Barber: 1. Sinfonie (Sinfonie in einem Satz) ∙ hr-Sinfonieorchester ∙ Marin Alsop

[@dmntuba]

Barber's Symphony is underrated, and forgotten in America. It's wonderful to see it performed by one of the finest orchestras in the world and helping to make the music international. Bravo!

[@mendax1773]

Not exactly forgotten. The reason why I know it is because Neemi Järvi conducted it with the Detroit Symphony Orchestra in a performance more than thirty years ago that I heard on the radio when I lived in the Los Angeles area. If Järvi conducts it, I would say it's not forgotten. Incidentally, that DSO performance was marvelous. But you are right in that it's underrated. It should be performed much more often because it's just that good! It's not just a great American symphony, it's just a great symphony no matter how you slice it.

[@johnrandolph6121]

I agree it should be done more often....but it's hardly forgotten.

[@NewMusic.FreshIdeas]

@@mendax1773 30 years ago! In other words, it's largely forgotten. If a work is performed only once in a few decades it is at the very least ignored, and all but forgotten.

[@billwilkinson1397]

Isn't it best forgotten? Sounds like it was written by a robot churning out what a symphony should sound like. 60 yrs of composing and only one memorable melody, yes you know the one. There is nothing worthwhile in this bluster signifying nothing. Emperors new clothes - something widely accepted as true or professed as being praiseworthy, due to an unwillingness of the general population to criticize it or be seen as going against popular opinion.

[@TheStockwell]

For what it's worth, Barber completed this work shortly before he turned 26. When it was performed at the opening concert of the 1937 Salzburg Festival, it became the first symphonic work by an American composer to be played at the festival.

[@steveegallo3384]

"For what it's worth"? It's worth very much....Why self-deprecate?

[@rodericknash4204]

This great Samuel Barber Symphony thrilled me over 60 years ago and still works its unforgettable magic every time I hear it.

[@finjarmo]

A good thing in listening music on the internet is that every now and then you find a real gem. Like this 1st of Barber. Thank you Frankfurt Symphony and Ms Alsop!

[@louismastrangelo3781]

I completey agree, I didn't know much about Barber, but he has my attention now.

[@rapmacl1]

​ Barber's Violin Concerto is still my favorite of the form. The first movement is absolutley sublime. Love this piece as well, and by my fave orchestra! Bravo Maestra, e Bravi Tutti!

[@WilliamScharf]

Samuel Barber one of the giants of American music. Marin Alsop wonderful promoter of his music.

[@MichaelConwayBaker]

I have always thought this symphony was a masterpiece. The ideas are fabulous. The musicians and finally, the conductor, Marin Alsop really brings out the best playing from each and every musician. Bravo!!

[@lefaune66]

Außergewöhnliche Sinfonie. Samuel Barbers Musiksprache bereichert die symphonischen Möglichkeiten mit seiner Charakteristik, Bläser und Holzbläser in dramatischen und düsteren Melodien zu kombinieren, ohne die süßen und menschlichen Passagen zu verlassen, so menschlich, dass die großen Meister dieser Kunst uns hinterlassen haben ... Danke, dass du sie informiert hast!

[@tomascostero9962]

Allegro ma non troppo 00:04 Allegro molto 7:26 Andante tranquillo 12:17 Con moto 17:16 22:01,

[@canticle56]

Marin Alsop really has a feel for this neo romantic Americana. She’s a wonderful conductor.

[@frogmouth]

I would like to hear a lot more BARBER if this is anything to go by . We hear the Adagio a lot on radio and a handful of other pieces. This was wonderful. Superb orchestra and Marin!

[@whatafreakinusername]

Cello Concerto, Violin Concerto, three Essays for orchestra

[@davebarclay4429]

@@whatafreakinusername I also suggest Knoxville, Summer of 1915

[@edwardcoe7293]

Barber is great - it's a shame he is only popularly known for the Adagio. Try the violin concerto.

[@peterwhyte317]

And include the beautiful and exciting piano concerto.

[@Mezzotenor]

There's an amusing suite, Souvenirs, for piano duet and in other arrangements.

[@charleswise3067]

A wonderful performance of Barber Symphony # 1. This is a composer deserving a bigger international audience.

[@verdiguy]

Thank you for the reupload of the symphony. It's a wonderful performance of an impressive work.

[@RepertoireSharer]

Thanks for doing this symphony! It’s a wonderful work.

[@lowe7471]

Great music. Brilliantly performed. Thank you for sharing this.

[@valeriechapman1612]

Barber: 1. Sinfonie in einem satz . hr - Sinfonieorchester - Marin Alsop. I must admit to not hearing this Symphony before. I think I need to hear it again before I talk about whether I liked it or not. I’ll listen to it again. Thank You for sharing it with me.

[@brennentaggart3291]

13:20 is unbelievable, I want to be able to write the the energy of this man but I don't know where to start commiting myself

[@louismastrangelo3781]

Wonderful piece and a beautiful performance!

[@jonathanr2830]

I enjoyed this performance very much. I performed the solo clarinet part with an orchestra many decades ago, and this brought back good memories.

[@gerontius3]

Wonderful performance. A sparse audience but maybe that was Covid (2021). Great sound and very fine playing - oboe solo very nice. Barber sure loved his oboe solos, there's a similar one in the slow movement of his violin concerto. What a fine piece this is. Compact, intense, and just like the Sibelius 7th that he modelled it on.

[@harriejanssen3984]

Great composition and performance. Thank you.

[@vanhouten64]

I love that there are lady conductors now! So inspiring! 👍🏻💖

[@jeffwatkins352]

Much as I love Wagner, this magnificent work alone proves he was wrong that the symphony had died with Beethoven. And what an incandescent performance under Alsop''s inspired conducting! Bravo, Frankfurt! You keep music alive.

[@tomstarzeck7137]

From what I've gathered on the topic of Samuel Barber, he was very impressed with Sibelius, and his first symphony is in one continuous evolving movement like the 7th of Sibelius.. very pleasing to the ears.

[@alejandroherreradelaparra3977]

Great work. Thumbs up. Hats off...

[@junao6959]

Regência magnífica muito bem executada simplesmente lindo demais !!

[@rodrigo9617]

what beauty

[@danielagreda1974]

I do love this!!!

[@CENTEXRailProductions]

Beautiful!!

[@BalbirSingh-gs2xi]

SuperbSuperb.

[@ronaldbwoodall2628]

This may not be a masterpiece, but I've always enjoyed this unpretentious but accomplished symphony. It's been quite a while since I'd heard it though; I'm glad to have heard it in this fine performance.

[@harriejanssen3984]

This is a masterpiece.

[@carson3370]

Maybe I'm not listened enough to know the full depth of what a symphony can be, but this is my favorite symphony and has been for a while

[@censorshipisreal9370]

It's a masterpiece in my book!

[@nevertheless123]

this is surely a masterpiece, one of the greatest symphonies ever written in my opinion, and Ive listened to 100s of them.

[@bryanpoulsen8969]

This is certainly considered a masterpiece by any serious observer of classical music.

[@osushi1366]

見事な演奏！

[@austinchapman9079]

hoc numquam audivi. interdum mihi videtur simile esse Sibelii operibus. mihi placet.

[@edgesdragon888]

Apparently it is modeled after the 7th symphony of Sibelius. I got that from Wikipedia but it does cite a couple sources to double check.

[@roblindauer6521]

The notation on the musicians' sheet music seems huge, compared to what I normally work from

[@lindashapanka6229]

How young is the first bassoonist? Wow!

[@janklaas6885]

🇺🇳 14:52 she dances on the wind

[@LCMM2150]

Kommentar, um den Kanal zu helfen

[@maumtzrs1344]

Does anyone know what the piece is called at the beginning of the video?

[@Gwailo54]

Barber is sadly known for one work. The symphonies and essays should be better known and played more often. The essays would make perfect opening pieces for a concert.

[@WilliamScharf]

I believe his mother was a singer. Barber's contribution to vocal music is enormous.

[@domajeur9798]

Beaucoup de délicatesse . Merci!

[@gant73]

16:52

[@fabianfrankenstein7294]

1:34

[@karstenmeyer1729]

Erstaunlich, ich kannte das Stück noch gar nicht. Barber kannte ich schon und sein Adagio.

[@Capyguarda]

12:20

[@notaire2]

Wunderschöne und lebhafte Aufführung dieser einzigartig konstruierten doch perfekt komponierten Sinfonie mit gut phrasierten doch perfekt entsprechenden Tönen aller Instrumente. Die Virtuosität aller Einzelspieler ist echt ergreifend. Die intelligente und geniale Dirigentin leitet das hoch funktionelle Orchester im veränderlichen Tempo und mit effektiver Dynamik. Wahrlich hörenswert!

[@dickswingston8854]

Hahaha... "Die Intelligente und geniale Dirigentin"... "Das hoch funktionelle Orchester"... Bester Bot auf KZbin :D

[@hansjuergenkohlhaas871]

@@dickswingston8854 @notaire2 - Mich überrascht es nicht daß Marin Alsop dieses feine spätromantische Werk auswendig leitet, mit präzisem und inspirierendem Dirigat, ist sie doch als jahrelange Chefin des Baltimore SO mit Barber's Werk sehr vertraut.

[@SweUnpoor]

STW al over 🙂

[@NewMusic.FreshIdeas]

Observe how few people are in the audience! Is this had been a performance of Beethoven's Fifth it would've been overflowing. Hardly anyone appreciates 20th century composers. Few are even aware of them.

[@celloguy]

It was Covid - limitations on audience numbers

[@karstenmeyer1729]

Beim Hören ist mir ein Gedanke gekommen. Ich würde zu gerne Leute, die (nur) auf Rap stehen fragen wollen: "Leute, fühlt ihr überhaupt noch etwas? Musik, das ist ja nicht nur das, was wir hören, sondern auch das, was in unserem Gehirn an Gefühlen ausgelöst wird. Man sollte die "klassische Musik" nicht unterschätzen.

[@Quotenwagnerianer]

Vor allem stellt sich mir dabei die Frage, was dieses Obsession mit Texten soll. Alles was populär ist sind Lieder. Musik funktioniert aber doch eigentlich viel besser ohne Text.

[@highground7761]

@@Quotenwagnerianer Nicht zwingend. Auch in der Romantik gab es schon Lieder, bei denen der Text die Emotionen der Musik sogar verstärkt (Winterreise von Schubert z. B.). So ist es auch bei vielen modernen Songs, obwohl natürlich meist der Text im Vordergrund steht.

[@Quotenwagnerianer]

@@highground7761 Du willst doch nicht ernsthaft Wilhelm Müller mit Adele vergleichen. ;)

[@highground7761]

@@Quotenwagnerianer Habe ich nicht. Ich habe lediglich die Aussage infrage gestellt, dass Musik ohne Text besser funktioniert. Das muss man m. M. n. differenzierter sehen.

[@diekluge]

It is a tragedy that there are empty seats in that audience.

[@celloguy]

It was played during covid so lock down prevented people coming to concert halls

[@basspoem]

Like a fourth Essay...

[@RechtsstaatBRD]

Es klingt ähnlich wie viele modern-klassische Kinomusik.

[@stephenjablonsky1941]

Marin and this wonderful orchestra worked very hard to make this music come alive but the end result just misses the mark of greatness. It is certainly very "symphonic" but seems to be full of empty gestures. My overall impression is that this is zombie romanticism. Hate me if you will.

[@clairepanke918]

With pleasure…

[@stephenjablonsky1941]

@@clairepanke918 Love and hate both create relationships.....

[@scottmichaelawaken]

So, what have YOU written? 🤔

[@stephenjablonsky1941]

I have been composing music since I was a senior in high school in 1958. I am a good composer but not a supreme genius. You might check my channel if you are curious.@@scottmichaelawaken

[@mendax1773]

"My overall impression is that this is zombie romanticism. Hate me if you will." Okay, I will. It's a great symphony and it's a shame you can't see it. Sure, it doesn't have the great sweep of something Mahlerian, but it sure is a damned exciting, impressive work and completely engaging.