Atheist Challenged Shamsi on Hadith! Shamsi and Visitor Speakers Corner Sam Dawah

[@maaziy_ghaziyIYI]

Shamsi's dawah style is free from Greek philosophical language. It's clear and straightforward. The Quranic logic is infinitely clearer and superior to the Greek and Western logic.

[@Quran_Alone_Dawah]

What do you mean by this?

[@ChrisBrown22082]

I think one key aspect of logic is that it is universal. As it is objectively true, the Qur'an and modern Western academic literature should be in agreement. If they aren't in agreement then you need to demonstrate why the Qur'an is in fact correct and Western academia is wrong. The Qur'an appears to contain an informal logical fallacy in Sura 4:82 "Do they not ponder about the Qur'an? Had it been from any other than Allah, they would surely have found in it much inconsistency." This implies that if a book contains only a few inconsistencies, it must have been directed by Allah. However, there are clearly many books with only a few inconsistencies or none at all that haven't been inspired by him so it is fallacious.

[@cumar9875]

​@@ChrisBrown22082do you know Arabic if don't don't make false claims

[@ChrisBrown22082]

@@cumar9875 Why is knowledge of Arabic relevant to understanding logic? Logic can be expressed in many languages. What false claim have I made?

[@scottholder4431]

@@cumar9875 We don't have to know arabic........you are wrong and mistaken.

[@alH1ndawi]

May Allah preserve brother Shamsi

[@ydmali864]

This guy seems sincere... He has asked the right questions! May God guide him to accept the truth and stay on the right path.

[@Baldeh-o4r]

Shamsi is powerful debater he is my favorite debater May Allah reward him Ameen ❤❤

[@sasha2209]

he is not debater, he is teacher and preacher

[@sbludba]

Logic better than bullshit.

[@yaseenconrad1795]

Him and Mansur is my favorite too. What do you think about Mansur.

[@sbludba]

@@yaseenconrad1795 Master tactician with logic

[@Solemn_G]

Clear and simple message. That's what I like about Shamsi.

[@pasulaymanjeng9772]

Alhamdulilah 🙏 for Islam May Allah swt bless you brother shamsi and all the brothers out there

[@AbdulrahmanAlsheikg]

بارك الله فيكم يا شيخ شمسي ونفع الله بعلمكم في نشر الدين الاسلامي الصحيح ونشر التوحيد الذي هو اساس الدين

[@wanzainwanmustafa502]

MasyaAllah Shamsi. May Allah guide forever. Amin Ya Rabb

[@ahmedadawy1238]

May Allah bless you brother shamsi

[@quranicverses.2394]

I like the way he put everything into perspective from beginning. Anyone who truly want guidance will definitely knows there a creator.

[@syedaleemuddin6804]

Say dua for this guest. He sounds very nice mashallah

[@ocelotblack310]

The speaker makes a logical argument

[@mohammednasir3110]

Mashaallah

[@ibrahimkamara3660]

Great job

[@Rayan-gm2jf]

27:47 is this for real?!! anyone here is a lipsreader besides me to translate that?

[@aleks1586]

The only hadith that matters is the ones that don't make Mohammed look bad....in other words weak and or not authenticate 🤪

[@aleks1586]

Thank you 🤪

[@dudewheresmykar7720]

​@@aleks1586If hadiths were tailored to be bias towards Mohammad PBUH, I promise you that the weak hadiths that put him in a bad light wouldn't exist at all. So your sarcastic claim isn't valid at all.

[@aleks1586]

@@dudewheresmykar7720 calm down buddy

[@salttea8926]

​@@dudewheresmykar7720subhanAllah Brother.... Now he can said to you chill brother😂😂😂., that is only he got....

[@salttea8926]

No Hadith makes Mohammad PBUH bad, the only Hadith which are weak are those which have no proper chain of Peoples through which came forward to us... If you don't know the Hadith which are weak glorify Prophet Mohammed PBUH even more than Authentic ones... 🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@scottholder4431]

Shamsi doesn't understand alcohol. Just because it can be bad, doesn't mean that it's always bad in all cases.

[@alH1ndawi]

Medical institutions even state that even "moderate" drinking is harmful. You won't get rid of the harmful elements within the alcohol itself which harm the body and mind. Why do people drink it in most cases? Not for the taste. But that it distracts them from their lives and gives them a false sense of reality and they use this mostly as a form of escapism, intention or unintentional.

[@sohaila9634]

There may be some benefits from drugs & alcohol... But the harm outweighs the good individually & collectively. This is something very noticeable in all societies across the globe.

[@scottholder4431]

@@sohaila9634 its not always harmful. Try again!

[@scottholder4431]

@@sohaila9634Your religion is lying to you and telling you it's always bad.........but it's not always bad. Your quran is just plain wrong. LMAO!

[@MohamedAli-sg2gk]

I followed your trail of comments. You are not Muslim. COME OUT YOUR SHELL! Do not cause fitnah in the Muslim ummah. You will be exposed!

[@refuse2truggle246]

Shamsi habibi please stop mentioning about your past Allahuma yabareek feek

[@Quran_Alone_Dawah]

Anyone who takes any hadith besides the ahsan al hadith, the Qur'an, is a ka fir.

[@LADavis-ih3ok]

Do you make salah, do you fast in Ramadan? Where do you get your directions from?

[@Quran_Alone_Dawah]

@LADavis-ih3ok Yes I do these things. I follow the simple instructions from my creator in the Qur'an :)

[@alH1ndawi]

​@@Quran_Alone_DawahWhoever rejects the commands of the Prophet ﷺ is a ka fir.

[@Kashif-kq3vg]

A non-muslim trying to make takfir. Hilarious

[@Quran_Alone_Dawah]

@@Kashif-kq3vg I am a Muslim. Anyone who believes that the book of Allah is not enough is a ka fir.

[@flembarbossa4834]

There are to many presumptions in Shamsi arguments. Ex what is said in the Quran is not proof but statements. And because Shami thinks The Quran is word from a God he belief and assumes that what is the The Quran is proof. That’s a fallacy.

[@momomouh115]

Try to read the Quran with an open Heart and you'll see what he sees

[@flembarbossa4834]

@@momomouh115 Now it’s you that assume i don’t read the Quran. :)

[@scottholder4431]

@@momomouh115 Well your assumption is wrong. You are assuming we haven't looked into the quran. Besides, we don't have to read the quran to know it's not from a god, we can examine the claims made by those who do believe it's from god and learn it's not from a god.

[@scottholder4431]

@@momomouh115 See? Just like I said. Flembarbossa4834 has at least read some of the quran......maybe all of it. LMAO!

[@oo6069]

Shamsi is extremely dangerous

[@abdulquadirsulaiman-p1e]

You are dangerous for talking bad about Shamsi who isn't dangerous

[@oo6069]

@@abdulquadirsulaiman-p1e to deviated muslim.

[@harryd8010]

Hadiths are full of errors 😂😂

[@kamikan7622]

what were the errors just curious

[@SuperKauser]

Please explain what errors you talking about 🤔

[@harryd8010]

@@SuperKauser there are many 😂

[@harryd8010]

That black seed cures all diseases except death. This is proven false

[@harryd8010]

@@SuperKauser According to the hadith, the embryo spends 40 days as a drop of sperm, 40 days as a clot, and then 40 days as a piece of flesh. By contrast, modern science has revealed that by day 56 the fetus is essentially a complete, though tiny, human being with all organs systems in place, and all tissues. developed 😩

[@Waseem-z4n]

Aslamalykum my brothers and sisters can anyone tell me I can communicate with brothers shamsi etc email address or contact details. Jazkhallah heir