Analyzing My Worst-Ever Whatnot Auction [What Sold]

[@trendyhunter9392]

The photo of you smiling with your coffee and the word “disaster” right next to it really reeled me in here. You’re the best. 😂

[@lisaliv2585]

Thank you for telling it like it is. I'm a huge fan of learning by doing. You are a better seller on whatnot now because of this experience.

[@amethystscorner]

Thank you for sharing this! I definitely signed up for what not with the expectations low. I never expected it to be my main form of resale but it's done a lot for me in terms of rekindling my love of resale and helping me move some inventory that I wasn't super passionate about. I appreciate these types of videos

[@swmdad1]

no matter the content you are always informative and fun to listen to. Love your advice and analysis across the board

[@joseelacasse3189]

Good, honest analysis. The other resellers that I follow who seem to do extremely well on Whatnot tend to advertise their upcoming events big time on YT and Instagram, sometimes annoyingly so, but their followers know when the event is happening and what will be on offer, they show up and buy their stuff for decent money. I'm sure you will do very well next time, Matt

[@brian942011]

I feel your frustration believe me I’ve been on whatnot for almost 2 years and it still has its problems. I sell trading cards and use to start them at $1 but not anymore since I can’t seem to get more viewers for whatever reason so I end up taking a huge loss. It’s definitely a struggle and honestly I think part of the problem is that they have too many sellers and not enough buyers.

[@robsomething4435]

Agree. The influx of sellers is diluting the platform too much. I have personally moved on, not worth the time for me to make a fraction of what I can command on pretty much any other platform.

[@BethDavidoff]

I was waiting till the end of video to see if you would put lipstick on your hand to do Sesame Street voices!

[@dianeshiddengem]

This just shows us all you have a great sense of humor. That you can drink coffee and laugh at yourself. Knowing not all things go the way we planned it out. Good luck on your next show. Chin up, keep laughing and doing what you do best. ❤️❤️

[@lurkingcaro]

I knew you were hilarious, so I was glad you did the video about your comedy. I have a strange dry humor as well. Lol. I'm still scared to try what not.

[@cheddartreez6826]

The only reason Daily Refinement is on WhatNot is because he's banned from Ebay. I hear Nicole State who was banned on Ebay is on WhatNot and is probably going to get banned on WhatNot. They are so desperate, they have to try to scam resellers with faux "wholesale." Cringy.

[@Launena100]

Daily refinement has admitted that Whatnot has removed a lot of his negative reviews from those crappy mystery boxes 😒

[@cheddartreez6826]

@@Launena100 He's still doing it i believe. He says everyone should be able to double their money on his wholesale boxes. All this means is he's plucking out the best stuff and selling us his deathpile.

[@elliecandle773]

How is it faux wholesale? Also I was thing about buying one of his boxes and I read the reviews and decided not to!

[@maries1381]

Hey Matt, as always I appreciate your transparency. I am not a Whatnot seller but do have a question for you. Was your show on a Friday night? I remember when you started selling on the platform you scheduled your shows on Friday nights. If so, besides the glitches, do you think that perhaps scheduling a show for a Monday or Tuesday night when more people are 'home' and not out socializing might help? Back in the days of Ebay when auctions were truly 'the thing' (talking about 20+ years ago) I remember strategically scheduling my listings so they would end on a Sunday or Monday night (also at a time when it wasn't too late on the East coast... around 7 to 8 pm pacific). I also would take into account if selling mens clothing, I would avoid a popular sports tv night. Obviously, back then people did not have 'smart phones' or much access to the internet on the go. Just curious if that might help... especially since people are socializing much more now and in the 'holiday' and 'fall' spirit. Seems like restaurants, gastropubs and bars are crowded here in lala land on the weekends.

[@ThriftALife]

I think there's something to that, yeah. I schedule my friday auctions for 5 Pacific, which I think catches most people before they go out. Haven't noticed a huge discrepancy between this and weeknights. But certainly something to pay attention to.

[@MadelineTheFashion]

Poshmark recently introduced the same form of live selling as whatnot. Assuming this could be a major reason why the lower sales on whatnot.

[@wiggiq995]

Thanks for the information. Although I don't sell on WhatNot, your information is helpful.

[@michellelane8961]

I really appreciate this and you being willing to talk about mistakes! I tried to bid on an item the other night and didn’t know I got an update so I didn’t get the item and I was willing to pay!! I have my first sale tomorrow 11/7 7:30 (lemonsoda) and I’ve agonized a little over what to choose to sell. I’m a poshmark seller which I enjoy but I work way too hard for the amount that I actually sell. Hoping to do better on Whatnot. I will keep watching you for inspiration!

[@B0BBuys]

I would definitely take his advice and promote on your socials, and also stick to a genre show both really do make a difference.

[@michellelane8961]

Thank you!

[@giancarlotorres3520]

Woah that USC polo could be 20-25 on ebay man! You have an influence so whatnot is an advantage for you. Keep it up man!!

[@Tania_VolverVintage]

Still better than any of my planned what not sales. I think my best sale was $185 and honestly I would rather do a live sale than something like uber eats/door dash. Your at home just talking to people on the internet 😂 I love live sales even the worst ones are profitable!

[@helpfulcommenter]

I like your name ;)

[@Tania_VolverVintage]

@@helpfulcommenter thank you!

[@ThriftALife]

Definitely a great way to look at it. Maybe I am spoiled by past successes.

[@vdr3846]

I've worked for Uber Eats. It's AWFUL. My experience with regular Uber was mixed, but I at least got to meet some cool people.

[@chrissheffield5468]

This thumbnail is the standard by which all "Hide The Pain" memes will be judged.

[@sundropkat]

Does whatnot have a set starting bid, or can you start the items at various prices?

[@ThriftALife]

You can pick any starting price on any item.

[@uwannadance1971]

Whatnot has been around for a year and shouldn't be having problems. Sucks that you had to pay for their issues. Been with them since the beginning and got a TON of awesome deals.

[@ThriftALife]

I guess. Cars have been around for almost a century and a half and they still break down all the time.

[@SzSouthfox]

Matt someone is using your picture to run a scam on here . Supposedly a contest for a box of Quality stuff just for paying for shipping, starting at $80 and it goes up depending on what carrier I want to use. I did not fall for but some one may.

[@ThriftALife]

Thanks Suzette, I did catch it. The account's been reported and blocked and I deleted all the comments.

[@pamela4236]

This thumbnail needs to get traction as the new "This is fine" meme. 😄 ✌

[@Dawn-S]

I’m so very glad you kept the sneezes in! I sneeze exactly like it! Yikes! Unexpectedly 😅

[@catherinemorriss6082]

Could you start the price higher than $3 … like $5 to make sure you make a profit per item?

[@ThriftALife]

I could, yeah. 3 has been a sweet spot for me

[@DruidUkari]

I’ve decided not to do clothing on whatnot. I’m just not popular in the clothing category. Gonna be changing it up, but Pokémon and comics is where I’m finding my sweet spot.

[@jonnyschaff7068]

We’re friends now. Just started reselling. Listing 15 a day. Bought your manifesto for a measly 5 dollars. I just quit my job to do this and money is tight. I was wondering however if I could add tags to the manifesto and send you the draft.

[@brndafay8518]

Your responses to some of the comments kills me 🤣😂🇨🇦💗

[@NN-pe6ip]

Sounds like you got a taste of being a "regular" seller on Whatnot without a huge social media following.

[@ThriftALife]

Siqq

[@mattk8810]

@@ThriftALife you didnt announce whatnot anything in your last video!

[@dreamsreselling7215]

Why shouldn't he use his social social media following for Whatnot ? I'm sure one time Matt started out his channel with just a few hundred sub's. And has grew his channel through his own hard work. Good on him i say

[@Xeyxey0]

@@dreamsreselling7215 Did someone delete their comment? I think the original comment was just saying that's how it is for the people who sell that aren't hugely popular and make it seem like Whatnot is for everyone.

[@lindak1768]

I just signed up to buy on what not and was watching a few ladies try to sell jewelry. It looked hard, they was not successful. My cat likes to touch my iPad and I was afraid he would bid on something. So I quit watching. The swipe thing would help with that, maybe.

[@NicholasMarty]

Even though it didn't go as well as you'd hoped. I think you probably still learned a lot and the next one will be better! Keep it up!

[@kathyisonline2986]

Just curious on a $3 item what the fees would be and what your cost is for shipping. or does the buyer pay the entire shipping cost? I live in an off grid tiny house with 2 lofts where I store my inventory. So the way I feel is its got to be worth me climbing up the ladder if I'm going to accept an offer. Consequently, I don't make a lot of sales. I try to concentrate on those higher dollar sales because I'm basically working to pay for health insurance and high cost meds. The State pays for disabled people's health insurance if they work. The catch is that if you're a sole proprietor you have to make a profit. You can't just sell stuff to keep busy, or as a hobby it has to be a bona fide occupation. That is why I have to be choosey about how I spend my time. So if there's a chance I would only break even on WhatNot it wouldn't work for me.

[@michelle9057]

As a buyer I will cruise right by auctions that are vague in its content, or nothing in the store. I’m shopping for plus size and bags; if you’re not marketing your show to the proper audience, you’ll sell stuff for 0.00. I know you won’t make that mistake again!

[@patipetals]

Resellers are just hurting themselves with these dumb auctions and the lowball prices . Now poshmark is doing the same. All this is becoming a dumpster fire.

[@bigyumbo]

Good idea. You should definitely quit.

[@ThriftALife]

You're right, I will orchestrate a massive price-fixing scheme across all independent resellers and large retailers to make sure prices never fluctuate, and new marketplaces don't emerge,, for the first time in human history.

[@BenVanCamp]

Most buyers for fixed price items are not willing to sit through these auctions. They are not competitors with us. They are sources for us more than anything. Does not hurt.

[@timhazeltine3256]

@@patipetals Curious to know what standards you are contemplating.

[@matthewjackson5990]

I’ve seen a lot of streams on whatnot glitch recently

[@simoneleone]

You're awesome, no matter where you sell. I'm happy Whatnot has been reaping you rewards and I'm sure this sitch was a one-off. Hang tight. :)

[@skokiereaders]

Sad @ Lululemon sale for so low. 😬

[@helpfulcommenter]

That Normal shirt is fire, I would have paid $20 on eBay. Just kidding I don't shop on eBay I just sell stuff there. But I'd pay like $15 in a store.

[@robertschemmel971]

Its alot of. a work for such low sales. I give you credit for sticking with it but its not for me.

[@tristanconnell6574]

I really don't like whatnot as a buyer or a seller. I can see the appeal but it's just not for me

[@NiftyNate-sy7gp]

I just had a large Christmas show and had 1 sale- only because she won a giveaway . Seems everyone wants items for free. Very discouraging.

[@jmavierpayne9726]

Hey, you gotta get off whatnot... Seriously. You don't know me or what I sell, but close your eyes and listen to me say I sold 75 items for $3-$5 each. Then I hauled a huge bag of shipping to the USPS for a whopping $250 GROSS .. Now open your eyes and look in the mirror. Love ya brother 💪

[@mrslehman3]

Sorry I missed the sale. :(

[@thriftingsistersaudrey]

All part of the learning curve.

[@bethinthe305]

Sorry I missed that whatnot show

[@carriebettinger]

Right now Whatnot has a problem…..resellers selling to resellers. That’s just my opinion conspiracy allegedly

[@robsomething4435]

This!

[@colleenrotondo7666]

Clothing catagory on Whatnot has always been resellers selling to resellers and that was never going to be sustainable. Could see the rise and fall from a mile away. Most of the bigger " influencers" have all but left the platform and are trying Poshmark Lives now or back to listing again. They told everyone to join Whatnot and like sheep people did. Group think mentality crack me up.

[@ThriftALife]

@@colleenrotondo7666 u see thru the bullcrapp

[@colleenrotondo7666]

@@ThriftALife Well for alot of the clothing sellers it was raining money for them with all the free referral dollars and people joining with their link. Good for them they made their money while everyone was still high on the adrenaline rush of pressing a bid button to buy a sub par piece of clothing. Stick with the book auctions.😊

[@AnatheBrave]

I would have paid 40 for the Marx tee❤

[@FaithfulListener315]

is whatnot good for you because you have a following? I don't have a KZbin channel so I don't think I'd get many ppl to find me.

[@ThriftALife]

It certainly helps. There is success to be found without one though.

[@Chicago48]

$250 - what was Whatnot's commission?

[@ThriftALife]

Probably around $40

[@shannonw5999]

Wow, some of these comments are unreal. Can't believe people feel entitled to complain about what type of content you choose to put out.

[@bobrohubres7704]

this is so sad

[@KevinDurantisnot]

Anyone remember when this guy used to make really good informative videos centered around the manifesto?

[@ThriftALife]

Anyone remember deez nuts?

[@KevinDurantisnot]

@@ThriftALife Feel free to take or ignore the passive aggressive criticism

[@carriebettinger]

Burn🔥🔥 Kevin

[@themercado210]

@@ThriftALife 😂😂😂😂

[@DonnaW71]

As you are his #1 super fan, I'm sure you do

[@elifern2642]

Even inventory that's gone around the track a few times has its platform: yardsale. I run yard sales every once in a while with stale Inventory and its gone great. Maybe you should give that a try. You'll be surprised how much you can make on stuff before donating it. Every penny counts these days

[@mrEVOLjo]

maybe im blessed and can find $50 plus shirts everyday but this is low quality stuff man....i wouldnt buy any of these

[@guavagirl8344]

Nice typing, LOL.