Are protests HARAM? - Response to Sh. Assim Al-Hakeem

[@j400wel]

none of the salaf sided with the enemy like the house of saud did.

[@-------....___]

Because Salaf were Muslim. Saud and other ‘Royal’ families are not. It is very disrespectful to even say their name in the same sentence with the Salaf. The Salaf were not greedy psychopaths who ruled by secularism, called for nationalism, and only cared for their own kursi.

[@-------....___]

@@dub4fr so I will make it clear, the ruling family members, the ones who support MBS, support nationalism, support secularism, support taghut, are kafir. Allah SWT was very clear on this.

[@-------....___]

@@dub4frlet me make it clear then. Anyone of them that supports MBS, or supports secularism, or supports nationalism, or supports taghut, is kafir.

[@Rexorazor]

I always knew they were Zionists. They made sure to keep our community backwards.

[@Rexorazor]

​@@-------....___Salafi Zionist spotted.

[@InshalHassan-r4s]

Do more of this please , I am sick of these Scholars who label everything Haram without giving a second thought

[@colettenora9769]

In many Muslim countries,scholars may not speak about politics. But they speak about the faith, the behaviour…..and it’s necessary because many people don’t pray and follow the behaviour of non Muslims.

[@EruRoraitoX]

Free mixing against murder = haram Free mixing shopping in the shops around Kaabah = Halal. Hey, as long as it bring the prince money is halal.

[@-------....___]

Lol, you forgot ‘free mixing’ in music concerts, film festivals, pagan celebrations, bikini competitions etc.

[@EruRoraitoX]

@-------....___ shhhhht, obey your ruler and your scholars, they know best, you just follow like a good sheep you are. Let me misuse a verse completely out of Islam context just so you can be convinced: "We hear and we obey." [ Qur'an 24:51] And if you read the whole verse, know that you're unable to understand it, only I can understand it for you.

[@-------....___]

@@EruRoraitoX like the Jews before them, they have taken their ‘leaders’ and ‘scholars’ as lords besides Allah SWT. Islam and the Quran is all about Justice, whether it’s to ourselves, to our lord, to our parents, our enemies, to animals etc. They ignore all of that just to blindly follow the taghut. Everyone is commanded to be just, except the ‘rulers’. They can be unjust. Everyone is punishable under Sharia for crimes they commit, except the ‘rulers’. Sharia doesn’t apply to them for some reason.

[@tanveersheikh9860]

but when did he condono these things you are talking. Fear Allah before falsely accusing Daees

[@-------....___]

@@Dukingaround1yes, so the point is, the Saudi scholars or those who support taghut, they will come out and say demonstrations are haram, but they won’t do or say anything about the other things. And those that do, they get jailed. Also, again, you say demonstration is haram. Did you even watch this video? Are you making something into haram which is not haram.

[@fatimah9202]

We gave you shelter when Europe disowned you But instead of appreciation You were greedy You began slyly occupying our Land Then you shelled my home to the ground You destroyed my olive groves You burnt down my orchards You killed my mother and father You imprisoned my brother You shot down my spouse, and young children You left me with nothing I retaliated only with stones And the Resistance with rockets So you and your accomplice Called 'us' the Terrorists Yet you can see, that I still smile Yes! I am strong You can break my bones and cut my flesh But you cannot destroy my faith Yes! I am Muslim And I will carry on protecting al Aqsa Our beautifull Holy Land And I am not alone For I have Allah And I believe in life after death You actually did me a 'favour' My kindred now rank as Martyrs You elevated my status Through your oppression But I will find you On the day of judgment I will find you. In'shaa-Allah Ya Allah have mercy on the Ummah Ya Allah free Palestine Ya Allah guide all Humanity The children of Adam Peace be upon him Father of mankind For the sake of thy beloved Prophet Muhammad Peace be upon him

[@tigerizalive2821]

Protest against the despotic regime is a natural reaction of the injustices. Those who discourage, know they are working with the enemy behind closed doors i.e. wahabi and takfiris

[@-------....___]

Madkhalis and pseudo salafis

[@RobertOfStAlbans_]

@@-------....___Yes, correct.

[@AAAAAA-jb8lq]

⭕ The Messenger ﷺ said: *"After me, there will be people (rulers) who will say what they want, and there will be no one to stop them (to contradict them). They will leap into the fire (of Jahannam) like monkeys."* One day, during his Friday sermon, contrary to his usual practice, Mu'awiyah said: "The wealth of the Bait-ul-Mal and the booty is at our discretion, we will give it to whomever we want, and we will not give it to whomever we do not want." *No one responded to this.* On the second Friday, he repeated this again, *but no one responded.* But when he repeated the same on the third Friday, a person from the crowd stood up and addressed Mu'awiyah, saying: *"Indeed, no! The wealth of the Bait-ul-Mal and the booty belong to all Muslims. Whoever stands between us and it, we will confront with the sword."* After the Jumu'ah prayer, Mu'awiyah called him over. Some people went with him, and when they entered, they saw that Mu'awiyah was sitting with this person and thanking him. Mu'awiyah said to them: *"I heard from the Prophet ﷺ:* *"After me, there will be people (rulers) who will say what they want, and there will be no one to stop them (to contradict them). They will leap into the fire (of Jahannam) like monkeys."* Therefore, I said these words in the Friday sermon with the thought of whether someone would admonish me or not. I was worried when no one admonished me on the first Friday. So my concern increased, but today, when I said the same for the third time, *this person stood up and admonished me, which gave me comfort that I would not be counted among those people."* Source: At-Tabarani and Abu Ya'la have narrated this event in their Musnad, both Al-Haytami in Al-Majma' and Al-Albani in As-Silsilat-as-Sahiha. Classification: Hassan according to Al-Albani. The narrators are trustworthy according to Al-Haytami. Ad-Damam narrates from Abu Qubail in a connected chain, according to At-Tabarani. Both are considered trustworthy, although Abu Qubail is somewhat weaker.

[@peazout]

Dont speak bs. You dont even know what a Wahabi is. The people in Subcontinent use the term Wahabi for Salafis while this sheikh himself is Salafi. Its funny how ignorant you are.

[@joshrentos216]

I discourage. I’m not working with the enemy behind closed doors. I’m not a wahabi or takfiri. Now what?

[@A.--.]

Im so glad the Scholars are finally speaking to each other in public square to clarify concepts.

[@reemabdi2316]

there not scholars, there both just da3ees.

[@reemabdi2316]

both of them are not scholars

[@A.--.]

@@reemabdi2316their students disagree

[@A.--.]

Im open to listening to all points of views and weight the evidences. I absolutely disagree with those who want to force a khilafa or sharia in. I think Khilafa is a miracle not possible without divine intervention and only Prophets can establish them...Dacid, Muhammad, Jesus. Men who try to do it end up destroying the society. The reason is they dont have convincing power (aka miracles) like prophets do.

[@spring0h430]

Even assim al Hakeem says he is not a scholar, just a da'ee

[@AAAAAA-jb8lq]

⭕ The Messenger ﷺ said: *"After me, there will be people (rulers) who will say what they want, and there will be no one to stop them (to contradict them). They will leap into the fire (of Jahannam) like monkeys."* One day, during his Friday sermon, contrary to his usual practice, Mu'awiyah said: "The wealth of the Bait-ul-Mal and the booty is at our discretion, we will give it to whomever we want, and we will not give it to whomever we do not want." *No one responded to this.* On the second Friday, he repeated this again, *but no one responded.* But when he repeated the same on the third Friday, a person from the crowd stood up and addressed Mu'awiyah, saying: *"Indeed, no! The wealth of the Bait-ul-Mal and the booty belong to all Muslims. Whoever stands between us and it, we will confront with the sword."* After the Jumu'ah prayer, Mu'awiyah called him over. Some people went with him, and when they entered, they saw that Mu'awiyah was sitting with this person and thanking him. Mu'awiyah said to them: *"I heard from the Prophet ﷺ:* *"After me, there will be people (rulers) who will say what they want, and there will be no one to stop them (to contradict them). They will leap into the fire (of Jahannam) like monkeys."* Therefore, I said these words in the Friday sermon with the thought of whether someone would admonish me or not. I was worried when no one admonished me on the first Friday. So my concern increased, but today, when I said the same for the third time, *this person stood up and admonished me, which gave me comfort that I would not be counted among those people."* Source: At-Tabarani and Abu Ya'la have narrated this event in their Musnad, both Al-Haytami in Al-Majma' and Al-Albani in As-Silsilat-as-Sahiha. Classification: Hassan according to Al-Albani. The narrators are trustworthy according to Al-Haytami. Ad-Damam narrates from Abu Qubail in a connected chain, according to At-Tabarani. Both are considered trustworthy, although Abu Qubail is somewhat weaker.

[@Iam_GodAmbassador]

Of course Mohammed knew everything he taught the people was total rubbish and lies so one day people will come to know All this black stone rubbish and they will begin to question the stupid Quran full of nonsense that is why he made those statements to defend his lies, Mohammed was never a prophet anywhere but a rebel leader and very corrupt womanizer

[@ahmednur2114]

One man came to prophet Mohamed Pbuh to complain about one of his neighbour,Prophet Pbuh said take all staff and sit in front of house, when people ask you why are you get out from your house? said “ my neighbour inflicted me and causes me to get out my house” when he did that all people starting talking about the bad neighbour, at end he come to him and said please come back to your home I will stop all bad things that I have done to you. So sometimes putting pressure on culprits might cause to stop the crime they are doing.

[@walidak8229]

These so called scholars (mainly based in the KSA) are not preaching so islam would prevail but so their rulers and kings would prevail no matter what they do.

[@husnahassen4077]

True 👍

[@Lagosawee]

How do we stand against injustice then…….

[@ZeeKay1430]

Is it not said in islam, "when you see and injustice, stop it with 1 of 3, the hands, if your not able to with your hands then your mouth, and if not the mouth then the heart, and the heart is the least of the 3" Something along those lines,

[@-------....___]

Madkhalis say, if you try to stop with your hands, you are kharji, if you try with your tongue, you are deviant. Just do with the heart, this is best, and remember, always obey the ruler

[@najmaalikhan]

It's authentic hadith, that when you see an evil, stop it physically, if you are unable to do then speak against, if you cannot do this then at least hate that evil in your heart. And this the weakest of iman. And Allah knows best

[@-------....___]

Let’s be honest. The main people who say ‘boycott’ is haram, or ‘protests’ are haram, are those who also preach absolute obedience to the ‘rulers’. These people are typically called the madkhali cult, or the pseudo-salafi. The ONLY reason they say these things are haram because these are things which could affect their ‘masters/rulers/lords’ power and wealth. They are always afraid that if they say protests are halal, then one day people might ‘protest’ against their beloved taghuts and despots. I mean, you have scholars being jailed in KSA and other gulf nations just for calling haram as haram. It makes a lot of sense. Protest for saving our brothers and sisters in Palestine, it is haram because of ‘free mixing’. But bikini competitions and music concerts, those are defended by saying ‘it’s only a mistake, leaders can have mistakes’.

[@kenaikyoshi416]

They say anyone who dissagrees with them is pseudo-salafi, as well lol. I say all wahabi salafi movement is rotten from the start. Even shaikh AlKalbani,imam Makkah admitted it. For decades they spread sectarianism and divided the Ummah, it;s time that movement to go to the garbage of history

[@ifteshamulbari2738]

You are right about boycott and partially about protest. But protesting along with people in public involves free mixing and may involve musical instruments and so one might consider not attending.

[@ifteshamulbari2738]

One may protest in a separated group maintaining hijab.

[@JohnJohnson-zt3bv]

@@ifteshamulbari2738 brother go out to literally anywhere and its free mixed. When you go to the restaurant or to grocery shopping it will be free mixed. Because guess what, we were created as two genders 🙀

[@JohnJohnson-zt3bv]

@@ifteshamulbari2738 the world is “free mixed”. Bet you go the grocery shops and “free mix” or should we have gender segregated malls now 😅

[@markov.2467]

My heart is settled. Someone finally addressed some of the nonsense fatawa

[@flowersarered]

👏👏👏👏

[@rukayyahbello7147]

Just shows how you love to follow your heart desires instead of the truth and the command of Allah

[@-------....___]

@@rukayyahbello7147 What truth and command? Prove from Quran and Sunnah where the specific action of protesting is haram.

[@wajhussain6013]

This guy doesn’t know the difference between protest and dawah. Also if some asks a question or disagrees he thinks they’re protesting.

[@saliuabubakar689]

Lol, ya akheel kareem, he knows what protest means, but they are ahlul hawā. They do this to mislead the unsuspecting Muslims. This is why one needs proper or basic knowledge of Islam to identify the deception of this kind of acclaimed scholars. He said the prophet was telling the quraish, "You can't worship idol! You can't worship idol." Look at the deception and lie against the prophet of Allah, عليه السلام. The prophet that received the revelation "no compulsion in religion " would never use the verb "can't" for other people's worship. هدانا الله و إياهم

[@-------....___]

@@saliuabubakar689 you are talking n0nsense.

[@DrWoofOfficial]

There is a faction that is adamant on protesting being haram and they prohibit it because these protests rarely happen except with the haram elements included. But in any case, blanket prohibition of protests, raises a generation to do inkaar of others based on incomplete information and deficient understanding on a topic, and we have seen this plenty of times.

[@-------....___]

The faction that are adamant that it is haram, are those afraid that one day people ‘might’ protest against their ‘rulers’ and taghuts. Most of these people who are adamant it’s haram are living in the gulf nations. They don’t even say anything Israel, or anything in support for Palestine, because they are not allowed to.

[@Dukingaround1]

This is about following our desires. Do not conflate demonstrstions with other forms of halal protest. No person of knowledge would allow or attend such demonstrations. Any claim otherwise is a lie. All classical scholars would not permit such things.

[@rashadabdulazeem5387]

The classical scholars probably would if they lived in 2024, they had absolutely no idea what the future Ummah would experience. Moreover, what is our prime directive as Muslims when we witness munkar, I'll let you fill in the blanks.

[@Dukingaround1]

@@rashadabdulazeem5387 classical Orthodox scholars are still alive brother.

[@Ameer-is3dh]

@@Dukingaround1 doesnt mean he let our corrupted rulers live in peace. Solution is kilafah gov which will remove all these corrupted people.

[@RobertOfStAlbans_]

Evidence? Being a fake salafi and defending tagoot is following desires.

[@Dukingaround1]

@@RobertOfStAlbans_ you're gay

[@mohammedmajidi-u7x]

Free mixing is totaly haram and there is nohing unclear

[@raffatperveen3150]

Shiekh jazzak ALLAHU Khairain Khathera for giving us the lslamic perspective to understand things according to Quran and Sunnah

[@fatheraff3542]

Allah help this Ummah to unite!

[@RobertOfStAlbans_]

Madhkalis and FakeSalafis mad that their no Ijaza “sheikh” has been refuted. The Ways of the Salaf are free from these people.

[@-------....___]

The worst insult is when specific pseudo salafis say MBS is salaf. Is this a joke? Show me any salaf like him. Even Yazid, who was an oppressor and tyrant (from the sources I have read) was still Muslim and 100000 times better than MBS lol. MBS main mission is to remove Islam from daily life (keep it to the prayers only), and misguide the youth, and they saying he is Salaf???

[@fishmud3264]

Where us this Muslim Ummar I hear so much about? You guys always slander each other that's why I convert to Islam. The diversion and confusion pushed me away. Life is challenging enough in these crazy times

[@fishmud3264]

Where us this Muslim Ummar I hear so much about? You guys always slander each other that's why I convert to Islam. The diversion and confusion pushed me away. Life is challenging enough in these crazy times

[@thundel6152]

​@@fishmud3264people are feeble but they don't slander out of enmity rather honestly to their opinion tho it might be little hard sometimes but if the life had to be so easy we probably wouldn't be sent to earth, have tawwakul and don't worry about things that are not in ur hand but works towards that are in ur hand

[@imammamunu9537]

Saying that non of the salad did protest is plainly not true if you are the seera of the prophet and His companions

[@markov.2467]

Mashaallah for critiquing this incompetence

[@binteshuaib9188]

Misguided callers all resemble eachother. No problem shaykh, please send your wife and daughters all over the world to protest alongside with men. We would love to see them.

[@-------....___]

What a straw man argument. It’s like someone saying the Muslims should actually go to Gaza and fight for their brothers and sisters, and you saying it is haram because there will be free mixing. And then you coming up with your straw man and saying send your wife and daughters to fight. Your thought process is f1lthy

[@Ameer-is3dh]

You are saying... People shouldn't protest and try to change gov?? Lol if you too afraid to talk against gov or too afraid to go out remove the gov system then you r basically a coward who loves to live in so called peace.

[@AAAAAA-jb8lq]

Didn't Bilal also demonstrate against Omar? And there was also an incident with Muawiyyah that was linked to a hadith of his where someone stood up in the khutbah to denounce Muawiyyah. Something similar was also mentioned by Abdelmalik bin Marwan, commented on by Said al Khudri, who also linked this to a hadith

[@AAAAAA-jb8lq]

⭕ The Messenger ﷺ said: *"After me, there will be people (rulers) who will say what they want, and there will be no one to stop them (to contradict them). They will leap into the fire (of Jahannam) like monkeys."* One day, during his Friday sermon, contrary to his usual practice, Mu'awiyah said: "The wealth of the Bait-ul-Mal and the booty is at our discretion, we will give it to whomever we want, and we will not give it to whomever we do not want." *No one responded to this.* On the second Friday, he repeated this again, *but no one responded.* But when he repeated the same on the third Friday, a person from the crowd stood up and addressed Mu'awiyah, saying: *"Indeed, no! The wealth of the Bait-ul-Mal and the booty belong to all Muslims. Whoever stands between us and it, we will confront with the sword."* After the Jumu'ah prayer, Mu'awiyah called him over. Some people went with him, and when they entered, they saw that Mu'awiyah was sitting with this person and thanking him. Mu'awiyah said to them: *"I heard from the Prophet ﷺ:* *"After me, there will be people (rulers) who will say what they want, and there will be no one to stop them (to contradict them). They will leap into the fire (of Jahannam) like monkeys."* Therefore, I said these words in the Friday sermon with the thought of whether someone would admonish me or not. I was worried when no one admonished me on the first Friday. So my concern increased, but today, when I said the same for the third time, *this person stood up and admonished me, which gave me comfort that I would not be counted among those people."* Source: At-Tabarani and Abu Ya'la have narrated this event in their Musnad, both Al-Haytami in Al-Majma' and Al-Albani in As-Silsilat-as-Sahiha. Classification: Hassan according to Al-Albani. The narrators are trustworthy according to Al-Haytami. Ad-Damam narrates from Abu Qubail in a connected chain, according to At-Tabarani. Both are considered trustworthy, although Abu Qubail is somewhat weaker.

[@letusreason5071]

I strongly believe you are wrong. The free mixing, music and what not. All your examples were exceptions and they don't make free mixing in protest permissible. Your deduction is completely flawed. If you pushed for an islamic type of protest that is gender segregated free from free mixing, music and other impermissible things I would have agreed but you went on to justify haraam with exceptions and even irrational things. Total nonsense!

[@-------....___]

So when women went to the battlefield with the Sahabah, there were drums and free mixing. Did the Sahabah not know what they are doing? In the market there is free mixing and music too, but there are etiquettes then that we take care of. Why do you assume automatically there will be music at a protest lol. Do you go to the hospital? There is free mixing and music there too. Even in buses.

[@Robkia]

Facts

[@fatimah9202]

Dear brothers and sisters we must do whatever is in our ability, then trust in Allah. Indeed the results are in Allah's hands alone. Our duty is to make duas, wake up in tahajjud, raise awareness, protest, give charity, and support everyone and anyone (according to our means and abilities)who are sincere and have the means and power to bring about change, and stop the genocide of our brothers and sisters and children in Palestine🤲 And pray for the Ummah worldwide

[@maxkak2149]

Ya ,Sheikh may Allah reward you, keep it up , ur every single word matters as u speak with evidences and sincerity with out any fear and any personal interest.

[@tahmed8499]

Alhamdulillah, JazakAllah for speaking the truth Sheikh. Muslims are big in number but these misconceptions are causing our Ummah letting such injustice going on 💔

[@KankuMusaMensamandenka-dp5fo]

Greetings from Mali. The way I see it is that large political protests are part of ijtihad (use- your-brain) of modern methods akin to opinion press and other ways of saying No to injustice and despotism. Despotic rulers would definitely favor scholars who insist any type of protest is haram. I’ve been searching to see if there is a deep wisdom (to keep peace and unity, to avoid fitnat etc..) behind preventing public protests but did find anything. In fact, to me It makes all the sens that if I am going to do the Nahy anil munkar with my thong in public where I can be heard and that I if know that by myself I will be crushed then I would want to do it in groups. Now if « the salaf did not do it » but the Quran and Hadith did not say not to do it…. In fact both said to prevent/stop the evil/injustice then maybe they did not do our type of modern public protest only because it wasn’t known or necessary for impact in their time. Today you can enjoin good and stop evil by your hand through writing news paper editorials or opinion articles. Is that halal or haram? Did «the salaf do it » ? No. They could not have done it simply because it was not there. The 3 levels hand, thong and heart to stop the evil are protest. The salaf with stronger iman were practicing the first level always ready to strike at injustice instead of spending much time on saying « no » e.g., Abdullah Ibn Zubair etc.. Modern protests is commensurate with the second level .. stopping evil «with your thong» by going out and saying in public in whatever légal manner possible. The Third level and the weakest in faith is of course preferred by the rulers …is stopping evil with «your heart» that is, you can hate it but stay silent.

[@DrWoofOfficial]

Ma Sha Allah

[@narelle24k]

mashalah very well explained. I agree with everything you said❤. may Allah swt reward u brother 😊 and free palestine 🇵🇸

[@131470]

Thank you for speaking up bother, he is saying we have to watch when innocent people slaughter. Shame on him to say that.

[@fatimah9202]

I looked at Gaza from the window of my heart And saw the destruction of precious lives Flattened homes and shattered dreams But when my gaze fell upon the sorrowfull eyes I saw the overwhelming calm And acceptance of God's decree The people here were true believers Valiant, courageous, resilient and faithful But when I turned to look the other way There was utter despondency and fear For these people had waged a war against Allah The most powerful and Just Lord of the Worlds Then I looked towards the Muslim leaders But they had sand in their eyes And their hands were tied As the Ummah awakens O Allah free Palestine! HasbunAllahu wa nimal wakeel

[@reubenboipai7728]

Islam means Submission Those who Submit should not protest.

[@doctorsfaithcorner4917]

Shykh I have a question; What about the Hadiths which indicates not to revolt until ruler is praying or not seen kufr in him.

[@mahmudulhasan3353]

How do you know the ruler is praying?

[@anjumkamal7669]

​@@mahmudulhasan3353Because it's not proven that the person is a Kaafir.General people know him as Muslim.Question is:Does he know that leaving prayer deliberately is kufr?

[@-------....___]

@@anjumkamal7669 Making Halal what is haram is kufr. Legislating in contradiction to Sharia is kufr. If Riba institutions, or alcohol shops are wide spread, are allowed (therefore making them halal), that is enough proof.

[@AhmedJaisam]

They were talking about armed rebellions not protesting.

[@mohammedzakari5561]

Let’s reflect on Verses 16:125

[@mohammedzakari5561]

Of course I am referring to Quran Kareem

[@-------....___]

That is about preaching, protesting is about attempting to change evil. Try to be smarter next time

[@fatimah9202]

O Ummah of broken hearts! Keep calm! For the scorching fire of Hell Will not die out Like the fires from the piercing bullets The treacherous grenades And the murderous bombs, of the cruel oppressors And glad tidings for the Martyrs Who are surely 'Alive' Indeed the everlasting blaze of Hell Awaits in anticipation Those who oppress Humanity And where Death is no more There is no Escape O Ummah of broken hearts! Keep calm! For the gardens of Eden Where the rivers flow And the gentle breeze, cause the trees to rustle In the sweetest melody Under the shade of the glorious Throne Will abide forever Those who are patient, grateful and compassionate And love and help each other For the sake of Allah O Ummah of broken hearts! Keep calm! For there will be no pain, or loss or sorrow in Paradise But peace and joy and everlasting love And most precious of all The pleasure of Ar-Rahman, our merciful Lord O Allah! Please have mercy on thy creation Guide all mankind to the path to Paradise And save Humanity from the path to Hell For the sake of thy most beloved Prophet ﷺ Surely if the tyrants knew the Truth They would not be oppressors Indeed it's not the eyes that do not see But the hearts that are blind O Ummah of broken hearts Keep calm!

[@Unspected7]

Ittaqillah ya ikhwani, Who do u think you are to slander Sh Assim and the scholars, The people of Bid'ah take things out of context and leave the scholars just like you. Fear Allah and delete your video.

[@abuladula]

A layman like me could've made this refutation response..

[@-------....___]

This is exactly the problem. Even layman can see, but certain ‘scholars’ can’t.

[@adamtandia2386]

This guy is contradicting Hamad Ibn hanbal , Sheikh Fawzan , Sheikh Ibn Baz , Sheikh Hussemin . Protesting is not sunnah .

[@-------....___]

Something can be halal and not Sunnah. The opposite of haram is not Sunnah. He already explained the prophet pbuh and his Sahabah protested.

[@adamtandia2386]

My friend protest is newly invented in Islam by ikwani . Go study we don’t need opinions we need dalil .

[@-------....___]

@@adamtandia2386 You don't know the meaning of protest. Go and search in a dictionary, it's not that hard. Even if you believe that ikhwani invented it (LOL), so called ikhwani are muslims. Dalil is history of the Sahabah.

[@samik3184]

Sheikh can you comment on the whole idea of "rebelling against a Muslim leader?" Salafis say we cant because it causes fitnah. JazakAllah khair

[@-------....___]

As long as he rules by the book of Allah SWT, even if he is sinful, we should not rebel. And these Hadith are only applicable to the leader (singular) of the Ummah. These Hadith are applicable to the Imam of the Muslims who has ‘baiyah’ from the ummah. Not secular leaders who call for nationalism.

[@CyborganizdInc.-gc5so]

@@-------....___ Isn't it also applicable to your parents, as your parents are basically ulool amri minnkum? Unless your parents connnnand you to do something against A||aah and His Me55enger SAWAS ofc.

[@-------....___]

@@CyborganizdInc.-gc5so For parents, specifically it is said even if they are kafir, obey them and treat them kindly as long as they don’t ask or force you to disobey Allah SWT. This is from Quran. As for leaders, they are given baiyah, and they have rights over you, just as you have rights over them. If they are kuffar, you cannot give baiyah to them as baiyah is only for the Amir. There is no verse or hadith that says fight your parents if they don’t rule by the book of Allah SWT. But there are Hadith which limit obedience to the ruler - he must be removed if he rules by secularism. Parents are completely different category brother. Jannah lies at the feet of your mother, not the feet of the ‘ruler’. Lol. You know when I say this, I think maybe this why Madkhalis bootlick so much lol. They believe maybe jannah under feet of ruler, hence the bootlicking.

[@-------....___]

@@CyborganizdInc.-gc5soparents are different. You obey them even if they kafir, and be kind to them, as long as they don’t tell you to disobey Allah SWT. Rulers, if taghut or kafir, you cannot give baiyah to

[@-------....___]

@@CyborganizdInc.-gc5soparents are different. Even if they disbelievers, you still obey them and be kind to them, as long as your obedience to ALLAH SWT is there. As for rulers, we cannot give baiyah to kafir, and kafir and taghut must be removed.

[@fatimah9202]

Children of the silk curtains O children of the silk curtains With bright shining eyes When you reach the garden Please convey our salaam To the guardian of infants With the flowing white beard Surrounded by angels O children of the silk curtains Innocent and pure When you reach the garden Please convey our salaam To our prophet Ibraheem Whilst the celestial nurturers await to hold you O children of the silk curtains With the cheeky smiles No fault of yours that you were martyred But Allah wanted that you play in heaven So when you reach the blessed garden Remember to convey our salaam To the guardian of infants For our hearts are bleeding And your sweet memories Will forever remain And Palestine one day Will be Free...

[@maxkak2149]

May Allah reward u Sheikh, I always have petty on these kind of ulema who have sold themselves to the regime . May Allah protect u and reward you, u are speaking on the topics that other Ulema have neglected .

[@yahyajohnlorenzen4713]

This is the way!

[@raffatperveen3150]

We tired of these celebrities Shiekh who are not really Shiekh and these salafees one we need a middle ground to know the lslamic perspective please continue always ln Sha Allah

[@HenryTownsmyth]

Well, calling the prophets protesters is a weird concept. That would mean the primary job of a Muslim is to protest. I am sure what our prophets did was "Dawah" not protesting.

[@RobertOfStAlbans_]

Assim doesnt have an Ijjaza. No need to take anything from him.

[@ALLAHSHAHAADA]

Give us some names of people with Ijazah so we can start listening to them

[@RobertOfStAlbans_]

@@ALLAHSHAHAADA Israr Ahmed.

[@ALLAHSHAHAADA]

@@RobertOfStAlbans_ thank you, unfortunately, it's not in English

[@RobertOfStAlbans_]

@@ALLAHSHAHAADA Doesnt matter. He’s still objectively better than Assim.

[@-------....___]

Assim is pure madkhali murji'a

[@alexcamden473]

This is the guy who said that Istanbul was not conquered by the Muslims yet because ottomans were not Muslims. House of Saud's evilness is something noone can explain fully.

[@slickrick2420]

He's right the Ottoman were super sufi grave worshippers

[@alexcamden473]

@@slickrick2420 another typical ambassador of saudi kufr...

[@nomanfreezy3197]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/hqXQZYqumtuSh9Usi=WXip-XnqGCtvvaWK this is a compilation of ahlul ilm like imam al albani who was a muhaddith and also he was not a saudi. may allah guide us from misguided people.

[@-------....___]

Al Albani made many mistakes, he is human.

[@algalib5217]

Do you not differentiate between protesting and preaching? Prophet used to preach the revelation that comes from Allah. This is not protesting. What is this guy talking about?

[@baisjeng]

Where did this guy study from?

[@SG-ve7zz]

Exactly!!

[@adamtandia2386]

Muslim brotherhood’s ikwani

[@mawlududdin3587]

Sh Assem's views rises from pacifying Muslims from rising against all these regimes especially Baghi family Sauds. So forget about evidences, for there are many evidence regarding accounting as long as the means and styles are not haram.

[@rasoulrahimzada7620]

Aameen

[@luizmanar6025]

Salaf also did not fly a airplane ✈️ also haram. You can demonstrate and use the powers we get these days. Protesting is more united and an example of what it is to be a Ummah.

[@TitaniumSlayerNinjaCopper]

So totally incorrect. Unity means freemixing which is haram so unity as a whole is haram. And there is no “ummah”. This “ummah” has Shias, asharis, Sufis, muttabarijats, dayouths, etc. it will only be false unity

[@-------....___]

@@TitaniumSlayerNinjaCopper Ummah unity is haram because it will have free mixing? Have you been drinking?

[@TitaniumSlayerNinjaCopper]

@@-------....___ yes. On the first part the unity part not the drinking part astagfirullah no

[@-------....___]

@@TitaniumSlayerNinjaCopper 👍

[@-------....___]

@@TitaniumSlayerNinjaCopper I meant drinking tea :)

[@alexharvey91]

This guy is a Saudi funded imam. This type of imam always toes the Saudi line.

[@Ara24_td]

Saying protests aren't a part of Islam because the Salafs didn't do it is like saying school is haram because it didn't exist back then. Now I'm not saying that protests are or are not haram but if that's the reason then I find it quite unconvincing, the issues of free mixing and music are a different story though. Yet again he's a scholar and I'm an ignorant person so I don't want to come across like I know better, I don't.

[@TiGeR08167]

The question would be are protests saving lives in Gaza? I would say definitely not. Why would we do something that doesn’t benefit us? Boycott actually works and I would do that too.

[@John-Jenin]

What are you talking about? Boycott also don't save lives.

[@-------....___]

Protests are not helping Palestinians? Prove that. Protests are the only thing that are making leaders everywhere speaking up. If there were no protests, and the whole world is silent, you think that would the same or better?

[@fahimruffsun5545]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/r4OpYp-JntOJldEsi=iH7FJ76ydZq-3rvg Pls go through the full video by Assim Al-Hakeem. May Allah subnaytala makes easy for us to understand the actual truth.

[@gixotube]

May Allah bless you brother I totally agree

[@Xscrambler]

The way I see it ONLY MADKHALIYA ARE AGAINST PROTESTS.

[@bronzebueno]

It makes sense to not attend such protests though. Knowing there's no segregation of sexes.

[@NazmusLabs]

do you go shopping? If yes, then you’re telling me you’re OK mixing for Dunia gains but when it comes to standing against oppression for the sake of Allah, you’re gonna apply this rule? Are you listening to yourself?

[@bronzebueno]

@@NazmusLabs Shopping's a necessity that can't be avoided and doesn't fall under the guise of free mixing. Attending a protest willingly knowing there'll be women without accurate hijab is your own doing.

[@NazmusLabs]

@@bronzebueno standing up for injustice of the highest degree is a necessity. It’s fard. Just like Hajj is fard. End of discussion. have a simple challenge for you: ask Allah (A.W.J.) sincerely if you’re right or wrong. You’ll find out the truth. Never have I asked Allah about an opinion except that I was absolute clear signs showing you which one of the opinions are more beloved to Allah (S.W.T.).

[@bronzebueno]

@@NazmusLabs What has begging and pleading with the disbelievers achieved? The Palestinians continue to suffer. Would the Prophet and his companions gather around such protests with their wives?

[@fadumonor868]

⁠@@bronzebueno, you’re not begging, You’re simply exercising right to protest the government works for the people so if their money is being misuse, they have every right to speak against it.

[@mohammedmajidi-u7x]

Which scholar is he folowing because he is not a scholar and his oppinion is not enough to say if it's permissable or not and not like assim alhakeem when he gives us the oppinionif sheikh ibn uthaymeen rahmatuallah alahi

[@-------....___]

and who is 'shaykh' Uthaymeen? Is he a prophet?

[@getinspired7687]

Everyone is wrong about everything. And here is why!

[@bebmab6779]

He follows Islam that serve MB.

[@mohbubmiah955]

They put dawa table with books so my question did prophet Muhammad do that ?

[@SossoKart]

Like the Quran says if you see oppression fight it with your hands if you can't fight it with your tongue and if you still can't then fight it with your heart and protesting is still an important part of the struggle therfor it is still jihad therfor those who say it's haram to do that might be in majority those who follow corrupted leaders meaning they picked the side of Ibliss may they think about it who would Ibliss try to corrupt first his best targets? It's not too hard to see it cause even humans with bad intentions go to people with power to corrupt them cause horrible people know if they get to the leaders they will immediatly get an army of people who follow these leaders in their own ignorance meaning Ibliss doesn't really have a lot to do to get to us HE DOESN'T EVEN HAVE TO GET TO US TO GET TO US he just needs to corrupt popular leaders to get to us and it's frightning to see how easy it is to cause chaos now another thing if Moses himself didn't listen to Pharaoh and his army then why should we listen to the unfair? Why would Allah even help Moses peace be upon him against the unfair like He helped so many? He also helped us while many of us don't even aknowledge His existance astaghfiroullah i hope what i said can help people to figure things out cause i know that protesting can hurt a country can make us go backward slow things down and annoy people but know one thing if we don't struggle OUR CIVILIZATION CAN BE DESTROYED AS A PUNISHMENT AND WE WOULD ONLY HAVE OURSELVES TO BLAME anyways thanks for reading through this painfully long comment and keep your face up no matter how bad things seem

[@-------....___]

The madkhali psuedo-salafi manhaj is: If you see evil, change by your hand: then you are khariji If you see evil, change by your tongue: then you are deviant and want to cause fitnah If you see evil, change by your heart and this is the lowest of iman: yes, this is the best way. Pray in the masjid or your home, don't talk about islam or politics. And always remember, obey your rulers.

[@legolassonofthranduir33254]

@@-------....___ we are ordered to obey the rulers whether you like it or not

[@-------....___]

@@legolassonofthranduir33254 which rulers? We were also told not to divide. We were also told to stick with jama’a. We were also told to stand up to tyrants and oppression. We were also told to fix evil. Enjoin good and forbid evil. Since you replied and thought ‘oh I am quoting Quran and sunnah, I am so smart’ please show me anywhere in the Quran and Sunnah where you are allowed to have more than one leader of the ummah. Let’s go madkhali

[@-------....___]

@@legolassonofthranduir33254show me bootlicker

[@legolassonofthranduir33254]

@@-------....___ the word in surah an nisa is الو الأمر which is plural. You would know that if you had a shred of knowledge of the arabic language yet alone this deen

[@zahraali3480]

You cannot see injustice and be quite.that is against islam.

[@mshaz452]

Assalamu alaikum ya sheikh. You are 100% correct but the way you were passionate here you weren't like this when you were correcting Yasir Qadhi on the Topic of Khilafa and etc. I don't understand this. Kher In shaa Allah anyways May Allah Bless you

[@DevilFruitJourney]

To not mimic the kuffar thats why we dont protest because the quraish did it, or not?

[@amrehky9025]

May Allah help us strait them.

[@brahimjamaa2955]

جزاكم الله خيرا.

[@saibouaboubakar9888]

thanks sheikh for prooving my thought about protest against ruler was done by the sahabah and the prophet saws

[@-------....___]

If you think about it, nearly every Prophet of Allah SWT protested in some way against the people and customs of his time. Lut AS protested against his people for a particular sin. Ibrahim AS protested against idol worship.

[@saibouaboubakar9888]

@@-------....___ you are right bro thats why i was really shocked when i heard saudi sheikh saying protesting against ruler was haram while at the same time palestine were being massacred

[@-------....___]

@@saibouaboubakar9888 a Saudi ‘shaykh’ also said if the ‘ruler’ makes Zina on live TV for 30 minutes whilst drinking alcohol, you cannot say a word against him. These ‘scholars’ that do the dirty work for their masters are despicable.

[@yahyajohnlorenzen4713]

Ma sha Allah jazakum Allah khaira jaza very nice answer

[@salahdin6382]

Hajj is the biggest live protest every year .

[@salahdin6382]

Hilful fudhuul was a protest .

[@salahdin6382]

Every prophet protested . Musa a s punching a man was a protest . Protest means to protect and defend the truth .

[@Truthiscrystalclear]

Perfect response, jazaakalah. May Allah guide sh Asim.

[@BlackSpice]

We cant just watch small clips and make quick public judgement

[@vehidferhatbegovic9870]

Show proof for what you are talking about (I don’t agree with your statement)

[@fatimah9202]

Jazaa kAllahu khairah fid daarain

[@FayselMohammed-rg4yk]

You should sit and debate with the sheik on the issue rather than falsifying all his speech on public. That is what a Muslim brother should do!

[@junaidjan4947]

100% CORRECT AND NO ONE CAN DENY

[@-------....___]

@@junaidjan4947 I deny

[@raihanua]

There is more abt Mr. Assim - in one of his videos he said that our prophet (pbuh) called the meat of cows poison for us. I never found any reference of such hadith. I asked a scholar as well. If there is no such hadith, then what does that make Mr.Assim? Should any muslim even listen to this man?

[@-------....___]

Take the good from him, leave the rest. This is the best way. Like the scholars of Saudi, take the good from them, stay away from anything they say related to ‘rulers’ or politics.

[@fatimah9202]

As well as protesting and charity: ORGANISATIONS TO SUPPORT BY DONATING FOR PALESTINE AND HUMANITY AND BE INVOLVED IN THE STRUGGLES THAT YOU ARE UNABLE TO DO SO PRACTICALLY! PSC PALESTINE SOLIDARITY CAMPAIGN PALESTINE ACTION C.A.G.E. HHUGS FOA - FRIENDS OF AL-AQSA BDS MOVEMENT EVERY LITTLE COUNTS! BE ACTIVE ❤ FREE PALESTINE ❤

[@TawfickahmedAhmedReda]

Al Hakeem is terribly mistaken that protest is Hsram . That simply means you're favouring the oppressors.

[@doctorsfaithcorner4917]

WALAIKUMUSSALAM

[@zaidazam2592]

You said Haq 💕💕

[@mohamuddahir8334]

He get money from Saudi

[@letusreason5071]

Respectfully speaking, Shaykh Assim is right and you are wrong!

[@RobertOfStAlbans_]

Assim doesnt have an ijjaza. Relax with the taqleed.

[@kmir224]

if the reasoning for protests/demonstrations being haraam is "well, the Prophet (saw) and sahaaba never did it," cool. then using the internet, driving cars, using phones is also haraam, since there's absolutely zero chance they ever used these things also that's how stupid that argument and reasoning is

[@rukayyahbello7147]

May Almighty Allah forgive you🤲🏾

[@rukayyahbello7147]

Amin This video just shows how irresponsible he is with the way he is publicly criticising… even if assim was to be wrong which he isn’t

[@-------....___]

@@rukayyahbello7147 Asim is wrong, and he is murji'a, and a taghut w0r.shipper

[@dr.briaro]

Yes, its haram and still with sheikh assim Al-Hakeem! in Islam we don't critize another brother online infornt of millions of people, you should contact him and just you allah and him should be there when doing this critic, because this you are doing is also against the sharia. Destruciton of cars, boutiques name of Islam becoming more bad. May Allah guide us all!

[@dylberzylali5065]

I had to stop listening at 2 minutes… because of misinterpretation?!!!

[@Ameer-is3dh]

whats the issue?? akhi Muslim must be political .

[@rashadabdulazeem5387]

Well for one I'm not Salafi, and I'm under no obligation accept the sheikhs position, respectfully. Try to peacefully ask for more rights or even send an email criticizing MBS and you might just end up under the sword. This is position of dictators, the biggest fear of the gulf rulers are two words Islamic democracy. They would rather see the genocide of the Palestinians than support their movement for democracy and true freedom. Let's not forget, MBS cannot wait to establish diplomatic and normal relations with Zionism, let that sink in. Moreover, what is our prime directive as Muslims when we see munkar? Consult the Salaf?, let's get real

[@geelechannel2579]

Salaam from 🇸🇴 First of all, this Sheikh is trying to Correct another Sheikh who he sees him as if he is wrong, but the unfortunate is that He ( This Sheikh) insulted Biden how can you insult some one when you are acting as if you are a great sheikh. Does Islam allow its followers to insult anyone? No. Second, when you speak to anyone Calm down no shouting, that is not the way Islamic scholars talk to others. Quran 15:88 ( And lower your wing [i.e., show kindness] to the believers.) Third, According to my knowledge in Islam. Today’s demonstration that happens in western counties has no basis in Islam . And Muslims should not participate it all. Today, We all know Israelis are killing Palestinians, should Muslims demonstrate or Fight against killers? Fourth, When a muslim try to stop a bad action which a person or a government wants to do , he/she is Warner and vice verse he/she is bearer of good news . He/she is not a demonstrator. Allaah knows the Best.

[@shahankhan2468]

My friend he is a pay roll. Don't listen him except fique of wado and salah etc.

[@fikrmustaniiiir]

❤❤❤

[@fikrmustaniiiir]

Good video

[@farzanaanisha8929]

Salam with due respect I am disagreeing with you.

[@yousuffdar-kd7yx]

Wasting time wit these nonsense issues when Muslims all over the world are being persecuted and you still are worried about people having lived. 1400 years ago as commoners. Forgetting the prophet s a w and his progeny

[@asharalam.]

Even sheikh Alwan and the scholars in support of protesting said it is only permissible when the Islamic conditions are met, like no music or free mixing etc. even by his fatwa these protests in the west are haram. Additionally the first people to do something similar to a protest were the Khawarij, why would you imitate them. Protests is not something we Muslims do it’s not appropriate for us to do it. When you are protesting your begging the government to do something, isn’t it better to beg Allah instead? We have hours to spend at protests to beg governments but 10 minutes for a dua is too much, and then you look down on the person who does dua and come back from the protest like you’ve done something when all your have done is gain sin. Yes this isn’t what you want to hear but many of the major scholars said protesting Is haram, what you think or feels right according to you doesn’t matter, islam isn’t here to align with your opinions. Additionally I advise you to fear Allah, why are you encouraging Muslims to participate in sin with all the music and freemixing that occurs in a protest, it might get you whatever gain here but Allah will hold you accountable for everyone who justified protesting with this video. Really think about it, is it appropriate for our women to go around screaming in protests, for us to blast music and freemix, is this how we support our burgers and sisters? May Allah guide us all.

[@reemabdi2316]

So far I’ve only seen one where the conditiona were met and it was in Australia.

[@LeafSouls]

Support our burgers

[@Ameer-is3dh]

so you are too afraid to involve in politics???

[@-------....___]

So you saYInG we should only make dua to Allah SWT. If I have an exam coming up, do I study or only make dua? You know the Hadith about tying the camel then leaving the camel in Allah’s hands right? Show me which scholars said the act of protesting is haram, when we know prophets and Sahabah protested. Ibn Taymiyyah protested.

[@adamtandia2386]

Wallahi this is ikwani mentality .