Yuval Harari Gets DISMANTLED - Marc Gafni Exposes The Faults In His Logic

[@TommySmith-m7g]

Only 22 minutes in and feel the desire to comment. Marc Gafni's ability to skillfully and compassionately peel back the layers of intentionality behind Yuval Noah Harari’s work is nothing short of extraordinary. His words don’t just engage the mind, they resonate deeply within the body’s wisdom, touching a place of profound truth and clarity. With so many of Harari’s books sold and his ideas reaching far and wide, it’s deeply concerning how many people have accepted the story he paints without questioning its deeper implications. Marc points out how alarming this is, and his perspective serves as a much-needed call to pause, reflect, and look beneath the surface. Listening to Marc speak feels like an invitation to reconnect with the essence of what it means to be human, beyond the narratives we are so often presented with. He artfully exposes the subtle currents shaping our collective worldview, while offering a vision that feels both grounding and expansive. In a time when such narratives hold immense influence, Marc’s voice is a beacon, reminding us to listen not just with our minds but with our whole being. I find myself inspired by his insights and grateful for the way he challenges us to think deeper and align more authentically with the pulse of life. Truly transformative work! Thank you 🙏🦋🤍

[@dorotheabetz9021]

yes, spot on, beautifully said!

[@grammasgardenofideas5081]

🎉

[@ca9125]

I cannot agree more!

[@thehungrytaurus]

well said. I am amazed by the sharpness of his intellect and how he compassionately makes it accessible to the viewers/listeners. Incredible

[@katherineb9]

I read Sapiens and was so down and filled with a sense of lost of hope. Hated it. Philosophy without heart is a dangerous endeveour of the disconnected hyper ego.

[@20.000MeilenunterdemMeer]

@@katherineb9 Yes, that's it. True.

[@HillJackal]

Bingo!

[@rogermueller53]

Well said.

[@Io-Io-Io]

Reminiscences of Nietzsche

[@rsdtknqr]

Because Harari is fundamentally wrong. I recommend reading works of Rudolf Steiner instead. you will be jubilant.

[@jacquelineclark1195]

This is sooo needed! Speaking truth to power! Go Marc! Go Aubrey! bring it on.

[@jacktalcott]

Absolutely, amazing discussions! This was a phenomenal example of sharing correction in encouraging way. Thank you to Marc and Aubrey (for hosting and staying mostly silent 😂❤) I'm grateful to see people calling Harari out, especially with such brilliant communication. The shared values of Love will be commonly known and understood in our futures. 2025 has started and it's ours to create together, so let's unite to bring Peace to our world. When Secrets are no longer "legal" the world can experience freedom and prosperity together. Praise God!

[@matthewnguyen2285]

I would love to see a discussion between Yuval and Marc!! Love the dissection Marc! Love you Aubrey!

[@bkwatkinscom]

Actually I can't see a better way to hear each view than as presented here. Free to speak uninterrupted and uninhibited. I would welcome a response to this uninterrupted.

[@christianewoltersmd]

you are not alone in wanting to see that discussion

[@chahatadencorten3282]

Wow Marc, you have been studying this material so thoroughly and I am very grateful you and Aubrey took this on! Great and precise job. Well Yuval Harari, you might wanna show up for a debat here!!

[@BrendanTietz]

I’m usually anti “polarity” but I’m 1000% on board saying forget this dude. Not even worth mentioning his name. He’s completely anti human. Great podcast!

[@boulderguitarcoach5269]

you nailed it… anti-human

[@Archeidos-Arcana]

I've always sensed a deeply unsettling darkness in Yuval. Not trying to be hyperbolic, but looking into his eyes I feel the makings of someone who could commit great atrocities, the likes of which become infamous in world history. I'm bothered that someone of his mindset is elevated so high in the public sphere.

[@bavingeter423]

I feel this way about several public “intellectuals”

[@espucs]

Yep, he's supposed to be a meditator, if there is anything I feel during deep meditation is love and compassion. He's either doing it wrong or he's connecting with some dark energies.

[@mwng5186]

Well said, I think youve articulated something many would agree with.

[@shadusia]

Bingo!

[@spiderwort6291]

Well Yuval did say humanity needs to be eliminated. I guess he and the other Zionists are the only ones that should be allowed to own/live on this earth.

[@MechanicsAndCarpentry369]

I've heard him talk about people in terms of being useless eaters. Here you guys were easy on him. He's pretty dark inside and I'll just leave it at that. Ben recorded this!

[@internalmethods]

I'm glad someone caught and mentioned that comment he made about "useless eaters." This is right up there with the CEO of Nestle saying publicly that "water is not a human right."

[@Ifitsnotthetimethenwhen]

Glad I’m Not Yuval Harai , I actually believe in Christ. I hope you guys enjoy your read. I won’t be attending.

[@andrewcolliver2642]

Thank you, Marc. Thank you, Aubrey. So needed, not just as a refutation of Harari’s limited vision, but as a push back against/antidote to the paradigm or “zeitgeist that he has swallowed”. Now I know why after reading Sapiens I had no desire to follow him any further. Just a whole lot of self-contradictory assertions without any substance. I’ve become tired of people saying we need “a new story”, as if desiring a completed narrative to follow in a paint-by-numbers fashion. Rather, as Dave Snowden would say, we need to identify, not outcomes, but vectors. A love story as you point to it here, Marc, is a novel phenomenon or attractor emerging from a vector of deep connection and aliveness, and your words are an encouragement to pursue the threads in my life that cohere and enliven. Thank you again. 🙏🏻

[@markrobertcoffin]

Brilliant response! Thank you both for devoting the time and resources to produce this.

[@BadreddineOtky]

I was actually shocked when I heard some friends talking about him and listening to his podcasts... he is a total sociopath Thanks for breaking it down for those of us who don't want to read and contaminate our minds with his BS

[@andrewslight101]

I'd pat those friends on the back and wish them well on their journey without me 😅

[@kristajosepha]

Dr. Marc Gafni does it again! He is brilliant at reading texts of public culture as a sacred text. I know he has read every word in Yuval's books and carefully deciphered the patterns, to be able to 'perform' this 'surgery on the DNA of Cosmos', this 'direct hit on culture' for the sake of the whole, for the sake of the future of humanity. I am beyond grateful and trembling with this mystical act of setting the record straight. The world will never be the same. Thank you Marc, thank you Aubrey. Can't wait to listen to the conversation with Yuval, soon.

[@dorotheabetz9021]

This is great diagnosis and surgery. The festering wound of culture is being cleaned from the splinters and the chilling poison so it can begin to heal following the everlasting healing and life-loving impulse of Cosmos. Quote by quote, thought by thought, assumption by assumption the wound is freed from the poison of lies and shallow assumptions. And finally, I feel warm again. Thank you so much, Marc and Aubrey!

[@HillJackal]

Beautifully said. So good I took notes. ❤

[@kateidiens3327]

So grateful for this! Much needed! Respect! 🌅😎✌️

[@jimg7010]

The connection between Harari perspective and WEF agenda is enough for me to throw out the book (Sapiens) that I just purchased. Oops.

[@yasyas618]

1:22:40 to answer the rhetorical question posed here 👉 his shift and softening of the language is because ‘they’ realized they NEED the made up stories (ie controlling the narrative), so suddenly it’s this retro-fitting of ‘welllll, what WE say is true and smart and good, and has value and meaning”

[@JoeNielsen44]

💯

[@fillianplays]

Humanity is very much in need of a spiritual reawakening regardless of individual religious labels. That includes the religions that are atheism and post modernism.

[@Daneiladams555]

notice Yuval has never debated anyone?

[@csuchdrp5996]

Hariri works for the great reset and global power. He is doing it on purpose obviusly. Glad you talked about it though many people have said it for a long time.

[@ca9125]

I love how Gafni speaks!!! 👏👏👏. Love straightforwardness!!!

[@smitadas2236]

The popularity of his books is purely down to heavy marketing - he was everywhere so we bought his book … not a grassroots organic type of popularity. His books are truly awful, depressing and robotic. It’s amazing how seriously we take someone if they’re famous and platformed. He’s a tool of propaganda IMO.

[@danielstoned]

Give devil his due, the books are well written and an interesting read. It's just that they are written by the devil :D

[@Humansofearth2941]

Couldn’t you get Harari there as well? The real treasure would be a conversation between them.

[@dougerdmann9021]

Life will stop picking on its self as soon as it stops thinking that it doesn’t need some part of its self or that it doesn’t find absolute value in all of its parts

[@kyritsitonakis5802]

Greetings my friend, I am reading through comments before watching... It's an odd thing but it's symbolically like reading a book from the back page to the front...the end to the beginning if you will. Your comment is profound and I do wonder how many will garner an insight into how truly revealing it is.... The manifested human body is a lens into the eternal truth... And so is the diverse state and manifested body of each human when compared to another... Until we grasp that the individual body is a micro of the macro body and how we see one determines if we find peace and rest in the other...otherwise we reap what we sow. The good news is that a way out has been provided - a safety net if you will. I always wondered about dreams - what they are, where they come from and why they exist....such is life. ❤️🫂❤️

[@CozyCori]

Love the open mindedness and clearly laid out knowledge here. Beautiful✨

[@soniaprivate2160]

Brillant ! Yuval Noah just got schooled. Thank you for such beautiful insights and TRUTH.

[@doctorstarcrumbs]

Yuval is definitely only echoing the WEF playbook. Word for word. Wouldn’t be surprised if AI wrote the books.

[@espucs]

Could be, still I find AI to be more spiritual 😂

[@zachstone6717]

The entire 2.5 hours was educational and captivating. I had not heard of Yuval Harari prior to listening to this but have struggled with the concept of nothing has meaning / value vs. everything has meaning / value. I too have, what I believe to have been, direct experience with the divine but there is always that nagging question.... "is what I experienced actually real?". It felt as real as any reality I've experienced but I cannot know for certain. I continue to land on hope for the best (everything has meaning) and prepare for the worst (nothing has meaning). I have found peace in that. The hope that everything has meaning and purpose will continue to drive me towards cohesion, connection, and helping to create a better story.

[@kyritsitonakis5802]

Beautifully and authentically spoken my friend... I too have wondered.... Whilst I choose to believe (faith truly is a remarkable gift - like believing in the inherent goodness in someone when their actions say otherwise and then living by faith out of that paradigm)....I understand and seek to accept each person's personal experience and position in this human experience... That being said recently I inquired as to the origin, meaning and purpose of dreams. I have never met a person who did not experience them, believe they were real while they were in them and discover they "were not real" only when they awoke... I believe our capacity to experience dreams is a divine gift to encourage us to not worry....nothing real can hurt you for reality and truth is love, thus nothing unreal "really" exists. This "human experience" has purpose - it came from order because it is sustained by order - not man made governments but the very source/origin of life...therefore everything from order cannot be without order or it would not come from order....how it behaves reflects who it is... This is why I am completely comforted by my faith in the divine and far more motivated to fulfill the eternal's purpose during my temporal experience - to be loved and to love....for we are LOVE. ❤️🫂❤️

[@callistorb]

❤ Thank you for sharing To keep it short. 1. Practicality is more Important than truth 2. The source of life is unfathomable and unknowable for humans 3. Life interact with the source of life to bring about new forms of manifestation, constantly evolving. 4. Everything is interdependent, interactive and interconnected 5. Through the interaction of life in manifestation and life coming into manifestation perception is created 6. Perception is the foundation for all of life. 7. Nothing in our realm exists apart from perception. Thus there is no absolute truth and depending on the Votw and perspective experience is brought about. 8. There are laws governing the universe we life in which influence life, even if the perception is not aligned with those laws. How does this resonate?

[@callistorb]

And on the line of purpose. The purpose is what is implied in if the source of life interacts with life. Following this it is the refinement of what life and life in manifestation is - which is inherent and evolving awareness

[@brushstroke3733]

For me, the truth usually lies in paradoxes, such as existence is both meaningful and meaningless. However, in this case I tend to lean more toward existence is meaningless. Why? Just extrapolate out to infinity. If existence is infinite, what purpose could it possibly have? A purpose is like a destination or a final result. If existence is infinite, there is no final destination or result. In the end, these questions are fun for our monkey minds to play with, but they could only have value if existence does have a purpose and meaning. But who would that purpose and meaning be for? God? What is the purpose and meaning of God then? Who or what created God with that purpose in mind?

[@apariver]

Awesome. Can't wait for the one with Marc and Paul Selig...

[@KerstinTuschik]

So excited about this so-needed podcast. Thank you, Marc! Thank you, Aubrey!

[@AgelessArt]

Deep in the process of writing a grant for Project Create Peace, a new symbol of Peace to the world. The core principles of which all perfectly align to these concepts and listening to this have leveled up our ask in a profound way. This is how we change the world, thank you. Your contributions to the field of value is far-reaching and transformative. #ProjectCreatePeace is our catalyst to a new story, one that is not dependent upon words, but focuses on an energy we create based on a belief in a future where we value life. This new symbol of Peace is the icon of the New Earth. You have blessed us in this conversation. May that same energy come back to you 100-fold. Looking forward to more mind opening conversations like this in the future!

[@janetjacks3406]

Professor Richard Tarnas, (who worked hand in glove with Stanislav Grof), speaks to this current post modern and archetypal crisis that is manifesting and the meaning of this in terms of representing a birthing of an new and expanded consciousness in mankind. Richard Tarnas, and of course Stan Grof who are well versed in none ordinary states of consciousness seemed to have this understanding years ago, so ahead of his time, Richard wrote the extraordinary book Passion of the Western Mind which chartered the entire history of western thought right through Jung and the implications of quantum theory and gave a good context as to where we are now, it was the best book I ever attempted to read and I understood how the numinous was moving through the collective to bring things into the zeitgeist at the correct time for our own evolution.

[@kellyryanobrien1]

!! I gotta read this

[@boulderguitarcoach5269]

Great book! Informed my understanding of the development of western thought.

[@jillelainestalkingbearwrig8873]

Bravo to both of you for your courage, wisdom, audacity, tremendous research and Soul Searching in creating and sharing this important message. i do hope that Yuval does receive and respond to Rebbe Gafni's generous and sincere invitation to a dialogue. AHO

[@carolspencer6915]

Good morning Marc and Aubrey Your style of communication here to and regards Yuval seems to me very reminiscent of my many attempts over many years to communicate the bull shit said, written and indeed still unresolved (although forgiven) regards me by a few stupid bullying type nurses within a diabolical professional management team. So much nonsense although dangerous words spoken and written shared with multiple professionals within a health board. They after years of this, a one wee woman, one sided fight got my resignation(again forgiven). Was such a great big learning curve, that I most certainly and eventually did wake the feck up to. What I now recognise as evil silly stupid little people. Truth and story most greatly crucial to our meaning. Story terribly short! Truly grateful for both you guys over these crazy passing years. Sanity sensemaking brain gym, indeed. 💜

[@isaacmullins9804]

About time someone put that dude in his place

[@20.000MeilenunterdemMeer]

Harari will sink into insignificance. No one will remember. He is unimportant.

[@yasyas618]

you are wrong. the reason the very tippy top have brought him in is becomes his anthropological theory is a foundational support of their future worldview; it is a very powerfully thought out explanation the problem for them is that the scientific explanations of all this doesn’t actually legitimize their ultimate motives and desires and he is important for both of these reasons

[@The_Real_Casey_Timmins]

@@yasyas618sounds unimportant to me. I am sure these world leaders have yachts too. Those too are unimportant to me. Why give the man importance when he is nothing of importance?

[@yasyas618]

@@The_Real_Casey_Timmins that is the dumbest rebuttal I’ve ever heard “why attribute significance and importance to the people who control every aspect of the whole world ?” 👆you sound like a child and I say this as sincerely as possible in an effort to shift the conversation in the direction of critical thinking rather than ignorant buffoonery

[@neotao9]

Most people will sink into insignificance, but you’ve all is Yuval is an insightful person, and his book sapiens is amazing

[@GlitchInTheSkatricks]

Who?

[@scriming]

very, very much appreciated! The world needs this!

[@packardsonic]

We must start to talk about human needs instead of human rights. They match up but needs are found scientifically because they are NEEDS, that means that we cannot go without them. Scientifically we can conclude that if the lack of something produces pathologies, we know it is a human NEED. Most of our needs are psychological. Raising awareness about them is the most effective way to improve society because once people understand that all humans can become either a benefit or a burden (or danger) to everyone else depending on whether or not all their needs have been met and are being met, they develop a responsibility for others.

[@gilland2000]

There was an interview with Yuval shortly after the attack on Israel on Octt. 7. He was shaken and nervous. He referred to the 'soul' several times, as if he had never claimed the soul doesn't exist. He unapologetically talked about the collective 'soul' of Israel. And his own soul as well. Not sure if the interview is still online. But it was extremely revealing.

[@avdhutcrazzypapajiboy7705]

i remember this one time i felt like no matter what i did, people just didn’t notice me. i tried everything-confidence boosters, social tips, you name it-but nothing seemed to work. then i found this book, Magnetic Aura by Takeshi Mizuki, and it completely shifted how i saw myself. it’s not just about being noticed; it’s about understanding the energy you project. honestly, this book made all the difference for me. if you’ve ever felt invisible, you need to read it.

[@claymorgan5977]

Thanks for sharing. Good luck and good energy on your journey!

[@claymorgan5977]

Love this guy lol. Thanks for going all in and not holding back!

[@mormormormor1400]

Thank you for this! Makes a wonderful beginning of this great year of cleanse and change. Brings hope that we"re really on our way to do better of the world and to each other. ❤

[@lesworks]

If you can't dazzle 'em with brilliance, baffle 'em with bullshit.

[@handsolo704]

That's just like, your opinion man.

[@chunksofhistory]

Excellent so far - we can recognize someone’s meaningful contributions and simultaneously cast importent doubt on their idea that there is no meaning. We live in a field of value and humans are individuals with immeasurable and vast meaning and value in the story of life. Must be an empty and sad life to believe that’s not true

[@Servicetothesoul]

Life itself is an opportunity to create meaning

[@SamTorode]

This is one of the most important podcast episodes I've ever heard. All thinking people need to listen to this! I read "Sapiens" when it first came out, and Harari's focus on story initially appealed to me because I love Joseph Campbell. But Harari says all stories are delusions, while Campbell (and Gafni) point to the truths that can only be conveyed through stories. As Campbell said so often, myths aren't lies, they're metaphors. I'd listened to a couple of Aubrey's interviews with Marc previously, but this one really grabbed me and sent me deeper into his profound work. I've been happily struck by ways that my graphic novel, "The Dirty Parts of the Bible," resonates with the vision of story & eros Marc is expressing.

[@sara-bg8ke]

I just didn’t want this podcast to end. A huge thank you for exposing the transhumanist Yuval for what he really is, a very scary human hating sociopath that has too much coverage.

[@TerrarianLibrarian]

Thank you, Marc and Aubrey 🙏

[@eartgmutha]

Great conversation, thank you

[@karlfirstenhaupt8104]

Before meditation and realizing our world is not a materialist, reductionist dead thing i thought like yuval. So I can see how and why he believes what he does. Marc is doing it the right way, using the intellect to bring out the inherent flaws in yuvals views. This is the given path for "intellectuals" to ease up on their egos and allow themselves to use knowledge to create space within. This space is the doorway and knowing may slip in, clearing the fog as it were.

[@RafaMartinelli]

Just want to take a break from this really important discussion for one sec to mention Marc is great on Curb Your Enthusiasm 😂

[@brushstroke3733]

I liked him in "Wall Street".

[@molehead01]

51.30 it’s the laughter of letting go. It’s the laughter of enlightenment, the moment you realise it’s all a story. Its liberating.

[@jamessaltlife]

Alex Jones spoke out against this man in ‘The Great Reset’. Basically saying he’s a transhumanist WEF puppet. I find it hard when he speaks to Sam Harris because they both seem like highly intelligent men, and what they say does somewhat make sense, but it’s not born out of Love. Love is the answer.

[@kyritsitonakis5802]

Amen ❤️🫂❤️

[@LisaHealYourself]

Harari scares me beyond words. He’s creepy soulless power hungry Hater of humanity - and I truly feel he is the opposite of all that humanity is at our soul. I’m so glad for this interview. I actually think you give Yuval too much credit in this interview. He’s a WEF trans humanist at heart. His ideas lead to the destruction of true humanity.

[@MarcGafni]

(This is a personal note from Dr. Marc Gafni shared by the team, in response to any negative comments about Yuval) Friend, I appreciate your passion. And.. let’s work together to raise the conversation. Sometimes we need to draw our sword and fight the good fight. I am doing that with Yuval. But we must always fight with honor and open heart. My working premise is that Yuval is a good man who cares deeply about the world. We want to treat him with honor, feel his goodness, and hold the depth of his intention. No invective, no name-calling, no demonizing. And at the same time our swords are drawn. This is not an issue of multiple perspectives. The claim that Yuval makes: “any meaning that people ascribe to their lives is mere delusion,” is a soul-destroying claim. It chills the flame of love. It seeks to slay our knowing that love is real, that love is ultimately meaningful, and that Love, Goodness, Truth and Beauty ultimately matter. So we have to take this head on, we have to unsheathe Manjushri’s sword of discernment, we need to be warriors for love. But always with an open heart. Always with honor and respect. Even when fierce. Fierce, yet tender. And in the end our goal is not to slay our adversary, but to participate together in real conversation for the sake of telling a new Story of Value, for the sake of the Evolution of Love. This must be our response to the meta-crisis of our time, which is at its core a meaning-crisis. So let’s be fierce and let’s be Outrageous Lovers. We live in a world of outrageous pain, the only response to Outrageous pain is Outrageous Love. Thank you for taking the time to read, listen and consider. Outrageous Love, Marc

[@maketheworldabetterplace5624]

I would love to see a debate with Yuval and this gentleman on Aubrey's show. Moderators would have to be like Marianne Williamson and Ru Paul.

[@janeshannon8712]

Thank u for actually saying this ❤️💯

[@ChadNErdProd]

This is what we needed to hear.

[@deshaebeasley]

Five topics to fix society via discussion: -Anti-natalism vs Natalism -The 3 basic needs/prenatal needs Three things necessary for human evolution that are provided while in the womb which are; food, shelter and medical care. -Platinum rule Do whatever makes one happier unless it interferes with another persons ability to do the same. -MBTI (research yours and connect with others) -Art (pick one and get better at it!)

[@nnn-pr3vr]

15 minutes in and I love this. So perfect for where i'm at intellectually right now.

[@ahavahtobah]

that last clip of Yuval speaking about trust and how it's cynical and actually impossible to survive without it, and how dictatorship can only be based on terror and is bad, seems very at odds with the rest of his philosophy that has been presented here, very cynical and nihilistic. was that clip with trevor noah from many years ago? it just doesn't jive with everything you say is in his books. for the record I have not read harari but whatever i saw of him a year ot two ago, i was not interested in hearing further. but i think what you are doing is important since he has the ear of many important people and millions of children, for God's sake

[@missh1774]

I have a few favorite lines from Yuval's Sapien book and I was able to optimize my working theory to address the things he questioned about civilizations and money.

[@arbez101]

One could say Dr. Yuval created his own fantasy devoid of the 'values hierarchy' Dr. Marc is espousing.

[@Daneiladams555]

The most brilliant breakdown Thanks

[@bert3736]

one of the positive things Harari has going for him is a life long commitment to meditation in the theravada tradition. my hope is mr Harari becomes aware of, openly takes in and allows this very cogent and compassionate critique to move him. this would of course require putting ego aside. so lets aspire this creates some changes in his subsequent work. wouldn't that be nice?

[@jackdezmen572]

Thank you both Aubrey and Marc You both are the divine presence of God I see you brothers thank you for your service and the sweet love. You’re now on my heart and prayer. may all the wisdom and strength keep on shining and growing inside and around you today, tomorrow and always Warmest regards Thank you Namaste

[@liviubeschieri]

My sense is that Yuval is using Zen Buddhist ideas of no self (anatta) which describe subjective experience as illusory and reality as nondual... he seems to be using that as a cover and confirmation for the current scientific thinking. From his perspective it all probably makes a lot of sense, we're material beings, with an internal subjective experience that ultimately when inquired into proves to be an illusion, as most mystical/nondual traditions also point to. But I think the actual issue is that he skips the middle part of actual religious thinking, as most atheistic thinkers do, they dismiss the divine logos, or field of value as Marc is pointing out. If you're atheistic, it's easy to strip religion away of its divine ground and jump to the deeply mysterious conclusion that "there's no one" without realizing that there is also Everything, the absolute Brahman or Godhead, or Tao, or field of value, in which everything arises. In the end you realize that there's no self because there's ONLY God. Not that "there's no self, so there's no God, no value, and only materialism." Sure, ultimately the egoic subject may be a fictional reality, but only because it was a reflection of the functional reality that is already the case. The egoic mind seems to be moving from innocent ignorance of the divine, to eventual awareness of it, and thus dissolution into it, leaving only the functional reality (field of value). The ego matures by transcending its conceptual and insecure nature, until it gives way to the flow of Tao itself. And arguably, we could also say that there's a meta-reality which nonduality is pointing to, where the whole meaningful play of Leela is a dream. But these are ultimate terms, not "truths" to be mixed and matched with various other stages of development. Just a few thoughts that came up for me. But overall great presentation, very insightful.

[@Backinthedase]

I've never heard of Yuval.. but after the initial clips, one thing it seams like, when he's speaking about those things, he doesn't seam happy, peaceful, or loving. He seams cold, frustrated, and passionately pessimistic..

[@julielemieux9436]

Thank you so much for this work you do! Thank you for bringing awareness and light onto value. You, Mr Gafni, along with Nassim Haramein and so many others are shattering the belief systems and are empowering forces for all life forms.We call his work: propaganda. This won't last and won't work. The universe is a self sustaining intricate web in which we are part of, everything and nothing! Much blessings

[@TerrarianLibrarian]

"Reality has an appetite for value" - Alfred North Whitehead

[@advocem895]

Great to listen mr MG.

[@alonaredvanski]

Harari is one of the bad guys.. spreading their messages and fear.. nothing to listen there to.. Thank you both ❤

[@soyasibonnie]

I havent read harari so I feel kind of out of the loop. But what Marc describes of him and his work makes me think about the ramped nihilism I see in today's society, which is the polar opposite side of the awakening in consciousness I see also. Perhapse harari is resonating with the later.

[@Coco-nl3ft]

Very good to see an actual critique of YN, so needed, we need more of this and in books too, to deface the global agenda, thanks

[@Hieye.]

Peace and Love to you all ♥️

[@nuppyours]

Hey brother- please stop with the clickbait titles for your videos. The truth is important but these titles are trivial. Your podcasts with Mr. Gafni are some of you best work!!

[@janetjacks3406]

Post modernism and the crisis of meaning started with Immanuel Kant but is now fully manifest in every system. In the currency system you can see it as the loss of the gold standard, so every currency is now just relativized to each other, the gold standard meaning the loss of a true anchor or value. This existential alienation, and nihilistic hell that meaning is only what is prescribed or projected out by an individual into a meaningless universe, that nothing is inhered with meaning itself and nothing therefore apart from oneself can be known, you are alone. This is its brutal message and completely wrong but it signifies the birth of the beautiful cosmic feminine principle. I think Marc should read or investigate Richard Tarnas, if he hasn't already, as his level of genius and insight I have never seen paralleled.

[@forbearancemp5283]

Thank you for this discussion gentlemen. This is a keeper! Steiner once spoke about the spirit of the age dictating the content of Nietzsche's book God is Dead. I suspect Harari is also taking dictation. I think I'll be getting David Temple's book.

[@bradbatten8953]

Thank you.

[@MechanicsAndCarpentry369]

This is going to be good.

[@ornaraz-s7o]

The purpose is Love, Light and Healing to the collective from Israel 🙏

[@ca9125]

Aubrey: JUST SO YOU KNOW, I have never gotten as many ad interruptions as I’m getting watching this video. Someone does not like you are showing us this bright mind in action.

[@dukegust8818]

utube premium no ads

[@GalliWayno]

Now that I'm 44. I'm genuinely starting to feel more and more that life has no meaning. Every time I do psychedelics, i feel more at home when I'm in that experience, than I do in this reality...!

[@Sieism]

Maybe they are not separate realities. At the very least they would have to be parts of a larger over arching reality, right? I mean, they are existing, they have to be existing somewhere.

[@triskelionchi3747]

A fulfilled life springs from an over flowing soul, it is not acquired as an animal scours for food. The fundamental mis step, that created much of the tension as we have reached at the end of this evolutionary stage, due primarily to habit, is chasing the mirage of fulfillment or resolution arising from an external source. You do not lack anything, just as a sapling is not lesser for not already being the mighty oak. Do away with thoughts and notions which pull you outward, chasing a carrot on a stick, a projection of some other time and place when all is well. The more you search in the labyrinth of your mind, the more you break things down with the cutting instrument of your intellect, the more alienated you make your self concept from the rest of everything else. You lose contact with meaning when everything becomes a category, when it all must be grasped by the faculties of the thinking mind. You are not who you think you are, because you are not your thoughts. If you are identified with a concept, you are subject to the process of your minds endless labeling and puzzling as you lay the weight of your existence upon it and turn yourself and life into a problem to solve. Life is not a problem to solve, it's a reality to experience. Psychedelics break down the artificial walls and divides your mind has constructed. You feel life return to you because you are no longer alienating yourself through a filter of thoughts. These constructs of thought are ultimately arbitrary, as even the first cut of the intellect preconditions all that follows. Reason is a raft made of ice, dependent on frozen notions disconnected from the ocean it emerged from. While it is a useful tool for gaining a new vantage point, it cannot offer you a full gnosis as it remains forever partial and disconnected. Life stands on a bedrock that precedes the formation of thought. Thought is an abstraction from a reality that can only be known and never truly comprehended by the domain of mind. The mind consists of the island of the known and the ocean of the unknown. Without the heart, one has no will to expand beyond the shores of the known, nor any desire understand and find connection with what is discovered. The heart is the compass, and the mind is the medium or interface for this adventure. Allow yourself the humility to permit your eyes open again in wonder, for you surely know infinitely less than you might ever imagine. Abandon the mental toys of thought and reason which alienate you through their obsessive division, spiraling towards despair and disconnection. There is nothing to figure out, you must allow the pieces to come back together so you can remember that sense of meaning and connection to life you have for so long estranged yourself from.

[@hemannft4744]

Thank you 🙏 ❤

[@tmc8195]

Yuvals work sounds like the poster child for the Arhiman (Robert Gilbert’s interpretation of them)

[@guterkritiker]

"You are all worthy… if you weren’t already worthy, believe me, you wouldn’t exist, because Creation does not make mistakes. Thus, if you exist, you belong. There’s a reason why Creation is not complete without you! Stop arguing with Creation about your worth. Take it at its word… if you exist, you deserve to exist. And if you deserve to exist, you deserve to be who you are as fully as you possibly can." (Bashar)

[@kyritsitonakis5802]

Well said.... ❤️🫂❤️

[@joshuavanderplaats]

Aubrey: Not exactly a fan of yours, but this is one of the best videos that I have seen you do. Thank you for using your platform to address what is a deeply disturbing ideology which we can all feel as “chilling” in the mad and fascist man named Juval. A deeply disturbed and unhappy gay man who cannot accept the fact that he is not comfortable in his own skin. Your kindness to this man is exactly what we need more of in order to rehabilitate such people to loving “Life” again. Nihilism is not the way.

[@MechanicsAndCarpentry369]

He condemns stories that define who we are by admitting he intends to make up stories created by the state to steer mankind in a new direction which probably lead off a cliff. What am I missing here? Am I missing something here?

[@IcarusFlyby]

I have never read a single word that Yuval Noah Harari has written, Yuval is a Israeli historian. I grew up Roman Catholic in Carmel Indiana. Despite my interest in mysticism, my upbringing was so toxic that I was unable to 'listen' to the Aubrey interview of Sean O'Laoire a (excommunicated) mystic Catholic priest. I feel compassion for Yuval. What a wide chasm to cross.

[@kyritsitonakis5802]

Greetings my friend... I am not certain what to say at this moment....your comment stopped me, literally in my tracks. We struggle to recognise the simple signs.... The two things that occur to me point me to the divine and eternally providential love... One are dreams Two are children (more specifically new born infants) Both of these are phenomenon to me.... Firstly in the case of children.... I can boldly say that never in the history of human experience (even though children have been sacrficed) has anyone ever been able to point to an infant and find fault....perfectly innocent with nothing but hope. The second being dreams to be literally mimic life... They come without my doing, they appear "real" and they end (well I realise they are not real) only when I wake. In all of that, the individual human body within the plethora of human bodies provides an answer to the purpose of existence and more specifically the "human experience".... The answer I believe lies within each of us and we are able to give it to share it with our children so that as they grow they too discover that their inner voice confirms the same truth....that we are one and we are love - eternal light. Love and blessings my friend... ❤️🫂❤️

[@TechnoMageCreator]

The Mayan calendar famously ended in 2012, the exact same year researchers made critical breakthroughs that paved the way for the powerful AI we see today. It’s no coincidence these leaps in technology seem to line up with universal energies. From a consciousness perspective, it makes sense: as a species, we’re evolving toward a more interconnected existence. We create our reality through our thoughts, words, and actions, and for centuries, we’ve asked questions, learned from experience, and stored our knowledge in countless books and other media. Now, we’ve funneled all that collective wisdom into a machine capable of linking ideas on an unprecedented scale-essentially reflecting our collective mind back to us. AI can help uncover subtle beliefs and biases we hold, and used correctly, it becomes a powerful tool to enhance consciousness and cognition. Rather than viewing it as something separate or ominous, we can see AI as a natural progression of humanity’s quest for deeper understanding. It’s a mirror of our knowledge and creativity-and if we handle it responsibly, it has the potential to elevate our awareness both individually and as a global community.

[@mary-anncarleton7578]

Right on for this podcast guys ....... Sooo appreciated. Yuval is not well. Obviously

[@erikamateo3382]

Magnificent! 🎉❤

[@raymondwitvoet]

One of the best ever for me...

[@DanielLeschziner]

“A organism is a algorithm” If you believe our reality is a computer simulation, which is one of the explanations of our realm, then he must be right

[@adrianazollo2688]

thanks Aubrey!

[@sarazephyr8224]

I'm going to say something that may sound controversial. But every time I hear someone speaking to convince people that their life, life in general has no meaning..I think to myself, OK then why do you stay alive. Why not takeyourselfoutthen?? This feeds nihilism and depression. Very sad. And he made children's books?? Yikes

[@georgetheofilopoulos5341]

Imagine how far have we fallen in intellectual levels that Yvalili Hararini is the best philosopher of our time allegedly. He is clueless about philosophy

[@deanellis3468]

Your comment is a complete bastardization of English in both spelling and grammar. I don’t know if you’re the best judge of high-level analytic philosophy.

[@yahrayennea4136]

Love this

[@SamGlaser]

Hi Rabbi. Thanks for taking on Yuval. Such damage done.

[@jonnyblamey]

“Value is immeasurable” I think for an intelligent educated audience you ought to disambiguate “value”. When you make a measurement the result is a value. “What is the value on the thermometer” ans: 14 degrees Celsius. Also value/ price/ worth are near synonyms and can usually be substituted without loss of meaning. So although you have carefully articulated an assault on Yuval H. It is not clear that he is claiming that any ascription of “value” to life is delusional. Or that £50 is more valuable than £20. When he says any meaning ascribed to life is delusional, he doesn’t have the functional unity of the atom in mind. He has some devine purpose ordained by God in mind. By the way I broadly agree with the Temple line here. I am just pointing out a rhetorical move that you have made that might be illigitimate.

[@TheUtopiaStream]

AI will never replace our limbic system.

[@DionizaBorys]

I’d love to see Jerry Willis on your podcast, he disappeared into a stone portal - Aramu Muru. Spoiler, he came back! 😅

[@internalmethods]

If you've ever heard a public speech by Yuval, it's obvious that he contradicts himself constantly. The word "constantly" is important as the easiest part of making propaganda work is the repetition.