Altaic languages - word comparison with Map, Animal section

[@yoshiko1036]

So fascinating and educating, thanks for the effort、大変参考になります！

[@Apistoleon]

Nice comparison. Also if you can put local dialects or other synonyms of in all languages, the relationship would be more clear. In some Anatolian dialects of Turkish, " mal" means farm animal. Also, in some Anatolian dialects , "teyin" or "tiyin" means " squirrel" 🐿️. Not everyone would see the sound shifts between the languages, the untrained people may think some languages are not related or less closer. If you can show the sound shifts between the lexical terms of the languages that appear seemingly diverged, but actually related. It would be easier for the untrained individuals, so they can grasp the relationships. Arigato gonzaimas and rahmet to you both.

[@TurkbodndiLanguage]

Thank you for watching our video. Thanks to your comment. We also learn new things. Thank you

[@Apistoleon]

@@TurkbodndiLanguage ​ I really appreciate, you guys making a lot of effort. This is great!!! Please keep inviting Ms Albina. She is very knowledgeable about Chuvash, the precious jewel of Turkic languages that is connecting them, all the way to Great Hunnic Empire's Hunnic language.

[@EnginAtik]

In Turkish we also use “pisi” and “bisi” for cat. “Gel pisi, pisi” means “come here kitty cat.”

[@arthasmenetil3068]

In Kazakh,the word "mal" is used the most to talk about farm animals.

[@arthasmenetil3068]

Are these dialects still in use?

[@leroyurocyon]

私は主なアルタイ言語であるトルコ語、日本語、韓国語と、英語、ドイツ語、スペイン語、フランス語、イタリア語、ロシア語のインド・ヨーロッパ語族の 6 つの言語がとても好きです。 その他の重要な言語としては、北京語などの中国・チベット語や、アラビア語などのアフリカ・アジア言語があります。

[@sirzavod6717]

After watching this video, I was once again convinced that the inclusion of Japanese and Korean in this family is extremely doubtful. I can't find anything in common in terms of basic vocabulary. Moreover, even with modern Russian, it is not difficult to find cognates with ancient languages, such as Latin, ancient Greek. But here there is nothing at all, except for some isolated coincidences. Btw, according to the Kurgan theory, Proto-Indo-European broke up 2500-4500 BC, just like the Altaic proto-language (if it ever existed)

[@llillllii]

Tiger in pure korean is 범(beom) 호랑이(horang-i) is mixed words of chinese character 虎(ho) 狼(rang) and korean 이(i or e)

[@오합지졸동로마군대]

전 세계의 알타이어족 형제들인 튀르키예🇹🇷, 몽골🇲🇳, 카자흐스탄🇰🇿, 한국🇰🇷, 일본🇯🇵, 중앙아시아 국가들, 시베리아 형제들에게 축복을!

[@TurkbodndiLanguage]

감사합니다!

[@leroyurocyon]

우즈벡어도 넣습니다!

[@siyacer]

very interesting

[@Dages_005]

Не забывайте про Кумыкский, Карачаево-Балкарский и ногайский народ, мы тоже тюрки

[@kujira-c5m]

In Japanese we usually say “raion“ but the word “獅子(shishi)”also means lion.

[@TurkbodndiLanguage]

Thank you for watching our video. Yes, we had a candidate 獅子 as lion word in Japanese. Thank you.

[@DN2060DN]

Im Mongolion, we also say 'aduu' for horse.

[@GustafUNL]

This only seems to further weaken the argument for an Altaic language family.

[@TurkbodndiLanguage]

Thank you very much for your comment.

[@Apistoleon]

Actually, there are some similarities between Turkic, Mongolian, Manchu and Korean. You can only see them when you see the sound shifts and have lexical knowledge about them. They were separated thousands of years ago. The similarities always are not totally obvious. Japanese seems quite distant though

[@robabnawaz]

@@Apistoleon there are NO regualar sound shift, and old Mongolian/Korean is even much less similar to turkic languages.

[@otaggokcer6875]

In Turkish livestock (animal) is MAL "Çiftlik Hayvanı" is a definition of MAL.

[@UnitedKorea-w1s]

4:37 Korean Tiger : Beom (Ho-rangi) Ho is Sino-Hanja 11:35 Korean Chicken : Tak

[@jameskynge4757]

A lot of these words have alternatives that aren’t being cited here. If they were cited then more similarities would be apparent in these languages

[@talantabdurashid3939]

Bird is Qush in Kyrgyz, chimchik is a small kinds of birds

[@Susamcocuk]

こういう種類のビデオを公開してくれて本当にありがとうございます。きっととても疲れたでしょうし、この素晴らしいビデオを作るのにたくさんの労力を費やしたことでしょう。しかし、日本語を話せるトルコ人として、日本語とトルコ語は近いとは思いません。人類の歴史上、キリスト以前に日本人を形成していた弥生民族は、単なるツラン民族である可能性もあり、私たちの間には非常に遠いつながりがある、ただそれだけだ。 Thank you so much for publishing these kinds of videos. I am sure you must have been very tired and put a lot of effort into making this wonderful video. However, as a Turk who speaks Japanese, I don't think Japanese and Turkish are close. The Yayoi people, who formed the Japanese people before Christ in human history, could just be a Turan people, and there is a very distant connection between us, that's all. Bu tür videoları yayınladığınız için çok teşekkür ederim. Eminim çok yorulmuşsunuzdur ve bu harika videoyu hazırlamak için çok çaba sarf etmişsinizdir. Ancak Japonca bilen bir Türk olarak Japonca ile Türkçenin yakın olduğunu düşünmüyorum. İnsanlık tarihinde milattan önce Japon halkını oluşturan Yayoi halkı sadece bir Turan halkı olabilir ve aramızda çok uzak bir bağ var o kadar.

[@tengkuferdiansyah8617]

Japonic is near with Austronesian language, and Jomon people migration from Southeast Asia 🌏

[@nadirhikmetkuleli]

Turkish has many dialectal equivalents for the words used in other Turkic languages and some words are obsolete. -Horse is at in Turkish. However, Yılkı (Kazakh Jılqı) is also used for a feral horse or a group of feral horses. -Livestock is çiftlik hayvanı in Turkish. However our dialects have "mal" for cattle or nolt. -For squirrel standard Istanbulite Turkish uses sincap from Persian but Turkic tiyin or teyin still lives in our dialects. -Deer is geyik, but in Anatolian dialects maral or meral is a doe or hind. Also dialectally buğu means a gazelle or antilope (akin to a deer). -A cat is kedi but our dialects use pişik/pisik and we call cats as pisi pisi (kitty kitty). These are related to Central Asian Turkic mışıq/mısıq etc... -Horoz is a Persian loanword, its Anatolian Turkish variant is Öteç (akin to Tatar ätäç and Kazakh äteş) but it is obsolete now.

[@alperensahin1153]

Thank you for the video. As a contribution, the word "meral" in Turkish is widely used as a girl name which means female deer.

[@TurkbodndiLanguage]

Thank you for watching our video. We didn't know the word "meral " is related to Maral in Azerbaijani. It's very interesting ! Thank you for your comment.

[@nikocat2008]

As a Hungarian I am amased. Even if not all the words are similar, but sometimes we use these word a part of the country, or it means a type of that animal. Thank for it! ❤❤

[@saidamsakha]

A native Yakut speaker here. Some corrections: SHEEP in Yakut is khoi/хой ('baraan' is a Russian loanword!!) "mal/мал' means a thing, a property in Yakut. TIGER --> baabyr/баабыр CAMEL --> tebien/тэбиэн Seriously, where'd you find such an uneducated person to represent the Yakut language?! such a shame. you should always check your sources. so-called 'natives' aren't always right! lion: raion in Japanese is obviously a loanword "lion", the Chinese loanword is 'shishi' (獅子), similar to Korean 'saja' ( 사자 = 獅子) livestock: both Korean and Japanese originate from Chinese 家畜 camel: both Korean (nagta) and Japanese (rakuda) originate from Chinese 駱駝 Maybe Chinese borrowings shouldn't be considered if there are native words?

[@otaggokcer6875]

Mal means property in Turkiye Turkish too, and also livestock animals.. and Tiger calls "Kaplan / Babür"

[@nikocat2008]

We also use bárány and juh in Hungary. Sometimes birka aswell.

[@Buyuk_Turanuz]

I am Uzbek from Uzbekistan in Toshkent Tiger = Babur Bobur(Uzbek language

[@UnitedKorea-w1s]

​​@Buyuk_Turanuz Korean Tiger : Beom

[@Yuri-ib3ej]

Мал тоже заимствованное слово.

[@문기강-v2i]

Very interesting. Would you compare Japanese dialects of basic words?

[@圭田村-o4f]

テュルク諸語は似ていますね。

[@SerkanKabak25]

Tiger is also called tonga or tunga in Old Turkic.

[@seseh7068]

Livestock of turkish "Mal" became Korean "Mal", horse . So there were some changes in the meaning of the word as it went across Eurasia. Interesting.

[@xxpark3596]

A Turkic merchant brought horses with him. When an old Korean chief points a horse at him and asks what that is, he replies, "They are my livestock." This is my imagination.

[@Theslaveoflogic]

Gajog, holangi, saja, nagta are not pure Korean.

[@furkancetin3947]

Çiftlik hayvanlarına iç Anadolu'da "mal" kelimesi de kullanılıyor sayın hocam

[@robabnawaz]

As expeczed we see a lot of similar words inside the turkic group, chavash and Saha a little bit farer away. But I do not see any connection to the others. Mogholian and Manchu seem to be closer to each other as well as Korean and japanese which can of cause also be caused by chines loan-words.

[@краузе11]

Yep. I don't understand what Korean and Japanese doing there and what are the arguments why they are. Literally not a single word is similar

[@proudbacteria1373]

Actually Mongolian words were closer to Turkic than Yakut words to other Turkic languages.

[@siyacer]

interesting

[@nikocat2008]

Sheep is bárány in Hungarian❤ or juh ❤ horse is lò. Chiken is tyúk, female often called tojò. Cockerel is kakas.

[@siyacer]

very interesting

[@selcukkyar6418]

So, scientifically, is there a Ural-Altaic language?

[@yukillyouu]

Yes of course

[@robabnawaz]

no !!!

[@jivkoyanchev1998]

For now it's only speculative. There is a language-exchange area in central Asia (a sprachbund), between Kazakh, Mongol, Kyrgyz, Uzbek, Turkmen, Tatar, Uygur and Yakut, but for now the two families, Turkic/Mongolic, are counted as separate. Koreanic and Japonic are separate language families, I believe most people agree on that.

[@proudbacteria1373]

@@jivkoyanchev1998Grammar is absolutely identical between Turkic and Finnic languages but of course vocabulary is different. Though there are a lot of similar words and many of them belong to basic words like pronounce but many of them seem to be borrowing from Indo-European languages ironically. Like pronouns in both languages: ( i) Men - Mina, ( you) Sen -Sina, ( my) Menin - Minun, (your) Senin -Sinun. Absolutely identical in Turkic and Finnic in different forms. In Turkic and Finnic no gender difference. In Turkic Ol ( he, she). In Finnic - Han ( he, she).

[@proudbacteria1373]

@@jivkoyanchev1998Turkic language is obviously a hybrid by its nature due to extremely small population of that area ( small population - easier to change or shift a language) and there were absolutely different populations in one place living - Indo-Europeans ( Scythians), Paleo-Asians ( like Ket and Samoedic peoples), Amur river and Mongolic people migrants. All these three groups merged into each other and lived on the same area with small population which resulted in a hybrid language where you won’t find a core vocabulary. You can find some similarities with Finnic words, some similarities with Mongolic words, some similarities with Ket words, some similarities with Indo-European words. For example famous word Han( Khan) could derive from Indo-European word King ( Kan, Kun in Danish and Swedish) but we can’t prove that. We know that Indo-Europeans lived in Altai and Siberia several thousands years ago.

[@SerkanKabak25]

Mongolian has a very unusual pronunciation. At least the words don’t seem to match up with what the speaker’s saying.

[@jivkoyanchev1998]

Well that's because of the great reduction of vowels in Mongolian. Its a sign of historical spelling, words written in one way, but pronounced in a different way, due to lack of spelling reform.

[@albinapopova252]

На якутскооом тоже Хой

[@ProudToBrotherWithJapans]

Proud to altaic geography better than indo European geography

[@TurkbodndiLanguage]

Thank you very much. We will upload another section. please wait while. Thank you

[@ProudToBrotherWithJapans]

@@TurkbodndiLanguage thanks my altay brother

[@ProudToBrotherWithJapans]

@@TurkbodndiLanguage just spread to nothern asians (altaic) culture against to Europeans

[@irembulut3057]

Why does Türkiye looks like that?

[@SmokeyMountain0]

it is language map

[@irembulut3057]

@@SmokeyMountain0 and???? Bro I've literally lived there and the language is TURKISH nothing else

[@SmokeyMountain0]

@@irembulut3057 Did you forgot Kurdish?

[@irembulut3057]

@@SmokeyMountain0 what did you say i can't see it

[@SmokeyMountain0]

@@irembulut3057 With this pathetic attitude you have shown, you have proven that they are real and that you are disturbed by it.

[@Coby000]

çiftlik hayvanına mal deriz zaten xD

[@Uygar07]

«Мал» al sana mal yazdım😂

[@kkaixer]

Mal in the region of ordu fatsa means cow.

[@하율이의일상_부계정]

3:44 korean is not gajog. It's gachuk.

[@albinapopova252]

На якутском тигр - Баар, где вы нашли не владеющую якутским якутку?

[@ata9750]

Mal in Korean horse? In Turkic languages Mal means animal!

[@sanzhar6399]

4:02 also tigr is russian word too

[@НайырОоржак-з6ц]

если нужен перевод на тувинский язык есть я

[@halilbelberler4390]

Tüekiyede Yaban Tavşanı Göçen

[@sanzhar6399]

5:48 russian word again

[@orhanaliyev9774]

Since when did Koreans become Turkic-speaking?) Something new)) All these Japanese and Koreans have nothing to do with the Turkic peoples at all. Why are you misleading people?? As a descendant of the Oghuz, I will never understand either the Korean or Japanes, we don’t even have a common culture with them, nothing in common

[@robabnawaz]

so true#

[@tengkuferdiansyah8617]

Agree 👌

[@captain75tur]

im from turkey. we says mal.

[@sanzhar6399]

4:24 egh

[@sanzhar6399]

11:26 again

[@UnitedKorea-w1s]

한국쪽 여성분은 자꾸 엉뚱한 단어만 가져오네 ㅡㅡ 한국인 맞나? 치킨은 한국어라 닭 tak 인데 dalg 뭐임? 닭은 닭이지 암닭 숫닭 이러고 있네 ㅋㅋㅇㅋ 기가 찬다

[@Buyuk_Turanuz]

🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@soheildian371]

this kazakh girl are beautiful.

[@albinapopova252]

Мал на якутском вещь

[@Tokyo2905]

There is not altaic language

[@ChristopherTanne-se3pz]

It is. Transeurasic languages. If you like or not. Sry eastasien turc

[@Tokyo2905]

​@@ChristopherTanne-se3pz Are you stupid? Did you know that the similarity between Turkish, Mongolian, and Tungusic in the Swadesh and Leipzig-Jakarta lists is only 14 words out of 300 words? At the same time, did you know that the similarity between Turkish and Dravidian reaches 33 words, while the similarity between Turkish and Indo-European reaches 190 words?

[@フォックスjp]

日本は3万年以上前に最初に日本へ来た人はトルコ系民族だった可能性が高いですが、その後イスラエル系の人が大きく日本の文化を変えてる。現在の日本語の単語はヘブライ語の影響を受けてる可能性があります。

[@TurkbodndiLanguage]

ご視聴くださりありがとうございました。

[@orhanaliyev9774]

If they were Turks, then you had a Turkic culture, at least you believed in Tengri. but you are not Turks, alas

[@TurkicQaghan]

Israelites? Really? Is there some errors in the translation?

[@sirzavod6717]

japanese is not turkish at all. it is funny to read about israelis. you are the first japanese antisemmit i have ever seen

[@mirnowruz]

Korean and Japanese are not altaic

[@sanzhar6399]

9:40 russian word again