EACH MEMBER BROUGHT THE FIRE ON THIS! First Time Hearing Led Zeppelin - In My Time of Dying Reaction

[@bdmention]

Never enough footage of John Paul Jones playing. The bass runs in this song are sick.

[@wildbill7081]

Yes very true many people seem to forget about John Paul Jones and how great he contributes to all the great music of Led zeppelin

[@vicprovost2561]

That seems to be the case in most Led Zeppelin video from back then, JPJ is often MIA for long stretches. The glue that held the band completely together, whatever they needed, he provided.

[@wildbill7081]

@@vicprovost2561 Yes true

[@Tijuanabill]

He must have tipped the camera guy to leave him out of all their videos. You wouldn't even know he was there, if you couldn't hear him.

[@gary6754]

When Zeppelin was at their best its impossible for another rock band to touch them

[@PUNKinDRUBLIC72]

Floyd!🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿

[@musicairplanes4884]

@@PUNKinDRUBLIC72 Apples and oranges. Floyd is not a rock band imho..

[@gary6754]

@@PUNKinDRUBLIC72 um no

[@PUNKinDRUBLIC72]

@@musicairplanes4884 Are they disco? Get on KZbin and get up The Nile Song, it's pure metal!

[@w.geoffreyspaulding6588]

@@PUNKinDRUBLIC72I can see why some say apples and oranges…..but the point was level of quality. Ans yes, Floyd matched Zeppelin in quality. Different genre. Some mastership.

[@rockerman4791]

The type of performance that solidified Led Zeppelin as the pinnacle of rock and roll. Intricate, emotional and absolutely masterful!

[@lloyderc]

This song is just grungy with blues. This is some Mississippi delta blues .

[@chrissy8230]

When Giants Walked the Earth ~ Led Zeppelin 💯

[@JPMadden]

The cameras never pay enough attention to John Paul Jones. When your bassist is that amazing, you don't need a rhythm guitarist.

[@RobertDavisAdman]

Amen to that!

[@Ziko1962]

JPJ don't need attention..he knows he's good...

[@malcshone4409]

I was there. May 1975. Loud as hell. Three hours of magic.

[@normatako3971]

Me too! Amazing.

[@malcshone4409]

@ Unforgettable.

[@ariewarmer]

my in rotterdam 1975

[@albertmata8813]

I’ve already told my family that when I die I want this played at my funeral

[@shegocrazy]

Did you done good?

[@PeterTea]

Talk about going out with a bang.

[@stephpaynes]

Good one. Rain song 4 me

[@stevenphilpott1493]

LED ZEP at their worst were 100 times better than anything produced today. They were the pinnacle of rock and will never be bested ever!

[@jimmorrish6771]

the drums are just unbelievable on this

[@charlesmyers8150]

Bonham, just like Charlie Watts was irreplaceable.

[@soundbreak7]

@@charlesmyers8150 absolutely

[@ronniel879]

Led Zeppelin…. Often imitated but never duplicated !!

[@verribarry]

My favorite Led Zeppelin song has always been the one I'm listening to at that time.

[@aaronarnold7653]

Amen brah...

[@jeffelliott7353]

You are absolutely right! For such seemingly reckless energy, they are ON! They are precise! They are tight! They are able to go wild because they are all firmly in the same groove.

[@maureenwagg5305]

Easily Zep's best album of all time. This song is moving and epic. Oh yeah! And those pants JImmy has on are awesome. Dragons like silk PJ's lol.

[@LeonardoRodrigues-wy7ds]

I love Led Zeppelin. They are the best!

[@richardjames3022]

Lucky you, I missed getting tickets for that and had to wait until Knebworth

[@tothemoomka]

Led Zep being the best rock band is wrong, they are the ultimate rock band. The essence of Rock, blues, groovy, raw, hard, flamboyant, they have it all.

[@henrysiegertsz8204]

I saw them in concert in 1979 at the age of 18, at Knebworth Park in the UK, it was the most memorable performance ever from the greatest rock band of all time.

[@AngeloMarcheschi-vj9em]

The GOATS at work

[@Dan-zq5wt]

There are no epic rock performances like this anymore. This was a band who played in perfect synch with perfect timing with so much fire and passion. What an amazing band!

[@tanyaweathersby9393]

Robert is pure magic❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@betsyduane3461]

The studio version blows this away. But this is still fantastic. This was Earl's Court 1975

[@joescott8877]

It really does. I like the live "No Quarter" better than the studio, for ex., but that's not always the case. UR right, in THIS case, as killer and well-mixed as the instruments are, the REAL fire of this song is to unlocked in the studio version. (which, yes, was a "live" jam session IN the studio, as the cough at the end shows, lol)

[@richardbaker8928]

I'm 69, saw them live three times...fantastic band. This song was sung by Blind Willie Nelson then Bob Dylan before LZ

[@nickgeorgiou7770]

No one ever in recorded history ever said can you please turn it down when Zeppelin was playing. If anything it was turn it the F up!

[@Dan-zq5wt]

Jimmy Page circa 1971-1975 was the most swaggering, rock star monster guitarist alive. A complete badass

[@vicprovost2561]

Yep, he vaporized most other guitarists, for me, only Jimmy Page, Jimi Hendrix and David Gilmour are in the same conversation.

[@anthonyattard6726]

Back in the day we had to imagine what they looked like moving on stage, no videos, no TV, only Iive or you didn't see them.

[@RoboSteave]

Back in your day maybe. Back in my day I saw 'em live in concert. Hate to say this, but I was a bit disappointed.

[@kbrewski1]

They released The Song Remains the Same to theaters in the mid 70s. But, as much as I liked Zep in the 70s, they had a rep of being sloppy live because of the drugs.

[@ernestpacheco8148]

As a kid listening to the studio version in the car , cranked in my boom box system... Life changing !

[@Scimitar1976]

How relaxed John Bonham seems playing the drums on this track.

[@ChrisLegner-qp1yh]

Simply a master class of a heavy rock performance. Everything that made them so great is here. "Soulful" is an apt adjective to use.

[@markcox731]

Organized Chaos Jam Session in Concert , with every Member putting their trademark on their Instrument , Love It !!!

[@arthurlangford5861]

JPJ put in just as much work on this one as Jimmy! Bonham drives the train....as usual! And what more can be said about Robert Plant! Greatest amalgamation of talent in a group.......EVER!!!! 💯

[@Tanguy2000]

Jimmy Page The goat guitarist

[@ryanr5319]

Agree! Him, then everyone else. 😊

[@Motownmike73]

One of the Goats!!!!

[@joshuadeshaies7266]

Yes he is also Robert the goat rock singer, JPJ the goat multi talented musician, John BONHAM one of the goat drummers. You can't go wrong with these icons!!

[@jessedebord1041]

Great rhythms but many of his leads were mid…to be honest.

[@davidleach4689]

Jimmy’s my favorite couldn’t agree more

[@alexshkoditch4593]

If you think it was remarkable that Roberts voice held up through the length of this song, be aware that Zeppelin's set was over 3 hours long that night. Dr. Winston O'Boogie (an alias for John Lennon) once said, "You should have been there" in reference to music of the past.

[@donaldallison7202]

The greatest rock band that will ever walk the planet

[@RonaldRon-se4db]

I enjoy so many of your reaction vids... A comment about Zeppelin more importantly about the fact that most people, certainly not all but most, people totally under appreciate JPJ's bass playing! He is very much responsible for not only allowing Jimmy and Robert to execute their greatness but was so involved in the mastery of their rewrites of most of their songs... He's so underrated by people who know music and underappreciated by many who just love their their music. I'm not being judgemental just expressing my thoughts after many years of listening and observing the entire music scene beginning in 1964. Yep! I am an old man. To toot my own horn a bit, I started playing drums (and progressed to other percussion 'diddies' over time) and to make some of you jealous had the absolute privilege to see Led Zeppelin in concert!!!! No, not once, not twice but 3x's in the early 70's!!!!! (as well as 73 other fantastic live performances by groups of the greatest era of music EVER!!! (Not just the era for music but LIFE IN GENERAL!!!!) Such beautiful times as well as BEAUTIFUL, LOVING PEOPLE!!! "Those were the days" to coin an old phrase.... Thanks for giving a platform for us ancients to ramble on. I appreciate y'all and enjoy your reaction videos. GOD bless you and keep 'em comin'...... 🙏❤✌️

[@helenespaulding7562]

I agree completely except for the poor guys who were drafted. Wasn’t the best of times for them.

[@jasonbarlow8263]

Love the reaction. ❤ Led Zeppelin blows my mind live

[@fishboy91]

They are masters at transitions...going in and coming out of solo's....slowing down and then speeding up...going into one key and them coming back to the original key. One guy will play off another. All 4 guys will use "their" instrument to do that and will do it buy ear. They ALMOST never look at each other and telegraph it. However, they will glue themselves to what Bonham is doing. This performance is basically a master class. It is improvisational but within a structure/framework.

[@helenespaulding7562]

Agree with most of what you said. However, it’s my understanding that one of the many things that made Zeppelin so incredible live was that Bonham, while laying down the groove, also followed Jimmy’s lead. He had to, since Jimmy would improv every performance, so you had to have a drummer who could switch on a dime and add accents to Jimmy’s flights of fancy. And also, there was plenty of eye communication between Plant and Page.

[@bradconrad936]

One of my favorites. I would have recommended starting with the studio version on this one but this version does it some justice. The studio version is just plain fire.

[@sicotshit7068]

I prefer the May 25 version from this concert, believe it or not, it’s actually better than this one.

[@winstonsmith3690]

They were amazing at playing in weird timings yet keeping things tight.

[@charlesmyers8150]

1969, Zeppelin, Johnny Winter, Jethro Tull played a US tour, with a stop in Baltimore. Fantastic year for music!

[@kirstenstewart5758]

One of my favourite live performances of Zeppelin, at the top of their game, each a virtuoso of their own craft come together to create this masterpiece!!

[@JohnLedger-g4i]

Well done guys !!! The first reviewer to actually pick up on JPJ’s outstanding bass. He never ever gets his dues. Without his driving bass Zeppelin wouldn’t be Zep. Plain as day!!!

[@michaelt3308]

Jimmy being Jimmy! "Don't touch JIMMY!"

[@bowtiefidenine]

More zeppelin please ❤

[@cline7269]

great song !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@ddhartma]

JPJ was playing his heart out! In fact, they all were, and yet - they were so tight!

[@sergiodavila5269]

Definitely an EPIC Zep song!!! Favorite line: “OH MY JESUS…..” however many times he wails it. 🤘🏽🤘🏽🤘🏽🤘🏽🤘🏽

[@juliemanarin4127]

A true masterpiece!! The studio one actually was a jam session and recorded with them just playing! Yes a slide guitar!

[@davidadams5280]

Hey Julie the guy who is talking about Zeppelin stealing songs is the usual loser. They act like they are so smart and telling us something we don't know. And we don't care. Zeppelin did more to bring the blues to the mainstream than anyone. They deserve a Congressional medal. Maybe that guy is busy doing his other hobby. Melting toy soldiers onto ants

[@wildbill7081]

It seems that both you have fallen into the grip of how great Led Zeppelin is and I love how both of you young ducklings get mesmerized by their music

[@rickburke6936]

The drums are incredible in this song!!

[@MikeEnglund-ih1zh]

I like the bluesy Led Zeppelin songs more than the fantasy Led Zeppelin songs.

[@waynevarrelman9363]

The mighty Zep!

[@bluetopguitar1104]

Love the slide guitar. They took an old traditional acoustic blues tune to another planet. John Paul Jones is an important part of the band. The bass playing on "ramble on" is awesome.

[@rowenatulley852]

Bring It On Home is a Led Zep version of a blues song. Give it a listen!

[@ronaldfrank2076]

Greatest Band Ever!

[@marymargaretmoore9034]

Probably my favorite live LZ performance. Gotta give it up for Jonesy too. From the old blues song "Jesus Make Up My Dying Bed" by Blind Willie Johnson in 1927.

[@richardgearhart1286]

It's called improvisation-- they never played any song the same way in a live performance. This was 1975-- go watch Celebration Day, a one of a kind concert on Dec 10 2007. They're playing 16 of their greatest hits 32 years after this show. The venue was the 02 arena in London. 20 million ticket requests for 20,000 seats. Sold out within hours

[@tonysousa9305]

Masterpiece

[@jefftheuma5645]

The greatest blue's song.

[@Jude_196]

SO, SO GOOD!!! This band was SO TIGHT: they worked, together, IMPECCIBLY!! Their VISUAL and MUSICAL queues to each other are PRICELESS!! You have to have an ENVIRONMENT like THAT, to SOUND like THIS! They LITERALLY fit together: like a GLOVE - and, that's probably a ONCE in a century TREASURE! ...and, there are NO BAD SONGS!! LOVE THEM! Thanks for the reactions!! HUGS, YA'LL, from Texas!!

[@billbusby3180]

I got to see this live, and will never forget it..

[@stewpot6998]

This is where you close your eyes and listen. That drumming!! Bonham is the greatest. Good one. ✌️

[@hog7203]

Excellent suggestion for this version from whoever picked it 👍 I liked the song back when it first came out on the Physical Graffiti album. Not one of my favorites at first but it kinda grew on me. But this song is excellent performed live. Some tunes are like that. Of course it helps when you have four of the best musicians of all time doing it.

[@John_Locke_108]

Definitely needed to do the studio version. Jimmy can only play one guitar at a time. He does a tremendous job here but you're definitely missing out.

[@joescott8877]

Agree! It's a monster, the studio version, thunder from Heaven...

[@juliocesar8374]

Kashmir 👍🏼

[@davidadams5280]

I like how Zeppelin could take an old flat blues song that no one ever heard of and was about a 4 level and make it into a legendary song. Wish they did more of these.

[@RobertDavisAdman]

Nothing”4 level” about Blind Willie Johnson. He is considered by many to be the finest slide guitarist of all time.

[@davidadams5280]

His song sounds more like Hats Off To Roy Harper. They have very little resemblance. And it's an old blues standard that's nearly 200 years old . And yes he is a fine guitar player but I 💯% believe his version sounds like a dude playing by himself on his porch. To me Zeppelin took an old blues standard that was flat and boring and put it on steroids. Blind was a great guitarist but if anything Zeppelin did more to get him to be known than anyone ever did

[@williamharris7357]

That guitar was a danelectro Sears and Roebuck used to sell them very inexpensive but very good quality and with that soap bar pick up that had that Mississippi Delta sound

[@vernhoke7730]

I bought this album back in high school in '75. Working for minimum wage, $2.10 at the time, it took me a while to come up with the $15 "Physical Graffiti" cost. Almost 50 years later I find it well spent.

[@kbrewski1]

Even at 2.10 an hour, 8 hours (ie a full shift) would give you the cash. Lmao 🤣

[@tcdeger]

Why does no one recognize John Paul Jones on bass ????

[@WilliamdeSouzaSantos-kv9pc]

Still exciting to listen to and see , I bought the album in 1975 ! Amazing .

[@WilliamdeSouzaSantos-kv9pc]

Congratulations both of you !

[@stevenseul361]

Yeah Phil and Sam woo woo Favorite Album here.. Jimmy on the slide 💯💥

[@reality1958]

Now check out the original studio. Amazing

[@albertmata8813]

On the studio version the drums are way more prominent I like this version but the studio version to me just sounds way better!

[@leannlaplante3643]

I love that you two really get Zeppelin. Thank you!! I love many types of music. Led Zeppelin was and is my favorite band.

[@billtaylor3382]

These 4 guys just messed together and produced many many great songs!

[@michaelearly8097]

Released by Blind Willie Johnson in 1928. Bob Dylan also had a version.

[@alzeppo]

About Jimy. He was always bringing or adding something innovative by the time..like the Theremin in Whole lotta love..or the Violin elbow in Dazed and Confused..or that extrange amp in Live in Marrakesh

[@alzeppo]

or the Hurdy Gurdy with the Unplugged dvd..jaja

[@lesgrice4419]

Robert Plant did his first gig as a lead singer for another group, before Led Zep at a small venue near me, must have been early 60's maybe, some groups just have a chemistry, The Beatles, Led Zep, U2 and others that others cannot match nor never will, legendary truly is the word....

[@majones501]

Yeah! This is one of the reasons Physical Graffiti is my favorite album of theirs. You are right that this sounds like a jam session, BUT, it is so completely structured and tightly timed, everyone is in sync. Jimmy’s extremely complex jamming on the slide guitar, flawlessly and rapidly hitting notes up and down the neck, is totally in sync with Jones’s bass riffs and Bonham’s lead drumming. There is no way that they can be so completely in sync without the song being tightly structured. Imagine the work they put into rehearsing so that they could perform with such mastery! I had not seen this performance, so thanks for reacting to it. Love it!

[@kennethwellington9547]

You are right about JPJ's bass was kicking.

[@plcamp1]

It’s hard not to be distracted by Jimmy on this song, but try primarily listening to the bass line on this…it’s astoundingly good.

[@arnoldcox9128]

What else can we say about Zep? Just spectacular ✨️

[@kimzwolinski9919]

I love this performance 🔥🔥🔥

[@verginithe]

Well put, and that's what makes Zep so dam good. Jammin,, free style add libs

[@ifull393]

Jam time!

[@helenespaulding7562]

The Earls Court concerts were a five night run. Peter Grant, the manager, had even arranged special scheduled trains to bring people from outside London into the city for the performances. That’s cultural sway for sure. I believe they filmed two nights of the run because this video is not the one I normally see. This one is outstanding but I guess I prefer the other one, as it has a more extended exchange between Plant and Page at the end. Plus Robert ad libs a bit of You Shook Me at the very end as well. But as I said, this was superb musicianship all around. You two should check out the studio version as well.

[@baronvonthrophousen5930]

One of the greatest song interpretations by the greatest band of all time! If you haven’t already, check out “Moby Dick” live at the royal Albert hall 1970. That song is just John “Bonzo” Bonham on fire, it is utterly incredible. Great reactions by the way, love your content

[@JohnnyG911]

Gotta check out the studio version of this Phil its straight 🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@JGMor]

A good one to watch is “ a whole lotta love” live from NYC the album “The song remains the same “ it’s pretty long and has two parts but it’s awesome

[@isadona59]

These performance is perfect....PERFECT...All they are, like every time, in his high moment. I love to see this actuation caus it is plaine of passion

[@christopherone1]

Jimmy Page with those little hip swivels...OMG. GOAT!

[@jerrytamborello6847]

Love Led Zeppelin and this review! Classic live performance.

[@davidepperson3685]

Gospel song by Zepp! Epic

[@JoeandAngie]

They set the bar for cool....and no ink.

[@helenespaulding7562]

No ink? What does that mean?

[@RobertBreedon-c3b]

One of my favorite Zep songs will be played at my wake when that time comes Jimmy on the slide is so good this is why he is a guitar god, You two need to watch the concert movie The Song Remains the Same from their 1973 tour at MSG in NYC over three shows for me this was and is the closest I ever got see them live. Sir James Patrick Page just turned 80 this past January and Plant is turning 76 this August. Also Jimmy did the guitar work on the movie Deathwish II and III. Slide guitar has been used in the Blues since the beginning of time. George Thorogood is a master of playing slide guitar.

[@RabbiSteve1]

Good reaction. Wish you had done the studio version first, though this is still good.

[@TexasMagnolia]

In my Time is from Zeppelin’s “Physical Graffiti” album. This was John Bohnam’s album…Drum dominated! Thank you Phil and Sam! I’ve never seen this live clip. Next Sound - The Rain Song.

[@rickeylucero3955]

Got this on DVD. Robert's voice is strained. He is taking it easy. Happens often on a long tour like this was. Still great. But he is holding back.

[@allenlocke1935]

Absolutely MASSIVE!

[@danielfox6907]

Page is very recognizable by his playing style and choices.Eddy is holding Jimmy's coat for this one.

[@randyhochstein8455]

For clarification, “slide guitar” is not actually a particular type of guitar. It is on the other hand, a style of guitar playing where the guitarist uses a small cylindrical item worn on one finger to “slide” up and down the neck of the guitar producing that signature “slide guitar” sound. Any guitar can be played in the slide style. 🎸🎸🎸 ✌🏼😎🇺🇸