Are ARMA 3 Tanks Realistic?

[@RedEffectChannel]

JOIN Brothers in Arms: kzbin.info/door/K4DL_v1goCxV5kyIIjn1Cg

[@temiola3458]

Which is better in t14 armata and the kf 51 panther?

[@nemiw4429]

@@temiola3458 how on earth can anybody know when they are both very new, the kf51 basiclyma few hours old.

[@rowdy8814]

Do NOT join brothers in arms

[@nemiw4429]

@@rowdy8814 why

[@Adam-kk7nw]

I just wish arma increase the graphic for arma 4 when it come out

[@RedEffectChannel]

The KF51 is coming soon, just waiting for something, but it should be up really soon so stay tuned.

[@georgekordalis5465]

Cool, cant wait!

[@Creppystories123]

Ahh finally

[@radonsider9692]

Also RE, you were right about Altay having hope, the tests with Korean powerpacks were successful and now they are trying to buy around 150-250 powerpacks

[@radonsider9692]

And also, you have said that we don't know if there are new APFSDS' developed for Altay (not specifically Altay, these can be used in all 120mm L/55, as MKEK L/55 is a licensed version of the CN08, but Leopard 2(TR1/TIYK)s and M60TMs can use these too), I digged some and found that there is Mod290 APFSDS, Mod300 HE-T, Mod292 Thermobaric, Mod310 HEAT-MP-T and Mod291 TPCSDS-T by MKEK. Mod290 APFSDS has 689mms of penetration at 1 kilometer to a RHA block (states NATO RHA 70°) angled at 70°.

[@davidpekarek6622]

is there any info about specs of KF51 ? or it will be theoretical?

[@darachoco6012]

Small trick : The most explosive thing (when it comes to destroying buildings) are vehicles. Put a vehicle next to the building, make it go boom, and say bye to the building. Includes the one seen at the end I believe.

[@claverse5478]

rolls back to that one moment in Soviet womble's Arma vid

[@vaclavjebavy5118]

Nah, the trick is to aim for the roof. I have no idea why, but buildings are indestructible unless you aim for the roof.

[@philmybutup4759]

@@vaclavjebavy5118 makes sense bc in the game I think the buildings can only be destroyed from top down. It doesn’t have to capability to have a building be destroyed from the bottom

[@vaclavjebavy5118]

@@philmybutup4759 Yeah, but it's not that unbelievable that a building might partially collapse from a sideways rocket shot.

[@philmybutup4759]

@@vaclavjebavy5118 oh yeah I agree. I meant that the game doesn’t have the capability to render that stuff

[@PineCone227_]

Correction on the APS: The smoke is not fired automatically, it has to be launched by the tank commander, and, the missile launch warning is only given once the missile is in flight, so it's detecting the projectile, not the launcher lock.

[@ahrec2786]

Yeah, the "automatic" smoke dispensers are basically AI's reacting to an incoming missile and deploying smokes, it is not automatically deployed.

[@OksmanTV]

The APS mod definitely does automatic firing of commander smokes by default as far as I'm aware but by default it's just AI who always pop smoke

[@PrivateMemo]

We gotta keep in mind that this game came out in 2013, really. I am expecting the next Arma to vastly improve upon all of this.

[@F-18Super]

Well I mean……war thunder

[@PrivateMemo]

@@F-18Super Are you telling me that you think War Thunder is better in that regard? Don't get me started..

[@dandas8726]

@@F-18Super War Thunder is a totally different type of game. War Thunder is some kind of quick-dopamine-release-pvp-grind-game that just happens to use tanks for its combat. 99% of tank combat in war thunder is nothing like arma nor reality.

[@F-18Super]

@@PrivateMemo in tank realism yes as arma doesn’t go in detail of modules, stats like M829A1 591mm of penetration at 0° from 500m with a speed over whatever m/s

[@F-18Super]

@@dandas8726 yes but war thunder does tank combat better and sometimes even more realistically which is what separates it from its arcade counterparts like WOT

[@starblazer6907]

You should try out the ACE mod for Arma 3, it has interesting advanced damage simulation for vehicles including ammo cook off. It also makes the Javelin and NLAW more true to real life adding the actual guidance systems and top attack modes for both. There's also an APS mod that just came out that has actual hard kill and soft kill systems modeled in it.

[@supbro_the_crazy2681]

I had a bmd keep cooking off in ace for about 8 times while I was trying to repair it and it never blew up, it was the dumbest thing ever

[@starblazer6907]

@@supbro_the_crazy2681 Yeah the cook off scripting in ace seems buggy and exaggerated. I wanted to see Reds opinion on it tbh. I wish it was more like GHPC, they could take some serious notes from those guys.

[@kreut5299]

Top down attack mode also exists in vanilla for the Titan and NLAW since the tanks DLC

[@supbro_the_crazy2681]

@@starblazer6907 I remembered being scared to shit everytimeit cook off and tried to repair it after like 5 seconds of it burning and now blowing up, after the 6th time I just ignored it and repaired everything on it and it still kept ammo racking lol

[@Myuutsuu85]

Wait, by the time you wrote this, Arma 3's Javelin equivalent, the Titan already had a top attack mode. -Same goes for the PCML, the NLAW's succsessor.- Correction: the PCML uses an Overfly top-attack mode, which means the projectile detonates above the target, it doesn't descends on it. Or are you talking about mods like RHS?

[@GiorgioChiellini723]

Hey can you review the realism of tanks in il-2 Sturmovik: Clash at Prokhorovka? I know it's quite pricey, but I believe it's arguably the most realistic WW2 game on the market atm. Has modelled interiors, multi-crew (friends can be your driver, gunner, etc), realistic animations, ballistics, and more!

[@RedEffectChannel]

Yes, this game is on my list, in fact, I have already recorded some footage for it.

[@GiorgioChiellini723]

@@RedEffectChannel Great! Looking forward to it.

[@liammiddleton3064]

@@RedEffectChannel are u gonna do it?

[@sapperbean5791]

Are Arma Tanks real? > Truck bumps to Tank gently > Tank goes flying across the map, explodes on impact when it hits the mountains.. Nah bro, totally realistic.

[@ThatSlowTypingGuy]

Someone shouting BONK! shouldn't be able to scare away an entire tank battalion, I'm with you on that.

[@oghuzkhan6136]

All games has glitches. I think its not fair to judge this game because of one glitch which doesnt happen everytime. Overall its pretty good at giving a realizm feel at vehicles

[@Slayer119988]

The tanks in war thunder can hover and even fly sometimes if you simply drive forward off a hill and are bestowed with the Holy Blessing of the Glitch. Gaijin only gives this great honor to those who would rather not fly suddenly.

[@Myuutsuu85]

@@oghuzkhan6136 the only time I ever encountered glitches like this where in other youtube videos that used an extensive number of mods. I trust if others say it happens in the base game, too. But I never have encountered this issue in my.. *checking* 1498 hours of playing that game.

[@oghuzkhan6136]

@@Myuutsuu85 Thats what im talking about. Its unfair to judge a game because of a glitch which happens rarely

[@MarcinP2]

I heard a comment from tanker that they would tweak the brightness and contrast until it the vehicles were visible and pretty much nothing else so that way they could traverse the sight fast and scan quickly for things that stand out.

[@RedVRCC]

You should review the RHS mod tanks, they have a lot of cool real life tanks with realistic FCS controls for most of them. I'd say they are more detailed and functional than the base game ones.

[@LynxErgo]

Its still miles away from overall realistic state

[@GK-xg6yc]

A video on SQUAD's vehicles would be cool!

[@midknight0693]

Yeah it does some things better than arma

[@ArielK-a]

GHPC review when? : P

[@pavelcerny9803]

5:55 not true, you can destroy this warehouse too. Source: more than 3k hours played.

[@PineCone227_]

It *is* incredibly resilient, however. But there are for sure destroyed models of it. Source: Over 2.4k hours

[@LeonTReal]

Yeah, he did oversee a small feature. The HEAT-T he used on it simply penetrated both metal walls, therefore didn't explode next to the warehouse and caused no damage whatsoever. It would've been a different story if he shot HE right next to the building

[@Meuduso1]

An improvement to the armor experience is what I am hoping for the most. As an IRL tanker it's so sad that there's exactly one game that gets the tanker experience kind of right and that's GHPC. Even "realistic" games like War Thunder and especially Arma 3 get things wrong, and it starts with the basics of being inside a tank: You don't hear shit, you don't see shit unless you're looking outside using the hatch, everything shakes and you've got a team of 4 people in there trying to make the best out of it and most importantly, the sights you have, those are the ones you're stuck with. If they are damaged, that's one less eye. You can't zoom with every single optic either and you won't believe how fucked actual first and even some second generation thermals are. There's so many things you can't even be mad at a developer for not including but which are kind of important to the "experience", be it maintenance on weapons like changing barrels mid fire fight, all the safety precautions (to be fair some of them get quickly thrown out once combat starts anyway), the technical problems that can come up you'd have to work around, on that note the levels of redundancy present in MBTs etc. etc. And one big thing regarding the environments: DUST! Holy shit you wouldn't believe how easily and how much dust is kicked up just by a tank driving through a rubble filled city or country roads or whatever and don't get me started on the dust that's kicked up when firing the main gun in a dusty area. I could see this being a technical limitation as well as a gameplay one because whenever some games actually do have a lot of dust, players will usually get butthurt over it VERY quickly. The Tank DLC did help with some of these issues, like the interiors but they are basically just eye candy. WIth Reforger so far I think that the vehicle experience could very greatly be improved upon, the potential is there. The vehicles just really, really benefit of things like full interiors and proper damage models.

[@wote2760]

Man, if you did if Warthunder tanks were realistic, you might start ww3

[@PrivateMemo]

He already has

[@yajamanvamsikrishna509]

True though

[@andybreadley429]

We already have Spookston for this.

[@Maza945]

I remember that in some mod in ArmA 2 or ArmA 1 there was a working Shtora APS and it was intercepting ATGM's.

[@adityaparam8736]

I know there's an APS mod for Arma 3. Drongo's APS or something like that.

[@theglitchedmissile9239]

@@adityaparam8736 yes that

[@flabby2142]

Can you do a Vid on effeteness of T-34 85 in Yugoslav conflicts tnx

[@star2buk]

Really would love to see you do a review of ACE3. It's a standard mod for milsim Arma and adds a more complex damage model, as well as ammo cook-off

[@dariozanze4929]

Even with some elements not being realistic ArmA 3 is still the most realistic "tank" game on the market. Because it's not just a tank game. Most of the tanks games are pretty much tank vs tank, and capture the point or some shit which is not realistic at all. In ArmA there is a mission editor in which one can create a realistic mission with realistic objective, and there are tanks, infantry, planes, helicopters, jeeps, trucks, AFV's, UAV's... Controlling a single tank with 2 friends on discord, or 12 players controlling the platoon of tanks in a realistic scenario which involves all kids of units on friendly and enemy side is waaaaay better experience then WoT or Warthunder.

[@TheRaptorSh00T]

I used to be in the FantastiqueWar Arma team and fought against your team during the ESM 2021. It was really cool to fight against you guys.

[@holern904]

The game Squad does armor gameplay really well

[@matsv201]

4:00 i don´t know if this is true for all tanks. but for Leopard type tanks the drop of and lead is "solved" by changing the position of the radical in the sight. So its actually the gunner that leads, unkowing of doing so (well, of cause, if you have a computer lock, the computer will lead)

[@GoRideLP]

3:17 something red orchestra 2 would shamelessly steal 7 years prior

[@gavinwallander4693]

One thing I've learned from arma, another vehicle is the the perfect anti vehicle weapon. If I take a hunter and crash it into a tank going 100 kmh 8/10 times that tank will be sent 50 feet into the air at mach 2

[@olejnik5165]

I used to hate it when in Arma 3 a T-55 could destroy a Leopard 2 or any other tank basically but hey its just arma and mods I guess, spent so much time in this game and almost never used vehicles in editor which I usually used

[@pilopet1150]

T-55 can destroy any modern take if it shoots enough at its most vulnerable part. It would take many many shots but it would work

[@josephahner3031]

It can though. A T-55 can destroy a Leopard 2. It would have to get obscenely lucky, but it technically can. Hence why Romania hasn't replaced their TR-85s yet, it can still get the job done.

[@comeinhendy8931]

2:54 I beg to differ here. Arma is set in 2035 so it's near futuristic gear and vehicles. In the present days you already have systems that can warn you about incoming ordinance such as a missile. For example APS systems or C-RAM. The A-10 if I am not wrong has a system that detects when missiles are being launched called MWS ( it's a set of UV sensors that can detect missile exahausts but doesn't discriminate between friend or foe ). So it's not too unrealistic to have an automatic smoke dispenser that activates once it detects a missile launch. So yeah, passive locks, such as IR, should not give any hint to the target but there are ways to detect a launch and some systems even have their on firing control radar to lock on the incoming missile and destroy it. The Isreali trophy APS is a good example.

[@BoleDaPole]

"In this wideo" This is why I like this show

[@knucklesandwichdude133]

The Arma 3 T-72 can Lollipop (Ammo lock, Turret pop off, 50 meter ceiling, etc…) but when you look at the bottom of the T-72 turret it’s flat. It’s disappointing. Not even RHS could change that. I Really want a turret with a modeled interior like the ammo at the bottom if the hull under the turret and the bottom of the turret being hollow with a modeled gun and seats and optics and such.

[@RLXxEpic]

i would like to see you do this video with squad

[@makarovj6871]

Also, one thing missing from actually every single game is that the barrel doesn't get stuck in objects around you. Which changes everything actually. You don't feel the effect of having such a long barrel

[@HyperactiveMelon]

Now please do Squad

[@vimana6226]

Hello. Tank singleplayer. How do you set how many meters the cannon's range should be ? The T button measures the distance ? But where, how set distance for cannon ? What button should I use to set the distance if the meter showed 1000 meters ?

[@hadesdogs4366]

Agreed and especially for planes where if you’re hit you can’t bail out

[@johnsmith2591]

Based RedEffect coming out with Arma 3 content just when I'm considering getting CONTACT and APEX on sale, puno hvala.

[@PineCone227_]

Get them. Apex is the best content DLC and Contact is the best story DLC. They're worth it on sale (Bohemia's products are a tad overpriced without a sale on, but discounts are very common)

[@johnsmith2591]

@@PineCone227_ Ended up getting them, so far so good.

[@akipovakipov8240]

A IFV survived 10 of my sabot so very realistic

[@thelordofcringe]

You can destroy that one at the end, but you need to bomb it with a plane or set off like 8 satchel charges.

[@hubbel6831]

the best counter to everything in arma is ramming a quad into thing

[@makarovj6871]

3:12 No you can't detect incoming missiles but if you see it coming, which should happen if you are a good tanker as everything plays through observation. However the only thing you can do is pop smoke's as it will create a heat signature since it is made of phosphorus

[@HoroTheWiseOkami]

you should try GHPC :)

[@Puzzoozoo]

As BI are now working on Arma 4 it will hopefully be out in 2025 - 2026, and as they are using a brand new engine, object destruction might be a feature of the Milsim.

[@mostdefinitelynotadurian]

idk, me in a tank getting rammed by a humvee and being sent to the stratosphere seems realistic to me

[@Haulvarn]

Hey man, really liked the video :D Just some quick points: -You generally have very limited indication on wether you hit a tank or not in rl aswell, unless the ammo ignites (besides a bright flash, and of course depending on the ammo used). -Agreed, the tank crew wouldn't be alerted if a heat seeking missile were to lock onto them. However Hardkill systems might still be able to destroy them if they actively scan for incomming objects -As for the thermal sights, you're both right and a tiny bit wrong... what we're seeing in the clip represents basically two different generations of thermal sights. The green one being the older generation. And I can tell you, that they often look far worse than in the game. xD

[@hadesdogs4366]

Honestly the internal models are far better than the old ones where it was just a camera or just a drivers slit vs a decked out interior with much wider fields of vision

[@viceralman8450]

Red can you analice the Peruvian modernization of the T-55 the Typhon.

[@hassansal3129]

Great video man, Subscribed

[@Maks-Yarysh]

Dear author, pls make also about the squad!

[@Morororoca]

Warthunder is insane on that point

[@Valkyrie_Yukikaze]

There are also working APS mods and damage model mod for some vehicles.

[@Saffi____]

I mean it is Arma, I have seen once a shotgun shell that literally can destroy an entire building with only a few shots.

[@hadesdogs4366]

Personally for me the problem is that whilst having damage modules are nice and all i do wish that we could get actual armor or ricottas rather than a module just taking damage

[@aregularperson7573]

As someone who has over 10 thousand hours in Arma 3 I can say Arma 3 is not a realistic game mainly because of all of the bugs but that is part of the fun

[@importantname]

i find computer games to be fun or not or a little bit fun, but never have i found a computer game anything like reality. Which is why i play computer games.

[@mattin5850]

Actually as far as I am aware there are system that CAN detect all types of missiles approaching the vehicle, it is very limited range, but some aircraft and helicopters use, for example AN/AAR-56 ( on F-22 raptor) So it would be acceptable to think that in 2035 tanks could equip similar systems to detect incoming projectiles and looking at the range in arma 3 ( 3km or so) I personally believe that it is possible such a system could get developed in armaverse

[@yume5338]

Really have my fingers crossed we can get some more realistic tank ballistics with Arma Reforger, like War Thunder and GHPC. Was always annoyed at the HP system in Arma tanks, I guess it's the reason I never get the chance to use them in public servers, because nobody wants to use them.

[@LeonTReal]

Great video. Though some information might not be correct as seen in the comments, I would love to see another video - but with the ACE3 extension. It adds a lot more depth to vehicles and their damage behavior in general :)

[@ThePatriarchXCI91]

This is a video I have been waiting for

[@chalkchalkson5639]

Maybe Combat Mission, especially Shock Force 2 and Black Sea could be interesting. Being tactics games balanced by a point system rather than FPSs they have a lot more freedom to model certain things that would otherwise be unfun. On the other hand the game is fairly abstracted with concepts like spotting being a little bit opaque leading to situations where it feels like every russian and syrian tanker goes to battle with a blindfold on. That could be very neat to evaluate!

[@MarcinP2]

Combat Mission in my experience and based on community testing is a game where the mission designer decides which tank is better by varying the crew skills. The properties of the tank are secondary it seems.

[@jsgaming3248]

can you please make a video of AMX Leclerc's problems and review/ tank realism for armored warfare.

[@user-gi4wg9ib8i]

Are you planning to do this for any other games? It'd be interesting to hear your takes on some sci-fi vehicles,sort of like Spookston did.

[@eslSlightz]

I hope Arma 4 has better vehicle physics 🥹

[@SkywalkerWroc]

Yep. And a damage model that gets at least remotely close to what War Thunder has instead of this BS in the Arma 3.

[@LA.20]

Well it is "realistic". *Proceeds to ram a tank with a bicycle to send it to space*

[@jryde421]

Arma reforger is to refine the franchise

[@slamsgt6642]

can you do a realism check for il 2 sturmovik battle of stalingrad tanks. Also do you play that game because i have once seen a guy with your username playing it

[@Snortolodmyr-SS-Cokelensky]

I believe the RHS t-14 has APS hard kill effects

[@dominiksieberer3925]

There are far more health pools in arma than the 6 shown in the ui to the player. Eg every periscope and optic has its own health and amor value. Also all buildings have to have a destruction model. On some buildings it's just very difficult to completly destroy them. The white barn you showed can be easily destroyed with a couple of hydra rockets though. I'm not trying to say arma 3 is perfect, but it's better than you have shown. And you forgot the worst part of arma... The hit registration and collision calculation in multiplayer with a couple of clients playing

[@rayotoxi1509]

do a video On GHPC (GunnerHEATPC)

[@DonMapel113]

maka about Squad/Project Realisty

[@RT-mm8rq]

Looks better than World of Tanks. ( console). With stupid tanks like the GI Joe Armadillo added it became more "Mario Cart" with tracks than a tank game.

[@stevehildebert8954]

Could you do a breakdown on the armored vehicles from Halo?

[@hiruharii]

Maybe you haven’t played in tanks enough smoke is a commander thing lmao

[@fjshdf]

so is it realistic when they flip and bounce 300 feet in the air

[@luggilu7864]

Please do squad next. The tanks in that game make me angry

[@flyingchair8103]

How about squad?

[@sam8742]

Maybe not all that realistic but screaming "Re-engage" as my gunner barely misses the enemy tank immerse me a lot

[@subjectc7505]

I was able to slaughter a convoy of Abrams from a long distance in a default tank and I have mods that makes ground combat a bit more realistic. So I'll say yes, tanks are somewhat realistic if you know where to aim.

[@rickspencer6343]

Arma 3 is my favorite game of all time. But, the least realistic part of Arma 3 is vehicles and most specifically, armor vehicles. In real life tanks don't drive around like go carts. There are other reasons for my opinion, but I'll leave it at that.

[@thusharikabotheju5655]

Please try out steel beasts

[@100Kakdela]

Do Post-Scriptum next please.

[@spacewargamer4181]

1:47 That makes super annoying to play as an AT infrantry, and actually I think that the worst part of the game for me. I think that even the in old ACWA(OFP) I could tell how a tank was damaged just by looking to it, but here not. AT also have super tinny explosions in Arma 3, a grenade have a more powerfull one, I guess that if it prenetates maybe makes sense because it explodes inside the tank, but only if it does and that would be last one needed. It however does that always.

[@StefanBlagojevic]

Not to mention Physics in ArmA when it comes to vehicles...

[@federicoetcheverry7963]

Squad?

[@TorbisINACTIVE]

You tried SQUAD tanks?

[@ShopeeMarketteam]

Here's a TDLR: Are ARMA 3 tanks realistic? Fuck no

[@irishkiwi477]

Could you do squad?

[@user-7635h]

Good day Please take a look at GHPC and revive this series of videos you make

[@odlader3]

can you mad a video about Squa?

[@Wyk_]

no, they absolutely are not realistic, some players just ram into tanks using common cars and the tank is just EJECTED from the ground

[@T0ghar]

Still no KF-51 video?

[@nsort3009]

Well no, it protrays Russia as having successfully upgraded its equipment from the Soviet era

[@WarBomb117]

once i was going like 70Km/h with T 100 down hill in koth server hit a bush got yeeted cross the AO was a funny moment for everyone who saw it just arma things XD love this game

[@arslankhan2134]

wheres the correction you told me you were going to make on Al Khalid? We talked about it in PM over a year ago and yet nothing so far...

[@STRYKER1467]

You should have reviewed RHS instead.

[@martinwalker8569]

Arma is from my country is it good ? I olny downloaded (ilegal) beta version Arma 3 and full Arma 2 for friend

[@kajschak]

Have you tried the vehicles of the RHS mod, which have a way more advanced damage model compared to vanilla arma

[@kajschak]

Because RHS comes with ERA, ammo racks, bullets/apfsds not being able to penetrate strong armor or 7.62 ap being able to take out the crew of a brdm. Likewise 50cal are find to take out BMD4s.

[@rowdy8814]

>join BiA Oh my lord do NOT. Did that rich greek really pay you to shill that awful community.

[@menacereconnaissance7406]

New Video yay

[@rogue__agent5884]

We need arma 4

[@mortarboss]

While an interesting video about a game many play, in the middle of a war I was hoping for videos about real tanks. You have a lot of knowledge that you can share about real tanks in a real war. You've made some videos, but I feel that there are lots of topics not covered. Every day brings new armoured vehicles to this war, so there's plenty of potential topics. For my part games are put aside until the war is over.

[@tasman006]

I'm an older fan of Arma2 I really liked that game. Arma3 was okay but after a while I got bored of it. Overall not a bad game.

[@harambe999]

Buddy, 3:00 minute mark.. completely wrong, oh boy you will be surprised by some of the technology tanks got. And thats all i have to say