]

I love these more in depth videos about one product! The butter bronzer is the only bronzer I had to repurchase multiple times! It's the best! Hope you are doing well! And happy new year :)

[@claire5862]

The original side looks much more heavy, while the new one looks so soft and airy. I need to get my hands on the new one!

[@MitzEve.]

Yes I enjoy both styles of videos, it is refreshing when youtubers do single product focused reviews or comparisons.

[@TiannaOuellette]

YES SO HAPPY YOU ARE DOING THIS VIDEO!! I have been wanting to try the new one

[@dawnwagnerprincesslgunab6476]

I like the fact as well that now the company is offering a Matte and Sparkly version. Yeah!

[@SS-zj5lk]

You look really nice here, fresh and simple. I think light makeup colours suit you best. Happy new year!

[@melaniefarrow7152]

Loved this. The coconut scent is the selling point for original. You just saved me some money.

[@clkhoo821]

I just can't stop starring at ur eyelashes! They looked soooooo pretty! Nice simple elegant makeup! Happy New Year!

[@adele3672]

Thank you for mentioning the strong scent in the newer version 🥰 I’m very sensitive to fragrance

[@gabye.]

After years of resisting the urge to buy the butter bronzer, I finally gave up and got it a month ago, and it's a gorgeous bronzer, but I need a light hand when applying it (people say it last for years without touching pan) I think this matte bronzer is a pass for me. I need some shine on my dull skin. Thank you for the comparison Ally, happy New Year to all!

[@sarahfruin6414]

Really enjoyed the style of video. I love it when you go super detailed.

[@janeneg]

I’m a big fan of the comparison videos! Especially when a brand comes out with a new version of a popular product that we “all” have.

[@julianursten6399]

Wishing you and Tylan a very happy new year and a healthy, blesses year ahead. Thank you both for all your hard work this year

[@makayla8693]

Hi Julian

[@sabrinaa8948]

I wish they would release an unscented line :(

[@kathybrou1340]

Wanted unscented version for years. You would think “physician’s ” formula would have one.

[@hiitehinen]

I depotted mine and the smell has almost completely disappeared! I will catch a tiny whiff randomly when applying, but it's otherwise gone. I imagine leaving the compact open might have the same effect.

[@kathybrou1340]

@@hiitehinen Yes. I did that with the Peach eyeshadow pallete. Left it open for months. Hm. I may buy one and try that. Maybe I can use it in 6 months! hehe

[@hallucinangel]

Yeees, i don't want that lingering smell on me, my nose can't take it

[@karly.asshhh]

Yes! I got the healthy liquid foundation but I can't use it at all. The scent is so overwhelming and gives me a headache every time I try it. It's a shame because I really like the finish.

[@nikkibotts6239]

I really liked this in-depth take on the product. You did a great job covering all aspects of this bronzer and between this video and your follow up in the description, any and all questions were answered. Thank You!😉

[@auroragloqueen4979]

I enjoyed this single product focus videos. It was really helpful.

[@nastassjahall9358]

The scent's probably tiare, which is what monoi is scented with

[@monicamcdonald5474]

Hi Allie, Happy New Year! I LOVE your eye look in this video but I can't quite figure out which colors you are wearing. Would you mind, please, listing the colors? Thanks!

[@carriesutherland2333]

Have you done a tutorial using that Colourpop Boudoir palette? Love the look you have in this video!

[@isabelledesmeules6856]

You are awesome, beautiful eyes and lashes. I love the old version, not too matte. Thanks for comparing the different versions. Thanks for your excellent vidéo. 💖

[@kristendaugherty]

I do enjoy this style of video and would love to see more similar videos on your channel!

[@Michellemybelle2012]

Allie!!! Happy New Year to my all time fav KZbinr out there! ❤️🎉

[@makayla8693]

Hi Michelle

[@JacqueGonzalesTube]

The scent is from the Tahitian Gardenia. The petals are soaked in coconut oil to get the finished Manoi oil. 💜

[@mariabarbaramarquez4698]

They both look very good on you. Physicians Formula is my favorite bronzer and I need to find one that is similar to it. I do like the coconut smell to it.

[@stephaniethat40somethinggi45]

I really like this style of video. Knowing the difference between two very similar products with different formulas can be very helpful in deciding what is best to use for dry to normal skin vs. combo to oily skin.

[@JazUpMyStyle]

If you’re reading this .. 2021 is gonna be AMAZING FOR YOU! just claim it!!

[@morganblalock873]

I love love love that they released a matte version. Definitely interested. I got the little 3-pan butter bronzer palette from Ulta (3 shades of the regular butter bronzer) and it was SUCH good value for plenty of product. One of my fave new purchases. I'm sure this would be a nice compliment to those three shades when I want some more matte-ness in my look.

[@BookwormEmEm]

Oh no I’m very sensitive to scents, the floral is going to be a big con! I love matte bronzers but I think I’m just going to stay with my Milani silky matte one.

[@leah-in-recovery]

My favorite videos are single product reviews!!!! So happy for this video. ❤️❤️

[@accesstotheredcarpet]

The new one looks similar to my PF matte booster bronzer but minus the floral scent. And I also own the PF butter bronzer. I’m obsessed with both of the PF bronzer I already own.

[@plumdutchess]

I'll stick to the original. I absolutely love the scent and enjoy it every single time I apply it.

[@Jehniferj_4063]

I love the idea of both styles. Full face & then switching it up to 1 product focus. Ooohhh then you can take all of the single product focus vids & put them all together in 1 video showcasing all of them together 💡. Yes, I like that! 👍❤

[@anaos1004]

I love every video you upload, honestly! But personally, I like even more when it’s trying out a few things instead of just one or even better when it’s a tutorial on a look or when you’re doing one palette/ 2 (or 3 or 4) looks! But honestly, I’m here for everything, just commenting cause you asked what we liked. I’m pretty sure, though, that your videos are diverse enough so that your entire audience is happy with your content 🥰 Btw, happy new year!! 🎊 🍾

[@makayla8693]

Hi Ana

[@Ashoolay]

Thank you for comparing these! I’ve been curious what the difference really was!

[@Ewoklynn]

If the matte bronzer smells anything like the Carol’s Daughter monoi products, then I’m gonna have go on a Walmart run lol!

[@sanaderbas718]

The matte monoi butter butter has a gardenia scent that they classify as tropical.

[@jessicawhite3893]

The original butter bronzer is my every day go to. Its nostalgic for me cuz its literally the first bronzer I ever tried and fell in love with it. The scent is an added bonus. Loved this style of video as it's a more targeted way to review one production depth. Keep it up please!

[@amandaford864]

Ooo Allie I love how the matte one looks!!!

[@alexisknursing]

You should try the Physicians Formula Complete box set. It's a big pink box and has everything you need to finish complexion, eyes, and lips! I love it

[@alexisknursing]

Physicians Formula Ultimate... www.amazon.com/dp/B07WPWSZ47?ref=ppx_pop_mob_ap_share

[@sandracox9287]

I enjoyed this in-depth video! Nice to see a new product compared to an existing product to help make up our minds on potential purchases.

[@alesiaturner7328]

I love your makeup today and I know you posted the palette your wearing but could you do a video on this eyeshadow palette and show what products you’re wearing. Yes I do like these one products reviews. Happy New Year 🎈🎊.

[@mymakeup1669]

I would also love to see that tutorial on your eye look.

[@mkel858]

Both looked good! Of course I think matte is better for me especially if you use highlighter! Thanks for comparison, hope you have a nice next year!

[@marynall7280]

Both bronzers looked beautiful. Your eyes are so pretty, would love to see a GRWM or tutorial on how you created it. Happy New Year.

[@kristineolver3268]

I'll definitely be getting it because I dont use my Butter Bronzer often because of the sheen it has.

[@anistonweeks688]

Yes!! LOVE single product videos! Super helpful and informative!

[@veronicalee3831]

I received your pink makeup bags for Christmas and I love them!!!

[@PlainJane144]

Oooo an exciting drugstore addition 😁 thank you Allie 🥰

[@RM-kx6qv]

Yes I loved this! Going in depth on one new makeup is cool!

[@luceromanjarrez349]

Yes i like u doing a focus on one type of a product at a time.

[@rhondapomeroy5695]

I like the single product comparison BUT I also enjoy a full face .... you choose! Happy New Year!

[@crystalmesser7829]

Great video! Especially because we all know butter bronzer but I do prefer your full face videos. Thanks Allie

[@IsraaKassab]

I wonder if the new monoi bronzer seems more fragrant because it’s a new scent because after using the original butter bronzer for so long I barely smell it now

[@elizabethl8462]

I love the single product reviews! They are so informative and helpful!

[@bubblishousness]

Yes I definitely like this type of video! Happy New Year!

[@ortegaangarita]

Hi! I love this types of videos of just 1 or 2 products . Thanks for the review and the comparison

[@crystallilly7257]

I like the single product reviews , it just short and sweet. I would be interested in seeing a one and done eyeshadow review from you for the new year 😊

[@gillianleontsinis9648]

Really enjoy one product at a time. Nice to focus on one product.

[@nicoleschriever8929]

Hi Allie!! I’ve never used the Physician’s Formula Butter Bronzer. I have mature skin, and I’m not sure how it will look on me. Do you think it would look good on mature skin?

[@angstaples]

Mesmerized by your eyeshadow! 🤩It's so dreamy!💖

[@emilydevlin7454]

I like the single product reviews! I will also always love the multiple reviews in one video too. I enjoy any and all of your content. xoxo

[@Kayra-hb7cx]

I am loving the subtle gold bronze on the eyes 👁❤️❤️❤️

[@anniebanannie414]

Allie’s skin is looking like velvet 😍😍😍

[@erinbisson918]

I got the PF Allstar palette. It has both of these bronzers. For me the Monoi Matte is darker than the Murumuru Bronzer in this palette. The palette does smell amazing. For $14. I am sure it will get its use. 2 bronzer, 2 highlights, 1 pressed powder, and 1 blush.

[@heathermarshall6124]

I really like this video concept! I probably wouldn't have even given this a second look in the store, but now I'm intrigued I'm so glad they didn't gret rid of the original. I would be interested in the water resistance claim of the new one vs. the original.

[@helsconceit]

I really like the one product at a time videos! 👍🏻

[@carolpayne3697]

Hey Allie! Thanks for the review. I feel like you went in heavy with the original because you are super comfortable and familiar with it and you applied the matte in gingerly because you didn’t know how pigmented it would be or how it would blend...they are different and both lovely

[@betterlifebroadcasting7547]

I appreciate the idea of the true head to head comparison using your normal trusted products as the base. The full face videos are fun, but it's hard to judge which thing went weird if something doesn't quite work.