Attack On Titan: What If Marley Never Attacked Paradis || What If Wall Maria Never Falls

[@SpammytheHedgehog]

So basically, Reiner chickens out of the mission.

[@thenenhunter2600]

@@SpammytheHedgehog Not necessarily. More like Marley abandons the plan all together.

[@nc1609]

1:38 Grisha definitely gave Eren his titan because he found out Carla died - in the scene he hugs Zeke he asks Eren to show him Carla being safe, in Shadis's season 3 flashback it shows how cold Grisha became after he heard about Carla's death and in Eren's season 1 flashbacks of being injected Eren says "You've lost it, mom's death pushed you of the deep end." whilst Grisha was screaming at him and crying. He also says "Eren, Carla, Mikasa, please be alive" in tears whilst returning to wall Rose after killing the Reisses.

[@pradityapascalisprawito3153]

Morale of the story, having good parents can save the world!

[@TheAwesomeGamerofEpicness]

one thing I have to say about the start, grisha would not have taken the founding titan if the wall wasnt breaching, the only reason he went to the reiss chapel was because of Carla's death

[@Experlment1188]

He went to the Reid’s chapel BEFORE Carla’s death

[@TheAwesomeGamerofEpicness]

@@Experlment1188 if you listen to what he says, you will see that it was after he heard wall maria was breached, hence after her death. He says something along the lines of 'we lived right next to the broken wall'

[@wild_skeptic]

There's one more cutscene where he returns from his mission to claim founder on the horse where he straight up thinks to himself "I wish nothing happened to Carla and Eren" or something among these lines.

[@jaipandey7142]

What if Grisha attacked Reiss family when he learned about the chapel (the time when he postponed his mission for the sake his family)

[@Gold_Gamer_100]

Oh that's a good one

[@darthjeager9056]

The goat has returned

[@ItsZaynX1]

Still waiting for what if Frieda survived the finale

[@Experlment1188]

He’s remaking the series : )

[@ItsZaynX1]

@Experlment1188 really?

[@Chrisplaysrequiem]

You should do a "what if" video, of what if the veteran scouts like Miche, Hange Squad, Nanaba, Gelgar are alive during the Marley & War for Paradis arc? That would be interesting :)

[@Anakinskynader]

What if Mikasa succeeded in killing Reiner and Burrito when they revealed themselves to be titans?

[@GamerLightWarrior456]

Wow Marley not attacking Paradis seems odd to me.

[@slapsmans6900]

YESSS THE GOAT UPLOADED

[@salty5103]

i comment under almost every vid pls post more when u have time and also pls try and drop earlier if u can

[@Kreekyblock]

I WAS THINKING OF THIS THEORY LAST WEEK

[@kokichistextingstory374]

-What if Reiner Ate Eren During Season 2? -What if Ymir Ate Reiner Instead of Marcel?

[@jaipandey7142]

1) Specify when? When Reiner revealed himself or during the forest conversation or when scouts came to rescue Eren? In one case that would be end game for everyone as the scouts would be killed by Titans and maybe Mikasa would have gone mad and killed Reiner and Bertholdt. In second case, Reiner and Bertholdt managed to escape with Ymir, and maybe Historia. Reiner at some point would touch Historia causing Reiner to see future, learning that he have the coordinates. Then either Reiner would be next Eren or Zeke would find out and use Reiner for his cause. 2) Marcel and other warriors would have captured Ymir. What happens after that would be same scenario as of other what ifs like What if Marcel survived, What if Ymir ate Bertholdt, and others done by this KZbinr.

[@Experlment1188]

The mission wasn’t to eat the founder, it was to capture and obtain its powers. Otherwise, they would’ve done that

[@TheCrimsonKing56]

If ymir ate riener they’d just grab her go back pass the armored to porco restart the mission

[@HadeTheReal]

@@jaipandey7142I think Reiner obtaining the founder would be interesting but boy would it mess with his already fractured mind even further and I think he'd probably go crazy from it all but that could snap him and turn him Into a complete different person. But most likely he would probably end up working with Zeke and Zeke's plan would succeed.

[@jaipandey7142]

@HadeTheReal Yeah it was what I meant. Reiner is already insane and after activating coordinates, he would go all mad. But if he manage to control himself, he can use best out of the Founding's power to help his family and people in Liberio. However, the chances are less as that guy is pessimist and suicidal, so he would either collab with Zeke for euthanasia or just pass his powers to someone to end his life.

[@dharanrobinjames4647]

My only opinion on this without even watching the video would be Eren doesn't rest the world population that's all.

[@index3562]

14:16 Clear wall Maria? But it never even fell in this timeline? Do you mean clear the Paradi?

[@thenenhunter2600]

Good catch. Absolutely a typo. I meant clearing behind Wall Maria of titans.

[@nc1609]

11:09 Does this mean Eren only has the Attack Titan and the other Reiss children are still alive? If Grisha took the Founder and killed the Reiss children, why would Historia still be killed?

[@thenenhunter2600]

Basically Historia wasn't killed but instead died in a blizzard trying to save Daz. In the original story, Ymir was there to rescue her. But Ymir is still a pure titan in this storyline. And Eren has the founding titan in this storyline

[@nc1609]

@@thenenhunter2600 Thanks!

[@HadeTheReal]

What if Reiner ate Eren out of desperation as he couldn't capture him do he made the hard choice to eat Eren and obtained the Attack and Founder Titan for himself. This could be at some point during the clash of Titans arc. Most likely during Eren and Reiners first fight where instead of capturing Eren Reiner just straight up dates him.

[@yuta3234]

no mention of marco?

[@Gaint_anas]

Why would they take out bertholdt too?

[@Heat_6789]

What if levi died?

[@harryhurry8978]

Ok one thing confuses me, Ymir remains a pure titan, so she never ate Marcel, but if she never ate him then why would warriors give up if Marcel is still there to lead them?

[@thenenhunter2600]

@@harryhurry8978 Basically I made an adjustment at the start of the video. What if Marley never attacked Paradis. Meaning the warriors never set foot on the island as Marley abandons the founding Titan.

[@harryhurry8978]

@@thenenhunter2600 Ah, apologies for that, I rewinded and I guess I over looked it.

[@MiD.OriyaIzuku20003]

What If King Karl Fritz Never Left Never To Live On Paradis?

[@minecraftmajor]

Wall "Maaria"

[@nani4249]

What if keith was given the attack titan instead to eren

[@DebdrikDebnath]

why would ymir remain a pure titan? she did eat Marcel, right?

[@thenenhunter2600]

@@DebdrikDebnath Nope. In this scenario, Marley never attacks Paradis so the Warriors don’t step foot on the island.

[@Maina980]

🔥🔥🔥