The fact that binnie’s pic is here means so much to me I’m just bawling my eyes out right now 🥺😭💜
@KRMx1010 ай бұрын
You and me both 🥺🥺 I honestly still cry most days. I miss my BinnieBoo so much 😭😭💔
@ThaoLe-js8hb10 ай бұрын
Even though tears don’t run daily, but tears haven’t stop. Can’t bare to watch Binnie video miss him so much 😢😢😢
@ПоляМомчилова2 ай бұрын
Moonbin always will be part of Astro and the members will continue forward keeping him in their memories and hearts.
@cklg8810 ай бұрын
Thank you for keeping Binnie in the group pics. The song is about their undying friendship that broke apart and their minds are going in circles of what happened and they will meet again. Heartbreaking 💔 Keep Binnie alive PLEASE 😭💔😪🌙🌹💔 we all love you Astro.
@lightlight863310 ай бұрын
It's so comforting that Binnie is still "with" them💜 You're so thoughtful. My heartfelt thanks 💜
@marielcuriel64310 ай бұрын
Que hermosa canción, ASTRO FOREVER🎉🎉🎉
@tipaniwhuat10 ай бұрын
Moonbins presence is evidently still being kept alive by his beloved brothers, undying love and respect for their brother 😢😢❤ beautifully written
@chuchaymeme926610 ай бұрын
😢"CIRCLES" SPEAKS A LOT, it simply explains the unsaid thoughts of OUR BOYS throughout their journey😢
@leot186410 ай бұрын
Astro is one of the first groups I stanned and Moonbin was my bias. It still feels unreal that he's not with us anymore but whenever I look at the moon I know he's in peace and not hurting anymore.
@eerye7010 ай бұрын
It's so hard to see Astro without our angel there. So to see his face is so nice. I pray the group is doing OK and that this song is therapeutic for them.
@fatimatamer38010 ай бұрын
It's hurt seeing no color coming towards moonbin 🥺💔😖Love you moonbin 🥺❤
@하태희-s4k10 ай бұрын
빈이 사진이 있어서 너무 좋다..❤
@aly_romero10 ай бұрын
Binnie, I miss you. Your brothers are doing a good job, the arohas are very proud of all of you. Binnie continues to shine as he has done so far. That we'll always be together 😭💜🥺
@tsurugayuna773110 ай бұрын
I miss the old day's. I miss my binnie so much. Just hoping the Astro always be happy and healthy. Hearing this song made me feel empty yet comfort. Thank u for the song jinjin...
@gwenmloveskpopandmore10 ай бұрын
He’s the moon now so if u miss him just look to see the moon and he’s the brightest shining star in the sky too
@EnhalogyStay10 ай бұрын
Moonbin 🥹🫶🏻💗
@_a.r.m.y_bts_162210 ай бұрын
❤❤❤❤❤
@esmerferrer528110 ай бұрын
I'm happy that they still included Moon Bin picture
@user-ri6cj4wq7b10 ай бұрын
thanks so much for keeping Binnie’s photo here…😢
@karlitanenita10 ай бұрын
Omg thank you for putting Binnie's picture here 🥺🥺🥺 I'm crying 😭💜
@ederlynlim359910 ай бұрын
❤my heart melted and happy to see moonbin picture with them❤moonbin forever❤
@llov..10 ай бұрын
Ангел Бини🥺
@arleneromana217810 ай бұрын
Happy to watch and listen to you Astro but with a heavy heart when i think Moonbin is not here anymore, we just miss him so much. Thank you for always including Binnie in the picture. I wish you all well❤
@SabrinaGalassi10 ай бұрын
È bellissima ,siete grandi . Grazie per aver messo anche la foto di Moonbin. Continuate così ,vi auguro tutto il bene del mondo.❤❤❤🎉🎉😊💖💖💖💖💖💖💖
@deepshadow.2410 ай бұрын
謝謝您,這麼用心的製作MV,還有彬尼的照片,彷彿他從未離開...
@_a.r.m.y_bts_162210 ай бұрын
I agree with you! Binnie's photo was very touching to me...😢😭❤️🩹
@allinaxxxx6610 ай бұрын
He has never left...🖤😔
@KathrynJones-c9c10 ай бұрын
8 years. ❤❤❤.I can hardly see to type. So beautiful and poignant. So clear how loved Moonbin was, and still is, and how much he is missed. We all still feel his loss and the Astro boys have done him proud. ❤❤❤😢😢😢
@Felix97-s6b10 ай бұрын
I Love u so much My Boys, ASTRO 8th Anniversary. Thank you For your Present Circles Song.
@IwonaChojnacka-m8h10 ай бұрын
Jesteście cudowni, pięknie. Kocham Was ❤❤❤❤❤❤Binnie 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢,Saranghae
@floranavarro520310 ай бұрын
I miss moonbin❤...
@semidash10 ай бұрын
Me too ❤
@azucenaquiroz81210 ай бұрын
Es una fortuna que hayan sacado una nueva canción lo más triste es que Moonbin ya no está en este plano terrenal Dios quiera que que siga ASTRO con su carrera así como paso con SHEENE lo mismo paso y en la actualidad es un grupo con mucho éxito así astro no ha perdido vigencia ❤ rest in peace Dear MOONBIN 😢✨💫🇲🇽🇰🇷 éxito querido ASTRO Aroha los amamos 💜💜💜💜
@trinidadvsanchezsosa852610 ай бұрын
Woow que hermosa canción con sus increíbles voces, es un regalo verlos juntos otra vez y siempre que está Nunu con sus hermanos es feliz éso me llena de alegría, gracias por poner la letra para poder cantarla que Dios los bendiga y que tengan muchos años más juntos ❤❤❤❤❤
@teresarowe86909 ай бұрын
Amazing lyrics and great depth of emotions, remembering MoonBin in this, a great anniversary song, JinJin is a very underestimated lyricist and not recognised for his abilities in his writing ability and what he has produced, he doesn't get enough credit in my honest opinion, love this and well done gentlemen xx
@liezelfabello914210 ай бұрын
Astro never disappoint ♡♡♡♡♡♡
@damytaylor816810 ай бұрын
It’s heartbreaking, I can’t help it 😢almost a year I’m crying every day 😭
@bsong2110 ай бұрын
Ooowww 🥹 So much appreciated to include Binnie's pic 🩵 Thank you for the translation too! Sending love to ROHA around the world 💫
@sweetcalinestar10 ай бұрын
I'd appreciate your kind to put such a beautiful picture. Binnie staying with them means a lot for me for arohas. I can imagine and hear Binnie’s voice behind the sweet song. Thank you so much.
@МарияМоисеева-ш9ш10 ай бұрын
❤Мунбин❤ навсегда с ASTRO
@문로하-r6f10 ай бұрын
빈아너무너무사랑해 고마워 내심장빈 오늘도 우린함께야 🙏🫶🏻💚
@ГалинаНовикова-и8щ10 ай бұрын
Вы согревает нас теплом своих песен, а постараемся согревать ваши сердца своим ожиданием вас.
@elenamartinez144510 ай бұрын
mi hermoso Bin me faltas tu ,me falta todo😞😭💔
@semidash10 ай бұрын
Same here. It's just wrong without him
@mldejonge10 ай бұрын
Moonbin...always a part of Astro 💜💜💜
@elenazzza10 ай бұрын
Astro and Aroha forever 💜Moonbin is missed, but he is forever in our hearts❤️
@nancybates658510 ай бұрын
Awesome song! So very happy Astro is continuing their music. Moonbin's voice is certainly noticably absent. However, MJ, JinJin, Nuni, and Sanha have produced an incredible new piece of music in spite of his sad absence. I'm so sad, yet I am proud they have not given up on Astro, Aroha, and their dreams. Well done, Astro. I dare say you've made Moonbin proud! ❤❤❤❤ ❤
@Lalocasoyyo10 ай бұрын
I love the fact that you put a picture Binnie that was so beautiful and got me about to cry in school this has so much meaning to me
@marinadebrazil10 ай бұрын
Went through this mv hoping to see binnie’s image gets the color😭😭😭it’s so hard but so nice to see him still there
@vaneyeon256810 ай бұрын
Feel like he still alive.
@뿌우우웅-l3s10 ай бұрын
빈이가 같이 있는 아스트로…. 눈물이 멈추질 않네요 영상만들어주셔서 정말 감사합니다💜 아스트로 사랑해!!!
@zshllebbcgyj521510 ай бұрын
I'm happy it's finally out. But it hurts to not be able to hear binnie's voice anymore.It really hurts. I hope binnie is fine wherever he is. May Allah keep him in peace in sha Allah. Love for you all ❤
@김다애-f9n10 ай бұрын
감사합니다 너무 감사합니다.. 진짜..
@НаталияМещерякова-т4у10 ай бұрын
С Юбилеем Вас🎉🎉🎉 Вы молодцы ,очень красивая песня 🎉🎉🎉 крепкого здоровья, творческих успехов,счастья и любви ❤❤❤
@rosss967110 ай бұрын
Feliz aniversario 💜!!para astro, ✡️ hermoso el vínculo de hermandad tan profundo entre ustedes y 🥹🌙 Moonbin 💜✡️.Forever ASTRO !!!
@villanuevaannamarie0010 ай бұрын
Hear there angel voices again is so much mean to me🥹🥰. missing them together at stage🥰🥹
@SusanCresswell-x3n10 ай бұрын
Its such a heart warming song about true friendship that never ends. The words are very meaningful. Really like the song. Friendship forever.
Es cm que fuese a escuchar la voz d Bin en cualq momento. Dios como duele la ausencia ...nunc se t olvidará nunca lunita
@rosaliel.278710 ай бұрын
Moonbin will always be part of Astro. So happy to see his picure amongst the others. ❤
@conniecadelina392210 ай бұрын
It hurts that Moonbin is not with them but happy that they are trying to move on. Be strong Astro!
@MB_012610 ай бұрын
8주년 축하해,너무 너무 보고 싶어~아스트로 화이팅💜
@mahlykamage632410 ай бұрын
Eunwoo's voice is different again! So high ... 😮
@caseycoleman39410 ай бұрын
That is a beautiful gesture that you put Moonbin in there🥲. I love the song. It is filled with so much love for him.
@rubesg842510 ай бұрын
Moonbin🥺🥺
@eloisabento96608 ай бұрын
Eu amo essa musica... MJ e Jin Jin no video dela demonstram a preocupação e carinho por meu querido, lindo e amado Sanha e por Eun woo. Aliás a voz de MJ é bem marcante.
@lindajennings291910 ай бұрын
Felicidades por la hermosa letra y por su amistad eterna.👏👏👏💕💕💕
@kibtitle110 ай бұрын
thank you so much Bin still with them 😭 thank you for make this song very fast 💜
@BonnieBonnie1810 ай бұрын
Miss you Moonbin !🫰🙆💐🙏
@AROHA_ASTRO151710 ай бұрын
Los amo ASTRO _AROHA FOREVER 💜🔯💜🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶
@AngieCello10 ай бұрын
Se comprimió mi corazón al ver la foto de Binnie, sentí por un momento que ya había despertado de esta horrible pesadilla que ya duró un año 🖤🌙😔🌌 Binnie te extraño, sigo pensando y esperando a despertar donde tú estás.
@laurasegovia184210 ай бұрын
Bello regalo de 8 aniversario gracias astro ❤
@keylinmarroquin-ok4vq10 ай бұрын
Te amo astro eres muy especial en mi vida y solo quiero que sean felices y sus sueños se hagan realidad y esa será mi mayor felicidad ❤❤❤❤
@Lindseythemii10 ай бұрын
I admittedly was disappointed JinJin didn't have a lot of vocal parts (if any; I honestly couldn't tell) in this song like in their all-vocal and no-rap song Footprint (among other songs), but here is to hoping he will get to actually sing more in future songs, with Footprint being proof that his vocals have certainly been improving. I too believe in him
@sandraaliciacisnerosbelt-cs5xm10 ай бұрын
💜💜💜Gracias ASTRO💜💜💜
@yennissanchezsoto265210 ай бұрын
Falta binni 😢 y Rocky... Los extraño demasiado 😔
@caroarias344710 ай бұрын
Hermoso.. Está canción si que se va a quedar grabada en mi corazón.
@ginaeldridge380610 ай бұрын
Such a beautiful song. You can feel the emotions they all put into singing it❤❤
@Kaee_zz7 ай бұрын
Just the picture of Moonbin being here means a lot, but even tho Rocky is still alive he should have been there too. He used to be part of Astro and in a way will always be. Like Moonbin.
@Lindseythemii6 ай бұрын
"even tho Rocky is _still alive"?_ you mean "even tho(ugh) Rocky *left".* while I admittedly too find it weird (and funny) not seeing Park Minhyuk's picture along the other guys, having left the band last year officially made him _no longer a member,_ the uploader of whom did the right thing not putting him there
@pumkin690910 ай бұрын
So proud of them.
@Nora6_810 ай бұрын
omg! binnie 🥹
@lovepeacefreedom352810 ай бұрын
This song made my day💖
@ГульнісаМінакова10 ай бұрын
❤❤❤❤❤❤спасибо за подобную картинку, где видно кто исполеяет часть музыкальной композиции ❤❤❤😂
@vikktorianwankaegooboro845410 ай бұрын
I love you so much Astro and even you moonbin
@deloreswheeler10 ай бұрын
BINNY MUCH LOVE❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
@Ancnhanan10 ай бұрын
Thankyou for put moonbin in here 😢
@penialvarez99577 ай бұрын
No sabéis cómo me alegro mucho ver a moonbin,el ya no está pero el dejo una huella muy grande y profunda no será olvidado 😭😭😭😭😭😭🫂🇪🇦💜💜💜💜💜
@MariaGonzalez-bn4ug10 ай бұрын
This is my new favorite song of Astro. OMG!!😮 It made me cry. Love these boys❤❤❤❤💜🤍
@PandorasArtBox10 ай бұрын
I wasnt even planning to come here, just scrolling through my feed, but I got really emotional when I noticed you kept Moonbin in the group pictures. Thank you. 💛🫰🏽
@0ff_rr75510 ай бұрын
감사합니다💜
@idaliacampos7910 ай бұрын
Glückwunsch zu 8 Aniversario 🎉🎉 und Dankeschön für das überraschende Lied ❤🥰 euren stimme sind Strahlung von Freude für meiner Seele 💜🫶🏼 ✡️ Jinjin ✡️ Sahna ✡️ Mj ✡️Cha-únu 🌠 Binni AROHAS alles gute zum Jubiläum 💜💜💜 Gott Segnet unseren Jungs 👏🏻
@jjjjjjjjjjjj70910 ай бұрын
ASTRO 6 FOREVER💜💜💜💜💜💜🌙rocky from astro forever
@fuji_saku10 ай бұрын
✡️ASTRO 사랑해💜
@qokkami10 ай бұрын
thank you for adding moonbin
@gwenmloveskpopandmore10 ай бұрын
Remember moonbin isn’t truly gone ❤ he’s just no longer on earth 🌝
@CDiaz_AROHA10 ай бұрын
My heart fel take Astro forever love you Sanha❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
@margariteoyler10 ай бұрын
I'm so thankful Binnie was included, but in my opinion, Rocky should have been included in this as well. His contributions to Astro were immense, and to not include him just seems wrong to me. Just my opinion. Thank you for the video...
@nelliemar014310 ай бұрын
I think it was a talk if Rocky was going to renew his contract or not. He had his reasons but maybe he wanted to go his own path. I adore Rocky and I was disheartened of him not renewing for Astro however, there could have been some complication’s behind the scenes or delays of any promotions.
@user-so2jw6px7b10 ай бұрын
정말 너무 감사합니다🥹 아스트로 영원하자💜
@feahsalta743410 ай бұрын
We miss you ON STAGE❤❤ASTRO ✡
@rosss967110 ай бұрын
Increíble ✡️💜✨🇲🇽✨!!!!
@mariaglassova10 ай бұрын
Thank you ❤❤❤👍👏
@mariaelenavalencia936910 ай бұрын
FELICIDADES A **ASTRO**POR 8 DE HISTORIA***GRACIAS POR TDS SUS CANCIONES,COREOS,JUEGOS ,RISAS,PERO SOBRETODO EL AMOR QUE HAN DADO A LAS FANS Y AROHAS DE TD EL MUNDO.🙏BENDICIONES A CADA UNO Y SUS FAMILIAS, LO ESTAN HACIENDO PERFECTO 🎉🎂👏👏👏💜🇲🇽