Atul Subhash Case | How False Allegations Destroy Lives & Legal Realities | Explained by Law Expert

[@iamshobharana]

Watch Our Podcast with Men’s rights activist Deepika Bhardwaj where she highlights the plight of Indian men : kzbin.info/www/bejne/g3S8qHWFrK-afpo

[@ncharan5948]

Dowry...na na ye illegal ha Alimony..ha ye legal ha..3 crore Dena padega...

[@MoniAlly-tr6hs]

Madam, I have seen women and wives being harassed and nothing coming out in favour of genuine women’s even thou the law according to many discussions is in favour of women. I have personally experienced and also seen in many women’s case where in small cities the women’s who even earn and give all earnings to husband and in laws and still when the women is harrased and when she ask support from her own parents and home, still she get to hear from all sides that rather pressurise her to die or stay there in marriage,,, kindly put discussions from both sides

[@MoniAlly-tr6hs]

How many discussions or podcast have u seen madam when women or wives die by murdur or suicide, and then we make it viral?????

[@ameya7723]

Shobha Rana ji aap hi batao 15 din aur 2 mahine ke shaadi me wife ka kitna right banna chahiye. Aapki kya rai hai isme?

[@shersingh-ov9pf]

Thanks

[@GeetaSorot]

Atul Subhash is rare case but thousands of male are under this trauma. We’ve witnessed many cases.

[@Knotfox221]

It's not rare. 498 A is the most misused legislation in Inida.

[@GeetaSorot]

Rita kaushik is not only corrupt judge, they are countless in India…

[@sagaraiwale]

Atul Subhash Suicide ❌ Atul Subhash Hatyakand ✔️ Main accused: Indian Law

[@RahulK-d5g]

Not indian law. Indian mind. Plz do not apply indian mind, plz copy paste law from other country. At least they will be well discussed n thought of.

[@prabhuramkrishna]

Correction: Atul Subhas R*pe and murder Case !

[@ayushjain4226]

केवल सिस्टम नहीं बल्कि कही ना कही पूरा समाज ही उसका हत्यारा है। इसलिए ऐसे समाज के प्रति अब मेरी भी ना कोई जिम्मेदारी है ना कोई संवेदना😡

[@vikramchand7205]

मुझे भी यह सब झेलना पड़ा, अंत तलाक के साथ खत्म...20 साल बाद

[@baljindersinghsidhu3959]

😮😮😮😮😮

[@baljindersinghsidhu3959]

20 saaaaal

[@funpro740]

😢😢

[@hukamchandra9822]

20 saal ladane ke baad aapke pass kya bacha? Naa to age naa hee paisa aur naa hee emotion sab khatam..life bahut short hai bro

[@sunnyaden3626]

Accha hua khtm hua.....atlst zinda ho bhai.... Woh sbse bdhi BAAT hai

[@amitthackrey5152]

In the mean time judge Rita Kaushik is enjoying luxuries under police protection 😄😄😄

[@muhamamd784]

Shoba je I am from pakistan my respect increase for u u raise voice for males Males are also suffering not only in India even in pak

[@AA13494]

islamic laws to anti-women hai, how r islamic men suffering??

[@saurabhmahaur7581]

so sad to see this also happens in pakistan

[@C.GK.]

" Democracy cannot deliver justice " So nobody should expect justice from the Indian law system..

[@SatyaSanatanMahadevGuitarist]

In the case of Nikita Singhania,she was thinking she was Durga Mata and she could practice all her powers on her husband but nature also play its part and now she has become Jail Mata.

[@sagnikbhattacharya9191]

But unfortunately she'll get bail and as the guest on the podcast said, she'll not be convicted

[@sagaraiwale]

​@@sagnikbhattacharya9191 She has to be convicted....Nirbhaya ke time law nai tha fir bhi kiya na unko faasi

[@manojsuri007]

We can officially, morally, ethically declare that the institution of marriage is over. No man will trust any woman after this case. This case has spread like fire all across India. Women will only learn their lessons when men stop marrying and they stay single.

[@fireStorm070]

It's not over. May be it's in distress among the upper middle class, high class masses but in middle-lower middle and labour class, marriage is being carried out just normal and through the culture of endogamy, and Caste marriages.

[@ajagir72]

After this case? Bhaisahab, 20 saal se yeh sab chal raha hai yeh. Iss baar video viral ho gaya. Kuch change nahi hoga

[@manojsuri007]

@ajagir72 chal bahut saal se Raha hai lekin asli mein awareness iss case ke wajah se Mila hai. Ab kyunki yeh case itna spread ho gaya isiliye shaadiyan Kam ho jayengi.

[@ajagir72]

@@manojsuri007 kuch nahi hoga. Likh lo

[@abhishek8195]

Veshyaaly jindabaad Bharat Mahaan jindabaad

[@suyashdixit8669]

This advocate said one thing right that once 33% seats are reserved for women in parliament,any law related with men's safety is just joke and literally this will destroy concept of marriage

[@Jasmine-q4b9y]

The courts in India blindly accept any case and issue OS numbers. The victims should run around finding lawyers who swindle money out of us. Then, they run trials for years and years. The trial court judges do not apply their minds and give judgment. We have no say in it. It is final. If you do not get justice, go to the high court and spend more money, then go to the Supreme Court. In the end, if it is found that the case is frivolous, there is no consequence for the culprits. This very reason enables people to use courts as a platform for extortion, blackmail and torture people. The basic common sense should be for the courts to investigate the evidence before accepting the case. And punish severely for filing false cases. Enforce IPC Section 209/BNS 246, like YOGI Adityanath, enforcing bulldozer JUSTICE.

[@ramachandrannair8461]

@@Jasmine-q4b9y Don't glorify yogi for his bulldozer action. Maritial disputes are a different subject. Did yogi bulldoze the house and business establishment of Nikita Singhania's family because of whom Atul Subhash had to commit suiside? Courts have also ruled against bulldozer justice.

[@jogeshsachdeva4578]

Thanks shobha rana for making podcast on this topic/😊

[@kishangzp]

Simple solution - put the burden of proof on the spouse accusing, and follow rule not guilty until proven…

[@puranmishra7439]

Bhai forget about marriage ek chote mote relationship ke baad bhi wo fake harassment and fake rape attempt laga ke aapki jindagi tabah kar sakti h. Phir police, lawyers ke saath mill ke jabtak aapse mota Paisa na hadap le tab tak aapke fake FIR ki dhamki degi. Paisa legi wo alag aur trauma degi wo alag. Ek tu tu main main ke baad it's a great tool for such women for revenge, I am the victim of such a corrupt system.

[@Epiclips-y5m]

Guys don't marry, marriage is overated and obsolete system in this world, the disadvantages greatly outweigh the advantages, and the risk is too much. The mental Hassel is just not worth it

[@prem1230]

Mai bhi jhel raha hu jhute 498A, dv, cases😢. Lady ke kehne bhar se case ho gye, ham court me cheekh kar bata rahe hai, ham nirdosh hai koi nhi sun raha😢

[@vmk8970]

Shame on this law

[@raghumahato7967]

Law Banya Kisike liye or istemal kar rahe koi indian law bhi biased hogiya hai 90% fake hone ke baad bhi andha kanun ko sahi galt nahi dekte hai 😮😢

[@factmi10x]

Tum bhi video banao Pura india sun raha hai. Taki e topic strong ho or law chenge ho

[@ayushjain4226]

किन पेटीकोट छाप हिजड़ो से भीख मांग रहे हो भाई, अपना न्याय खुद करो😡

[@ramachandrannair8461]

Our insensitive politicians and the justice system are purely to be blamed for the sorry state of affairs of husbands in India. Law needs to be uniform for both men and women Only God can save India.

[@pradeepkumarkoot5622]

You are right, our incompetent political leaders are root cause for these problems

[@VivekKumar-iv7pm]

Shame on the Indian law & judiciary system

[@sheetalsingh6792]

Our law and judges are creating problem for Husbands.

[@HappyLifestyle266]

And woman also

[@nishiarora655]

Such a clear picture of matrimonial cases and explained in clear words . Thank u to the anchor as well as the guest invited .

[@jewelfields]

Ladkiya ajkal ladka ban na chahti h. Par ye nature (prakarti) ke khilaf h

[@useuheheksidhhd]

मैं भी पिछले 5 साल से 6 केसेस को लड़ रहा हूं😢😢😢

[@jitenderwebdesigner]

न्यायालय, पुलिस स्टेशन और गवर्नमेंट ऑफिसेस अब रिश्वतखोरी का अड्डा बन चुके है। रिश्वतखोर ज्यूडिशियरी और पुलिस केस को सुलझाने की जगह उलझाकर दोनों पार्टी से रिश्वत वसूलते रहते है। आम आदमी की मेहनत की कमाई को लूटब्रेज है। Rita और माधव खुले में घूम रहे है।

[@paparazzina1]

Its so sad that in the end there is no solution to this but to suffer in this system, the police the lawyers and the judges enjoy such circumstances and people suffer due to their innocense. Dear shobha rana thank you so much for this podcast but i feel sad that there wont be no solutions to this but just suffering to this.

[@RamadeviIndukuri]

Laws related to family matters are to be reformed to save the families. Property and dowry and maintenance are to be delinked from marriage. Men and women must support themselves in marriage and divorce must be with mutual consent.

[@BrahmadeoNarayanSah]

Bahut dukhad hai Matrimonial cases

[@amarsinghkandari9179]

वकील साहब आपने इस अंधे और अनपढ़ कानून के बारे में और डिटेल से समझाया आपका बहुत बहुतआभार लेकिन वकील साहब इस कानून के एकतरफ के आगे पुलिस वकील जज सब पत्नी पक्ष में फैसला देने के लिए बेबस हैं तो पति पक्ष को वकील या कोर्ट जाने सेभी क्या फायदा

[@supersayaaain]

Boys arrange marriage karne se pehle documents ,proofs and ek lawyer arrange karlo😂😂

[@BraminWarrior]

Kyo love marriage nahi hota kya ?

[@freecoder522]

Shaadi hi mat karo , or safe raho . . . .

[@abhisheksuryavanshi135]

Thanks shobha rana for making podcast on this topic

[@rohanbansal9563]

These things scare me as someone who would be moving to India in next few months. I am 33 year old, and was 21 years old when I went to US for my master's. I came back to India when I was 28 to be closer to parents, stayed in India for 2 years and moved to Canada as I wanted a backup as I thought it might get difficult to adjust in India on long term. Since in US it is impossible to get green card and citizenship due to country cap. I plan to return to India for second time in April 2025 after filing for Canadian citizenship so that I am at least closer to my parents and can easily move to US in future (or worst case Canada). I do not like India or Canada, and would have liked to return to US but before getting married, I would like to be at least closer to my parents. But things like these scare me, about marriage and India society in general. It would be my second return to India but corrupt judicial system and people that vote solely on religion, caste and freebies is scary.

[@ayu_insane1503]

Dowry hee kyon Sanjeev Bhatt jaise hazaroan log hain jo dowry case se bhee rigerious law jaise UAPA, TADA,MPLAD deshdroh, NSA, ,Narcotics etc ke system dwara knowingly created cases mein years se jail mein hain. Years ke baad court of law unhien fake prove karta hai. Fake alliegation ka sabse exclusive case 2G Scam tha.

[@Padmanabham.]

Thank you ma'am

[@archanakochar1578]

Unfortunately situation of marital laws in urban india.

[@yontan6141]

Uhh... Such a heavy podcast shoba ji.

[@nishiarora655]

Judge and police may doubt the lady but her lawyer helps to put lies in the petition ...to win the case for client .

[@manujain753]

"Yeh Andha kanoon hai".....this has been lyrics of a famous song from old time and still true in today's era

[@shubhamsrivastava2493]

कई बार पुलिस भी महिलाओ की सही बात पे पुरुषो के खिलाफ कारवाई नही करती पर झुठे केसीस पे करती है।

[@mohindershangari8777]

TOXIC FEMINISM IS THE DE FACTO RULER OF INDIA.We can not blame her servants for doing her bidding.Make sure you don’t irritate her or her servants.

[@AmitChahan-h8p]

Atul Subhash is one of the case but millions of male are under this trauma. We’ve witnessed many cases.

[@shanusingh8511]

जेल जाना हो तो लड़के तुरंत शादी करे ।। क्योंकि शादी एक पवित्र रिश्ता है ।।

[@supersayaaain]

Ek dum sahi😂😂

[@thunderentertainmentshorts3712]

I think sometimes , its just better to take the law in your hand and not leave this world alone but take the ones responsible with you. #atmhasclosed

[@funpro740]

Justice for Atul

[@amarsinghkandari9179]

वकील साहब जब कानून में पति के लिए कोई रियायत नहीं है तो पति फाइट किस करेगा कब तक करेगा पुलिस जज वकील और कानून सब पत्नी के पक्ष में तब मजबूर पति घुट घुट कर कब तक जिएगा

[@shersingh-ov9pf]

Just avoid wedding , risk is too high I was divorced after 22 of my wedding, learnt my lesson and never got married married again Lost everything I had and then rebuilt myself, feel much better, did much better in second innings in all respect

[@MsDownloader40]

इसिलीएं हमारे बुजुर्ग खानदान देखकर विवाह कराते थे। लडकी और लडके का खानदान देखा जाता था। अच्छी लडकी मतलब घरसंसार सभालने वाली। आजकल लवमँरेज और सोशल मेडीया से बहु ढुंढते है जो खतरनाक है।

[@Tigerdsz]

This is so scary..avoid getting married

[@hukamchandra9822]

Thank you sir❤❤

[@Ankur71284]

Stay away from marriage if you wanna keep your hard earned money . Indian law is the most dumbest law in the world .. jisne bhi banaya ye law wo Pakka nashe main hoga .. yaa to Phir gaanja le ke betha hoga ..

[@ShreeVivekAgrawal]

If the wife files false allegations, the husband should file criminal cases and make sure that the wife also attends 120 dates. Never pay maintenance if the wife has deceived the court. I myself didn't pay maintenance for 10 yrs because my wife underrepresented her income by 75% and inflated my income by 400%. I simply fought back. We finally settled without any exchange of extortion money called alimony or maintenance. Every husband should fight back such greedy wives. I loved my wife. But that doesn't mean I will get my entire family blackmailed because of my sentiments for her.

[@MB-my4ik]

Maintenance should be capped with Rs. 1500/- which is equivalent to pension given to a widow and a child by any State government. If wife won in the court the cases of dowry and D.V. than husband should be sent to a Jail.

[@manujain753]

The trial should run other way round......the allegations must be proven before granting any maintenance

[@onlytruth9073]

Ye vakeel sirf court me kya chalta hai jo ki galat hai, usko hi bata raha hai... Reforms kya hone chahiye uspar kuch nahi bol raha ..

[@ayu_insane1503]

Fake alliegation n witness creation mein advocates kee important role hota hai.

[@anuragjain2133]

I know someone, very close to me,the husband and wife and their daughter were bullied, blackmailed and mentally tortured by boy mother, sister her husband and children of sister, career destroyed by mother and sister of the husband

[@shanusingh8511]

Sarkar ko Sadhu Sanyasi ki bahut Jrurat hai ... isliye 498 a Dhara mai koi Shudhar nhi hoga ..

[@manujain753]

Sir , why government is mute spectator on grossly misuse of this law.....are they waiting for many people like Atul sacrifice their lives....or the law will change when the incidence happen to some high-profile person

[@nishiarora655]

Sir the opinion of the common man is insaan mar jaayey par court naa jaanaa padhay .

[@Ahmedabad-Single-Souls]

Marriage has become a business. Most relationships are materialistic. Stay single stay happy.

[@arhronline]

Oh sure, *now* the podcasts roll in-right after a tragic suicide. Because, apparently, giving this advice *beforehand* so men actually have the information *before* it’s too late would just be too much to ask.

[@cerestouch_in]

10 साल से पहले मां बेटी अगर रोड पर नजर आए ना, तो जनता ही इन्हें कूटेगी इसलिए इनको कम से कम 10 साल जेल जाना जरूरी है।

[@manavchoan5393]

Means government/court kuchh nahi karegi. Public ko hi khud karna hai.

[@SumanWaldia-r7p]

Law discriminatory hai..change hona t.. equality is equality.

[@Varun-uq4jr]

What about the cases where the husband does not want divorce and only wife wants it.???????

[@priyeshsharma8509]

Room m cctv kese lagae

[@alokprasad03]

Vakeel saheb ko khud smjh nhi aa rha ki kya bolu kya na bolu...

[@BethLegal]

now I know why indian PM is not married 👨‍🎤

[@Indian_477]

One thing to say to the Podcaster who is asking there is no law for men in India and Its such a shame for us

[@BraminWarrior]

This women is 100% FEMINIST.

[@SureshChandra-si9gz]

Make discuss action on judicial system of jonpur family' Court

[@alokprasad03]

Lekin vakeel bhi suggest krte hain

[@Matkggg]

Intro ko thoda chota rakhe 🥲

[@Varun-uq4jr]

12.45 you said one can go to Hon. SC. sir paise kitne sare lag jate hai. Kahan se laye aadmi paise. Mard ko bhi emotional pain hota hai.???? Why in case of dissertation automatically divorce without maintenance and alumni or any other Rights......?????

[@alabhyav]

The lifestyle burden should be on individual. The wife's lifestyle as per her income before marriage and her parents income and standard should be considered not the husband's family lifestyle because all women upgrade to a higher standard family. When your ex empolyer does not pay you why should a husband be forced to pay maintainance and alimony. Thus law has to be abolishhed by MPs in the Parliament. If the dont press NOTA in elections.

[@AshwaniKumar-zj9hl]

Stupid country stupid law, ye neta Rahul Modi sb ek he chatte btte hain, women women krte rahte hain, my stupid netao agar aadmi kamayga bo ja ke women ko he dega, bo jaye wife ho ya mother ho, pr agar women kamayegi to bo pti ko nhi degi, isliy job man ko do, maintenance band kro sb ghar bs jayenge

[@umashankarjangid8848]

योगी भी ऐसा ही है

[@sarojinijanganure130]

Husband has to attend the cases with BGV brand, where the stress is increasing in balancing career, life, cases, resposibilites . With this his mental tortuchre increaaes

[@suyashdixit8669]

Enjoy marriage without wedding this is the need of the hour as simple as that

[@sheetalsingh6792]

Supereme court ase hi kuch bhi kahta rahe ga. Ladies ke liye khao pio moj karo, ye india ke law ne arrangement kar diya h.

[@pratapnayak3649]

Only self realisation. Ed, cbi, govt and courts failed to help sushant singh case. All attempts are nonsenses. Subhash case will be as usual forgotten with the passage of time. Everyone is not born with strong mind and are victims of aggression from either sides. It is to file case against males or females but false allegations are paramount in every duch cases being filed. Let us forget all these discussions

[@Varun-uq4jr]

Mujhe aapse Jana Tha ki kya ismein ulta bhi ho sakta hai ki Mahila Hamari aur Purush se maintenance Le Saken. Agar aisa Nahin Hai To Kanoon kahan barabar Gaya equality before law kahan hai.?????

[@codedusting]

Let me answer: They can't.

[@neerajjariwala]

He is saying the Indian Laws ir Men is ... Do what wife says else do what Atul did.. isn't it.. No option

[@adimishra7188]

Sir ,jaise saas sasur ki income ke wajah se wo badi kothi main reheti thi ,pati ki income nahi tha , to kya hoga , sasurji property kamayi Hui hai ya pustaini hai ,to kya hoga ,means pati ki koi banayi Hui property nahi hai to kya hota hai

[@gnageswarreddy5597]

Ye to atankwad se bhi badi samasya hai. Yahan pura samaj barbad ho raha hai.😢😢😢😢

[@PreetyPareek-iy3ze]

Mera bhai bhi ke sath bhi same Atul ji ke sath huwa hai abhi divorce case file huwa hai or samne wali party ne sare false cases dal diye hai..or family pr jyada gande cases dalhe jis se mera bhai majbur ho or use moti alimony mil sake

[@codedusting]

I heard similar cases where the female members of the husband side filled failed R cases on male members of other side and then mutual agreement with no alimony.

[@np2819]

Anchor didi, please let him speak. Please don't blabber. Do some homework on these women centric laws. Don't act innocent.

[@Singer-AmeetDutt]

#justiceformen

[@rajnivarshney1883]

Should we should marry????

[@prabhuramkrishna]

How? : By not maaring

[@reframelife22]

जस्टिस is due कानून अंधा है sarkar ankh hote हुए bhi अंधी और behri है

[@supersayaaain]

Yeh sare law ladko ko agar shaadi se pehle pta jaye ,tho ek second mein sara romance nikal jaye😂😂

[@sscreation7615]

In sabka ek solution hai sadi bhut soch samajh ke kare

[@sagaraiwale]

Shaadi Indian Aurat se na kare....duniya ki koi bhi Aurat se kare

[@Tiger291-y1c]

Mat karo bhai

[@supersayaaain]

Ladko ko shaadi hi nahi Krna chaiye, itne sare anti men law dekh k kis ladke ka shaadi krne ka man karega.

[@p.tiwarimusician2121]

Bahut men ke sath aesa ho raha hai

[@avinashkumar-td2dp]

why no one challenges this law all together in sc atleast we can plea for making it gender neutral.

[@captainnemo1606]

JUST DON'T MARRY AND STAY AWAY FROM WOMEN ALWAYS INTERACT WITH WOMEN UNDER CCTV.....

[@imprasann]

say 'no' to marriage.

[@neerajjariwala]

Men has no option.. simple

[@shaundsilva994]

Salute atul for awareness 🫡 After these unlimited videos or after atuls death all men who got married are aware and can decide if they want to take the risk. Before atul men were not aware maybe only 5% knew about it. thnx to atul its 80%.

[@BraminWarrior]

😂😂😂😂 mens will not marry now

[@narinderpalsingh5349]

Miss use of Law

[@sandeepy7ec288]

😢😢😢

[@VijayHshs]

Contract marriage mandatory karna chahiye govt ko