Are Remakes Better Than The Originals? Teens & Millennials Decide Which Is Best!

[@ChrissaTodd]

the 2017 jumanji isn't a remake it's a sequal they literally reference allan parrish in it lol

[@timsamanthony]

Exactly, Nick Jonas' character stays in Alan Parrish's shelter when trapped in the game

[@squattingnevil]

Came here to say the same thing.

[@YurpNationReactions]

I came for this comment 😂

[@Anzac71]

You beat me to it. 👍

[@davekennedy3985]

Came here to say the same thing.

[@ItsMeJT]

For Jumanji, the 2017 movie wasn’t a remake. It actually is considered a sequel, considering it acknowledges events from the original movie

[@taylamichell]

Yep exactly it’s a sequel to the original not a remake so they got that wrong

[@ArtByDesign80]

7:56 The 1954 “A Star Is Born” was itself a remake of the 1937 version…they even note there was 4 versions…and show the 2nd as “original”

[@Chatman666]

Thank you. 🤣🙏🏼

[@dawggirl]

The thing with the OG Parent Trap is the chemistry between the leads was insane. And no one can beat Maureen O'Hara.

[@dvsreed]

A Star is Born made originally in 1937, remade in 1954 with Judy Garland, remade in 1976 with Barbra Streisand and then again in 2018

[@openfrom9to5]

was literally about to type the same thing... lol

[@jkiahampton6295]

I honestly didn’t even know any of that. Thanks for the information.

[@Devnet94]

I prefer the 1976 Barbra Streisand/Kris Kristofferson version. The music seems to be more female empowerment than the other 2 remakes. I haven't seen the 1937 version.

[@EntertainmentFan11]

The '50s version IS the original in terms of it being a musical

[@gypsygirl3255]

WTF, what happened to Streisand/Kristofferson

[@isaiahwade1484]

Why is Jumanji here? It's not a remake at all. Its a sequel and a reimagining of the game.

[@antoniomarin9061]

It technically is a remake because it’s based off of the game and it’s still part of the Jumanji series

[@martha170687]

I agree I don't see as a remake.

[@LoneWolf1493]

@@antoniomarin9061is that why “Alan Parrish was here” was carved into the side of that hut?

[@isaiahwade1484]

@@antoniomarin9061 that is false, technically and realistically it's not a remake. Like LoneWolf said, it even has references to the original. Alan Parrish is Robin Williams' character in the original, and his name is referenced in the 2019 Jumanji. Nora in the 2019 movie is also the same Nora from the original. She was the aunt of the kids. The end of the 2019 movie also goes back to the original Jumanji rules when the ostriches come out of the game and into the street, instead of the characters going into the game. So yes, it's 100% a sequel and not a remake.

[@antoniomarin9061]

@@isaiahwade1484 Well that’s why you can blame it all on the producers of this channel for making that mistake

[@manuelfuentespardo8102]

Correction: Tim Burton’s Charlie and the Chocolate Factory is not a remake from the 1971 film, but a more accurate version of the book.

[@jamesmoyner7499]

It irks me so much when people call it a Remake when it is just another adaptation.

[@KevinFauver]

Heres the thing though, everyone who worked on Jumanji 2017 said that it WAS NOT a remake but a continuation...

[@dennis2966]

Yep, it wasn't a remake. The two movies shouldn't even be compared, especially not using those two totally different clips.

[@mjolner42]

It's obliquely referenced in the movie, too. Seaplane name drops Robin Williams character when they meet him. Definitely a sequel, not a remake.

[@Zenoroth1]

I was surprised about The Grinch part. I'd have to go with the original only because it was a family tradition when I was a kid to watch it along with The Christmas Story as we opened presents and spent time together for the day. The original just hits me harder.

[@yomogami4561]

agreed original all the way

[@jamesmoyner7499]

@@yomogami4561 Finally some sane people.

[@1canadiankid1]

How are they supposed to decide which is better if they only watch a 30 second clip of each movie? They didn’t even get to see Robin Williams in the Jumanji clip?

[@Bouquez]

To be fair jumanji was a sequel. Hense the fact that they found the house of Allan Parrish, and the game started as a game board even in the sequel but when the kid would only play videogames it turned itself into one as a thirst trap

[@skzismyuniverse]

The mean girls one wasn't really a remake. It's a movie version of the musical. Which is a different thing altogether.

[@EntertainmentFan11]

Much like Little Shop of Horrors and Phantom of the Opera were movies based on the musical versions, but in the case of the former, it's still a remake because it started out as a '60s B-movie.

[@ChrissaTodd]

kind of like the Matilda musical not being a remake of the 90s matilda movie

[@marcussmith6805]

I disagree with Izzy. I feel like Jamie Lee Curtis carried "Freaky Friday." Lindsay was cool, but Jamie was top-tier.

[@EntertainmentFan11]

BOTH actresses honestly carried the remake.

[@itsizziman]

I meant it as she carried this era (early 2000s) jamie lee curtis and lindsay are always amazing. 🥰♥️

[@marcussmith6805]

@@itsizziman I can agree with that. 🫡

[@mikesg001]

Jumanji wasn't a remake, it's a stand alone sequal and its actually called Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle, it is the 3rd film in the series.

[@fire083]

Wow, I didn't expect someone to count zathura.

[@Firefistlaw69]

None of the actors in the last 10 years Can hold a candle to actors back 30 to 50 years ago They actually had talent back then

[@alenaseelye8672]

For those who did not know, "A Star is Born" first came out in 1937. The 1954 version was a remake with Judy Garland. Then, in 1974, they released another remake, this time with Barbra Streisand. The final remake was in 2018 with Bradley Cooper and Lady Gaga. So, the 1954 version is not an original movie. It is a remake.

[@sheenat3]

Yes.

[@heatherkiwi4286]

I'll fight someone. They got it wrong. Jumanji is not a remake it is a continuation of the story. They need to work on their videos if they are going to flub like that.

[@sofyuchiha9]

Either way no one should care about the remake/continuation. Only the og exists for me. I'm always there for my boy Robin williams

[@mspirits9911]

Agree with this. It has the continuity shown in the beginning of the 2017 movie.

[@The_Rising_Ape]

Great video folks with one small nitpick... Jumaji (2017) is not a remake, it's a stand-alone sequel in the Jumanji series. We see at the beginning Alex's father finding the Jumanji boardgame and giving it to him, when he's not interested in a boardgame it transforms itself into a video game to entice him into playing.

[@philliplittle6465]

Correct me if I'm wrong but I'm pretty sure Jumanji is a sequel not a remake. The first movie still happened, and the game "transformed" to become a video game in the beginning of the movie.

[@ShadowFist13]

As others have said 2017 Jumanji was a sequel and not a remake and should not have been included in this video.

[@DavidBrown-nr9py]

Judy Garland's version of A Star is Born is also a remake. The original came out in 1937. And it starred Janet Gaynor. So they just chose between two remakes.

[@reneehedin2252]

You forget the remake with Chris and Barbara

[@DavidBrown-nr9py]

@@reneehedin2252 I didn't forget about Barbara & Kris but it is another remake. The show was the original vs remake.

[@reneehedin2252]

@@DavidBrown-nr9py then you should show the original

[@ShowtimeSynergy12]

They chose Judy’s version because the two remakes (Streisand and Gaga) were based off her version. Judy’s version was rewritten specifically for her and is very different from the original 1937 film. The two remakes after were blatant copies of Judy’s version.

[@sunflowerscreativeshowcase]

@@ShowtimeSynergy12 Off topic, but love your @ name!!! I was a huge fan of Jem and the Holograms.

[@projectionreflection5475]

"Jumanji: Welcome To The Jungle" (2017) is a sequel not a remake. The scene in the beginning literally picks up where the last film left off

[@runeguardian]

JUMANJI should NOT be on this list as it was a continuation of the first one even having the pieces from the board game and the treehouse that the first boy built. They reference him by name a few times in the 2nd one. They even clarify that the magic of the game evolves the game as time goes by to lure in modern players.

[@bklynkat23]

I came here to say exactly that! Jumanji 2017 was not a remake but a straight up sequel to the original movie

[@brummboss4205]

even the parent trap from 1961 is a remake of the german movie "das doppelte Lotchen" from 1950.Based on a story by Erich Kästner. the only differnce, in the german version they take actual twins.

[@deidarafan1491]

Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle wasn't a remake it was a sequel. They even explained that the game turns into what is popular at the time which is why the boardgame turned into a video game cartridge.

[@zakomama6430]

A Star is Born was originally released in the 30's, not the 50's, despite how good Judy was in it (robbed of an Oscar). Also, Barbra Streisand was in the 70's version of the movie (yes, they made this movie 4 times).

[@tysangels]

jumanji 2017 was a direct sequel of the 95 jumanji and mean girls isn't a direct remake of the sequel but rather an adaptation of the broadway music version of the 04 story (made by tina fey) so that's why a lot of things are different

[@jeremyc4215]

You can definitely do this video again but pair maybe Gen X and Boomer generations; two generations who either remembered watching the originals and/or were alive when the original came out.

[@PHSDM104]

Mean Girls 2024 was not a remake. Just like Hairspray and The Color Purple, it was an adaptation of an adaptation of a film.

[@AkodoGarou]

This! All of this!

[@SpinX522]

The 2017 Jumanji is a sequel, not a remake and we know this for sure because in Jumanji the Next Level Bebe Neuwirth comes back as the aunt from the original Jumanji.

[@TheFoxPrince1]

Everyone in the comments is right, Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle isn't a remake, it's a standalone sequel. Seriously it's like saying Marry Poppins Returns is a remake to the 1964 movie Marry Poppins when it's clearly not. I would have used both the 1961 and the 1996 101 Dalmatian movies for that instead.

[@ariusbudiman7105]

Charlie's Angels original is 2000? wtf? the OG Charlie's Angels is 1976-1981 🤣

[@josevilas4927]

Of course. You just read my mind.

[@swimminlikeapig]

Johnny Depp as wonka is terrifying, but Gene Wilder as wonka is terrifying in an incredibly misleading way. That sh** scared me as a kid.

[@larryk731]

True - not enough "kids" films include attempted manslaughter, slavery, chickens being beheaded, and general psychopathy, all committed by a single individual.

[@petitebaje]

This is it exactly.

[@KhalidQuesada]

Choosing the 1984 Dune because it "inspired Star Wars" is insane. All 3 of the original Star Wars movies came out before it. Yes, the novel inspired the movies, but not the movie.

[@mesalgearsolid]

I'm pretty sure she was paraphrasing because the other girl literally told her it was the book that inspired Star Wars.

[@stevenshropshire5819]

Jumanji with Robin Williams is the original. Ones with Rock and Jack Black are the sequel versions as original is a board game while versions are gaming console games.

[@Ilix42]

It's like they didn't even watch the new ones. They even have a whole scene in the tree house Robin Williams lived in when he was trapped in the game in the first movie. I love all three of the movies.

[@stevenshropshire5819]

There were different movies based on Freaky Friday with one has former teen actor, Kirk Cameron & late comic actor, Dudley Moore in Like Father, Like Son (1987)

[@gugurupurasudaikirai7620]

Wait, Charlie's Angels 2000 is listed as the original? You know the original was a TV show from the 70s, right?

[@kayladeliz6504]

For A star is born those are actually 2 remakes the original came out in 1937

[@kendrama1]

What a freaking random clip to use for the 1984 Dune. “Here, have two minor characters sitting in chairs and talking to a Muppet in a tank!” I mean, what?? You had a whole-ass David Lynch movie to pick a scene from, and you chose *that* one??? (Was it even part of the theatrical release?) Stillsuits, sandworms, visions, duels? Sting in a Speedo? That one poor dude who had to milk a cat? Nope, gimme three randos sitting perfectly still! WTF

[@jamiedungo]

1995 Jumanji all day, but technically the new Jumanji films are not remakes... R.I.P Robin Williams

[@noodle155]

The 2017 Jumanji was a sequel, not a remake.

[@Kyllinge]

Jumanjia 2017 technically isn't a remake, it's a belated sequel. There was a 2nd animated version of The Grinch you could've compared it to instead of the live action.

[@joannemarkus4019]

Agree!!

[@mspurplducky6671]

Agree ^

[@DexterMoregan]

Zathura is a remake in my opinion.

[@ChrissaTodd]

@@DexterMoregan yeah claim that one is a sequal too but tbh that one screams more remake then the 2017 one does

[@EntertainmentFan11]

The Illumination version of The Grinch is far different. I think the title character's backstory in that one is why they decided to include the Jim Carrey version. As for Jumanji, some people are actually labeling WTTJ as a remake despite the Alan Parrish reference.

[@travisgreenaway1692]

Yes I agree with you that the 2017 Jumanji is a sequel especially when you watch the beginning where the original board game turns its own self into a video game

[@MsKeylas]

BINGO. So it is not old versus new it is Jumanji 1 and Jumanji 2 ))

[@spikejr3113jr]

The 2017 Jumanji movie is a sequel not a reboot. They even show how the board game turns into a video game. Some of the new producers are dumb.

[@joshfields22]

Lets go Izzy! All the love for the originals, but can appreciate a remake when its done well.

[@Intotheabyss1988]

If your comparing remakes to originals, you should be doing your best to pick the same scenes to compare to really showcase the differences

[@robertpease9834]

Yeah, I was thinking the same thing. Dune had a fight scene versus conversation.

[@impishsongster333]

100% agree

[@1jidion]

i object, jumanji: welcome to the jungle IS NOT a remake, it is a sequel, the game evolved from a board game to a video game, and alan parish (robins character) is mentioned in this movie

[@gothelismyfave]

I was about to comment this same thing. I don't understand why they thought remake when the story is completely different in Welcome to the Jungle.

[@1jidion]

@@gothelismyfave glad I wasn’t the only one

[@rebeccamcdermott9259]

So dumb it was included. Clearly they've never really paid attention to the film.

[@patriciaroberts308]

I'm sure you know this bit of trivia already, 2018 of A Star Is Born is the 4th remake. First: 1930's Second: 1950's (shown here) Third: 1970's Fourth: 2018 (shown here) 💕

[@islandgreenstrong]

Original Parent Trap is BEST overall!! Can't go wrong with Haley Mills who was a Disney classic actor for so MANY Disney movies...pahleeze! Her father was even in a Disney movie...The Swiss Family Robinson. Go back and watch the classics. OH, and big props to the beautiful ginger Maureen O'Hara and handsome Brian Keith. OG Parent Trap all the way every day!!

[@GeminiWolfstarGaming]

If you really like Maureen O'Hara as much as you appear to, I'd like to recommend the movie, if you haven't seen it, The Quiet Man with her and John Wayne.

[@islandgreenstrong]

@@GeminiWolfstarGaming Don't forget McClintock! and Big Jake with John Wayne (they were in 5 movies together), Miracle on 34th Street, Only The Lonely...and many many more. Yes, I know Miss O'Hara, she's my favorite actress.

[@GeminiWolfstarGaming]

@@islandgreenstrong I'm not real big into John Wayne's movies. I had to watch The Searchers in two different classes in college. Personally, once was enough. I didn't really enjoy the movie, but I do really like The Quiet Man, though. Miracle on 34th Street... that could be another original and remake one the reactors could react to as well! For me, I've seen the remake, but I have not seen the original (but I want to!).

[@islandgreenstrong]

@@GeminiWolfstarGaming I'm hit or miss with John Wayne movies, but I did think he was a great actor. I still remember the day he passed away, how I heard and where I was...I cried. My second favorite Duke movie, after McClintock! is The Cowboys. Spoiler alert if you watch it...two scenes made me cry HARD. I'm old, so I'm very partial to the OG movies. But, I did enjoy the remake of Miracle on 34th Street. My thing about most remakes is...why mess with a good thing, most end up trash.

[@GeminiWolfstarGaming]

@@islandgreenstrong He was a good actor. I do agree with that. I just don't care for his westerns. I liked him in The Quiet Man and in The Longest Day, as well as his guest appearance on I Love Lucy. The thing with remakes is they're made for two reasons: 1) To update it for newer audiences, a.k.a. younger generations. 2) To get the younger generations potentially interested in seeing the original. So it's kind of a 50/50 thing. If the remake is a win for the younger generation that's a good thing, and if it gets them interested in seeing the original, that's even better. At least, speaking as a movie buff and having an opinion of his own, that's how I see it.

[@wj8054]

I've seen both Parent Trap movies snd while both are very good, the original is still better. You have to watch the original, from beginning to end. Not just short clips.

[@stevenfriedman2902]

The Jumanji one is actually a sequel since they mention Alan from the first movie in it.

[@kncd1999]

YAYYY Izzy I!!! Excited for this video! Love an original and remakes so this will be cool to pick each one

[@bobbihancock5012]

Y’all need to watch the original Charley and the chocolate factory with adult eyes. Gene Wilder was brilliant in the role, but way more sadistic than we remember. “Oh no, please don’t “ while rolling his eyes and looking away every time

[@airbrushdungeon]

Jumanji never had a remake. The new ones were sequels.

[@speedy_brennan]

Junanji: Welcome to the Jungle is not a remake. You can't have reference to the original movie being apart of that world unless its a sequal or a movie in that universe. For example The Karate Kid remake with Jackie Chan is actually a Remake. The Karate Kid Miyagi-verse movies and Cobra Kia are cannon to each other but are movies and series in the Jackie Chan Reboot Version Universe because they are reference to in The Karate Kid 2010 is a movie. The stange thing is how the upcoming Karate Kid movie is going to have Daniel LaRusso and Mr. Han in it and would have to reckon the mentioning of the original movies out of the 2010 movie.

[@rachelmcdonald7296]

Jumanji 2017 is a sequel not a remake

[@vickibanks6538]

Willy Wonka has a special place for me because Pure Imagination is mine and my son's song. I've been singing to him since was only a few months old. And whenever I start to sing it he calms down if he's upset or has a really big smile on his face.

[@toodlescae]

Technically Jumanji 2017 is a sequel not a remake. It takes place many years later and Alan Partish from the original is even mentioned in it. Sorry but Depp as Wonka creeped me out.

[@ChrissaTodd]

i still prefer the jonnhy depp one personally, the fact that charlie gets in trouble in the OG one with the fizzy drink, and roahl dahl not liking it, i like the gene wylder version but i like the johnny depp one for being more matched with the book.

[@GeminiWolfstarGaming]

I just remembered something from the Jumanji movies. There's proof the newer ones are sequels, and not remakes. The third movie, Jumanji: The Next Level, toward the end of the movie, there's an appearance from Bebe Neuwirth as Aunt Nora. I now remember when I first watched it, I was blown away that Nora was back. I'm just waiting for a fourth movie with Kirsten Dunst and Bradley Pierce to come back as Judy and Peter. At this point, that's what I'm now expecting if they were to make a fourth movie.

[@meganhutcheson5867]

In the second one, Nick Jonas’s character stayed in the house or whatever it is that Robin Williams character built, and said this was built by Alan Parrish, and I don’t know who that is.

[@eddmario]

It was even confirmed before it came out that it was a sequel

[@GeminiWolfstarGaming]

@@eddmario I've only just watched the newer movies a couple of years ago now, so I did not know that. I mean, I am a movie buff, but I've been behind on newer movies for the past... I want to say about 10 years now. And it also doesn't help that I decided to start a gaming channel almost 4 years ago.

[@timidwolf]

Looks like you don't know the difference between a remake and an adaptation, or even a sequel for that matter. Out of the nine examples only four are remakes (possibly fewer, I don't know all the origins of these).

[@jacksonhytes4066]

So happy that majority chose the Judy version of A Star Is Born. She gave one of the greatest performances ever captured on film, and the film itself is one of the best movie musicals of all time.

[@timsamanthony]

Jumanji Welcome to the Jungle is a sequel and not a remake. Also the 2023 Mean Girls isn't a remake of the original movie, it is a movie based on the Broadway musical, the musical is an adaptation of the movie. In conclusion, Jumani Welcome to the Jungle and the 2023 Mean Girls movie are not remakes

[@TheAOTSdude]

Steve Martin is also a prop comic

[@mwle07]

Jumanji 2017 was Not a Remake but a continuing of the Story line 💯

[@SpinX522]

Was going to say this myself and we know this for sure because in Jumanji the Next Level Bebe Neuwirth comes back as the aunt from the first movie.

[@thebibliobibuli6395]

I'm surprised no one in the video mentioned the fact that the "original" Jumanji has Robin Williams in it.

[@lateramae]

It took me years to figure out that Rachel McAdams played Regina in the original 'Mean Girls'! I was so used to her with red hair that I couldn't even recognize her as a blonde.

[@hushabyezw]

I wouldn't consider Jumanji 2017 a remake of the original one, there are some references to the original movie, so for me it's more of a sequel when the original game evolved to videogame to attract new gamers

[@inluvwiththesun]

Exactly! That's my take on it, too.

[@taylorkendal17]

Was coming here to say that.

[@phoebs69]

Yeah with Jumanji and also Charlies Angels it was more a sequal then a remake

[@ebbhead20]

Theres 5 versions of A STAR IS BORN. The original from the 30s, a tv one from the 50s and the Babara Streisand and Kris Kristofferson one from 1976 and the 2 you got.

[@TheGeekpreacher]

The original Dune movie did NOT inspire Star Wars. However, the books DID inspire George Lucas. You can see that in the Sandworm skeleton in Star Wars: A New Hope on the planet of Tatooine.

[@theekatspajamas]

She literally says that in the video

[@bl3343]

Freaky Friday has actually been made four times now. There's the 70s version, a Disney Channel version from the 90s, the 2003 version, and then Another Disney Channel version from 2018.

[@ScarlettRoses]

Finally! Someone else who remembers the 90's Disney channel version.

[@GeminiWolfstarGaming]

I remember the 90's Disney Channel version, mainly because at the time I had a crush on Gaby Hoffmann. She's no Jodie Foster, but I remember thinking at the time she did a decent enough of a job.

[@malimae3191]

Jumanji can’t be compared they’re very different concepts and it’s actually a sequel series

[@AJDaniels99]

Ok technically the 2000 Charlie's Angels is not the original. I've seen a lot of people say that simply because nobody talks about the TV show

[@fire083]

It wasn't the original iteration of Charlie's angels. It was however the first film adaptation.

[@maplenerd22]

It's the original film. The entire episode they are talking about original vs remake films.

[@savannahryan91]

Well technically the 2000s Charlie’s Angels wasn’t the original unless specifically talking movies. Since Charlie’s Angels was originally a TV show from 1976-1981 with Jaclyn Smith, Farrah Fawcett and Kate Jackson as the 3 Angels.

[@Shadewe]

the 2017 Jumanji was not technically a remake. They showed the board game. When the kid was not interested in the board game. The game changed itself to a game cartridge.

[@Sokolikjr]

The real original Charlies Angles is the 70's tv show version & I remember that & that's better then those two movie versions of it.

[@tragictrust]

Didn’t even mention Robin Williams in Jumanji

[@mrzbrown053]

That truly bothered me actually he deserves them flowers

[@NicoD1990]

"Thanks for the idea"? Both Parent Trap movies are remakes. They are both based on a German children's book and there was already a German, a Japanese and a British film adaptation before the first US one...

[@Szilvi79]

Das doppelte Lottchen ? :) We read it in school here (Hungary) I liked it. And it is still a required reading today.

[@sgrabtune3950]

There were four Parent Trap movies made - The Parent Trap (1961) featuring Hayley Mills - The Parent Trap II (1986) (made for TV) featuring Hayley Mills and Tom Skerritt - Parent Trap III (1989) (made for TV) featuring Hayley Mills, Barry Boswick Patricia Richardson (best known from the TV show Home Improvement) & and this time playing three triplets are are real triplets Leanna Creel as Lisa Wyatt (Best known for playing Zack Morris's love interest in the last season of Saved by the Bell), Monica Creel as Jessie Wyatt & Joy Creel as Megan Wyatt - The Parent Trap (1998) featuring Lindsay Lohan, Dennis Quaid and Natasha Richardson All made by Disney

[@dancegregorydance6933]

In this case the Lohan remake is superior

[@vermonter19]

Jumanji is it’s own. 2017 is NOT a remake. Why did they have it as a remake? AND Jumanji had Robin Williams and any movie with Robin should not be remade he is one of a kind actor

[@UnusualPete]

You should do a video about Flop Movies from the 90s that became Culture Icons like... Tremors. I freaking love the Graboids! Much better that the Dune worms.

[@dawnelambert1546]

You need to hear Judy Garland sing in the original “A Star is Born”--incredible!

[@mikawhofan]

It was a remake. The original was in 1937 or 39

[@gigi-ij1hk]

@@mikawhofan True, but the 1937 version was not a musical, which all three that followed it are

[@marcussmith6805]

I figured The Parent Trap was going to be like that. The bias is clear there. How could it not be? Although, I grew up watching the Lindsay Lohan version, I enjoy the original with Hayley Mills.

[@lifeisbitvlover171]

Agreed I mean, I love Lindsay Lohan and that movie, and all... but the original has a special place in my heart from when I first watched it with my parents

[@zoeballard8545]

The OG Parent Trap is iconic. Hayley Mills was amazing in this. These kids need to watch more classics

[@tarah86]

I loved the original one as well.

[@sassycatz4470]

@@tarah86 They didn't even play much of the original!

[@zoeballard8545]

The Moon-Spinners and That Darn Cat! Are also two amazing movies. They need to do one where gen z and millennials watch old movies before the 60s

[@JodiesSideEye]

​@@zoeballard8545also the trouble with Angels series

[@zoeballard8545]

@@JodiesSideEye Love those movies

[@tanyamyers1637]

Y'all are liars. One Jumanji and the others are continuing. NOT REMAKES .

[@CerberusTenshi]

How can Dune, a 1984 movie be the inspiration for Star Wars, a 1977 movie. Even Return of the Jedi came our before Dune in 1983. One of the most influential shows for Star Wars was Star Trek. George Lucas said so.

[@jaredj.]

The novel Dune was written in 1965.

[@bsg666]

George Lucas also said that Dune (THE BOOK SERIES) was a inspiration for Star Wars, next time do your "research" first before.

[@jeffreyphipps1507]

They talked about Jumanji without mentioning that Robin Williams was in it or showing a clip with him? Injustice!

[@wheelz9414]

How do you show the original jumanji and not show Robin Williams?!?! And like everybody else says, it wasn't a remake.

[@beard78748]

That is not the original A Star is Born. The first is from 1937. The 1954 film is the first remake!

[@Yeahthatshowifeel]

Yes I came here to say that as well! React producers should really do their homework before posting this videos.

[@love4aliii]

@@Yeahthatshowifeel they get things wrong so often in videos, like they got Charlie’s Angels wrong in this and Jumanji and A Star Is Born.

[@maplenerd22]

@@love4aliii They technically didn't get Charlie's Angels wrong because they are talking about remake of movies, not TV show.

[@love4aliii]

@@maplenerd22 ☝️🤓

[@Soulhunter1981]

Actually both "The Parent Trap" Films are remakes. In 1950 a Film with the Name "Das doppelte Lottchen" (Lisa and Lottie for you Americans) was released in Germany and for "The Parent Trap" only the Setting was changed to USA instead of Germany.

[@violetwheatley2381]

That's interesting did not know that. 🤯

[@darr12100]

You should have teens react to old commercials featuring celebrities before they were famous and have them try and figure out who those celebrities are.

[@stevendeans4211]

Hailey Mills was an Oscar winning actress. This was Lindsey Lohan's first film.

[@totaldramasurvivor9723]

My jaw dropped when everyone chose the live action Grinch. I’ll never understand what people see in that version.

[@kg6276]

The first Star Wars movie was released in 1977. That would've been before Dune.

[@0leander410]

The BOOK inspired Star Wars. They missed the point.

[@steeldawg_steffie]

The OG Parent Trap is the better one and I am willing to die on that hill.

[@toodlescae]

Same

[@corymiller536]

It depends on who you ask really

[@TeXXicJA]

Love Hayley Mills

[@steeldawg_steffie]

@@TeXXicJA Same! I remember being shocked when I found out she was Miss Bliss from Saved by the Bell.

[@fire083]

I agree with you.

[@philippeterson1953]

The original Parent Trap is icon

[@nicolediablo]

with mean girls you all have to realize that the movie was more based on the broadway musical than the original movie.

[@ThomasVanhala]

Odd that they did not try to match up scene in the movies when it was possible. My Charlie's Anges is the original Jaclyn Smith, Kate Jackson and Farrah Fawcett and always iconic John Forsythe as Charlie but he was also voicing Charlie in the 2000 and 2003 movie

[@brat30012005]

For the Grinch one, they should use Ilumination one instead of the live action one. All because they were comparing animated original to a live action movie. Jim Carry movie stands on its own.

[@citylily]

Did not know Jodie Foster was in the original Freaky Friday. Will have to check it out!

[@neilvanrooyen7196]

Correction, Jumanji 2017 is a sequel to the 1995 Jumanji... So you can't compare them. they are both great in their own right.

[@baixiaolang]

Just because it's a sequel doesn't mean you can't compare them (that doesn't even make sense), just that maybe they weren't right for this specific video.

[@neilvanrooyen7196]

@@baixiaolang Sorry my bad, Thought the question was "Are _Remakes_ better than the original". 🙄

[@SnickerSnatcherz]

@@baixiaolang It makes sense if the challenge is original vs. remake, not original vs. the sequel.😐

[@mariaelenagarciamolero1437]

You should really try to compare the same scenes or the closets, otherwise it doesn't feel really fair Original: Jumaji, Mean Girls (but I did like the remake a lot), Charlie and The CF, Charlie's Angels (again I did like the remake a lot too) Remake: Parent Trap, Dune, A Star is Born, Freaky Friday, Grinch

[@Kalani_Saiko]

Jumanji and Mean Girls weren't remakes. Jumanji's was a sequel to the OG and Mean Girls was actually an adaption of the musical.

[@kategentry]

Judy Garland was not the original star is born. The original came out in 1937.

[@jariah92005]

Yeah, Gaga remade a remake as well. Its Barbra’s version down to the hit single.