Are Man City Broken?

[@FalseNi9e]

Want to add that I don't believe Rico is a defender. I think he is a midfielder....keep up the tactical videos mate they are informative and I love talking tactics

[@Nobbins]

Thanks mate! Yeah he’s a midfielder isn’t he 100%, right now we’re not platformed to use him correctly

[@daniel67797]

a midfielder who can't defend or attack.. tell me the point of such a player lmfao

[@mealo]

@@daniel67797 r u dumb

[@grzegorzbrzeczyszczykiewic5083]

Your analysis videos are probably my favourite football-related content on youtube, keep it up

[@Nobbins]

Thank you mate

[@pareshchatterjee1541]

nice analysis.even last season i wasn't confident how we were performing and this season without rodri it was expected.

[@Nobbins]

Yeah it’s the same but worse basically haha

[@KobElia824]

I love your detailed and meticulous analysis on the various aspects of our team... in my opinion... you are underrated as a content creator... you are very good... clear, exhaustive and at the same time concise... at explaining the various concepts... you deserve a lot more subscribers buddy🩵💙💪👊... I love you LNobbins🩵💙... Never change mate... be yourself anytime, anywhere!

[@shedikahassan6242]

Congrats on the Sponsor. Keep up the good work. Yes,we want a video on signings for January

[@Nobbins]

Gotcha!

[@jacekmarczuk7718]

City needs to do everything to sign a midfielder in January. Because if they won't do it, it might be over ever to finish top4. Sorry, too many problems right now, but we have to try to solve them like returning players from injuries and signing a midfielder.

[@Nobbins]

Yep agreed, we need it

[@jacekmarczuk7718]

@@Nobbins For me ideally we need 2 - DM and forward. Not fuckin prospects from South America. We need ready players.

[@jacekmarczuk7718]

@@Nobbins and Nunes is not a solution to any of City's problems. He is simply not good enough and doesn't fit at all. He has to leave.

[@Faren_]

Watched that Sociedad vs Barcelona game yesterday. Zubimendi is legit.

[@fplraze4358]

He won’t Leave san Sebastian. Liverpool and Arsenal have both tried earlier with no sucsess.

[@a.price587]

we’ve always been at threat of being in this position since the treble season as good as we were i think a lot of us knew we were 1 rodri injury away from the team collapsing, we’ve been lucky that his injury record has been very clean so far. The fact we lost fernandinho and signed phillips was a major mistake and hopefully the board have recognised that and we sign someone genuinely city quality in january

[@goodman4093]

Gvardiol rather than nunnes. Grealish is also good in the middle

[@douglaswright2143]

Excellent as usual. I was delighted to hear the phrase "trade offs", which is a more accurate description of tactical adjustments than the overused and misleading phrase "solutions". Pep has always been tinkering or adjusting to use a more neutral word, but this seems the only time that he has approached something akin to a kind of dogmatism. I hope I am wrong, but there are maybe signs of an end to an era.

[@knotJammy]

U r analysis are always top notch mate ......would love to see more like this

[@Nobbins]

Thank you! They just take ages to write, film and edit (I’m a one man band haha)

[@zerishhailemariam1339]

This is not just an opinion, this is an excellent insight!

[@manlikeal-oj6qs]

amazing video👍👊 A january transfer window video would be amazing as it it is detrimental we get signings in

[@Nobbins]

Thank you!

[@willyc.8141]

I've always said it, Nunes has always been a central midfielder, we need him to help Kovacic. But the Gvardiol move surprised me, that could be a very good fix. Perfect video mate, I really enjoyed it💙

[@Nobbins]

Thank you mate! Means a lot

[@j_0278]

We need at least one ball winning midfielder in January. No balance in the midfield at the moment. If we can get that resolved, everything else will fall into place.

[@Nobbins]

Here’s hoping 🙏 who might you like to see signed?

[@AD-gu6sr]

​@@NobbinsRicci for his physicality and distribution.

[@GregoryJamesHulse]

Super cathartic video, keep up the great work! 💙

[@Nobbins]

Thank you matey!

[@Steven-nb5cr]

Yes plz make a video on potential winter signings ! Keep up the good work !

[@ThisIsCity]

Brilliant brilliant analysis 👍spot on

[@hondaacord6167]

I would say that our problems offensively are almost as bad as defensively. if the centre backs block out haaland which is not that hard with his current form, city have no real threat on goal. Sure you have savinho and doku but 9 times out of 10 they will dribble past full backs and cut the ball back, not shoot on goal. I honestly hate watching us pass the ball around the oppositions 16 yard box and hoping something happens.

[@FalseNi9e]

Eh mate, we are not finished. I think the injuries are a factor as well as we are tired. Now I'm throwing this out there. I think Pep is done after this season and the club knows this and it's being reflected on the pitch. I have nothing to back this up, but it has happened before with clubs

[@Nobbins]

We shall see!

[@Imperator_27]

Nice analysis!

[@Nobbins]

Thank you!

[@Fals3-Wing3r]

Good video mate.

[@Nobbins]

😃

[@anubhavkonwar8395]

That’s some next level analysis mate, good job keep it up love from 🇮🇳🩵

[@Nobbins]

Thank you!

[@valentineabade9870]

We really messed up letting amorim leave for United

[@rafaeltorres7147]

Rico is too small to play an advanced position in the midfield and too slow to play RB.

[@Nobbins]

I think he’s an 8 but the squad isn’t set up for him to start right now sadly

[@loukanjima-bechard7180]

He isn't much smaller than Messi who is the best player ever, unless you're and actual midget you cant be "too small" to play and attacking position.

[@Darth_Bennett]

Say that to lahm mate only difference is lahm was 10 years more experienced. You saying Lewis is slow because of FIFA? He sees something in Lewis and compares him to Lahm and what pep did to Lahm. If you don't loose the ball then you don't need to charge up and down he's a false fullback Cancelo Zinchenko did these Alaba Lahm brilliant for the role. Lewis is quality 😊😊

[@Bigboat-v9q]

You don't know ball mate, Rico is class and has been one of our "best" players this season right behind gvardiol and Erling

[@debasishmaity7173]

Great video as always ❤❤

[@anhtruong585]

Really really good video. Pep need to watch this video and let Nunes play centrally

[@bradchad6345]

great video bro please keep it up we are depending on you for good analysis like this 💯

[@Nobbins]

Thanks matey! Would like to do these more often but they take days to research write and edit!

[@roytonboy7245]

Excellent analysis, as always.

[@Nobbins]

😃

[@tavongalennox3994]

I remember in the watch along vs Tottenham Hotspur in the Carabao Cup. Many people were saying they didn't care about the result and that we'd played our B Team but the cracks were becoming more and more apparant. Arsenal showed us that we dont really have a creative treat and its becoming more of a norm that we will keep passing the ball left to right and right to left. Turn overs of possession are finishing us and having us butchered in the transition. We really need to shake things up in January otherwise we really should forget about another title with the way we are playing

[@Bigboat-v9q]

City fan? Subbed! 💙

[@mahdisoleymani660]

Great job!

[@Nobbins]

🩵

[@cfclogan74]

Well outlined. I believe the 3-2 is the better solution (something I have wanted for a while now)…more base solidity. Pep was stubborn in the past and eventually adapted, hopefully he reflects and realizes it’s time to adjust while we are in contention.

[@vector_vector__]

Definitely would like to see u do ideal Transfer targets to solve all these gaps 😇😘💙 Cmon MCFC ✊👊

[@Nobbins]

Shall do!

[@vector_vector__]

​@@Nobbins ⏲ ⏲⏲⏳⏳⏳ 🕐 🕙 🕦...

[@JerifKhan-pz5ie]

You are the best City fan channel. Cuz you talk with brain and tactics..... something I prefer ❤ from 🇮🇳

[@Nobbins]

Thank you!

[@YOUFRKEN]

analysis on point✅

[@AK-pw3oq]

Best channel for tactical analysis

[@KS_511]

Was waiting for your video mate . And I do think playing Gvardiol in the stones role could be the temporary solution as he has the physicality and is good on the ball while playing akanji Dias and ake as centre halves . But still I think the creativity in this team is lacking .

[@Nobbins]

I don’t think creativity is the issue tbh, we create plenty but conversion is poor. Hoping the gets sorted with our returning offensive players Defensive concerns however… no returning player helps us there ☹️

[@Darth_Bennett]

Ake. Diaz Gvardiol Stones Kovaci. Lewis De Bruyne Bernando. Foden Haaland.

[@jaber765]

Nice One Nobbins As Always

[@KobElia824]

We absolutely need to get to January and maintain... or rather shorten this distance from Liverpool (first in the league at the moment)... let's hope for good news... related to injuries... contract renewals... at the moment of difficulty we need to stay together as much as possible... and not disunite... we need a shock from one of the team members... who can get us back on track... and rediscover that right mentality that it belongs to us... for the rest... if there was the possibility... in January... (I absolutely believe in Pep, his staff and our work ethic)... we have to operate on the market... we need reinforcements... our squad is too short to face more competitions... and when we are missing our best players... the ones who should step up... at the moment... they don't take the next step... we need them all our players... have the desire and energy necessary to reverse the negative trend that is being created... above all they must want it!

[@ajaykumarvs8134]

Rodri is the guy who unlock the attack and also who lock the defence

[@its_visheshk23a]

Hey Nobbins, we would like a video specially targeted for the players we need to sign in January and please include the arrival of Claudio Echeverri too. Although, this one was great and required video. Kudos.

[@nishchaychauhan8814]

Whatever maybe the case but it can't be denied that pep has been really really stubborn in making use of the substitutes..and sticking by his favorites I.e. gundo and bernardo

[@cityslacker6221]

I still think we could stack the midfield by playing a Pep style, but true, 352 with Josko and Rico has wingbacks and Phil playing off Erling’s shoulder.

[@alecjohnson5269]

GREAT SHOW NOBBINS 👍

[@Nobbins]

Thank you!

[@tune23kkganyago28]

Trust me guys Pep has a plan to keep us in check he won't make it easy for the other clubs. Watch how we are gonna turn the season around. And in fact we still in the best position on the league table and that's like every other season.

[@Nobbins]

I hope you’re right!

[@jereflechis4014]

Very good analysis This season gonna be long 😂

[@Nobbins]

Thank you! It’s not over until it’s over

[@interrupted_reverie]

honestly , it feels like the injury of bob ruined all pep plans. It felt like he was going to play him in the same position he played julian last season. It would have not fixed our defensive issues but it would have made us much threatful

[@bhayaji4176]

Change the system that suits aging players and sign a proper cdm,a full back and a backup striker

[@Nobbins]

Think 1 signing is the max we’ll get, which must be that midfielder

[@fifty-five6929]

We are broken but it isn't unfixable. No contract extension for Pep get a fresh manager in and start getting rid of washed players and new ones in. I understand that is difficult to take but it is what it is

[@matthewsengendo6302]

Pep has started his Arsene Wenger phase the longer he stays there the more issues it creates in starting a new the next irritation of City will suffer for around 3 years they wont win Titles like the prem or Ucl

[@WarzoneGhost017]

I don’t know why pep didn’t add a player with kova he is in such a stress at that position he desperately need a player who can win balls at midfield he can carry ball but not stop o’rille is a player i really liked him at that position in matches bro doesn’t lose ball easily and has great passes just need experience he is ready pep should consider him and kova together

[@djn1856]

I agree that its not purely down to rodri, more forward players, more direct wingers who will inevitably turn the ball over more compounds the issues. From peps view, imo he will want to stop the turn overs before he looks at changing the way the team play. Dont be surprised he starts to look at more pausa wingers when available to try and stop the turnover

[@LOWKEY-m7b]

Zubimendi is just another Rodri prefer ederson/ricci I feel Pep has gone too much with his tactics cos he sacrificing the defence to suit the offensive play.

[@Nobbins]

Yeah not sure who the right signing is yet

[@heartthrobbb]

Our drop off is scary but it’s about time teams figured us out tactically. But at the same time our weaknesses are too big.

[@Nobbins]

Hopefully we can sort it in Jan

[@ashrafmukhtar]

you r the GOAT.. bigup

[@kevangorton4167]

IMHO City’s problems are simply fatigue, look at the games or lack of breaks since Covid. Players cannot play at the levels City play at without the break between seasons to simply allow the body to naturally recover. I think City’s current problems will spread throughout the top clubs as the season progresses.

[@Nobbins]

Injuries haven’t helped 100%, but we saw similar issues last season

[@kevangorton4167]

​@@Nobbinsagree but what has caused so many injuries, fatigue. Wasn't Rodri saying before his injury that there were to many games especially with the club world cup at the end of the season.

[@Bigboat-v9q]

With the FFP case looming I think city are walking a tight rope with signings, not looking to add +1 charge for the 24/25 season especially seeing as we're battling the PL itself they might choose to play dirty. I dont see us making a signing in January and the aftermath of Rodri blow is devastating. Hopefully KDB gets more gametime and stays injury free so the defense can focus on defence.

[@mulwa_arts]

Top notch analysis

[@wazreacts]

Great analysis as always, lad. The Rodri hole is only as big as it is because we still play Haaland. You mentioned Haaland only once or twice, I think using the term 'of course Haaland starts'; however, I believe the Rodri injury has highlighted the Haaland problem from 24 months ago at the start of the Treble season when we began to struggle and Pep had to adjust. The only reason we were able to paper over the problem of how does Erling fit into a Guardiola team was the power and resolve of Rodri. Without Rodri, that issue rears its ugly head again. Now, I don't know what kind if contractual situation exists in relation to proportion of games Erling starts, but I'd be trialling reverting to the false 9 set up that worked as well as anything prior to signing him. That hole in midfield shrinks if we do this, and Kova, Gubdogan, Nunes, and like you say Gvardiol or Stones could cover this role with slightly less pressure. Of course, playing like that all the time would mean Haaland would be sold. I mean, isn't that inevitable anyway?

[@Nobbins]

Thank you!

[@skybluescaff]

We’re going through a bad spell with injuries and ageing players… and we are STILL 2nd in the Prem. I don’t think anyone realistically expected to do the ‘5’ in a row! A lot of teams would welcome this crisis. Gundo, Bernado, Walker, KDB all past the of peak of their careers, Pep knows this, so he will know we need to make signings in January. C’mon CITY.

[@sharvaniphaneesh]

I have some crazy tactics: 6-4 formation and just hit on the counter Front 4 : gvardiol haaland foden and kev

[@footballhipstertv]

I remember during Covid when City were like 7th in December and went on to win the title comfortably

[@Nobbins]

Indeed. This is nothing like that season unfortunately

[@footballhipstertv]

@Nobbins it isn't, but I see the differences as positives. In my opinion with regular game time players like Matheus Nunes and Savinho will massively improve and start contributing more, a solid double pivot of Kova+Rico/Kova+Gundo to cover for Rodri with a fit KDB behind Haaland will cause teams tons of problems. I think the attack just wasnt good enough with a single CAM(that wasn't de bruyne) City usually played with 3 or 4 players attacking simultaneously because Rodri covered so much defensively

[@wassimakram4143]

The profile city need is ball winning duelist with pace and physicality but that's very high premium and tough to find Guimares from Newcastle was the dream fit but not gonna happen links to Zubimendi have been circling but he's more a traditional Spanish 6 not pacy like we need

[@Nobbins]

Yeah the market is scarce in that respect

[@sayandeb6459]

What do you think of Ederson from Atalanta? Is he a good signing in Jan?

[@Pdmc-vu5gj]

Other managers have figured out peps system. It's so mechanical and intertwined. Break it up and city are a mess.

[@adergas1]

Exellent break down.

[@AD-gu6sr]

Pls do the video on the Jan signings..

[@Ricardolivechannel]

Pep haven’t fully figured out how to play without Rodri and this gonna be a bad season for us

[@jworth150]

did you watch baleba cook our midfield. looks a lot like kante but better onball

[@Nobbins]

Bring him to le Etihad

[@paulinho2118]

Icl the injuries are the only setbacks we have, the system pep is still trying to instil is slightly revealing it’s weaknesses, our defence system lately has been very poor, with the absence of Dias, stones and such, we don’t have defensive prowess, our newcomer Savio seems out of place when playing eve when he tries his best, no doubt he’s talented but players like him need freedom, for players like Doku without a shadow of doubt we need him crazy wether people lie it or not, his pace ad tricky dribbling adds pressure than anyone in the EPL usually making space constantly which all attackers, Haaland savio etc can exploit, I really think much has to change but let pep do pep😅

[@petarpelov5302]

2nd in the league and everyone is talking about how Man City are in crisis. In the 20/21 season on the same Matchday, City were 9th in the league with 4 less points than they have now and 6 points off first place and had 3 less goal difference than now. They had already lost at home to leicester 5-2, lost to tottenham 2-0, and drawn to leeds, west brom, manchester United, Liverpool and Porto. The same year, they went on to win the Premier League by a 12 point margin with the least goals conceded and the most goals scored in the league. They also reached the final of the champions league and won the efl cup. So how about we stop overreacting? The last time that Manchester City were doing better than they are doing right now was 6 years ago. The season when they won a quadruple...

[@jonasemborg177]

They are fine. but ofc, they are going to rebuild after KDb, Rodri,gundogan, bernardo silva, walker stones. Actually i was sure they were already going to do it with the departure of Fernandinho, and leave the Era there. but it is going to be after this season instead. I am sure Guardiola intended to win this season, but if they dont its probably going to make the decision of rebuilding easier for him. Cus i know he loves these guys. Its gonna be exiting to see the rebuild with liverpool Arsenal chelsea finally finding their roots. Maybe he leaves with the era of the players, but that would be tough for the next one.

[@Nobbins]

Big rebuild coming for sure

[@adamstoylibrary4880]

6 times Premier League Champions in last 7 Editions, still 2nd in the EPL table and I suprised how some guys are making their 4 losses the biggest news. Manchester City will comeback soon and will comeback strong.

[@Nobbins]

That’s all lovely but it doesn’t change the fact that City simply don’t have certain key profiles in the squad

[@iggigrinner]

Thanks

[@egavasenoynot_beats]

bro are we ever going to update and play well before the January window because liverpool is already gone

[@ajaykumarvs8134]

Gundogun played CDM role in Barcelona why city is la liga slower 🤔

[@ChineduIgwe-f9s]

Thanks I think that is OK for me

[@KabuyeMichael-q7g]

Through this international break tell us what pep can do bring it, this bad moment trust is going to grow your channel were leaving those pannels who only talk about crisis each minus talking about what must be done ❤❤❤

[@KabuyeMichael-q7g]

Keeps us updating us on positive we are going through this bad moment

[@mrinmoykshattry527]

Gvardiol should fillup for Rodri

[@Nobbins]

Not sure he could do it out of possession tbh

[@PDSREACTION]

Do you think man city's future is doomed if pep leaves? Like how untd couldnt dominate like Sir era?

[@Mavrykk]

We need a Johnny Stone midfield double pivot.

[@Nobbins]

Need Stones to be fit before that haha

[@revantnagar6232]

Frankly speaking its the midfield which is done dead end Bernardo kdb gundo kova all r old and cant run and due to high line they cant run back fast. Kyle walker being our captain has something happened to him which we dont know but his form has horribly dropped In defense we dont have any leaders left like dias thats why we r constantly conceding Foden's form has been horrible for us as he is struggling massively in our team Kev's injury is causing more problems for our team balance Im very shocked from pep that still pep doesnt even trust mcattee to play even a little bit,a new young academy talent can help us to a certain extent Kyle's legs our gone and our defense plays so high line thts why we concede so much

[@notthekid1937]

gvardiol going into midfield to add physicality isn’t a bad idea at all, he could do it. fact is, i don’t believe pep would ever do that 😭

[@Nobbins]

Here’s hoping!

[@abhinabbishoyi4420]

loved it.

[@smanqele]

This tends to be a October - December question every year now 🤣

[@Nobbins]

This is very different as I outline however. Those past seasons City have never had their most important player out for the entirety of a season

[@engespress]

Yes.

[@ibrahimmusa7594]

I would be waiting to see how we Liverpool would be able to be invincible till march i can only hope 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙈😭❤️💓💖

[@leonardobonilla4866]

Yes and no in my opinion. City has a midfield that is all controllers no real play makers especially in that pivot role. No one to play that ball over the top to stretch opposition teams especially for haaland who loves playing over the top and two wingers who love space. Honestly kdb should play more of that Toni kroos style to let the team build out more but also tough without a true dm. Which hurts walker who is kinda being asked at his age to play a more traditional fullback role which is leading to some goals . But I say no because legit the prem is pretty solid right now , Brentford, Bournemouth, Fulham are all solid teams with physical midfields and good managers which leads to results like have been seen against city.

[@BreezeElna-gi6di]

I know we have already spoke about Frimpong not being a rightback, but he could work Start two solid rest midfielders, KD, Foden on the right wing and Frimpong at rightback Frimpong will do a better job there than Walker or Josko and he is very fast got the recovery pace in him, in transition he could work He wouldn't only work on the more controlled Situation we he has to show his defensive skills but i mean he is more less like Rico

[@iampower5547]

I think it's vini balondor curse. Ever since Rodri rob him city never look the same 😢

[@user-df5kr3ld4r]

We have seen this movie for the past 7 years🥶🥶🥶🤓🤓🤓

[@shreyas8954]

no gvardiol in the XI nobbins?

[@Nobbins]

He’s there yes 😃

[@ajaykumarvs8134]

Best defence makes trophies 2023 city have best defence in the world and city won epl fa cup UCL

[@overman2306]

It's just Rodri and Kev are not there.

[@Scottymol]

Interesting that Bernardo Silva wasn't in any of those revised line ups. I wonder why? I agree by the way he is surplus to requirements. Useless in other words.

[@Nobbins]

I like Bernardo but personally I’m not starting him if everyone’s fit

[@sleepysun3082]

We need heavy reinforcement in January.

[@Nobbins]

Realistically we can get 1 signing I think

[@sleepysun3082]

@@Nobbins i really hope so its always better than nothing. tho the more the better because so many injuries and more competition cuz new format.

[@highestmadeit8809]

I wish pep would see this video 😢❤

[@knotJammy]

Mf that's pep..he already knows what's going on...but he's lacking certain players ..so he can't help now

[@Nobbins]

Haha as I say in the video, Pep’s well aware of the issues as he’s commented on them

[@highestmadeit8809]

@@knotJammy maybe we are overreacting

[@hillbilly904]

Guardiola lost 4 in a row with Bayern once.

[@Nobbins]

He didn’t

[@max-nm6qx]

"THE BATTLE OVER BRITAIN "BY PROF WALTER VEITH POWERFUL POWERFUL WATCH TRUTH ALWAYS WINS ❤

[@Quantalksfootball]

Pep is too stubborn at times

[@Asadarfhgv]

If we dont sign proper players in january. Its over brother we wont even finish inside top4. Only haaland is our goalscorer if he get injured for longer period🔪🔪....... I dont even wanna say anything else 💀

[@Nobbins]

Will need to take action in Jan 100%

[@broman1429]

Inside top four we r shit at the moment but outside top four is a stretch

[@Asadarfhgv]

​Problem is our midfield is too old they can hardly play 45/50 mintues after that they melt like ice 😂 literally opponents wait for the 2nd half & then they kill the games, rico lewis & nunes looses too many balls in midfield.. Not good enough. In january we need two midfielder, i will say zubimendi & douglas luiz on loan he is not settled at juve ​@@broman1429