"Apple Sleep Experiment" - MLP Grimdark Song

[@thelostnarrator]

CHECK OUT THE OFFICIAL SEQUEL TO APPLE SLEEP EXPERIMENT: kzbin.info/www/bejne/e2a1c2xoi7mVY5Ysi=zBDByogf_8KWMP0u

[@PullaWheellllll]

As somebody who has the irrational fear of being afraid of a piece of media once it reaches a certain amount of years old instead of being able to enjoy the memories, i am thankful for a sequel to trick my brain into thinking it shouldn't be scared cause the original is now still relevant. I wish everyone involved continued joy and success, cheeeeeeeers to the sequel!

[@DianeWinchester94]

Now this song needs a sequel apple blooms POV.

[@whattheflipper27]

SEQUEL??

[@funnatopia704]

This song hits so different after “Another Apple Sleep Experiment”

[@mushroom5209]

It really does

[@queenkaterose]

Yep

[@darkwolf988ify]

Very

[@Murasaki_RS]

Applejack you’re acting strange. Eat a snickers.

[@queenlatrodectushasselti7711]

Eats snickers Better? Better!

[@angelicsakura4928]

She needs a SNICKERS and a EXORCIST

[@cronaxblade]

You're not you when your hungry

[@Goobie_Snooberting]

Aj have a break. Have a kit kat.

[@jamieharris693]

@@angelicsakura4928 nu she needs kit kat U_U AND a exorcist

[@devilhowl7455]

Poor AJ. She got a fate worse than death. Half responsible for the deaths of over a dozen ponies including her sister, Twilight more or less threw her under the bus, and she's serving a life sentence in a dark prison. I wonder how the Apple family and the rest of the mane 6 are handling this. Best case scenario, AJ doesn't get any of her memories back and she dies. Worst case scenario, they slowly return and become more vivid. If the fic had a sequel and she somehow gets out of there she'd go after Twilight with a vengeance. Also, if it were up to me I would've put Aj down instead of locking her up. Not as a punishment, but an act of kindness to a friend. Great song by the way.

[@birthdayfriendship8399]

Yes but that would be awesome

[@poofy3202]

It would be AMAZING

[@charleswalker8262]

I Agree 💯!

[@Magicalwolfgamer]

I felt more bad for aj . It wasn’t her fault. Twilight should of tested the potion before hand.

[@redballoon9007]

@@Magicalwolfgamer She just should have magic-ed the Zap Apples down tbh.

[@violetsmokes5815]

We need an Applebloom song now.

[@Magpiepony]

I have to admit, this is probably one of my favorite songs I've ever written the lyrics and melodies for in the history of my KZbin career... Glory did such an AMAZING JOB singing and Lost with her backing vocals are just awesome

[@cherryberry1073]

First to respond

[@birthdayfriendship8399]

Yes

[@kira101]

This is seriously amazing!! Could you release the instrumental? (when you can!)

[@tirzahchaney3067]

Same here

[@andrewjennings7306]

@@kira101 the music belongs th the dark somnium

[@prismanocturnalpony3819]

I wonder how Lost did those screaming parts without making her neighbours wonder what's happening.

[@roadiegirl2000]

Sound proofed the walls?

[@prismanocturnalpony3819]

@@roadiegirl2000 Probably

[@gachamoon_xx5235]

Apple jack lives on a farm :> Her house is deep in forest so it's almost impossible for peeps to here her :>

[@y.9645]

i just wonder if her vocal coards are ok lol

[@kiddo6925]

@@gachamoon_xx5235 they meant how Lost did the voices for this song, and how Lost's neighbors didnt hear her-

[@CT-BONITA]

I'm still gonna hold twilight responsible for what happened. 13 ponies, the blood is on HER hooves, not applejacks. The potion is her doing. She will reap what she sown.

[@billie-jsullivan8581]

Same I still hold a grudge against twilight to this day since she is responsible for the deaths not poor aj grrr!!!! I hate twilight so much in this fanfic she made aj suffer knowing it's all her fault who did this (by that I mean twilight) she's a monster from hell

[@nicholasnguyen5181]

She’s really hi rep, so no one would’ve suspected her 😂. Just like how pinkies a killer, and no one knew

[@michaelpollard5977]

Guys this is filthy riches fault if he hadn't been so greedy she wouldnt have gone crazy so it's partly his fault

[@Dewdropster]

It’s not fully twilight’s fault, she didn’t have to lie about the potion, but she did warn AJ

[@CT-BONITA]

@@Dewdropster 🤦

[@PhillyCheeseBro]

That accent low key scared me for a second

[@arandomjew3127]

Me, someone with a southern accent: 👁👄👁

[@PhillyCheeseBro]

The fact that I can sing in that accent scares me more

[@Clown234-k1p]

Dats offensive

[@xxvioletcookiexx1668]

Lol yup

[@jazzykingjack2846]

That potion that AJ drank really did a number on her mental health. I loved that story it was bone chilling and the ending, in my mind is kinda the aftermath of the potion wearing off. Still another awesome song for an awesome grimdark fic. Though the ending is really confusing.

[@Earth.is.F1AT]

it never wore off LOL they had to inject her with the antidote

[@TheManWhoErasedHisNane]

Twilight should have known better than to give her friend an experimental potion that for all she knows could have immediately killed her or something a careless decision that resulted in the deaths of multiple ponies one of them being Apple Bloom (even if she does survive considering this is AJ we are talking about that kick definitely would cause major brain damage)

[@katelynthewhitewerewolf6376]

​@@TheManWhoErasedHisNane Even if Twilight didn't give her the potion AJ probably would've stolen it without her and Spike knowing it and drink it and everything would happen anyway.

[@summersweete09]

What makes the story so unnerving to me is Twilight basically says it her potion robs AJ of her sleep when creatures don’t sleep they do really hallucinate and can be delusional the memory loss also lines up as it is a psychological affect of no sleep we don’t know how long Aj was awake by the time they cured her it’s no surprise she went insane it’s wonder she didn’t die herself

[@renamon5658]

Well if you don't sleep for 72 hours you become insane

[@renamon5658]

@Arnorian Restoration according to deathbattle frank west vs leon s Kennedy they mentioned if you go without sleep 3 days in a row you will hallucinate

[@queensurreal]

I’m thinking she was probably up for a week or two

[@savannahhague4989]

@@queensurreal possibly.

[@bertacrowler1784]

I think AJ was active without sleep like... 2 months. Just the fact that her broken legs were cured. Broken bones need to grow like... 3 weeks. But its only in normal way! AJ used to walk all this time and that slowed process of heal. And if its legs they take all weight of body. So its needed 2 or even 3 months. Without sleep... And still alive. We still don't know effects of magic. Twilight need to start buisnes of energetics.

[@Jerkwad152]

There was always one plot hole in the story I could never resolve. Rainbow Dash, Pinkie Pie, Fluttershy and Rarity all knew that Twilight was the one who mixed up the potion that made Applejack go crazy. Why would they go along with her imprisonment? At the very least, why would they let that stay secret?

[@summersweete09]

I always assumed everyone kept it secret because no one wanted to admit twilight could cause such carnage plus if twilight admits she caused it she’d be Imprisoned with AJ could be wrong tho

[@Jerkwad152]

@@summersweete09 That could explain one of them, maybe two at the outside. No way all four would go for that though.

[@summersweete09]

@@Jerkwad152 I agree with you I’m just trying to make sense of it is all

[@foxythepirate7918]

Scared plus no one will believe she could do it

[@maizielozano8420]

@@Jerkwad152 Hmmm- sequel potential perhaps? Maybe the author could address this plot point and even use it to their advantage if they ever decide to make a continuation.

[@TheCommenterDragon]

Applejack's Apple angry melody...as usual the vocals in this song are totally awesome and the music is both bone chilling and vibrant, thank you for this Lost Happy Nightmare Night!!!

[@whoknows7889]

Apple sleep experiment is one angry version of Applejack.

[@katelynthewhitewerewolf6376]

@@whoknows7889 She looks so funny with the angry face

[@whoknows7889]

@@katelynthewhitewerewolf6376 I personally think Apple Sleep Experiment looks really angry and sleep deprived. Just my opinion.

[@JustAWeirdo_123]

In the depths of her cell, she has nothing but time. Time soothes her wounds, but does nothing for her rage. She trains her damaged body. To build the strength to someday escape and become the monster her former friend made her out to be. She will discover the fate of her sister, and expose the so called princess of friendship. She would die trying, but would be sure to take her false friend down with her.

[@theloganator5738]

I would like to see that get adapted into a grimdark story as a sequel to the Apple Sleep Experiment

[@theshinyguru951]

@@theloganator5738 same here

[@questionablemotivegirl6054]

Can I make a fanfic outta this?

[@theshinyguru951]

@@questionablemotivegirl6054 its already based on a fanfic called an apple sleep experiment. Unless u meant one of ur own?

[@JustAWeirdo_123]

@@questionablemotivegirl6054 go for it bruh

[@parthxus]

Ok- time for a small story. I never listened to An Apple Sleep Experiment until a few months ago in like June/July. When I listened to it, I was obsessed with it. I love the story to the point I have fan art of the story as my laptop background. I listen to it atleast every week or so because of how it gives me the chills but also makes a good reading. When I saw “a bone breaking buck” in your trailer, I was hyped. I have been waiting for it since you announced the trailer and when I saw this I got more chills. At first it didn’t seem very scary but as it went on, I felt the chills. Well done Lost! Thank you for the amazing narration of An Apple Sleep Experiment and the song for it!

[@Magpiepony]

Aww that's so sweet, thank you!! It's one of my favorite things I have written (song and story tbh) so this just made my day

[@parthxus]

@@Magpiepony yes! You did an amazing job writing it! My fav grimdark I’ve listened too :)

[@jasonethridge4506]

@@Magpiepony This is very spooky. I love it. I wish you could do a sequel.

[@dabi211]

FRRR

[@arumikahaven]

Apple Sleep Experiment is my favorite MLP fanfic for the reasons you listed

[@Bluefoxtail]

Lost, I can only imagine how fun, yet exhausting it was to play the role of "Screaming Applejack." RIP vocal chords. Also, did anyone else notice that the background music is the same music played during the credits of this story's narration video? Such a cool touch! The effort in this song is so evident, and I am loving it!

[@crystalpayne_entertains9903]

DAMN!! the shouting parts caught me off guard XD This was really great!!! Chilling, Grim and malicious~

[@Rockhoppr3]

This was one of the first MLP darkfics I've listened to, so this brought back some nostalgia. As for the song itself, I just love the darkly melancholic beauty of the guitar and vocals, contrasted greatly with Applejack's twisted, violent side.

[@MultiMegaman64]

Losty, I did NOT expect you to make another one of these ghoulishly sinister symphonies! Throughout this song, it gives me the haunting chills as I kept coming back for more! I’ve listened to you reading “An Apple Sleep Experiment” before, and the lyrics are basically a musical interpretation of that very story! From Applejack’s descent into bloody and gory insanity while finding Filthy Rich, to her in a jail cell, left to die by Twilight. Those lyrics just shook me to my very bones! Happy Halloween Losty... And you too Mag... *evil laugh*

[@ccappa2001]

0:53 that face is one of the scariest faces I've seen, this song makes me so creeped out I couldn't sleep after watching the story narration :"( I was so scared because I was young and was like "Wow mlp that looks cool" then got TRAUMATIZED

[@maskvideos8325]

I imagine twilight having a dream where AJ is screaming at her for doing this to her "You were supoust to be my frend! I WILL NEVER LET YOU REST!!!"

[@SarahMallo]

Ooooooh, I like that *evil laughter*

[@Im_The_Magic_Dinglenut]

Always blown away when I hear how similar AJ's voice was in this song compared to the show. Absolutely amazing lyrics, visuals, and vocals! It's been stuck in my head for the past few hours pft.

[@jareththegoblinking3191]

Applejack: Now this is just darn disturbin Pinkie Pie: And I thought I was creepy Rainbow Dash: They made really scary stories about me, I was awesome Fluttershy: Oh my, I don't like the stories they made about me Rarity: Or me Twilight: Or me

[@TheCourtJester8]

I'm kinda curious to hear their stories now, except Apple Jack and Rainbow Dash for I already heard their stories. An Apple Sleep Experiment and Rocket of Insanity. ( And also Big Mac's creepy story)

[@arcticwolflover263]

@@TheCourtJester8 twilights is expirament of twilight sparkle,rarity little miss rarity,pinkie,cupcakes or muffins afterstory,and fluttershy butterflies

[@TheCourtJester8]

@@arcticwolflover263 I think I heard a couple of those already, but that was The Experiment of Twilight Sparkles about?

[@arcticwolflover263]

@@TheCourtJester8 uhm well the fic..is basically like cupcakes.but in the fic twis sane,but puts her friends through death like experaments,namely youd have to read to find out what they are..trust me is dark as hell

[@TheCourtJester8]

@@arcticwolflover263 I remembered listening to Apple Jack's story and the one with the butterflies. Both were creepy, especially the one with Twilight and her toy Smarty Pants. As for Rarity it was by dubbed comics.

[@mayaharmony4394]

I can't stop listening to this

[@retroradkat]

"A bone-breaking buck..." When you think about it, despite being the least popular of the mane six, AJ is the best and most terrifying candidate for grimdark. AJ's super-powered apple bucking strength is unparalleled, even among Earth ponies. I always wondered what kind of damage a buck could do if AJ was insane with anger.... and this fic answers that question 😬

[@GutiSerenade]

Applebars for Appledays~~

[@shannonpotter1233]

I'm actually still mad at Twilight. This song was sang most beautifully, this made my day.🤟

[@mlp_g5_updates785]

Same! And yeah, it was awesome :)

[@katelynthewhitewerewolf6376]

@@mlp_g5_updates785 I like The Creepypasta Series and The Creepypasta Characters and I'm a big fan of The Creepypasta Series.

[@Bostonterrierslol]

This was one of my favorites and I just love that people are keeping it alive. It just goes to show that even with the show over with the fans will keep it alive. That makes me feel better. Happy Nightmare Night Everypony

[@animooredpanda7097]

The ending still confused me, but the story amazing. And it's Filthy Rich's fault for Applejack's downfall

[@parthxus]

I agree with the ending, it confused me until I finally knew what happened. I also believe it’s twilights fault for AJs downfall.

[@animooredpanda7097]

@@parthxus think you can explain the ending?

[@parthxus]

@@animooredpanda7097 Basically, I had to look this up, but it was twilights potion/spell that made AJ basically go insane. It wasn’t because of the heat, as she told AJ. You also know it’s twilights fault because of when in the present, when they visit AJ, she’s gloomy and knows it’s her fault AJ winded up in the hospital.

[@screamitloud7923]

@@animooredpanda7097 Twilight lied to Applejack at the end. Saying Apple went crazy in the heat and killed all those ponies so Twilight wouldn’t have to take partial blame for giving Applejack the potion in the first place. Because if the town found out her entire reputation as princess of friendship would be ruined. Apple is pretty much set to a life sentence in jail for her crimes and Twilight leaves with the town thinking she’s innocent but her having the guilt knowing part of this is her fault, and now her friend is paying for it.

[@helpersmultiuniverse9645]

Ending summed up: Applejack wakes up after affect of the potion (and when given the cure serum) and Twilight asks what she remembers and Applejack states that Twi gave her said potion but Twilight lies saying she never have it to her. She did this to save her own skin and keep her reputation (if Twi was honest she'd be also heald accountable for Applejack's breakdown and murders). Applejack felt betrayed and was upset. Twilight leaves Applejack to rot in the cell as Applejack asks if her family is ok. When she asked about Applebloom however and Twi didn't respond, its heavily implied that Applebloom died when AJ bucked her. This lead AJ to continue asking and fear what she may have done to Appleblooml

[@katiemefford6483]

Theses songs keep getting better and better. I hope they will eventually become available on a steaming service in the future

[@clarissaokeSkittlecat]

Just as the other day i watch the apple sleep experiment. You can clearly hear the rage in applejack voice And the betrayal that aj feel when twilight put blame on aj. Bravo! Love this❤

[@ArianaNicole]

It will always be such a pleasure to work with old friends

[@alienreble9426]

Apple sleep experiment was the FIRST MLP Grimdark fic I ever listened too and this is amazing!!

[@pastevyx507]

i absolutely can’t get over how spot-on AJ sounds. if i didn’t know any better i’d say it’s her actual voice actress singing. i keep coming back to this video. wonderful job!

[@TakumoKun]

Ugh im late but lemme say.. WHERE DO I BEGIN?! Ariana's Vocals up front really give that haunting country feeling y'know? Not to mention in the cuts with Lost's screaming remarks..this just gives me straight chills top to bottom! Marvelous writing Mag, amazing Vocals Ariana n Lost its all just..*chef kiss*

[@tabby21dreams33]

I love how it's never shown in this song exactly what she did, you would only know if you read or listen to the fic! Such a smart way to write the song, to take us into how she saw things!

[@cameronjsmith7382]

The song was absolutely awesome! Really well done! You're an incredible VA Lost both you and Mag totally rocked!

[@Starryflame]

I believe the singer was Ariana Nicole with Lost on the vocals :P

[@cameronjsmith7382]

@@Starryflame she did great as well! But I meant Mag did well writing the lyrics

[@Starryflame]

@@cameronjsmith7382 Ah gotcha, misunderstood

[@cameronjsmith7382]

@@Starryflame its alright Starry :)

[@Gresekjr122]

Oh my goddesses Ariana & Lost Narrator you both did a wonderful job. This song really goes with this story. Fantastic lyrics MagpiePony. Keep up the good work everyone. Have a wonderful Spooky Day. Love you Lost Magpie & Ariana.

[@gren8te319]

i feel so horrible for aj in this fic

[@y.9645]

i only now realized this background music was used at the end credits of Apple Sleep Experiment which makes this 20%cooler

[@pokemonfan6132]

This was truly a great song, you and everyone involved through this month has made this sucky year just a bit better, so thanks for the hard work.

[@FaolanCortez]

This was a splendid song creation! I have to get this on my phone since I've been replaying this ever since the upload. 😍 Applejack's constant mood-switches in the song defined her descent into gory insanity in glorious fashion! Wonderful job on providing the vocals on Applejack's madness, Lost. Ariana did a lovely job as well! This sinister symphony is a golden keeper for certain! 💚 😈

[@heathledgerthelegend7699]

I LOVED THIS STORY!! And the song is perfect for it, I love what you did with this Voice Over. This is now going on my mix!

[@ashleighstangeland5046]

I CALLED IT FROM THE TRAILER both a Rainbow Factory based song AND an Apple Sleep Experiment based song.... And I was not disappointed.... Now if tomorrows is Vampire Vinyl based I will be shocked... Either way I am ready for the last song... For halloween/nightmare night.... Lets do this.... Also FANTASTIC job again Lost and Mag.... Happy almost Nightmare Night/Halloween you two hope you are staying safe

[@silver45470]

This one's amazing! I fell in love right after the first cords. Lyrics and the atmosphere are so perfectly matched they complete each other. You've done a fantastic job, Lost and Mag! I wish you both and everypony a marvellous Halloween :-)

[@shimmeringglimmerart8746]

I always wanted a song for this fan fic and now it is here !!!!!😭💗💗💗

[@classicsans4973]

YES JESUS I LOVE THIS

[@amaracrisostomo2612]

An Apple Sleep experiment made me shiver to the bone, and this song fits perfectly to the story! The mental change of Applejack in the song was my favorite part. Great job on this 👏

[@jupiter_crawford]

AMAZING the rhythm is like a lullaby but the lyrics have a sinister tone and it just all comes together beautifully, like a twisted melody

[@BeesMeliss]

The screaming parts scared me a little bit. Great song! :)

[@moody_lumi]

This is beautifully sung and gives me a beauty of annihilation, but if it was calmer and slower that keeps a nice pace that’s surprisingly relaxing.

[@pacifistdoodl3r354]

agreed, fren ヾ(@^▽^@)ノ

[@emperorrenfieldblackburn549]

Great emperor here, the song. The melody. The horror. It's beautiful work you've done, well done. "Well done indeed" *said Baxter who was sitting on his chair clapping as an applause rather a slow clapping though* "I say she's a good lyrics writer" *referring to magpie* yes indeed so, don't forget the rest of the crew as well, they too did splendid. *glasses clinged as we drink cherry wine together getting prepared for Halloween* Magpie, Curse word and the rest of you please enjoy your Halloween tomorrow. "Stay safe as well" *said Baxter*

[@summersweete09]

That was amazing! I’ve listened to Apple sleep experiment so many times though out the years due to it being so good and actually scaring me I didn’t expect a song it’s awesome! Great job now I have two songs to continually listen to this and the rainbow factory 😊

[@zaybug]

this is so beautiful !!! god you are so talented lost !!! keep up the incredible work magpie and lost

[@raincloud7273]

I think this is the one of fanfic where I hate twilight. She isn’t my favorite but I remember being upset of what she did in the end.

[@raven3067]

This is absolutely beautiful. The story scared me when I first listened to it.

[@BellaPinkSavage]

OH MY GOD! FRICKEN YES! I was hoping you guys were gonna do something with Apple sleep! Everyone did a fantastic job! Bravo! 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

[@andrewjennings7306]

Hey isn't this dark somnium music? He's the best creepypasta channel there is!

[@lunaalsephina]

Yeah, I recognized that too lol

[@katelynthewhitewerewolf6376]

​@@lunaalsephina I know him he does Creepypastas.

[@Kathy-eh8jt]

In my option if someone can do that to their so called friend to save there skin. You don't deserve to be a princess of friendship, let alone be the elements of harmony.

[@fluffystar7088]

Oh jeez, I listened to the grim dark, now I've listened to the song... instant sub XD

[@mangabrony6125]

My favorite reading got a song! Awesome!

[@lightningfirst689]

When you wake up 5 minutes before your alarm goes off.

[@MissKoiFishPonyProductions]

This has to be my favorite Sinister symphony song due solely to Lost’s wickedly awesome death metal backing vocals 😈👏❤️ Rock on Lostie 🤘, rock on 🤘 Also Happy Halloween 🎃 ❣️Thank you for this month filled with beautifully sinister melodies🌙💛

[@MintAddictWolfy]

OMG YES!!! I'VE BEEN WAITING FOR A SONG OF THIS FOR SO LONG!! GREAT JOB TO THE BOTH OF YOU!!

[@KitsuneRokaku]

I know I keep saying this but I'd love a sequel to this story. Maybe a group of ponies gather to try to solve the mystery of what caused AJ to snap, for example Sunburst and Maud Pie because they don't buy Twilight's explanation of what "happened". They manage to get a visit to AJ with the help of someone like Discord to get them in without being noticed by someone who would tell Twilight. AJ, who remembers most of her actions, tells them what happened and they form a small group to expose the Princess of Friendship. Maud would have a stake in it because she noticed Pinkie was acting secretive and sad, Sunburst would have a stake because he's worried about Starlight and he wants to know the truth, Discord offers to help because for some odd reason he doesn't know how AJ was able to go on her madness induced rampage without him knowing and also to help Fluttershy who is too scared to tell anyone. Maybe add Scootaloo and Sweetie Belle because they want to understand what happened and seek the truth for Apple Bloom who is either paralyzed or dead. Maybe Sweetie Belle is also helping because Rarity asked her because she loves AJ and it kills her to see the pony she loves found guilty for a crime that wasn't entirely her fault. They could square down with the Mane Six and expose Twilight's lies But that's me just rambling

[@lvl13plaguedr]

AppleJack was my favourite already, but when i see her like this, i don't know why but i love her more, even if she's a crazy murderer(or an assassin for hire if you've watched Friendship is Tragic), i swear why do i love the characters more when they're etheir murderers or just downright crazy? TTvTT

[@vixymix101]

Finally AJ has a good popular grimfic! That completes the collection!

[@scottneshine2547]

Amazing job on this song. You had me going to loving this song a lot. You did a wonderful job. Keep up the great work and Happy Nightmare Night, Lost Narrator.

[@IZabellaArtZ]

I probaly have been here already. And it’s nooo surprise apple jack and her dark tales are my favorite. But this song terrifies me.. you do so damn damn well.. that I just love this to bits..

[@allisonthefox9900]

AJ: I wont stop till hes dead! Lyra's death: well actually-

[@TheBlueJay69]

I saw the fic when it first came out on the channel. A couple years later, after I thought the fandom long gone following the end of MLP, you release this absolutely amazing piece to go with the already phenomenal thriller you made all that time ago. Lost, the fandom may be dwindling, the show may be over, but you’re still one of the best I’ve come across. Your readings and your own works were some of the highlights of my time as a brony.

[@joshleonard8364]

Damn. The story, this song, and your reading. It all is just amazing. It makes me want to practice voice acting and music again. I even started reading fanfics again because of it. Beautiful work!

[@karladenisetorda5785]

Just saw this randomly in recommended, I ended up watching a 1hr vid-- This and the story is really good ngl--

[@Zeruel3]

Now I'm more scared of AJ than I ever was of Pinkie or RD in their iconic creepypastas, that fact you do such a good AJ makes it that much scarier

[@danielsurvivor1372]

One of the best MLP songs fandom produced. Wish there were more grimdark songs as good as this one

[@LightningSpiritVA]

Dame that sounds AWESOME!!!!!! :D Amazing job lost nailed the screaming and Ariana amazing singing voice

[@MusingSprite3045]

This is a banger. Adding it to my weekly list.

[@sifanyart359]

Wow! How I love this song with the Grimdark This is a Masterpiece, Amazing Job! 💖💖💖💖

[@sippingtealads]

" AJ: " How yah like my spooky~ song kiddo? Uhh bloomy? Hellooooo.. " AppleBloom: " sister if you ever sing that song again.. *I M T A K I N G T H E A P P L E S I D E R* " AJ: " GAH NOT MY PRECIOUS BABYS "

[@sueemeralda1290]

In this au applebloom is.. dead

[@monsterrbae]

she really let the intrusive thoughts get to her

[@DubbiKnight]

Wow, chills... I love this! Apple sleep experiment is definitely one of my favorite grimdark stories!

[@g-max1808]

Can’t wait for part 4 of the sequel

[@X6800]

Story was in 2017. Song was made in 2020. First time hearing either. Yay!

[@kitkataki1]

I keep going back to this song

[@nicholasnguyen5181]

Same

[@MidnightTheGothArtist]

I was actually listening to the narrative yesterday XD Loved the song!!❤️☠️🍎🔪

[@wendigostudiosLNandMlp66]

That voice almost sounds like the real Applejack o_0

[@nicholasnguyen5181]

That’s what I was thinking

[@katelynthewhitewerewolf6376]

​@@nicholasnguyen5181 Yeah I was too it sounds just like her.

[@nicholasnguyen5181]

@@katelynthewhitewerewolf6376 right?

[@katelynthewhitewerewolf6376]

​@@nicholasnguyen5181 Yeah it does.

[@nicholasnguyen5181]

@@katelynthewhitewerewolf6376 okay

[@rien6841]

you aren’t you when you’re hungry. here applejack, have a snicker!

[@weigangwan9357]

Isn’t this copied? the top comment was 3 years ago, this is 2 years ago.

[@sunnyskies3969]

When I heard melencholy nights. I wondered, then I heard AJ. Honestly a pleasant surprise!

[@nicolaaudyova9362]

Awesome as usual. Thank you every one who did this beutiful song.

[@LeandroBrony]

Wow, This Song Is so Epic and the Animation on this Video Was really Insane and Awesome.

[@kitfitsugaming9417]

Achievement: Get one of Lost's good songs stuck in your head for almost a week

[@racapinang]

Yep, I just found this music like 2 days ago and already listening to this like...... Idk

[@mckenzieknowlton995]

I love this song it matches so well with the story and what goes on in her head through out the story that’s art people

[@queenkaterose]

This is one is chilling song edit: if Another Apple Sleep Experiment doesn't get a song like this, I will be very surprised

[@samuelkirkwood6702]

Woah, now I've definitely got to make time to actually read this fic. This song was unbelievable!

[@theshinyguru951]

After i heard this song it inspired me to read the story for the very first time. It was well worth it

[@MillerW143]

This song brings me so much joy even after years. My gosh I love this- omg I need this on Spotify on repeat I love this the voice and everything is amazing!!

[@breadstick4386]

Wow this just popped up, and its really good!

[@rorokun_1666]

The VA can act really well and sing really well?? Amazing!!

[@arnoldmws6330]

This is still one of my most favorites that you have done. Terrifying and heartbreaking.

[@nicholasnguyen5181]

Nice, amazing, depressing, and creepy. I love it lost. This is amazing. You’re the best singer; ever! Edit: I just got back from listening to your sleep experiment story. So this is definitely a great song whilst listening to the story. My mind.. is blown.

[@huntertyre1037]

Apparently when AJ turns mad, her vocabulary expands.