Blurring Lines between History & Mythology | Arth - A Culture Fest 2023.

[@rtprtprtprtp]

Arth badly needs to work on their videos. Terrific discussions - but poor reach. The thumbnails tell nothing about who all the speakers are. Just an image of one of the panelist speaking. Themselves to blame perhaps.

[@ajaypalsinghbhati693]

Yeah damn true brother.

[@bvishwas99]

They dont care..most of the people hired by them are leftist..

[@ajaypalsinghbhati693]

@@bvishwas99 make sense! RWs hiring leftist lol

[@roughkernel324]

RW guys are mostly incels who will fap to random women who speak anything on hinduism. So they put her on thumbnail to attract them, but failed pathetically lol!

[@hemendrasharma]

+1

[@adhikaralasomashekar3503]

MAHABHARATA-UNRAVELLED is truly a remarkable book by Ami Ganatra Ji. 🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@A.Aa..]

The way Ami ji explain things is just awesome.. so easy to understand 👏

[@crypton_8l87]

In fact if history was taught today in Katha form, it would actually have much more appeal and retention!! Amit Ganatra is a brilliant gem!!

[@adityatapi7513]

Arth - Being so vibrant platform for vivid discussion on almost all topics, it's reach is shocking. Views have to 100 times more than the actual minimum.

[@chandra_himanshu]

Only 23 comments. That's shows the interest of this generation to know about our own culture and literature.

[@kalebj7001]

No ones interested in mythology these days.. make it into a movie like Brahmastra people will start Boycott trends and also watch it large numbers

[@TP.marshall]

Ami ji is the best person to talk about Mahabharat and Ramayan She is well read Genius 🙏🏻

[@ajaymehndiratta2736]

This was one of the best discussions in this time's festival. Please do shorts out of it and release on your channel..and work on advertising please!

[@arihantjain8347]

I want to blow my head in the wall, such terrific conversation, such less reach..

[@vpatel7437]

Thank You for such a great platform, where topics are well-chosen and a very relevant panel is invited !!

[@akshu_p8230]

Kindly use ' scripture' word instated of mythology, this can make big change

[@morderncombat7903]

Great video, nice, I am buying your books and looking forward to more works in this genre

[@nitinnimkar1654]

One Correction needs to be made in Ashwin Sanghis' statement "Narhari Acharya's research" came out with a particular celestial position. The work is not done by Narhari Acharya but Nilesh Oak. It was first proposed by Mr. Vartak but further researched by Nilesh. The incidence Ashwinji is talking about, is Rishi Vyas meeting Dhritarashtra & telling him about Arundhati Vashistha phenomenon. It's all explained in Nilesh Oak's videos on KZbin. One can search for Nilesh Oak's videos on youtube.😀

[@kavitha5698]

Thank you for sharing this discussion. There are so many Vidwans who have spent lifetime on our scriptures like Shathavadhani Ganesh, who can add much more meaningful insights to such subjects. It was pleasure listening to Ami ji. Also, Thanks for calling in Author Ashwin who clarified his position, that he is more a fiction writer and neither a historian nor a Vidwan. This is important because as Ami ji said people may take these fictions to be the truth, while it also has a positive side-effect that these may create more interests towards the original texts.

[@uvg319]

I missed this 😲...wish I had known. Would have loved to speak with these panelists!

[@Divineeternalbliss]

Ami Ganatra is a genius in Knowledge of Vedas. She knows Ramayan and Mahabharata by heart.

[@akshu_p8230]

Time should be more of interview, both leaders talking facts and sharing knowledge, but got thought interviewer cutted down conversations

[@sureshkpuppala]

The epics which are written to inspire the generations to come and struggle for the truth shall not be messed with creativity crap. They do their fantasy stories leaving the ideals in those epics, as many story tellers tell these as truth, some insert their creativity for their selfish ends. Which destroys whole purpose of Rama and Krishna.

[@rvind000]

Amazing Ami 🌼

[@prasad7553]

For invaders and their Stooges, what all good about Hindus is myth. But truth cannot be hidden for long. Great work done by R C Majumdar and others is being carried forward by young researchers .

[@gajendrabhardwaj7851]

🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼

[@girijanarayan6974]

If this guy knows nothing why did you get him here?! His view has no value

[@MS-ov9sv]

Ami ji is amazing researcher

[@lakshyavarshney9942]

She is giving the points

[@avni5020]

What about the meaning of Dusshashan?

[@adityadey9029]

Organizers, could you please clarify that if Shri Arjun Singh Kadian is a pilot by profession?

[@lakshyavarshney9942]

These ppl are better than overprogressives , modernists, so called dynamic etc i want the freedon from the latter

[@unteck7023]

Director of Arth "Vikram Sampath". Till now he didn't come in single clip.

[@happiness16575]

There is need of awareness between sanatan dharma history , Christian mythology and Islamic mythology.

[@kalebj7001]

All are mythology only.. humans been making gods and goddesses for thousands of years from Upper Paleolithic period..

[@venkateshkannan5]

that lady have facts at finger tip

[@mudrarakshasa]

Sabha me baithte samay aise pair par pair rakh ke nahi baithte..ye ashisht hai aur shastra charcha aise hoti nahi.. angreaonke fhanng me shastra charcha karna kitna uchit hai

[@jinmuwon1108]

Faila hua aadmi, Is irritating

[@SK-rp9hu]

pit this goggled pappu part 2 in front of Advocate Sai Deep,,he will regret why he survived until that day😝🤬🤬🤬

[@kalebj7001]

Advocate? Why not some archeologist or historian.. why use Advocates here? This is not that line of profession.. let's not bring people are not from that expertise

[@lakshyavarshney9942]

@@kalebj7001 yes but most your historians are biased to the core

[@kalebj7001]

@@lakshyavarshney9942 I'd rather have surgery done by a surgeon than an engineer 🙄 we need to bring people from their academic expertise.. if not than anyone can be giving free gyan

[@lakshyavarshney9942]

@@kalebj7001 j sai deepak dosent give free gyan and what more do you exactly want him to do?

[@kalebj7001]

@@lakshyavarshney9942 what's his academic expertise? Anthropologist? Historian? ... How can we infer from an advocate if he's not using historical research based sources and analysis? Will u go to a mechanical engineer if u have to do an operation on ur heart? Or would go to a Cardiac surgeon? Academic expertise is important if we want to know about the subject in detail and with research based knowledge.. otherwise anyone can give free gyan

[@rexxbailey2764]

FIRST OF ALL THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS " MYTHOLOGY " IN ANYTHING INDIAN! THERES ONLY HISTORY! 😑😒

[@dineshkumarsanatani2104]

Myth bolne walo ki thattri