Battlefield V vs Battlefield 1 | Direct Comparison

[@Nick930]

Correction: You can slide. You need to "double tap" the crouch key. Thanks for the heads up guys! Now to begin spamming it again :)

[@markl4159]

*nice*

[@Ivy64_]

I was about to comment about that. Lol

[@Jack_5894]

@@Ivy64_ me too 😂

[@roopelampinen188]

I didn't remember you could do that, but propably still not going to use it though

[@mrtyddet9726]

Nick930 correction: the map is twisted steel not broken steel

[@userandresearcher1036]

Most satisfying thing in BF1 is probably the sound when you get a kill.

[@sl9wdive]

That's one of the reason why i like bf1 more, when i get a kill in bf5 it feels so flat compared to bf1 kill sound its so satisfying

[@userandresearcher1036]

@@sl9wdive Yeah Ik!

[@synno5312]

Aahahah true

[@gorpri1]

It's addictive!

[@sik2185]

I hate the sound when you get a kill on bf1. Not realistic and it's annoying

[@monibehtesham1609]

That’s not fair ... they’re 4 games apart

[@shaggydog9789]

Looks like you missed the joke here.@@hh6248

[@jacobbussieres3528]

/r/woosh

[@Thenikksmeister]

This had me dying lmao

[@kylevickers2824]

@@hh6248 r/woosh

[@hh6248]

@@shaggydog9789 ik what he ment i was joking too...

[@kaiservonpanzer213]

Just imagine BF1's atmosphere combines with BF5's graphics. That would be absolutely amazing.

[@rabbit3734]

PTSD Simulator

[@OLZEAL]

You can mod it I believe

[@rabbit3734]

@@Jackson-uu2cm jesus christ dude

[@Jackson-uu2cm]

Average Boy I’m sorry I have a sick sense of humor 😔

[@saimhasankhan7483]

BF4 with BF5 graphics

[@goldy_on_pc930]

Funny how enemies are more visible in the darker game

[@anirudhashok7537]

Battlefield 1 captures the lighting perfectly!! It's war , it's supposed to be gritty , dark and overall depressing not a fun colourful experience!!

[@mogz1485]

I think bf1 is darker because dice was going for a more serious and brutal tone

[@balasankarajith2923]

And they made BFV look like Fortnite

[@I_bacon_I]

My brother was telling me how they were super respectful in b1 with the brutal truth of war and all these young kids fighting in them. In contrast b5 takes real stories and replaces the men with wahmen instead of telling the real stories of wahmen in ww2. Playing b1 you feel scared and heart ache during the campaign or at least I did to some degree. b5 looks like it has no atmosphere. Just another run and gun fps

[@fuqupal]

Trench warfare is not sunshine and rainbows, yo!

[@josh_the_alien]

@@balasankarajith2923 why use fps hacks on fortnite when you can just play Battlefield V

[@mogz1485]

@@josh_the_alien hah lol

[@bogyrect7268]

Bf1 for me is super immersive if I really get into the game, commanding my squad, running head first into the front lines spraying the enemy with hundreds of bullets with explosions all around me. I hope bf1 will never die as it’s one of the greatest FPS I have ever played and same for many people.

[@forzaf1gtaracingandmore824]

Bogyrect the problem with bf5(among many) is the fact that it doesn’t and never will have the same feeling as bf1 like with the factions and the bad operations ripoff in bf5 and the small bf5 campaign which is mostly historically inaccurate except for the last tiger, also the maps lack in feeling of all out war like bf1 maps, arras is decent with surrounding fields and a town to fight in but nothing on bf5 will really get as intense as some hallway battles in bf1, also no behemoths or special units(besides reinforcements which are a watered down version of behemoths) also the fact that the new mercury map has no naval aspects, or any map, also the max level is only 50.

[@elchavo7310]

bf1 is more infantry skill based thats probly why

[@lefty6112]

@@forzaf1gtaracingandmore824 you do know in chapter 5 they're gonna change the max lvl to 500

[@EldyPlaysMinecraft]

@@lefty6112 Not even in chapter 5. They're doing that this month.

[@simplemusic3311]

It will die if cheater still exist

[@DogmanOffical]

Bfv is very pretty, but it doesn’t feel much like an actual war, bf1 had a darker grittier atmosphere than bfv.

[@sharplancer2990]

I agree

[@sxyjimbo]

I agree but keep in mind people can do battle when its sunny lmao

[@DogmanOffical]

sxyjimbo something that I can agree with, but I do think bf1 feels more “authentic”

[@oliviastewart1591]

SharpLancer so u lived in ww2?

[@theaces3697]

BF1 being gritty is not realistic, the only time it would be grey, dark and gritty is if you were fighting in a destroyed urban setting, BFV is more realisitc you dont loose colours just becuase theres a war going on

[@superbcucumber9755]

This video should be called "how to give someone an urge to play Battlefield 1"

[@generalripper7528]

I just purchased the BF1 Revolution Pack for 30€ (thanks quarantine). Never touched BF5 and never will. Too whacky for my taste.

[@BirdsFn4Life]

@@generalripper7528 You made the right choice my friend. Nothing compares to bf1's atmosphere.

[@TheInternetSaga]

@@generalripper7528 I bought it last week for €8,54 on G2A.

[@generalripper7528]

@@TheInternetSaga What the hell is G2A? Damn, that's a bargain!

[@TheInternetSaga]

@@generalripper7528 Its a marketplace fors games at a heaviliy reduced price.

[@tim8241]

In my opinion, Battlefield 1 nails the historical perspective and feeling.

[@reeeeedmil]

Are you open to changing your opinion?

[@tim8241]

Sergei noo bc, f.e. on BFV on the map Rotterdam, the british fight against the germans, but in that region of rotterdam. The germans never fought againt the british soldiers

[@reeeeedmil]

@@tim8241 I mean that Battlefield 1 didn't nail the historical perspective and feeling. I tho do agree that it is better than BFV

[@tim8241]

Sergei ooh i get it, sorry bro, didn’t fully understand you

[@musje83]

@@tim8241 I understand what you mean, but BF1 is far more historically inaccurate with its weapons and vehicles than BFV. They are, after all, just games.

[@PCSupportGamingTest]

Graphics are better in bf5 but all other things are better in bf1

[@aeaeaeaei]

Lol, no, not in ps4 at least, graphically btf1 eats apart btfv, textures are really pixelated in V. I'm not sure if that's a bug but textures and trees looks pixelated when running 5m from them and ground textures are all the time pixelated with pretty much worse quality than the 1, and I come right now from checking it at 1, I got really shocked to see those graphics again in the 1 first I when in..

[@lukedontknow9283]

PC Support & Gaming Test player base

[@lukedontknow9283]

Bloody Naerien what you talking about I have a PS4 and it looks fin

[@nirvanic3610]

@@aeaeaeaei Yeah also don't forget connection and servers, they are far better on bf1. Probably because more people actually play it. (I know I'm late)

[@elijah4168]

@The Poison it's not graphics, it's lighting. The graphics are great, but the lighting makes it looks like Just Cause 3

[@JimBurly]

If I could use 1 word to describe both games, battlefield 1 would be "Boom" and Battlefield 5 would be "Pop"

[@zoberajaburz8859]

Those are 2 words though

[@nazarethdude5070]

@@zoberajaburz8859 1 word to describe both games separately

[@ABC-in2le]

Sean Dicitra each game

[@notapseudonym678]

@@nazarethdude5070 oh thanks

[@sugarjesusyt]

U mean poop

[@awesomejf03]

Battlefield 1 = Too dark Battlefield V = Too bright

[@orion260]

Real world = fucking perfect

[@awesomejf03]

abrar khan damn right

[@JayJapanB]

BFV has too much contrast.

[@blakbear6528]

abrar khan Real world = too real

[@markl4159]

Battlefield 3 = too blue

[@oscarmedina7368]

I really miss having the whistle as the squad leader and telling my squad to charge out of the trenches.

[@JustMat01]

Yea me too

[@thatdogeguy9108]

same man i was just playing bf5 and i thought saying go go go would wisles like in bf1 but i was very disapointed

[@hermannthefisherman2960]

What trenches?

[@welsh-cymru1588]

Because if the time period ww1 had whistles

[@VirtualBliss888]

@@hermannthefisherman2960 nivelle nights

[@thesiselchannel]

Battlefield 1 looks like a war game. While Battlefield V looks like a Walt Disney cartoon, no war feel at all.

[@dylangill4251]

Mr Sisel war don’t make things instantly dark😂 BFv got better graphics

[@quizzys7106]

@@dylangill4251 no it dosent

[@ThemomSlapper]

Russian Doge your a kid so you don’t know what’s better go play your roblox

[@thesiselchannel]

Fat battlefield Kid , you’re *

[@sunnymanny5671]

Mr Sisel The lighting for BFV is the problem, not the graphics. BFV lighting feels like you’re on a vacation, and not fighting a war. BF1 lighting is perfect, really suits the atmosphere of WWI.

[@Spraggy2712]

You know what the real game is? Life..... It doesn’t lag and it has the best graphics with the best history.

[@maoraharon21]

But the story line sucks and the game is pay to win

[@reafux6998]

Your profile is bo4 which is shit at all of that

[@SFH_Jenkins]

They patched the respawn. You cant respawn now because Jesus abused it!

[@kuwapii___6002]

It lags with disease and your eyes wear

[@Spraggy2712]

@@maoraharon21 good point

[@Jmrc1908]

Battlefield 1 is still my fps Favorite game

[@TH1CC0LAS]

You must have never played BF3

[@Pantichul0]

White Lighting Gaming BF3 is just a masterpiece, specially if you have all DLC’s. That said, BF1 is just great. Just two different styles I think

[@hasandiab6479]

Me 2

[@adumbmaggot3476]

you never play battlefield 2

[@RonnieRonnie3697]

Same but this goes for all Fps games not just the Battlefield series

[@joansolis9687]

As soon as he said “hit or miss” I went straight to the comments

[@tescolemonbleach2359]

Z.KILLER 898 I guess they never miss HUGH??

[@generalgrievous4851]

@@tescolemonbleach2359 you got a boyfriend I bet he doesn't kiss ya!

[@tescolemonbleach2359]

General Grievous he go’n find another girl no he won’t miss ya!

[@samdor-dc7sj]

He’s gonna hit the dab like im already tracer but nerf bastion

[@d0nger_]

I already chose mcree?!!

[@michal4736]

Atmoshpere: Battlefield 1 - GREAT ! Battlefield V - NONE

[@QNAAJTUJPRWJSGEZLPXYECAZFHODYW]

battlefield V planes even more op and boys carabine

[@santank4]

honestly lets make sense battlefield v forgot the m1 garand

[@bigturn1051]

@@santank4 ironic considering we got footage of that a month ago

[@theycallmehope7707]

Are you Sure? Because Its Clearly Show that bfV is Better

[@Novak_the_great]

Battlefield v is much better than battlefield 1

[@willpartridge6899]

I prefer bf1 weapon sounds

[@sebasitanroberts2378]

It feels like your really there dont it

[@brandonsnodgrass7687]

They sound the same

[@lukedontknow9283]

MATINI HENRY

[@setesh1294]

The weapon sounds are more meaty in BF1, but the explosions are more meaty in BFV.

[@karlgustav3186]

bfv weapons sounds more realistic, but less crisp. reaal weapons doesnt sound like booms. they sound like popopop

[@J_C_CH]

Tbh I liked the sound of movement in BF1, such as sprinting, more. It’s not just footsteps, but you can also hear all of that heavy equipment you’re supposed to be carrying (like the rocket gun) clunking around on your body.

[@schlotkratzer5782]

Is it just me or is it harder to hear footsteps? For me it's more difficult to locate enemy players in BF5 compared to BF1.

[@J_C_CH]

Stefan Wagner it does seem like that doesn’t it? It’s only really when inside a building that it’s rather easy to hear someone coming in.

[@iKickBullies]

maybe it's because i have pretty great speakers but I heard all of that in BFV's sound in this video. Just all sounds slightly turned down and more emphasis on movement

[@J_C_CH]

iKickBullies I do hear what appear to be his pouches or equipment in BFV, but in BF1 you can hear the clicking of metal as well as the rustling of his other equipment that lets you know that he’s carrying a lot.

[@schlotkratzer5782]

@@J_C_CH exactly.

[@kadenater123]

5:20 looks like an explosion from battlefront

[@deepdog8729]

Maxum it’s the same engine battlefront uses the frostbite engine

[@deepdog8729]

FBI Battlefront as in Starwars Battlefront

[@quarol732]

@@deepdog8729 I'm just saying that the frosbite engine is used from batledield 3 including the BF 3,4,1,5 and the batlefron 2, and the previous installments including the bf 3 have better and more realistic explosion effects than the batlefield V but batlefron 2 is I have enjoyed a great game since it came out

[@onrch]

@@quarol732 ah yes my favorite game battledield 3

[@quarol732]

@@onrch same :,)

[@Tsotne82738]

Battlefield 1: Like Battlefield 5: Comment

[@chuckymoss4400]

The moment of silence...

[@Tsotne82738]

@Nobody ,,Nobody loves you'' you don't know that. ,,not even I'' Nobody cares.

[@James-ru7nz]

@Nobody why are you such a bully

[@TheGuyThatsNotFunny]

Cringe like farmer lmao

[@Itsshaunbewarned]

Comment.

[@guitaroso]

You can crouch slide by DBL tapping x

[@Nick930]

Is that so? Niiice

[@guitaroso]

@@Nick930 Makes for some sweet medic role playing like that dude from Hacksaw ridge

[@Nick930]

@@guitaroso That movie was awesome. Finally watched it this summer.

[@guitaroso]

@@Nick930 I know hey! - it's a great challenge to try too - anyway, keep up the great vids - looks like a bit of work goes into them

[@anything5430]

Unknown double tap

[@jortuspelatus7364]

I kinda prefer explosions that put up more smoke than just plain up fireball. Still good graphics tho.

[@elias_xp95]

It's more scientifically accurate as well. An explosion has very little fire. Fireballs are caused by vapour and a grenade shouldn't have any vapour lol

[@anttitheinternetguy3213]

I've served in the military and seen amd thrown real grenades. i can tell ya, grenades create just a enourmous boom that you can feel in your guts, even like 150m away, and a lot of ground and schrapnel kicked up ofc. no fire or flash or any amazing visual effects. Mortar rounds are the same. So Bf 1 seems to have more realistic grenades

[@jortuspelatus7364]

They probably made the change to showcase their Raytracing tech but I don't really know for certain.

[@shaydesofblue2281]

@@anttitheinternetguy3213 agree as I'm still in. Bf1 grenades are more accurate.

[@arhickernell]

Agree. I like all the dirt kick up

[@danishakhtar00795]

Nick930 - showing battlefield 5 is good in every aspect people in comments - Battlefield 1 is better than battlefield 5 Nick 930 - Am I joke to you

[@Nick930]

Doesn't matter what you tell people, if they all already hate battlefield V, they will continue to hate it. Shame, it's a great game. Just finished another great night of "Grand Operations"

[@Nick930]

@Joe Arguin yeah me and my group are loving it. Feels way more competitive than bf1

[@slyfer81]

Nick930 you mean it feels way more like COD? Seriously. Wanna play COD? Buy BF5 . Want a BR ? Buy COD . Want BF? Stick to BF1... this all from my viewpoint and what i noticed, but thats just what im trying to say. Not that BF5 is bad , it just isnt BF anymore imo.

[@matthewewing9066]

sven what?, if anything Bf1 was far more like CoD, in that everyone just sprinted to each objective, in Bf V there is actually some sort of strategy involved and defending flags and holding down choke points are actually important.

[@matthewewing9066]

hmm interesting is there really a lack of content? I personally think theres more in this game than Bf 1 at launch, for example in Bf V there are more vehicles available and you have more options when it comes to customising there kits. And for infantry I think each class has more guns than their Bf 1 counterparts at launch, Assualt f.e has 8 guns at lauch compared to the 6 in bf1 and they have far more customisability when it comes to specialisations as in bf1 the only changes you could do to guns was give them a aperture sight or a different iron sight. Bf V has 8 maps at launch possibly 9 if you count the new map just released only like 2 weeks in, while Bf 1 has 9 so not mich difference there. So by cokparing it like that Bf V does has quite a lot of content. And its not really fair to compare Bf V to Bf 4 because of the time periods they are set in as in Bf 4 the developers have alot more freedom when it cones to guns they can add, and even then BF 4 only had 10 maps which really isnt that much more then Bf V, not to mention all the dynamic improvements in BF V so I dont understand the complaints about lack of content really.

[@ALegendthateatslunchatam]

Well battlefield 5 doesnt have this cool little feature *We have an airship on route* *Our airship has arrived* *Angry Tripod Sounds*

[@siyacer]

Bwoooom

[@DAVID__EXPO]

Idk why but I preffer Battlefield 1 graphics

[@lostmontanelas4236]

You mean aesthetics*

[@wyattaker6422]

Lost Montanelas ikr it’s not a question bfv literally has the same level of graphics, but bfv added dynamic grass, snow particles, and reactive water. the same thing but more.

[@Handonforehead]

Yeah it looks more like a world war game

[@MuscledRMH]

I think because BF:V is more colorful which hurts the immersion of the game. BF1 feels more like an actual war

[@trakigtsomfan6435]

MuscledRMH This is sent in early war

[@calvin-]

Definitely prefer the "grittier" look of BF1.

[@NeonVars]

CALViN this aesthetic is greatly missing in BFV, even on destroyed maps.

[@MrBucksfan7]

CALViN it also fits in with the overall vibe and tone of ww1 too.

[@hollowfied702]

CALViN exactly that's why 1 is better than 5 for me I just feel like I am a German soldier storming the trenches of ww1 in bf1

[@keff5984]

I agree. Colors pop too much and are much to vibrant and alive despite being a warzone

[@MrBucksfan7]

Kevin fellow I don’t mind it too much for the maps depicting the early stages of the blitz before everything got ruined as a contrast to the combat. Hopefully as the stages progress it’ll get grittier. But that’s just me.

[@TryingExplain]

But the clothing detail looks better in bf1 in my option

[@JackLively]

I actually had a chance to look at some clothing detail in an EXTREME close up during the campaign. I was playing Nordlys, during the final level. I killed a German soldier, and his body rolled down a hill to me. I proned in front of him and realised that his textures were extremely detailed... You can literally see every individual fibre that had been weaved into the uniform. That's no exaggeration. His face textures looked muddy as hell, (not sure why) but his clothing texture was seriously impressive. It was a sort of twilled weave, and really high quality, too. It was one of those video game things where my face was literally pressed against his uniform so I could see EVERYTHING. In BF1, the textures were good, but not really quite as impressive. However, they're a bit more consistent in BF1. There are a couple of problems where textures meet in BFV.

[@TryingExplain]

@@JackLively yeah battlefield V uniforms really shine at some parts but is not as consistent like you said, as well as it being in the campaign the graphics are a bit more detailed because of it being a single player mode but at the same time it is a different time period as well as battlefield V being more bright and colourful than battlefield 1 being more dark toned

[@TryingExplain]

@@JackLively but I do agree about what you said

[@hassouss4512]

*opinion

[@elitegamer8351]

you are on shit shut up

[@pushpapathak3038]

Who else get chils after seeing the dark environment of bf1

[@AgateBlackST]

Explosions look more like star wars in bfv vs bf1

[@JonatasAdoM]

And they already looked like Star Wars in BF1. I thought it couldn't get ant worse.

[@kylewestrip531]

It's like battlefront.

[@JonatasAdoM]

Indeed Battlefront, even star wars explosions look more reallistic.

[@weiwu1442]

Because they reused the assets from battlefront

[@johneec65]

Grenade explosions and TNT explosions aren't meant to be that fiery, unless they're incendiary.

[@iliamorshed6556]

I don’t know if it’s just me but I don’t get the war feeling that I would get from bf1. But bf5 is still a good game and I don’t really hate

[@greatgallade]

Yeah it's just shallow with hardly much to do with minor tweaks and improvements making it okay to be called a new game but the menu UI is fucking stupid

[@greatgallade]

@@faderneslandet3489 too true. Idk why you have two men and two women

[@dayumgirlRS]

Bf5 has more content on release then any other battlefield ever released yet you people say it lacks "content". You obviously played for 10 minutes and went back to what you are used too. Bf5 is superior in every way.

[@Cormac131]

@@dayumgirlRS is it I find battlefield 1 more enjoyable I also loved the campaign

[@timbrooks6830]

I actually enjoy bf5!

[@meganegbert8570]

6:22 I guess they never miss, huh?

[@fultonfolper7236]

Kevin sSOLOo Beasley you got a boyfriend I bet he doesn’t kiss ya

[@kzh2313]

I wanna tracer

[@cucklechuck4345]

that wasn’t very cash money of you he’s gon find another girl and he won’t miss ya

[@blue_redemtion78x2]

Die commi

[@nathancurmi2540]

E

[@Tycho3889]

I think BF1 has better explosive and gunshot sound effects.

[@peanutrecord6989]

Honestly I preferred the bfV effects, but I do get a satisfaction from bf1 that I just can't get in bfV , I actually quit 5 just Because it just felt too easy and too much like a wannabe cod and not for the better

[@nav9325]

Battlefield 1’s darkness helped add to the feel that the events in-game are historical. The brightness of Battlefield V doesnt give as much of that effect. But overall, both are good games.

[@mementoscuderia833]

Conclusion: both are better than battlefield 2042.

[@LL0Y-]

I put 60 days or so of time into bf1, the game was astounding. Bfv just doesn’t compare, “better graphics and more” dont matter if the game isnt good

[@brandonbosworth1829]

Dude did u even watch the video

[@hklassehutten1476]

@@brandonbosworth1829 bfv fanboy

[@josh_the_alien]

@@hklassehutten1476 he a real softie

[@magnumbeefus]

@@hklassehutten1476 I mean, he kinda has a point, this is coming from someone who prefers bf1 btw.

[@Goldrunner1169]

@@hklassehutten1476 same thing can be applied to you

[@gloomyjz]

Everything in BFV is too clean and vibrant and contrasting, like its a really toned down acid trip or something.

[@enjoi9970]

The sun existed in WW2 you know that right

[@Dabpss]

@@enjoi9970 yeah but where's the fun of the lack of immersiveness

[@dutchvanderlinde5218]

would you rather play with downgraded graphics? bf5 is more realistic war doesn’t put a dark filter on the environment

[@dutchvanderlinde5218]

@@Dabpss I think its still immersive

[@nepnepguythegreatestofall]

@@treett4268 Bro, where is the smoke even coming from? If you are on Narvik or Mercury, why should you put tons of darkened skies with excessive amounts of smoke? Has BF1 literally blinded you to what things actually look like outside during war? Take the Iraqian War as well! Do you see tons of black smoke in the sky in the footage? No, cause wars don't filters.

[@solokom]

To this day BF1 is THE reference for atmosphere! The colour grading and the overall art design are unbelievable. But what really takes the cake is the sound design. OMG, no other game has such a dense sound scape! The gun shots, the explosions, the vehicles. The voices, screams, shouts, show all the range of emotions soldiers experience during a battle. All that in 6 different languages! One of them is my first language (German) and I speak two others (English and Russian) fluently, and I understand French quite well, and I find the voices in all languages to sound so natural, and they are definitely all spoken by mother tongue speakers who also must have been voice actors. Even when playing on the Turkish side and don't understand a word, I FEEL the intensity, the tension, or fear of the soldier I am playing. And then you get something like BF2042. HOW?!

[@optiTHOMAS]

Such a masterpiece, man! One of my all time favorite games! The atmosphere, visuals, gameplay, amazing animations, immersion, and god tier sound design just makes it an amazing and fantastic overall experience! It just feels so intense and detailed! Not many games come close to its level of experience! I love the big behemoth set pieces too! Makes the world feel vast, huge, expansive, and more realistic to some extent! Love it! 😁🥲👍🏻

[@Szczypek223]

6:23 I guess they never miss huh

[@creeping_thyme]

@Bryce Moll Look bro, we get that you weren't raised the right way, but don't get mad at other people because you're frustrated yourself

[@dylantapiafonseca1773]

@@creeping_thyme Damn son

[@themagnuspowfilms5956]

Szczypson i don’t get it

[@genericname9994]

@Bryce Moll Hit or miss, I guess they never miss huh? You got a boyfriend I bet he doesn't kiss ya, muah. He gon find another girl and he won't miss ya. He gon skeet and hit the dab like Wiz Khalifa.

[@B--uf4ne]

oh you bastard you remind me of deltarune comic dub

[@tvojastara6940]

Bf1 will always stay in our hearts

[@Hominid.11]

I was in the infantry and can say that grenade explosions have zero fire. It’s just a huge thump and a bunch of dust kicked up

[@Nick930]

Good thing this isnt the infantry.. its a video game that exaggerates every aspect of war to make it fun and enjoyable. Hollywood explosions look better in a game like this. Realistic puffs of smoke can stay in military sims instead

[@miep6463]

@@Nick930 Well yes but BF 1 is more realistic then.

[@facemcshooty6602]

The fire only happens when there is something to combust

[@Vroth]

@@Nick930 wow, you really just threw away a sub with your ignorant comment. Btw, isn’t realism what these games are after?

[@vomErsten]

@@Nick930 Go take a gander at the effects in every previous Battlefield game, and especially Battlefield 2; the series staked its entire reputation on being the more realistic of the Big Two mainstream combined arms multiplayer shooters. Leave the Hollywood effects to Call of Duty.

[@zladam9]

Mans really out here calling twisted steel “broken steel”

[@setesh1294]

What is this, Fallout 3?

[@woo00shbait93]

@@setesh1294 no this is Battlefield

[@budlightlyme9826]

Woo00sh Bait no this is Patrick

[@upengraden3792]

We loved BF1 so much more because the darkness added the correct tone.

[@erikseavey9445]

Idk I think battlefield 5 is lame honestly.

[@imepi9050]

Its like BF3 is blue filtered version of BF4, but BF1 is darker version of BFV

[@the3idiots14]

Im Epi eh they feel very different. I’ve played BF1 for hundreds of hours and BFV feels very different. Other than that visually it’s usually filters and higher fidelity.

[@ponraul1221]

I liked the “blue filter” and darker version. They give it atmosphere and visually represent the grit and bleakness of war. It’s the same reason war movies don’t have the bright colours of say, guardians of the galaxy. Imagine if Saving Private Ryan was very colourful lol

[@InFamXYT]

Bf3 looked better tho

[@bindiese1]

Nothing more satisfying than getting a headshot with the Martini Henry in BF1

[@02HARMAE]

Even if you get that 90 damage body shot, finishing them with the Kolibri is always amusing

[@datnigga7445]

Idk but I like bfv better but bf1 atmosphere feels more legit

[@oscarsterner2623]

I feel like you are more emerged in BF1 than in BF5. I can recall several times where I felt like I where actually there in the battle, especially on the European maps when it was dark, gritty and thick smoke everywhere. It felt like an old tape recording from the time. I have much harder time recalling such experiences in BF5 with its hollywood explosions and bright graphics. The only times I almost get such feelings in BF5 is when it is raining or thre is fog or somthing similar that darkens the setting. Also the new customization in BF5, though fun and all, makes the battle feel more like a Halloween party than a battle between two highly organised armys. It does really ruin the immersion when you see a German soilder runing through the desert in his thickest winter coat

[@SpinningTurtle66]

I don’t really care about the whole debacle that happened before launch, I find BF1 to be the better game. It just feels like a bigger and better game.

[@enjoi9970]

Gameplay wise it’s very casual and not as replayable. It caters to players who aren’t as good at FPS games.

[@SpinningTurtle66]

@@enjoi9970 You think so? I can replay it forever, it’s so addicting and fun. Both are low level FPS games but I think BF1 wins in fun and BFV in gameplay (more mechanics, smoother experience etc)

[@detroitdave3505]

If only the historical accuracy was as good as the graphics

[@baileyharris9172]

So you want the game to change to become more boring not saying the game is boring

[@elitemation]

No flying tanks No body under the floor Those sound like a nightmare

[@partly_sunny1955]

Bailey Harris You’re not getting the point.

[@baileyharris9172]

I know but it is boring if it had accuracy as it would be like every other ww2 game, it would be cool to have a multiplayer d-day.

[@trondala9602]

Historical accuracy shouldnt come before fun

[@GatitoCarreras]

Basically BF1 was aimed for a realistic and casual gameplay to enjoy with super long TTK, BFV was aimed to be competitive again, feels more arcade, more CoD style play with the new Super fast TTK like old BFs, while BO4 has new super slow TTK which everyone is hating over there they will like BFV i bet because of the fast TTK that they are used to

[@MrStrangermoon]

İts amazing some old grandfathers play bf1 and enjoys i think its about the faction it feels more world wide game. Many of bf1 game elements ripped off movie called desert lion which is old dude times 1980movie.

[@cthoffman9351]

In a fps, the characters extremities and weapon deatil/graphics are so important for the feel. And bf1 is twice as good in that department imo..

[@mitchelkvedar674]

This

[@lulzsec4445]

battlefield 1 looks more realistic

[@McuThar]

No

[@kurakusjakurczak4604]

BF1>BFV

[@InfinityHS]

Same

[@omnissiah7859]

True

[@kasft]

immersion: BF1>BFV Core gameplay: BFV >>> BF1

[@tbg8882]

Im a BF fanboy but yeah I do agree that BF1 is better, maybe not in graphics but the gameplay, the story.... Its even a budget game considering BF5 came out

[@Oregun44]

Hands down

[@minimasterd]

I wish DICE would bring back levelution like BF4, I know in some maps like Lancang Dam it made the map worse, but with how the frostbite engine is now I feel like it could be a lot more dynamic. Like (using Shanghai as an example) if you destroy the left side of the buildings base it could fall to the left. I think the massive map changes made BF4 really cool and I hope they would bring it back to new battlefield titles.

[@dominique.gonzalez622]

I agree full on

[@Nugcon]

Bf1 had kinda levolution with the Airships. Damn I miss behemoths

[@ponraul1221]

The levolution on Lacang Dam did barely anything to change the map. Siege of Shanghai though was ruined when the skyscraper was taken down as the best fights occurred up there. Of course this is already somewhat ruined when DICE decided it was a good idea to allow attack helicopters on a map with lots of cover without any effective counter like anti-air.

[@BioClone]

" if you destroy the left side of the buildings base it could fall to the left." Thats NOT levolution, thats a more dinamic destruction... Levolution was just the same instanced destruction always seen but on big/iconical unpractical elements of the maps

[@r4nowo]

Levelution was just a marketing thing its not important for gameplay

[@bryanrodriguez6875]

Prefer battlefield 1 looks like a war is actually taking place bfv on the other hand idk wtf going on looks dull in comparison

[@staryoshi06]

Bigger maps is likely the reason. Which is a good thing.

[@weswwbr]

You my sir are a complete fucking moron.

[@ALYXC7]

staryoshi06 it most likely is, also less nade spam could also play a large part

[@chanceg6209]

Oh shit we gotta a war veteran here

[@godlybatiste4708]

How does bfv look dull? Are you crazy?

[@clungemagnet3388]

I have 30 hours on this game and I just don’t Find it fun. There is nothing there for me to earn through playing the game. In bf1, BF4, and bf3 I played because I wanted this Gun or I wanted to attain a rank, but in bfV I don’t care for any of that. Idk why but it’s just not fun.

[@HEARD201]

Boromir 30 hours? Sounds like you are having fun

[@Sadzi7]

maybe because BFV best weapons are the first ones so you don't feel that you are progressing I play as a support, and it's only for mg34

[@thewisebread3653]

exact same problem here

[@ricardolarsen8819]

Acabo de desinstalar el Battlefield 1y solicite mi reembolso por la compra del 5.- Estoy esperando juegos como Mount and Blade 2 o AoE 4 y cosas así, que sean entretenidas y diviertan, y no pendejadas gráficas, que un juego con todos los gráficos, y sin contenido ni inmersión, son una vergüenza para mi hardware.-

[@KenLinx]

There are a lot less guns in BF5 and none of them have the varied unlock requirements like the guns in BF1

[@Ash-np4pd]

Having played both now. Battlefield 1 is far superior. Especially the campaign.

[@lfle9933]

But we all know what the true WW game is.. Call of Duty: World _at_ War No, I'm serious I still play the campaign today 😂

[@clevelandfeller1223]

Couldn't agree more with you.

[@pinkdoe1725]

Yes

[@spoderman7455]

Say no more

[@denizkaanbudak2857]

Right

[@JP-297]

Cod waw is the definition of dark. It kinda feels eerie/creepy. Best WWII game by far.

[@chokonnit7337]

Battlefield 5 has too many colors and contrasts. Battlefield 1 was more gray and dark

[@worlds3061]

Well play the game on black and white LOL

[@staryoshi06]

Wow it's almost like real life has colour.

[@chokonnit7337]

@@staryoshi06 lmao i meant as in it looks like someone had a nice looking game and then just turned up saturation to 100

[@Flourikum]

@@chokonnit7337 yes in real life the weather was affected by feelings...

[@chokonnit7337]

@@Flourikum in real life the world doesn't consist of the entire rgb spectrum wherever you look

[@castelo9976]

Graphics: Battlefield 5 Multiplayer: Battlefield 1

[@enjoi9970]

BF1 casual af

[@bananasandbass]

The sound design in BF1 is sooo much better than any game out there.

[@antonio3789]

They are both great games!! Be happy dice is putting in effort to provide us with great graphical and realistically war games.

[@gioisgud]

Bfv looks good, Bf1 IS good !!

[@elang1702]

BF1 clearly the winner, It fits the "world war" atmosphere but BFV in the other hand... the visual and atmosphere felt like Call of Duty AKA felt too Arcade-y

[@blexyi1049]

And even the new call of duty is darker than bfv

[@edts3218]

@Deathtrooper204 no.

[@edts3218]

@Deathtrooper204 no.

[@edts3218]

@Deathtrooper204 no.

[@ThomasTom__00]

BF1 ALL THE WAY.

[@generalgrievous4851]

Slipknot all the way

[@ThomasTom__00]

@@generalgrievous4851 always.

[@dreggman2796]

10 minutes of hearing bf V looks better

[@jackshoggoth677]

What were you expecting when you clicked?

[@mikey-nm3od]

i mean you cant argue that BFV definitely has some visual upgrades, though BF1 is probably the better overall game at this point. im not a huge battlefield fanboy and only bought BFV because the DLC is suppose to be free. i like the game for the most part, the map that has the grass fields and swamp is amazing

[@jackshoggoth677]

@@mikey-nm3od I find bfv a lot of fun, but bf1 is definitely a superior game, even at launch which is where bfv still is. Heard that DICE is thinking about reworking the TTK for Bfv so they are trying to really change the game for some fans

[@Jsc.bone019]

Who is overhyped by the offer of 80% of battlefield 1 revolution?

[@theorangeboichannel3339]

JOSS #9851 lol just bought it two hours ago. Better then. Bf v for sure

[@theorangeboichannel3339]

Christopher Cats me too

[@theorangeboichannel3339]

Christopher Cats I bought it from g2a

[@KaLaka16]

I love BF5 graphics its almost like therapy to watch them. I have been killed many times in game just watching the scenery. Best graphics i have ever seen.

[@MrTosser2011]

Seravasvu Olio try red dead redemption 2 then

[@xers6704]

try rdr2

[@juliusviesca135]

IMO. BFV has still the Best graphics than RDR2

[@Ptah-Tatenen]

I'd love to see the more realistic explosions from BF1 in BF5. They made me feel more like in an actual battle.

[@d3aDsH0T_xxX]

*Insert wAmEn comment here*

[@a.storms9001]

Bf1 even today is still one of the most immersive and good looking game in the industry.

[@archismarathe1589]

I actually like 1's darkness and dullness, fits with the theme better

[@johns818]

The Soundtrack to BF1 cannot be touched by any AAA game. The visual tone and soundtrack (score) are an absolute perfect match. BFV is a cartoon that caters to Fortnite kids.

[@negritorican]

Can't believe you didn't mention the curtains in BF5 building's blowing inwards or outwards depending on the direction of the explosion. One of my favorite effects.

[@tardarsauce1842]

To be honest. the colorful theme of Battlefield V doesn't match the dark gritty tone of World War II

[@kylemccormick4589]

I hate how bright BFV is - the snow maps make me feel like I’ve just had my pupils dilated

[@jimbojamous2974]

If battlefield 1 just got battlefield 5 lightning we all know what game would b dead

[@scammingpizzahutwasmyfamil5052]

Bf1 had great graphics for its time

[@diegofkda199]

lol we're still in its time

[@grandpasandwich]

you realise battlefield 1 wasn't the first battlefield? It's the previous installment in the battlefield series

[@scammingpizzahutwasmyfamil5052]

grandpasandwich no shit Sherlock

[@magrittsandberg1550]

But we are in this time

[@hagridpotterz7802]

What are you talking about? "for its time" lol. BF1 is still one of the best looking FPS games

[@emanu1674]

0:34 About people that say BF1 is darker than V...

[@zedeon6299]

6:23 I guess they never miss huh

[@largeone923]

*s t o p*

[@zedeon6299]

Aidan Scalia u got a boyfriend I bet he doesn't kiss yaaa ~

[@sapnupuas6950]

Tyrenica he gonna find another one and he won’t miss ya

[@zedeon6299]

@@TheHipProK

[@kpi4162]

i hope you dont miss when you find your dad shotgun

[@Cryptic_]

BFV a game 2 years advanced than BF1 Who fucking knew it would look better BF1 Still best

[@IONredline06]

I like the look of BF5, It is a shame that they have to play the identity politics crap, sorry there were not a bunch of females fighting the war.

[@dayumgirlRS]

They took the bs that pissed everyone off away and you do not even realize any of the PC shit in the game unless you are looking really hard for shit that doesn't matter who cares that woman are in the game.

[@aser3951]

@@dayumgirlRS I do if the graphics are realistic the game should be

[@lucabazooka1979]

Idk but hearing the Bf1 soundtrack I always get goosebumps

[@kareramberg2218]

Battlefield v is so schway

[@homem9243]

I think that Battlefield 1 is better on campaign, because the only good Battlefield V campaign honestly is The Last Tiger, others are trash.

[@dayumgirlRS]

You aren't a battlefield player if you actually care about the campaign.

[@homem9243]

@@dayumgirlRS I didn't say i do tho.

[@dayumgirlRS]

@Homem You are comparing bf1 campaign to bf5 campaign showing that you actually played them and that you care. So technically you did say you do.

[@homem9243]

@@dayumgirlRS Following your logic if i compare gays to lesbians that means i care about them but ok

[@garyl6561]

the bf5 intro campaign is also pretty good tho...

[@yeahiambrody3302]

I absolutely hate how bright and and colorful BF5 is. It’s WW2, it was a dark time

[@prospect-criticalops6182]

GingWITHaSoul ok the it was a "dark time" meaning it was a bad and scary time. it doesnt mean lighting

[@juan.p054]

To be honest, Battlefield V isn't a bad game at all.

[@ST3FF3]

My opinion on sound design. BF1 had better gun (shooting) sounds but the reloads and other sounds on the guns sound better on BFV. BFV has drastically better explosion sounds I was genuinely suprised when I got into a narvik match in the BFV BETA, I really felt like I was there when the AA guns were trying to shoot the plane down. I also prefer BF1 running sound for the metal clatter on your person.

[@Calvin_winship39]

ST3FF3 in bfv they recorded the actual guns for sounds so that is how they sound in real life

[@MrStano-jy3ts]

Both are awesome! Thank you DICE 🙋🏻‍♂️

[@nec8050]

I would do anything to play with the frostbite engines lighting.

[@theimmortalgrenadier3851]

BF1 better than BF5? Oof everyone say that but is not actually true. Surely BF5 is not realistic at all. For example reviving system where if you give an hand to the wounded guy he gets up like nothing happened even if he got shot by a tank. Or another example is women and face war paint. All this is not realistic at all. BF1. Well as first look you could say its way more realistic than BF5. But just play a bit and youll notice that the problem are the players. Who keep jumping and getting down shooting with way too many types of automatic guns. If you played BF1 campaign, the italy mission. It shows a italian soldier wearing a full armor and helmet of steel. Thats absolutely fake. Im italian and i know what im saying. Italian army in ww1 never had such armors. And tbh I have more fun in BF5 than in BF1 even if both games are fun but i must admit that in BF1 there are waaaay more factions and maps. They should do the same with BF5

[@theepickirby200]

BF1 & BFV are my favorite FPS games. I love them both equally.

[@VitrixYT101]

Same

[@Spawn223311]

Bf1 immersion is just a lot better. Everything looks so movie like and soldiers,weapons and atmosphere look more robust. The sounds and screams are so powerful with deep impact, kinda like I would imagine being there. Bf1 is just pure war atmosphere. Bf1 has it's technical problems, but in all around feel its so good.

[@nickabbott319]

Spawn223311 kinda like battlefront 2 straight out the movies :)

[@donotpress5729]

bf1 felt surreal cuz it felt so real. bf5 have better graphics but idk why it feels uncomfortable and unnatural.

[@Atomicinvaderz]

In my opinion battlefield 5 nowadays is a great game I love to play

[@indie3818]

I wish cod ww2 had bf5's graphics

[@Nath_0460]

boom ...

[@wezzy8885]

Yes but bf5 is much grand than cod ww2