不会说华语的大马华人？！背后的真实原因！频道史上第一部说英语的影片！

不会说华语的大马华人？！背后的真实原因！频道史上第一部说英语的影片！｜Mamak Talk EP5 ft.

Рет қаралды 112,367

Ling BigYong

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 241

@Jinnyboy Ай бұрын

I’m here, clicking on “translate to English” on all the comments lollll, thanks for having me!

@ngcollin88 Ай бұрын

Glad u realised that in this day and age, social media industry in the region 🇲🇾🇸🇬 requires ‘all-in-one’ aka baokaliao language abilities.. Even the famous hero namewee 黄明志 - 华小+独中educated and his core management team (perm status senior staff) need to be highly proficient in both Chinese and English in order to work and reach out internationally.

@ahquan15 Ай бұрын

The collab we need, but we don’t deserve! The best YT OGs who inspired me to start KZbin!

@lamkw6329 Ай бұрын

There was one time i was taking MRT and i saw this Chinese couple, 1 spoke Mandarin, and another spoke Cantonese...and both of them communicate throughout the journey 🤣 which i find it interesting. But as a Cantonese/ Mandarin speaker, whenever i go out i also speak Cantonese first, but people won't look at me like 1 kind la 🤣 honestly, I prefer Cantonese first, Mandarin 2nd 🤣🤣

@leealex24 29 күн бұрын

@@lamkw6329Canto first in KL

@selfmadegod8341 27 күн бұрын

You're such a disgrace for not being linguistic as a Chinese, shame on you 😢😢😢

@fuka1843 Ай бұрын

只会中文的烦恼：不会用英文沟通只会英文的烦恼：不会用华语沟通都会的烦恼：看到华人不懂要先讲什么语言好😂

@JirachiJirachi Ай бұрын

去新國一趟就遇到这个problem了，看他们明明是华人，开口和他们说华语，他们却到用英语回答我说他们不会说中文，有时还故意挑比较老一辈的人来问的，结果还是尴尬了所以第二天开始遇到几次华人就试着用英语和他们交流还有问路，一直到问到那人也不知道怎么回答我，他开口用华语和身边的朋友进行交流的时候，才知道其实他们都会说华语的，那么一开始我为什么还要和他们说英文？到现在想了还是觉得有点好笑

@guanmooiwong7051 Ай бұрын

博主的English 有待加强

@watson5245 Ай бұрын

@@JirachiJirachi 笑死人。在新加坡看到黄皮肤的就100％是华人？有留胡子的就是胡须张？我在新加坡某所大学的实验室，有一位亚裔的国际交换生同学被中国籍博士生刁难，质问交换生为什么不说中文。他直接回怼那博士生，他是某东亚/东南亚国人，又不是墙国人。所以说，不要以为看到黄皮肤就是华人。

@nicholasxamotainiumgilgamesh 20 күн бұрын

@@guanmooiwong7051另外两位的华语有待加强？

@juntatlaw Ай бұрын

大马华人如果不会华文的话不会丢脸的但是只要你有心想要学习华文相信身边的人一定都会支持你因为学多一种语言就是多一个趋势有一句话说的很好《失败并不可怕可怕的是放弃自己》

@winson875 Ай бұрын

当然这里不是华人国家，有些华人还在认为自己活在大中国脚下。

@winson875 Ай бұрын

对啊，有些华人还在认为自己活在大中华脚下。

@ymsamantha Ай бұрын

說得對，只看你自己有沒心學而已。

@cyl5533 Ай бұрын

为什么你不说马来文，印度人也要学华语多个语言就有个优势

@surayamysara Ай бұрын

那我们也要学多马来文哦

@alstonchyemlp Ай бұрын

Jinnyboy终于上你的频道了👍 有些大马华人不会讲华语很正常，我在安顺中学的老师也是华人兼佛教，但他也是不会讲华语的

@lengyeowang4147 24 күн бұрын

馬六甲信仰南傳佛教的華人，不一定會講華語！

@alstonchyemlp 24 күн бұрын

@lengyeowang4147 也对，只会说他们的方言，这个很正常

@lengyeowang4147 23 күн бұрын

@ 「方言」這個名詞，帶有歧視，還是用「母語」吧！

@alstonchyemlp Ай бұрын

我相信总有一天Jinnyboy是可以去学讲华语的，目前青体部长杨巧双也是在学习着，以后他在和你们拍影片的时候可以很顺利和你们对话了，就好像Joseph Germani一样肯说几句华语，他也可以向和他同样圈子的Joseph Germani学习一点华语也是好的👍

@comet2070 Ай бұрын

有心是可以学的 wabikong的bernice也是banana 但是她现在在节目讲的华语都ok

@alstonchyemlp Ай бұрын

@@comet2070 对，她的华语现在的确是OK了，那天看她访问沈志强的时候都OK

@eddykhoo6338 Ай бұрын

OMG, jinnyboy! My childhood channel, so excited to see Jin

@nysesgoh9628 Ай бұрын

这个video就是legend了吧三个大名鼎鼎的youtuber居然聚在一起讲英文哈哈哈哈😂 你们多聊聊行不🤣 来个encore

@raymondtanchokhui9369 29 күн бұрын

Dennis, I was totally educated in English ..... Also in a Catholic school. I picked up Mandarin from listening to Mandarin songs and watching Mandarin movies. May be, you can do that as well. I also picked up Cantonese the same way in songs and movies, and while studying in KL. Now, I am back to Sarawak. The ability in speaking and reading in Mandarin helps me a lot in my work now. Don't give up. Add oil... 没问题的。。。。。。

@bellhonglin6355 Ай бұрын

Great collab for the Malaysia’s English ed and Chinese ed background OG KZbinr ! 🎉

@username-nomad Ай бұрын

Jinny其实知道很多人对不会讲英文有自卑感，所以他很聪明的以一个自己也不会中文很自卑的姿态去交流。很聪明的沟通方式

@comet2070 Ай бұрын

我觉得马来西亚的banana其实没有说那么有优越感毕竟马来西亚华人说华语的还是很多

@callmeshit28 Ай бұрын

Yeah, I know 真情 lol. So happy to see Jin, love to watch your videos too, to me it's like WongFu Productions in Malaysia.

@cyl5533 Ай бұрын

好心不要种族绑架人家啦。那些coment说华人一定要会华语lol 看到吐血。真正的华人母语肯定是方言而不是普通话=中文/华语。那些人说华人一定要会华语你可以问回他那你会方言吗😅

@shyuenkim1479 11 күн бұрын

推

@alstonchyemlp Ай бұрын

你刚好和两个说英文比较流利的youtuber一起也可以帮助你的英文可以更进一步👍

@happyman5476 Ай бұрын

很多人以为香蕉人忘本，以为他们自认清高瞧不起别人。其实这些事情已经是半个世纪前的事了。如果你还持有这个想法，你应该已经是70岁的老人了。

@winson875 Ай бұрын

所以那些香蕉人跟华裔穆斯林的郑全行和黄维雄也差不多一样，那种人。

@MRPROTEO Ай бұрын

其实你们今天会受到英文教育是因为历史因素，讲的明白些是因为当年美国和英国在世界的影响力很大你们的家庭想要想学西方一样厉害，才会讲英文的。

@fuckchinaxi Ай бұрын

雜種中國人很仆街，黃俄孝子

@lamkw6329 Ай бұрын

我是在大概2000年時候讀中學的，那時候很多同學都是大家俗稱的香蕉人，不會看中文，但是呢，我們大家都是用廣東話交流的，那個流利的程度真的很好，之後出來社會我很多朋友也是這樣。。。所以別人說什麼香蕉人，其實我還真沒遇過連方言也不會的華人，最多只是不會華語和不會看中文字而已。。。 🤣

@bnnj7522 Ай бұрын

@@lamkw6329 会广东话不能算不会华语吧？这边也有一辈子只说方言的老人

@HuiMing-d5j 29 күн бұрын

For now language is quite important, English, Chinese, Malay or multiply language is very helpful.Even if you can't talk very well with any language but at least can understood ，but we can try our best to learn and speak out. 😊 现在语言蛮重要的，英文，华语，马来文（国语）或者多语言是可以帮助到很多方面。如果不会讲最少会听明白, 不过我们可以去试着去学习用我们最大的努力试着讲😊

@Wethey-ze4rm Ай бұрын

Jinnyboy is my close friend's uncle. Prioritising English for their first language or daily lives is already in their genes. My friend (jinny's nephew) does speak mandarin but even his family member converse in English whenever we met.

@raymil Ай бұрын

Technically speaking, Mandarin is NOT our native language, it is just a medium language for communication between all Chinese subcultures to unite the Chinese race. Your native language is Cantonese/Teochew, so I’d say you’re fine. Most of us are Southern Chinese and none of our native languages are Mandarin as Mandarin originated from the north, I think it is language and political appropriation to enforce Mandarin on every single Chinese individual who hasn’t been exposed to Mandarin since a young age. In fact, when looking back in history, ancient Chinese were closer to the southern Chinese languages instead of Mandarin, Mandarin has been proven time and time again that it is not the native language of EVERY Chinese.

@ryannieh Ай бұрын

this, like even as someone from SJKC and took chinese during SPM, i have came to the realization (too late unfortunately) that Mandarin is not and will never be our native language and mother tongue i get irritated when people here glorify mandarin like it's their god and savior and shun our real mother tongues, then the adults blame their children for not knowing how to speak the so-called "dialects" when they were the one that discouraged and punished us for not speaking mandarin even in Kuala Lumpur where Cantonese is still somewhat widespread, it hurts when the adults and elderlies reply to me in Mandarin even though I spoke Cantonese or Hakka to them first like dont give up bro :(

@raymil Ай бұрын

@ryannieh I am privileged enough to be raised speaking Mandarin as my native language, but Mandarin should not be forced on any Chinese, because in a way Mandarin is also just a "dialect of the North". Dialects are meant to be mutually telligible, but Chinese isn't, because Mandarin speakers will never understand Hokkien or Cantonese speakers completely, that's why it is Chinese languages not dialects.

@leealex24 29 күн бұрын

Keep canto alive, canto is the lingua franca dialect for klang valley

@wonderfulfable 28 күн бұрын

Thank you for this, It is quite perplexing there is all this glorification of "Mandarin" as the ONLY native language & mother tongue, Sure, I understand the pivot to China due to its steady rise as the a superpower, but there is also this "soft power" influence permeating into everyday life, like XiaoHongShu, China-pop music artistes, China based TV shows, films & dramas. Therefore, using Mandarin as the common language is a no brainer. But this leads to the slow death of other Chinese languages such as Cantonese, Hakka, Teochew, Hokkien, Hainan, Foochow ( Hockchew ). As a 40+ year old Cantonese speaker, it saddens me to see Cantonese being spoken lesser & lesser. Personally, I am forced to pick up business Mandarin in order to get my point across to an increasing amount of Mandarin speaking clients over the years.

@raymil 28 күн бұрын

@wonderfulfable The standardization of Mandarin is useful, but not at the expense of other Chinese languages being assimilated and erased... It is more responsible if the youth are proficient in both Mandarin and their own native language

@wilsonliowweicheng Ай бұрын

马来西亚就是各种可能性，华人不一定说华语，可能马来语和英语比中文流利，我男友就是马来文非常流利，他SPM马来文A1，会写官方书写，所以在公司管理不同族群的员工都很融洽，我也有马来同事她从来没讲过中文，可是无意中看到她打中文信息给朋友，其实都没关系，每个人的生长背景不同，所以造就马来西亚文化的多元😊

@Tom-cf5lk 20 күн бұрын

幸好我是双语的人，两种都会😅 I am glad to be bilingual 😂

@Nonameforme12355 Ай бұрын

我只好奇，很多banana从小都在英文环境下长大，可是语法和用词方面还是很偏向华人，不像西方的native speakers。而且口音也非常重，语助词也很多华人的样子。有时候，跟有些native speakers说话，native speakers有时候会get 不到他们在讲什么

@weelingae8090 Ай бұрын

我觉得是环境导致的，因为在马来西亚就算从小在英文环境下长大，可如果日常沟通的对象也都是bilingual的话就很容易被带跑偏

@OMGMG 21 күн бұрын

英語環境長大是在什麼學校的？當地國際學校？看似口音和文法和公立英文好的也差不多。🤔

@hungchan9479 Ай бұрын

During the old days most of the Klang Valley/Perak speak Cantonese. But more and more migrate from different states plus heavy influence from China so speaking Mandarin become essentials to most of the Chinese.

@leealex24 21 күн бұрын

Then, we must 100% preserve and use much much more our local dialects/language. Penang hokkien and klang valley cantonese. Why must follow that "one" country? This is Malaysia. We're unique.

@anyagamer3510 Ай бұрын

Finally i can watch this mamak talk because i cant understand chinese even though im chinese

@HONJIEHANMoe Ай бұрын

我在家是讲华文的，可是我去我印度朋友家时我和他家人讲英文但他和他妹妹会讲华文，因为我们从小就一起玩的。

@randalsee192 Ай бұрын

Jinnyboy终于上你的影片了！没有想到他会讲英文可是不会讲中文，这是我第一次看你讲英文的Mamak Talk

@nss1296 9 күн бұрын

不是每个人都擅长多语言啊，有些人就是弱语言啊。我大马华人，精通华语粤语，但是马来文和英文就只能基础日常，可能小学生都比我流利。

@aljy-u2z Ай бұрын

My dad learn to speak Chinese coz his daughter speaks Chinese. He went English school. And speak hokien at home.

@viviencc.7576 26 күн бұрын

大多数的马来同胞和印度同胞都比较热爱自己的语言和文化，很少有不会说自己母语的。

@Bowen-u3o Ай бұрын

在中国大陆，普通话=国语（国家级语言），广东话、福建话=方言（省级语言），潮州话=方言（市级语言）。普通话的基础是北京话，一种特殊标准的北京话。另外，中国最大的方言不是广东话，而是东北话！（东北三省说的话）

@新谷-t2s Ай бұрын

東北話最多只能算腔調，連方言都算不上，比北京土話跟普通話的距離還小。普通話就是黑龍江話。

@dhurry2654 Ай бұрын

国际上方言最流行的还是广东话和福建话了，在北美，选择语言的时候Chinese下面特意分为两种Mandarin and Cantonese

@刘仲安 Ай бұрын

东北话其实只能算腔调不能算方言，就算是方言也不是最大的。中国最大的方言应该是西南官话。包括四川、重庆、云南大部分、湖南湖北、贵州大部分的方言都是以西南官话为基础的

@hsiumeimei 24 күн бұрын

Wow Dennis’s english not bad. His sentence structure consider quite good for someone who is used to speaking mandarin.

@zhengyusteadygang5325 Ай бұрын

终于有mamak talk 系列

@Mimijie-qr9pz Ай бұрын

不会讲华语的华人，这才是真实样貌的大马华人，请不要再自认骄傲的认为大马华人都会四，五种语言而觉得沾沾自喜了（这句话要告诉外国人以及大马华人），其实真正的大马华人很多都是混合rojak的语言，不是全部华人都会说全部方言（福建，海南，潮州，粤语，福州，客家）以及华语包括流利的马来文和英文，再纠正一点，外国人说大马华人会4,5种语言以上的内含其实包括着方言而已。其实真实的大马华人不是全部语言都能说的出来的。你不会说华语，我觉得很正常。

@lamkw6329 Ай бұрын

我也是覺得不會華語很正常，畢竟我們婆婆的年代大家都是以自己本身方言交流，就算我在90年代長大也是這樣的，畢竟 “普通話”是以前中華民國和中華人命共和國要團結人民才設定出來的官方語言，然後到了現代大家就認為華人就要會講 MANDARIN ，而不管自己的方言了 🤷‍♂

@Mimijie-qr9pz Ай бұрын

@@lamkw6329 呵呵有些华人连自己的方言也不会说。中文(普通话)才是华人与汉人之间沟通广泛的共同语言，扮演着重要的文化传递角色。如果像你说的你只会说方言不就像你说的停留在奶奶时代只会说自家方言而已嘛？而我在这里主要想表达的是大马华人语言方面其实很rojak，很多人只会说一种或两种方言而已，但往往被外国人认为马来西亚华人都会四，五种语言以上，还认为马来西亚华人都能流利的掌握，其实有些人对语言掌握的程度也不够牢靠。这才是真实的大马华人。甚至有些年轻的华人只会听华语不会写。嘻嘻！

@tengchang7703 18 күн бұрын

啊？不会讲华语的华人才是真实样貌的大马华人？那我们都是假的？

@JirachiJirachi Ай бұрын

还好啦，至少还懂自己是华人，亚洲的其他國，只要不是由华人管理的，统一了，他们很多甚至都不知道自己是华裔了看他们明明是华人，但如果你说他们是华人的话，他们还很生气的，也就是他们跟着國名来称呼自己是什么人，不分种族

@MARZ.Media0412 Ай бұрын

这和自我身份认同有关

@theplaylistpsycho Ай бұрын

身在江湖，身不由己如果指的是泰国/印尼/越南, 完全归于历史/政治因素造成，要称呼自己为华人或有实质的后果

@winson875 Ай бұрын

最怕生在别个种族家庭，从小被洗脑

@lamkw6329 Ай бұрын

你是說台灣人吧？他們覺得華人一詞是中國政治上的東西吧，但是他們在台灣內，都是稱呼自己 “漢人” ，和原住民作為區分的。。。所以我覺得沒問題，如果台灣稱呼自己是漢人，那麼我也和他們聊天時候使用漢人來稱呼自己。

@leealex24 29 күн бұрын

说你是自己的国家，这没有问题。你出生在这里，你的父母甚至祖父母也出生在这里。国籍永远是马来西亚人，但当然，如果你的种族是华人，那么你也可以保留你的文化、生活方式和语言。

@1318peep Ай бұрын

Never knew jinnyboy is actually chinese 🤣

@micheletea9845 Ай бұрын

很喜欢Dennis的性格，很佛系😂

@chuaaa_6466 Ай бұрын

蛮乃哦👍🏻 大咏

@layliansherlynteh8786 Ай бұрын

好看的video❤️😍17亿

@ericlai3221 Ай бұрын

big SHOUTOUT to #jinnyboy & #dennislimming

@weiizhong326 Ай бұрын

可以这个主题不错😂😂😂

@johnsontong3424 Ай бұрын

好久不見了👋🏻

@simSamuel-m6p Ай бұрын

请问可以做搞笑短剧吗？

@wenyaohii3349 Ай бұрын

2大老板

@Cheesebags777 Ай бұрын

Dennis 英文很好诶

@guanmooiwong7051 Ай бұрын

中间博主的英语很差强人意

@LuckyLwee Ай бұрын

BigYong，你知道JianHao Tan吗？

@sleyouwee Ай бұрын

第一🎉

@deRykcihC Ай бұрын

我還以爲sarawakian的英文會不錯因爲多數都是信奉基督 bigyong是不是個例外

@CeliaGoh Ай бұрын

是因為教會都說中文英文也沒辦法變好啊😂😂 但英文不好的砂拉越人的確不多🫣

@yokelengleng Ай бұрын

@@CeliaGoh所以像大咏一样不会英文的sarawakian是少数？

@aljy-u2z Ай бұрын

Sarawak 也有独中

@CeliaGoh Ай бұрын

@@yokelengleng 主要也是看地區和環境啦至少我身邊的英文都很溜來到西馬被誤會是香蕉人的情況也不少畢竟1977教育改革之前多數人都是英教的所以很多80 90孩子在家很多都是跟父母說英文和方言但現在情況可能有所改變尤其數理也改回用馬來文教很多人少了用英文溝通的平台

@1318peep Ай бұрын

@@deRykcihC 有多數信奉基督嗎，我身邊的華人都是拜神拜佛的？我一直覺得我們基督是少數的，而且我去過多個教堂只有「洗禮教」會告訴我要看回英文的聖經才能更深入理解神的話，另外我們是有獨中，但是我也有遇過國中來的學生，英文不好的。然後其實我覺得lby 和他朋友沒有英文不好，但可能在面對一個一生都講英文的人，有點害怕英文太rojak沒有自信。我覺得語言是一個語言和環境需要的事情，我朋友國中生，但是上了大學的時候英語不好，大學時很常用英語，但也需要三年的時間才到不搞錯文法的程度。

@tanchengs5502 Ай бұрын

夢幻聯動！

@daigamessg6725 Ай бұрын

if you staying in JB,100% you can speak Mandarin,my son study in International school,he can speak Mandarin very well.

@lamsimon8458 Ай бұрын

Mean in JB 100% banana can speak well mandarin?

@manachurch Ай бұрын

@@lamsimon8458Yup, I'm from JB and I've seen one of my customers who studied in international school and has an American accent in her English and most of her school mate and friends are western students and Singaporean, but she can speak Mandarin with zero accent just like any other native Mandarin speakers from JB.

@comet2070 Ай бұрын

@@lamsimon8458 I can say mostly. some aunties I met can speak very well mandarin but actually they are english educated just can't read&write

@chuadesmond2485 Ай бұрын

Hello 🎉

@jiashengong6161 Ай бұрын

Ling Big Yong❤❤❤

@skibidi-888 Ай бұрын

大勇：其实我一句都听不懂😂

@LBY Ай бұрын

听完全没问题，平时在看的KZbin影片80%都是英语内容（不需要字幕）。只是因为平时没什么说英语，所以才会像影片里一样说话卡卡的，也没自信😂

@Emelyyy990 Ай бұрын

6😂

@gged8536 Ай бұрын

@@LBY明白你的感受，听完全没问题，但是说出来就是卡卡的

@YukiTiongShiiYao Ай бұрын

真的我也同btu的 @@LBY

@williamting9916 Ай бұрын

从你们的交谈当中，学到很多英文 very fruitful mamak talk 👍

@accel1231 Ай бұрын

现在才知道Jinny的本名，蛮好听的~尤其是用粤语念起来，真是好劲

@MRPROTEO Ай бұрын

@Andy0770 27 күн бұрын

I‘m type 3 Malaysian Chinese, but I wish can know 1 more dialect besides cantonese.

@lilywinbox3944 29 күн бұрын

这就是我们大马人的特色

@agnescheah0785 22 күн бұрын

我比较喜欢讲方言 😊

@lamsimon8458 Ай бұрын

Why not hear Eason Chan song?

@zacnzk8191 Ай бұрын

I must say, Dennis' English is better than Jinny's

@juudaitoushirou 19 күн бұрын

我倒是很奇怪😂我華文的確普通，可是日語倒是比華文好🤣馬來文和中文一樣中等，英文就😅😅😅明明聽得懂，生氣的時候倒是能用英文吵架🤣🤣🤣福建話會聽不會說，粵語小時有看香港劇所以會一些😂

@JunxuanChen-eq6mo Ай бұрын

Ling Big YOng，我读小学的朋友有一个马来人会讲华文

@zhengyusteadygang5325 Ай бұрын

Mamak Talk EP5

@私は退屈です一 Ай бұрын

英文其实我还是可以的马来文就...一言难尽考个L都可以不及格3次

@yenbinnchen1118 Ай бұрын

你自动jiamin吗英威他是我的badminton coach

@johnsontong3424 Ай бұрын

第一！！！！

@adrianlim805 Ай бұрын

上一次大咏说这么多英语还是在他教英文课的时候 😂

@アニメ先生朧之助 22 күн бұрын

芙蓉的话，大部分都是说广东话比较多，只不过我公司那边很多福建人（但他们都是说广东话，因为他们不会说福建话）

@jokfangng529 24 күн бұрын

我的马来文是在踢足球和友族学的，英文是喜欢英文歌和看英文电影学的

@Su-nv2ik 22 күн бұрын

在大马不会講华语的华人叫 '香蕉' 人（banana）

@ancestral_lingo 26 күн бұрын

4:00 “Chinese” doesn't necessarily mean "Mandarin" (勉柢䌢；華北語). Chinese language family (中文語系) / Sinitic language family (漢語語系) consists of Cantonese, Hokkien, Teochew, Hakka, Mandarin, etc. kzbin.info/www/bejne/gaOQnp6aeLiDj7M

@shiqing16 Ай бұрын

我是不会英文的华人😂你们可以多邀请他这样我就可以学一学怎么去讲和看英文

@jacksonyap8442 Ай бұрын

4:59 王力宏本來就是美國長大的人，他到了台灣才開始學習中文

@Switch-iw6md Ай бұрын

我的侄子我哥哥的孩子就快變成香蕉人了幸虧我哥有用華語和客家話和他溝通他只會聽不怎麼會說

@daeju9208 Ай бұрын

会讲广东话就不算banana了😂 就只是比较传统的华人就好像我们的祖先会讲家乡话不会看字那样华文（普通话）本来只是为了统一方便沟通。。。要学还是不要学都可以

@神秘人-u2g Ай бұрын

我来自马来西亚昔加末😊

@WCW2615 Ай бұрын

我理解有些馬來西亞人不會說華文

@alkuan6199 Ай бұрын

英文差真的会很困扰深深理解林big咏😢

@Intermiamifan_ITMI Ай бұрын

下一集讲国文

@kevinwang6147 Ай бұрын

你们讲的不是english ，是manglish

@ahleethay7993 Ай бұрын

对。虽然我不会说英语，但这种英语为宁愿不会🤔

@mycare388 Ай бұрын

是啊singlish and malaylish很难听

@reddamn6960 Ай бұрын

会mandarin还挺有用的。跟台湾人中国人交流会多很多朋友。

@lying9336 Ай бұрын

變了香蕉人😂

@sauchingsauching904 Ай бұрын

我妈妈也是福建人可是她讲华语也是一流的

@supeitan2949 Ай бұрын

@LiepienfWong Ай бұрын

🎉第一🎉

@WenYao90 10 күн бұрын

我个人觉得太多人认为能学中文华文理所当然的事就当作不重要我能懂老一辈人担心出来社会不会英文英语但至少别把我们自己的母语丢了

@LEEYUNGHANMoe Ай бұрын

11:13 这里开始笑了😂😂

@samuelee1206 25 күн бұрын

但他的英语也不怎么样，他如果跟外国人这么说英语他们也听不懂，因为太大马式口音了😄

@MsYokiss 18 күн бұрын

可能只是对大马人才这样沟通，环境的关系，就好像新加坡人对自己人说话也是用singling，也许对洋人的话口音就会不同了，有些人切换自如的。

@adam-z7j5i Ай бұрын

本以为基督徒英文都很好

@zhengyusteadygang5325 Ай бұрын

不会说华语的大马华人？！背后的真实原因！频道史上第一部说英语的影片！

@MrGamer_jinjit_96 Ай бұрын

Asked jinnyboy challenged fuzhou dialect

@アニメ先生朧之助 22 күн бұрын

我身为广东人，不说广东话，因为声音太像男的（我是女的）

@贤-j5v Ай бұрын

如果只是讲的话，华语是最好学的语言之一。不会像英文那么多的grammar，讲不好又会给人笑broken english

@junshanwong6277 Ай бұрын

在新加坡，几乎蛮多华人不是会讲华语😂

@kaiserlow652 25 күн бұрын

谁说的？

@诚聘板主 Ай бұрын

華人其實是虛構出來的民族，馬來西亞多數是福建人，廣東人，潮州人，福州人，客家人，海南人，其實各民族都有自己的母語。華語是中國北方人的語言。不會說華語很正常。被强制說是華人必須說華語才是不正常。

@leolau5652 Ай бұрын

你區分不了語言和方言。。。。。十九世紀來中國傳教的傳教士都會區分，並且編撰了相應的字典。

@诚聘板主 Ай бұрын

@@leolau5652 可以區分就是不同語言。相同的語言只會是口音部分不同，例如你會英語，你在英國，美國，加拿大，紐西蘭，印度，新加坡，香港，只要會英語，基本都能交流。他只會是發音部分不同。如果你會華語，那麽你在台灣，中國，馬來西亞，新加坡，如果都是會說華語，那麽基本也能溝通無阻，最後是一些發音和結構用法不同而已。但是福建話，廣東話，上海話相對與華語絕對是另一種語言，因爲如果你不懂就絕對聽不懂。爲什麽會説爲方言？那是因爲他發源于中國某個地方，例如福建話就發源于福建。廣東話起源于廣東。如果廣東獨立，那麽就不是方言了，而是國家語言，就是這麽簡單。

@ASD-tg4zu 19 күн бұрын

然后呢？搞分裂？你愿意学海南话吗？愿意学福州话吗？典型的广东人思想，恶心

@LYR03100 Ай бұрын

3:39哇，我妈广东，我潮州人，这么有缘的咩🤣

@asasoo Ай бұрын

😊😂😮

@cindylaw6461 23 күн бұрын

华人应该懂得自己母语。

@yxcheah7215 29 күн бұрын

how about thailand and Indonesia ? And Singapore if you said so. Don’t just think China now then learn manrdin

@smilingface2006 Ай бұрын

我还是觉得这些人父母，不够妥当。只让孩子懂英文，有确保他将来肯定住西方只和白人打交道了吗？我感激我父母，送我华小，英文让我上补习班，打个基础，现在不管我住东还是西我都不怕没法沟通。比如uncle roger在他西方留学之前，他英文我相信不如现在流利，还local broken式，但基础有了又混进去了流利是迟早的事，就别让孩子连基础都没有。现在看到那些父母，已经把孩子送国际学校了，在家还继续讲英语，真的啦，感觉很gelik。好在中国崛起，在那之前看到引以为荣的banana真的快把我弄到心里不平衡了。