Arthur should have married Mary-Beth in rdr2 (Mary-Beth romantic cut-scene)

[@YOUSCA113]

It would've also connected perfectly with the Mary-Beth side mission in the Epilogue

[@terraintactician]

True that!

[@KS-ke7xl]

MaryBeth dances with Arther at Sean’s rescue party. When Dutch and Molly are dancing talk to MaryBeth and she’ll ask to dance.

[@terraintactician]

Awesome!

[@fadhilanansyah3005]

damn i miss that bro, can i dance again in another event?

[@hankthegamerkid3463]

no​@@fadhilanansyah3005

[@unclebuns5286]

@@fadhilanansyah3005I think you can dance with her again when you take jack home in chapter 4 Edit: I might be wrong tho

[@YukiPyro]

Before she asks Arthur to dance she just turned down Micah who asked her to dance.

[@charlespc]

Man, Mary-beth was too cute for a Van Der Linde gang member

[@zaidan.444]

That's probably what mary linton family says about arthur

[@terraintactician]

Right!

[@charlespc]

@@zaidan.444 Hahaha. But he was a grown man at that time. Mary Beth Is 21 at least (one of the youngest in the gang not counting Jack).

[@kj4920]

Well she basically was just tagging along. At the lake camp if you catch Sean with a stagecoach robbery you can get more of her backstory cuz she joins in.

[@SeriousDragonify]

Cute? You ignorantly are thinking about her with your 3rd leg... You're a perv.

[@My6119]

I completely forgot she also says "Oh, Arthur." Along side Abigail and of course Mary.

[@saadisso6856]

awh arthuuh

[@isaacthompson4915]

Mary beth simply lost out because his loyalty to Dutch above all and his heart still holding out for Mary

[@sankalpchoubey6629]

Arthur: i keep killing animal needlesly Me: i gotta make that legend of east sachel and don't worry about animals. They just respawn 😂😂

[@lisvender]

It always bugged me that Arthur says that. Those were food for the camp!

[@RedWingsninetyone]

​@@lisvenderI think there's reference to players killing or running over animals in game for no reason too

[@baneofbanes]

@@RedWingsninetyonebruh sometimes those animals will purposefully jump out in front of my horse it isn’t my fault dammit

[@Rita_Morgan]

How cool it would be to switch to play as Mary Beth at this moment and give Arthur boah big warm hug 😢

[@terraintactician]

That would've been awesome!

[@godzillazfriction]

so superficial.

[@Jon14141]

@@godzillazfriction10 minutes ago you comment this bro 💓

[@Thomas_Angelo]

This just makes me realize how much of a sad life Dutch's gang provided Jack with.

[@jaydavis7122]

Arthur and Mary Beth would have made a great couple 👍 .

[@terraintactician]

I wholeheartedly agree!

[@Ari28basketball]

Arthur is 36 Mary is 21 I wouldn't think so

[@Revitalization4241]

​@@Ari28basketballVery normal age gaps during those days

[@SaifKhagan]

​@@Ari28basketball What's wrong with that. A mature man and a mature woman. End of.

[@TaeTae_08]

Ehhh shes way too young (20-22) and their relationship was always shown as platonic. She was just someone arthur felt comfortable sharing to every now and then

[@terraintactician]

I feel like Mary-beth possessed romantic feelings towards Arthur, rather it is Arthur who suppressed and made the relationship platonic.

[@gergopiroska5749]

Back then it was normal to marry even underage girls let alone a 22 years old Hell look at the age gap between Dutch and Molly

[@kj4920]

She's 20 something and arthur is 36 given she's the main one seeing about him it makes sense.

[@JOHNMARSTONmemes]

Hate to be the nerd but young girls used to marry old civil war veterans back in the day

[@godzillazfriction]

​@@gergopiroska5749there's no such thing as 'normal'... also, the initial post is very superficial & modernistic within a subdivision of values, & a set of beliefs.

[@Ra-NiMechagodzilla702]

aside from the occasional conversation and dance, they never show any romantic interest in each other.

[@flrn6233]

When you try to interact with Mary Beth repeatedly, the camp start yelling at you "Leave her alone"... I mean, she's an adult

[@terraintactician]

Lol, did you antagonize her repeatedly?

[@Jon14141]

@@terraintacticianLmao busted

[@tuipedroso6169]

He should have married Sadie

[@ReelGuyTv]

In my dialog with her author also confesses to needlessly killing people.

[@Jon14141]

Mary Beth, albeit a video game character aha, was stunning

[@AdityaRaj272.]

"Our time has passed, Jhon" -Dutch Van Der Linde, 1911 0:33

[@Jemandes_Liebe]

Я девушка, и мне с 22 лет нравится Артур Морган, так что Мэри тоже наверняка могла бы его полюбить, если бы он захотел..

[@GrinGrim87]

This isn't a romantic scene. Lord, help us. You can literally talk to all three women and Arthur shows no signs of being interested in any woman romantically BUT Mary Linton. People need to stop coping and realize this

[@scorpion6328]

You’d be amazed how lonely the average gamer is. They’ll see a man and a woman having a simple conversation and blindly assume they’ll be having babies in no time.

[@GrinGrim87]

@@scorpion6328 Seems like it. Damn shame

[@inkax]

shes way too young and arthur was never interested in her

[@SaifKhagan]

That's a mature man and woman. Your point makes no sense.

[@inkax]

@@SaifKhagan youre a creep, pls go touch grass

[@godzillazfriction]

as if Arthur didn't go out with a 15 year old Eliza... im so tired of this indoctrinated & polarized set of beliefs, & values based off of Modernism.

[@godzillazfriction]

​@@SaifKhagan'mature, immature, childish, manchild' is all BS...

[@inkax]

@@godzillazfriction arthurs and elizas age gap was never clarified, your pulling this out of nowhere. also just because we have different views on age gaps rn, doesnt mean they are justified in the 19th century. arthur wasnt a creep, he saw the women in camp as his sisters, even if mary beth couldve a crush on him. please check yourself and the women in your environment, because they sure as hell dont feel save around you

[@Lilycheezistpanda]

I had a dream that Arthur kept trying to flirt with Mary-Beth

[@kenward12-1]

I’m just know that there’s 2 Mary when Arthur Live

[@liamwalton3469]

Arthur should of dated Mary-Beth, it was sad they gave him Tuberculosis, Hosea deserved to survive as did Lenny and Sean too him and Karen made a good couple, Kieran Duffy deserved to survive too, Molly O’Shea deserved better as well and should of been the one to expose Micah as a traitor, Jenny Kirk should of been in the game giving Lenny a love interest too with us finding out she’s alive along with Sean and rescuing the both of them, all of them would of sided with Arthur when he exposed Micah as the traitor giving the Pinkerton’s information Saving Susan’s life in the process and the gang disbanding with the ones who sided with Micah leaving with him to avoid a shootout between his group and Arthur’s. Winton Holmes should of survived too with us rescuing him from the approaching White cougar and slaying it together with Winton selling the pelt to repay his loan to Strauss and been recruited into the gang by Arthur, we should had a side quest where we have to rescue Arthur Londonderry, a miner and another person in debt to Strauss from a collapsed mine. Expanding the game with an extra mission to rescue Strauss from the Pinkertons would have been a good idea too. Arthur should have absolved Thomas Downes debt and not gone near him the second it was discovered Thomas had TB saving his own life in the process. The game would of been a lot better and could of had Arthur still going after Micah killing Cleet and Joe in the process before taking out Micah once and for all after Dutch abandons them both and Arthur not hindered by TB with Arthur’s group helping John get his ranch set up in Beecher’s hope and celebrating John’s and Abigail’s wedding before Charles and Sadie leave together becoming Bounty hunters, Tilly leaving and still having the same epilogue and mentioning that she still sees Mary Beth, Arthur, Karen and Sean in a letter to John. Sean and Karen leaving but later returning and joining the Marston ranch. Lenny and Jenny Kirk leaving and building a farm close by with Kieran Duffy and Molly O’Shea joining them. Mary-Beth still having the same epilogue of becoming a writer under the pen name of Leslie DuPont and later marrying Arthur. Susan and Hosea leaving and opening a hotel together with Strauss as their bookkeeper. Pearson and Trelawney still getting the same epilogue along with Swanson. Winton Holmes joining the Marston Ranch as a ranch hand. Then in the other game with John Marston as the protagonist we capture Javier Escuella with us instead faking his death and allying with our former friend in and redeeming Bill Williamson with Javier’s help with the 2 renouncing their bandit ways and aiding John in rescuing Jack and Abigail from Edgar Ross and his men killing them all in the process with Jack and Abigail being shocked to see Javier and Bill alongside John with them setting the building on fire so that it looks like Ross and his men died in an accident. With Javier and Bill free to begin a new life with them heading to the Marston Ranch to celebrate and being reunited with Sean and Karen too at the Ranch

[@Avapxla]

A perfect match

[@DannyNitrouz]

This the only mary arthur needed!

[@CallMeShabah]

bruh Arthur is like Mary Beth's father

[@terraintactician]

lol nooh!

[@inkax]

@@terraintacticianyes

[@secondchance6603]

@@inkax No. Arthur is around 36, Mary is in her early to mid 20's.

[@splashnskillz37]

@@secondchance6603 Nah he's around 40

[@secondchance6603]

@@splashnskillz37 copy and paste this into your search bar and tell me the general consensus is that he isn't 36: How old is Arthur Morgan in the game Red Dead Redemption

[@normalplayer7377]

Definitely

[@FrankMartorana-vh1ot]

I’m still not convinced that’s not Mary-beth in the Valentine hotel bathing Arthur… She wanted it

[@1632Chitty]

I always thought that too