American Girl Dolls That Look Alike

[@AllycatlovesAG]

What dolls do you think look the most alike?

[@Aly-rn2pc]

Kira Bailey and Julie

[@Shadows_emerald]

Gabriella and turly me 46 because THEY ARE THE SAME DOLL THERE IS NO DIFFERENCE

[@sunny-rw3ei]

Probably Gabby and 64! I do think 59 and 68 look very similar aswell! Awesome video!

[@EmilyFitzmier]

#22 and #27. I can’t tell the difference at all!!

[@jojobee10]

Tenny and that truly me doll I don’t remember the number LOL!! look identical to me same with 22 and 27 blonde hair and blue eyes are common! :)

[@cookiemocher388]

I think the reason they even gave Molly braids and glasses is so it's not immediately clear how similar they're dolls look

[@jordyricha9917]

I agree all of these and especially the Emily one.

[@SuperButterfly217]

I love this!

[@linzeyh.2573]

I love kanani’s face mold 🥰

[@shaesshow8016]

Yes!!! It’s a Jess mold.

[@unagavric5008]

Yes me too😊❤

[@kianithemermaid]

Early! I just found your channel 2 days ago and was watching when you posted. Yay!

[@AllycatlovesAG]

Perfect timing! Glad you’ve been enjoying my content

[@kianithemermaid]

​@@AllycatlovesAG Of course! I subscribed and liked all of the the videos of yours I watched too. And you inspired me to finally start an Etsy shop selling homemade clay doll food as I am really good at that and have always wanted Caroline and Kanani so fingers crossed I can make enough to buy at least one and eventually both.

[@Grungest0ner]

I bought truly me 24 at AGPNYC back in 2015-2016? I can’t remember, but she’s such a nice doll!

[@jadycorson]

41 and ruthie

[@Galaxia_Moon]

i have maryellen and know a friend with courtney we checked they are NOT I SAY NOT DOPPEGANGERS

[@amynaddra7230]

Wow! You are so right on these dolls

[@iirabiaii]

Can you maybe do a video of rating all truly mes? if not thats fine, but i really want to see your opinion

[@AllycatlovesAG]

That is a daunting task! There are so many! I’ll write it down but I have no clue when I’ll make that

[@iirabiaii]

@@AllycatlovesAG You don't have to but it's an idea or you can rank GOTYS or historicals, etc

[@emilysamericangirl]

11:39 Oh hey! lol! Nice video!! Also, My sister has #27 and I even I can’t tell the difference between the two! I feel like one one those two dolls should retire and not a poc doll. We only have a few poc dolls and a gazillion blond dolls. We need more poc dolls!!

[@EmilyFitzmier]

Hi! This is my other account! Here are all my dolls in the picture!

[@Shadows_emerald]

The fact I saw all of these coming-

[@everythingAG591]

Lol

[@oilystringcheese]

Z Yang and Jess Mcconnell look exactly the same but with different fair styles-

[@oilystringcheese]

hair*

[@agstopmotionerjoss4147]

These videos are so intresting Ally, I defentily agree with these!

[@Drawing_Rat]

I own both mareellen and Courtney

[@howleanswolf]

I heard luciana is retiring at the end of summer

[@00Abigail013]

Finally it has been 4 years

[@AllycatlovesAG]

Yes! I am not a luci fan and she can retire

[@howleanswolf]

@@AllycatlovesAG the sad part is joss is retiring too along with lucianna and blair all 3 are retiring at the end of summer

[@lexi5345]

@@howleanswolf all at the same time? Where’d you hear that?

[@howleanswolf]

@@lexi5345 yea from a friend who calls ag alot

[@ginakillingbeck910]

Cécile and #67 look very similar,

[@pixieag6670]

24 is my mini me and I can confirm that if you put her in a Jean jacket and skirt she looks SO much like tenney

[@michelleshouseofminiatures]

This was such a fun video! Thanks for all the comparisons!

[@sleepy.editss]

I have Kirsten first my mom give it to me because she had it as a kid and she gave it to me and I want Samantha and Molly P.S. there wasn't three original American Girl dolls is there were more than that like 4 or 5

[@pinkfoxag7470]

I actually have molly Kirsten and Samantha you can probably find them used for a pretty good price and in good condition

[@ptfornatale]

maryellen could kinda be like courtneys mom

[@EmilyFitzmier]

I love your videos!! They are so amazing!!

[@fthurman]

#22 vs #27: #22 = light blue eyes (like Kirsten), #27 = dark blue eyes (like Kit)

[@EmilyFitzmier]

Apparently they retired #22 😯

[@PriDekoDan]

I’m still new to AG but I feel like Courtney is a nod to Kirsten for some reason having that Blonde and Blue eye combo but also still yes ironically like Maryellen too

[@RINRIN_seriniti]

The only reason why me and my sister have the same dolls too because we look like twins and cheese 3 years older than me

[@cindyeisenberg8367]

I have #22 and I think she is really cute. She and#60 got me into collecting American Girl dolls.

[@oilystringcheese]

The reason that there are a lot of truly me dolls that look alike or look like historical/goty dolls, is because the truly me line was made for people that wanted a look alike doll, so if there was someone that had blonde hair and blue eyes but short hair and wanted a look alike, they would want one that had short hair, and for the people with blonde hair, blue eyes, and long hair, they would buy the longer haired one.

[@irishseadollies]

your videos are always so well researched!

[@AmaraEmme]

Jess has red highlights

[@sleepy.editss]

I have Kirsten cuz my mom had her as a kid I have Isabelle cuz she was at this garage sale thing and my mom got her for my birthday and I have Our Generation doll named to Gabe and there's more than three original dolls

[@morganashleypeterson3713]

22 has the classic blue eyes whereas 27 has Kit blue eyes. 22's hair is also lighter.

[@Galaxia_Moon]

Btw Nelly o'malley and Gwen look like TWINS

[@nicolasproductionsinc4158]

Truly me 56 and Lanie

[@donotresuscitatetrampstamp]

i think a lot of jly dolls look similar or are slight variations of each other are because of the whole idea of getting a doll thats your twin, like the two blonde jly dolls with bangs and different eye colors is a good idea because maybe someone has the same appearance except have either green or blue eyes. idk thats my opinion

[@AGontheRoofTop]

I think Truly me 62 looks more like Luciana Vega than 66

[@amandachase7691]

Great video! I own Samantha and Molly but I don't think they look too similar to me. I agree with what you said about Courtney and Maryellen. I love Maryellen she is my favorite!

[@pamelawilliams2235]

I think Molly and Kirsten look alike

[@handasdollings9909]

I learned a lot from this, although I disagree with Molly and Samantha being double gangers. Molly also has a lighter brown wig than Samantha. #13 and Samantha are extremely similar. Only difference is the style of the wig. Side note: #13 is still available online. Again, great video;) I would love to see a part 2.

[@javionryland6079]

First and I really love your channel

[@AGJitters]

ahhh i've always wanted 66 because of her eybrows lollll

[@kpal.]

Ive been saying this for years, but I always think Grace and Chrissa look very similar.. unfortunately it's what's stopping me from buying Chrissa :(

[@ziamontsbestbud2072]

I love Gabriella and I don’t like the hate

[@emeraldag]

You literally got ever single one I was thinking of😂

[@AllycatlovesAG]

We think alike!

[@maeve.eileen29]

First! Love your videos ❤️

[@Lainie_joy]

39 and Emily look like cousins

[@purpledachshundstudios]

These are so true! Courtney and Maryellen were going to be my prediction when I saw the video title. They are so similar.

[@adayinthedollhouse1004]

I have a friend that has Lucianna and truly me 82 and she wants to get 66 to be her 82s twin

[@bethbacarella]

I have Kanani, #46 and #24, but not their look-alikes. However, I also have Grace and Chrissa, who both have Josefina molds, brown hair and the same color blue eyes, but their hair styles and Grace's freckles do make them unique in my opinion. And I have a #26, but she has no look-alike (medium skin Addy mold, amber eyes and mine has a black wig a lot like Kaya's, so she is very unique). I'm VERY interested in adding the new Evette (World By Us) to my collection. LOVE her freckles, hair color, hair style, and I think she has green eyes or grey, and I don't have either color in my collection (and her outfit is adorable too). I love the Jess mold, but Josefina, even though it is over-used, is still my personal favorite. Thanks for this great video!!

[@hopenolan4447]

I really don’t see the resemblance between Maryellen and Courtney

[@Razzberry_dollz]

Tbh I think molly and Samantha are more in common then Courtney and marry Ellen

[@QueenEmily25]

That was a great video, as always! I have a few doppelgänger comparisons that weren’t on the list: Marisol Luna (GOTY 2005) and JLY #28 are very similar. Both of them are medium skinned Josefina molds with brown hair, but the only difference is Marisol’s hair is long and JLY #28’s hair is shoulder length. Another Kirsten Larson doppelgänger is JLY #12. She looks exactly like Kirsten, with a classic face mold and long blonde hair with bangs, but JLY #12’s eyes are brown instead of blue. A better doppelgänger for Courtney would be JLY #33, since they look very similar with the blue eyes and curly hair. However, Courtney’s hair is sandy-blonde and JLY #33’s hair is light red/strawberry blonde. Also, I agree with the comparison between Emily and JLY #39. Emily’s hair is definitely a bit redder in person, but other than that, they’re pretty similar. Anyway, I apologize for the long comment!

[@AllycatlovesAG]

A few people on Instagram mentioned Marisol and 28 but for me, they look more distinguishable then other dolls on this list because the hair length is so different

[@QueenEmily25]

I completely understand.

[@clueless_dollz]

#58 isn’t retired, why do so many people think that

[@ronaldfarmer7205]

I love the ivy face and love look a likes and multiples haha have three ivys and two kanani and one Jess haha

[@blehzesfilms]

I have a #12 and oh gosh! I didn't realize how similar she is to Gwen! It is honestly scary!

[@sandrajackson4332]

What doll are you showcasing in the background?

[@AllycatlovesAG]

Kanani with straight hair

[@earthtoember]

i own 24 and tenny and tenny's hair is lighter

[@alexandreaalexandrearoxas]

NO Kira the girl of the year 2021 and Isable the of the year 2014 basically look the same!!

[@acaciaevans4185]

I love this video! I hear that Joss and I think it was truly me 68 are identical as well. I don't know for sure since I only have Joss.

[@AllycatlovesAG]

I had that on my list but this video was going to be so long if I included every lookalike

[@fthurman]

Joss can't be identical to a current Truly Me doll because, as of yet, Joss has a unique facemould.

[@AllycatlovesAG]

@@fthurman that’s why I decided to not include her, but it is definitely the truly me she looks most like

[@aginlife]

In my newest video I had a side by side of Maryellen and Courtney!

[@gretchennahas5994]

I have two Julie and so they are identical twins

[@ag_bubblez]

I have Luciana, and Truly Me #82, and they look alike, so I made them cousins, but I wanted to get Truly Me #66 to be #82's twin, but then I would have three dolls that look alike. I think I would be fine with that if I had more dolls, but right now I only have four.

[@elizabrookespams]

In my honest opinion, I don’t think Maryellen and Courtney look that much alike. I do happen to own both of the dolls. In person, the only thing that makes them look alike is the classic mold. Courtney has much brighter eyes than Maryellen and Maryellen has MUCH brighter hair. Next to Maryellen, Courtney looks like she has blonde hair. I can see how you would think they look alike from stock photos and such though.

[@abbysdollhouseag2160]

I have both Courtney and Maryellen and I honestly think they don't look that much alike! Also, great video!

[@ourdollhouse2292]

I agree with all of these !! I got 22 or 27 when I was little and I don’t know which one I got 😂😂😂 she is my look a like my hair isn’t like that any more though. I think I got 22 lol. I LOVE Maryellen !! I don’t like Courtney ‘s wig with the curls with side bangs. Even though Kirsten isn’t a very og doll when she came out she was the ONLY doll with blue eyes and blonde hair so she was unique then

[@EmilyFitzmier]

I’m glad my mom kept the box to #27 because I would be confused for ages on which one it is.

[@ourdollhouse2292]

@@EmilyFitzmier yes definitely !! The only reason I think I got 22 is the layered and shorter hair

[@RagingMoon1987]

I just got a #27, and I touched on how she and #22 do look a lot alike. However, i can vouch for #27's eyes; my Doremi has much darker eyes than Kirsten, Lindsey, and Lark do, and they're a noticeably darker than Courtney's as well. They're a pretty shade.

[@clairep3688]

I think Gwen and 12 are the same doll

[@gingerandcloves]

This was a fun video! I used to own 66, but I sold her because I had so many medium skin Josefina mold dolls (Luciana, Marisol, #89), I just didn't need another one. Courtney and Maryellen...they do look alike but I much prefer Maryellen and I sold my Courtney. I have a hard time telling Tenney and 24 apart in photos, and also Kira and Julie sometimes. I do have 22 and 27, and I don't think they look all that alike - their eye color, hairstyle, and eyebrows are all different, but I can see why they made the list.

[@that_girl_dx1360]

I’m sorry but molly friend does look exactly the same as 39

[@emsgems1973]

I want to compare Courtney and marry Ellen. Courtney has a dishwasher blond hair but I see what you mean when it comes to pictures and videos

[@DollsAndSpooks]

There is also a rumor that the next GOTY may be twins.

[@AllycatlovesAG]

I heard, I’m not a huge fan of that as it’s Girl of the year not GirlS

[@adayinthedollhouse1004]

Ally you should make a video where you can only say nice things and things you like about dolls you are not a fan of, like coloured hair dolls, Courtney, Lucianna etc.

[@AllycatlovesAG]

I genuinely don’t like anything about the coloured haired dolls sorry! I have praised some aspects about Luciana before like her story and I’m actually working on a video talking about the best girl of the years. I know I sound negative, but there are certain dolls I genuinely don’t like and don’t see myself ever adding them to my collection, and I want to share that. Plus in terms of video performance, negative videos tend to perform better then positive ones

[@adayinthedollhouse1004]

@@AllycatlovesAG ok that makes sense :)

[@stilltyping13]

Samantha and Ruthie

[@AllycatlovesAG]

I personally find them quite different

[@that_girl_dx1360]

First 3 mins and 24 hours