Bambu Lab A1, great bed slinger, but is it better than P1P? (for PLA)

[@Orion_007x]

10:01 I noticed some differences on the horns. I am guessing the cooling is slightly better on the P1P

[@MyTechFun]

Good notice. Yes, I agree, and this may explain that window on the benchy

[@ChannelRejss]

stepping up the thumbnail game :D

[@andrewwillcoxon]

I didn't realize that was the reason I click on this until I read your comment. Totally agree!

[@igwood71]

Came for the thumbnail. Stayed for the content.

[@redavatar]

A HUGE Asterix with the price: you compare prices of the A1 COMBO with the AMS Lite, with the P1P WITHOUT AMS. I think that makes a BIG difference! Please make sure to mention this in a pop up because this is quite a big difference.

[@manvirkaur502]

yeah no multi colour printing ability without considering price of the ams

[@GiulioJiang]

For your students, show them the Ender 3, how everything is pieced together, manual bed leveling, feeding, extrusion, and the whole manual package. Then, you can show them the bambulab, and ask them how they would solve all of the problems that now bambulab gives for granted. Your students will be the mechanical, electrical, hardware and software engineers of the future, and as engineers, they should be given a chance to appreciate all the technical details, and awesome technologies that now we can get out of the box, so that they can make the next iteration. Your students are lucky to have you!

[@pranavasthanaDelhi]

Thumbnail 🔥

[@bunch8]

Thank you for measuring the amount of waste that is generated with the color changing. As a bonus you showed a dual color cow that demonstrates what can be done with single color printers and clever design.

[@martythestines]

I just put the new bed on my A1 this morning. Being that it is my only multi-material printer, I was still using it the last couple months. If I had more money at the moment, I would bought an AMS for my P1S during this sale, along with the $120 credit they gave me for waiting. would've been like $200USD after tax. But I paid just $7 shipping, on 8 kilos of PLA for my A1 instead. Having an AMS to use with ABS/ASA is something that I could use though.

[@BennyTygohome]

I've an A1 with AMS lite which i purchased 1 week after it's debut. I replaced the recalled heatbed when bambu shipped the replacement heatbed. I love the A1 series. It's super easy to use and it was also my first printer. I liked it so much that i also bought the A1 Mini and another Ams Lite when they were on sale. I've nothing else to compare them to, but i just love them. They are super easy to work on too. I can change nozzles fast and I've even replaced the extruder gears which was pretty easy too.

[@deletedmediatj]

as far as the price you are not comparing apples to apples.. it seems the difference is only 10 USD BUT.... the P!P is 499 with NO ams while the A1 is 489 WITH the compact AMS.

[@aeonjoey3d]

THAT THUMBNAIL! XD BAHHAAHAHAHHAAH Love your vids already, but I clicked so fast :D

[@artspam]

It could be quite interesting to make a 3-way comparison: Surface quality near the bed, same surface 25 cm high up when the bottom of the print is light (Maybe 100g) and as the third option, the same surface 25 cm high up when the bottom of the print is heavy (maybe 400g). I wonder how well the vibration compensation will work in those cases because it's calibrated when the bed is empty. But no matter the result, I think it is a fantastic printer.

[@eaman11]

You would find that the bedslinger has a lot of ringhing ghosting on the top.

[@artspam]

@@eaman11 I agree. Would be interesting though to see how much of it, maybe depending on printing speed. I've started to do some test myself.

[@davidwilson4190]

Thanks for a comprehensive review. I was the 411th person to give you a thumbs up... thanks for the 411 on the A1!

[@sintetico82]

Thank you for your time! This is a very good and useful analysis!

[@SeanCMonahan]

I credit my Ender-3 V2 with teaching me much, much more about how 3d printers work than I would've had to learn with a printer that wasn't needing continual repairs and upgrades 😂. I absolutely would not recommend it for someone looking to get a 3D printer as a tool. I've enjoyed tinkering with it, but I definitely spend less time actually printing than I'd like. (14:56)

[@JenSalik_]

Yes, the thumbnail is very funny. But: the content is even better. Thanks for the comparison.

[@yakostudios5405]

Great comparison, Professor Igor! I would love to see a comparison between Sunlu and Esun PLA Pro. I'm sure that would be a very popular video, as they are among the best affordable brands available in Europe. Although you’ve tested them individually, using different printers makes it hard to accurately compare their performance. It would be fantastic if you could use your new impact test machine for this comparison. I'm excited to see the results! Keep up the excellent work!

[@jf0314]

Fantastic work, thank you for the video! Really enjoyed your analytical approach in this and other videos!

[@steeely_tales]

I'm working on a stop-motion short movie and i'm using 3d printing to make small gears and components for the main character's internal armature. I'm using the A1 mini with 0.2 nozzle. Astonishing quality even using presets.

[@eaman11]

One is a bedslinger, you should have printed something full height and then you can see the difference in quality on the top part of the print. Something like a very geometrical vase would do, use hi speed.

[@jesusochoa3721]

I just returned the p1s for a A1 combo and A1 mini. So much better

[@Red.exe7]

Why is it better?

[@jesusochoa3721]

@@Red.exe7 i think the p1s is louder and it doesn’t take cardboard spools. Its the same build size at the a1, but the a1 is $400 cheaper. Unless you only print in things that need an enclosure the bed slingers work perfectly.

[@jesusochoa3721]

So the p1s was like $1000 something after taxes i got the A1 combo and A1 mini for $200 cheaper.

[@Megavoltamper]

Imádom ezeket a mémesített új thumbnail-eket! ♥️ A gyerekek műve? 😁

[@riba2233]

haha nice thumbnail :D

[@riba2233]

@@alphadog6970 here is the thing, to make yt work you have to play the game. He can't make these vldeos for no gain as they take much time and m0ney, so it's either this or no more awesome vldeos from Igor...

[@aeonjoey3d]

@@riba2233 Agreed, those of us who know his content, respect his expertise, which he shows deeply in his vids, can take a joke now and then, i don't think it's rampant enough to trivialize anything, and we instantly got the reference :)

[@riba2233]

@@aeonjoey3d well said 👍

[@boazandruth909]

I couldn’t decide so I got both of em

[@jacobwilliamson8406]

Best thumbnail ever !!

[@StuckoTu]

What a thumbnail! And review of course 😄

[@martythestines]

8:01 did that print on the A1 Mini profile? Or did you catch it and just didn't re-record the shot? lol I do that all the time. I'm always slicing things for the wrong printer. At least until I saved profiles with the names to my printers. Christian(50 Shades Of Gray P1S), Karen(Hot Headed A1), Alicia(P!nk Ender 3 S1 Pro), Barry(The FLASHforge AD5M). They all have Gold Printed nameplates.

[@MyTechFun]

Oh, yes. I even re-record the shot, but inserted the wrong one in the video, but the time is the same. I got the worning when I wanted to sent to printing, so I noticed only then.

[@dosdont]

If you're going to pick just one for occasional printing, this is the one. I own an Ender and an A1 Mini, if I didn't have the larger Ender I would have bought this.

[@TheSyntactics]

Giving a like for that thumbnail haha

[@NeonDreams7]

Oh man, your thumbnail!

[@gillesreyna1272]

it is so quiet that I often look at it thinking it paused following a failure !

[@APxKP]

haha well done on the thumbnail.

[@edwardmarkaryan8312]

You’re obviously having fun making thumbnails

[@DenisOnTheTube]

Another excellent video! Very cool and useful 😀

[@DAIMANization]

I mean do you have to use the Bambu Lab AMS Lite with this? Or is there cheaper alternative that can be connected?

[@weeweepeepeehi]

BAHAHA I love the thumbnail 🤣

[@LivingTheDream77]

Can you test to see whether natural colored filaments are weaker or stronger than artificially colored filaments ?

[@MyTechFun]

I have several color tests in progress. ABS GF, PC, PLA+

[@_..-.._..-.._]

Why doesn’t the Bambu camera show better video? That’s disappointing, I’ve used a Blink mini camera on my m5c and it’s phenomenal.

[@JAYTHEGREAT355]

That color split was nice , whats that proceds called ?

[@peterpeter5666]

as usual an other great video

[@dekurvajo]

Just hope one day i can use Cura with these Bambu printers.

[@riba2233]

why lol, it is inferior

[@milosdjordjevic8272]

Is it possible to print ASA filament? Great video 👌

[@ThisisDD]

❤

[@_..-.._..-.._]

Core XY is completely unnecessary and over complicated for 90% of users. Unless you’re printing large objects very quickly, you probably don’t need the hassle and cost of a CoreXY. A custom bed slinger has made a Benchy in 1 min 59 secs without a heated bed, so I think bed slingers are underrated.

[@daymianhayes2493]

Bed slingers are slow POS's compared to CoreXY. The Anycubic Kobra 3 can only print at half the speeds of my budget Flashforge Adventurer 5M. I returned the Kobra 3 because it was a slow POS that requires like double the space because of the bed slinging. Bed slingers will eventually completely die off

[@Seaofjitsu]

Thumbnail was fire bwahaha. 🔥

[@WhereNerdyisCool]

It's too bad the tubing wasn't a bit longer so the machine can be enclosed.

[@riba2233]

you can replace them for longer ones :)

[@SeanCMonahan]

What's the reason Bambu says not to put it in an enclosure?

[@riba2233]

@@SeanCMonahan because you could overheat the internal electronics

[@nuy6n6nn]

That opening font is 😢