GRADING EVERY QB CLASS SINCE 2000

BUY MY MERCH IN ORDER TO SAVE LIVES! DO IT!
MERCHANDISE LINK: teespring.com/stores/barry-mc...

[@alexceastwood2246]

My wifes boyfriend let me out of the basement for 20 minutes just so I could watch this video

[@jarellharris7781]

You will miss 31 seconds

[@jojotho2480]

Happy for you lil bro

[@joonpak]

You’re welcome

[@manuthriftspr4725]

Pretty cool that hell let you comment as well

[@Jaykey-mj2mp]

He must be a hero

[@Recovery305]

2004 is easily the best because Big Ben is a man of class and integrity

[@Wither1224]

I would argue the 2017 draft brought us more overall talent in the gunslinger Deshaun Watson and the class act Jackson Mahomes

[@whoops9630]

Or 2002 because of animal rights enthusiast Michael Vick

[@FireAttack0811]

Wow what a original joke 😐😐😐

[@supernova21gaming30]

​@@FireAttack0811Still funny

[@Ericrawnsley]

​@FireAttack0811 wow someone attacking a joke what a fun guy

[@mch5922]

Absolute class act for leaving in yet another fart in the video at 18:46. Heroic Scene

[@Newhouse56]

Minshew stats are mind blowing for the situations he’s been in

[@tristanbarlow2167]

I've always said if he got a real shot on a competent team (not the 2019 jags) he'd be a top 15 QB

[@brendan9868]

Minshew’s honestly a beast and one of the tougher QB’s I’ve seen in the last few years. When he stepped in to start against the Ravens this year the guy was taking some absolutely punishing hits and somehow kept shaking them off, even ended up winning to add onto my eternal misery as a ravens fan.

[@TJMcGOAT]

@@tristanbarlow2167he’ll get his shit this year I think

[@specsrus7184]

Giving the 2014 year an A+++ solely Jimmy Garoppolo’s handsomeness is controversial but I agree.

[@monophthalmos9633]

What I most admire about Barry is that, despite being tough on players, even harsh you might say, he is fair in his judgement. When he gives a compliment, you take it serious and he speaks for him that he doesn't shy away from giving QBs he does not like for various reasons some credit.

[@MCLSD_]

He’s a die hard eagles fan and we saw him complement Tony romo in this vid. That’s why we love Barey

[@jamesmccormack6604]

maybe it’s cause not many people watch the commanders but sam howell does not suck

[@85isaboat53]

​@MCLSD_ than explains why he hates Brady so much also he called Andrew luck a pussy so I'm not a big fan if his for that if you know Andrew luck's situation with the colts than you shouldn't call him a pussy

[@PatFussy069]

That TD/INT ratio on Gardner Minchew is great on paper, wtf, I wasn't expecting that!

[@rylankoehn7560]

2018 was such a weird year. Josh and Lamar not going 1,2 at QB, Baker at 1, Darnold and Rosen massive busts. Wild year

[@AttainTheGrain]

Bakers not a bust.

[@cbktheguy]

​@@AttainTheGrainhe's not saying he's a bust he's saying he shouldn't have went one

[@ScaredWatched]

​@@AttainTheGrainlearn how to read

[@AttainTheGrain]

@@ScaredWatched no.

[@AttainTheGrain]

@@cbktheguy I misread it my bad, thanks for not being a dick and trying to grandstand on the internet 👈😎👈

[@wsgzae]

18:47 dawg ripped ass 😂😍

[@NflCfbFan]

hell naww😂😂

[@Chocobobob]

Aaron Rodgers 105 career interceptions is an amazing stat

[@WhatAG23]

It’s just a shame he only has one ring

[@cellamuert]

Less than Alex Smith with 2,500 more attempts

[@Chimeratics]

@@WhatAG23 really says a lot about Green Bay that they could only muster 2 rings with 30 years of first ballot HoF quarterbacks.

[@Chocobobob]

@@WhatAG23 yeah playing in the Tom Brady era will do that

[@GookSquadGaming]

@@ChimeraticsI agree the packers should’ve have had a therapist for Aaron’s autoerotic asphyxiation addiction.

[@loganb.1984]

Cleveland should’ve drafted Bryce Young, because if he doesn’t work out then he can be the elf mascot

[@reggielewis5321]

I can't wait for RB, WR, TE and all the other potential positions for this. This history grading is always fascinating.

[@francisayala9310]

As someone who attended the University of Hawaii and watched Colt Brennan play live, I appreciate the Colt Brennan love from Barry.

[@dc7236]

I'll never forget colt Brennan.. for 2 years that Hawaii team was the most exciting offense I've ever seen

[@Noctem_pasa]

No matter how bad Zach is I don’t know how Lance isn’t a bigger bust considering he was 3 first rounders and couldn’t even beat Sam Darnold

[@riseofthesugars5312]

Yeah, I didn’t get the Trey Lance hype going into that day. To me T-Law was the clear #1, followed by Bustin Fields and Maybe Zach Wilson. The rest were 2nd or 3rd round picks.

[@Noctem_pasa]

@@riseofthesugars5312 personally I think Zach has enough arm potential to outdo fields still, but either way they’re still way better than Trey

[@Chimeratics]

I will NEVER understand the Trey Lance hype and the massive machine that turned out for him. I don't see why it happened.

[@fortynights1513]

⁠​⁠@@Noctem_pasaAt least you can say Zach Wilson has played for a couple years even if he’s not good.

[@fortynights1513]

@@riseofthesugars5312When should Mac Jones have been taken?

[@infinityquartz4744]

Yeah 2020 is looking to be up there. You have 5 guys all, imo, good enough to possibly be franchise qbs, Herbert making incredible stats with his canon of an arm, Burrow and Hurts already making the superbowl, Tua spearheading an explosive offense with his elite accuracy, and now Love actually looking pretty decent in his first year actually starting. This could be a draft class to be remembered

[@treysonmcgrady4750]

No mention of J.T. O’ Sullivan in 2002? Shoutout the QB school!

[@SirZapdos]

Shoutout to Blake Bortles for being forever immortalized on the TV show The Good Place. Also, weird how so many QBs from 2020 have a first name that begins with J.

[@GabrielRodriguez-mc4me]

For 2007, I say the undrafted Matt Moore was the best. Lasted into 2019, winning a ring as Mahomes' backup ahead of Henne. He played more than anyone else in his class.

[@tylergrellner5139]

I think moore only played over henne because he was hurt. I agree though probably the best of that class.

[@TheRealHulk34]

Mark Sanchez “Behind” some great defenses? I caught that 🤣

[@fortynights1513]

Had a few good playoff performances, but not much outside of that. Sanchez’s best regular season was arguably his third year, but his defense regressed and the Jets missed the playoffs.

[@RatedRMario21]

I would normally say 2nd round pick Christian "0 NFL Snaps" Hackenberg would be the biggest bust of the 2016 Draft, but last Spring Paxton Lynch was benched by his XFL team. If you're a former 1st round pick and can't even hold down a starting job in the XFL, you take "suck" to a whole new level

[@NG-ue4th]

Personally I'd argue that the best qb class I recent years was 2020. Burrow, Tua, Herbert and Hurts are clearly great and Love is doing ok for himself as well...

[@vincegreene7031]

Word was Josh Freeman fell into a mountain of blow and never climbed out. Allegedly. Tough scene.

[@charlesiofaustria7361]

He was also inconsistent as hell. It was frustrating watching him play as a bucs fan.

[@evan9199]

18:46 Barry ripping a fart and leaving in in the video like a true American hero 🇺🇸🫡

[@hipstereagle6050]

6:30 what’s crazy is that outside of QB 2007 is one of the best draft classes ever

[@fortynights1513]

Sometimes there just aren’t any good ones available. Put a good group of quarterbacks on that draft class and it’d be a contender for one of the single best ever.

[@bartleysbattles]

20:02 Will Levis will fs see the field at some point, no doubt. I just don’t know if that will be this year or next year, really just comes down to Tannehill’s health and if Malik plays well or not

[@FAFO.K7NG]

Legitimately excited to watch this! We talk about classes for positions every year but gard to quantify .

[@_s_ss_s_]

18:46 Barry couldn't hold it in while talking about the poopy 2021 qb class

[@djturnure3185]

Wow my wife’s boyfriend helped me from my weed addiction and then said i could watch this video. What a great guy

[@josh678595]

Be a lifelong Chiefs fan. See 2005 draft list. See Alex Smith and have instant wonderful nostalgia. See Matt Cassel and have horrifying PTSD flashbacks

[@kingjay9929]

Man if Jordan Love becomes even just an average starter and can garner some playoff appearances then the 2020 class will hands down be the greatest class of all time. Somebody from this class is winning a super bowl soon

[@anthonykrause8052]

I grew up on Madden 13 and it’s so fun to look back on the fact that Mike Glennon, Jack Skelton, Matt Flynn, Christian Ponder and more scrubs are starting quarterbacks in that game.

[@marsella527]

Matt Barkley is that cautionary tale that college QBs should look at: had he declared as a Junior, he would have been #1 overall but went back for senior and got hurt and then completely fell off

[@fortynights1513]

Over Luck? Correct me if I’m wrong?

[@marsella527]

@@fortynights1513 Luck was 2012. Barkley was drafted 2014. Barkley should have declared 2013

[@fortynights1513]

⁠@@marsella527Barkley was a fourth round pick in 2013, and even threw 49 passes in the 2013 season. Would the Colts have picked him over Andrew Luck in 2012?

[@marsella527]

​@fortynights1513 whats sad is it was in the vid and I completely blacked out on that part. But he was projected but declared his senior year before hand. Would they have taken Barkley? Who knows. It's 11 years later

[@ScholarlyHiccup]

Wild, the 2007 QB class totaled more INTs than TDs

[@fortynights1513]

The fact that the class of quarterbacks that year is so bad is why I personally wouldn’t call JaMarcus Russell the biggest draft bust ever, because while the Raiders missed an opportunity to draft Hall of Fame players at other positions, if they wanted a quarterback, then 2007 wasn’t the draft to take one. None reached 1,000 career pass attempts or 30 career passing touchdowns.

[@anom9970]

thank you for the great content barry

[@gridirongod4207]

Barry what are your thoughts on CFL football? They say it’s a superior sport played by inferior athletes while the NFL is an inferior sport with superior athletes.

[@bouji_]

Do people from the United States watch the CFL?

[@miami2881]

What makes it the superior sport?

[@xelabadman5824]

@@bouji_I think he’s talking about college football

[@codykay6871]

@@xelabadman5824 nah thats ncaa, he means canada

[@JPS47]

Yes, this is accurate. The rules are too complex for the superior athletes in the NFL.

[@lolsmileyfaceSB]

I love the video but you should have had Andy Dalton as the biggest steal in his class. Legit starter at a high level in the 2nd round and still going

[@Deep_Canals]

Logan Thomas should be the steal of 2014!!!! Man is a solid NFL tight end at 30!

[@icrashout]

The 2007 QB class was terrible still gives me ptsd

[@devanshouse5027]

Despite being the worst class ever for QB's, 2007 was still one of the best classes ever at many positions.

[@WavveBoi]

That 08 WVU offense was crazy. Absolute insane team to watch and play with on ps2.

[@seand1011]

15:06 - For what it's worth, Chad Kelly is faring very well in the CFL. Too bad he couldn't do shit in the NFL.

[@steveraimee486]

Brad Smith in 2006 was a steal, but as a kick returner and wildcat qb

[@jacobringenwald]

I would say Brandon Weedon was a bigger bust in 2012 just because RG3 at least had that rookie year

[@seamusmcavey3826]

put some respect on my man B Smith from the 2006 draft. dude played every position on the football field.

[@nintoforgi]

Shoutout to the internet’s QB coach JT in that 2002 draft

[@joealese]

minshew deserves a starter spot

[@lopezklu]

For real.. dude does nothing but ball out. I wish the jets would grab him

[@joealese]

@@lopezklu That's what I said before they picked up Rogers. should have grabbed him and used him as a bargaining chip like hey Green Bay we don't need him for two first round picks we already have a starter!

[@alowe9142]

18:46 hmm yes the Fart rating such dynamic measuring charts you have my sir barry

[@unrelated1034]

Now that Jordan love won a playoff game his first year as a starter I think we can all agree 2020 is probably the second or first best draft classes

[@XKloosyvv]

I think Logan Thomas's successful career as a TE at least deserved a mention.

[@edwardellis3038]

If Jordan Love ends up panning out. The 2020 class has the chance to be the greatest ever. For one reason, no busts.

[@troystephens5735]

Evaluating and finding QBs are hard. It’s rare to even get a good quarterback for a few years

[@dumbinfp7951]

I'd argue Jameis is just as famous for crab legs as he is for his 30 TD 30 INT season

[@XxJERICHOHOLICxX13]

Never would I have ever guessed you were a Colt Brennan enjoyer. As a fellow Colt Brennan enjoyer, I would love to see a video from you about him.

[@tleoipl37]

Rip

[@MCLSD_]

As a cowboys fan, felt good hearing you put Tony above Carson Palmer. Sucks we never did anything with him. But I’ll forever hold the belief he could’ve won it all if we ever had a defense that wasn’t one of the worst ranked all time year after year. And also Dez caught it. My whole life as a cowboys fan rides on those two things. Because what else do we have ;-;

[@wellplayedninjas]

Id love to see you do this with other positions! Like WR and TEs

[@fortynights1513]

96 WR class was incredible

[@seandillon1359]

Romo was his own worst enemy. Kept making a 4-12 team 9-7 and they drafted like shit

[@kashwayne]

barry is such a hero

[@3serio]

R.I.P. Colt Brennan. He was so good and really embraced Hawaii and the culture there. Plus he was really good before his mental health deteriorated.

[@jok3r906]

Seeing Kliff Kingsbury got drafted in the 6th round is just 😮 I had no idea who he was, until his coaching career

[@SpicyMapping]

tom brady still playing while two of his former backups were head coaches is one of the weirdest fun facts I know of

[@RalstonProdz]

I mean Mike Vick had that DAWG in’em☠️☠️☠️

[@MrT571]

Get out 😂

[@jesusandreeangulogarcia8427]

An American hero dropping a video this morning, my weekend is going well.

[@misterfuzzyflippers]

I don't want to call Kenny a bust just yet and I'm hoping he starts to play better. I'd like to see him play with an OC that could at least hold a job at the NCAA level before I say Pittsburgh needs to take another swing at QB.

[@TheShinyFeraligatr]

The fact that he seems to get a lot better in situations where he'd be the one calling plays (no huddle, 2 minute drill, that sort of thing) does at least point to the fact that it may be a coaching issue. And we all know Canada's dogshit, he was dogshit before Pickett and he's dogshit now.

[@Mark_Cadden]

Agreed completely

[@jimc.goodfellas226]

The 2004 draft is, to me, the best in NFL history...not just for the QBs. Larry Fitz, Sean Taylor, so many stud players

[@fortynights1513]

I wouldn’t say single best, but it is a very good class

[@broncorage4694]

Aiden O’Connell looked good besides the fumbles

[@garrettgurley3473]

7:25 Rhett Bomar was my high school’s offensive coordinator

[@basicmeme1040]

Geno smith "good o line. Eww" "Wrs and no o line. Amazing"

[@boomersam4424]

bro needed to let off some steam at 18:47 💀

[@nicjet08]

As a Charger I’m gonna cream, brother said Justin Herbert’s the best qb of the class. God bless America

[@randallturner9094]

We are badass at drafting QB’s.. rest of them, not so much.

[@stebo5562]

This draft class is looking real good. Good rookies all over the league

[@quintonbrown1205]

The biggest steal in the 2006 draft class is Brad smith. Just didn’t play QB in the NFL

[@WhatsDownPatient]

Barry is such a man of integrity and has the utmost respect from me, my wife, her boyfriend, and their kid. I honestly wish I could see his remarkably beautiful face and kneel before him. If I ever saw both him and Jimmy Garoppolo within a span of 10 minutes, I would explode.

[@TheNamronTV]

You have to love football to enjoy this video. I really enjoyed this video.

[@lolcatzevan]

I’m going with Brandon Weeden as biggest draft bust in 2012. I know nobody but the browns expected him to be anything, but I also can’t really call RG3 a draft bust when injuries were what derailed him. Peoples definitions of draft busts are different though I suppose

[@DFossss]

He called Fitz a Cockroach 🤣🤣

[@brandonmiller7317]

You laughing at Bradford being a bust and best of the class was hilarious

[@KingDarkNova]

no booster seat joke i’m disappointed. that makes me laugh every time

[@magicmike3954]

Got a Jimmy G Travis Mathew ad on this video. So poetic.

[@ow_oso]

I love a strong, masculine man who can run the damn football. RBs should be next on the chopping block .

[@richardwells9172]

No mention of tyrod Taylor being the unluckiest QB in NFL history or David carr giving up his career as a punching bag

[@mrblue___]

Earliest I’ve ever been to a Barry video

[@ryankit92]

Maybe it’s because Vince Young is the player that first got me interested in watching football, but I call Leinhart a bigger bust. VY at least made a pro bowl, rookie of the year, and had some cool highlights.

[@nicholasjohnparks4872]

Geno Smith is a modern Rich Gannon

[@cappincrunchhh5351]

Do these videos for other positions!

[@mr.selfdestruct9616]

🚨🚨new barry mccockiner drop🗣️🗣️

[@henrybrown3158]

good video idea

[@Mastblood]

Chad Henne is a HOF level backup QB. He had a pretty mediocre career. But he still has 2 Rings, and and in the second one he actually had to help and score a TD. Change my mind.

[@thesleeper1974]

My dad went to school with Jeff Smoker (2004 NFL Draft) Said he was an absolute beast in HS but suffered from drug issues

[@californiaandwashington1377]

I think the 2020 QB draft class will be the greatest one ever in like 10 years

[@steadyrhythms9571]

had no idea jesse palmer from the bachelor even got drafted. that's cool man. i like him better on the bachelor. what a dual life that guy leads. for a few weeks he's out there being a sweetiepie traveling giving heartfelt counseling to complete idiots who are hopeless on finding love and then on saturdays in the fall he's giving me color commentary on why a&m sucks at football. thanks jesse palmer. apparently you sucked in the nfl but that's alright. you turned out fine.

[@devanshouse5027]

In due time, i think the 2020 QB class could be the best ever. I don't think there's ever been a draft class that produced 4 franchise QBs... once Burrow, Herbert, Tagovailoa and Hurts all hang up the cleats for good, we might have a new "best QB class ever."

[@HTV315]

2000 - Tom Brady 2001 - Drew Brees 2002 - Josh McCown 2003 - Rex Grossman 2004 - Ben Roethlisberger 2005 - Aaron Rodgers 2006 - Jay Cutler 2007 - **🤮🤮** 2008 - Joe Flacco 2009 - Matthew Stafford 2010 - Tim Tebow 2011 - cam Newton 2012 - Ryan Tannehill 2013 - Geno Smith 2014 - Derek Carr 2015 - Jameis Winston 2016 - Jared Goff 2017 - Patrick Mahomes 😫😤 *I hate to say it* 2018 - Josh Allen 2019 - Kyler Murray 2020 - Joe Burrow 2021 - Mac Jones 2022 - Desmond Ridder 2023 - ??? TOO EARLY TO SAY

[@Turtle440]

Great to see Barry grading Tom Brady once again!

[@brendonmartin7579]

I came from the hospital after a marijuana overdose, and this made my day!

[@benrotko6411]

Seems like the biggest steal of the 2007 draft would be Tyler Thigpen, no? Even if he’s not exactly good, over 3,000 career yards and nearly 500 rushing yards from a 7th round pick is at least a mild steal.

[@radaf4429]

Bradford was a part of the Vikings' 13-3 season

[@jamesquebral5941]

CJ Beat-Hard lmfao

[@orthodoxchad4014]

Cool vid bro

[@Aleph3575]

2:51 Man it makes me feel old seeing guys who are/were headcoaches either in the NFL or in college on draft lists lol. Yes, that's the same Kliff Kingbury that couldn't win with Patrick Mahomes at the collegiate level, and the Josh Heupel earlier in an earlier draft is Tennessee's Head Coach now, famous for his aggressive offense. 5:37 Call it a hot take, but Cutler probably would have had a better career if he had stayed in Denver. But everyone's lives would have been better if Denver hadn't hired Josh Mcdaniels that year. 7:08 I agree, he was amazing to watch at Hawaii. 9:48 As a Virginia Tech fan, it always stings that Tyrod never really got a shot in the NFL. He was always "That Guy you sign so the hotshot rookie you drafted doesn't start immediately but he's guaranteed to take over for by like week 5" and he notoriously got fucked over by the Bills benching him for Nate Peterman when they were in contention for the playoffs. And as much as I love Tech, they kinda fucked him over too. Frank Beamer never really had a great offense, even when he had generational talents like Michael Vick, not to mention Beamer randomly burned Tyrod's redshirt for literally no reason in a blowout loss to LSU only to barely play him the rest of the year. Its honestly not unreasonable to think that Tech goes back to the National Championship that year if they stick with Tyrod instead of trying to roll with Sean Glennon, they certainly don't basically make Matt Ryan's career with the infamous 2007 Choke Game in the rain against BC where they led 17-0 for most of the game only to lose at the end thanks to a combination of Sean Glennon sucking ass and Bud Foster calling prevent defense for the entire 2nd half despite that being the opposite of what was working for reasons no one has ever been able to figure out.

[@reke1k]

What's crazy is I been following nfl draft since like 2010 and every year they talk about drafting qb of the future to hold down the the franchise for the 10-15 yrs and damn near all of em don't even last more than 6 yrs 😂😂

[@jtmassecure4488]

You should review college football weeks it would be interesting.

[@dylanconry7561]

18:46 Barry just doesn't care to edit his farts out of the video