Are we allowed to CRITIZE the Muslim rulers? - Shaykh Uthman Ibn Farooq

[@DawahTrucker2024]

Very good response Shaykh Uthman

[@ibrahimhasimoglu7676]

The salaf were not rebelling against muslim rulers, thats right. But why does no one mention that todays rulers are nlt ruling with the shariah, replacing shariah laws wkth man made laws, openly claiming they prefer man made laws, allying with the zionists, killing and torturing muslims, so how can a muslim with a sound aqeedah see these rulers as muslims ? They did many nullifiers of islam. Just read the books of Shaykh Muhammad ibn Abdil-Wahhaab. May Allah Guide the righteous and Protect all muslims from these opressor rulers who became murtadeen. May Allah Grant the muslims Jannah al Firdaus.

[@tahanafis4970]

look. it is still not your or my domain to call them kaafir. Shaykh clearly said that if a muslim does an action of kufr, we the laymen cannot make takfeer on them.

[@FoeNemK]

@@tahanafis4970 why not? Why can we make takfir on kufar assliyin but not on murtaddin?

[@tahanafis4970]

@FoeNemK akhi making takfeer on a person whose asal is islam, requires an expert on matter. We as layman can not make takfeer and call anyone murtad unless a qualified individual has not declared them as murtad.

[@FoeNemK]

@@tahanafis4970 akhi who can be more qualified than Allah subahanu wa taa'la Himself who said in quran 5:44 "Those who do not judge by what Allah has revelad then it is those who are the disbelievers "

[@tahanafis4970]

@FoeNemK akhi kareem, takfeer is no joke. Read fiqh on it. No where it's written that layman can make takfeer freely on whoever he thinks is a kaafir. There are conditions of takfeer. Probably better thing would be to find a good scholar irl or on Internet, and ask for more detail.

[@Al-AminAlfaki]

Alhamdulillah

[@Soroush.73]

❤

[@FoeNemK]

Sheikh uthman i really hope youre not a murji'ah or a madkhali,ive been really liking you up until now and still subscribed to you so PLEASE DONT LET ME DOWN!!! PLEASE

[@SoulsLikeMe]

May Allah guide you.

[@ymi6945]

So following the Sunnah makes one a Muriji🫠. - Only khawarij that make takfeer on Sins or Major Sins (that don’t take one out of Islam). Learn your religion from trusted sources, get of social media. This speach or thought of yours shows the lack of knowledge and misinformation in our Ummah today. We are sounded with people following their desires.

[@zoub2237]

The Prophet (صلى الله عليه وسلم) said: "There will be leaders who will not be led by my guidance and who will not adopt my ways? There will be among them men who will have the hearts of devils in the bodies of human beings. I said: What should I do. Messenger of Allah, if I (happen) to live in that time? He replied: You will listen to the Amir and carry out his orders; even if your back is flogged and your wealth is snatched, you should listen and obey." (Sahih Muslim) So according to you, the Prophet was a murji or madkhali?

[@FoeNemK]

@@zoub2237 that was about oppressive rulers ,who oppress but DID NOT COMMIT KUFR and therefore are still Muslims

[@FoeNemK]

@@ymi6945 he might be murji if he's short in making takfir of murtaddin,thats the definition of a murjiah,like today's taliban

[@MostRightWingManInBritain]

TL:DR If it’s a just criticism speak out about it but if it’s an honest mistake don’t go in too hard If it’s ignorance or if they’re intentionally doing it you must be harsh

[@Šuki-z4c]

That’s not at all a what the video said. For anyone reading this, watch the video. It’s literally 3:21. The sheikh explains nicely Allahuma barik.

[@MostRightWingManInBritain]

@@Šuki-z4c I see what you did there

[@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543]

The scholars are soppose to advice the ruIers in private. Think of the 2 Umars. Umar ibn Abdul Aziz distributed zakat and no one was their to take. Umar Radiyallahu anhu delt with a famine and Iifted a ruIe but Umar was better. Point is ruIers and scholars hear complaints and try to help ppl we don't and may consider things we don't, not all the time but sometimes. Constant fighting over ruIers Ieads to fights in reaI Iife and this is not sunna, I've seen ppl even fight over soccer unfortunately.

[@FoeNemK]

If you ask sheikh ahmed musa jibril May Allah protect him this question you can see how his response is strict and straight to the point! Different than how sheikh uthman answered it

[@goldschool3077]

Which video?

[@FoeNemK]

@goldschool3077 all of his videos ,go to the channel "global message" you'll see a alot of videos talking about that

[@FoeNemK]

@goldschool3077 it won't even let share his videos,you have to access it yourself that's another difference between uthman and ahmed musa jibril May Allah protect him

[@ymi6945]

He is of the khawarij. That’s why his answer is different. - His answer not based on the Sunnah, but pure desires. If you’ve studied basic Aqeedah, you would learn this. The prophet ﷺ even said in a Hadith that if the ruler didn’t give us our right, we have to still give him his right and ‎الله will take him to account. - Allowing Party’s in Riyadh is not Kufur (It’s a sin, but khawarij make takfeer on it). - leader having Zina every night with a prostitute is not kuffur. - Having talks with certain countries is not kuffur. - And so on.. May ‎الله guide the Muslims leaders, even if I don’t agree with their actions. They are not Kafirs, unless proven otherwise. Go through the nullifiers of Islam with the real scholars. If you know Arabic , you can find Sheik Utheymeen, Ibn Baz and Albani. All with clear speech and knowledge regarding this. Only deviant sects and khawarij that make takfeer on sins or major sins (That don’t lead to kuffur). May ‎الله guide us all to follow the Quran and the sunnah of the prophet (ﷺ)

[@aosaleh97]

Mny other shayukh warned against his rebellious ideology. May Allah guide him.

[@FoeNemK]

Where you from in pakistan,are the rulers of pakistan disbelievers yes or no?

[@FoeNemK]

Uthman can you adress these comments? Maybe hes ignoring it cause he does not want to lose supporters idk.

[@FoeNemK]

Wait so the rulers of saudi arabia for exmaoke are not kafir??? Answer my question .He went around the issue and you dont have to be alim to make takfir of someone if its obvious that he commits kufr

[@ymi6945]

They are not Disbelievers. - Also a layperson can’t go into making takfeer. Mbs is not a kafir. Study this religion kid. 2-3 Videos of a Khawarij don’t give you permission to go and spread Batil (Falsehood).

[@zoub2237]

​@@ymi6945avoid him brother. He is a takfeeri. He does not know the danger of what he is doing. If these persons are not kaafir, he will be considered a kaafir according to the hadith of the prophet. May Allah guide him.

[@FoeNemK]

@ymi6945 you need to the study the religion. Quran 5:44 "Whoever does not judge by what Allah has revelaed then it those who are the disbelivers". So how mbs is not a kafir? And Whoever fails to make takfir of them and fails to call them what Allah called them then they are disbelivers as well.no need to be a shaykh to make takfir when there's a clear cut proof.just like I don't to be a shaykh to make takfir of ahlul kitab

[@FoeNemK]

@ymi6945 notice how you call shaykh ahmed musa jibril a khariji, yet you can not specifically explain how..I pay attention to those things

[@FoeNemK]

@@ymi6945 quran 5:44 "whoever does not judge by what Allah has revelaed then it is those who are the disbelievers "

[@CNGRYDER]

Im sorry but stick to comparative religion and bible bashing. You clerly dont know how politics works.

[@ShaykhUthmanQA]

And you clearly can't spell, my dear brother. Admin

[@CNGRYDER]

@ShaykhUthmanQA that's fine my brother, long as you get the point. 👍

[@yahyamohamoud7290]

this is firstly religion before it is politics

[@CNGRYDER]

@@yahyamohamoud7290 no it's a way of life that deals with all aspects of life. Don't relegate us to a merely a religion.

[@CNGRYDER]

@@yahyamohamoud7290 no it's one comprehensive deen. Separation is secularism.

[@israrahmed7774]

Just stick to street Da'wah bro. Don't dabble in things that you clearly cannot comment on objectively and conscientiously.

[@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543]

Like you the internet 3lim? If you give advice implying he is wrong at least give Quran and hadith.