Attack on Titan - The Rumbling WIT Studio 4K Remaster [Vogel Im Käfig]

Put your opinions aside because this edit is made for the 131 purists who believe that Vogel Im Kafig should be the OST that plays during Eren's "Freedom" speech as he massacres all of humanity outside the walls. Which one is better... original or edit?

[@Sena0069]

For me, Vogel im Kafig has something that always makes my insides stir up, i love it so much. i think the original version was good, but for me this brings up a different feeling. it makes much more obvious that the story is repeating itself, much more violent, but repeating after all...like that time the walls were blown up...

[@silentapple5923]

As much as I miss the score from the first season, The soundtrack actually used for this scene was perfect. Just the right amount of despair and horror

[@misadique845]

I disagree. It removes a lot of depth and impact from the scene when compared to the manga.

[@diroupaz5995]

​@@misadique845but the manga has no music

[@misadique845]

@@diroupaz5995 In the manga, the scene has more depth and impact because it shifts from genocide to kid Eren's dreams. It shapes a bittersweet feeling from the contrast between those two. The music in the anime makes it so that the contrast between the two is minimized, the only feeling is that of horror. It loses depth. I don't think this part of Vogel Im Kafig encapsulates this feelingg either. The edit on my channel is close to my interpretation of this scene.

[@Maisonier]

No, it sucked.

[@APsGTG]

@@misadique845 you woke up and chose to speak nothing but facts

[@Wilson-24]

3:02 What a good transition with the soundtrack!

[@studyday4128]

It’s really great 👍🏻 Why officials don’t did this 😢

[@tonyrockywarrior4096]

I am sorry but this was the right pick, mainly because it was the same track played when the walls were destroyed in the first episode, so it is fitting since Eren is doing the same here but in much bigger scale

[@goldsmith2459]

Amazing. Liked their music choice and their handling of the rumbling overall was great and a huge improvement over the TV anime, but still disappointed we didn't have Vogel Im Kafig or a leitmotif of it play even once during season 4 when it's Eren's theme. I would have had Vogel im kafig come in after the childrens' deaths and Eren's apology, not cutting out the added scenes by MAPPA. But that moment of silence at the end with the wind is masterclass.

[@gliderfs621]

Vogel im Käfig is the best music for the whole history of humanity.

[@JayHeartwing]

The original really gives that horror you can feel in the days of doom. Imagine that type of dream that makes you wake up at night with a racing heartbeat. Something terrifying that you feel you are inside of the scene. This kinda makes it like some type of drama you can see on TV. Vogel Im Kafig is really beautiful and can fit into other scenes, but not these ones.

[@KingG3244]

This score fits perfectly in this scene.

[@sunsetoverdrive2when321]

​​@@KingG3244 no it doesn't bcuz the scene mainly shows the innocent lives getting crushed, torched, and committing suicide. How would a song like that portray the dreadful atmosphere those people are facing?

[@KingG3244]

@@sunsetoverdrive2when321 it’s from Erens pov wdym how would a song portray that? This is what Eren is seeing. Hes deluding himself to thinking he’s so high over the sky flying when In reality he’s crushing people below. He thinks in his mind he’s finally free

[@sunsetoverdrive2when321]

@@KingG3244 Yeah it's eren's pov but at the same time given that the Rumbling is basically a global scale genocide the theme that was given perfectly encapsulates the end of world vibe.

[@LordVerdo]

People say Vogel is hopeful… despite the fact it fucking plays when Eren’s mom is eaten. Um, how in the hell is it hopeful. It’s called Bird in a Cage. So may fans of this story are deluded when they defend anything Mappa does and sadly those same people will defend the ending blindly without recognizing this is the last good chapter save for 134.

[@m_ron2742]

True but you’re also deluded if you think the original didn’t work. Vogel doesn’t really fit 100% here with the animation and scene. Sadly there is also be fans who will literally be unsatisfied with anything mappa puts out despite it being not bad (but ofc they aren’t perfect).. the original track felt depressing and expressed hopelessness and defeat which the scene and animation presented. Vogel also does but not to this extent

[@LordVerdo]

@@m_ron2742 I think they both work! I believe the track they used conveys the horror of Eren and the rumbling itself, which is perfect for the message Isyama conveyed in the story. I just always believed 100 percent rumbling would have made for a better story as the focus would have been more on Eren in the last arc.

[@doublekey8931]

Yeah, you're pretty much on point! Vogel im kafig is literally the opposite: it's hopelessness. Levi's squad being slaughtered in front of Eren's eyes and him not knowing how to react is a good example of that.

[@tonyrockywarrior4096]

I think it is very subjective honestly. It also plays during Armin's speech to convince the troops that Eren is not a threat so some people might see it as hopeful (even if the name is what it is lmao) Personally I find it the most tragic track, it sure is powerful but I feel it in a very sad way, that's why I think fits this scene so perfectly.

[@tomach6299]

It's a sad scene, but when people ask me if I'm cruel, I feel refreshed.If Ellen brings out the villain, the original song is more appropriate.

[@Kanniu.]

I respect your right to be incorrect

[@Shen559]

@@Kanniu. 💀

[@batrac.io7]

Increible. Ojala vuelva este ost al menos para el ultimo capitulo

[@mrbrightside6264]

I'm so impressed at how you separate the music and the fx so perfectly Could you upload a version without the music?

[@Jay-kr3wf]

I loved the silence at the end there.

[@abhijithraju5110]

when will people understand the difference between a better fitting ost & better sounding ost lol

[@Staralium]

This scene is incredible this soundtrack

[@radeon1108]

masterpiece ✨

[@Wilson-24]

I miss you a lot the soundtrack of the first seasons is perfect, the soundtrack that was used was quite good, although they should have used a sadder one in the death of ramzi

[@actionD]

oh my god the foreshadowing

[@Staralium]

This song is just end times

[@burningarms]

don't worry this ost will be used officially too tge rumbling scenes are yet to be animated

[@r1can79]

That would be amazing

[@anunaymani2005]

What ? Aren't these rumbling scenes as they titled 😂

[@Xominus]

Bruh how does this have anything to do with WIT? Also not every scene needs to have fucking Vogel im Kafig.

[@Thundeclap]

This time its literally the most important thing

[@radeon1108]

i guess the author meant the soundtrack usage. y'know wit was kinda better in terms of using goated soundtracks, or i just think so

[@kait3n10]

How did you remove the original ost so well? It sounds perfect!

[@studyday4128]

3:04 if wit made this 😢 Then this become best animation of world 🎉🎉

[@Thundeclap]

Witrash would ruined it with ugly cgi and stiff slidrshow animation😂😂😂

[@Thundeclap]

Acts like wit cabaple make rumbling😂😂

[@studyday4128]

Wit never use cgi on titans buddy

[@Thundeclap]

@@studyday4128 cough cough collosal

[@fufelmufel3606]

I was so disappointed when watching mappa version - I wanted to hear Vogel, thank you)

[@jonnyrose1288]

stop being a simp for the original OST and get out of your head. Vogel doesn't even fit this scene, notice how he had to change and cut some of the scenes to accommodate to the ost change. the OST MAPPA used was dark and apocalyptic which reflected the rumbling scene perfectly.

[@fufelmufel3606]

@@jonnyrose1288 of course, Vogel dont make Mappa's scene better, because Mappa did this scene for Kohto Yamamoto's sound. If Mappa chose Vogel for this scene, it would to be more relevant

[@jonnyrose1288]

@@fufelmufel3606 yes you can make the argument that Vogel would fit this scene too (so long they changed the scene because it doesn’t fit as it is) but every single time mappa adds an ost outside the original sound track the AOT fandom isn’t happy about it even when the OST choice MAPPA chose fits perfectly with the scene. Like come on you can’t tell me the OST in the original scene doesn’t fit perfectly. Like I said in the comment before this scene is very dark and the ost reflects that and brings out an apocalyptic feel. The Vogel OST doesn’t bring that same feel. Just makes me wonder do you actually think Vogel would be better or do you just love that ost so much that you want it to be in every single scene where you can picture it being in. And btw this is coming from someone who loves that ost so much and even I don’t want it to be in this scene

[@Wilson-24]

​@@jonnyrose1288 practically any soundtrack stays with the scene, correct murderers to later place the soundtrack

[@karlsoriso2304]

how did you separate the dialogue and the original soundtrack?, i was planning on doing this myself but instead using the soundtrack from season 3 named "0sk" it fits more in my opinion because of the ominous feel of the soundtrack

[@apolloart2671]

Original feels better tbh

[@stopzem1429]

nah bro you straight cap fr this solos the original

[@shrimpyshrimp5564]

Wrong

[@Nightfoxx444]

The original is better but this one is good too

[@MyHeramb]

​@@stopzem1429 no fucking way. Atleast not this part of the song. The first part of the song would have suited better

[@stopzem1429]

@@MyHeramb Pal this is a falsehood, the way @lookey_ uses this masterpiece of a song is perfect. any other part of the song wouldn't have held the same impact as this portion, especially the beginning.

[@hikky6201]

well this ost does not suit tbh prefer the OG tho, you can hear the despair and falls hope of the ost on the rumbling scene

[@stopzem1429]

As respectfully as possible I completely disagree, the original was mid.

[@aidan2849]

@@stopzem1429 whats good about this whole scene is that they couldn't mess up with the ost. Such a good scene as long as they dont play happy by pharrel williams or something it'd be fine lol

[@mateuszsieradzki9493]

I love the original soundtrack but that's also fire 🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@adeshroy3038]

well you know the music choice wasn t Mappas choice but ishayamas.... he know what he s doing so I think that original one is miles better than any ost for this scene......

[@jonnyrose1288]

MAN y'all are such simps for this OST. stop being a simp for the original OST and get out of your head. Vogel doesn't even fit this scene, notice how he had to change and cut some of the scenes to accommodate to the ost change. the OST MAPPA used was dark and apocalyptic which reflected the rumbling scene perfectly.

[@JakeYolk]

I can see it being used for the freedom panel, not here

[@zitchaden]

better although i still think my tkt edit hits harder

[@JakeYolk]

Ay i watched that one lmao

[@user-je9el6ty6x]

Gracias por sobrexplotar el ost

[@NovikNikolovic]

How is this a Wit Studio edit?

[@radeon1108]

video producer trying to say "what if wit studio made this scene"

[@vould7233]

I respect the edit but disagree on the song choice, the original fit the vibe way more because of how menacing it sounded.

[@Wilson-24]

Yes, but the way MAPPA represented it also influences, it is raw in itself, but it is also a tragedy and it is sad

[@te_27_maroofshaikh85]

Wit studio?

[@gerardogomez2820]

Fino

[@kaminomi3832]

People thinking this a good ost choice 💀

[@_-nos-_]

why not

[@sunsetoverdrive2when321]

​@@_-nos-_ unlike the actual track, it doesn't express the horror of the rumbling

[@radeon1108]

@@sunsetoverdrive2when321 bro how can you say that, just look after 3:02, how it doesn't express the horror of the rumbling..

[@Unknown-3455gamer]

@@radeon1108 nope 👎 it doesn’t fit plus I prefer the original not that music they played in this video

[@radeon1108]

​@@Unknown-3455gamer i was thinking this music is giving epic vibes but what can i say, personal thoughts

[@studyday4128]

3:04 awesome 🎉 Japanese music soundtrack scenes compositors are dumb 😢😢😢 They never make any music best for best animation 😢

[@scr3verrrb70]

shut up

[@leviathan9865]

it doesnt fit the scene, idk how many times we gotta say it

[@ayounis5158]

انت مين يلا، قولي انت مين وابوك مين وامك مين

[@Wilson-24]

لأن؟

[@ayounis5158]

@@Wilson-24 trolling

[@Alessio-tt6pp]

totally nope

[@Maisonier]

They should have used this song in the beginning of the fist chapter of season 4, part 3 ... mappa ruined everything.

[@te_27_maroofshaikh85]

Lol everyone liked the orignal ost which make everyone feel terror and despair rather then this sad OST i prefer.

[@te_27_maroofshaikh85]

And animators wipping theirs Ass for this show and giving us which we wanted from soo long and you wits simp always come to comolain rather then appreciation. People like you and your opinion mostly ruined studio hardwork and their efforts. if i assume wits for this show again then i can tell that they were by now animating s4 part 1 episodes which will still take more 2 years for them to release. so be greatful

[@JakeYolk]

Buddy mappa didn’t ruin anything lmao, the same person who selected the music used in each scene under wit studio also chose the music in each scene under mappa

[@adeshroy3038]

there you go again with your WITtarded comments

[@AM17titan]

Original better This feels like something hopeful is happening 🤷🏻‍♂️

[@Mau365PP]

Of course it is hopeful. The demon of Paradis is doing its jobs to save eldians

[@alihamza14729]

Hopeful for paradis😅

[@AM17titan]

@@alihamza14729 yea but people are dying maybe mappa wanted to make eren look like a villain so that the alliance would be more heroic

[@haveidonethisbefore]

Eren's mother death is very hopeful indeed lmao