Bass Singer FIRST-TIME REACTION & ANALYSIS - VoicePlay | You're A Mean One Mr. Grinch

[@QueenKim29]

If I remember correctly the Grinch was played by the Grinch. That's what the description said.

[@melodiemalone2317]

Yes but Eli doing the grinch voice . Eli doing lot of voice actor

[@leahschmid1494]

Impressive thing to think about is Adriana was 16 when they filmed this. She's so good. Great collab with voiceplay

[@amybruederle2086]

Apparently not everyone has the poem, "The Night Before Christmas," memorized like I do. That's the other text they sing in the middle. Great analysis for a great song!

[@DravenGal]

Geoff does a reading of it on his KZbin channel!

[@jerlynneallison6361]

I used to read it to my kids (and then grandkids!🥰) on Christmas Eve. 😁🎄🎅🤶☃️ MERRY CHRISTMAS Y'ALL!! 😉🤶

[@drekfletch]

My chorus sang this, and the director was joking around giving some of the tenors grief because they didn't know all the words by heart.

[@silverfeigner]

I'm definitely familiar with the poem "The Night Before Christmas ". I recognized where the words came from.

[@felicitymcdonald24]

I was shocked that Peter didn't recognise it! I listen to it every Christmas eve night, and have done so for years!

[@joshuakre125]

"and Peter said let there be light" I died laughing 😂 😂

[@zpinn8242]

Can't believe you haven't seen this one! Fun to see a first-time reaction to a song I've listened to dozens of times the past year Geoff is, as always, crazy with his bass notes. But it's not often that the reactor can hit the same notes :) From what I've read, the Grinch in the video is the 'actual' Grinch: someone who famously works as portraying the Grinch and whose real identity is unknown.

[@rtsbass7829]

FUN STUFF LIST: 5:00 - Bb1 Breathy Chest from Peter 6:11 - Bb1 Breathy Chest again 6:36 - The light goes bruh 9:51 - Peter had no idea... (Geoff's juicy low G#) 10:10 - *Double Glass Madness* 10:56 - Peter sing the bassline along with Geoff 11:15 - Bruh he stopped right before the Eb1 12:20 - *Bb1 Subharmonics from Peter* 12:26 - He was not prepared XD 12:30 - Eb1 Subharmonics attempt 14:12 - A nice riff from Peter 17:29 - *That's not it but it's good* that part really got me lmao 19:19 - *E4 Chest* 19:22 - *B4 Mixed* 19:43 - Peter's reaction on Geoff's *E1* 20:47 - *E1 Chest-fry* I really love this type of series! It gives more opportunity to talk with audience!

[@billparrish4385]

Totally agree that Adriano's voice is superb! And at the time VoicePlay recorded this (2 years ago), she was only 16! That effortless flip up into head voice, then back down out of it, and all the rest. Amazing vocalist!

[@christinestromberg4057]

Adriana was 15 or 16 I believe when she did this. She is the daughter of friends of Geoff. She has also appeared in their We're Good, Frozen 2, Good For You, and some minis. She's got a great voice. I love Geoff as bass guitar. He does it so well.

[@ilonadever8249]

This is one of four full length pieces that Adriana has done with them. They have worked with her parents, and for her 15th birthday, invited her to do the Frozen II Medley with them. Her mother still has to accompany her when she works because of her age. It is so much fun watching the joy on your face when Geoff sings. Eli freuently covers the bass when Geoff is doing a higher solo. I think he could have been doing it the first time, because he was not singing the same text as the others, but that last one, I agree. Geoff had to have been double tracked. Really enjoy your reactions, and loved your duet with Jennifer Glatzhofer !

[@jonadabtheunsightly]

In a lot of cases, Eli will pick up the bass line for live performances, where Geoff is double-tracked for the official music video. One very notable exception is Oogie Boogie, where they use a Geoff-bassline backing track even for live performances, because otherwise they would need a sixth singer, not even counting Sandy.

[@daventunes3822]

Adriana has done maybe 3 full videos and a couple of "minis" with Voiceplay. My favorite of those is "We're Good." She's quite young (said from the perspective of my 60-mumble years) but has a fantastic voice and more than holds her own with the guys. Thanks for your analysis of this one!

[@TYGER0902]

She’s done 4 Frozen II, this one, We’re good, Good 4 you then the minis.

[@MuriKakari]

We're Good was definitely amazing!

[@DravenGal]

Basses ARE awesome!

[@MJKFanatic]

You know the subharmonics are good when they make a fellow bass singer pull the "stank" face 🤣

[@DavideBaroni]

Did I tell you already that I LOVE your reaction&Analysis? 🙂 'Cause I do. 🙂 You always bring to my consciousness some things that I didn't notice before, and/or complete and clarify other things that I kinda WAS aware of, but not in such detail and, sure enough, not in such "technical" way. Thank you a lot for this. 🙂❤ I always look forward to your NEXT video, especially about VP. 🙂 Another thing that I love is that I can FEEL the respect you have for your fellow singers. Humbleness is rare, and for that reason even more appreciated, at least by me. ❤ Have a GREAT Christmas, and let me wish the incoming year to be the best 2023 EVER! 😉

[@braddicken6776]

love Geoff

[@lkayh]

Geez I love your analyses!! This was a Geoff arrangement so he gets the credit for the awesome switch ups, as well as the E freaking 1’s. And Adriana, even as a kid, was soooo good. She’ll go places. I’d love to see you react to Bobby’s version-and also, your featured singer guy from Mad World, Elliott Michael Robinson, has a new, original song that is the Grinch’s rebuttal-very entertaining.

[@maudglazbrooke1287]

Go back to Elliott's video and read the newer comments. *waggles eyebrows*

[@lkayh]

@@maudglazbrooke1287 Yay! Thanks for the heads up! Have you heard Bobby’s yet? I swear, anything Thurl Ravenscroft did back in the day, it’s just made for Bobby’s voice. Very nice!

[@maudglazbrooke1287]

@@lkayh Yeah, I cheat and am on Patreon for all the members of the Bass Gang and TBG themselves. You're such a regular in the comments section it would hardly surprise me to find that you are too.

[@lkayh]

@@maudglazbrooke1287 Unfortunately I have a couple pets who are hitting me with really expensive vet bills and it looks like it will be ongoing for awhile. I did join Peter’s Patreon, but I like to watch his reactions/analyses when they’re up on KZbin (don’t ask me why-makes no sense!). I hope to be able to afford to do others, but it may be awhile before I can part with more money.

[@maudglazbrooke1287]

@@lkayh That's perfectly reasonable, real life takes first place. It just seemed to me that you'd enjoy the discord community (singular or plural). :) And as I don't post there under this username and you may have a different one as well means we may have been chatting there for months. This thought I find amusing.

[@orihsenak]

I love how they change up their arrangements.

[@tiinanyrhinen6255]

"And Peter said let there be light" 😂 I knew it! I knew Peter Barber is a God! 😁😄

[@benjamindyke3325]

I would like to point out that I’ve noticed that Geoff’s voice has evolved over the years (as it obviously would through continued use and practice) and it would he interesting to see him perform this now, especially after hearing his recent “I’m dreaming of a white Christmas”😌

[@ellenlanderson]

Bassists are awesome and badass

[@jimmatosky8075]

all about that BASS

[@dbestdbestest5362]

As far as reactions go.... Yours are the best Peter like really.... I can safely crown you as the Greatest Of All Time in reaction videos (GOAT) 👑.... keep up the good work

[@Mei391]

GOAT indeed

[@a.v.y8331]

I would LOVE if this year you did a reaction of bobby's rendition of mr grinch, it's my favourite rendition of the song just because of how clean the whole thing is, just one man and some instrumentals and a bass that reaches into the core of the earth

[@edwinashewmaker1522]

Love this reaction. It's always nice to have a fresh take on the Christmas standards and VP never fails to satisfy! Merry Christmas!

[@tayakirtlan6438]

Always love your reactions and analysis! I love what Voiceplay did with this song!!

[@mariefein5544]

Love their artistic flair & vocal excellence. I really enjoy your analysis, especially when you are enjoying the video you are watching. A love of music is a gift.❤

[@venus5019]

Aware, the song was taken from a TV cartoon animation special that aired originally on CBS December 18, 1966. Boris Karloff (classic movie vampire) was both the Grinch & the narrator although many attribute the Grinch's voice sounding like Jim Carrey from the 2000 movie. I guess it was the race for Christmas dollars racing first with well-written & produced 'Rudolph The Red Nose Reindeer' (NBC December 6, 1964), then Charlie Brown Christmas (CBS December 9, 1965), Grinch 1966 & 'Frosty the Snowman' (CBS December 7, 1969). As one commenter already posted, Thurl Ravenscroft ('Tony The Tiger' Kellogg's Frosted flakes) sang the original bass version "You're A Mean One Mr. Grinch" on the special. It was him singing completely throughout the song singing all the lyrics. It wasn't broken into sections for a group. (Interesting fact, he was accidentally removed from the credits. People thought Boris sang it, finally studio recognized error & corrected it listing him.) During the song, at one point Ravenscroft does speak the words and answers himself. If Geoff had done it in the exact manner, no one else could have been able to answer as it goes down & down, so upped it a little talking in his natural speaking voice.

[@jonadabtheunsightly]

Yeah, I used to think the PTX version of this song was amazing and the best possible version ever... and then I found VoicePlay's version, and it just blew it out of the water, no comparison, not even playing in the same ball park.

[@Gael4ce]

PTX is damn good - their singing is top notch. But…they don’t bring the silly. They’re just too dignified sometimes. This track *needs* silly. And no one beats VoicePlay when it comes to bringing the silly. 😊 There are few things I love more than awesome vocals served up with a side of giggles.

[@hollyslinkard2718]

Hi, Peter. What's up? Geoff rules. Basses are AWESOME. (There you go algorithm.)

[@MuriKakari]

Layne has done "French" before - including an entire solo for Le Poisson in the Little Mermaid Medley

[@BeverleyStJohn]

Always enjoy your reaction, Peter. All the best in your future endeavours. Bev - Ontario.

[@MuriKakari]

Love this. Geoff definitely wanted to be Thurl Ravenscroft when he grew up

[@virginiabarber7999]

Really cool version of this classic piece! ❤

[@cherylsmith3291]

Love your voice too Peter!

[@chrissch8909]

I've loved this arrangement from VoicePlay, hadn't watched it in a long while so the video cracked me up. Your edits cracked me up jus the same! Like the light turning off *beep* and "He's going up to a B, of course he is... WoOAaAaH" 😂🤣

[@cyndihuber2456]

LOVE it! Your analysis is, as always, the best. Hugs from Florida 🌞🌈

[@keithwing1956]

Love the reactions as well as your solo and bass gang work. The Intel you provide in your reactions is great for understanding the workings of the songs . Ty.

[@jenniferjensen8538]

I think this is my favorite version of this song! So funky! 😁

[@tompeavy8254]

Basses ARE awesome. Great reaction, as always.

[@mdswish]

This is my favorite Christmas offering from Voiceplay. It's like it was made just for Geoff. Adrianna did an amazing job as well. One of my favorite collabs from her was their mini of the Stranger Things theme. You definitely have to check that one out if you haven't yet.

[@iamsquatty]

I love that they decided to do some of the whoville Christmas song at the beginning.

[@hannah9419]

Love when you do voiceplay/Geoff reactions

[@antimatterexplodes4014]

We basses are amazing!

[@alextuck5613]

I'm happy you got to see this and react to it, along with your musical knowledge. Thank you.

[@stevenschannel6411]

9:10 Eli hit an A1 chest in the Moana medley, so it was probably him lol

[@kimberlycrisler6834]

Peter, you’re the best! And Voiceplay rules!!!

[@charlesbouthillier7216]

Happy Holidays Peter I enjoy the way you do reactions. The way you break it down and explain what's going on vocally, May your holiday be filled with peace,joy,and loved ones. Again thank you and enjoy the holidays

[@royj.mattice]

Very nice Peter! Loved this reaction and analysis. I think this is the first triple Pit Viper status for Geoff.

[@talaoalii7]

Great analysis as per your usual professional standard. Always informative and a joy to watch.

[@RinniePere]

Probably one of my favorite versions for sheer comedic value and creativity. Have a Merry and a Happy!!

[@brandonschoen5047]

I love your analysis. Keep it goin' man. Nice job.

[@laurentelesca3921]

I am glad you reconsidered giving Geoff pit vipers at the end and use them to point out awesomeness during the song. I believe Eli voiced the grinch, I saw a post where he does a lot of voice acting.

[@dougtexas]

Always enjoy your R&A's. Surprised you hadn't seen this previously, but glad you're doing it now. Really good video!

[@Michael.p.sancomb]

The costumes are awesome! This is a great video. One other version of this song I would love to hear your reaction is from a group called Small Town Titans!

[@Blackard84]

I love your comment of "Did Geoff do ... Of course he does" like is there anything he can't do at this point?

[@Broomrider1492]

That lyric is from the story The Night Before Christmas. Thought everyone's parents read this story at Christmas time. Adriana has done 4 videos with the guys. I think the newest one is "Good 4 U". Peter absolutely loved The Bass Gangs' cover of Blue Christmas. Loved Bobby and your Christmas sweaters.

[@katrinfrank6114]

This was fun 😊 and as always I heard so much more than when listening on my own! Happy holidays 🎄

[@cherylrobbins715]

Amazing to hear your analysis of Voice Play’s complicated performance. Thanks!

[@charlotteannestudio]

Nice analysis, as always, Mr B. Thanks 😊 👍

[@laughloveshop2618]

I just listened VP’s video again this morning. What a fun surprise to see your ANALYSIS this afternoon 😂

[@Drake844221]

It was a glorious cover. I'm pretty sure that the guy who plays the grinch in this one is one of the regulars at Pattycake Studios. This Christmas, they put out a video with The Grinch and one of the Who's roasting tiktok fail videos, which was a lot of fun (but unfortunately thoroughly non-musical).

[@Lenny-mt5ht]

If you love a good riff you should definitely listen to their version of Tennessee Whiskey. It's riffs galore!

[@candilunsford2878]

I listen to Thurl Ravenscroft's version every year, but song this was just made for Geoff. Layne and his character voices just kill me.

[@TheImerei]

Engages nature-show voice at 9:54: "And here is a wonderful display of 'Bass-ception' -- that golden moment when a bass singer has to do the stank face at the bass note from another bass singer." XD But seriously, great reaction and analysis. Merry Christmas, Peter.

[@erinromary2796]

I always love your videos.

[@iamkerok]

Thanks for AGAIN pointing out the BV's so I don't forget to listen to the other awesomeness going on....

[@Alasterius41]

Love your analysis… esp. this one… your style has really settled. And I really like how it is now….

[@Traci2000]

Merry Bassmass, Peter!! ❤️🎄

[@marywilliamson3091]

I sometimes listen to music reaction vids but yours was the first channel of that type I felt moved to subscribe to. Excellent work, truly enjoyed the education. ❤

[@mariegeen7676]

Love the glasses ❤

[@BenchChan]

Love the glasses dude!

[@sarawlindgreen3115]

Fun to see a first-time reaction to a song I've listened to a bunch of times. Happy Holidays!

[@corwinbrodnick6750]

Love all your content!

[@artchic1984]

I love this version. You should also check out Small Town Titans version of this song

[@simmerplayer2747]

Great video and reaction Peter! Merry Christmas and Happy New Year. Oh also basses are awesome and Geoff rules 😉

[@greyeyesoffical]

Helping the algorithm; 0:55 "pweese do..."

[@AudioVile]

Great reaction Peter!! As always, your analysis is wonderful. I learn something new with every reaction! Merry Christmas!!

[@susannefehling5521]

What a great surprise! Loved your analysis

[@JoeSeverino]

Great analysis! They keep getting better and better!

[@Starrynightdiner]

I think you would dig “What do you get a Wookie for Christmas” if you haven’t seen it yet. It is even earlier than this one. Dig the glasses, by the way. 😊

[@WraithW69]

I'm amazed you haven't seen Adriana before. she did a great song with Voice Play called We're Good. There's a section in that that always blows my mind, I highly recommend that one Peter. Another great reaction, and as I am watching this on Christmas morning (my time in Aus), Merry Christmas to you

[@panik6131]

Another spectacular song from VP, a generous analysis from you Peter. You guys are giving us so much knowledge!! Respect!!

[@Wildecat10]

As always, I enjoyed your analysis. I hope you have a wonderful holiday season!

[@letheardaw]

I really appreciate your analysis - I kmow what i like, but I don't always understand "why" I like it. Between you and The Charismatic Voice I've learned so much about music that i didn't have any idea of. And OT, wonderful, wonderful Bass Gang take on 'Ding, Dong' - you guys are scary, musically and otherwise!

[@toddreed882]

One of my favorites!

[@tschlaak]

Basses are awesome!!!

[@cauldroncreations]

Always love your breakdowns!

[@Froggyh63]

Great reaction, great song! Merry Christmas good sir!

[@masafilipovic7629]

Peter u rock! (:

[@kathymchugh689]

Love ya Peter and love being a patron!

[@starlessgamers18]

Hi Peter! Love your content and your voice is very soothing. Also want to say, the glasses are a very good look on you!

[@gregknepper9035]

Was a great song and great review Peter

[@jesswoods8196]

The glasses 💜 Have a Merry Christmas Peter!

[@gilliandrysdale5306]

Adrianna is in a couple of their other ones try “We’re good” It was the first one Cesar was in as well before he joined them 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

[@billparrish4385]

Hi Peter, what's up? Geoff rules. Basses are awesome! Great reaction, Peter, and love your channel. Merry Christmas! 🎄

[@suecameron3124]

Peter, have a Very Merry Christmas.

[@arikaoakes182]

Merry Christmas, Peter! Love the reactions and analysis.

[@eriklind8489]

Thank you for another entertaining, and educational reaction Peter. I have listened to this many times, and knew there was a lot going on in the background, but not paid attention to it, since I am always trying to sing along with Geoff. But I really noticed it this time since you were pointing it out....makes this version even more my favorite. And I have been so impressed with Adriana, and how well she sings at a young age. I also loved your reaction at the end when Geoff goes down the steps into the Sub, Sub.......um....Sub basement. LOL

[@carolblake5029]

I am so incredibly impresses with you analysis and demonstrate abilities! Thank you, I LEARNED SOMETHING!

[@lindahall8707]

voice play does rule

[@vivette3990]

Love your reactions 😍