Authenticity of Kitab Sulaym

Does it have a Sahih Sanad? Is this book authentic?

[@EmranMuradi-vc7zv]

Allhamdullillah I left the rawafidh cult

[@muhammadhaydar3073]

Salam 'alaykoum, you make a distinction between ussulis and akhbaris to tell us that the ussulis have a good methodology and that the akhbaris have none. You ignore the fact that the akharis are part of the ancient Shiite tradition and that Kulayni himself was of this tradition which did not prevent him from doing serious work. Secondly, the ussulis have always had this inclination to smooth out their speeches and forget the tabarra to please the Sunnis in the name of the unity of Muslims and the Ummah. Third, as I have said in many comments, are you focusing on one book as if it were the only one to mention the events after the death of the Prophet (saas)? this is not the case, countless sources, both Shiite and Sunni, mention them.

[@descendancedenoefilsdadam1028]

These hindou are very bad example of the globalisation in shiism. There is a narrations about them labeling are stupid individuals even in Kitab Al Kafy. الهند السند والنقد ليس فهم نجيب … They are an insult to shiism and Islam in general.

[@ProAhlulBayt1]

Mention what? That Umar killed Fatima (ra)? Please provide your other sources. They all have been refuted. Of course Akbaris just accept anything, so their proof is not really proof.

[@descendancedenoefilsdadam1028]

@@ProAhlulBayt1 what is your ethnicity ? In shia ahadith even in the Kafy the hindous and pakistani are labeled as stupid.

[@ProAhlulBayt1]

@@descendancedenoefilsdadam1028 Bihar is against Blacks.| >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> It is a well-known fact that the Prophet had an admirable sense of humour - although even in witticism, he never spoke but truth. Once an old lady of Medina asked him to pray to Allah to give her a place in the Paradise. The Prophet said, "Old women would not enter the Paradise." She went out crying. Bilal saw her and asked her why she was crying. She narrated the whole episode. Bilal came with the lady to the Prophet, and said, "This woman is narrating such and such from you?" The Prophet said, "Even black men would not enter the Paradise." Now Bilal too started crying. Then 'Abbas, the uncle of the Prophet reached there and learning of the episode, tried to intercede with the Prophet, who told him that even old men would not enter the Paradise. When he too joined the crying group, the Prophet told them to be cheerful because Allah would create them young and with bright faces and then they would go into Paradise al-Majlisi, Hayatu'l Qulub, pp. 129-130; Bihar, vol. 16, p. 295.

[@descendancedenoefilsdadam1028]

@@ProAhlulBayt1 Bilal was not your average N . Only his mother was ethiopian hence the Nickname Ibn sawda by abu dharr. People of Nawba are thé descendant of Kush with caucasoid ancestry in middle east not as your nigerian West coastal zunuj.

[@descendancedenoefilsdadam1028]

ليس فهم نجيب - كتاب الكافي

[@mdmedia5095]

Very funny you guys criticise Tahreef of Quran in this book when in Sunni books there's heaps of evidence of verses missing and sahaba have given shahadah that the Quran they complied is missing verses. In fact Sunni believe there were 5 versions of the Quran and we only have the 1 version today so where are the other 4? If you say Shia Hadith also contain hadith that there are verses missing from the Quran we have today then that's ijma between Shia and Sunni hadiths. Your beloved Khalifa Umar said himself there are verses missing from the Quran and your mother Aisha said the goat ate verses of the Quran.

[@soothingandmediating5426]

Bruh u r jahil about this topics thats why u r saying all these stuf

[@mdmedia5095]

@@soothingandmediating5426 who are you calling a jahil. If you had read both shia and sunni text you wouldn't say that. So you're the jahil